A Silent Voice? More like A Silent Flop.

I liked it

Why? It did great in the theaters.

It's over Kyoani is finished

>>157568303
Isn't that pretty good?

Here are the sources, since the OP is too retarded to post them.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-05-23/japan-animation-blu-ray-disc-ranking-may-15-21/.116467
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-05-23/japan-animation-dvd-ranking-may-15-21/.116468

I like the voice actors. The rest is mediocre.

>>157568454
not for a movie

>>157568454
Goodish. Small number for a movie that surpassed Keion in the box office. the Keion movie sold more than 120k over its life on shelves.

Do BD sales even matter for a movie that aired in theaters?

>muh kyoanishop

>>157568303

>25,078 + 5,442

AHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAH

funny how kyoanus fanboys making fun of kizu sales, when kizu bd going to outsell thrice as this

>>157568482
How long was it on the shelves?

>>157568578
Do sales from their shop not count?

>>157569085
Its a sad day when that garbage outsells anything.

>2.3billion gross from cinemas
>I-it flopped guys!!

File: oricon_20120725150357.jpg (18KB, 300x207px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 300x207px

>>157569110
K-On movie sold 140K BD/DVD first week

>>157568578
It's funny that KyoAni fans bring this up as if they are they only studio that is in this position. Oricon doesn't and has never tracked every single store and isn't an accurate full representation of anything. For BD/DVD they track around 23,000 different stores in the country.

>>157569274
More like it's funny that salesfags continue making these threads despite that fact.

>>157569337
The data isn't meaningless but to say it captures everything and because Oricon says X sold Y that is fact is something only someone who knows nothing about how it works would say. It is useful as an indication and is often the best and most accurate and comparable information available but it isn't the final word of god.

>kyoani is finally selling 20K again
Thank you based Yamada.

It's an unfocused, meandering mess. If this were live action it would receive the far harsher criticism the terrible script and mediocre direction deserve, but because it's a Japanese Anime Movie it gets a free pass.

We got more threads made by haters than fans.

>>157569469
Can't wait for her next masterpiece.

Can't relate to people who put so much value into sales.

File: anime industry 2016.jpg (1MB, 4963x3508px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 4963x3508px

>>157569533
Their brains are just a little outdated. But it's still good bait.

File: 1363060459218.jpg (161KB, 584x466px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 584x466px

>>157569493
I'd agree it doesn't have a strong narrative structure, but honestly I don't think every story needs one.

Personally, I'm down with stories that aren't so formulaic with how they resolve issues.

>>157568446
Not worth seeing twice, I believe

>>157569520
Follow that train of thought.

>>157569624
Haters are more vocal because a lot of people come here to get a rise out of people.

>>157569642
Legitimate criticism != hating.
The film has several flaws, some more egregious than others.

>>157569683
>I don't get it
>why no kiss??
Several flaws.

The past 7 years have been overall suckish in terms of films. I think it's starting to improve, though.

>>157569737
Garupan movie restored my faith after watching this.

Why was there blood in Ishida's mom's ears after the Ishida's apologise to Nishimiya's family? Scene is at 20 mins 20 seconds.

>>157568303
But I heard from Kyoanifags it's the best movie in existence.
How?

>>157569683
Threads are made to hate on kyoani, legitimate criticism is absent in these threads, all I'm reading is x show flopped and >sameface.
>>157569624
Some people doesn't like the anime made by Kyoani and are shitting up the board so maybe more people join to make hating on the studio look trendy.

This is "trolling" these days.

They reallt butchered the original manga though, the film was ok

But it changed a shit load

>>157569756
That's what Ishida believes he did when he saw his mother paying Shouko's mom for the lost ear aid things.

>>157569793
I don't understand? Was it real or an allusion?

>>157569193
It's not tracked in those rankings.

>>157569809
Symbolism is easy to recognize because the characters never talk about it.

>>157569773
Kyoanifags are calling it improvement of source material (no one of them did read it, of course)

>>157569842
So how do we "know" Kizu was a flop?

>>157571238
Kizu was made by SHAFT.

File: received_1535567569821045.png (1MB, 1079x1576px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1079x1576px

It was fine

>>157568556
They do considering KnK didn't break even in the box office.

What was Koe no Katachi's budget?

>>157571582
Nice bullshit.

>>157571613
300Australian pounds.

File: 1489435910767.jpg (45KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 400x400px

**1位/**1位 (*27,159 pt) [*,*14予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Special Edition 1) [Blu-ray]
**2位/**2位 ◎ (*12,132 pt) [*,*22予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (4K Ultra HD) [Blu-ray]
**3位/**3位 ○ (*11,936 pt) [*,**4予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa [DVD]
**4位/**4位 (**9,390 pt) [*,*16予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Special Edition 3) [Blu-ray]
**5位/**5位 ◎ (*10,327 pt) [*,*32予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Collector's Edition) [Blu-ray]
**7位/**7位 (*25,974 pt) [*,*30予約] 17/05/17 Koe no Katachi [Blu-ray]
*12位/*12位 (**5,648 pt) [*,**8予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Special Edition) [Blu-ray]
*17位/*18位 ○ (**6,356 pt) [*,**1予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Standard Edition ) [DVD]
*21位/*21位 (**4,366 pt) [*,**3予約] 17/07/26 Kimi no Na wa (Standard Edition ) [Blu-ray]
*29位/*31位 (**5,177 pt) [*,**3予約] 17/05/17 Koe no Katachi (Standard Edition) [Blu-ray]
*32位/*34位 ○ (**6,059 pt) [*,**1予約] 17/05/17 Koe no Katachi [DVD]

>>157571703
KyoAni 4k when

>>157571613
It was made in like 3 months so around 200 million yen maybe.

>>157569766
There are legit criticisms past few threads ago. You just chose to ignore them.

File: 1492564018069.png (174KB, 358x358px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 358x358px

>>157571776
>Shinkai did it first

Really activates my neurons. That man is truly undefeatable.

Maybe kyoani should stop adapting feelsbait

>>157571854
Gundam Thunderbolt was 4k.

>>157571913
Gothicmade too, right?

>>157571804
You can repost them.

>>157569610
>>157569493

They botched the adaptation from the source material. This contributed significantly to its average at best film quality. The live action overlay is a very apt and appropriate lens to tease out just what is wrong with the film outside of its visual medium. You also need to look at it presuming there is no manga out there to fill in all the gaping holes.

Far too many under developed characters being given supporting cast introductions only to be totally abandoned. This is mainly due to whoever adapted the source material wanting to or being instructed to preserve x, y, z, useless character. There were at least 4 supporting characters that should have been cut down to 1. I'm sure we will never know but I wonder how much of that was Yamada's doing and how much of it was her bosses telling her they need all those characters for the marketing material.

The direction was fantastic for an anime series, it was below average as it pertains to film. That said, if this is Yamada's film debut, it was an above average "first attempt" but there were a great many things that could have been structured or cut better. One of the hidden flaws was the timing/pacing of scenes. Everything after the first 20 or so minutes was poorly paced because Yamada doesn't know how to use pacing to convey an emotion. The first 20 minutes was great because that was her "at rest" tempo. The problem is that tempo doesn't fit anywhere else in the film. -this will be lost on most outside of film studies.

>>157572930
Deja vu

I dont care. Sales are the absolute most superficial way to determine the quality of something and usually amounts to how much money was dumped into the ad campaign. There are plenty of things that are great without making huge sales.

I liked KnK and to me thats all that matters.

>>157568303
The manga sucked anyway.

>>157568303
But that's pretty good, not to mention it sold like crazy at the box office.