[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

One Piece

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 539
Thread images: 79

File: 1426635492438.jpg (199KB, 461x480px) Image search: [Google]
1426635492438.jpg
199KB, 461x480px
One Piece is far superior to HxH. There are no "O' MY RUBBER NEN"'s in One Piece
>>
>>158836239

>Will of D
>Muh nakama
>Going Merry
>Haki
>Devil fruits
>>
File: IMG_0356.png (601KB, 787x808px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0356.png
601KB, 787x808px
>>
>>158836239
>There are no "O' MY RUBBER NEN"'s in One Piece
What about Eneru
>>
File: opg thread yonkou.png (572KB, 720x913px) Image search: [Google]
opg thread yonkou.png
572KB, 720x913px
>blocks your path
What did I just hear you say about SaNa not being canon, sweetie?
>>
He should have died to the lion fag in the water arc, that was some asspull shit since the guy hit him with killer attacks multiple times
>>
>>158836239
"One Piece exists!" is the single moment the series reached its peak. There are other arcs of comparable quality for sure, but I don't think there's an arc better than Marineford.
>>
>O MY GEAR 269430
>>
Tried reading HXH a few years ago but couldn't get past the first 150 chapters. Just seemed like a generic battle shounen with some edgy moments whereas I was hooked on OP since the first chapter.
>>
>>158836466
Its pretty good mate. Nen is one of the best power systems in any comic book. If you like OP you will definitely enjoy it.
>>
File: zolo.gif (18KB, 149x112px) Image search: [Google]
zolo.gif
18KB, 149x112px
>>158836368
YOUR SHITPOSTING.....its EVOLVING!!!!

Good shit tho, good shit.
>>
these threads fucking blow because pussy mods won't do anything about shitposters, they've let that faggot repost the same fucking image ten times in every single thread and he's just going to do it in this one. they'll fucking randomly delete singular images that dont affect the thread, and nothing else. mods have ruined these generals
>>
File: onepiecev29c275p19.jpg (140KB, 641x960px) Image search: [Google]
onepiecev29c275p19.jpg
140KB, 641x960px
>>
>>158836521
Nen is an asspull concept. You can literally escape death if you just make a deal with it.
>>
>>158836239
O MY NIGHTMARE FORM
>>
>>158836466
How the fuck can you call HxH generic and then pretend One Piece isn't?
>>
File: absolutelydisgusting.jpg (49KB, 736x736px) Image search: [Google]
absolutelydisgusting.jpg
49KB, 736x736px
>>158836239
Great. So now on top of shipposters we have to deal with HXH fags. Good job OP, you just opened up a whole new box of cancer.
>>
>>158836621
Nightmare Luffy was time limited and gave him a modest power boost, it didn't bring him back from the dead for no reason.
>>
Remind he Luffy beat enel

With strong enough voltage lightning can melt rubber purely off the heat generated
>>
>>158836684
me how*
>>
>>158836642
It doesn't pretend to be edgy like HXH and is not just about shitty fights. I like the adventure aspect, lighthearted tone, and the world building which HXH seems to lack(from what I gathered of the first 150 chapters). Its a generic epic style story but it doesn't pretend to be anything else, which is why I like it.
>>
>>158836432
>no full fight
>better arc

Choose one
>>
>>158836368
Good lord you're mutating into something this world may not be ready for.
>>
>>158836738
>o my gomu gomu awakening

The properties of gum are already there
>>
>>158836521
>>
>>158836738
>It doesn't pretend to be edgy like HXH

How do you expect me to take your opinion seriously saying HxH is edgy?

I don't care what you like, one piece is the most generic manga out there to a point they literally copy and past a previous arcs structure and make a new arc based off that e.g Alabasta and dressrosa.

HxH has better pacing and doesn't waste 100 episodes getting party members before the crew actually starts their real adventure
>>
>>158836432
It's a great moment, but Oda's completely right when he calls Marineford a sidetrack. It affects almost nobody in the crew, it's all about the big players in the political world which are usually fairly distant to the actual story.
>>
>>158836239
>There are no "O' MY RUBBER NEN"'s in One Piece
Yes there are, they are just cleverly disguised as lore.
>>
>>158836893
>they literally copy and paste a previous arcs structure and make a new arc based off that e.g Alabasta and dressrosa

I mean, it's a sailing adventure, what do you expect?
>>
>>158836825
>>158836893
Eh. HxH's world doesn't feel real imo, whereas Oda has done such a good job with the world building that there's so much to speculate on and expect. And its comical that you complain about the pacing because at least OP fans gets to enjoy the content on a regular basis and by the time 100 episodes has passed, you guys end up getting only like 5 chapters. And for me, dressrosa was the only time I had trouble with the pacing otherwise it's been smooth sailing for the most part.
>>
>>158836466
For all the fags saying that One Piece is so 'generic'. Tell me, without me asking for recs here mods please read between the lines, what is so generic about it? Also generic isn't bad if it's high quality. I wish One Piece was bottom of the barrel and things would only improve from there but as it stands its one of the few shonen battle manga that doesn't have trash writing. It's genuinely brilliant, self-aware, parody, comedic, yet gets people that aren't too informed on it emotional enough about it to use words like 'nakama' unironically. I like edge though. Why do people hate edge again?
>>
>>158836239
O
>>
>>158836239
I wanna fuck Luffy desu
>>
>>158837034
I prefer gory and violent things to be done on special cases cause thats when it has a lot of impact. If it's done all the time, it just seems unnecessary to me. And for me I find it funny how edgy mangas try to portray the world as all doom and gloom and purposely avoid some of its positive aspects. Just feels imbalanced.
>>
>>158837079
CAPTAIN
>>
Can someone summarize the last 10 chapters I legit didn't understand shit
>>
>>158837157
What manga are you talking about in particular here? I think that just leans on being a poorly written one moreso than it trying to be as edgy as possible
>>
>>158837169
MY
>>
>MY NEN IS STRONGER THAN UR NEN XDDD SORRY GON

Next level power writing
>>
>>158837197
Berserk(though I heard its gotten better), and HXH is unnecessarily gory imo.
>>
>>158836581
yeah but it was shown that logias could train so that their DF activates unconsciously, like Crocodile
>>
>>158837209
RUBBER
>>
File: goodbye.jpg (160KB, 1000x922px) Image search: [Google]
goodbye.jpg
160KB, 1000x922px
>>158836239
GOODBYE CARROT. Time to go home.
>>
File: 1497541476172.png (187KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]
1497541476172.png
187KB, 300x300px
End game right here, brothers
>>
>>158837257
BROKE
>>
>>158837231
Berserk isn't edgy. He's just cursed. Only the first panel is out of place edgy and that's to set the tone. It's like those early Naruto panels that were toned down in the anime.

>I heard its gotten better
Personally I think it's worse now.
>>
>>158837187
luffy allies with mafia boss
try to kill big mom but they get btfo
jinbei is going to die soon
linlin did nothing wrong
sana is canon
>>
>>158836941
Don't give me that bullshit, recycling a major's arc premise and structure is epitome of laziness.
>>158837001
There's just as much as speculation in the current hxh arc so don't know what you're smoking.

And no the pacing in one piece is trash, how many episodes/chapters did it take for series to finally get it's main crew and sail off on their adventure?
>>
>>158837157
Hunter x Hunter isn't particularly gory or violent. It only gets that reputation compared to kid-friendly shonen. It's usually only as dark as an average OP flashback, just a bit more cynical with philosophies leaning more towards pragmatism with idealism usually being treated as noble but futile but noble.
>>
File: luffysempai.jpg (297KB, 1362x716px) Image search: [Google]
luffysempai.jpg
297KB, 1362x716px
>>158837281
End game brothers right here, brothers
>>
>>158837034
>It's genuinely brilliant
>Recycling arcs and dragging it out for years
>BRILLIANT
>>
File: smug carrot.png (765KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
smug carrot.png
765KB, 1280x720px
>>158837264
But, Uncle Pedro, we still have to escape! And you're obligated to make that HEROIC SACRIFICE that's been foreshadowed ever since you revealed you've had your life shortened by Big Mom.

Better get dying, bitch. I'm going adventuring with Luffy!
>>
>>158837389
Luffy-kun~*
>>
File: Meh.png (343KB, 1776x1300px) Image search: [Google]
Meh.png
343KB, 1776x1300px
>luffy went through so much shit for Ace
>the little bitch got taunted and then stopped following luffy like a retard and then died making everything luffy did pointless

Yeah dropped that shit there, how can someone be this selfish and retarded? I even felt like i wasted time watching luffy do all his shit.
>>
>>158837187
They try to assassinate Big Mom. Plan is to distract her (Luffy and a bunch of his mirror clones jump out of the cake) while Brook breaks Carmel's picture, it will make Big Mom cry and lose her invincibility for a few seconds - that's when Capone's men shoot her with poison gas. Meanwhile, Sanji saves his family.
Brook breaks the picture, Big Mom screams, drops on her knees and bleeds, Capone's men prepare to shoot, flashback time.
Big Mom was an unstoppable monster since the age of 5, it made her parents ditch her on Elbaf where Carmel took her in her orphanage with other kids. One day, they all joined in celebrating winter solstice with giants which involved fasting for 12 days. On the 7th day, Big Mom went on a hungry rampage (like CROQUEMBOUCHE) and killed several giants, including one of their leaders. They managed to stop her by giving her the snack she wanted (and Carmel stopped the fire she caused by using Soul Soul fruit), but when Big Mom came to, she didn't remember a thing. Giants wanted to kill her, but Carmel took the children and left Elbaf.
Then it's revealed Carmel was a human trafficker all along who sold children to the Navy, Cipher Pol and such. She wanted to sell Big Mom to CP-0. Then it was Big Mom's 6th birthday, they made her a cake, and she was so happy that she got carried away and ate Carmel and the other kids together with the cake. But she couldn't remember doing it, so she just thought they all left while she was eating.
She was seen by two people: a giant, who left for Elbaf and told everyone that Big Mom ate Carmel and the rest alive, and the cook who made the wedding cake for Pudding's wedding. The cook was a sick bastard who liked what he saw and decided to stick around. Using his own DF, Cook Cook fruit, he made all kinds of food for Big Mom so she wouldn't starve. Together, they founded Big Mom pirates and Totland (the island they were on was Whole Cake Island). 1/2
>>
>>158837352
You've got any actual arguments? What do you consider genuine brilliancy then?
>>
>>158837443
Ace is a bitch, a dick, and an asshole. He's a one man anal porn with fisting on the side. Or through the chest.

Anyways, Ace is actually a shit character and I hate him more than I hate Law.
>>
>>158836239
>There are no "O' MY RUBBER NEN"'s in One Piece
Pell didn't die
>>
File: 1498137010784.jpg (220KB, 1417x1890px) Image search: [Google]
1498137010784.jpg
220KB, 1417x1890px
I don't know what feels better that SaNa got this page or the butthurt of the other shippers.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>158837504
>hating law
law is great because he gets constantly abused by the strawhats

fuck ace and sabo though
>>
>>158837187
>>158837455
Big Mom was so strong, she got a 500 million bounty as a kid, and it only went on growing. She became able to use Soul Soul fruit seemingly without eating the fruit (most likely because she ate Carmel). Flashback over.
In the present, Capone's men shoot, but Big Mom's scream is so powerful that it obliterates the rockets mid-air and breaks the mirror they were supposed to use to escape. It also knocks the Tamatebako away, sending it falling down from the plateau. Nami gives Vinsmokes they raid suits, they HENSHIN and fight Big Mom's kids, but there are too many enemies. Capone creates a big castle (called Big Father) and tells the allies to get inside, but it only manages to buy them a little time. Big Mom regains consciousness and attacks the castle, injuring Capone. If the castle is destroyed, Capone dies.
>>
File: One-Piece-4-6.jpg (71KB, 580x500px) Image search: [Google]
One-Piece-4-6.jpg
71KB, 580x500px
>>158836368
I once hated you but now, now you're all right.
>>
>>158837560
I just hate how much of an edgy fujobait Law is. Poochie D. Law is accurate.

But I prefer to call him Trafalgar D. Edgehog
>>
>>158837473
>What do you consider genuine brilliancy then?

When an author doesn't have to rely on recycling a previous popular arc then that's the start of writing something good
>>
File: basedpedro.jpg (250KB, 900x1200px) Image search: [Google]
basedpedro.jpg
250KB, 900x1200px
>>158837389
Its ok Carrot, I know you're scared shitless cause of facing a Yonkou, which is why I'll send you with my former mink crew back to Zou.

Now that Luffy and the crew have BTFO BigMom and I got my life back, I owe my existence to Luffy and will do whatever it takes to make him Pirate King. Dont cause too much trouble back at home you hear!!
>>
If One Piece was as series that actually did research on elements ENEL would have killed luffy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qq-_JzYM6bo
>>
File: nah.jpg (15KB, 245x245px) Image search: [Google]
nah.jpg
15KB, 245x245px
>>158837623
Sucks for you I guess. Lets agree to disagree cause I genuinely tried getting into HXH and just wasn't the manga for me whereas its probably the opposite for you.
>>
File: 1498188907454.jpg (291KB, 1417x1890px) Image search: [Google]
1498188907454.jpg
291KB, 1417x1890px
>>158837545
and heres namis POV in the pupil-edit
>>
File: carrot tsun.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
carrot tsun.png
2MB, 1920x1080px
>>158837632
PSH. You couldn't stop me from coming with you guys. What can your old crew do? They'll get half-way to Zou before realizing I'm still with Luffy-kun~. And I ain't scared. I'm shaking 'cause I'm EXCITED! THIS IS FUNZIES!
>>
>>158837721
It's a cartoon.
>>
File: everyone agrees.png (137KB, 821x712px) Image search: [Google]
everyone agrees.png
137KB, 821x712px
>>158837545
>>158837734
You are beyond retarded. Take your fanart back to tumblr. Face it, her eyeline converges on Sanji's face in the edit and into the distance in the original. It was most likely a mistake by Oda, that will be fixed in the volume release/anime.
>>
>>158837734
She should really get that glaucoma checked out.
>>
File: eyecontact.jpg (384KB, 1126x551px) Image search: [Google]
eyecontact.jpg
384KB, 1126x551px
>>158837760
No need to put up such a brave act Carrot. I know you wanna travel the seas but I saw how you were shaking from fear when Daifuku almost got you. You can travel with the mink crew and they're defintely not gonna go to Wano. Now excuse me while me and my new best friend help Luffy in his journey.
>>
>>158837623
So who? Which titles? Give me something to work with.
>>
File: 144609246716.png (97KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]
144609246716.png
97KB, 250x250px
>>158837623
>recycling a previous popular arc is generic
>>
>>158836684
You know how Devil Fruits can be subservient to others? Well what if some are natural counters to each other? Could be a fun thing to play with.
>>
>>158837860
Don't worry, Uncle Pedro. You're NOBLE FINAL ACT to save us all will not be forgotten, and will give me more determination to carry on and adventure in your name! Your BRAVE SACRIFICE will move us all! Sure, me and Luffy-Kun~ will mourn, but we will carry on. And when I find a CERTAIN DEAD BIRD BITCH'S fruit, and I get my snow powers, I'll be able to help Luffy reach his goal to be Pirate King better. On your honor, of course!
>>
File: tumblr_ormc72y95U1w0jhvso2_540.png (260KB, 540x266px) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_ormc72y95U1w0jhvso2_540.png
260KB, 540x266px
>>158837734
A little more to the left.
That's why that autists edit is wrong
>>
People who hate on Marineford are just new and were not on /a/ when the arc was happening. The last stretch of the arc is full of shit hitting the fan week after week after week.

One week, we got Ace's death, the next week we got Blackbeard's arrival, the week after that, Whitebeard dies with the words "One Piece, it exists", the following week Blackbeard got Whitebeard's power. You think it's over? One week later Shanks arrived to end the war.

Being a One Piece on /a/ 7 years ago was a full on blast. Threads were had, capslock were on, shitposting drowned (to some extend). And after what's done is done, Oda decided to take a ONE MONTH hiatus before the time-skip, and the mod stickied the news (to the chagrin of Satoshi Kon fans because the One Piece sticky replaced the sticky about the news of Kon's passing) which reached 4k posts.

You just had to be there.
>>
File: 1497828233665.png (708KB, 750x500px) Image search: [Google]
1497828233665.png
708KB, 750x500px
>>158838042
>you're still triggered enough to false flag as me
It makes it all worth it, to be honest. Everyone just ignore my retarded little cousin here. He's trying to make SaNa look bad with specious arguments based on fanart.
>>
>>158838089
Marineford was good but >>158836768
>>
File: tumblr_orm5hxnIvn1vz2sn9o1_400.png (61KB, 363x300px) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_orm5hxnIvn1vz2sn9o1_400.png
61KB, 363x300px
>>158838107
So that's what you are trying to do. I already knew that though.
Stay mad LuNafag.
>>
File: Urouge.png (84KB, 201x224px) Image search: [Google]
Urouge.png
84KB, 201x224px
>>158836368
TFW SaNafag is getting out-trolled and this dude is actually kind of funny. Keep it up my dude, I'm not even mad anymore.
>>
>>158836466
watch the 2011 anime
Togashi's art is dogshit
>>
>Oda will never top Enies Lobby
why even read bros?
>>
>>158838204
LuNafags are still getting butthurt by his false flag though. It's all good
>>
>>158836368
>sweetie
What does she mean by this?
>>
>>158838250
He topped Enies Lobby two arcs before that.
>>
>>158837545
Which other shippers?
>>
File: One Piece Sanji Pudding.jpg (1002KB, 2551x1701px) Image search: [Google]
One Piece Sanji Pudding.jpg
1002KB, 2551x1701px
>>158838336
I'm more of a SaPu myself.
>>
Is the door from PH stronger than Sanji?
>>
File: 20170615_210916.jpg (208KB, 810x829px) Image search: [Google]
20170615_210916.jpg
208KB, 810x829px
>>158838336
SaPoofags aka L*N*whales
>>
File: foreshadowing.jpg (118KB, 607x598px) Image search: [Google]
foreshadowing.jpg
118KB, 607x598px
TFW Oda is right on the precipice of causing massive butthurt by opening the huge can of worms called crew romance. Remember that Oda never said there would be no crew romance, just that "they are in love with adventure".

Ussop and Kaya are clearly gonna end up together. Chopper is already in love. And one of the MAIN THEMES of this arc is romance, and within the next few chapters we will know for sure if Pudding and Sanji are in love(Sanji has been at one point with her but now we are not sure, Pudding may have fallen for him). And if that occurs then it would demolish both the SaNa fanbase and the no-romance whatsoever fanbase. Pushing forward even further, wait as Zoro and Tashigi's relationship will be expanded upon in Wano, as well that of Franky and Robin(matching shirts, and him sleeping on her lap is NOTHING?!).

Finally, last but not least wait as Luffy will either have to choose between Hancock and Nami
as Hancock's past may very well be focused on in the Celestial Dragons Arc. And Nami will probably get some spotlight when Luffy inevitably faces another emotional breakdown(due to loss of crew, death, etc).

From here on out its gonna be the OP is gonna truly be Romance Dawn. Damn it feels good to be an enlightened OP reader.
>>
>>158838579
Vivi is in the Luffybowl too. Don't discount her, even though she wont win!
>>
>>158838579
Chopper got a boner, let's not get ahead of ourselves here.
>>
>>158838636
>Chopper got a boner
hold the fuck up
>>
>>158838579
>(matching shirts, and him sleeping on her lap is NOTHING?!).
That sleeping on her lap bit was an edit. The matching outfits was fun, and they are a very good duo (especially with Brook now), but they haven't shown any real romantic inclinations.
>>
>>158837795
>makes retarded edit
>someone makes a strawpoll to see which /a/ prefers
>everyone votes for the original
>butttriggered madfag floods the poll with votes in his favor, about thirty votes in ten minutes
>continues reposting the screenshot of fake poll results daily

why are you such a loser? it's even worse because the everyone agreed the edit was shit and a new thread was made, yet you keep bringing up the poll. just how triggered are you?
>>
>>158838579
Usopp had a scene that was almost exactly the same as this, in reaction to the same event even.
>>
File: tumblr_mr7jjcfgX11riom3mo1_500.png (235KB, 500x474px) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_mr7jjcfgX11riom3mo1_500.png
235KB, 500x474px
>>158836323
>>
>>158838579
I think LuNa will happen. The hints that are there are definitely NOT explained by both of them being the main male and female roles.
I'm also not ignoring how the rest of the crew acts the same if not more
>>
>>158836239
>There are no "O' MY RUBBER NEN"'s in One Piece
No, there's just "O MY RUBBER BODY, LET ME BLOW AIR INTO IT TO SOMEHOW MAKE IT STRONGER" moments constantly.

At least gear 2 made sense. But, a 1lb rubber brick blown up with air to be 10 feet wide still just weights 1lb.
>>
File: Canon Soonâ„¢.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
Canon Soonâ„¢.png
1MB, 1280x720px
>>158838705
>this much damage control
You don't take losing well, do you? Stay upset, L*N*Blimp.
>>
File: 1498189515419.png (173KB, 821x712px) Image search: [Google]
1498189515419.png
173KB, 821x712px
>>158837795
Feel free to post your hijacked strawpoll daily, I'll just be posting this every time you do.
>>
>>158838579
How is are Nami OR Luffy love interests to eachother?
>>
>>158836239
>hxh has some terrible art that is fixed later
>one piece has a terrible anime that will never be fixed
>>
File: alphaandho7.jpg (981KB, 1696x1038px) Image search: [Google]
alphaandho7.jpg
981KB, 1696x1038px
>>158838814
>>
File: weww lad.png (6KB, 62x41px) Image search: [Google]
weww lad.png
6KB, 62x41px
>>158838805
top fucking l o l. Thank you for posting this. Your ass must feel like you met up with akainu at a gay mens bathhouse.
>>
File: mfw.gif (238KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]
mfw.gif
238KB, 600x338px
>>158838805
HAHAHAHA. Holy shit the BUTTHURT
>>
File: Hints for LuNa.png (59KB, 299x764px) Image search: [Google]
Hints for LuNa.png
59KB, 299x764px
>>158838837
>colorspreads
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>158838847
According to that screenshot there should be 36 other people who frequent these threads who would agree with you that the poll is not fake.

