[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Goblin Slayer is so last year. This is the current best fantasy

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 557
Thread images: 72

File: 007_1480281486.jpg (474KB, 836x1200px) Image search: [Google]
007_1480281486.jpg
474KB, 836x1200px
Goblin Slayer is so last year.
This is the current best fantasy manga that runs right now.
>>
File: lol.jpg (434KB, 836x1200px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
434KB, 836x1200px
>>150346874
This.
Even MC is better than all other MC out there.
>>
>isekaishit

Pity reply (still saged)
>>
>>150346874
not when konosuba exists
>>
File: laughingwhores.webm (451KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
laughingwhores.webm
451KB, 1280x720px
>>150346874
>serious isekai
>>
File: lol.jpg (483KB, 836x1200px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
483KB, 836x1200px
>>150347151
>konosuba
>even come close
>>
File: 1480266686685.jpg (66KB, 1280x720px)
1480266686685.jpg
66KB, 1280x720px
>>150347248
>isekai
>with mmo shit
It's shit. Your taste is shit. You are shit. You're waifu is shit.
>>
>more isekai tensei crap
FUCK no. I'll take the medieval doomguy any day.
>>
>>150347317
You're saying that like goblin guy isn't absolutely superior to this trash.
>>
>isekai

I'm in.
>>
File: lol.jpg (507KB, 836x1200px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
507KB, 836x1200px
>>150347317
>>150347356
>medieval doomguy
He's nothing against this DEMON.
>>
Jesus christ japan stop with the isekai.
>>
File: 1478392790161.jpg (46KB, 604x376px)
1478392790161.jpg
46KB, 604x376px
>>150347426
>He's nothing against this pathetic self-insert Gary Stu
>>
File: lol.jpg (1MB, 1366x1961px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
1MB, 1366x1961px
>>150347479
>>150347480
Unlike those trash isekai this MC is actually unique.
Also,
>pathetic self-insert Gary Stu
>pathetic
>implying you can even self insert as him
Unlike other trash isekai fantasy, this one is actually badass from get go.
And he's actually 94 years old before, not your average teen.
>>
File: 1350802962453.png (81KB, 281x552px) Image search: [Google]
1350802962453.png
81KB, 281x552px
>>150347651
Did this get licensed by Yen Press or why in the world are you shilling for this shit here like some kind of excited 12-year-old?
>>
>>150347651
>is actually unique

>>150347683
It's just Dungeon Seeker threads all over again, a stealth LN thread.
>>
Surprisingly enough the best written Isekai(character-wise) is Korean in the last few years, Dungeon Defense is really something.
>>
>>150347317
please don't compare that trashy mango to a vidya masterpiece of storytelling like D44M
>>
>>150347763
>Dungeon Defense is really something.
Muh daddy-issues supergenius MC. It's the same kind of wish-fulfillment bullshit most isekaishit are.
>>
>>150347683
There's new chapter out. More people should know about this good gem.
>>
File: 1480442551522.png (200KB, 437x332px) Image search: [Google]
1480442551522.png
200KB, 437x332px
>>150347768
>a lone, extremely proficient, silent, no-bullshit man in concealing armour goes on an eternal quest to exterminate goblins/demons
Now if only goblinguy went berserk at some point and ripped open some goblin skulls, I'd be satisfied.
>>
File: Zetsuen_10_2.jpg (118KB, 1280x720px)
Zetsuen_10_2.jpg
118KB, 1280x720px
>>150347800
Supergenius? Nah, just good at acting and bullshitting.

Pic related.
>>
>>150347800
Why even come into these threads if all you are gonna do is spout buzzword nonsense
>>
Oh man, oh no.
Isekai is my drug, I have zero resistance to it.
The worst part is that they generally take forever to flesh out the story, so it takes years for them to get anywhere.
>>
>>150347863
Mate, he was literally a fucking savant genius as a child, then got the absolute fucking highest genius stats when he got isekai'd into the shit MMO world. It's wish fulfillment to the max, once again.
>>
>>150347768
>imma kill all demons cause my waifu is dead
>better than anything

>>>/v/
>>
>>150347651
>unique
babbys first isekai
>>
>one of the girls is literally named Shion Femme Fatale
>it's her name, not a job or a class
what the fuck am I reading
>>
File: 1480158569569.jpg (32KB, 405x383px)
1480158569569.jpg
32KB, 405x383px
>>150347929
>imma kill all demons cause my waifu is dead
Are you telling me this isn't a valid reason?
>>
we all know this is a bait thread and this manga belong to the trash can of this genre
but truly, look at the comment sections kids love these shit so much It hurt
>>
is this the Dungeon Meshi thread
>>
>>150346874
It's trash
>>
>>150347926
You people seriously needs to get over this setting and archetype obsession like it's only thing that matters, how the fuck do you manage to read anything if they're all the same to you? Do you even read anything or just shitpost like a baby?
Dantalion could as well be the son of a interdimensional goddess and Azathoth, it's irrelevant, his abilities are irrelevant, it's how he's presented is what's people want, fucking execution, it's like saying IBO and LoGH are the same thing because they're both in space.
>>
>>150348015
>>150348053
Fuck off.
>>
It's trash.
isekai shit in NOT proper fantasy.
>>
>>150347986
it wasn't any good writing, it's basic af
>>
>>150346874
>>150347132
Isnt this almost exactly like how konosuba started
>>
>>150348145
Isekai can become proper fantasy.

