Would you still like madoka if all of the characters were gender-swapped?

>>153801541
It would be fujobait. Men are intellectually superior and therefore would not sexualize the megucas.

13-15 year old girls and boys are fundamentally different. If they had the same interactions all being boys the show would be unrealistic. If they had different interactions it'd be a different show

>>153802572
It'd make Sayaka more realistic.

Wouldn't it just be Kamen Rider Ryuki at that point?

>>153801541
This is extremely cute and erotic. Kyouko always makes my heartpenis go doki doki.

File: 1317577948482.png (309KB, 790x1011px) Image search: [Google]

309KB, 790x1011px

>>153801541
>all
Nah.

>some
Totally.

>>153801541

One of the main points of the show was magical girls happen because young teenage girls lead the most emotionally volatile lives.

So that whole part of the narrative doesn't work if it was magical boys.

>>153801541
Homura. Greatest Male Yandere of all Time

>>153801541
Yes, it would become my favorite series of all time.

>>153803604
Do they? Someone like Shinji is a lot more volatile than Mami or a younger Kyoko.

I think it was just a plot convenience to stay true to the genre.

>>153803604
>teenage girls lead the most emotionally volatile lives

That's just a stereotype, most boys are whiny bitches too. I would know.

>>153801541
The concept wouldn't make much sense since an adolescent girl is the main target for meguca.
However I'd still be fine with it if it were.

>>153803769
>Mami lost it
>Kills her friends

>Shinji lost it
>Third Impact

It would be different. I'd still watch it for the sake of watching it. It might be good.

>>153803785
As someone who recently graduated high school and entered into adulthood, I can tell you that teenage girls are far more emotionally unstable than teenage men. Men tend to bottle everything up and trudge on like nothing ever happened. Sure when they snap it's a lot more explosive, but women go off the rails far more often.

>>153801541
Some folks will enjoy it for example >>153806233 would love it because now she ride kyokos cock like there was no tomorrow.

>>153806772
That's just an artifact of different acceptable outlets. Bottling everything up doesn't make it disappear, it just makes it private.

>>153806772
>graduated high school and entered into adulthood
No anon, you are the emotional roller coaster

>>153806772
As someone who also fairly recently graduated high school, I can tell you that I don't know shit about how teenage girls really act and if you're here then you probably don't either. I was kind of a bitch back in highschool, but I did hold it in, as you would suspect, although I can't speak for everyone else.

>>153801541
Only if they're Super Sentai.

/y/ KyouSaya could be cute.

>>153801541
I don't like madoka in the first place.

>Girls are more emotional than guys and that's why it has to be girls!

Literally just a plot point to keep magical boys out of the way. Guys are just as emotional as women, they just bottle it up more. Sometimes it passes on and is nothing, other times it destroys them. There's a reason the suicidal rate for men is far above that of women.

>>153805108
Men proven superior once again. Can women recover?

>>153806065
Kyoko's shorts being undone along with Sayaka's obviously worn out index finger seem to imply that she already finished her off earlier

>>153806065
>>153809396
Relax. It is only fanart.

File: ab3.jpg (695KB, 1600x534px) Image search: [Google]

695KB, 1600x534px

Yes and it's been done.

>>153808560
>There's a reason the suicidal rate for men is far above that of women
Women attempt suicide 3 times as much as men, but men successfully die 3 times as much from an attempt.

>>153801541
Yes. Although it would be less popular without cute girls.

>>153803769
>I think it was just a plot convenience to stay true to the genre.
This. Realistically, teenage boys are just as emotionally volatile and hormonal as girls are. Shinji also had his fair share of homosexual subtext, as did the megucas.

>>153809984
Dumb bitches can't do anything right.

>>153809984
Both genders are miserable in their own special way.
>Men have the pressure of being top alpha dog, carrying the weight of society, and not allowed to express feelings
>Women have the pressure of being sex symbols or pure virgins. You lose either way and no matter what you achieve or accomplish otherwise, it all comes down to your looks. Once you're old, no one wants you and your achievements don't matter.

>>153809907

to be honest I feel Blade's characters fit Madoka better, even if the plot was Ryuki's

>>153802572
>the show would be unrealistic
>mahou shoujo and aliens
>realistic

>>153809984
Women like that just want attention; if they actually wanted to die they'd shoot themselves in the head.