I have not seen a single person besides you vouch for that poll. You're a loser and I hope you get banned for your constant shitposting.
>>
Please stop this One Piece v Hunter X Hunter shit storms. It just makes the fans of both look bad.
>>
>>158838941
who cares
>>
>>158838837
All those color spreads are cropped out of group shots with everyone in them.
>>
>>158837795
>expects anyone to believe 50 people voted in a random strawpoll in a one piece thread

lol what, strawpolls literally never get more than twenty votes in these threads. this is obviously b8
>>
>>158839019
So? Doesn't change the fact that she clearly wants dick as she is placed extremely close to him.
>>
File: S O O N.gif (283KB, 280x279px) Image search: [Google]
S O O N.gif
283KB, 280x279px
>>158838922
You seem upset. Don't be. Learn to lose with a little dignity. Learn to choose the winning ship. Embrace SaNa, it will be canon soon. Pic very related.
>>
>>158839059
Do you think male and female characters are magnetically pushed away from each other unless they're romantic interests
>>
>>158839059
And what about the dozens of dozens of other color spreads where she's not placed close to him?
>>
>>158836905
But it's also the arc that entirely sets up the universe we now exist in for the series, without that arc, we'd know nothing about like any of the major players in the world and have no idea of what level Luffy was actually on, it was a set-up that's needed, otherwise we'd just have to settle for a bunch of exposition about stuff people would have wanted to see like we get now

That said, anyone who thinks it is the best arc is retarded, it's the climax, but it's not even close to the best example of what made One Piece great
>>
File: 1470889197949.png (439KB, 541x427px) Image search: [Google]
1470889197949.png
439KB, 541x427px
>>158838089
>7 years ago
>this can't be right. I'm 99% sure this is bs
>google it
>2009–2010 (Manga)
Jesus christ no.
>>
>One Piece recycles arcs meme
Name one time this happens. If you say Dressrosa recycles Alabasta, you're genuinely retarded. The similarities are only on the surface. If you dig into the differences, you'll understand the story Oda was trying to tell with Dressrosa.
>>
File: foreshadowing2.jpg (958KB, 760x2364px) Image search: [Google]
foreshadowing2.jpg
958KB, 760x2364px
>>158838728
Fair enough. Though this picture speaks volumes as well.
>>
>>158838579
All memes aside if I was Oda I would be tempted to troll the shippers after watching the massive shitstorms over Naruto and Bleach. Luckily Oda is not me and respects is work too much to do something as retarded as that.
>>
>>158837443
Uh, the alternative is "yeah...sorry" so I think it's for the best, you can't get worse than Sasuke and still be considered a character
>>
>>158839104
>>158839109
Could be nothing sure. But Oda does it often enough where imo he is definitely hinting at something. Whether anything happens or not, I dont know but taken the direction OP is clearly heading at right now, this will probably come up as a later plot point as said >>158838579
>>
>>158839180
SaNafags are the most delu-


I'm done with this retarded fan base
>>
>>158839294
Tbh, no-romance fags will get btfo the hardest which will also be fun to watch.
>>
>>158839285
>imo
You're not even worth talking to.
>>
>>158839177
b-but they go onto an island everytime and there's a villlain and drama and fighting...
>>
The sad thing is the actually HxH threads are about the same level as this thread.
>>
>>158839285
>hinting at something
>in colorspreads
No he is not. This is some Ichiruki level shipping. Embarrassing
>>
>>158836239
O
>>
>>158836738

HxH at least for the first 13 volumes has much less fights than one piece.
>>
>>158839361
The OPM thread earlier was like exactly the same as OPG has been including twin shitposters ruining the thread using the same gimmick. It was impressive.
>>
>>158839362
Oda has a history of using colorspreads to foreshadow plot details. Its funny how in terms of other theories and speculation they are accepted as solid evidence whereas with "shipping" all hell breaks loose.
>>
>>158838772
Your message and image conflict with each other, are you implying you thought Naruto and Sakura was going to happen despite the series going out of its way all throughout its run to make it clear it wasn't?

The sort of interactions people cling on to for shipping are the sort that can be totally taken anyway depending on what the epilogue presents. At this point, you could ship any character with another and it could make perfect sense.
>>
>>158839319
I'm not against romance. I'm sure it will happen at the end but your hints are some of the most retarded shit I have ever seen.
Nami acts like everyone else in the crew acts with Luffy.
Especially the ones who are closes to him(Zoro and Usopp)
>>
File: 239009789.jpg (62KB, 452x444px) Image search: [Google]
239009789.jpg
62KB, 452x444px
I can't tell if the shipping is ironic or not. I always assumed there were a few shippers in the fanbase, but I figured they just did it for fun and kept it in their own corner of the internet. Now they are actively ruining the little discussion had here. Honestly feel like its some kind of plot to create shipping butthurt on the level of Bleach and Naruto, but Occam's razor says these people are just slightly loony.
>>
>>158839180
Nami is very hot here
>>
>>158839520
I remember when shipping wasn't even allowed in these threads

and for good reason
>>
File: 1497557945839.png (582KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]
1497557945839.png
582KB, 640x360px
>>158839442
Oh really like what? Plead show me what.
Ace death is total bullshit btw. And even if it wasn't that's only just 1 time.
Also how do you explain other colorspreads where Oda seems to be hinted other ships? Pic related is the only one I have saved but there have also been color spreads for Zoro x Nami.
How do you explain those?
>>
>>158836239
agreed yet HxH might be a decent competition for One Piece if its mangaka wasn't a lazy fag.

>>158836323
how is that a "rubber nen" moment? Ruffy inventing another gear during the timeskip is nothing surprising.
>>
>>158839442
>5

I'm surprised, because I remember when OP fans were not shitposters. But, I haven't followed OP for a while. Right, now HXH threads are pure cancer. between 99 vs 11 fags, O my rubber nen shitposters and so on I don't even bother.
>>
>>158839164
You are here forever.
>>
>>158836239
>My shitty WSJ series is better than yours!
Who cares? Shounenshitters need to fuck off already.
>>
File: 006.jpg (263KB, 869x1254px) Image search: [Google]
006.jpg
263KB, 869x1254px
>>158839180
That obvious romantically-interested-tsundere-picks-at-character-flaws trope. Fucking Goda.
>>
Why is Ivankov so based? When I first saw is design before I was even close to Impel Down I absolutely hated him but after marathoning the manga up to the timeskip he's become one of my favorite characters.
>>
>>158839690
>Who cares? Shounenshitters need to fuck off already.

I remember when HxH was more obscure and less people knew about it before the 2011 anime brought in the swath of newfags who constantly want to measure dicks with other shounenshitters.
>>
>>158839690
>muh taste is objectively superior
go back to your harem animus you pillowhugger faggot
>>
File: onepiece_c596_018.jpg (226KB, 715x1023px) Image search: [Google]
onepiece_c596_018.jpg
226KB, 715x1023px
>>158839719
Wtf Luffy x Usopp is canon now
>>
>>158839633
Not the guy you responded to but colorspreads still retain the character and personality of the crew. So it makes sense people would use it for shipping. As for the images you showed, they are all that of Sanji looking at Nami and it is in his character to ogle women. Not here to argue ships but just letting you know why people use them in arguments and why it's valid.
>>
>>158838772
Why did Naruto care for Sakura again? Nobody else did right?
>>
>>158839791
He's not picking at his character flaws he is just saying that there are enemies Luffy can't beat; therefore Luffy needs his power. Learn to read and don't reply to my posts or my posts children ever again.
>>
>>158838818
hxh 2011 isn't all that great either
>>
The problem with One Piece is its terrible world building and hamfisted attempts at tackling social issues without any nuance whatsoever. The world of OP feels artificial, every arc and location has some relation to the strawhats, it's built around them rather than existing as separate beings with their own historical and social context that can fully function without their existence. Also the rich and privileged exploiting the poor done redundantly in the most cringe manner. Let's not forget the shallow one dimensional characters with Sabo being a literal shoehorned replacement for Ace. Terrible twist, it rendered the entirety of post-timeskip meaningless, not to mention the drawn out pacing and cluttering of panels.
>>
File: 48390649.jpg (254KB, 455x700px) Image search: [Google]
48390649.jpg
254KB, 455x700px
>>158839586
I remember when Naruto discussion was pretty much not tolerated on /a/. One Piece and HxH were accepted without shitposting, and we discussed Bleach just to see how far Kubo was willing to go to fuck with his readers. I don't know what changed, but it was not for the better. /a/ was never perfect, but it was better than it is now. If the archives were around I think it would be pretty easy to prove. I could just be getting too old for this shit though.
>>
>>158839855
>you are wrong
Wow you post definitely helped LuNa there
>>
>>158839886
It's literally the best animated long running shonen adaptation.
>>
>>158839911
Hunter x Hunter 1999 and Yu Yu Hakusho are better. 2011 has no style, no authorial voice behind the animation staff, no soul.
>>
>>158839851
Because MUH SASSGAY
>>
>>158839911
>if I put it in these arbitrary boxes I have something positive to say about it
It's budget as fuck. 99 was much better.
>>
>>158839545
i think Skypiea Nami s the best

>>158839319
>>158839502
>niggas dont know that the romance has already happened and still happening because its pretty much the point of One Piece
stop using words incorrectly
>>
File: 20170623_000416.jpg (31KB, 126x200px) Image search: [Google]
20170623_000416.jpg
31KB, 126x200px
>>158839829
Wtf SaNa is canon now. The autist was right and Oda will add blushes on the volume
>>
>>158839911
Anyone who argues this is a retard. I'd chop my nuts off to get an anime adaptation of OP as good as HxH 2011.
>>
>>158839976
I understand Naruto caring for the sauce.
>>
>>158839908
Not being able to defeat every enemy by yourself isn't a character flaw(unless you're Onii-sama) but Nami is naming things that are flaws in Luffy's character. Stay retarded tho.
>>
File: 1487253818873.png (70KB, 147x254px) Image search: [Google]
1487253818873.png
70KB, 147x254px
>>158839889
>The problem with One Piece is its terrible world building
stopped reading here. here is your (you)
>>
>>158839998
I'd rather have studio pierrot handle it
>>
>>158839972
>>158839977
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zN5nQsUUtE0
>>
>>158839988
>The autist was right and Oda will add blushes on the volume

The guy's a LuNa fag who's trolling anon. As for that image, Nami flirts with Sanji all the time in order to make him do shit, that really isn't off character. Also given the traditional theme, her response is something that a waitress of that era would normally be expected to do, ie. be modest and shy.
>>
>>158840023
Every crewmember has pointed out those flaws. But j guess you don't see those don't you? Stay retarded. Can't wait for your angry tumblr meltdown when you are "letdown"
>>
>>158839894
>I could just be getting too old for this shit though
I feel you. I used to be here every single day, now it's more like once or twice a week at most and I just speedread the threads
>>
>>158839998
The worst part is that even a Kai won't save it because the base product is terrible. There is nothing to salvage. Why don't the elevens speak up about it?
>>
File: BigMeme.jpg (98KB, 792x388px) Image search: [Google]
BigMeme.jpg
98KB, 792x388px
>TFW BigMeme is going down this arc.

The butthurt here is gonna be amazing.
>>
>>158840207

lol already, isn't she a yonkou? 4 of the strongest pirates in the world?
>>
>>158840244
>lol

Man, I fucking hate summer.
>>
>>158840255
>linked anon supports your autism posting
>still doesn't match up with your delusions properly so you still find something to nitpick about
You really are something else.
>>
>>158840255
There is such thing as nuance anon.
>>
>>158840067
How does that compare with real cinema?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QvNUkqHni6o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i99EXTKcNx0
>>
>>158840244
She's just an overgrown fatass who sits around all day and eats sweets and her children. She's such a weak (((Yonko))) that she has to grovel and rape men into alliances just so her shitty territory doesn't fall apart. While REAL Yonko like Whitebeard, Kaido and Shanks were going up against the very strongest BigMeme was strugggling on the toilet trying to shit out yesterday's sweets. Only reason she never got injured is cause her cannibal face never had the opportunity to meat Whitebeard's fist. She's gonna job so hard that the word jobbing will be synoymous with BigMeme and her failure will inspire countless threads of shitposting.

So yeah, she's about to get BTFO
>>
File: file.png (253KB, 500x402px) Image search: [Google]
file.png
253KB, 500x402px
>>158836239
O MY BIRD CAGE.

KILL THE CITIZENS SO I MAY FIGHT LAW AND THE RUBBER MAN
>>
File: big meme is going down.png (431KB, 660x908px) Image search: [Google]
big meme is going down.png
431KB, 660x908px
>>158840436
Big Meme is going to get BTFO so hard the entirety of the Big Mom pirates will end up in Luffy's crew.
>>
>people have died waiting for one piss to end
>>
>>158840478
Does he even need to fight Shanks? Does Shanks even care about being pirate king?
>>
>>158840532
Luffy is still asspained Shanks wouldn't take him on his crew so he has to kick his ass before giving him the hat so he'll regret it.
>>
>>158836239
Yeah but do you remember when luffy got up from Lucci's most powerful attack for the third time and used gear second on top of it? I mean fuck I have not even seen HxH but that shit was an undeniable aspull.
>>
File: O MY GORO GORO NO MI.png (409KB, 728x1184px) Image search: [Google]
O MY GORO GORO NO MI.png
409KB, 728x1184px
>>158840451
>birdcage
newfag spotted
>>
>>158840641

Nakama power
>>
>>158840067
This really isn't that impressive. That dog face is meme worthy.

>>158840398
Kurapika was my first crush
>>
File: 1494562242067.jpg (63KB, 338x345px) Image search: [Google]
1494562242067.jpg
63KB, 338x345px
What did he mean by this?

What's the D's connection to the weather?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YI1cXfp8vjM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oV3KJw4rDXo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNRvpLgUjSk
>>
>>158840641
Remember that One Piece is a comedy.
>>
>>158840727
Surely that moment was funny as fuck. Got me laughing for years in the most suspenseful part of the arc.
>>
>>158840663
Exactly
>>
I haven't read One Piece in years. Why is there so much shipping faggotry in One Piece threads nowadays?
>>
>>158840641
Not an asspull. He just toughed it out. An asspull would be if he got back up, an decided to "USE THAT".
>>
>>158840747
my favorite part will forever be ace's death. Oda is a comedic genius
>>
>>158840787

He was near dead and he magically got back up.
>>
>>158840783
Naruto and Bleach ended. Fans of those series came over here, and then just regular shitposters who want attention.
>>
>>158840783
I'm assuming it's women that don't understand the appeal of one piece but know the threads are popular so use it to gain attention so they read one piece without understanding it and just self-insert as an actual attractive woman.

tl;dr talking about shippers is just as bad. Please don't do this.
>>
>>158840796
That was funny as three thousand fucks, but that's not even the peak of Oda's comedic genious. Remember Whitebeard's death? That shit was so unexpected.

Gintama my ass One Piece is where real comedy its at.
>>
>>158840783
Started out as ironic shitposting. And is now unironic.
>>
File: O MY ITO ITO NO MI.jpg (350KB, 728x1044px) Image search: [Google]
O MY ITO ITO NO MI.jpg
350KB, 728x1044px
What's the biggest asspull Oda did?

Hard Mode: No Gears
>>
>>158840783
The current arc was involves Sanji being forced to marry Big Mom's daughter. Shippers hear that and go crazy.
>>
>>158840863
>Remember Whitebeard's death
No?
>>
>>158840818
He didn't magically get back up. He did it through force of will and determination. Generic hero stuff. Not like a fairy popped up and healed him you know? Not saying its good even though I liked it, but its not an asspull.
>>
>>158840823
As if Naruto fans would ever settle for an inferior product like One Piece. The anime is trash and the manga is only slightly better.
>>
File: 1497950014624.jpg (22KB, 432x313px) Image search: [Google]
1497950014624.jpg
22KB, 432x313px
>>158836368
10/10
>>
>>158840877
This was just a play on Enel's resurrection scene.
>>
>>158840787
>>158840818
It would be ok, but he literally was not able to get back up from the second attack. The fact he got up from that one was cheap, but a tiny bit forgivable. The fact he was at the verge of passing out and magically uses gear 2nd and thoughed it out may not be an asspull by definition, but it sure is cheap as a white slave.
>>
>>158840877
Why would gears even be considered asspulls?
>>
>>158840907
>He didn't magically get back up.
>He did it through force of will and determination.

So, he used the power of plot to get up from an attack that clearly finished him.
>>
>>158840910
>One Piece
>Inferior to Naruto

Maybe in regards to the anime buy the One Piece manga knocks Naruto out of the park.
>>
>>158840885
No wonder you think Ace's death is the peak of comedy in One Piece
>>
>>158840955
it undeniably is
>>
>>158840877
No. That is somewhat believable and wasn't that big a deal when Doffy was beaten later anyways.
Zoro's 9 sword style is the biggest asspull.
The gears actually have some thought into them (even if it's incredibly unrealistic) so I don't mind them but they are definitely asspulls.
>>
>>158840949
>it's the op is better than naruto meme
kill yourself
>>
>>158840941
May I add, it already finished him the second time Lucci did it.
>>
>>158840974
>Zoro's 9 sword style is the biggest asspull.

Yes, this so much.
>>
why didn't whitebeard use his power to heal the wounds of his crew?
>>
>>158840877
Gears is using Luffy's body in a way which gives him advantage. It is not an asspull by any means, if anything, its the most acceptable type of transformation from most shonen. Since it doesnt involve "muh ki just got boosted as fuck lol"
>>
>>158840974
>>158841018
I feel like Oda knows Asura was a huge mistake and that't why it barely show's up.
>>
>>158841025
So now Whitebeard has the power to heal people. What the fuck man.
>>
>>158841030

You're a retard. He just blows air into is shit and becomes suped up. How is that acceptable? And, he uses some bullshit energy later on with Haki anyway.
>>
>>158840974
How are gears asspulls? Also I really don't think Asura is actually Zoro using 9 swords. I think its a visual metaphor.
>>
>>158841057
vibrations man, I don't think anything of significance to an organism without them.
>>
File: high-speed-rail-China-2014.jpg (74KB, 550x400px) Image search: [Google]
high-speed-rail-China-2014.jpg
74KB, 550x400px
SaNa train is going fast as fuck.
>>
>>158841045
Better that way. What the fuck was he thinking honestly, even diable jamble makes more sense in One Piece's silly context. What the fuck was that shit Naruto or some shit. Hidden demon my ass get that out of here
>>
>>158841093
>Also I really don't think Asura is actually Zoro using 9 swords. I think its a visual metaphor.

A visual metaphor that oneshots kaku and ripped through his attack? What?
>>
>>158841095
can happen*
>>
>>158841045
Yea. I think it's only been used twice. Against Kaku and the Pacifista on Sabaody.
I still don't know which would rub me the wrong way more. No explanation of it, just completely forget about it and it never shows up in the story, or some bullshit convoluted explanation for it.
>>
>>158841081
He's also made of rubber you going to complain about that too? Its cartoon logic.
>>
>>158841081
I mean it did make sense with gear 3rd and 2nd. Gear 4th makes muscles bigger, so the impact is bigger.

He uses his gummy gigantic muscles to charge up his punches so when they come out they have more impact, like a spring. Not that hard to understand man come on
>>
File: REEEE.gif (3MB, 440x250px) Image search: [Google]
REEEE.gif
3MB, 440x250px
HOW MUCH LONGER TILL SPOILERS?!!! I CANT TAKE IT ANYMOREEEEEEEE!!!!!!

REEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
why do shipperfags ruin everything?
>>
>>158841159

No, but don't act as if that shit is some well thought out masterpiece like you godafags tend to do.
>>
>>158841045
It showed up like twice, didn't it? First time was against Kaku and 2nd time I believe it was against Pica?
>>
File: bring the sun down.png (19KB, 559x207px) Image search: [Google]
bring the sun down.png
19KB, 559x207px
kidd brings down the sun when?
>>
>>158841167

I didn't say it was hard to understand, though. I said why is it more acceptable to blow air from your thumb to your arm, but less acceptable to use magic Chinese energy? Like the faggot poster I responded to said??
>>
Report and hide people, report and hide.
>>
>>158841228
Because magic chinesse energy is never introduced in One Piece at that point. Luffy using his gum propierties to his advantage is, and through the whole series.
>>
>>158841118
Zoro does that all the time though. Dude just gets stronger when he needs to. Enemy gets that shit pushed in so hard its like they're fighting someone with 9 swords and 3 heads is how I always saw it.
>>
>>158841250
Report and hide what, exactly, anon-kun-chan-sama-sensei?
>>
>>158841196
I don't see what you're arguing about then. If it makes sense in the context of the setting/story why is it an asspull?
>>
>>158841228
>>158841281

Ki/Chi/Haki is used in almost every shounen and it being introduced shouldnt have been surprising. Its a huge part of asian culture. I really dont see how Haki is a meme power, its been used pretty creatively by Oda.
>>
>>158841281

It doesn't matter, the point is how is blowing air into your arm like popeye more acceptable than energy bullshit? I prefer the simple devil fruit abilities pre-haki rubber too, but it isn't really any more or less acceptable.
>>
>>158841338
>its been used pretty creatively by Oda.

Jesus Christ you fanboys are will eat whatever Oda shits out? I'm so glad I dropped this garbage series.
>>
Sanji is a shit character. He deserves to die a lonely virgin.
>>
>>158841338
Most fights are a competition to see which haki is stronger now tho
>>
>>158841337

It's on the same level as what that faggot was deriding.
>>
>>158841387
t. Asspained Zorofag
Sanji is a more believable character and deserves to live with what he pulls from the jaws of fate.
>>
>>158841398
Oda never should have had Zoro say that shit about MUH HAKI IS STRONGER THAN YOUR HAKI that was such a fucking mistake. I get that he was trying to show that Zoro can use haki now but it cheapened it for him to say that.
>>
>>158841298

Something happening all the time doesn't make it good though. This was worst because there's no explanation of how it works, not even a pseudo-explanation.
>>
>>158836239
The MC is RUBBER NEN.
>>
>>158841367
Why do you think its not? Having it seperated into categories and making Conquerors haki unique is relatively uncommon. Dont blame me for not actively looking for faults, at least I can enjoy the manga without being a complete autist.

>>158841398
Besides Vergo, I dont really see how most fights are about Haki now. Doffy v Luffy was just as more about their fruits than just haki. Same with Cracker v Luffy. Most major fights now aren't haki slugouts.
>>
I want to cum iinside Killua
>>
>>158841457
>Why do you think its not?

Can't prove a negative. Explain how it's creative since you're claiming it is. Because it's no different than the garbage found in any generic shounen, you're kidding yourself if you don't think so.
>>
>>158841457
>Having it seperated into categories

That's literally so common in battle manga.
even fucking Naruto did this, c'mon.
>>
>>158837340
Sanji c u c k e d yet again
>>
File: stay mad lunaplebs.png (1MB, 1063x751px) Image search: [Google]
stay mad lunaplebs.png
1MB, 1063x751px
>>158841531
Just wait until jump fixes our SaNami moment in the full volume, L*N*kek.
>>
>>158841339
Because One Piece is half a gag manga. That makes sense here. It would be different if this was a realistic martial arts manga then all of a sudden the characters start shooting lasers out of their eyes, and summoning energy from the underworld. Context is key.
>>158841398
Besides Vergo what other fight? Zoro vs Pica? I feel like people misunderstand what was going on. It wasn't necessarily about having stronger Haki, but actually being able to cut him. By having tougher Haki than Pica Zoro was able to cut him without breaking his shit.
>>
>>158841367
>I'm afraid of argument. No one should respond to me when I make a statement ever. REEEEEEEE

What else can be said? It's evident enough with how Luffy utilized Haki to come up with Gear 4th that Haki can be used creatively. If you don't want to have people challenge your opinion, then go to echo chamber hugbox like tumblr. And huge chance that you dropped it before Gear 4th, hence your complaint. I also don't see the point of posting in One Piece thread if you have "dropped this garbage series", and since you've made your mind and concluded that the series is "garbage", I don't know what else can try to convince you otherwise, you're most likely just blinded with hate and think "everything in One Piece is shit. No exceptions hurrr duuurrrr!".