What is wrong with the Isekai genre is that is filled with copy and paste with only tiny changes, or not fully fleshed out worlds.

Anything can be good including Isekai. It just needs a good writer who isn't in it for cheap bucks.
>>
File: 1458172941691.jpg (96KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1458172941691.jpg
96KB, 1280x720px
>>150348093
>how the fuck do you manage to read anything if they're all the same to you
By not reading shitty otakubait isekai series.
>it's irrelevant, his abilities are irrelevant
Except it's not. He is represented as an isekai'd nerd because that's the audience the author is trying to bait into reading his wish-fulfillment schlock.
>it's how he's presented is what's people want, fucking execution
Yeah, perfect genius, manipulates everyone with his intellect even though he's weaker and uglier than others but he still wins because he is literally a self-insert character.
If you like this bullshit, fine, go ahead. I don't.
>>
File: best.jpg (45KB, 441x640px) Image search: [Google]
best.jpg
45KB, 441x640px
>>150346874
I do want to know why the WN translation was dropped for this series.

Also, best LN is (pic related)
>>
File: lol.jpg (1MB, 1366x1961px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
1MB, 1366x1961px
>All this people jealous since their favorite MC aren't as based as Renya
I'm laughing as we speak.
>>
>>150347970
it's fucking terrible,
the moment he pulls out a fucking MMO system, lel it's not even a game like SOA, you just know it gonna get worse
you see, when it's a legit fantasy world and author have to chock his dick and stain it with a game system. inventory skill with number and shit it's a clear sight of shit writing
>>
>>150348240
>the moment he pulls out a fucking MMO system
Seriously, this is the moment when you really need to drop whatever series you're reading and never look back.
>>
>>150348201
Post 5 fantasy LNs you like.
>>
>>150348276
Konosuba, Spice & Wolf, Kino no Tabi and that's it. I've dropped almost every single other fantasy LN I've read.
>>
shitsekai go to /lit/
>>
>>150347763
The dark gamer with his cynical outlook of life and the passion for blood whoah
>>
>>150348276
he was right, most isekai shit is the same trash, and we rarely see anything remotely out of the norm,
like I did see a lawyer in fantasy world, but it;s pretty shit too,
a nip restaurant in fantasy world, this one is nice
well the problem is much like battle shounen when you have a receipt for general writing, how ever shounen can change the setting around, new mechanic, new world.
but with most iseikai it was the same old jap fantasy stereotype, same kind of plot, same characters etc
>>
>this garbage
>When konosuba and overlord exist
Lol
>>
>>150346874
Goblin Slayer isn't a manga it's a LN adaptation that will absolutely never be finished and was never meant to be anything other than marketing material for the LNs and people are stupid for getting into it.

So is your series. Except since yours is also self insert garbage I'm sure it will get an anime to market it too!
>>
>>150348366
Wow, would you look at that, two waifubait series, one is Isekai.
Only Kino is a good series you got there.

And "I've dropped every single other fantasy LN I've read?"
Is that you pretending you have standards by discarding anything popular?
>>
>>150348478
>popular
Like what? Don't tell me spice wolf and kino is not popular
>>
>>150348478
>calling spice and wolf waifu bait
top kek this faggot and his bait
>>
>>150348478
>i'm a shitsekai lover pls rape my face
I seriously hope you're being irony
>>
File: 1478436384423.png (102KB, 651x541px)
1478436384423.png
102KB, 651x541px
>>150348478
I'm saying I don't really read LNs because the vast majority of them are complete shit. I'd rather spend the time reading an actual novel, with creativity, good writing, good characters and so forth. Or maybe I'd read a manga instead.

>discarding anything popular?
What the fuck are you talking about? S&W and Kino are pretty much the most popular LNs.
>>
>>150346874

>That pic

K-Konosuba?
>>
>>150348549
It is, but then you'd drop everything, but that would make you look silly, so you got pick a few.

The fact is you don't actually enjoy anything.
>>
>>150348478
You think your gook shit is popular?
>>
>>150348478
>applying nip sensibilities on popularity to western audiences
I mean he listed the most popular light novel series in the west then you go and call him hipster?
>>
>>150348588
Ah, aaaah, so that's where you were.
>>
Is this an ln thread? Anyone read that ln about the guy reincarnating as a vending machine in a fantasy setting?
>>
File: 1436443817811.jpg (29KB, 238x241px) Image search: [Google]
1436443817811.jpg
29KB, 238x241px
>another fucking trash
two weren't enough
>>
>>150348694
tell me more then
>>
>>150348588
>I'm too cool for LNs I'd rather read a real book from Brandon Sanderson which is basically Western LNshit but at least it's not Japanese

That's what I hear.
>>
File: 1471663353060.png (2MB, 1214x1109px)
1471663353060.png
2MB, 1214x1109px
>>150348747
>projecting this much
>>
>>150348724
I don't remember the name but he gets carried around by a girl with abnormal strength. He vends drinks, food items, and porn magazines for coin he uses to upgrade.
>>
>>150347763
>dungeon defense
Cut my life into piece this is my last resort
>>
Is this shit the new material for shitposters since Dungeon Seeker never took off?

