Now that the dust has settled, can we all agree that Mayoiga

>>152800600
AOTY is always Naruto

>>152800600
absolutely, sadly there is no enough PON in this world.

Fuck you f/a/gs, it wasn't that bad.

>>152801139
It really wasn't. It was an average anime that was overhyped to death by everyone.
Okada was a mistake though, without her this show would have had a chance.

Literally nothing happens. It wasn't bad, just dull.

>remembering all that forced OC
yeesh

>>152801139
It wasn't that good either.

>>152802152
Indeed it was just mediocre and forgettable

>>152802327
>forgettable
nah this show had some of the best threads. I still remember almost everybody's names.

>>152802407
I've got a full GB of memes from this show alone

File: 1461204865638.jpg (92KB, 500x377px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 500x377px

OC generator of the year for sure

File: mayoiga koharun juke.webm (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

Mayoiga just missed it by a hair.

>>152802700
I felt so bad for this guy

File: Mio laugh.jpg (23KB, 297x297px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 297x297px

>>152800600
That's a good one.

what I really enjoyed was a whole new generation of anime viewers learning to hate Mari Okada

>>152800600
Terrible writing and directing, no surprise it bombed as hard as it did.

>>152800600
It had so much potential. That huge cast of characters and that creepy setting. The whole Lord of the Flies thing early on. The heavy implication that people were going to start dying rapidly.

We all had our survivor groups picked out and everything.

>>152804281
>We all had our survivor groups picked out and everything.
Will /a/ ever be rused this hard again?

It was good - just not great.

Lion and Lovepon deserve to be in a better show, though.

I still believe it was meant as satire.

File: 1461990879996.png (76KB, 365x680px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 365x680px

Do you remember his name?

File: Mayoiga Bingo Ep 12.png (2MB, 2472x1122px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2472x1122px

>>152804399
>>152804281
I'm still fucking mad

>>152807697
best boy

I am in love with Sasaki-kun.

File: slutness.jpg (60KB, 365x680px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 365x680px

>>152807697
Do I ever

>>152800600
Yes.
Jack carried the show

>>152804281
this.

I'm still mad

File: grimgar-episode-2-screenshot.jpg (169KB, 1769x995px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 1769x995px

grimgar was aoty

>>152807697
Catacomb Assjack

>>152807910
I still have my bingo
I'm so fucking mad, what a waste of a premise

So I'm going to assume this show is only worth watching with /a/? I wished I watched it when it aired then.

>>152809963
Yeah, that's the case. Except it didn't even have the entertainment factor that stuff like Valvrave had.
It was just plain boring and most of the people watching it were exaggerating shit to squeeze some fun out of it. If someone has that one webm please post it.

>>152810053
that webm was made to make fun of the guy who said it though

File: mayoihat.jpg (444KB, 1137x1680px) Image search: [Google]

444KB, 1137x1680px

>>152804281
I'm not even mad about the wasted potential because I had so much fun with making stupid OC and watching /a/ blow the fuck up over this dumb show. If I could do it all again, I would in a heartbeat.

File: 1460784299253.jpg (15KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 1024x576px

>>152809963
The shitposting was the only good thing about this show

File: trainwreck.webm (915KB, 854x480px) Image search: [Google]

915KB, 854x480px

>>152810084
And yet it's perfectly on point with everything that happened.
At least we got Lion out of the show. Such an ultra-qt.

>>152810084
It was at the time, but he turned out to be right after everything was said and done.

File: 1463404505815.png (413KB, 1360x720px) Image search: [Google]

413KB, 1360x720px

At least Mayoiga gave me the first male tsundere I ever saw.

>>152801546
Everyone being wrong was awesome though.

File: 1461958726456.png (142KB, 734x363px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 734x363px

I'm happy that we got dedicated drawfags

File: [HorribleSubs] Mayoiga - 11 [720p].mkv_snapshot_09.22_[2016.06.11_13.59.32].jpg (35KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 1280x720px

>>152810185
More yan than tsun, friend. Hayato was a good boy.

File: 1462047545483.png (244KB, 416x598px) Image search: [Google]

244KB, 416x598px

I want to live my life like Lovepon.
She is my idol.

>>152810264
And the manga doubles down on it.

File: naana.jpg (25KB, 205x367px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 205x367px

>>152810265

>>152810302
He's literally Mitsumune's abusive boyfriend in the manga, it's crazy

File: 1463251068794.png (635KB, 960x1361px) Image search: [Google]

635KB, 960x1361px

>>152810302

File: the-culprit.png (2MB, 1313x969px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1313x969px

Friendly reminder that non of us could figure out the culprit before G.O.D came in to explain.