>>158841398
>Most
Aside from Zoro vs Pica, I don't see wherever else where that was the case.
>>
>>158841575

So, being a gag manga means you can go half-mast on concepts because it's just a gag? Literally, retard logic. You can't introduce a shitty and generic energy system and then when you ask for an explanation you respond "Well, it's a gag manga" fuck off.
>>
MONET LIVES
>>
>>158841492
Just did. Unlike most applications of Chi/Ki, Haki is seperated into different categories which are completely different than simple "force power". Armament haki is used as a device to counter DF users and can toughen the user. Observation Haki can be used to sense and in high enough applications can be used to predict the future, which gives explanation of fortune telling in OP. And finally conquerors haki is unlike most applications of chi elsewhere because the user is able to dominate others through will alone. That is different from the chi/ki uses we've had in other manga so far.

Sure it's not a completely unoriginal idea but its a shounen manga, what did you expect? We needed some sort of counter to DF powers to explain why characters like Garp, Shanks, and Mihawk can hold their ground so it was a needed power.

Still dont get the butthurt over it, just seems like people wanna get mad over nothing to prove that they are somehow "smarter" reader.
>>
>>158836239

Superior... at sucking dick
>>
>>158841636
And don't forget that Observation Haki can be used to see long distance, like how Usopp developed one when he was sniping Sugar.
>>
>>158841595
>What else can be said? It's evident enough with how Luffy utilized Haki to come up with Gear 4th that Haki can be used creatively.

It's creative because it was used in a retarded power up?

>If you don't want to have people challenge your opinion, then go to echo chamber hugbox like tumblr.

Why would I need to go to Tumblr to call out a retarded mechanic in a manga?

>I also don't see the point of posting in One Piece thread if you have "dropped this garbage series", and since you've made your mind and concluded that the series is "garbage", I don't know what else can try to convince you otherwise, you're most likely just blinded with hate and think "everything in One Piece is shit. No exceptions hurrr duuurrrr!".

This isn't OPG though. Another manga, which I read is being discussed and compared. I don't care that you like Haki or like OP, just don't lie please and try to convince people that Haki is "Thought out". We all know it's not.
>>
>>158841668
>>158836239
Fuck OP for having such a garbage title as /opg/ dealing with butthurt HXH fags is always cancer.

Yeah I get it you like your manga a lot. We like our manga too, no one wants to get into a pointless argument cause such a debate can never be resolved.
>>
>>158841636

So, it can conveniently be used to counter the powers that have been prominent through most of the series. Wow, that doesn't sound like a plot device, especially against Logias which luffy stood no chance against minus the convenient ones like Enel. It's amazing how Haki came right in the nick of time.

You're right, it is different. It's basically 1/2 anti-logia mechanic topped with nonsense sensing ability. Oda also tried to link it to older powers like mantra to make it seem he had Haki planned all along.
>>
>>158841081
>How is that acceptable
Because considering the nature of his body that is made of rubber, it makes sense and it's explained thoroughly in the manga.

>>158841492
>Haki is bullshit energy!
>Why do you think so?
>Can't prove a negative because I say so lol

You made the claim. Burden of proof is on you. And Haki is not an energy, it doesn't run out. It's not a finite energy with a sizable amount like Ki/Reiki/Reiatsu/Furyoku or whatever else. It's an ability. Do Stand owners ever run out of "Stand energy"? They don't, becaue Stand energy doesn't exist.
>>
>>158841636
>Still dont get the butthurt over it, just seems like people wanna get mad over nothing to prove that they are somehow "smarter" reader.

Yet, you're arguing that it's actually smart series despite saying something like that?
>>
>>158841765
>Because considering the nature of his body that is made of rubber, it makes sense and it's explained thoroughly in the manga.

How does being made of rubber mean you can blow air from your fingers? Wut?

>You made the claim. Burden of proof is on you. And Haki is not an energy, it doesn't run out. It's not a finite energy with a sizable amount like Ki/Reiki/Reiatsu/Furyoku or whatever else. It's an ability. Do Stand owners ever run out of "Stand energy"? They don't, becaue Stand energy doesn't exist.

It doesn't even have an explanation, it's just the power of what's convenient for the user. We all know Oda wrote Haki in so Luffy could fight OP DF users convincingly. Because he wrote himself into a corner.
>>
>>158841735
>>158841781
>seem he had Haki planned all along.
Of course he wants us to have the impression. If he didnt then the story wouldn't be coherent and connected. I dont really care that he came up with the idea later on, I'm sure HXH introduced concepts that the author had not originally thought of. Thats not a negative.

However, Oda actually took the time and autism to make sure the power fit in with the story so people don't lose their immersion. Nothing wrong with that. Again, I dont get the anger.

>>158841781
>actually smart series
Never said that and you're putting words into my mouth. I get that you dont like OP and prefer HXH but none of the points you mentioned actually are negatives to the vast majority of readers. Why do butthurt readers of other manga have to be so intent on proving their superiority? Its just manga and entertainment after all.
>>
So is fishman island basically kill whitey the arc?
>>
>>158841668
>Was used in a retarded power-up
No. Haki was used to COME UP with the power up. Without the hardening that Armamaent Haki provides, Luffy wouldn't be able to increase the elasticity of his body. That's the whole point of Gear 4th.

>Why would I need to got to tumblr
Because you just called someone who disagrees with you a fanboy in an overreacting manner.

>Haki is "thought out"
It's been introduced since many volumes ago way before the time skip. And considering the ambitious and strong-willed nature of One Piece characters, it's a power system that fits the universe.

>We all know it's not
Speak for yourself.
>>
>>158841848
>However, Oda actually took the time and autism to make sure the power fit in with the story so people don't lose their immersion. Nothing wrong with that. Again, I dont get the anger.

It doesn't fit the story, though. Majority of OP was DF and the thing about DF is that they were set in stone. You couldn't change them, whatever power you got you were stuck with. Then suddenly some massive magic power that can even the odds? That's not an asspull to you?
>>
>>158841859
>It's been introduced since many volumes ago way before the time skip. And considering the ambitious and strong-willed nature of One Piece characters, it's a power system that fits the universe.

Please tell me you're one of those retards who believes when Shanks scared away the King of the coast and saved luffy he was using Haki.

>No. Haki was used to COME UP with the power up.

So, what? How does that make it smart, because it can rationalize bullshit power ups? Because that's all it's being used for 24/7. There's nothing smart about it.
>>
>>158841848
>Never said that and you're putting words into my mouth.

You said:
>>158841636
>just seems like people wanna get mad over nothing to prove that they are somehow "smarter" reader.

So, why are you arguing that it's actually smart in the first place?
>>
>>158841890
>Some massive magic power that can even the odds? That's not an asspull to you?

Its not because Haki is extremely rare in any area NOT the New World. Conquerors Haki was introduced in the first chapter, mantra back in skypiea, and armament with Garp. Oda just hadn't given names to those things and called it Haki yet. I'm not saying there are no asspulls in One Piece(gears, asura, diable jiambe) but Haki was foreshadowed. I dont read HXH but I'm sure your author has included quite a share of asspulls as well, and that didn't stop you from loving the story.
>>
>>158841933
Obviously Shanks scaring the monster was not originally Haki but Enel reading Luffy's moves and Garp and other characters being able to hurt luffy with blunt attacks was foreshadowing for Haki.
>>
>>158841611
So your complaints are with Haki? What do you have a problem with?
>>
>>158841970
>just seems like people wanna get mad over nothing to prove that they are somehow "smarter" reader.

Never said it was smart. I said that you were giving me the impression that you thought you were a "smarter" reader for not enjoying Haki and gears,etc. I'm not arguing it was smart, I'm implying that you think you're somehow a superior manga reader for not enjoying OP.
>>
File: Enel_Face.png (681KB, 608x1119px) Image search: [Google]
Enel_Face.png
681KB, 608x1119px
>>158836368
Jesus Christ, this is the best thing I've seen relating to One Piece in a long time.
>>
>>158841972
>Conquerors Haki was introduced in the first chapter

No, it wasn't. Shanks just scared King of the coast away. There's no proof he was using Haki, you retards try so hard to link it when it shows none of the signs (King of the coast did not faint or foam at the mouth)

>>158841988

And, that's the problem. Anything is Haki, because it's vague enough to connect it to any phenomena in the series. I've seen people argue Zoro's Shishi sonson is Haki. It has no parameters, it's a bunch of random things with no actual relationship other than being rubber-stamped as being part of the same parcel.
>>
>>158842030

I don't understand how I gave you that impression. This whole debate started because someone implied luffy blowing air into his arm and making it bigger is much more acceptable than magic energy system.
>>
>>158841817
>It doesn't even have an explanation
Did you even read the last chapter right before the time skip where Rayleigh explains everything?

>How does being made of rubber mean you can blow air from your fingers? Wut?
I'm really thinking hard on how to explain to you the nature of goofiness in One Piece where a rubber man makes his body parts bigger by blowing his finger is acceptable without you being a cocky ass who responds with something along the lines of "HURRR OF COURSE EVERYTHING CAN JUST BE EXPLAINED WITH 'LEL IT'S JUST FICTION IT'S JUST BEING FUNNY/GOOFY, IT'S A GAG/COMEDY LEL WAN PISS FAG'", but seems like the entire tone of One Piece goes over your head.

>it's just the power of what's convenient for the user.
Luffy got injured while in Gear 4th against Big Mom's commander. It's not at all convenient and all powerful hax. Of course you wouldn't know this considering you dropped the manga.

>We all know Oda wrote Haki in so Luffy could fight OP DF users convincingly
There were non DF users introduced way early in the series such as Mihawk people wondered how they go toe-to-toe with Logia users. Haki, the power that has been introduced, is the answer. Oda wouldn't introduce non-Logias who have their names heard around the world if they can't hold off against a Logia.
>Because he wrote himself into a corner.
So the many many volumes and chapters when Haki was shown beforehand don't count somehow? It's natural for the crew to learn Haki in timeskip considering they were about to enter the strongest sea.
>>
>>158842063
I get what you're trying to say but like I said >>158841848, at least Oda made it fit into the story in a coherent way despite your or mine disagreements over whether it was foreshadowing or not. Again I never read HXH but I'm sure it has its share of asspulls which I hope some anons here can point out. But despite those asspulls you are still able to enjoy reading it and thats all that matters for readers of both mangas.
>>158842096
>Jesus Christ you fanboys are will eat whatever Oda shits out? I'm so glad I dropped this garbage series

This gave me the impression.
>>
File: Friendly old person.jpg (110KB, 500x279px) Image search: [Google]
Friendly old person.jpg
110KB, 500x279px
Oda, where's my friend Zoro?
>>
>>158841933
No. Mantra in Skypiea and Shanks meeting with Whitebeard.

>So, what? How does that make it smart
Did you even read past the part you greentexted?

>>158842063
>Oda wrote himself into a corner!
>Provided with evidence that there were preceding events tat showed Haki
>HURRR SEE? EVERYTHING IS HAKI!
Rayleigh said it out loud that Observation Haki is known as Mantra in Sky Island.

>There's no proof he was using Haki
If that scene didn't exist, you would call Shanks usage of Haki in his meeting with Whitebeard as "asspull".
>>
>>158842129
>There were non DF users introduced way early in the series such as Mihawk people wondered how they go toe-to-toe with Logia users. Haki, the power that has been introduced, is the answer. Oda wouldn't introduce non-Logias who have their names heard around the world if they can't hold off against a Logia.

When did Mihawk fight a logia user to become famous? What are you talking about? Mihawk was famous because of his swordsmanship and he was strong. His reputation when he was introduced had nothing to do with beating logias FFS.

>So the many many volumes and chapters when Haki was shown beforehand don't count somehow? It's natural for the crew to learn Haki in timeskip considering they were about to enter the strongest sea.

In otherwords it's necessary for plot progression and is thus a plot device. cool.

>Luffy got injured while in Gear 4th against Big Mom's commander. It's not at all convenient and all powerful hax. Of course you wouldn't know this considering you dropped the manga.

Who cares? In the long run is luffy at a disadvantage for using Haki? Obviously not.

>Did you even read the last chapter right before the time skip where Rayleigh explains everything?

TL: Read the manga, So, you can't make sense of it. Gotcha.
>>
>>158842202

Okay, fair enough. I agree.
>>
>>158842218
>If that scene didn't exist, you would call Shanks usage of Haki in his meeting with Whitebeard as "asspull".

Bullshit, because when they met the translations at the time translated Haki. I figured they had some power going on, but whatever.

>Rayleigh said it out loud that Observation Haki is known as Mantra in Sky Island.

Yes, Oda rubber stamped Mantra into the Haki parcel. I'm not disputing that. But, Haki can be linked to anything because the nature of the power is whatever Oda needs for the plot. It has no characteristics that identify it on it's own without Oda telling the reader that it's Haki.
>>
>>158842205
no seriously. Where did he go?
>>
>>158842218

So, Oda having Rayleigh say "Hey, remember that obscure power from Skypiea. . .Yeah, that's Haki" is proof Oda was such a master craftsmen that he planned it all along? Beautiful
>>
>>158842227
>When did Mihawk fight a logia user to become famous? What are you talking about? Mihawk was famous because of his swordsmanship and he was strong. His reputation when he was introduced had nothing to do with beating logias
Holy shit, how can one miss the point this hard? Listen, there are strong non-DF users in One Piece, and Oda would not introduce them as well-known powerhouse if they can't handle different types of opponents, especially DF users, and prominently of the logia type since generally you can't hurt them without Armament Haki. How do they handle a DF-user, especially Logias? Haki. Mihawk wouldn't become the best swordsman who can go toe-to-toe with all the monsters with DF in the New World if he can't use Haki. Same goes to other powerhouse that were introduced pre New World, such as Garp, Shanks, and others.
>FFS.
Oh, you're not from around here, huh?
>Who cares? In the long run is luffy at a disadvantage for using Haki? Obviously not.
You: "I've made a statement!"
Me: "Here's why you are wrong"
You: "Who cares?"

Do you even listen to yourself?

>TL: Read the manga, So, you can't make sense of it. Gotcha.
Jesus fucking fuck. This is the hardest backpedaling I've ever seen. If you don't even bother to read the manga, then don't act like you know shit.
>>
>>158842227
You need reading comprehension. People wondered how non-devil fruit users could compete with devil fruit users. What if there was a logia swordsmen? Or if Mihawk were up against Buggy, how could Mihawk have beaten him, without some kind of counter to the devil fruit ability.
>In otherwords it's necessary for plot progression and is thus a plot device. cool
Everything is a plot device you mong. Oda at least had the foresight to foreshadow or at least uses things that were previously unexplained to his advantage.
>Who cares? In the long run is luffy at a disadvantage for using Haki? Obviously not
No, but now people who aren't swordsman or have a devil fruit can go toe-to-toe with Luffy.
>>
>>158842425
>Holy shit, how can one miss the point this hard? Listen, there are strong non-DF users in One Piece, and Oda would not introduce them as well-known powerhouse if they can't handle different types of opponents,especially DF users, and prominently of the logia type since generally you can't hurt them without Armament Haki. How do they handle a DF-user, especially Logias? Haki. Mihawk wouldn't become the best swordsman who can go toe-to-toe with all the monsters with DF in the New World if he can't use Haki. Same goes to other powerhouse that were introduced pre New World, such as Garp, Shanks, and others.

Except that Mihawk exsisted before any of those characters. Not that it matters, that's on him for being a retard and introducing op characters that require you to add a shitty expansion to deal with. You're logic is ass backwards, something being necessary doesn't make it good retarded. I know it's necessary because of the way Oda made his story that just proves my point that it's a plot device. Cry moar faggot.
>>
>>158842322
>>158842292
In the same arc, Gun Fall said that Roger has the ability to hear the voice of all things. Oda made the explanation of Mantra to be mysterious and connected to the Pirate King so he could do an explanation later on. This is fucking basic storytelling, it's called foreshadowing.

And later on, Rayleigh, Roger's right hand man, gave an infodump on Haki. The wait was paid off.

>Hmph, yeah man, Oda is such a master craftsmen who planned things all along pfffft heh, Beautiful heh heh
You could do without the snarky asshat tone.
>>
gangster gastino confirmed for nakama
>>
>>158842469
>You need reading comprehension. People wondered how non-devil fruit users could compete with devil fruit users. What if there was a logia swordsmen? Or if Mihawk were up against Buggy, how could Mihawk have beaten him, without some kind of counter to the devil fruit ability.

So, it's a plot device

>Everything is a plot device you mong.

Literrally shit taster.
>>
I prefer shippers to this shitty HXH vs OP conversation. Please come back shipperfags!!
>>
File: ivankov.png (336KB, 444x590px) Image search: [Google]
ivankov.png
336KB, 444x590px
>>158842560
This. It couldn't be more obvious. I can't wait to have his antics become a recurring element of the manga.
>>
>>158842559

How does having one power imply a connection to another? Haki is so ambiguous you could connect it to anything which many people have. Here's a better question, what isn't Haki in OP? Because every non-DF user seems to be Haki now. Guess Rokushiki is Haki too since how else could you explain it amirite?
>>
File: nekomamushi.jpg (361KB, 849x941px) Image search: [Google]
nekomamushi.jpg
361KB, 849x941px
>>158842560
>>158842604
WRONG!!!

JIMBE PEDRO PUDDING CONFIRMED FOR NEXT NAKAMA
>>
>>158842559
>Oda made the explanation of Mantra to be mysterious

All powers can be described as mysterious. Saying something is mysterious just makes it open to interpretation and in Haki's case massive interpretation to the point it can move the plot forward without having any real idea what it does. Haki has got to be the stupidest battle shounen power I've ever seen. Irrespective of whether you like One Piece or not if you can't admitt to that then you're probably far gone.
>>
haha seriously though how is luffy going to get out of this situation, he can't just punch his way out can he
>>
>>158836368
11/10
>>
>>158842685

>can he
>>
>>158836323
Asspull/10
>>
>>158842604

only consistent strawhat to pull the keks every chapter
>>
>>158836323
Gear 4 is awesome.
>>
>>158842576
Yes. It's a plot device. Like literally everything that is used to move the plot forward. The problem becomes if a plot device is contrived enough to cause you to lose your suspension of disbelief. Calling something a plot device isn't a criticism. It's just stating a fact. You seem to think a "plot device" is a buzzword for bad writing, but that's not the case. Plot devices are a technique for writers to use.
>>
>>158842536
Garp existed after Logia. So did the CP9.

>that's on him for being a retard and introducing op characters that require you to add a shitty expansion to deal with
Powerful characters and a mysterious power system that were introduced way long before they became common turn out to complement each other and are connected. Sounds like a good setting up that paid off to me.
>something being necessary doesn't make it good
It's not about "being necessary", it's about "making sense", which Haki is the latter.
>I know it's necessary because of the way Oda made his story that just proves my point that it's a plot device
Not anyone else' fault you can't pay attention enough and make the connection.
>Waaahhh I'm losing this argument, better throw insults
Cry moar, faggot.

>>158842576
No, it's an explanation.

>>158842606
>what isn't Haki in OP?
Kinemon, Half of Luffy's crew, half of the fighters in Colosseum, fishmen.
>>
>>158842767
>Garp existed after Logia. So did the CP9.

People who we weren't talking about

>Powerful characters and a mysterious power system that were introduced way long before they became common turn out to complement each other and are connected. Sounds like a good setting up that paid off to me.

Sounds to me like you're a retard. Can you tell me what non DF power Haki can't be linked too? Given it's unpinnable nature I'd wager there is none.

>Not anyone else' fault you can't pay attention enough and make the connection.

The connection requires no thought. What exactly makes Haki distinct enough that you can pull it out of a crowd of powers? Answer is nothing. It's an ambigous use when needed bullshit device.

>Greentexting
Concession accepted fagrag.
>>
>>158842606
>How does having one power imply a connection to another? Haki is so ambiguous you could connect it to anything which many people have. Here's a better question, what isn't Haki in OP? Because every non-DF user seems to be Haki now. Guess Rokushiki is Haki too since how else could you explain it amirite?
You're retarded. Rokushiki isn't haki because it doesn't fit into the rules haki was given too by Rayleigh or literally anything we have seen from haki users.. Rokushiki is just some martial art trained into marines and Cipher Pol members.
Haki isn't ambiguous, there are clearly defined rules to it. Just because some retards argue Zoro's shishi sonson is Haki doesn't mean it's ambiguous.
>>
>>158842767
>No, it's an explanation.

You just said why it was needed, how does that make it good?
>>
>>158838579
NamivHancock for Luffybowl is gonna be awesome. Used to think that it was fairly obvious that Hancock would end up with Luffy but after rereading the manga Nami is a far better choice and I definitely think Oda will head in that direction. She's the only woman so far who has been able to remotely control him so far and make sure he doesn't get himself killed whereas Hancock would let him do whatever he pleased and that is a boring relationship. She's his perfect foil in that she can take care of day-to-day life and finances and make sure that Luffy doesn't die broke and hungry. Also Luffy doesn't seem like the type of guy to stop adventuring so and I doubt he would want anyone but Nami to be his navigator. In return Luffy would continue to protect Nami and make sure she's always happy(like he promised Nami's father figure--Genma). Overall it's a very sweet romance and Oda seems to be heading in that direction. Who knew he had the ability to craft a decent romance?
>>
>>158842854

So, where are the rules and characteristics that prove it cannot be Haki? In your ass?

>>158842760

It's an abusable plot device because it has no clear interpretation and is open to whatever the author needs it to be which makes it abusable. How is that good?
>>
>>158842685
Its really something isn't it. I'm legit stumped. The only thing I can think of is the germa clone army.
>>
>>158842876
>>158842760
You fags are thinking too hard about this shit. Who cares? If you enjoy the manga good for you and if you dont you can fuck off. All of your arguments are subjective and no one will ever win it.
>>
>>158842854
>Just because some retards argue Zoro's shishi sonson is Haki doesn't mean it's ambiguous.

So, if Oda said it was Haki then how would you tell it was intended to be in the first place? It's completely random what is Haki and what is not. You're deluded if you think otherwise.
>>
Generals were a mistake.
>>
>>158842748
No its an asspull. Stop liking things nerd.
>>
>>158842866
All Luffy wants is to be free. Why would he want to be with a woman who can control him?
>>
File: hedontcare.png (40KB, 193x525px) Image search: [Google]
hedontcare.png
40KB, 193x525px
>>158842933
I dont care about that stuff, I like the design and think the power is cool.
>>
>>158842958
>All Luffy wants is to be free. Why would he want to be with a woman who can control him?

Cause love is give and take. And Luffy doesn't really mind that Nami controls him cause he lets her do so. She is allowed to control him. Just think its a far better and more nuanced relationship than LuBo
>>
>>158838579
How could Luffy possibly end up with Hancock? The moment he falls in love with her, she will turn him into stone.
For Luffy, it's either Nami or nobody I'd say.
>>
>>158842205
>>158842301
wano kuni
>>
File: without nami.png (355KB, 1400x880px) Image search: [Google]
without nami.png
355KB, 1400x880px
>>158842958
Luffy knows he's fucked without Nami. At this point she is constantly wiping his ass and making sure he has enough food to eat. Read the part where they land on chocolate island, he doesn't even buy things without her permission.