Anyway

>Good Isekai

Konosuba

>Good Fantasy

Dungeon Meshi

>Alright Fantasy

Goblin Slayer
New Saga

>Guilty Pleasure Isekai

Overlord
Hatakaru

>Garbage

The rest.
>>
>>150348761
Cute, but when you actually delude yourself into thinking all LN is shit but then turn around and read stuff from Garth Nix, Sanderson, Esslemont or Suggs then you just look like a faggot.
>>
Can i isekai my 7?
>>
>>150348821
this,
>>
>>150348821

Forgot to add

>Guilty pleasure Fantasy

Maoyu

>Can't even say I actually enjoy it but I keep reading for some reason Isekai

Shieldbro

And now that I remember

>Lower that trash

Re: Monster
>>
>>150346874
>not YgS
>>
>>150348873
Isekai my 5 instead
>>
>>150347651
Lol
Dropped
>>
File: 1479707592590.png (871KB, 968x720px)
1479707592590.png
871KB, 968x720px
>>150348863
I said I'd rather spend the time reading actual novels, not that I do. Why would you think I use my time in any constructive fashion?
>>
>>150348821
Good Fantasy:

The Girl Who Ate Death.
>>
>>150348950
So you don't read anything at all and still believe you're entitled to an opinion on the subject?
>>
Complaining about wish fulfillment in LNs is use less
It's like reading smut and bitching that there's too many sex scenes
>>
Is there an Isekai without the following parameters?

>Harem
>MC is OP
>MC is Edgy
>MC is a supergenius
>MC is an Otaku

I just want an Isekai where the MC is a normal non-otaku guy living in a fantasy world
>>
>>150348821
Is that for LN manga adaptations only or something?
>>
File: 1479072584422.png (3KB, 147x130px) Image search: [Google]
1479072584422.png
3KB, 147x130px
>>150348998
I don't need to eat bucketloads of it to recognize shit.
>>
>>150348588
>>150348950

>actual novel

"Light novel" is really just a marketing term. There's nothing that distinguishes them from the medium of plain ol' novels.
>>
>2 chapters
Relatively new series?
>>
>>150349063
They're essntially young adult novels and quite often too shit to actually sell enough copies to justify publishing outside of otaku circles.
>>
>>150349021
You can't recognize anything because you don't read anything, what you do is parrot someone else opinion which might actually be valid since he spent time and effort to read it, unlike you who at best can function as a third rate news aggregate site.
It would be better to not say anything at all.
>>
File: BooBoo_v01_234.png (659KB, 1434x2048px) Image search: [Google]
BooBoo_v01_234.png
659KB, 1434x2048px
>>150349011
Sort of, Boo Boo is OP and has super calculation needed to keep his body from tearing itself apart but he's too pure to realize it. He's also native to the isekai world, it's the humans that are coming over (and they can return). It does have game mechanics to an extent, but only for human magic.
>>
>>150347763
>Dungeon Defense

I was really surprised when a bunch of people were praising this on /a/, I thought you had to be over 18 years of age to post here
>>
>>150349011
You're asking for too much senpai
>>
Question regarding LNs

Are there ANY moderately succesful light novels that don't have a cute grill at the forefront of most of if not every volume? I say most of because I do remember the odd Index cover without a girl in it.
>>
File: 1476794549241.jpg (238KB, 1425x2048px)
1476794549241.jpg
238KB, 1425x2048px
>>150349136
>You can't recognize anything because you don't read anything
Except as I think is completely clear, I've read, but not finished many isekai series. I am not repeating anyone's opinions, nor am I going to waste my time reading awful fucking wish fulfillment novels.
Good night.
>>
>>150349154
There are people reading deviantart gook shit on /a/
>>
>>150349154
A lot of people like simple escapist fantasies and they're too lazy or stupid to forge their own worlds in their mind, so they turn to stuff like DD.
>>
File: Rakuin_no_Monshou_v05_002-003.jpg (375KB, 1671x1200px) Image search: [Google]
Rakuin_no_Monshou_v05_002-003.jpg
375KB, 1671x1200px
Speaking of fantasy, what do you think about Rakuin no Monshou?
>>
I'de totally read an Isekai where MC is pic related
>>
>>150349322
About 2 million times better than Eureka Seven.
>>
>>150349246
Pretty rare even for LNs like Heavy Object that focus primarily on guys.
>>
>>150347308
That's RPGshit not MMOshit, moron.
>>
Guys, guys, what in the fuck happened to Vamp!, why did it stop at 5 volumes?
>>
>>150349367

>"N-NANIIIII!? The Maou is staring at that human boy right in the face and he's not even flinching!"
>"Look! They Maou himself looks unsettles by the human's face!"
>"What kind of monster is he!?"
>>
>>150349011
Toaru Ossan no VRMMO Katsudouki