File: IMG_6364.jpg (400KB, 1300x844px) Image search: [Google]

400KB, 1300x844px

I would love it. This series is probably the best anime I've ever seen boys or girls alike.

>>153810512
One of the major plot points was that QB and his ilk went after young teen girls because, when they enter puberty, girls become emotionally volitile because of the menstrual cycle and raging hormones. And emotions like that are what power grief seeds.
The show fundementally couldn't work with boys because young teen boys aren't emotional wrecks like their female counterparts.

File: 33.webm (824KB, 853x480px) Image search: [Google]

824KB, 853x480px

>>153812206
>young teen boys aren't emotional wrecks

>>153812206
have you been on any board outside of /a/? lol. this is the wrong website to attempt that one

>>153801541
>boys making contract with devil to be magical girl
That show transforms from bland generic mahou shoujo into something that should've been done already.

File: tmp_10968-Sadamoto_nadia-shinji-832082676.png (116KB, 492x488px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 492x488px

>>153803769
>draw a girl
>call her a boy
Why is this allowed?

>>153812206
>when they enter puberty, girls become emotionally volitile because of the menstrual cycle and raging hormones.
Wait, wasn't this is a Kill la Kill premise?

>>153812716
It had blood yes but not the subject you are thinking of.

>>153812607
>draw a boy
>an actual boy
>claim it's a """girl"""
the real redpill is hard to swallow, but someday this site will get there.

I would give it a try if madoka, homura and mami were swapped to cute boys.

>>153814297
Why those three?

>>153814590
No reason but I don't want boy sakura or filthy heterosexuals in madoka.

>>153814590
Hey Apple. I saw your post in that archived thread in desuarchives. If you dont mind me suggesting. If you want to practice translating why not start on that kyoko doujinshi?

File: 9B9.jpg (752KB, 1666x726px) Image search: [Google]

752KB, 1666x726px

>>153801541
I'd watch it

>>153814297
>it will become sentai
I am okay with this.

>>153801541
Dont you fucking steal my idea. I am the one who will write a manga about mahou shonen trap magica.

>>153816851
You just implied that you haven't done the manga which means you just stole the idea.

>>153801541
Only if they keep the pretty dresses.

File: ocb8uv0mqg1u6qua2o8.jpg (95KB, 640x896px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 640x896px

>>153801541
I would be curious to see it but I think the series is best when the characters are girls. The show focuses on the turbulent time in a girl's life when she is becoming an adult. I do not think this could translate very well if the characters are boys.

>>153814590
Tomorrow is your special day, right?

File: being upset.jpg (100KB, 638x636px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 638x636px

>>153812206
>young teen boys aren't emotional wrecks like their female counterparts.

You cannot be serious.

File: 40278804_p0.png (1MB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1000x1000px

>>153818871
I think it is different though. Boys and girls are affected differently during that time in their life.

>>153818980
They still go through shit.

>>153801541
Gen actually once mentioned that Madoka's story will fit nicely for cantonese speaking 5 boys in some back alleys in hong kong

So how about that Madoka Magica? Will we get anything new?

>>153818677
No. Her special day is April the 8.

We all would have laughed at how much of an edgelord male Homura would have been.
Then lose it at Rebelion
HE IS THE COOLEST GUY

>>153823848
Not really.

>>153809984
It's closer to 8 times as deadly for men. Mainly because IIRC the main suicide method for men is gun, while for women it's OD(I think?).

>>153821979
Huh?

>>153803769
>>153812607
EVA is pretty much gender-swapped versions of mecha character archetypes when you think about it.

>>153823848
He would have pulled it off in a cool manner

About time. In April the 8 Kyoko fucked you for the first time in your sleep and you drenched yourself in your juices. Do all women drench themselves through dreaming? Only ever seen it and in one anime.

>>153826920 for >>153826574

>>153826989
Fuck off Sayaka and or Kevin-kun. Apple-chan is mine!

>>153801541
I didn't watch madoka tho

File: M Manoka and Homura.png (280KB, 720x1000px) Image search: [Google]

280KB, 720x1000px

>>153803353
My man.

>>153827206
I would if I had one. Besides I also have to fight Kyoko for Apple-chan.

File: m Justice Buddies.jpg (113KB, 600x800px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 600x800px

Too many namefags and not enough magical males.