Also you guys better be careful or the sweetie poster will be extra triggered when she wakes up from bedtime.
>>
>>158842673
You seem to misinterpret the part you greentexted. Oda made, past tense, MADE the explanation mysterious so he could do a full explanation later on, which he did, through Rayleigh. He introduced Haki in Skypiea as Mantra, but what Mantra actually is became a plot point as not only it wasn't fully known what it was, but it also has a connection with Roger's power to "hear the voice of all things". And then Rayleigh infodumped us regarding Haki. Therefore, paid off foreshadowing.

>without having any real idea what it does
Chapter 597.

>Haki has got to be the stupidest battle shonen power I've ever seen
Strengthening your attack and defense, predict your opponents' attacks, and intimidate your opponents (of the cannon fodder level). Wow, never seen powers like those in battle shonen manga before, so stupid, amirite?

>>158842837
>we weren't talking about
I did mention Garp. And Garp, Shanks, and others, actually including DF users as well, serve as examples of strong characters that you might wonder how would they fare against Logia if they are so strong to the point of well known.

>Can you tell me what non DF power Haki can't be linked too?
Rokushiki and Shishi Sonson.
>The connection requires no thought
You definitely don't think at all.
>It's an ambigous use when needed bullshit device
It's a reasonable power that fits the universe and has been shown and built on beforehand.
>Concession accepted fagrag.
How dare someone call you out for acting like an edgy faggot, amirite? And since you threw out insult first, that's a sign of running out of arguments, you conceded first, fagrag.

>>158842856
>How does that make it good?
By showcasing the power of the top players and how they handle DF users, especially logias?
>>
>>158842998
>You seem to misinterpret the part you greentexted. Oda made, past tense, MADE the explanation mysterious so he could do a full explanation later on

You can't prove he purposefully made the connection mysterious. That's your opinion, it could also be there is no connection until he made one later. That's pure speculation.

>Chapter 597.

Doesn't say anything next

>Strengthening your attack and defense, predict your opponents' attacks, and intimidate your opponents (of the cannon fodder level). Wow, never seen powers like those in battle shonen manga before, so stupid, amirite?

No, I have seen them. So, why would it need an entire system named and branded attached to it?
>>
>>158843002
I dont think he will. Just didn't want LuBo shippers to feel neglected cause I think they will get their moments.
>>
>>158843002
Its also important to note Hancock has a really, really shitty personality. She's only goes kyaa kyaa and is friendly to Luffy. Otherwise she's literally punting baby animals and being a total bitch.
>>
File: 2eb.jpg (25KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]
2eb.jpg
25KB, 600x450px
>>158836684
>expects realistic physics in a manga
>expects realistic physics in a manga created by a guy who probably knows jack shit about physics past "lol rubber is an electric insulator xdddd"
>expects realistic physics in a manga with magic fruits and superhuman strength and slingshots outranging rifles
>>
>>158836368
A few things you could add
>aww, sweetie
>She's doing it for HIM
>YES YES YES
>>
4 DAYS AND 20 HOURS UNTIL SPOILERS
>>
>>158843032
>Rokushiki and Shishi Sonson.

Based on what?

>You definitely don't think at all.

You haven't proven anything. So, I really don't have to argue much.

>It's a reasonable power that fits the universe and has been shown and built on beforehand.
The connections are tenuous at best. I mean even within the system, what does armament and being able to predict movement have in common that they need an umbrella term? It's not like luffy's rubber and is ability to stretch or take damage. There's nothing connecting the two.

>How dare someone call you out for acting like an edgy faggot, amirite? And since you threw out insult first, that's a sign of running out of arguments, you conceded first, fagrag.

It's obvious you're anal pained about being called out for being a retard. I don't care who insulted who first, you're fag through and through based soley on the fact you argue like one. Please, cut you balls off so we have less retards like you and jump out the nearest window post haste so we have less of you. What a waste of life, christ.
>>
>>158843064
TBF she's been abused to the point of being a total bitch. She's not a bad person per se.
>>
>>158843015
Why would Ruffy just allow Zolo to do his own thing when he just lost Sanji?
>>
>>158843032
>By showcasing the power of the top players and how they handle DF users, especially logias?

It's good because it allows strong guys to win. I thought DBZtards were dumb.
>>
>>158843125
Zoro's gonna have a Sanji/Robin moment with Luffy I guarantee it.
>>
Coby's such a faggot
I bet dicks don't turn him on because they're too straight. I bet his dick is shaped like a Z. Faggot.
>>
>>158842876
>So, where are the rules and characteristics that prove it cannot be Haki?
The fact that it's a martial arts style and NOT a power/ability?

>It's an abusable plot device because it has no clear interpretation and is open to whatever the author needs it to be which makes it abusable
Chapter 597.

>>158843046
>It could also be there is no connection until he made one later
The straw-grasping is real. It wasn't fully explained, therefore, it's being foreshadowed to be revealed later on, which it did.
>Doesn't say anything
If you can't read, sure.
>why would it need an entire system named and branded attached to it?
It's useful against a particular type of enemies.
>>
I get the appeal of OP but I have no clue how you cane joy it for 800+ episodes.
>>
>>158843153
You probably dont believe me, but OP is legitimately HYPE AS FUCK at this moment. Most of the episodes before are just setup for the next 300 episodes.
>>
>>158842876
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_device
Here do some research.
Something being a plot device doesn't absolutely make it bad. I'm trying to educate you so when you try to criticize things in the future, you don't look like an absolute fool. The plot device arguement was basically semantics.
>So, where are the rules and characteristics that prove it cannot be Haki? In your ass?
It's where Rayleigh explained Haki to us, and the mountains of evidence we have from haki being used in the story as well as rokushiki being used in the story and how they are not related at all.
They are completely separate powers and you being a retard not understanding how haki works doesn't mean haki has no set rules or characteristics.
>>
>>158843149
>The fact that it's a martial arts style and NOT a power/ability?

Are you stupid? Rokushiki has 6 powers in it, it's literally 6 super powers. Holy shit

>597
Doesn't explain shit. next.
>>
>>158843147
He might be a faggot, but I don't think he's gay. He's not got the gray hair after all.
Law on the other hand is clearly luffy sexual
>>
Why didn't the strings on Dolfy's organs stop working when he as knocked out?
Why not when he was bound by Seastone?

Literally a plothole.
>>
>>158843149
>The straw-grasping is real. It wasn't fully explained, therefore, it's being foreshadowed to be revealed later on, which it did.

Something not being explained doesn't mean it's planned on being explained let alone connected under some magic umbrella power.

>If you can't read, sure.

Not an argument

>It's useful against a particular type of enemies.

It's useful against the more powerful DF users which is why it's needed. So, luffy can win.
>>
File: 1496809658287.gif (205KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]
1496809658287.gif
205KB, 500x281px
>>158842960
>I love eating shit
Just kidding anon I love G4 too
>>
>>158843153
Just read it? Where did you get tired of it? One Piece is extremely fast paced and I actually wish I had an anime with a proper budget I could enjoy but am forced to look at scrawly drawings and poor scans. One Piece is truly a comedic epic that will go down in history.
>>
>>158836239
I think they're both terrible. Everything about them feels like filler episode after filler episode. I mean the plot in one piece is to get to the one piece and they don't even know where it is or what it is.
>>
>>158843188
Law's so gay that he put his dad's gay smile on his chest so he could pretend his dad was motorboating him. I bet he jerks off with a black feather boa wrapped around his dick and a plastic flamingo up his ass.

And don't get me started on Zoro. Zoro puts swords in his mouth to replace the dick he never got. Each sword represents a dick he fantasizes about. Eventually he'll hold one in his asshole.
>>
>>158843202
Explain Enel's resurrection first.
>>
>>158839639

He's made of rubber, anon, how the fuck is it not
>>
>>158843139
No. It's good because it answered questions about how would people like Mihawk, become so incredibly strong and renowned, when Buggy directly counters his ability. Or how Garp could hurt Luffy, when he was shown to be immune to blunt objects before. Stop being dense if you want your points taken seriously.
>>
>>158843002
I assume she has enough control over her power that she wouldn't turn him to stone. He is the only persons affection she actually wants.
>>
>>158843240
He defibrillated himself.
>>
>>158837981
It really is, don't even know why that reaction image.
>>
>>158843175
>It's where Rayleigh explained Haki to us

You mean where Rayleigh connects two completely unrelated things and basically says: "Yeah, that's Haki"?

>Something being a plot device doesn't absolutely make it bad.

It is when you literally made it so your fag main character can become King of the Pirates and solely for that reason. We all know Oda made Haki so Luffy can beat logias, he even gave him the rarest one.

>They are completely separate powers and you being a retard not understanding how haki works doesn't mean haki has no set rules or characteristics.

Separate because they haven't been rubber stamped by Oda. If Oda decided they were Haki today there is nothing that would indicate he hadn't planned in advance because Haki is a bullshit magic pirate power that links random things together: "Yeah, it can detect movements, give you armor and beat devil fruits luffy would have a hard time against" Fucking stupid.
>>
>>158843251
>replying to shitposters
>>
Do you guys think Sanji will get any power up this arc? His my favorite crew member, but he keeps jobbing like a madman. I wish timeskip was enough, but how thing are he is ussop tier.
>>
>>158843251

So, it patches holes in Oda's plot. Gotcha.
>>
>>158843278
Links random things together like an aura with the properties of both rubber and gum?
>>
>>158843229
I like this post a lot. You should write fanfiction. Keep posting in the 1P threads as-well anon.
>>
>>158843267
Fair point...why should his strings stop working? I'm not intelligent enough to tell you what's wrong with it. I'm still scratching my head over Sabo's entire amnesia arc.
>>
>>158843318
>Links random things together like an aura with the properties of both rubber and gum?

What's random about that? Go ahead and explain.
>>
>>158843335
O
>>
>>158843120
Martial Arts and a special attack, not a power or ability.

>You haven't proven anything.
The fact that the proofs are told and laid bare in the manga that Haki has been foreshadowen and shown beforehand before it became common? I proved more than enough.

>I mean even within the system, what does armament and being able to predict movement have in common that they need an umbrella term?
Chapter 597.

>What a waste of life, christ.
Oho, a sign of frustration. Sounds like I hit a nerve.

>>158843139
>It's good because it allows strong guys to win
It's good because it allows people to harm logias and strengthen their attacks to have more advantages in battle, does not mean they are guaranteed to win the fight. I mean, I'm pretty sure you know that DF users can use Haki.

I thought DBZtards were dumb.

>>158843178
>Are you stupid? Rokushiki has 6 powers in it, it's literally 6 super powers. Holy shit
You would know that Rokushiki is a martial arts style if you actually read One Piece.

>Doesn't explain shit. Next.
If you can't read, sure.

>>158843216
>Something not being explained doesn't mean it's planned on being explained
So there's this power that was shown and the characters wonder what's the deal with the power, but the characters present at the time don't even fully understand, which indicates that is a plot point to be revealed later on. Chapters later, the power got a full explanation. Once again, this is basic storytelling.

>Not an argument
So is saying "Doesn't explain shit" when it does.

>It's useful against the more powerful DF users
Which showcase how the top players that were shown can go toe-to-toe against logias.
>So, Luffy can win
Luffy got injured right on his Haki-strengthened arm a couple chapters ago in the current arc. He won only with Nami's help.
>>
>>158843288
Maybe his germa enhancements will kick in. That might be a stretch though with his mom taking the suppression drug. I don't think he needs a power up though. He hasn't had a fight where he wasn't gimped in someway yet besides FI where he stomped on them like everyone else. Maybe he will reveal a new move though. I'm honestly stumped on where the story is going to go from here.
>>
>>158842918
So, if Oda said it was Haki then how would you tell it was intended to be in the first place? It's completely random what is Haki and what is not. You're deluded if you think otherwise.
Oda wouldn't do that because it was specific technique Zoro learned in order to cut steel. If Zoro used shishisonson on a logia or someone like Buggy, it wouldn't work. It work on Mr One, because Zoro cut his steel body,therefore finding another way to bypass the devil fruit.
Next you'll start asking if luffy using water on his hands was haki to defeat crocodile you utter buffoon.
>>
>>158843344
MY
>>
>>158843347
>He won only with Nami's help.
Ah yes, the power of friendship, especially with a female character. Glad I and my friends dropped this series and continue to read HxH weekly.
>>
>>158843278
>>158843311
Let's assume what you are right, and he didn't plan this at all: How is it a negative at all that a writer went back through his story, and tied concepts together to create something more cohesive?
>>
>>158843384
RUBBER
>>
>>158843320
The gayest character in One Piece (besides you) is probably Ace, honestly. Faggot only has 2 other guys he's ever seen hanging out with, has a family full of buff bara boys, walks around shirtless, and has a picture of his sugar daddy Whiteprick on his back so his family knows which way to thrust. He probably got it so big so that Whitey could see it past his cataracts. Not to mention that he's so clearly into fisting that he has to choose it over Monkey Dicks Limply. I bet his freckles are cumstains from all the shots he's taken to the face. Flaming gay.
>>
>>158843347
>Martial Arts and a special attack, not a power or ability.

Semantics, it is a power. Which martial art in real life do the things they do in Rokushiki? It's six superhuman abilities learned through the art.

>The fact that the proofs are told and laid bare in the manga that Haki has been foreshadowen and shown beforehand before it became common? I proved more than enough.
You haven't proven shit. Fact of the matter is Haki is open to interpretation that you could link it too anything and outside of Oda's random rubber stamping, you wouldn't be wrong. The connections within Haki make no sense, what does armament have to do with being able to hurt logia and mantra?

>Chapter 597.
Ah, the running out of arguments but must still respond by repeating the same thing tactic.
>>
>>158843311
So it gives a reasonable explanation on how someone strong like Mihawk is more famous than a weakling like Buggy whose power is supposed to be a direct counter.

You say Haki is a convenient plot device, when it's actually a raise in the stakes for a lot of the characters because they realize they aren't so invincible anymore, and not just the villains.
>>
>>158843416
I always got a gay vibe from Mihawk as well.
>>
>>158838837
Now I am not a shipper, but why isn't there an image of Nami and Luffy just before the walk to Arlong Park?
Not that it would make sense, mind you. Luffy is trying to help Nami, not fuck her, but still. I thought shippers would really jump onto that scene.

Also, don't bother replying to this, I probably have half of the words in your posts on my filter list.
>>
>>158843420
>Ah, the running out of arguments but must still respond by repeating the same thing tactic.
You seem to like that tactic a lot.
>>
>>158843347
>It's good because it allows people to harm logias and strengthen their attacks to have more advantages in battle

So, it's good because it makes characters you like more powerful? Okay

>You would know that Rokushiki is a martial arts style if you actually read One Piece.

A martial Arts that gives you supoer powers like most martial arts in fiction. Hell, Luffy
's training for Haki was like a martial arts series where he needed to learn a special technique from an elder. There's nothing distinct about that either.

>If you can't read, sure.

Concession accepted yet again.
>>
>>158843433
Mihawk is the master of gay sex in One Pizza. He cruises around on his hard wood to put buff boys on the end of his sword. Zoro wants to be king of the faggots, and Mihawk trained him by fucking his loose asshole every night. He probably had to lock Perona up so she wouldn't become a lesbian from seeing such a fucking disgusting display of manhood. Faggot rides around the world on hard wood and plays with his sword. What more can you say? Also he's Dracula, so you know he sucks.
>>
>>158843271
What anime do that?
>>
>>158843347
>So there's this power that was shown and the characters wonder what's the deal with the power, but the characters present at the time don't even fully understand, which indicates that is a plot point to be revealed later on. Chapters later, the power got a full explanation. Once again, this is basic storytelling.

No, more like it couldn't be explained until some magic umbrella term that randomly selects powers under no real criteria other than the author says so says it's Haki.

>So is saying "Doesn't explain shit" when it does.

It doesn't

>Luffy got injured right on his Haki-strengthened arm a couple chapters ago in the current arc. He won only with Nami's help.

But, it can be written without using Nami's help whereas before Luffy would auto lose against logias that had a natural weakness. Now, it can go eitherway because of muh haki without breaking the story because haki is so malleable it can do what they story needs it to do.
>>
>>158843467
>So, it's good because it makes characters you like more powerful?
Haki makes characters such as Ace more powerful, obviously.
>>
>>158843414
FRUIT
>>
I wish we had cool and admiral tier bounty hunters in OP.
>>
>>158843523
Gayce, the only character to get fisted by another man elbow deep in all of anime.
>>
>>158843356

Why wouldn't Oda do that? Because you trust him? There's nothing stopping Oda from doing such a thing minus his discretion because Haki is flexible enough to do such a thing.
>>
>>158843394

It's not negative, but I'm arguing people who say it's brilliant and he planned it all along.
>>
>>158843423
>So it gives a reasonable explanation on how someone strong like Mihawk is more famous than a weakling like Buggy whose power is supposed to be a direct counter.

Gimmie a break, this is the same series where Zoro was pulling out techniques where he could "Hear every living thing breathing" and could choose to cut what he wanted or some nonesense like that. He didn't need to introduce anything to justify Mihawk beating buggy.
>>
>>158843544
There's nothing stopping Eitchytaint Oda from writing Brook into literally boning Franky. He asks for panties all the time, and Franky, a caricature of Gachimuchi, wears a Speedo, the male version of a thong, and can shape his hair into the shape of a dildo as well as cause his rock hard nipples when he sees Brook the Gay Crook to light up.
>>
>>158843278
>You mean where Rayleigh connects two completely unrelated things and basically says: "Yeah, that's Haki"?
>Here are the rules of Haki
>RAYLEIGH CONNECTS TWO UNRELATED POWERS THEREFORE IT'S DUMB!1!!!1
Thanks for your wonderful argument my friend.
>It is when you literally made it so your fag main character can become King of the Pirates and solely for that reason. We all know Oda made Haki so Luffy can beat logias,
Yes. He did make Haki so Luffy could beat strong opponents like akainu and other devil fruit users. That was necessary. Just because you don't like it, doesn't make it a bad plot device.
>the rarest one
That multiple people have, including but not limited to the Yonkou, Luffy's main rivals for PK. Also, conqueror's haki isn't that strong so.
>Separate because they haven't been rubber stamped by Oda. If Oda decided they were Haki today there is nothing that would indicate he hadn't planned in advance because Haki is a bullshit magic pirate power that links random things together: "Yeah, it can detect movements, give you armor and beat devil fruits luffy would have a hard time against" Fucking stupid.
Oda wouldn't do that, because he has read his story, and clearly laid out the rules to haki. If he did, I would be pissed because that's stupid. But Oda has clearly made a line between haki, devil fruits, and any other weapon/power like swordsmanship or rokushiki. Let me ask you this. Why do you think haki isn't explained properly or doesn't have clear rules to it?
>>
Spunky Dick Lubey
>>
PTS Franky is so ugly holy shit
>>
>>158843392
>The power of friendship
No, it was legitimate teamwork where Nami weakened the enemy using his new Clima Tact so Luffy can deliver blows. It was 2-on-1. Nothing cheesy like the power of friendship. Since you dropped the manga of course you wouldn't know this.

You: "Haki is a plot device so Luffy can win lolol"
Me: "No, Luffy was struggling even with Haki. He needed someone's help."
You: "P-POWER OF FRIENDSHIP, SHIT MANGA IS SHIT!"

Nice damage control.

>>158843420
>Semantics
It's spelled out loud in the manga that it's a martial arts style.
>Which martial art in real life do the things they do in Rokushiki?
Good Lord, is this your first shonen battle manga? Try reading HSD Kenichi.
>You haven't proven shit. Fact of the matter is Haki is open to interpretation that you could link it too anything and outside of Oda's random rubber stamping, you wouldn't be wrong. The connections within Haki make no sense, what does armament have to do with being able to hurt logia and mantra?
Chapter 597.
>Ah, the running out of arguments but must still respond by repeating the same thing tactic.
Same stupid replies warrant the same arguments.
>So, it's good because it makes characters you like more powerful? Okay
Characters I don't like also have Haki (Doflamingo). Characters I like also still lose even when they have Haki (Tashigi).
>A martial Arts that gives you supoer powers like most martial arts in fiction
HSD Kenichi. Read it.
>Concession accepted yet again.
You refused the proof I kept offering and continued to argue out of pride. Sign of concession from you there.
>No, more like it couldn't be explained until some magic umbrella term
Then Oda wouldn't go the way of making the power have an explanation that leaves the characters wondering.
>It doesn't
If you can't read, sure.
>But, it can be written without using Nami's help
Nope. Had Nami not been there, he would lose. Haki isn't hax. It's not an auto win. The story needed Nami to help.
>>
>>158843641
Post*******
>>
>>158843544
Because there are clear rules to haki.
Haki is not flexible to do such a thing. Do you even read One Piece? How could you possibly argue this? Am I being baited?
>>
>>158843644
>Nice damage control.
It was an obvious parody of that guy's arguments. The bit about reading HxH weekly should have tipped you off.
>>
>>158843561
Because it's evident enough that he did plan it.
>>
>>158843500
Yeah sure man but you have not talked about Zoro's raging homosexuality. The dude is obsessed with swords and even carries one in the mouth. Probably because Luffy's gummy dick can't satisfy his needs for rock hard head
>>
>>158843616
>Thanks for your wonderful argument my friend.

The rules of Haki are two unrelated things are now connected = good explanation? The explanation is retarded, that's what I'm telling you moron. It doesn't matter if it's explained, I'm not arguing that rather that it's poor and doesn't really explain anything.

>Yes. He did make Haki so Luffy could beat strong opponents like akainu and other devil fruit users. That was necessary. Just because you don't like it, doesn't make it a bad plot device.

Well, at least you're honest. So, you have no problem with luffy now magically after hundreds of chapters having the secret to being the pirate king because he trained on some island earning the force?

>That multiple people have, including but not limited to the Yonkou, Luffy's main rivals for PK. Also, conqueror's haki isn't that strong so.

And, luffy which puts him on the same field as those people you just named who are amongst the strongest in One Piece. Wow, what a disadvantage.

>Oda wouldn't do that, because he has read his story, and clearly laid out the rules to haki. If he did, I would be pissed because that's stupid. But Oda has clearly made a line between haki, devil fruits, and any other weapon/power like swordsmanship or rokushiki. Let me ask you this. Why do you think haki isn't explained properly or doesn't have clear rules to it?

Why wouldn't he do that? You think if Oda had luffy fighting some strong opponent he wouldn't make up a power just to have him win. . .oh wait, he did? It's called Haki. If you set a precedent to use some magic power whenever your character needs it why wouldn't do so other times? What if Zoro needs it? What then?
>>
Do you think we'll get another small timeskip soon? I mean when you think about it that would totally blow all expectations out of the water
>>
>>158843601
>>158843542
>>158843500
>>158843416
I have not laughed this much in days holy shit please keep coming back to these threads every once in a while
>>
>>158843679
Zoro is definitely sucking off Sanji bro and Sanji in turn is giving him some Okama head. Jeez, I thought it was obvious, those two are clearly homosexual.
>>
>>158843679
What about Sanji? All you really need to know is that he's in the kitchen, carries a cigarette (a phallic object) in his mouth, cannot hurt women because he wants to spank homos, and never uses his hands for anything but cooking and said spanking. And that's without getting into the Newkama thing.
>>
>>158843679
I talked about it in the reply before, you big faggot, but just for you

Zoro is shaping up to be the pubic heir to Mihawk's throne. In addition to placing swords in his hands and mouth to keep his insatiable lust for cock in check, he can project his lust outward to create Ass-Ura, a form that allows him to suck and tug in every lateral direction. The ultimate form for both Bukkake and gangbangs, it perfectly encapsulates the gay icon that is Zoro, including the fact that, like a cock, it was pulled out of his ass.
>>
>>158843278
>two completely unrelated things
It's a power that the characters and readers at the time wondered about because the explanation was not in depth and the characters that were giving the explanation themselves couldn't expand on it further because they lack information. This indicates a full-blown reveal sometimes later in the story. It's called foreshadowing.