It has the same patterns you hate, only they aren't the main focus.
Also, it isn't exactly an Isekai.
>>
>>150348478
If you had said entry level I would have maybe even had a higher opinion of you, but calling Kino no Tabi "waifubait" is just fucking stupid.
>>
>>150347248
>>150347132
>>150346874
>>150347308
This just sounds like VRMMO Ossan.
>>
File: 000 (6).jpg (244KB, 1045x1536px) Image search: [Google]
000 (6).jpg
244KB, 1045x1536px
>>
>>150349569
Read again.
>>
File: 1262277240847.jpg (20KB, 592x406px)
1262277240847.jpg
20KB, 592x406px
>>150348747
You do realize Nips have genre fiction books that aren't LNs, right? They're just produced at a much slower rate.
>>
I hate it when a LN is trying to preach me something.
I hate it when a LN is trying to teach me something.
I hate it when a LN is trying to get some message across.
I hate it when a LN is trying to morally attune me.
I hate it when a LN is too morally ambiguous.
I hate it when a LN doesn't follow conventional story flow.
I hate it when a LN follows conventional story flow too literally.
I hate it when a LN has a lot of blood and violence.
I hate it when a LN is too sterile.

Case in point I just hate everything and nothing can satisfy me.
>>
>>150349816
Sounds like you need a heavy novel, to the head.
>>
>>150349816
Sounds like you just want middle ground, I can think of a few that still probably fit in that criteria
>>
>>150349874
I got just the thing.
>>
>>150348821
Where does Kumo Desu ga Nani ka fit on this list? Surely it can't be garbage. I refuse to accept that. I guess I should try reading Konosuba since so many people are praising it in this thread for some reason though.
>>
>>150349902
But it has to have a normal MC with normal skills with a normal personality surrounded by normal friends living a normal life.
>>
>>150349322
Oh, I can't remember what volume I was on. Either 5 or 6.

Pretty good.
>>
Is there something out there that's not otome/otakubait wishfullfilment?
>>
>>150350111
No.
Because nobody would actually read it and no chief editor would let it be printed since it's a waste of money.
You're looking for a book, about beautiful, pristine and virgin girls, and you want it to not be wish fulfillment, that's ridiculous.

Every novel has some, the only difference is intensity.
>>
>>150347763
the third volume was more than I could stomach and I had to give up half way. the MC is an edgelord who acts like someone who has the mentality of a 16-year, thinking it's cool to be an edgy sadist. he also copulates with random women for seemingly no reason at all, besides wish fulfillment. I fail to see where the "good writing" come into play, but apparently I dropped before that happened.

>>150347970
>>150348240
I don't get why he had to be an inhabitant of the modern world and THEN die. Why couldn't he just be a normal person from a fantasy series? Only reason I can think of is "muh master kendo skills", just like Kirito, which gives him a massive advantage against anything thrown at him, even multiple seasoned mercenaries despite it being his first real fight.

tldr it's a shameless power fantasy
>>
>>150350111
You must be new here.
>>
>>150350111
I really hate stories that cater to my tastes, I want books that I'm not interested in!

Idiot.
>>
>>150350203
>You're looking for a book

You were right up until this point but then you went on some weird tangent about beautiful pristine virgin girls and how there are no books with virgin women (???).

Have you ever actually read a book?
>>
>>150350283
But those obviously aren't his ... I mean you're ...
>>
>>150347248
Konosuba is objectively better in every single way.
This shit is trying to ride the wave that Konosuba got, and it's failing miserably in everything it tries. It's embarrassing, and cringeworthy.
Be ashamed.
>>
>goblin slayer mentioned
IS THIS THE NEW GOBLIN SLAYER THREAD?????
>>
>>150350334
What specifically makes Konosuba superior to something like Overlord? I'm not trying to be provocative, I'm looking for a genuine answer. Is it the world building? Characters? Explanation/usage of mechanics? Consistency?
>>
>>150350376
It doesn't take itself seriously.
>>
>>150348821
Perfect list, well done anon
>>
>>150350376
Self-effacing
>>
>>150350052
>But it has to have a normal MC with normal skills with a normal personality surrounded by normal friends living a normal life.
You unironically hate fun. That's impressive.
>>
>>150350376
It takes the piss out itself, and is actually hilarious. Overlord is just comfy isekai
>>
>>150350502
But if everything's not normal how can I relate? Everything abnormal is weird and wrong, the bible said so.
>>
>>150350394
>>150350466
>>150350542
Thank you for the sincere answers. I already downloaded volume 1 of Konosuba, but I was curious all the same. I'll be reading it later. I appreciate the responses.
>>
>>150350376
The problem with Overlord is that the comedy and SOL bits are the best, but they are not the main focus.
>>
>>150346874
>isekai
>best fantasy manga
>good at all
Baited/10
>>
>>150350613
If you insist. I liked almost all of the Overlord LN. The volume which focused on Sebas was remarkably dull, the parts with him specifically, but otherwise I enjoyed reading basically all of it.
>>
>>150350111
Yes.
>>
>>150348821
I heard that Konosuba descends more and more into the usual LN wish fulfillment rubbish, but at least it started out okay.
>>
Why don't you all grow up and go read a real book.
>>
>>150350809
Go back to your dead board, /int/.
>>
>>150349944
She spent way too little time as arachne, and I find the current Shiro kind of boring, but I know it's because she's shouldering the world on her back so I bear with it
I wish the author kept her as a spider
>>
>>150348747
What?
>>
>>150350743
No it stays hilarious all the way through. There is some sidestuff to please shipping fags, but it's not really relevant. Its a comedy above all else
>>
>>150350838
That I can completely agree with, I suppose. The first 100-someodd chapters with her as a spider were great. After it starts getting into the bigger world around her the story really starts to wear down.