File: Madoka.png (1MB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1200x1200px

>>153827541

>>153827558
I dont care what sword you give so long as they are equally sharp. Once I deal with you you are not Kevin-kun is next followed by Kyoko

File: 1389287136515.jpg (53KB, 700x572px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 700x572px

>>153827702

>>153816032
Do they have to be bishi fujobait? Can't they be manly boys?

File: 1455152853926.jpg (100KB, 736x552px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 736x552px

Got to admit, some of these designs are impressive.
>>153827299
Mandoka with Homura (female) looks amazing and
>>153827652
Sayaka (male) is just has handsome as Sayaka. (female)

>>153801541
It would just be Kamen Rider Ryuki. Which was a damn good show.

File: M Papi.jpg (209KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

209KB, 600x600px

>>153827814
This is as manly as we can go.

>>153827882
Either way I will take on the world for Apple-chan heart. Even if that means destroying everything I own.

Can you two shut the fuck up and post megucas of any gender? Please?

File: M Manoka and Homura.jpg (253KB, 595x600px) Image search: [Google]

253KB, 595x600px

>>153827844
>Mandoka with Homura (female) looks amazing and
Yeah, I really like it this way as well. I used to be able to sperge on why I was so into this but its been a cool minuet.

File: M Kyousaya & Sayakou.jpg (174KB, 850x660px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 850x660px

>>153827989
Well you could practice what you preach and dump some images yourself.

>>153827989
I want to post you.

>>153828043
Got anymore?

>>153801541
No, because the show was already shit.
BUT if we are talking about shotas with dresses fighting against female monsters with big tits then I don't know.

File: Manoka.png (491KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

491KB, 800x600px

>>153828094
I'm about out of male Madokas.

>>153828112
I will go through many if I have to.

File: PMMM Otome.jpg (78KB, 850x448px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 850x448px

Put yourself in Madoka's frilly skirt and who would you chose? Your childhood best friend whose depressed and on the rebound, a hobo who seems a little murderous, your handsome upperclassmen who has a dark secret or the creepy stalker you just met?

>>153828086
>>153828145
I think the Kyouko (Male) I posted was the only one I had. Fuck.

File: M Miki.jpg (139KB, 936x656px) Image search: [Google]

139KB, 936x656px

>>153828145
You could always check pixiv and the booru.

File: Madoka's Otome.jpg (817KB, 1058x1505px) Image search: [Google]

817KB, 1058x1505px

>>153828293
You know I thought there would be more new ones that came out since 2012 but

>>153828468
That is the difference between you and i. I only covet the Apple. You will fall in combat.

>>153828541
Those hairstyles need an improvement. They all look the same except Kyouko.

File: 517.jpg (9KB, 248x233px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 248x233px

>>153812206
That's true, teenage girls are always huge faggots about everything but teenage boys are laying down foundations to becoming the strong, emotionally stable men that bring this world to greater things. As expected of the superior gender, Madoka is basically a flawless tribute to the objective superiority of males, if they were boys there wouldn't even be a plot because the problem would've been solved by episode one. Then take a look at how the girls handled it, it took time warping powers and hundreds of fuck ups just to make the situation slightly less bad without even completely fixing it, and even as goddesses Madoka and Homura are still pathetic pieces of shit that can't fix a damn thing because MUH EMOTIONS. It's actually kind of funny, in a pitifully tragic way.

>>153828863
I can destroy all you covet. If you destroy the only thing I covet it will also hurt you.

>>153828697
Only girls get interesting hairstyles boys only get short or long in shojo.

>>153829062
You covet both nothing and everything. You can still be happy when I demolish all because you will be left with nothing but yourself. Can you yourself hurt the precious Apple-chan? She is only spectating us so destroying her will bring great sadness.

>>153829408
You are willing to kill Apple-chan? Then I must protect her from you at all costs.

>>153829623
Then I shall continue to fight for Apple-chan. I will pull through whatever this plan of yours is.

File: 1427064631280.png (120KB, 486x417px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 486x417px

>>153828887
I can't tell if this post was written by a /pol/tard or a self-hating fujo, I honestly feel like it could be either.

>>153829923
Whatever it is it couldn't have been written by a female, because it's absolutely correct.

>>153801541
I would not.

>>153801541
That's just be BL and shit.