>It is when you literally made it so your fag main character can become King of the Pirates and solely for that reason. We all know Oda made Haki so Luffy can beat logias
It was introduced long before that. And to show how the top players that were shown beforehand can handle logias. And since it's the tech top players use, Luffy would have to get to that level and learn the tech eventually. You can't go around having the dream of becoming the Pirate King if you're gonna stay underdog forever. His name is gonna be known wide one day, it's obvious he's gonna be on the same playing field as the major characters and of course use the same powers as them.

>Separate because they haven't been rubber stamped by Oda
Separate because one is a martial arts, while the other is a power.
>>
One Piece is literally one long drawn out "O MY RUBBER NEN"
>>
>>158843644
>It's spelled out loud in the manga that it's a martial arts style.

How does that stop it from being a super power? The two things aren't mutually exclusive. So, you're argument is semantics notwithstanding

>Good Lord, is this your first shonen battle manga? Try reading HSD Kenichi.

You missed the point entirely. They have powers, the basis of which are from martial arts. The explanation of Haki is very simmiliar to the explanations you see in many Martial Arts fantasy, the training moreso. There's no difference.

>Chapter 597.
Ah, the running out of arguments but must still respond by repeating the same thing tactic.

>Same stupid replies warrant the same arguments.
Which is why I must repeat myself with you.

>Characters I don't like also have Haki (Doflamingo). Characters I like also still lose even when they have Haki (Tashigi).

And, most importantly the main can now beat people he couldn't beat to become pirate king. That's the point of Haki.

>You refused the proof I kept offering and continued to argue out of pride. Sign of concession from you there.

>Nope. Had Nami not been there, he would lose. Haki isn't hax. It's not an auto win. The story needed Nami to help.

Are you so stupid that you're honestly arguing that Oda can't fudge the system of Haki to make the character he wants to win do so?

>Then Oda wouldn't go the way of making the power have an explanation that leaves the characters wondering.

False Dichotomy, He could have left it because he didn't have any way of explaining it or he didn't care. It's not one or the other.

>HSD Kenichi. Read it.

Right, and they have super powers which they gain through training in Martial Arts in HSDK. Infact, it's no different than Haki where the explanation was that they tap into a latent power that all living things possesses. How is that unique again? Oh, it isn't.
>>
>>158843749
Sanji is a phenomenon unto himself. He's seemingly existing at both the straightest and gayest ends of the spectrum, and may actually be evolving into a gender of pure faggotry. He somehow manages to be more of a bitch than any bitch he meets but also more of a faggot than any faggot he meets. If there was ever a being that reproduced through being a fucking actual doormat, it would be Sanjii. I'm pretty certain that he might even count as being a lesbian and a faggot, because he seems to lack any form of testosterone or backbone in his entire body. The only thing he is superior to is the unprocessed piles of shit he prepares for his superior human masters. And yet, somehow, Zoro is still more of a cock loving faggot.
>>
File: ((you)).png (1MB, 1113x768px) Image search: [Google]
((you)).png
1MB, 1113x768px
>>158843810
>>158843644

You guys are actually more cancerous than shippers.
>>
>>158843789
>It's a power that the characters and readers at the time wondered about because the explanation was not in depth and the characters that were giving the explanation themselves couldn't expand on it further because they lack information.

And, Oda decided to glue them to his new plot device that will allow luffy not to garuntee lose against logias. "Anti DF, Mantra and whatever else looks cool".

>It was introduced long before that. And to show how the top players that were shown beforehand can handle logias.

Who handled Logias on-panel before it was formally introduced?

>And since it's the tech top players use, Luffy would have to get to that level and learn the tech eventually.

Prove your premise.

>Separate because one is a martial arts, while the other is a power.

Those two things are no mutually exclusive cause you say so hon.
>>
>>158843830
Give me the quick rundown on the BBC-Beard Pirates, anon.
>>
File: cakebakingfag.jpg (47KB, 709x353px) Image search: [Google]
cakebakingfag.jpg
47KB, 709x353px
>>158843830
>If there was ever a being that reproduced through being a fucking actual doormat, it would be Sanjii. I'm pretty certain that he might even count as being a lesbian and a faggot, because he seems to lack any form of testosterone or backbone in his entire body.

Please never leave
>>
>>158843597
Steel =/= Devil Fruit power

That was merely a technique. A technique to cut a particular solid material.

>>158843707
The rules of Haki are in chapter 597. And Mantra has always ben Haki. Oda wouldn't bring up Mantra if he didn't want to introduce Haki. If Oda never brought up Haki you would say "HURRRR MANTRA WAS ASSPULL DURRR"


>Well, at least you're honest. So, you have no problem with luffy now magically after hundreds of chapters having the secret to being the pirate king because he trained on some island earning the force?
Not the guy you replied to. And I disagree with both him and you. The power has been foreshadowed and shown way long before it became common. And with Luffy's dream of becoming someone big like the Pirate King and how the major players use Haki to fight which showcase how they deal with logia, it's a no brainer that he had to eventually learn how to use it.
>And, luffy which puts him on the same field as those people you just named who are amongst the strongest in One Piece. Wow, what a disadvantage.
Conqueror Haki only works on fodders.
>Why wouldn't he do that? You think if Oda had luffy fighting some strong opponent he wouldn't make up a power just to have him win. . .oh wait, he did? It's called Haki.
The power has been shown enough before it became common. He didn't make it up. It's been set up to show that it's a necessary power to have if Luffy and friends want to be on the same playing field as the ones that dwell the New World.
>>
>>158843890
I second this. Laughed my whole way through
>>
File: haki.png (89KB, 699x300px) Image search: [Google]
haki.png
89KB, 699x300px
ITT
>>
>>158843946
>Steel =/= Devil Fruit power

Supa Supa no mi says hi

>That was merely a technique. A technique to cut a particular solid material.

What technique allows you to hear the "breath of all living things" There's no difference between that technique and Haki in respects to how supernatural they are.
>>
>>158843885
Imagine if every stereotype of an immigrant existed as an actual person. That's the Black Dick pirates. They've got a diseased mongrel of a horse spreading its aids everywhere, a spic masked wrestler who steals fruit, a shitty snake cum-selling doctor, ex-cons, and Niggerbeard himself who stole both his powers, and everything else good that he has, from the Whites. If it wasn't apparent how fucking redpilled the Japs were, it should be by now. The Niggerbeard pirates steal, rape, and pillage everything they get close to. They also kill terrorists, so you know they're proud Americans with textbook level education. I bet they play "don't drop the soap" for fun.
>>
>>158836239
How can you enjoy a story that moves its plot forward like one step every 3-5 years?
>>
>>158843707
>The rules of Haki are two unrelated things are now connected = good explanation? The explanation is retarded, that's what I'm telling you moron. It doesn't matter if it's explained, I'm not arguing that rather that it's poor and doesn't really explain anything.
It explains how Luffy knocked out the bull Duval had and how Rayleigh knocked out everyone at the auction house without even touching them. It explains how Enel could dodge Luffys attacks so effortlessly and how Jozu managed to hurt Aokiji.
You're problem seems to be that seemingly unrelated powers are under an umbrella term. If thats the case do you also find DF to be poorly explained. How could so many different abilities be under an umbrella term?
>Well, at least you're honest.......
Why do you think Luffy learning Haki is some key to completely winning every battle from now on? If Akainu went down just cause Luffy learned haki, that would be dumb. Haki is also used by Luffy's enemies, so I don't understand how you think Luffy has some secret key to become PK.
>And, luffy which puts him on the same field as those people you just named who are amongst the strongest in One Piece. Wow, what a disadvantage
And Doffy, and some random old dude that was a rival to garp, and Boa hancock. Conqueror's haki isn't the end all be all to power. In fact it is probably the most useless haki in OP
>Why wouldn't he do that
If Oda said rokushiki was some for of Haki, I'd call bullshit.
They are clearly and purposefully defined differently.
>You think if Oda had luffy fighting some strong opponent he wouldn't make up a power just to have him win..oh wait, he did? It's called Haki.
Haki doesnt make Luffy win.
He wouldn't do it other times because it'd be an asspull, and if Zoro learned some crazy haki ability that no one else had id be pissed. Hasn't happened yet tho.
>>
>>158843946
>The rules of Haki are in chapter 597. And Mantra has always ben Haki. Oda wouldn't bring up Mantra if he didn't want to introduce Haki. If Oda never brought up Haki you would say "HURRRR MANTRA WAS ASSPULL DURRR"

Please prove that Oda always planned Mantra to be Haki.

>Not the guy you replied to. And I disagree with both him and you.

Riiiiight

>And I disagree with both him and you. The power has been foreshadowed and shown way long before it became common. And with Luffy's dream of becoming someone big like the Pirate King and how the major players use Haki to fight which showcase how they deal with logia, it's a no brainer that he had to eventually learn how to use it.

How could the major players be shown to use Haki before Haki was shown? Wut?

>The power has been shown enough before it became common. He didn't make it up. It's been set up to show that it's a necessary power to have if Luffy and friends want to be on the same playing field as the ones that dwell the New World.

Where was it shown? "Linking old powers to Haki doesn't prove he mean't for them to be Haki. People link all powers that happened before Haki to haki all the time It's all speculation.
>>
>>158844023
>They also kill terrorists, so you know they're proud Americans with textbook level education

Why are Eurofags so much better than Amerifats like myself? It pains me to realize how much better these threads get when Eurofags are around.
>>
>>158844079
Because we've had more time to get hateful and bitter of the world.
>>
Alright, I have shit to do so you cock loving sluts keep yourself nice and moist for me. I'll be back after I fuck each and every one of your mothers. Bye.
>>
>>158843990
>Supa Supa no mi says hi
Yes. Zoro learned how to cut steel. Not how to cut a devil fruit users body. If zoro used that technique on Buggy it wouldn't work.
Look at Luffy vs Crocodile. Luffy learned how to land hits on him using his natural weakness to water, Luffy didn't learn haki. Coating his hands in water wouldn't hurt smoker for example.
The "breath of all living things" was just some stupid nonsense throwaway line oda put in to make it seem more mysterious.
>>
>>158844035
>It explains how Luffy knocked out the bull Duval had and how Rayleigh knocked out everyone at the auction house without even touching them. and how Jozu managed to hurt Aokiji.

Just stop, by that time Haki had already been introduced. Haki was introduced when Whitebeard and Shanks had their meeting befoe being fleshed out later on.

>It explains how Enel could dodge Luffys attacks so effortlessly

That's Mantra


You're problem seems to be that seemingly unrelated powers are under an umbrella term. If thats the case do you also find DF to be poorly explained. How could so many different abilities be under an umbrella term?

I dunno, ask Oda. The thing with DF is they had alot of characteristics and they made the bulk of the system for combat in OP. Haki on the otherhand seems like something Oda contrived just so luffy can win in the end. Because outside of linking a bunch of random powers it comes so late in the story officially.

>Why do you think Luffy learning Haki is some key to completely winning every battle from now on? If Akainu went down just cause Luffy learned haki, that would be dumb. Haki is also used by Luffy's enemies, so I don't understand how you think Luffy has some secret key to become PK.


Strawman, I never said every battle but we know there are battles he will never win without it. Correction, battles he can justify winning in style without it. Before Haki, could you imagine luffy taking own Aokiji or Kizaru in a one on one fight? What about after it, nevermind the setbacks of Haki. Clearly he stands a chance of winning.

> And Doffy, and some random old dude that was a rival to garp, and Boa hancock. Conqueror's haki isn't the end all be all to power. In fact it is probably the most useless haki in OP

All of this is post Haki shit. So, it's irrelevant. Haki changed how the fights would play out.

>If Oda said rokushiki was some for of Haki, I'd call bullshit.
They are clearly and purposefully defined differently.

cont
>>
File: 1450151285573.png (13KB, 390x470px) Image search: [Google]
1450151285573.png
13KB, 390x470px
>>158843392
>read HxH weekly
>>
contd

>>158844035
>If Oda said rokushiki was some for of Haki, I'd call bullshit.
>They are clearly and purposefully defined differently.

Okay, so what is it? What's the difference between tekkai and armament besides aesthetics? What exactly is so distinct about haki that you can't add more bs powers to it?

>Haki doesnt make Luffy win.

In the long run it does. He doesn't have the limitations of his DF to worry about now it's about training just like other shounen

>He wouldn't do it other times because it'd be an asspull, and if Zoro learned some crazy haki ability that no one else had id be pissed. Hasn't happened yet tho.


But, structural there's nothing stopping him from doing it. All we have is good will towards Oda. That's not enough for me.
>>
>make a shit thread while baiting HxH fans
>wonder why the discussion is terrible
>>
>>158843810
>How does that stop it from being a super power?
Because it's a martial arts style. Not a power.
>You missed the point entirely. They have powers, the basis of which are from martial arts
So, shonen manga martial arts. Not super power, gotcha.
>Ah, the running out of arguments but must still respond by repeating the same thing tactic.
Which is why I must repeat myself with you.
>Which is why I must repeat myself with you.
I'm repeating myself to give explanation. You repeat yourself because you're just a broken record.
>And, most importantly the main can now beat people he couldn't beat to become pirate king
The main can now use Haki since his journey to become a pirate king with many strong enemies ahead would eventually lead him to learn it.
>Are you so stupid that you're honestly arguing that Oda can't fudge the system of Haki to make the character he wants to win do so?
The rules have been set. And the point is that it's no hax bullshit power like what you've been implying.
>He could have left it because he didn't have any way of explaining it or he didn't care
Then he wouldn't give cut-off explanation at all. Basic storytelling here.
>which they gain through training in Martial Arts
So, martial arts.
>>158843862
>glue them to his new plot device
He left the explanation in Skypiea cut-off until Rayleigh's full explanation. Basic storytelling.
>Who handled Logias on-panel before it was formally introduced?
Jinbee vs Ace flashback. Considering the big function of Haki was to handle Logia, obviously a scene where a non DF user is handling a Logia is made to corroborate the power. Whether or not there's a scene between a non-DF user handling Logia before hand doesn't matter.
>Prove your premise.
?
Luffy would eventually use it since he's aiming for the big league and the big league use that technique. I don't know what else you want me to prove.
>Those two things are no mutually exclusive cause you say so
So they're mutually exclusive because you say so?
>>
>>158844174

So, you don't see the difference between having specific weaknesses that work on specific enemies like you just showed vs some magic power that works on all enemies. Before, luffy couldn't hurt smoker the same way as crocodile with Haki he can and this is the sameguy who wrote the bs explanation about hearing steel breath that's gonna steer how Haki plays out.
>>
>>158844272
I see the difference between your dick and mine wanna have a sword battle
>>
>>158844265
>Because it's a martial arts style. Not a power.
Which gives them super powers. You're not even explaining shit anymore. Just repeating the samething to save face. How is Martial Arts and Super Powers mutual exclusive in manga where people with martial arts are super human?

>So, shonen manga martial arts. Not super power, gotcha.

Which grants super human abilities. That was the point retard

>Which is why I must repeat myself with you.

You are litterally repeating the same argument just to have a response. Look above, you claim Martial Arts and powers are distinct despite in shounen martial arts giving people powers and yet you can't explain the distinction but rather parrot it on. pathetic.

>I'm repeating myself to give explanation. You repeat yourself because you're just a broken record.

You're not explaining anything now.

>The main can now use Haki since his journey to become a pirate king with many strong enemies ahead would eventually lead him to learn it.

That would only be true if Oda planned on him learning Haki in the first place rather than it being a band-aid for luffy's limitations with the rubber fruit.

>The rules have been set. And the point is that it's no hax bullshit power like what you've been implying.

They weren't set before when observance Haki was just Mantra and not attached to anti DF bullshit. Why can't they change now especially given that Haki's limitations aren't clear;. Rayleigh can easily come back and say: "Who said Haki was limited to only 3 powers?" You would eat it up.

>Then he wouldn't give cut-off explanation at all. Basic storytelling here.

No such thing as a "cut off explanatoin" you're making up words to support your bs theory that he left it unexplained to connect it to Haki he always planned for.
>>
>>158844265
>He left the explanation in Skypiea cut-off until Rayleigh's full explanation. Basic storytelling.

Because you assumed he would connect it to Haki because he cut it off? Nice Circular Argument: He cut it off to connect it to Haki because he cut it off?

>Jinbee vs Ace flashback. Considering the big function of Haki was to handle Logia, obviously a scene where a non DF user is handling a Logia is made to corroborate the power. Whether or not there's a scene between a non-DF user handling Logia before hand doesn't matter.

I was talking pre-haki. But, at least you admit he made it to beat logias.

>uffy would eventually use it since he's aiming for the big league and the big league use that technique. I don't know what else you want me to prove.

Only if you believe it existed at the start of the series. Unless you prove that to be true, then that argument fails.

>So they're mutually exclusive because you say so?

What? I'm saying they're not mutually exclusive, do you mean mutually inclusive? How old are you?
>>
>>158844479
Dude what the fuck leaving something unexplained until later to give a sense of mystery isn't an asspull created by Oda, its just a basic technique in storytelling and suspense.

Get your head out of your own ass for fucks sake
>>
Wish there were more straightswords.
>>
>>158844591

It wasn't even unexplained. Oda just linked it to Haki.
>>
>>158836239
I'm curious what happens first: OP 1000th chapter or HxH 400th chapter.
>tfw it's probably the former
>>
File: samefag.png (36KB, 510x1499px) Image search: [Google]
samefag.png
36KB, 510x1499px
>>158843990
>Supa Supa no Mi
Zoro cut steel, not a devil fruit power. Pre Haki Zoro can't possibly cut a logia.
>What technique allows you to hear the "breath of all living things" There's no difference between that technique and Haki in respects to how supernatural they are.
Difference being one is to cut steel and the other is to harden your attacks which can hurt logia.
>>158844051
>Riiiiight
Must be hard to accept the fact that there can be two people who are arguing with you. I even said that I don't agree with the guy. Oda didn't make Haki solely for Luffy to win. Period.
>How could the major players be shown to use Haki before Haki was shown? Wut?
Missing the point yet again. Major players were shown to use Haki, which indicates that Luffy will have to learn it to be on the same playing field.
>Linking old powers to Haki doesn't prove he mean't for them to be Haki
Your argument basically boils down to "IT'S NOT HAKI BECAUSE I SAY SO". The explanation, the proof, is right there. You have nothing to disprove this, nothing to back you up. He left the explanation in Skypiea cut short because he planned to do a full blown explanation, which he did, via Rayleigh.

>>158844178
>Haki was introduced when Whitebeard and Shanks had their meeting
Thank you for agreeing that Haki was shown beforehand.
>That's Mantra
Which as Rayleigh explained, is Haki.
>Haki on the otherhand seems like something Oda contrived just so luffy can win in the end.
Then how come he introduced it way back in the story before it became common?
>linking a bunch of random powers
Can't link a bunch of random powers when they were always the same power
>Before Haki, could you imagine luffy taking own Aokiji or Kizaru in a one on one fight?
Aokiji dodged Whitebeard's Haki punch by making an ice hole in his chest to let his punch go through. Haki isn't a hax power.
>Haki changed how the fights would play out.
They still rely on techniques and skill. Conqueror Haki only works for fodders.
>>
>>158844632
Wait, what chapter is HxH on?
>>
>>158844657
I think its at 361. It started in 1998 so thats kind of hilarious.
>>
>>158844178
>Just stop, by that time Haki had already been introduced. Haki was introduced when Whitebeard and Shanks had their meeting before being fleshed out later on.
Yes I know. I was giving some other examples before it was fleshed out after the war. Thanks for adding another example for my argument.
>That's Mantra
Finally I see. I'm dealing with either a spreedreader, or someone who has never read the story at all. Mantra and Observation haki are the same thing. Rayleigh explained this and said Skypeians have a different name for it, probably due to their wildly different cultures compared to the Blue sea inhabitants. The Roger Pirates visited Skypeia so he would know.
>I dunno, ask Oda. The thing with DF is they had alot of characteristics and they made the bulk of the system for combat in OP. Haki on the otherhand seems like something Oda contrived just so luffy can win in the end. Because outside of linking a bunch of random powers it comes so late in the story officially.
Haki won't let Luffy win in the end tho. It's only another tool in his arsenal, which his opponents all have to. You say it was contrived or that it came late in the story, but it was clearly foreshadowed.
>Strawman, I never said every battle but we know there are battles he will never win without it.
You said Luffy has the secret to become PK. That implies winning all of his battles.
>Before Haki, could you imagine luffy taking own Aokiji or Kizaru in a one on one fight? What about after it, nevermind the setbacks of Haki. Clearly he stands a chance of winning.
No I couldn't. That's why when Jozu hurt Aokiji, everyone wanted to know why. Now with Haki, Luffy does stand a chance. Why is that bad tho? I'm reading this story for Luffy to become PK not him being beat by other characters.
>All of this is post Haki shit. So, it's irrelevant.
Not Boa hancock You were upset that Luffy had a special power that made him super strong when its not at all.
cont.
>>
>>158844631
I don't see why that is a problem if it makes sense.
>>
>>158844227
>Okay, so what is it? What's the difference between tekkai and armament besides aesthetics? What exactly is so distinct about haki that you can't add more bs powers to it?
Tekkai just hardens your body from attacks. While it can be used as offensive, that is very rarely and you have to have great mastery over it to do so because your movement is considerably lessened. This is in stark contrast to Armermant Also, tekkai doesn't allow you to hit a DF user.
>In the long run it does. He doesn't have the limitations of his DF to worry about now it's about training just like other shounen
Not necessarily. He still has to worry about being knocked out by people, because his rubber body no longer protects him from blunt attacks when his enemies are also using haki.
>But, structural there's nothing stopping him from doing it. All we have is good will towards Oda. That's not enough for me.
Yeah, there's nothing stopping from any author to do anything with their story. Shoud Oda pull some bullshit like that, you'll hear me first complaining about it.
>>
>>158844637
>Thank you for agreeing that Haki was shown beforehand.

Beforehand means when it was introduced to you? Certainly not before Skypiea. So, no clue what you mean.

>Which as Rayleigh explained, is Haki.

Because Oda arbitrarily made it so.

>Then how come he introduced it way back in the story before it became common?

Shanks meeting with whitebeard isn't way back. Way back relative to what?

>Can't link a bunch of random powers when they were always the same power


Prove they were always the same.

>Aokiji dodged Whitebeard's Haki punch by making an ice hole in his chest to let his punch go through. Haki isn't a hax power.

Never said anything about Hax, but relative to the gains the downsides are inconsequential

>They still rely on techniques and skill. Conqueror Haki only works for fodders.

But, it's still easier relative to before it was introduced.