I still wouldn't consider it garbage though.
>>
As someone who has read over 200 different novels over the last 13 years even before the Isekai boom this thread looks absolutely silly to me.
>>
File: 1476675517788.gif (259KB, 500x354px) Image search: [Google]
1476675517788.gif
259KB, 500x354px
>>150350809
>being this euphoric
wew
>>
>>150350809
>not reading superior Han dynasty cartographic manuals
>>
Is it super hard to get an LN published in Japan with all these isekai repeats coming out in droves?
>>
>>150350920
See, this is the thing with people who read for a long time, they read so much crap that if they start complaining about stuff, it would never end.
Same thing with me but my area of expertise is manga, I've finished over 1800 series and am actively following over 900 of them, good and bad, if I started bitching about stuff I didn't like, it would literally never end, I don't have that much energy.
Thank fuck for that, I'd rather be reading and enjoying myself than telling someone else how I don't like something instead of just forgetting it.
>>
File: 1470972178379.jpg (76KB, 524x710px) Image search: [Google]
1470972178379.jpg
76KB, 524x710px
>>150350052
Go away Kamisato.
>>
>>150350809
I did, I'm not fond of western fantasy "it just works" style of magic that focuses more on the creatures than the magic. I don't care about unicorns and shit.
>>
>>150348747
Well, I do actually recommend Wheel of Time to anybody who wants to spend a few weeks to a few months reading about a fantasy setting with swords and magic and politics and warfare and relationships actually happening/progressing.
>>
>>150351274
If you want an elaborate magic system you do have Wheel of Time and Words of Radiance.

But then again WoT is the clostest thing to LN fantasy as you can possibly get and I wonder why it hasn't been animated yet.
>>
>>150348960
Underrated series, just like The Girl Who Bore the Flame Ring from the same author.
>>
>>150348821

Would GATE be guilty pleasure?
>>
>>150349322
I still can't believe that translations weren't dead and we're finally halfway through the story. Also the afterword of volume 6 was great, with the author's talk about the girls in the series

>“According to this, this time. No, I say ‘this time’, but it should be ‘this time too’, Vileena doesn’t appear, huh?”

>“(Ugh) She doesn’t appear… huh.”

>“Huh.”

>“Although she’s the heroine.”

>“It’s gone on for two books.”

>“That she doesn’t appear, huh.”

>“Since this is the sixth book, the heroine has been absent from a third of the whole series.”

>“Ha ha ha.”

>“This is no laughing matter. This is, in the best of circumstances, a plain story reeking of men. I want to at least refine it into something a bit prettier.”

>“Right.”

>“Can’t you do something about it?”

>“It’s not like I can’t but then it’ll be longer. Because even as it is, it seems kinda…”

>“Long, huh.”

>“Long, yeah.” (I restarted my game with it still on mute.)

>“Does she appear in the next one?”

>“If there is a next one.”
>>
>>150350376
Overlord is just awful garbage. The real question is why anyone would like Overlord at all.
>>
File: 6e9QEXo.jpg (164KB, 777x600px)
6e9QEXo.jpg
164KB, 777x600px
>>150348913
>>Can't even say I actually enjoy it but I keep reading for some reason Isekai
>Shieldbro
You're here forever
>>
Gormenghast, The Black Company, MythAdventures, The First Chronicles of Druss the Legend, The Lies of Locke Lamora, His Dark Materials, Novels of the Malazan Empire.

Anyone? There's a boatload of fantasy for you.
There's also "The Name of the Wind" if you're a faggot enough.
>>
>>150351703
A few more series and you summed up all the western fantasy worth reading.
A few months if you're a fast reader and that stuff is all read, what are you gonna do after that? Watch paint dry?
>>
>>150351674
For skelly man and monster girls I think.
>>
>>150347763
Is Dungeon Defense that stuff where the guy has to "outwit" some brigands in his cave, then pulls over some succubus advisor from a big finance company to his side?

If it's that, then I remember there was exactly one writing-related thing I genuinely liked about it, but it's pretty shitty otherwise. Still, having one thing I liked is better than a majority of isekai stuff I tried reading.
>>
>>150351793
Hit my head on the table really hard in hopes of shaking my brain and forgetting it.
Then read again.
>>
>>150351648
So uh, does the Heroine show up again?
>>
>>150351916
In volume 7.
>>
>>150348913
>for some reason
>>
>an young Japanese male has been thrown into a medieval fantasy RPG world
Why not make a story about a medieval fantasy hero in a medieval fantasy world without all the nonsense?
>>
File: 003_1479269040.jpg (2MB, 1366x1961px)
003_1479269040.jpg
2MB, 1366x1961px
>>150346874
>no memory

Isn't that against the point of this kind of series
>>
>>150351676

It's not like I'm suffering, but it disappointed me that the main party ended up being nothing but little girls and then the ancient advisor was a little girl and the mysterious antagonist is a qt grill and so on.