>>152810575
RANGERS

File: weedman.png (154KB, 244x279px) Image search: [Google]

154KB, 244x279px

>>152802700
>getting cucked all through the series
>uncucked himself at the end

HOW DID HE DO IT?

>>152810756
All the characters saying fuck it and giving up towards the end was so stupid yet funny. It was like a reflection of what was going on in the threads.

Whatever happened to the people of the sekrit club?

>>152810835
They've all entered to Nanakimura where you can make a hasubando/waifu out of your tulpa.

File: 1466391053857.jpg (2MB, 1520x6908px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1520x6908px

This is the last version I have. This show was amazing

>>152810835
They've probably killed themselves.

so who built the town and where did they go?

why was the town hidden in the first place?

LOVE PON

>>152811231
Such questions will never be answered. The village was just a place to contain their subpar drama.

Your enjoyment of this show is heavily dependent on whether you expected it to be serious or not. Anyone with a smidgen of media literacy could immediately tell it was gonna be goofy from episode one, but a lot of retards were expecting Lost or some garbage. It wasn't amazing in the end anyway but the "disappointment" and "wasted potential" crowd really needs to watch more than one show per year.

>>152800780
Moot fuck off we're done with this already.

>>152811415
it was only lighthearted at the start so when it got dark it would have more of an impact

is what people would say when it was airing

fuck off with you 20/20 hindsight review, no one was able to tell what was going to happen

>>152801546
It was subversive of horror/survival tropes. If it had gone full Another people would just have complained that it didn't do anything interesting or new. Sometimes you just can't win.

>>152811000
>We never completed this image
Still makes me sad.

File: 1465017295385.jpg (50KB, 500x737px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 500x737px

The amount of good, memorable shows in 2016 was exactly zero.

File: laughingflipflaps (2).jpg (248KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

248KB, 1920x1080px

>>152800600

nope, not even close

>>152811579
>We never completed this image

exactly

File: image.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>152807697
Yes it was Hyouketsu no Judgeness. I remember because that's my name, Jack.

File: e9z450P.jpg (160KB, 555x565px) Image search: [Google]

160KB, 555x565px

Man, the threads were so fun and comfy. I miss them.

File: My nigga.png (195KB, 637x711px) Image search: [Google]

195KB, 637x711px

>>152812027
This.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6oyVq47AAA8

WHY DID YOU STAY LION YOU LITTLE PIECE OF SHIT

>>152812111
>I see dead people
>Just kidding lmao

Wasted potential. Even the fat detective with her lump of wisdom was better.

>>152810835
It was fun until that dick spammer forced him to add user registration to the site

>>152811579
Eh, who cares nothing matters anyways

>>152812169
>fat
That's not how you spell 'perfect'.

>>152800600
LOL

>>152800600
No, Mike.

>tfw can't find the jack rules of nature on yt anymore
was it deleted?

>>152800600
This is easily one of the worst shows I've ever watched.

It wasn't even 'bad' to the point where it would be remotely entertaining. It was just shit.

File: Cgs7MLPU0AAH-KZ.png (3MB, 1799x1345px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1799x1345px

>>152812456
Speak for yourself, faggot. I had a blast.

File: 1472227996168.jpg (252KB, 800x1120px) Image search: [Google]

252KB, 800x1120px

I bet Jack is a hung beast in bed.

>>152812456
This.
This show was so offensively boring, every single week I was wishing it would give me my time back. There was really nothing about it to like at all.
Also the threads were complete cancer.

File: 1445738265219.gif (134KB, 340x340px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 340x340px

>>152800600
>AOTY
kek

>>152812608
So you actually loved the show and the speculah.

File: Soy Goddess.jpg (98KB, 600x780px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 600x780px

The fujos that though Yamauchi was gay got BTFO so hard I was almost sad for them.

>>152802327
>Mayoiga
>Forgettable
I will never forget this trainwreck.

>>152813114
Not a trainwreck.
>>152810156

>>152800600
No, but its OP was really good. Really wonder why the OP's singer isn't more popular or why her CDs don't sell more.

>>152811415
>a lot of retards were expecting Lost
Probably because it felt like the people who made Mayoiga had just gotten off a Lost binge watch.

For fucks sake, they stole the smoke monster almost entirely.

>>152813199
Are you trying to say that Mayoiga isn't a train wreck because instead of having one major point of derailment, it was just a consistent failure?

>>152813641
Yes. A trainwreck implies that until a certain point in time things were progressing normally, and then suddenly everything goes "off the rails" so to speak.
Mayoiga was bad from start to finish, there was no grand explosion where everything goes to shit or things turn around, in fact such a thing might've helped save it, since the show was plain boring without it.