>Must be hard to accept the fact that there can be two people who are arguing with you. I even said that I don't agree with the guy. Oda didn't make Haki solely for Luffy to win. Period.

Two people who argue the sameway, kay

>Missing the point yet again. Major players were shown to use Haki, which indicates that Luffy will have to learn it to be on the same playing field.

They were shown way later. So, ow does that prove they were always intended to learn it from the onset.

>Your argument basically boils down to "IT'S NOT HAKI BECAUSE I SAY SO". The explanation, the proof, is right there. You have nothing to disprove this, nothing to back you up. He left the explanation in Skypiea cut short because he planned to do a full blown explanation, which he did, via Rayleigh.

Can't prove a negative fag. Burden of proof is on you.
>>
File: fuji.png (308KB, 696x1012px) Image search: [Google]
fuji.png
308KB, 696x1012px
Just a heads up that the strawhats wont be running away and that the big meme pirates are going down this arc. Pic related.
>>
File: 549307549.jpg (801KB, 658x1041px) Image search: [Google]
549307549.jpg
801KB, 658x1041px
Am I going to have to dodge OP threads until HxH goes back on hiatus? Guess I'll hang out in the DBS threads. At least the shitposting there is kinda funny. Also why specifically HxH?
>>
>>158844766
>Tekkai just hardens your body from attacks. While it can be used as offensive, that is very rarely and you have to have great mastery over it to do so because your movement is considerably lessened. This is in stark contrast to Armermant Also, tekkai doesn't allow you to hit a DF user.

It's a stark contrast why? You didn't explain how it's a stark contrast other than just saying it is. Tekkai requiring mastery means nothing because all in all it can be contrived as being armament Haki

>Not necessarily. He still has to worry about being knocked out by people, because his rubber body no longer protects him from blunt attacks when his enemies are also using haki.

How is that a downside for him using Haki? If he didn't have Haki he would have it worst.

>Yeah, there's nothing stopping from any author to do anything with their story. Shoud Oda pull some bullshit like that, you'll hear me first complaining about it.

Oh please, it would be much harder to contrive a fight where luffy beats logias without Haki than with Haki.
>>
>>158844809
Linlin is just an overgrown fatass who sits around all day and eats sweets and her children. She's such a weak (((Yonko))) that she has to grovel and rape men into alliances just so her shitty territory doesn't fall apart. While REAL Yonko like Whitebeard, Kaido and Shanks were going up against the very strongest BigMeme was strugggling on the toilet trying to shit out yesterday's sweets. Only reason she never got injured is cause her cannibal face never had the opportunity to meat Whitebeard's fist. She's gonna job so hard that the word jobbing will be synoymous with BigMeme and her failure will inspire countless threads of shitposting.

So yeah, she's about to get BTFO
>>
>>158844637
>Difference being one is to cut steel and the other is to harden your attacks which can hurt logia.

There's nothing stopping one explanation from stretching to fit the other. Zoro couldn't cut steel because it's too hard, but with Haki he can cut anything because it's Haki. There's no power Haki can't fit.
>>
>>158844272
I do see the difference. I pointed that out to you. And I don't mind. Having Luffy for example come up with some gimmick just to beat an opponent is dumb and would get lame quick. Haki solves this problem and puts people on an equal playing field.
>and this is the sameguy who wrote the bs explanation about hearing steel breath that's gonna steer how Haki plays out.
?????
>>
>>158844399
>Which gives them super powers
>super human abilities
From martial arts. Therefore, martial arts, gotcha.
>Just repeating the same thing
That's what I do when talking to retards, yes.
>You are litterally repeating the same argument just to have a response
Are you talking to mirror right now?
>That would only be true if Oda planned on him learning Haki in the first place
Considering it was shown way back in the story to be used by the major players and Luffy's dream involves him into the big league, so yes.
>They weren't set before when observance Haki was just Mantra and not attached to anti DF bullshit.
Step by step. First was Mantra, and then Shanks vs Whitebeard for Conqueror, and then Armament.
>No such thing as a "cut off explanatoin" you're making up words to support your bs theory that he left it unexplained to connect it to Haki he always planned for.
Basic story telling isn't a bullshit theory.
>>158844479
>Because you assumed he would connect it to Haki because he cut it off?
Basic storytelling. Not assumption.
>I was talking pre-haki. But, at least you admit he made it to beat logias.
I didn't admit shit. He didn't make it up halfway through the story as a plot device because he wrote himself to the corner like you implied. He wouldn't introduce such strong and famous characters if they can't fight logia. Pre-Haki or Post-Haki, a scene where a non-DF user handling a Logia was a way to corroborate on the power, it doesn't matter. Not to mention Haki has existed by the evidence I posted(Mantra, Shanks vs Whitebeard) before it became common.
>Only if you believe it existed at the start of the series. Unless you prove that to be true, then that argument fails.
Skypiea was where it was introduced. That was way long before it took commonplace. Early enough.
>do you mean mutually inclusive?
Yes.
>>
>>158844734
>Yes I know. I was giving some other examples before it was fleshed out after the war. Thanks for adding another example for my argument.

How is that helping your argument? Tjat's when it was introduced, it never exsisted before.

>Finally I see. I'm dealing with either a spreedreader, or someone who has never read the story at all. Mantra and Observation haki are the same thing.

Because Oda made them the samething. I'm arguing they were never implied to be connected until after. Because Haki did not exsist.

>Haki won't let Luffy win in the end tho. It's only another tool in his arsenal, which his opponents all have to. You say it was contrived or that it came late in the story, but it was clearly foreshadowed.

It wasn't foreshadowed and it's ambigous enough that any power can be interpreted as Haki. It has no clear traits, just a random assortment of shit combined: Mantra, Anti DF and Ghetto Tekkai. It's completely random

>You said Luffy has the secret to become PK. That implies winning all of his battles.

Winning the important ones and he does. Before Haki, he couldn't defeat certain opponents, but with Haki he has a chance against anyone even if he loses he can power up with Haki related bs.


>v

By that time Haki was already at play

> Why is that bad tho? I'm reading this story for Luffy to become PK not him being beat by other characters.

Because it's easier and boring imo. I rather it be harder like back when he had DF limitations

>Not Boa hancock You were upset that Luffy had a special power that made him super strong when its not at all.
cont.

It was special, rubber fruit was unique to him and no other shounen had anything like DF. Now, it's generic shounen chi in the form of Haki. Boa isn't before Haki
>>
>>158844178
>Before Haki, could you imagine luffy taking own Aokiji or Kizaru in a one on one fight?
Not him but Luffy can just use Kairouseki
>>
>>158844847
>It's a stark contrast why? You didn't explain how it's a stark contrast other than just saying it is. Tekkai requiring mastery means nothing because all in all it can be contrived as being armament Haki
Reading comprehension my man. It's stark contrast because Armament haki lets you move freely and use it much more offensively compared to tekkai.
Also I think we have only seen one user use tekkai offensively and that was Jabra the wolf guy from enies lobby. He was said to have the most mastered and control of tekkai.
>How is that a downside for him using Haki? If he didn't have Haki he would have it worst
Reading comprehension. You seriously need it. You said haki in the long run makes Luffy win, which is not the case.
Luffy's previous invulnerability to blunt attacks is now gone due to an opponents armament haki This means he won't always win exactly.
>Oh please, it would be much harder to contrive a fight where luffy beats logias without Haki than with Haki.
Maybe. But we haven't really seen this yet. However this statement isn't relevant at all to the part you quoted.
>>
>>158844789
>Certainly not before Skypiea
Skypiea is far enough before Haki became commonplace, yes. Therefore, it's planned.
>Because Oda arbitrarily made it so.
He wouldn't cut short the explanation in Skypiea if that was the case.
>Shanks meeting with whitebeard isn't way back. Way back relative to what?
Way back relative to Haki becoming common. And wow, 10 years isn't way back now, apparently. That chapter was in 2007.
>Prove they were always the same.
Skypiea and chapter 597.
>Never said anything about Hax, but relative to the gains the downsides are inconsequential
Point is, Haki isn't an auto-win power against Logia.
>But, it's still easier relative to before it was introduced.
No. Because Luffy still struggles against Big Mom's weakest commander, even with Haki on.
>They were shown way later
Way early enough before it took commonplace.
>Can't prove a negative fag. Burden of proof is on you.
>CAN'T PROVE A NEGATIVE BECAUSE I SAY SO
I actually have clear, concrete evidence to back myself up. You only have your denial and stubbornness. Burden of proof is on you since you were the one who first made the claim that Haki is bullshit.
>>158844884
It wasn't Haki. It's to cut steel, not logia.
>>
>>158844914
>From martial arts.

It's still a power. How does it's source change how it works?

>That's what I do when talking to retards, yes.

Or when you are a retard yourself. You didn't even know that the opposite of mutually exclusive is mutually inclusive. You were dropped on the head as a baby, weren't ya?

>Are you talking to mirror right now?


So, witty. A shit tier joke to boot. How long did it take you to come up with that? Did your mom help you with that? You're proof that condoms are necessary.

>Considering it was shown way back in the story to be used by the major players and Luffy's dream involves him into the big league, so yes.

Wayback being when? One Piece was in the triple digits when Haki was introduced. That is not wayback.

>Step by step. First was Mantra, and then Shanks vs Whitebeard for Conqueror, and then Armament.

Mantra was a retcon

>Basic storytelling. Not assumption.

Basic assumption because you have no evidence. Saying because it 's a device used in stories doesn't prove it was used. That's an assumption.

>I didn't admit shit. He didn't make it up halfway through the story as a plot device because he wrote himself to the corner like you implied. He wouldn't introduce such strong and famous characters if they can't fight logia. Pre-Haki or Post-Haki, a scene where a non-DF user handling a Logia was a way to corroborate on the power, it doesn't matter. Not to mention Haki has existed by the evidence I posted(Mantra, Shanks vs Whitebeard) before it became common.

Why wouldn't he do it? Because he's Goda, and he shits rainbows? Please, this is the same guy that makes nonesense like shishisonson and asura and a bunch of random bullshit when he wants to. Just because you dickride him doesn't mean shit.

>Skypiea was where it was introduced. That was way long before it took commonplace. Early enough.

Prove he intended Mantra to be Haki in the first place.
>>
File: 1492570775166.png (466KB, 820x708px) Image search: [Google]
1492570775166.png
466KB, 820x708px
>>158837352
>Dragging out arcs for years
>Oda has retained his passion for writing and loves his story as much as if not more than his children
>>
Come on, guys, is not that hard

Mantra and "Hear every living thing breathing" were not Haki in the past but now they are
>>
>>158845051
>Reading comprehension my man. It's stark contrast because Armament haki lets you move freely and use it much more offensively compared to tekkai.

That's a minor detail, blueno used tekkai offensively.

>Reading comprehension. You seriously need it. You said haki in the long run makes Luffy win, which is not the case.
Luffy's previous invulnerability to blunt attacks is now gone due to an opponents armament haki This means he won't always win exactly.

Take your own advice. Luffy isn't more vulnerable because he has Haki though. That vulnerability is because his opponents have Haki. So, how is that proof it's not an advantage. Is every opponent Luffy fights gonna use Haki? And, even if so how is he worst off because he has Haki?

>Maybe. But we haven't really seen this yet. However this statement isn't relevant at all to the part you quoted.

Maybe? He fought several logias and struggled pre Haki. That's the point, it lowered the difficulty.
>>
File: things JUST GOT VERY BAD.jpg (60KB, 1014x1024px) Image search: [Google]
things JUST GOT VERY BAD.jpg
60KB, 1014x1024px
>>158838089
>Satoshi Kon died 7 years ago
>>
>>158845175
>miyazaki is still alive
You take some you lose some.
>>
>>158844847
You can't move while using Tekkai unless you're Jabura.

Any downside from using Stand?

Haki is inevitable. It's not an asspull.

>>158844989
>Because Oda made them the samething
You really have to read past the part you greentexted. Roger was in Skypiea and Rayleigh would of course be aware of what it is. And there's the cut short explanation of Mantra.
>It wasn't foreshadowed
Skypiea
>It has no clear traits
Chapter 597
>he can power up with Haki related bs.
Haki isn't a power up. And again, Big Mom's commander made Luffy struggle and had Nami help him and he had Haki on. His Armament Haki hand was legit being slashed by a sword.
>Because it's easier and boring imo. I rather it be harder like back when he had DF limitations
He still struggles against certain opponents. Do I need to repeat myself about Big Mom's commander? He had to go Gear 4th AND Nami's help.
>It was special, rubber fruit was unique to him and no other shounen had anything like DF. Now, it's generic shounen chi in the form of Haki
Yeah man, it's not like Haki helped him increase the elastic property of his rubber body in the form of Gear 4th. Oh, wait. See my point? He implemented Hai not as a simple buff, but expanding the property of his devil fruit. No other fruit user can use Haki to gain a property expansion like Luffy can. That technique is exclusive to Gomu Gomu fruit. Only when you have Haki on and Gomu Gomu power can you use Gear 4th.
>>
>>158845052
>Skypiea is far enough before Haki became commonplace, yes. Therefore, it's planned.

Non-sequitur How does it being far enough mean it was planned? Wut?

>He wouldn't cut short the explanation in Skypiea if that was the case.

BAsed on what. What's stoping him from cutting it short because he can? Because you say so?

>Way back relative to Haki becoming common. And wow, 10 years isn't way back now, apparently. That chapter was in 2007.

That's when it was introduced I never argued anything before that point.

>Skypiea and chapter 597.

Doesn't they were the same before hand, just after the retcon

>Point is, Haki isn't an auto-win power against Logia.

Doesn't have to be, it's just a lower difficulty rating for Oda to write a fight between one and luffy

>No. Because Luffy still struggles against Big Mom's weakest commander, even with Haki on.


But, he doesn't have to. With rubber, on the other hand, his options are limited, but with Haki he can do much more because it has far less limitations and the limitations are ambiguous.

>Way early enough before it took commonplace.

Not relative to mantra or early one piece.

>I actually have clear, concrete evidence to back myself up. You only have your denial and stubbornness. Burden of proof is on you since you were the one who first made the claim that Haki is bullshit.

Burden on me to do what? Prove it's not bullshit? Can't do that sweety, can't prove a negative. You're job is to prove Haki is not an Ad Hoc plot device made to have luffy beat logias. . .oh wait. you can't.
>>
>>158845252
>You can't move while using Tekkai unless you're Jabura.

Bleuno did it with Tekkai wheel and it's plausible that others could too. It's a minor inconvenience which can be written easily to fit Haki.

>Any downside from using Stand?

What?


>Haki is inevitable. It's not an asspull.

Based on what? Other than Oda needing it.

>You really have to read past the part you greentexted. Roger was in Skypiea and Rayleigh would of course be aware of what it is. And there's the cut short explanation of Mantra.


Doesn't change what I said, Roger being in skypiea and using mantra doesn't mean Od planned for it being linked to all the other powers that are collectively known as Haki.

>Skypiea


Was just Mantra, no proof it was planned to be Haki minus a retcon

>Chapter 597

Was a retcon, no proof it was planned at first

>Haki isn't a power up.

Yes, it is. It made luffy surpass the limitations of his fruit and allows him to now stand a chance against unbeatable enemies. That's power up.

>And again, Big Mom's commander made Luffy struggle and had Nami help him and he had Haki on. His Armament Haki hand was legit being slashed by a sword.

So what? He's still better withit than without and his gains far outweigh any drawbacks. He would have done worst without Haki.

>He still struggles against certain opponents. Do I need to repeat myself about Big Mom's commander? He had to go Gear 4th AND Nami's help.

But, know he has a device that can expand his power. Losing a few fights doesn't change that structurally he's more powerful ebcause Oda can power inflate luffy because Haki's limits are who knows vs the rubber fruit.

contd
>>
>>158845081
>It's still a power
From martial arts.
>You didn't even know that the opposite of mutually exclusive is mutually inclusive
You were typing "your" as "you're" in your previous posts and I never said shit. And now when I accidentally mixed up a word you go ham on me.
>So, witty
Indeed. Unlike you.
>Wayback being when?
Way back before Haki became common.
>Mantra was a retcon
Because you desperately believe so due to your stubbornness in winning argument.
>Basic assumption because you have no evidence.
Pray tell, why did Oda make Gun Fall do an explanation on Mantra that got cut short because he himself stated he doesn't know the origin of Mantra? Oh, that's right. Because Oda planned to make Rayleigh do an explanation on it.
>Why wouldn't he do it?
Because a universe wide technique like this that was evidently shown in the series before it became common is surely not made halfway because the author wanted to.
>Prove he intended Mantra to be Haki in the first place
If Mantra was a separate power than Haki, then the explanation in Skypiea would be conclusive.
>>
File: wow desu.png (101KB, 498x255px) Image search: [Google]
wow desu.png
101KB, 498x255px
Have you guys really been doing this for like four hours now? Impressive.
>>
>>158844989
>How is that helping your argument?
My argument that haki was foreshadowed.
Shanks and whitebeard met before the war and that's when haki was introduced. It was later explained upon after the war.
>Because Oda made them the samething. I'm arguing they were never implied to be connected until after. Because Haki did not exsist
Yes obervation haki didn't exist but we new something about conqueror's haki and armament haki. Oda conveniently put these along with mantra, which would be known as Observation haki to Blue Sea Dwellers, into one category to show that thse things would be used in the new world. This is story telling 101. Take something unexplained before, and expand upon it.
>It wasn't foreshadowed and it's ambigous enough that any power can be interpreted as Haki. It has no clear traits, just a random assortment of shit combined: Mantra, Anti DF and Ghetto Tekkai. It's completely random
See>>158845051
Haki has set rules. Your whining stating otherwise does not convince me. Give me some examples.
>Winning the important ones and he does. Before Haki, he couldn't defeat certain opponents, but with Haki he has a chance against anyone.
Yes. The main character should have an opportunity to win the battles he is facing.
>even if he loses he can power up with Haki related bs.
This has yet to happen. Nor I doubt will.
>Because it's easier and boring imo. I rather it be harder like back when he had DF limitations
Having Luffy have to come up with some gimmick to beat DF users that his attacks don't work on wasn't sustainable and left unanswered questions like how could non devil fruit users go up against DF users. Now Zoro and Sanji can fight against devil fruit users. That would be interesting.
>Boa isn't before Haki
Boa was before haki was explained.
>rubber fruit was unique to him and no other shounen had anything like DF
DF aren't unique. Every shounen has some ability. Also was refuting your points on Conq haki. Not rubber DF.
>>
>>158845252
n, it's not like Haki helped him increase the elastic property of his rubber body in the form of Gear 4th. Oh, wait. See my point? He implemented Hai not as a simple buff, but expanding the property of his devil fruit. No other fruit user can use Haki to gain a property expansion like Luffy can. That technique is exclusive to Gomu Gomu fruit. Only when you have Haki on and Gomu Gomu power can you use Gear 4th.

The combination with rubber is unique but armament itself is not. The main buff for Haki is beating logias because it's the only thing luffy couldn't do on his own. But, with how vague Haki is who knows what he can't do. Hell, he's throwing fireballs now with red hawk punch.
>>
>>158845402
These two are literally autistic. Kind of funny to witness desu.
>>
>>158845384
>From martial arts.

Which doesn't change power. What difference does the source make again?

You were typing "your" as "you're" in your previous posts and I never said shit. And now when I accidentally mixed up a word you go ham on me.

That's a typo, mixing two words is not.

>Indeed. Unlike you.
At least I know what mutually inclusive is

>Way back before Haki became common.

Which is when? No explanation on your part

>Because you desperately believe so due to your stubbornness in winning argument.

What exactly am I winning? I s that why you have to keep repeating shit over? Because you think I want to win? Sounds like you're projecting. Bottomline is there is no proof Haki was in Oda's head when Mantra was around outside of speculation.

>Pray tell, why did Oda make Gun Fall do an explanation on Mantra that got cut short because he himself stated he doesn't know the origin of Mantra? Oh, that's right. Because Oda planned to make Rayleigh do an explanation on it.

Who knows? There's no evidence that he planned for Rayleigh to take up the explanation. Just because he cut it off. It's an assumption

>Because a universe wide technique like this that was evidently shown in the series before it became common is surely not made halfway because the author wanted to.

I'm asking you why he wouldn't make strong characters before introducing Haki? When he makes up techniques on the fly: Shishi sonson that can conveniently get the job done.

>If Mantra was a separate power than Haki, then the explanation in Skypiea would be conclusive.

False Dichotomy. He could have had other reasons to cut it off. You're saying it has to be Haki simply because that's what he ended up doing, that doesn't mean he couldn't do something else.
>>
>>158845583
>>158845583
>>158845583

let the two autists argue while we move to this new thread
>>
>>158845142
>That's a minor detail, blueno used tekkai offensi'vely
>"Give me an example on how they are different!
>Okay here
>"THAT DOESN:T COUNT1!!!!!11"
Kill youself my man
>Take your own advice. Luffy isn't more vulnerable because he has Haki though. That vulnerability is because his opponents have Haki.
Yes this I agree with and it clearly refutes your argument that Haki would make Luffy win easily.
>So, how is that proof it's not an advantage. Is every opponent Luffy fights gonna use Haki? And, even if so how is he worst off because he has Haki?
No he's not worse off because he has haki. Never said that nor did you argue it. Yes every major opponent will probably have haki, as it is needed to survive the new world.
He doesn't have an advantage. I said he now has a disadvantage due to his previous invulnerability to blunt attacks. Are you responding to the wrong people. You're confusing me.
>Maybe? He fought several logias and struggled pre Haki. That's the point, it lowered the difficulty
Yes. That's usually what happens during stories. Protaganist gets stronger after learning new technique and lets him more easily fight against tough enemies. If you think that's bad then I disagree. Haki was needed.
>>
>>158845256
He revealed it first in Skypiea and left the explanation ambiguous because he planned to expand on it later on. That's planning.
>BAsed on what. What's stoping him from cutting it short because he can? Because you say so?
Because basic story telling and common sense. Read more books, please.
>Doesn't have to be, it's just a lower difficulty rating for Oda to write a fight between one and luffy
No, Luffy still struggles.
>That's when it was introduced
No, that was Skypiea.
>Retcon
Because you say so? The explanation at Skypiea would be made conclusive about Mantra if they were different powers.
>His options are limited
Still limited with Haki considering it's common place now. The only plus Haki gives Luffy is that now he can punch Logia, however there are Logias who play smart like Aokiji who can let a punch go through him by making an ice hole on his body. You're the kind of selfish spectator who doesn't think. You prefer Luffy losses and One Piece ends because he doesn't know Haki, oh wait, you'll complain that Oda is stupid because he couldn't come up with ways outside of Haki for Luffy to fight Logia. But when Oda keeps putting Luffy in environment and give him tools to fight Logia, you will complain "HURRR PLOT ARMOR! ODA A HACK!!", and when you're asked to come up with the way Luffy would fight Logia without Haki or constant convenient environment without losing you would say 'HURRR NOT A READER'S JOB LOL. ODA'S JOB!!". Not to forget that Haki was planned since way back.
>Not relative to mantra or early one piece.
Early enough before common usage.
>Can't prove a negative BECAUSE I SAY SO
Oh, how convenient. You made the claim that Haki is a plot device, then you have to back it up. I have actually provided an evidence. Where's yours, faggot?
>>
>>158845410
>My argument that haki was foreshadowed.
>Shanks and whitebeard met before the war and that's when haki was introduced. It was later explained upon after the war.