Next chapter when Shieldbro? At the very least I'm looking forward to the priest getting his shit kicked in
>>
>>150346874
I thought this might be shit but seeing how this man now has become my role model I'll be reading it anyways.

>>150351945
Not really. He's reborn but aware that he is on his second life and retains part of who he was before just no specific memories.
>>
>>150351942
Why not make a medieval fantasy story about a hero who goes around killing people who traveled from another world into his because he hates black hair.
>>
>>150351941
IS it wrong I wanted her to keep that terrified look?

>>150351942
Nips can't self insert. Plus they don't truly know enough about western medieval times.
>>
>>150348821
Good list anon.

>>150349944
>Where does Kumo Desu ga Nani ka fit on this list? Surely it can't be garbage. I refuse to accept that.
Don't ask if you refuse to accept the truth.
>m-muh level up diary

>>150351619
Either as an alright or a guilty pleasure fantasy.
>>
>>150351942
What would a japanese person do in a western medieval fantasy world?
>>
File: 3D Dakimura 05.jpg (135KB, 840x630px)
3D Dakimura 05.jpg
135KB, 840x630px
>>150348771
>I don't remember the name but he gets carried around by a girl with abnormal strength. He vends drinks, food items, and porn magazines for coin he uses to upgrade.

That is the Reincarnated As A Vending Machine story premise. It is being translated by Ensig at:

honyakusite {IQ_TEST} wordpress {IQ_TEST} com


There is a similar story about someone who was reincarnated as a sword. Ahhh, why don't these authors write something more interesting like "Reincarnated As Taylor Swift's Dildo"? Something like that would have a huge number of varied adventures all day long!
>>
>>150352104
Acclimate or die.
Hope he's pretty open minded and reasonable or he's gonna die real fast since he has no modern laws to protect his dumb ass.
>>
>>150351942
Because that would require character development and realistic interactions whereas with isekai you can just get out of everything with "miss harem member number five, here's my cheat ability wwwww".
>>
>>150352092
>M-muh level up diary
What's wrong with this premise though? It starts off basically being a journal/diary of her life since she awoke in the new world, and then gradually moves on to more real time events. Is that your only issue with it?
>>
>>150352104
Be a foreigner who is distrusted and is probably beaten or mugged.

Make money cleaning shit from the streets or other areas of a city. Which was great way to make money back then.

Working on the manor as a foreign butler for shelter and food.
>>
>>150352104
>>150352046
I never said western.
>>
File: 1460267115757.jpg (642KB, 2544x1920px)
1460267115757.jpg
642KB, 2544x1920px
>>150352148
>>150352169
Exactly.

Hence why he needs to be transported from the modern world with OP cheats. No honorabu japanese wants to see a japanese character fumble in a western setting.
>>
File: 1449901103024.jpg (32KB, 304x368px) Image search: [Google]
1449901103024.jpg
32KB, 304x368px
>>150352020
Supposedly there's a hiatus in december but i have something to make up for it. There's a bit more gender variety (male) for villains in the LNs but most of it are going to be women, that cannot be avoided.

>>150352046
Not really You like to bully loli tanukis don't you
>>
Wait /a/, I got it. How about a iseka LN about a pothead surfer dude that rides inside a sick ass wave that turns out to be a portal to another world filled with magic and catgirls and all that crap, and his response to every new little thing is "whoa dude! That's like, super radical!" And now he travels this brand new world acting like the stereotypical cooldude while searching for the mythical medicinal herb "kanabis"

>>150350838

Does she really spend too little time as a spider? Because I've been reading the manga and I'm fuck tired of it going nowhere.
>>
>>150352207
Which one of those two girls is for rape?
>>
>>150352264
Well, it's a rather interesting story to tell you the truth..
>>
>>150352233
>mythical medicinal herb "kanabis"
What with japan's exterme anti-drug culture i'd say it'd be banned. But i'd buy a copy.
>>
Is Grimgar at least a 7/10 as far as Isekai go?
>>
File: 1476625223603.jpg (75KB, 600x535px)
1476625223603.jpg
75KB, 600x535px
>>150352281
indulge me, otherwise I'll just pick one at random, and it'll probably be someones waifu
>>
>>150352330
Wait, you really don't know?
>>
>>150352311
I loved it. I know a lot of people who weren't very fond of it, and said it was boring.
I thought it was great, very pretty and comfy. 8/10 for me
>>
>>150352344
Nope. Haven't watched it at all
>>
>>150352207
Never saw that anime, but that image makes me upset over katana wanking.
>>
>>150352164
It's not a problem with premise, it's a problem with writing. Now, making a good, entertaining story when you only have one sentient character available isn't easy, but even the parts following her former classmates are outright bad, clearly showing the abysmal level of the author's writing skills. And of course there's the stupid ass RPG leveling system allowing the MC start as a spider and end as a deity. I'm starting to think that all those web novel writers would actually get a heart attack if they weren't allowed to use RPG skill trees for their characters' problem solving.
>>
>>150352391
Wow, it was a Kannagi-tier shitstorm.
>>
File: yoki1nd5.png (154KB, 372x391px)
yoki1nd5.png
154KB, 372x391px
>I hate isekai, but trust me, THIS ONE is different, it's actually really good
>it's not different
>>
>>150352330
>>150352391
In the light novel the redhead gets raped, in the manga she gets 'raped' by a eunuch, in the anime I don't know as I couldn't stand watching it. Basically the rape was retconned due to her being a waifu, and people complaining in the most amusing way.
>>
>>150352439
Splendid, she's the hot one anyway.
Is the LN's any good, or should I just start on the manga`?
>>
File: Capture.jpg (166KB, 777x1474px) Image search: [Google]
Capture.jpg
166KB, 777x1474px
>>150346874
>literally hundreds of isekai web novels
>a random one gets a manga every month
>this one is good trust me
>>
>>150352311
>as far as isekai go
so, a better than average shit but still shit in a pile of shit?