>>152813724
I think you are mixing trainwreck and jumping the shark. A trainwreck simply implies that it is absolutely fucked in every which way, it doesn't have to be good prior to a certain point.

>>152813724
I'm not sure I subscribe to that definition of a train wreck, but I see what you mean.

>>152813724
>Mayoiga was bad from start to finish
Anon I know you didn't understand it but that's okay.

>>152800600
Mayoiga AOTY? Fuck you f/a/ggots, the only discussion this anime should be in is worst anime of all time.

Mayoiga is a show that has some of the worst writing I've ever seen in any story ever and it seems to be self aware of that fact.

>>152814109
See >>152814053

>>152800600
No, that was Danganronpa 3.

File: 1483599014287.png (1MB, 990x774px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 990x774px

>>152814211
Is this what ironic shitposting is?

>>152814251
That reminds me, I still don't know if V3 spawned any memes.

File: 1482027257388.png (705KB, 1136x640px) Image search: [Google]

705KB, 1136x640px

>>152814127
Jesus anon kill yourself. Criticism of something does not always boil down to a misunderstanding of it. Please, defend this anime.

Protip: it's literally fucking impossible.

30+ characters in a 12 episode season. Disaster. None of the characters act like actual functioning humans. Disaster. MC is as deep as a puddle and as interesting as watching paint dry. Disaster.

File: ride never ends.jpg (284KB, 960x929px) Image search: [Google]

284KB, 960x929px

Mayoiga gave me one of the best /a/ experience I've had

There was 7 weeks of just straight fun theorizing and livewatching with you guys before the story fell off the road. Plus nearly 24 straight hours of threads on the show.

It was a good ride

>>152814349
>only 7 weeks
And that's why DR3 was better.

>>152814334
Are there things it does wrong? Absolutely. I'm in no way trying to say it's completely immune from criticism. But there's one absolutely key thing central to its entire idea premise that it absolutely nails. Mayoiga is above all else a show that aimed to subvert the viewers expectations about the mystery-horror genre. Everything about this show from it's setting, characters and presentation try to, and successfully, trick the viewers into expecting something that it is not and never intended to be.

>>152814469
>trick the viewers into expecting something that it is not and never intended to be.
Exactly, finally someone who gets it.

This show tricks you into thinking it might be something worth watching and then it removes all doubt that it is unwatchable trash.

>>152814469
you sound like someone that would unironically defend School Days

what the fuck was Nettaiya's reason for going to Mayoiga

>>152814700
While I haven't seen it I've heard the spoilers and yeah I probably would.

A show doesn't have to be a masterpiece or even good to have good parts or ideas. SAO is garbage for a lot of reasons but the idea about the blurring of lines between reality and an indistinguishable virtual reality is a top tier concept.

>>152800600
>watch this
>it's shit
>read Deadtube
>it's basically the same
>instead it's good

>>152810575
Rangers!

>>152814700
>disliking school days
Mayoiga is trash but School Days is a masterpiece.

>>152812600
Speaking of hung, wasn't there an anon who theorized and made an entire description of every male character's penis?

File: 1460732021490.png (210KB, 261x466px) Image search: [Google]

210KB, 261x466px

Did anything even break 1k+ replies since Mayoiga, literally every week?

>>152815329
The fujoshits really took a toll on the threads, although that might have been due to people losing interest leaving just them behind to fill the threads.
>>152815347
Week after week? No. I don't think any airing show threads have even broken Mayoiga's 1300+ record last year.

>>152815371
>Mayoiga's 1300+ record

I don't remember this. At what episode was it?

>>152815371
I'm almost sure LWA broke that recently. Our another show this season.

>>152815449
I'm just guessing here but 5/6

>>152815489

LWA was a sticky

>>152815449
Episode 6
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/141152134/#141152134
Episode 7
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/141462709/#141462709

>>152815590
Those were some good times.

>>152815208
>not having the mental capacity to separate liking something from objective criticism
School Days is one of those anime that's so bad it's good. Nothing more.

they tried to horror us in the first 2 eps, try to troll us in ep 3-7, try to joke us in the rest, and become serious in the last episode.
They could have just chosen 1 route. The directing was messed up

>>152815590
>Mayoiga VN never

It's a shame the website anons never got to make that a reality, it was a great project. They also had cool people for the fandub.

>>152800600
No, Keit-Ai was.

File: 1464363745685.jpg (253KB, 960x1361px) Image search: [Google]

253KB, 960x1361px

Should have been OTP

>>152816994
Hellfag was such an angry manlet in the manga, holy shit. But at least he princess-carried Nyanta and was with her in the final chapter, which was better than what the anime did.