I never disputed Haki came when shanks met whitebeard. I'm disputing mantra being Haki nonesense

>Yes obervation haki didn't exist but we new something about conqueror's haki and armament haki. Oda conveniently put these along with mantra, which would be known as Observation haki to Blue Sea Dwellers, into one category to show that thse things would be used in the new world. This is story telling 101. Take something unexplained before, and expand upon it.

There's no proof it was mean't to be Haki before he retconned it. That's your belief not a fact

>Haki has set rules. Your whining stating otherwise does not convince me. Give me some examples.

A set of rules that are poorly explained linking random powers together and could possibly link more. Outside of retards who trust Oda no matter what.

>Yes. The main character should have an opportunity to win the battles he is facing.

So, it's about luffy winning. Just like I said.

>This has yet to happen. Nor I doubt will.

Because of faith. structurally it can happen.

>Having Luffy have to come up with some gimmick to beat DF users that his attacks don't work on wasn't sustainable and left unanswered questions like how could non devil fruit users go up against DF users. Now Zoro and Sanji can fight against devil fruit users. That would be interesting.

This is the same series where a guy was cornered because he couldn't cut a DF user. Suddenly, could hear the sound of his metal breathing. So, yeah.

>Boa was before haki was explained.

Not introduced.

>DF aren't unique. Every shounen has some ability. Also was refuting your points on Conq haki. Not rubber DF.


DF is more unique because it has less bs you can squeeze in when you're in a tight space unlike Chi/haki/whatevs.
>>
>>158845640
>He revealed it first in Skypiea and left the explanation ambiguous because he planned to expand on it later on. That's planning.

Which you have not and cannot prove
>>158845640
>Because basic story telling and common sense. Read more books, please.

Retcons are a basic story telling technique too

>No, Luffy still struggles.

Not the same extent

>No, that was Skypiea.

No, you didn't prove it

>Because you say so? The explanation at Skypiea would be made conclusive about Mantra if they were different powers.

Why not? You said it was introduced simple because it was cut off and not explained then I could do the same and say it was a retcon.

>Still limited with Haki considering it's common place now.

Not as limited compared to DF only

>That's a big plus considering he could barely do it before.

> however there are Logias who play smart like Aokiji who can let a punch go through him by making an ice hole on his body

He can still win when before he had basically 0%

>You're the kind of selfish spectator who doesn't think. You prefer Luffy losses and One Piece ends because he doesn't know Haki, oh wait
So, OP would end because Luffy doesn't have his gay power up? nice DBZ tier series.


>you'll complain that Oda is stupid because he couldn't come up with ways outside of Haki for Luffy to fight Logia. But when Oda keeps putting Luffy in environment and give him tools to fight Logia, you will complain "HURRR PLOT ARMOR! ODA A HACK!!

No, I won't. I hate bs power ups.

> Not to forget that Haki was planned since way back.

Not before logias and other stronger characters appeared.

>Early enough before common usage.

Not early enough for luffy to have been planned to have use it, not before Aokiji and other hax logias.


>Oh, how convenient. You made the claim that Haki is a plot device, then you have to back it up. I have actually provided an evidence. Where's yours, faggot?

You admitted it was a plot device faggot.
>>
File: 1463609012928.jpg (566KB, 505x782px) Image search: [Google]
1463609012928.jpg
566KB, 505x782px
First 10 volumes of one piece might just be the most painful thing that I ever have read.
It just got worse and worse volume by volume.
>>
>>158845620
>Kill youself my man

Nice greentext, who u quote fag?

>Yes this I agree with and it clearly refutes your argument that Haki would make Luffy win easily.

Easily, relative to non-Haki luffy

>He doesn't have an advantage.

Except against logias

>Yes. That's usually what happens during stories. Protaganist gets stronger after learning new technique and lets him more easily fight against tough enemies. If you think that's bad then I disagree. Haki was needed

Of course you disagree, you like One Piece Z and retarded shounen power ups.
>>
>guaranteed replies: the post
why are HXH fags so easy to bait?
>>
>>158845793
>First 10 volumes of one piece might just be the most painful thing that I ever have read.
Did you laugh so much your stomach started hurting or what?
>>
>>158845832

Shit fanbase.
>>
>>158837244
And it's explained in HxH before that Nen doesn't necessarily canceled by death, some even get stronger
>>
>all these autistically long posts
Lol
>>
>>158845583
>>158845583
>>158845583

New World
>>
>>158845662
>I never disputed Haki came when shanks met whitebeard. I'm disputing mantra being Haki nonesense
But mantra is haki anon. Rayleigh said so, and they act completely similar only difference is the name. Sure you can argue Oda retconned it, but it's a perfectly reasonable explanation with the different names, because of the different cultures.
>There's no proof it was mean't to be Haki before he retconned it. That's your belief not a fact
See above point as well. Of course there is no proof. There is no proof that Oda did alot of things that we speculate about. You're just buttblasted haki was introduced and when people praise Oda for foreshadowing it, you get your panties in a twist.
>Mantra wasn't Haki Oda Retconned it!1!1!
You don't know for either. That's your belief not fact.
>A set of rules that are poorly explained linking random powers together and could possibly link more. Outside of retards who trust Oda no matter what
I don't trust Oda no matter what. Should Oda bring in some random bullshit haki that doesn't already belong to one of the three categories, then I'll be pissed. But that has yet to happen. Haki is clearly defined and has a set of rules. Once again your whining does not prove otherwise.
>So, it's about luffy winning. Just like I said.
Never disagreed faggot. For some reason you don't want the main character to have a chance at winning the battles. Why are you reading any manga again?
>This is the same series where a guy was cornered because he couldn't cut a DF user. Suddenly, could hear the sound of his metal breathing. So, yeah.
Yes and it was a great fight. Now Zoro can cut people like Buggy as well.
>Not introduced
Never said otherwise. You were upset that Luffy had Conq haki because it made him super strong and special, when in reality it doesn't. I used Boa as an example to state otherwise. Don't debate if you can't keep your thoughts straight.
>>
>>158845848

The Cliche upon cliche thrown at me trying to make me care with visceral images of people crying made me physically ill.

It's like the devil himself created it.
>>
>>158845421
Nice backpedaling. You were all about how Haki is bullshit and against the notion that Haki can be implemented in creative way. Now you said "B-B-B-BUT THE HAKI ITSELF"

>>158845562
>What difference does the source make again?
One is martial arts, the other a super power.
>That's a typo, mixing two words is not
Typo is a typing error. Typing "you're" as "your" is mixing up two different words. Legit grammar error. Come on, "you are" where you refer to someone, and "your" which means belong.
>At least I know what mutually inclusive is
So do I. Good thing mixing up words is an honest mistake and doesn't mean I don't know what certain words mean. At least it's not a 12 years old-esque grammar error like mixing up "your" and "you're".
>Which is when? No explanation on your part
Skypiea
>Mantra was around outside of speculation.
Why did Gan Fall not give clear explanation to Mantra?
>I'm asking you why he wouldn't make strong characters before introducing Haki?
He did make strong characters before Haki was introduced. Those characters turn out can use Haki.
>He could have had other reasons to cut it off
Because you keep deluding yourself and thinking you're right because you think so. It's basic storytelling.

>>158845363
Jabra can use more freely. Rokushiki is martial arts, not Haki. There were clear explanations for each of them.

Based on Skypiea and Shanks vs Whitebeard.

Gan Fall explanation would be conclusive, then. Therefore, not a retcon.

It's a power. Power up is Gear 2nd, 3rd, and 4th.

>So what?
To show the enemies' power and how Luffy would have to handle them. Once again, if Luffy loses and One Piece ends because of no Haki, you would bitch, if Oda constantly supplies him with the right environment and tools without Haki, you'd call "PLOT ARMOR", if you're asked to write something better, then "LEL THAT'S ODA'S JOB. IF HE CAN'T DO IT HE'S A HACK LOL"

>expand his power
Inevitable.
>>
>>158845949
Yeah. I love how self-aware One Piece is. Oda is truly a comedic genius
>>
>>158845927
>But mantra is haki anon. Rayleigh said so,

After Oda retconned it to being so.

>and they act completely similar only difference is the name.

Which Oda changed when he retconned.

>Sure you can argue Oda retconned it, but it's a perfectly reasonable explanation with the different names, because of the different cultures.

I didn't say it wouldn't fit. But, Haki being some magic power bs anything can fit. If Oda said Shishi Sonson was Haki what exactly could you point it that makes them different? You could do the same with any power.

>See above point as well. Of course there is no proof.

At least you're honest

>You don't know for either. That's your belief not fact.

It is my belief, same as yours that he always had it planned.

> But that has yet to happen. Haki is clearly defined and has a set of rules. Once again your whining does not prove otherwise.

Structurally its abusable and if the only thing that keeps him from abusing it is good will then fuck that.

>Never disagreed faggot. For some reason you don't want the main character to have a chance at winning the battles. Why are you reading any manga again?

I don't, I want him to win despite having no chance of winning by outplaying his opponent. Not, because he has some magic plot device.

>Yes and it was a great fight. Now Zoro can cut people like Buggy as well.

So, as long as it's cool huh

>Never said otherwise. You were upset that Luffy had Conq haki because it made him super strong and special, when in reality it doesn't. I used Boa as an example to state otherwise. Don't debate if you can't keep your thoughts straight.

It allows him to win when he couldn't without it. That's the complaint.
>>
>>158845951
>Nice backpedaling. You were all about how Haki is bullshit and against the notion that Haki can be implemented in creative way. Now you said "B-B-B-BUT THE HAKI ITSELF"

I never argued it couldn't be used in a creative way. I said it's exploitable from a story perspective which it is.

>One is martial arts, the other a super power.

Which makes them different how?

>Typo is a typing error. Typing "you're" as "your" is mixing up two different words. Legit grammar error. Come on, "you are" where you refer to someone, and "your" which means belong.

Nope, it was a typo. You legit couldn't tell the difference between Mutually inclusive and exclusive despite that you're using the same argument about martial arts and powers not being the same even though in fiction they're not mutually exclusive. You're falling apart.

>So do I

No you don't

>Good thing mixing up words is an honest mistake

Only for a retard like you. Keep crying over it, makes my job easier.


>Skypiea

Mantra is not Haki, minus the retcon.

>Why did Gan Fall not give clear explanation to Mantra?

Because Oda forgot to finish the explanation.

>He did make strong characters before Haki was introduced. Those characters turn out can use Haki.

Retroactively turned out you mean, as in retconned into being able to.

>Because you keep deluding yourself and thinking you're right because you think so. It's basic storytelling.


Basic storytelling, just like retcons.
>>
File: 84656163.png (146KB, 302x387px) Image search: [Google]
84656163.png
146KB, 302x387px
>>158836239
>OPfags insecure because the true king is back
There is a reason why HxH gets spoilers earlier and the whole script is typed.
>>
>>158845951
>Jabra can use more freely.

And, armament is a more free tekkai. Oda can do that too and it would fit because the ambiguous nature of Haki


> Rokushiki is martial arts, not Haki. There were clear explanations for each of them.

Nope, Haki is a martial arts concept. Even Rayleigh explanation about it being a latent energy that everyone shares is like Chi which is a martial arts concept.

>Based on Skypiea
Retcon

>shanks vs Whitebeard.
Never questioned that, you okay? You sure you're not sleepy from being an idiot for so long?

>Gan Fall explanation would be conclusive, then. Therefore, not a retcon.

False dichotomy and non-sequitur

>It's a power. Power up is Gear 2nd, 3rd, and 4th.

"It's a power up?" Okay

>if Oda constantly supplies him with the right environment and tools without Haki, you'd call "PLOT ARMOR",

I would not.

> if you're asked to write something better, then "LEL THAT'S ODA'S JOB. IF HE CAN'T DO IT HE'S A HACK LOL"

I would write something better.

>Inevitable

To powerlevel fags.
>>
>>158845761
>cannot prove
Cut off explanation that was corroborated by Rayleigh is proof enough.
>Retcons are a basic story telling technique too
Retcons are making a statement and then retracting it. You can't call Haki a Mantra retcon when the explanation was cut short and then explained in full later on. Hell, might as well say Vivre Card is retcon too.
>Why not? You said it was introduced simple because it was cut off and not explained then I could do the same and say it was a retcon.
Can't be a retcon when the explanation wasn't full.
>Not as limited to DF only
Less limitation but still having limitation nonetheless is bad now?
>he had basically 0%
Guess you prefer One Piece ends because Luffy dies midway.
>So, OP would end because Luffy doesn't have his gay power up? nice DBZ tier series.
See? This is what I was talking about. You would complain that Luffy can't win without Haki, but when Oda keeps putting Luffy in an environment and tools to fight Logia without Haki like when he fought Croc with water and blood over and over and over again, you'd say Luffy has gary stu Jackie Chan plot armor.
>No, I won't. I hate bs power ups.
I wasn't talking about bullshit power ups, I'm talking about environment or tools to fight Logia WITHOUT Haki like at the time against Croc which wouldn't always be the case. But when such case presents itself EVERY time Luffy fights a Logia, it would be too convenient and you would start going "HURRR PLOT ARMOR DURRR LUFFY ALWAYS FINDS A WAY". And when asked if you can write better, you'll say "LEL THAT'S ODA'S JOB. WHAT A HACK".

>Not before logias and other stronger characters appeared.
Early enough before it became common. It's an inevitability.
>Not early enough for luffy to have been planned to have use it, not before Aokiji and other hax logias.
Tell me other ways to defeat these logias. Oh, wait, I know your kind. "HURRR I DON'T KNOW, ASK ODA. THAT'S HIS JOB! I JUST WANT TO WHINE!"
>You admitted it was a plot device faggot.
Nope
>>
>>158836239
I just was on /v/
they have better OP threads than /a/
>>
>>158845994

I don't know what to say bro.
>>
>>158846103
>the true king
hahaha he is actually eating this Detective Kurapica dogshit
>>
>>158846186
>Cut off explanation that was corroborated by Rayleigh is proof enough.

Cut off is proof he didn't plan it. I could argue it eitherway

>Retcons are making a statement and then retracting it.

Not, it's not. It's changing details of the plot that are established. Mantra being Haki is a retcon.

>You can't call Haki a Mantra retcon when the explanation was cut short and then explained in full later on. Hell, might as well say Vivre Card is retcon too.

What exactly was cut short? Where it came from? Because we know how it works, only thing that was cut off is the origin which is innate and that isn't changed by Haki. Just the name.

>Can't be a retcon when the explanation wasn't full.

It was full enough

>Less limitation but still having limitation nonetheless is bad now?

Far less and it is bad because it's easier.

>Guess you prefer One Piece ends because Luffy dies midway.

False Dichotomy

>See? This is what I was talking about. You would complain that Luffy can't win without Haki, but when Oda keeps putting Luffy in an environment and tools to fight Logia without Haki like when he fought Croc with water and blood over and over and over again, you'd say Luffy has gary stu Jackie Chan plot armor.

I never complained about the water and blood to beat croc. So, no clue what you're talking about.

>I wasn't talking about bullshit power ups, I'm talking about environment or tools to fight Logia WITHOUT Haki like at the time against Croc which wouldn't always be the case. But when such case presents itself EVERY time Luffy fights a Logia, it would be too convenient and you would start going "HURRR PLOT ARMOR DURRR LUFFY ALWAYS FINDS A WAY". And when asked if you can write better, you'll say "LEL THAT'S ODA'S JOB. WHAT A HACK".

Environmental tools are fine, no haki.

>Early enough before it became common. It's an inevitability.

Not based on the early story
>>
Hunter x Hunter is drawn so fucking horrible
>>
>>158846268
Just agree.
>>
>>158846186
>Tell me other ways to defeat these logias. Oh, wait, I know your kind. "HURRR I DON'T KNOW, ASK ODA. THAT'S HIS JOB! I

You just mentioned them, environmental tactics, team works or items. But, I guess macho shounens needs luffy to do it by himself to prove how big his cock is.


>Nope


You went on a whole tirade about plot devices not being bad.
>>
>>158836239
And no ALLUKAAAAAAAA asspull
>>
>>158846313
Aluka is a cute girl (male)
>>
>>158845583
>>158845583
>>158845583

Now fucking move in
>>
Hunter X Hunter currently: Detective Conan X Boringness

One Piece: Alice in Wonderland meets Sentai + Attack on Titan

hmmmm wonder what is more exciting? Huntards are maggots btw
>>
File: 1462643371996.gif (2MB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]
1462643371996.gif
2MB, 500x281px
>>158846313
>asspull
>>
>>158846025
>After Oda retconned it to being so.
But he didn't. Keep whining about it tho.
>Which Oda changed when he retconned
Oda changed the name in a completely great way tho. Skypeia has a completely different culture that was rarely undisturbed by the people who call Mantra, Haki. Therefore this also adds a nice worldbuilding touch. It makes totally perfect sense.
>If Oda said Shishi Sonson was Haki what exactly could you point it that makes them different?
Hypotheticals huh? If Oda did this I'd be angry, because Shishi sonson was only used to cut really hard metals, like Kuma's shoulder or Mr 1's body. If that technique was somehow a replacement for Haki I'd be angry. But sine Haki has a defined rule set, and Zoro hasn't used shishi sonson to cut logia users without cladding it with haki, it's a moot point.
>At least you're honest
>It is my belief, same as yours that he always had it planned.
So you agree that Haki was planned since skypeia. Well at least you're honest.
Guess the discussion is down now eh?
>Structurally its abusable and if the only thing that keeps him from abusing it is good will then fuck that
It's not the only thing that keeps him from abusing it. It would be bad writing and a glaring plot hole. Oda has been doing this for twenty something years now? I have faith.
>I don't, I want him to win despite having no chance of winning by outplaying his opponent. Not, because he has some magic plot device.
Him winning because of muh water for a bunch of times would be dumb. Having survived Crocodile's second attack by him was already to much chance for my liking. That was a dumb plot device.
>It allows him to win when he couldn't without it. That's the complaint
Please give me an example of Luffy winning a major fight using Conqueror's Haki.
>>
>>158846100
>I never argued it couldn't be used in a creative way
See>>158841367
Can't backpedal from that, can you, faggot?
>different how
One is just a power, the other comes with martial arts training.
>Nope, it was a typo
"You're" and "your" which are two different words(three if you want to get technical since "you are" are two words) with different meaning are typos now. Wow.
>No you don't
Yes, I do.
>Keep crying over it
You're the one who keeps bringing it up, though. Reminds me of a 12 years old who tries to derail the topic with criticizing word usage. Yes, I made a mistake, I mixed up exclusive and inclusive. I've admitted that I meant to use inclusive since the first time you addressed it. I don't know why you're so adamant to keep highlighting it. It doesn't make my entire point any less right.
>Mantra is not Haki
Proof? At last I got evidence that Mantra explanation was cut short and Rayleigh giving full explanation makes sense due to Roger's visit there.
>Because Oda forgot to finish the explanation.
More like, because he wanted to fully expand it with Rayleigh later on.
>Retconned into being able to
It's not a retcon when the first explanation wasn't in full.
>just like retcons
Retcons isn't even telling a story. It's changing an established statement. Oda did planning with Mantra explanation and expansion by Rayleigh.
>>158846177
Tekkai can't hurt Logia. Tekkai is mainly for defensive.
>martial arts concept
I guess practicing Yoga makes you a martial artist now.
>Retcon
If it was retcon, the explanation on Mantra would be conclusive.
>You okay?
I'm okay. Unlike you.
>False dichotomy
Why would the explanation cut short then? Oh yes, because plans with Rayleigh.
>Okay
You can't understand proper punctuation. Haki is a power. While a power up is Gears.
>write something better.
Please try to do so.
>To power level fags
No. To people who pay attention.
>>
>>158846522
>But he didn't. Keep whining about it tho.

He clearly did if he made mantra become part of an umbrella of powers

>Oda changed the name in a completely great way tho. Skypeia has a completely different culture that was rarely undisturbed by the people who call Mantra, Haki. Therefore this also adds a nice worldbuilding touch. It makes totally perfect sense.


That just proves you like it and I didn't say it was good or bad, I said it was not planned and Haki's ambiguous nature makes it fit any explanation as needed and ad hoc.

>Hypotheticals huh? If Oda did this I'd be angry, because Shishi sonson was only used to cut really hard metals, like Kuma's shoulder or Mr 1's body. If that technique was somehow a replacement for Haki I'd be angry. But sine Haki has a defined rule set, and Zoro hasn't used shishi sonson to cut logia users without cladding it with haki, it's a moot point.

The rule set isn't definite though. Why can't Zoro hear the breathing of Ice or fire or any substance Oda wants it too? There's nothing hard about extending from one material into another that a logia just happens to occupy.

>So you agree that Haki was planned since skypeia. Well at least you're honest.
Guess the discussion is down now eh?

No, I don't agree. You're getting desperate now if that's your game: rewording what I said.

>It's not the only thing that keeps him from abusing it. It would be bad writing and a glaring plot hole. Oda has been doing this for twenty something years now? I have faith.

But, it's abusable more so than DF because there are less set in stone limits. The only thing you have is faith, it doesn't change the nature of the device.

>Him winning because of muh water for a bunch of times would be dumb. Having survived Crocodile's second attack by him was already to much chance for my liking. That was a dumb plot device.


Why would he need water a bunch of times when fighting other logias?
>>
>>158846557
>Can't backpedal from that, can you, faggot?

Saying it can't be used in a creative way doesn't mean it is. No need to backpedal, you just can't read.

>One is just a power, the other comes with martial arts training.

Yeah, a power with martial arts training. But, both are powers

>"You're" and "your" which are two different words(three if you want to get technical since "you are" are two words) with different meaning are typos now. Wow.

So is mutually inclusive and exclusive. And, show me where I made this typo.

>Nope

>You're the one who keeps bringing it up, though. Reminds me of a 12 years old who tries to derail the topic with criticizing word usage. Yes, I made a mistake, I mixed up exclusive and inclusive. I've admitted that I meant to use inclusive since the first time you addressed it. I don't know why you're so adamant to keep highlighting it. It doesn't make my entire point any less right.

It shows you're an idiot and I can't take you seriously.

>Proof? At last I got evidence that Mantra explanation was cut short and Rayleigh giving full explanation makes sense due to Roger's visit there.

But, getting cut short can mean so many things. That are not what you said.

>More like, because he wanted to fully expand it with Rayleigh later on.

You're opinion, though

>It's not a retcon when the first explanation wasn't in full.

It wasn't missing anything. What did Haki add to it minus connecting it to other powers?

>Retcons isn't even telling a story. It's changing an established statement. Oda did planning with Mantra explanation and expansion by Rayleigh.