Grimgar has an interesting premise but apart from involving death, its character development and drama is on a Pokemon level more or less. Just watch the anime and its pretty backgrounds and don't touch the novel, trust me.
>>
>>150348821
I'd put Dungeon Meshi above Konosuba. The source material is a lot better, even though Konosuba is better in anime form (and a dungeon meshi adaptation probably wouldn't do it justice).

>>150349944
Somewhere between good and guilty pleasure.
>>
>>150350809
Variety is the spice of life famalam.
>>
>>150352463
She isn't the best looking girl either, that's Aria.
>>
>>150348821
Depending on where you draw the line between fantasy and not, Mahoutsukai no Yome is also good fantasy. It's set in modern times but otherwise everything about it is fantastic and it's based primarily in mythology.
>>
>>150352419
It does get more interesting when you get to the deeper stuff, like taboo and the system's inner workings. How it's a crappy interface at best made in magical java just for shits and giggles
>>
>>150348151
>anything in this thread
>good writing
Full retard
>>
>>150349063
They use more kanji.
>>
>>150352505

Isekai and Fantasy are separate on the list, I just put one before the other on a whim.
>>
>>150352463
I have only read the manga, I checked out the LN when I looked things up but I just read the difference there. But the series is bad, I dropped it because I read the manga up to as far as it was translated at the time and just didn't care to read the LN or watch for further updates.
>>
>>150352546
>magical Java

But Java is already magic.
>>
File: 1475445191873.png (59KB, 174x200px)
1475445191873.png
59KB, 174x200px
>>150352496
>those fucking titles

Everything other than skeleton knight sounds like hot garbage.

The first two (which I know) are cold garbage, but still garbage in the grand scheme of things. Why can't we get adaptations of stuff like Warashi of the Intellectual Village instead of Issekai Harem #342 ?
>>
>>150352546
The deeper stuff is pretty awful, especially when it starts talking about souls and energy which just straight up fast talking in the hope that nobody notices that none of it makes sense.
>>
>>150348821
No, let me correct you:
>Good Isekai
None
>Garbage
All of them
>>
I just want an isekai with an actual person as the main character rather than a cardboard cutout. Hell, you can even keep everything else.

Cheat ability? Unrepentantly aims for world domination and has to deal with the massive logistical problems that arise from that.

Harem? He fucks them all and creates an actual harem, complete with kids and wives infighting.

Someone unrelated to him in trouble? He doesn't give a fuck. Orders them executed for wasting his time.

Basically, give me a real person's actions and a real look at what the problems arising from the tropes would be.
>>
>>150352583
More like an alchemy experiment performed by bats.
>>
>>150352618
So basically you want an Isekai where Rance drops into a new world.
>>
File: Zashiki_Bonus_Track.png (496KB, 640x880px) Image search: [Google]
Zashiki_Bonus_Track.png
496KB, 640x880px
>>150352588
We're more like to get Boo Boo first with the Isekai boom. I'm hoping the White Queen and Kyousuke landing top 10 in the kono light novel polls gets Blood Sign an adaptation.
I'm still not giving up hope for a 0-X Office Zashiki Warashi spinoff though, I want more detective.
>>
>>150352618
>wants isekai with actual person as the main character
>goes on to describe ridiculous generic edgelord gary sue #3902482038
>>
>>150352618
edgelord gary stu etcetc
>>
>>150349322
Man in the iron mask + Gladiator + Romeo and Juliet
>>
>>150350376
Overlord doesn't have an overarching plot, it just tries to make every book be fundamentally different within the same framework. Like, there's a novel on being an adventurer, and there's a novel on lizardman sociology, and they're the same world and same overall narrative, and the characters need to do things that sometimes are questionable in order to make that work.

KonoSuba also doesn't have a super big plot, but it doesn't try to, it has the plot elements it needs (mostly character-oriented) and it consistently supplies fun SoL comedy.
>>
>>150352433
Every time
>>
>>150352618
We already that. It's called Gilgamesh or Three Kingdoms.
>>
>>150352618
>actual person
You are describing an edgy psychopath. Go read Re:Monster.
>>
>>150352663
>>150352668
It's interesting how the results of dropping a normal person into an alternate world with a superpower instantly means gary stu.