Retcon is a storytelling device you dumbass. Can't even spell either lol.
>>
>>158846398
I want to bully her mentally unstable
>>
>>158846285
He wouldn't cut it off with the characters still wondering if he didn't plan it.
>It's changing details of the plot that are established.
Exactly. What Mantra was wasn't fully established in Skypiea.
>What exactly was cut short?
The origin, and how to use it.
>is the origin
Which was planned to be revealed to be Haki.
>It was full enough
Not when we weren't told how and why it works
>It is bad because it's easier
It's harder because the New World enemies are way strong now.
>Environmental tools are fine, no haki.
Over and over and over again? Wow, so convenient, Luffy will always be in the perfect place with perfect tools in hand. Totally not plot armor.
>Not based on the early story
But early enough before the common usage.
>>158846310
>You just mentioned them, environmental tactics, team works or items
Be specific.
>You went on a whole tirade about plot devices not being bad.
You went on a whole tirade on a power being a plot device.
>>158846670
He cut Mantra explanation short so he could expand on it later on.
>I said it was not planned and Haki's ambiguous nature makes it fit any explanation
It was introduced and then fully explained.
>Zoro hear the breathing
Technique to cut steel. Not Haki.
>there are less set in stones
His enemies also has less limits set in stones now because they also have Haki.
>water a bunch of times
That's not what he meant. Needing to be conveniently placed and presented by tools over and over again is just plot armor. Bad writing.
>>
>>158846557
>Tekkai can't hurt Logia. Tekkai is mainly for defensive.

It can be expanded on as being able to. Nothing stopping it because structurally it's the same.

>I guess practicing Yoga makes you a martial artist now.


Yoga is used in Martial Arts too.

>If it was retcon, the explanation on Mantra would be conclusive.

It was, what was left out about how it works?

>I'm okay. Unlike you.

No, you're not. You're misspelling words and shit and now you say "It's a power up" when you were arguing it wasn't?

>Why would the explanation cut short then? Oh yes, because plans with Rayleigh.

It could be for any number of reasons.

>You can't understand proper punctuation. Haki is a power. While a power up is Gears.

It's a power up because it allows Luffy to do shit he couldn't do.

>Please try to do so.

Try to be wittier too.

>No. To people who pay attention.

I.E. not you.
>>
>>158846761
>He wouldn't cut it off with the characters still wondering if he didn't plan it.

Characters wondering if he didn't plan it? What?

>Exactly. What Mantra was wasn't fully established in Skypiea.

What wasn't fully established about it? It's mechanics were fully explained minus the name bs, Rayleigh just glued it to Haki. Nothing more.

>The origin, and how to use it.

It was described as being innate. The origin doesn't matter because it could have been from anywhere. What's the origin of Shishi sonson? Oda's ass.

>Which was planned to be revealed to be Haki.

Prove it was planned

>Not when we weren't told how and why it works

We were told why it works and why is because it's biological. It could have ended there and it would make no difference.

>It's harder because the New World enemies are way strong now.

Because Oda overpowered them.

>Over and over and over again? Wow, so convenient, Luffy will always be in the perfect place with perfect tools in hand. Totally not plot armor.

He wouldn't fight them over and over. Luffy doesn't have to beat every logia by himself or at all.

>But early enough before the common usage.

Not in skypiea

>Be specific.

I was, referr to what you said.


>You went on a whole tirade on a power being a plot device.

It is, and in this case an abusable one.>>158846761

>>158846761
>It was introduced and then fully explained.
It was already explained fully.

>He cut Mantra explanation short so he could expand on it later on.
No proof on your part.

>Technique to cut steel. Not Haki.

Could be expanded as being haki like mantra was.

>His enemies also has less limits set in stones now because they also have Haki.

Doesn't mean he has more of a disadvantage. In the long run he can win more because the logias biggest threat (Invulnerability) is gone.
>>
>>158846761
That's not what he meant. Needing to be conveniently placed and presented by tools over and over again is just plot armor. Bad writing.

As opposed to using some magic energy out of the blew that requires training and other generic shounen bs?
>>158846557
>No. To people who pay attention.

Pay attention to powerlevels

>>158846557
>Please try to do so.

You don't need to write better to critique something.
>>
>>158846749

He's already a tranny so...
>>
>>158847066
too young to be a trap
>>
>>158846670
>He clearly did...
Make a vague power, and leave it unexplained on purpose then adding more context to it later does not mean it was retconned.
> I said it was not planned and Haki's ambiguous nature makes it fit any explanation as needed
What is ambiguous about Haki's nature? You've yet to give any examples. You've only said "BUT WHAT IF ODA DOES MAKE SOMETHING PREVIOUSLY NOT HAKI INTO HAKI" with shishisonson and mantra. Except Mantra is haki, just a different name, and shishisonson is clearly not haki, because Zoro didn't use shishisonson on Kizaru during Sabaody.
>The rule set isn't definite though. Why can't Zoro hear the breathing of Ice or fire or any substance Oda wants it too? There's nothing hard about extending from one material into another that a logia just happens to occupy.
Zoro "heard the voice of metal" and used that to cut through Mr 1 natural armor (who wasn't a logia). Shishisonson is not haki. It never was haki. Anyone saying it was and is or arguing it is haki is a retard. Why you keep using this as example in your argument of Haki's poorly defined nature just goes to show you have no clue what your talking about.
See >>158846025
where you say
>It is my belief, same as yours that he always had it planned.
You're loosing it pal. I didn't reword it, you're just a retard who can't keep his thoughts straight.
>But, it's abusable more so than DF because there are less set in stone limits. The only thing you have is faith, it doesn't change the nature of the device.
I'd argue Devil Fruits have less set in stone limits than haki. You just fail to comprehend the rules of haki either because you're a shitposter, a speedreader, or a literal retard. Either way I'm done replying to you. I can't make my point any more obvious and you are failing to make yours convincing.
cont.
>>
>>158846746
But it is used in a creative way. Gear 4th.
>Both are powers
Martial arts style isn't power. It's technique.
>So is mutually inclusive and exclusive
Indeed. And I made a mistake by mixing them up, that I admit.
>Show me where I made this typo
Sure. Here you go:
>>158842536
>You're logic
>>158843810
>you're argument

>It shows you're an idiot and I can't take you seriously.
Same goes to you when you type "your" as "you're".
>But, getting cut short can mean so many things.
But it obviously means only one thing in this case. Further explanation coming along.
>You're opinion, though.
It's "your". And it's not an opinon, the evidence is right there with Gan Fall's explanation being cut short.
>It wasn't missing anything
Where the power came from? How to use it?
>Retcon is a storytelling device you dumbass
Which isn't present in One Piece.
>Can't even spell either
Look who's talking.
>lol
[Summer newfag intensifies]
>>158846805
>it's the same
Pray tell, how come they are separately explained in full?
>Yoga is used in Martial Arts too
Indeed. But just practicing the Yoga itself makes you a martial artist?
>It was
It wasn't. Gan Fall himself wasn't sure what the deal was.
>Misspelling words
So are you
>Any number of reasons
Primary reason(only reason, really) being so Rayleigh, who once visited Skypiea, can explain it in full.
>It's a power up
It's not a full state upgrade like Gears. Are Stands and Nens power ups? No, they are just powers. The power up is something else.
>Try to be wittier too
Talking to the mirror again?
>not you
Again with the mirror.
>>158846951
Characters wondering about the deal of Mantra.
>Fully explained
How the power came to be?
>being innate
Same as Haki, then.
>origin of Shishi Sonson
Zoro's on the fly adaptation.
>Prove it was planned
Cut short explanation and then Rayleigh's full infodump.
>We were told
We weren't.
>Oda overpowered them
Hm, so you agree Luffy and co need Haki?
>Not in Skypiea
Yes, common usage was before Skypiea.
>>
>>158846670
>Why would he need water a bunch of times when fighting other logias?
I was using this as an example of Luffy "outsmarting" Crocodile when he had no haki to counter him. Having all the fights relying on some random gimmick to beat the opponent with would be stupid. This is why Haki is needed. Now Luffy (and Oda) don't have to keep coming up with stupid things like coating your hands in water to beat people like Kizaru.
Anyways bye shitposter it's been fun
>>
>>158846951
>>158847156
>I was
No you weren't.
>It is
It's not. It's been foreshadowed.
>explained fully
Except how to use it.
>No proof
Gan Fall would have full explanation if it was a retcon
>Could be expanded
Mantra was never expanded to be Haki. Mantra IS Haki.
>Doesn't mean he has more of a disadvantage
Doesn't mean he have more advantage too, then.
>>158846994
>As opposed to using some magic energy
For consistency and well-established universe-wide power, yes.
>Out of the blew
Out of the blue*, by the way. Oh, and it's not out of the blue, it's been foreshadowed.
>Requires training
Realistic, no? Having to work to earn it.
>Pay attention to powerlevels
To lore and basic storytelling.
>You don't need to write better
But you did say you can write something better.
>>
>>158847126
>Make a vague power, and leave it unexplained on purpose then adding more context to it later does not mean it was retconned.

So, you admitt it's vague and open to interpretation far beyond what it originally does because of that? cool.

>What is ambiguous about Haki's nature? You've yet to give any examples.

IT has not limits, I mean how are hyper observation and anti DF even connected? It's not implicit like rubber and stretching. It's a very random connection.

>You've only said "BUT WHAT IF ODA DOES MAKE SOMETHING PREVIOUSLY NOT HAKI INTO HAKI" with shishisonson and mantra. Except Mantra is haki, just a different name, and shishisonson is clearly not haki, because Zoro didn't use shishisonson on Kizaru during Sabaody.

So, why can't Oda say it was just Shishi haki and change the name like mantra? There's nothing in Haki that would make it inconsistent. Haki after all can create fireballs (Red hawk), armor, and mantra too. It's completely random.

>Zoro "heard the voice of metal" and used that to cut through Mr 1 natural armor (who wasn't a logia). Shishisonson is not haki. It never was haki. Anyone saying it was and is or arguing it is haki is a retard. Why you keep using this as example in your argument of Haki's poorly defined nature just goes to show you have no clue what your talking about.

Never said it was Haki, I said just like Mantra it can be made into being part of Haki because Haki can do so much unrelated things.

>See
>You're loosing it pal. I didn't reword it, you're just a retard who can't keep his thoughts straight.

That was in reference to the retcons. He always had it plan, nice try.
>>
>>158847275
Did you even read past the comma?
>It has no limits
Yeah, Stands also have no limit, do Stands count as bad power now?
>So, why can't Oda say it was just Shishi haki and change the name like mantra?
Because White Sea and Blue Sea have different culture and different sense of naming. Why would Zoro change the name of his technique.
>just like Mantra
Mantra is Haki. The initial explanation was left incomplete for a reason.

So he always planned a retcon? What?
>>
>>158847156
>But it is used in a creative way. Gear 4th.

He just added Haki to rubber, how is that creative?

>I'd argue Devil Fruits have less set in stone limits than haki. You just fail to comprehend the rules of haki either because you're a shitposter, a speedreader, or a literal retard. Either way I'm done replying to you. I can't make my point any more obvious and you are failing to make yours convincing.

Less limits based on what? Devil fruits had a shit ton of rules and weaknesses.

>Martial arts style isn't power. It's technique.

Power as in special abilities, not power as in strength moron.

>Indeed. And I made a mistake by mixing them up, that I admit.

Then you're dumb

>Sure. Here you go:

Honest mistake unlike you.

>Same goes to you when you type "your" as "you're"

Close enough that it's understandable. But, you confused your own position when you said: "It's a power up" when you meant it's not one.

>But it obviously means only one thing in this case. Further explanation coming along.


Why only one? Because you say so?

>It's "your". And it's not an opinon, the evidence is right there with Gan Fall's explanation being cut short.


That's not evidence, it can be for other reasons too.

>Where the power came from? How to use it?


It was innate, they use it by concentrating. Haki added nothing but other powers to it.

>Which isn't present in One Piece.


Only Oda cocksuckers believe this.

>Look who's talking.

Someone who can spell

>[Summer newfag intensifies]


I'm not a regular to this board, left it in 2012. So, I don't care much for the etiquette. But, from where I'm standing with your green text, you're just as annoying.

>Pray tell, how come they are separately explained in full?

Nothing was explained in full. How does Rayleigh saying "That's Haki to" equate to a full explanation?
>>
>Indeed. But just practicing the Yoga itself makes you a martial artist?

No, not that it matters does practicing a martial arts mean you can't use what you learn in martial arts for combat? Or that they can be related, it's called transferable skills tard.>>158847156
>It wasn't. Gan Fall himself wasn't sure what the deal was.


It predicts movements and is described as the ability to hear the voice of living things. Hell, Oda could link Shishi sonson if he wanted to it.

>So are you


You can't even follow your own argument. "It's a power up"

>Primary reason(only reason, really) being so Rayleigh, who once visited Skypiea, can explain it in full.

The explanation wasn't missing anything. Rayleigh didn't add anything.

>It's not a full state upgrade like Gears. Are Stands and Nens power ups? No, they are just powers. The power up is something else.


They are power ups, because they're upgrades relative to what the character had before them.

>Talking to the mirror again?

No, to you.

>Again with the mirror.

Again to you.

>Pray tell, how come they are separately explained in full?


Same with mantra, Oda made them categories for now. But, the difference is superficial.

>Characters wondering about the deal of Mantra.

Which Rayleigh didn't explain. We knew it was innate and Rayleigh just said the same with some extra power shit added to it.

>Same as Haki, then.

Something we knew already.

>Zoro's on the fly adaptation.


Just like Rayleighs.

>Cut short explanation and then Rayleigh's full infodump.

Doesn't prove he planned it before.

>We weren't.

We were.

>Hm, so you agree Luffy and co need Haki?

No.

>Yes, common usage was before Skypiea.


Not even close.
>>
>>158847385
>Did you even read past the comma?

Yep.

>Yeah, Stands also have no limit, do Stands count as bad power now?


Stands have a unique ability per person. Unlike Haki.

>Because White Sea and Blue Sea have different culture and different sense of naming. Why would Zoro change the name of his technique.

It might not be his technique. Someone could have discovered it before him and it's true potential via Haki. All plausible under Haki.

>Mantra is Haki. The initial explanation was left incomplete for a reason.

It's Haki now, and it was left incomplete for a reason unknown.

>So he always planned a retcon? What?

He could've planned something else, but ultimately he decided to retcon it.
>>
>>158847275
Damn I just can't keep myself from this delicious bait.
I admitted Mantra was vague and later expanded upon faggot.
How are rubbery body parts and turning yourself into fire connected? Haki has three distinct branches. Why you struggle understanding this or for some reason not liking it doesn't make any sense. If anything every shounen should piss you off. Do multiple different Nen categories upset you as well?
>So, why can't Oda say it was just Shishi haki and change the name like mantra? There's nothing in Haki that would make it inconsistent.
Because Zoro specifically learned that technique to cut hard metals, not devil fruit users you absolute retard. It wouldn't make any sense if Oda did that because Haki is something that everybody uses, and shishisonson is a technique only zoro uses. There are differences you fail to see. Shishisonson cuts metal. Haki lands hits on Devil Fruit users like smoker. ShiShisonson wouldn't work on kizaru. Haki would. Haki would work on Mr 1 as well. But not the other way around.
>Never said it was Haki, I said just like Mantra it can be made into being part of Haki because Haki can do so much unrelated things
I said haki has a defined rule set, you set it wasn't and brought up shishisonson >>158846670 here. Don't try and gaslight me.
>That was in reference to the retcons. He always had it plan, nice try.
>It is my belief, same as yours that he always had it planned.
I mean that seems like a confession if I've ever seen one.
>Red Hawk
This is a unique power to Luffy with combing his devil fruit with haki. After making his blood pump like crazy and him making his bloodpressure higher it results in steam coming from him and radiating heat. Applying haki ignites the heat into flames.
>>
>>158847160

The irony is Haki is a random gimmick, you're just too stupid to see that. It's gonna open up to more retarded power-ups when Oda is in a corner. Far more than bullshit environmental convenience.
>>
>>158847736
>The irony is Haki is a random gimmick, you're just too stupid to see that. It's gonna open up to more retarded power-ups when Oda is in a corner.
If that should come to, then you will hear me complaining about it.
>Far more than bullshit environmental convenience
>Luffy literally having his own water dropped directly onto him after getting completely dehydrated by Croc is somehow less of a gimmick than a defined powerset.
Kill yourself my man.
>>
>>158847447
>How is that creative?
Increasing elasticity which can make him change the direction of his limbs when stretching
>Power as in special abilities
That's what I was referring to, you moron. Martial arts isn't special abilities, they're techniques.
>Then you're dumb
No, I'm just the bigger man because I own up to my mistakes, unlike you.
>Honest mistake
It's an honest mistake when you do it but not when I do? Oh, child.
>It's a power up
Never said that. Go ahead and link me the post. I'm gonna show you how to notice punctuation.
>Because you say so?
Because basic storytelling and common sense.
>That's not evidence
Show me your evidence, then.
>It was innate
Just like Haki, then. Therefore, it's Haki.
>Oda cocksuckers
Paying attention making me an Oda cocksucker now? Interesting line of thought.
>Someone who can spell
I didn't know "out of the blew" is the correct spelling instead of "out of the blue". And that "you're" is the correct spelling when you want to type "your".
>I'm not a regular to this board, left it in 2012.
That explains why you reek so much of a newfag. No wonder all your posts are cancerous as fuck. That explains it.
>Nothing was explained in full. How does Rayleigh saying "That's Haki to" equate to a full explanation?
It's not "that's Haki too". That IS Haki. Full explanation is in chapter 597.
>>
>>158847727
>I admitted Mantra was vague and later expanded upon faggot.

It was never vague, Haki's relationship and categories being connected are. Nen categories are traditionally the powers of chi in media. Togashi just divided them into classes minus the specialist class where he makes sit up on the fly. Shounen is garbage anyway. So, saying other shounen does it won't prove shit.

>Because Zoro specifically learned that technique to cut hard metals, not devil fruit users you absolute retard. It wouldn't make any sense if Oda did that because Haki is something that everybody uses, and shishisonson is a technique only zoro uses.

He retconned Mantra to being Haki. What's stopping Shishi sonson from being Haki, it doesn't matter if zoro invented it. He can contrive some bs to make it connect now that Haki is on the table.

>I said haki has a defined rule set, you set it wasn't and brought up shishisonso

What is the rule set? All Haki says is these three random powers are connected. How is that defined? Luffy can now do things like shoot fireballs (Red Hawk) and so much stupid shit now.


>I mean that seems like a confession if I've ever seen one.

Follow the argument better then.

>This is a unique power to Luffy with combing his devil fruit with haki. After making his blood pump like crazy and him making his bloodpressure higher it results in steam coming from him and radiating heat. Applying haki ignites the heat into flames.

That's the stupidest explanation as to how luffy can generate fire that I've heard in my life. Especially, an element that is his natural weakness.
>>
>>158847806
>If that should come to, then you will hear me complaining about it.

We both know that's not the case. But, okay.

>Kill yourself my man.


It is, wait till Oda starts pulling Haki level bullshit left and right.
>>
>>158847811
>Increasing elasticity which can make him change the direction of his limbs when stretching

Why does he need Haki to change the trajectory of his limbs? God, that's retarded.

>That's what I was referring to, you moron. Martial arts isn't special abilities, they're techniques.

The techniques can give super human powers. So, the semantics is irrelevant. Luffy's techniques with Haki are similar to the whole spiritual power you supposedly gain from martial arts. Take a hint.

>No, I'm just the bigger man because I own up to my mistakes, unlike you.
>It's an honest mistake when you do it but not when I do? Oh, child.


Fair enough, it's 4chan so I come out straight hostile. It's a bad habit.

Never said that. Go ahead and link me the post. I'm gonna show you how to notice punctuation.

See:>>158845951
>It's a power. Power up is Gear 2nd, 3rd, and 4th.


What did you mean?

>Because basic storytelling and common sense.

Same could be said about retcons.

>Show me your evidence, then.

I already said it could go both ways. Either a retcon or he planned it. But, you're 100% sure it's one way.


>Just like Haki, then. Therefore, it's Haki.

Sorta like Shishi sonson? That's innate.

>v


You're okay with Oda putting an abusable system in a story because you trust him.

>I didn't know "out of the blew" is the correct spelling instead of "out of the blue". And that "you're" is the correct spelling when you want to type "your".


Typo, honest mistake.

>That explains why you reek so much of a newfag. No wonder all your posts are cancerous as fuck. That explains it.

It also explains how I know how to b8 you fags so easily.

>It's not "that's Haki too". That IS Haki. Full explanation is in chapter 597.

Because it became part of it due to a retcon.
>>
>>158847861
>It was never vague, Haki's relationship and categories being connected are. Nen categories are traditionally the powers of chi in media. Togashi just divided them into classes minus the specialist class where he makes sit up on the fly. Shounen is garbage anyway. So, saying other shounen does it won't prove shit.
Mantra was absolutely vague. Haki's relationships with each other isn't vague either. Just because you don't think they belong together, doesn't make it vague. If you hate shounen, then why the fuck are you here? You love shounen considering your knowledge of HxH, you just got baited by OP. Again why do you have a problem with Haki being related, but not devil fruits?
>He retconned Mantra to being Haki. What's stopping Shishi sonson from being Haki, it doesn't matter if zoro invented it. He can contrive some bs to make it connect now that Haki is on the table.
Because mantra and observation haki are the same thing and use the exact same ruleset. He couldn't retcon Shishi sonson into haki, because they are fundamentally different. Zoro didn't use Shishi sonson on Kizaru. It doesn't work like haki. Mantra does work like haki. Because they are the same thing.
>What is the rule set? All Haki says is these three random powers are connected. How is that defined? Luffy can now do things like shoot fireballs (Red Hawk) and so much stupid shit now.
Read the fucking manga or watch the series. It'd take up the entire post to explain it to you. Luffy doesn't shoot fireballs either you fucking retard. If you don't know anything about the series, don't get into arguments about it.
>That's the stupidest explanation as to how luffy can generate fire that I've heard in my life. Especially, an element that is his natural weakness
Sorry to hear that. Gear 2nd is awesome though. Does Sanji spinning on his legs to create friction and then fire also trigger you? If so, maybe you shouldn't be reading shounen series.
Now seriously fuck off.
>>
>>158847631
>skills
So, martial arts? Not power, then. Gotcha.
>It's a power up
It's not a power up. It's just a power
>Wasn't missing anything
How to use it and how it came to be.
>They are power ups
They are being used as techniques just as often as Luffy using his Gomu Gomu no Pistol
>to you
Don't be shy, just admit you're talking to mirror.
>Difference
There are no differences. Mantra IS Haki. Rokushiki is martial arts, though.
>Rayleigh just said the same
Same power confirmed. Mantra = Haki. Thank you for agreeing.
>we knew already
Yes, Mantra is Haki. Thank you for agreeing further.
>Just like Rayleighs
Rayleigh use Haki from experience. After all, he came to Kizaru and stopped his attack with his leg right away.
>Doesn't prove
Explanation would be conclusive if they are different powers.
>We were
We weren't
>No
Too bad to backpedal. You just agreed.
>Not even close
Early enough before Haki became commonplace.
>>158847705
>Yep
Then you should have realized the explanation was left on purpose so Rayleigh could elaborate on it.
>Stands have a unique ability
It still doesn't have limits. And not having limits doesn't make Haki OP.
>It might not be his technique
Now you're just reaching. Cutting steel isn't cutting a devil fruit's power.
>Haki now
It's always been Haki.
>left incomplete for reason unknown
The reason was revealed to be Rayleigh's explanation.
>Could've planned something else
Baseless speculation, oh my. He left it not fully explained, and then elaborated it via Rayleigh. That's all there is to it.
Thread posts: 539
Thread images: 79


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.