Henry VIII was a gary stu by /a/'s definition.
>>
>>150351319
>Wheel of Time
>good

Leave this world and never return.
>>
>>150352748
>pulls braid angrily
>>
>>150351274
Malazan Book of the Fallen has a very well thought out magic system. It also doesn't hold your hand though, so it'll take a while to understand what's going on.
>>
>>150352737
>king
>rich
>powerful
>legal harem

Gary stu
>>
>>150348478
>shit talking spice&wolf, konosuba and kino on /a/
the conversation became unsalvageable there

>>150348549
>>150348588
>S&W
>Kino
>popular
literally only on /a/

wuxia is the new big thing in the ln/wn community

the most popular jap lns are shieldbro, mushouko tensei and overlord
anything else like monogatari is only popular because of the anime
>>
>>150352608
Okay yeah i give you the souls thing.
>>
>>150352762
I felt my forehead vein throb
>>
>>150352618
You can't write people if you don't interact with people. These authors quite possibly have no idea how their characters would realistically act facing any given situation in the plot, so they make shit up relying heavily not on real life, but on what they know best - anime tropes. You can't write assertive characters if you don't know any yourself except for your bullies. You can't write romantic relationship if you've never been in one or even seen one up close, and so on.

>Someone unrelated to him in trouble? He doesn't give a fuck. Orders them executed for wasting his time.
I'm sure you'd find a lot of this actually.
>>
>>150352829
>blames men hypocritically
>thinks one of the other two protagonists understands women much better and would know how to deal with this problem
>>
>>150352463
Keep in mind that this is the same anime where we got pic related.
>>
File: 30451933.jpg (142KB, 892x735px) Image search: [Google]
30451933.jpg
142KB, 892x735px
>>150349322
Despite the MC being a gary stu I really like him and the story. It just has many elements that I like: Revenge, strategy, sword & sandal, romantic subplot, secret identity.
>>
>>150352869
The only good thing about Wheel of Time is Mat to be honest.
>>
>>150352891
>romantic subplot

HAHAHA

Where?
>>
File: 030.jpg (465KB, 836x1200px)
030.jpg
465KB, 836x1200px
>>150346874
Times up Goblin Slayer
>>
>>150352907
Mat is fucking amazing though, him bullshitting his way through everything with a full luck build was fantastic, plus dude ends up married to a brown loli waifu
>>
>>150352801
I don't know if it's because of the the translators or not, but the wuxia/xianxia I've read all have way better readability than jap lns. As in, the sentences flow better and the descriptions are more vivid.
>>
>>150350376
Konosuba is a comedy. It just happens that it has an isekai setting, so it fits on the list.

By the way this is the problem - isekai novels' genre is usually just "isekai" because apart from the MC being overpowered there's nothing else to it.
>>
>>150352801
>the most popular jap lns are shieldbro, mushouko tensei and overlord
And there's them Re:Zeros and konosubas that got popular because of the anime too.
>>
File: 1476588474555.jpg (31KB, 372x407px)
1476588474555.jpg
31KB, 372x407px
>>150346874
>Makes thread to promote a manga.
>Doesn't bother to tell us the name.

You're sure doing a good job there buddy.
>>
>>150352866
Like, I would find a lot of this in Isekai or in an actual person in Isekai?

Because, while I have seen it VERY occasionally, the vast vast majority of authors like to have their protagonists to be unambiguously in the moral "right".

Just look at Richard from the Sword of Truth series. Basically a textbook evil character, but the author warps reality so hard to keep him as the "good guy".

If you meant this would happen a lot if you dropped a normal person into an alternate world and gave him a hax superpower, well, yeah. Of course. People kill each other over trivial shit today, when they are infinitely more vulnerable than they would be with legitimate worldhax.
>>
>MC is slightly competent in some field
Gary Stu
>MC is overspecialized in some field and useless elsewhere
Gary Stu
>MC is jack of all trades
Gary Stu
What the hell do you people want? A vegetable?
>>
>>150352496
22 seems like a really fertile premise to do interesting stuff with. I imagine that's not what actually happens, but I like the idea.
>>
>>150352918
Don't deny there isn't one, it's just very slow development. We will eventually get there, we haven't even seen Vileena's reaction to MC's "death" yet.
>>
>>150353004
That's basically Rokujouma.
>>
>>150352994
>Vegetable
>Good against calcium deficiency
Gary Stu.
>>
>>150353004
I'd love to see an anime of 19 even if most people would call it re:monster without being re:monster.
>>
>>150352618
>just want an isekai with an actual person as the main character
Re:Zero does this.

What you've described isn't really how actual people behave, but it would make for a decent isekai anyway, I guess, by isekai standards.
>>
>>150352994

Maybe it would help if a group of girls didn't wet themselves at the first sign of MC's competence EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.
>>
>>150352866
>Some employee unrelated to him in trouble? He doesn't give a fuck. Orders them FIRE for wasting his time.
>I'm sure you'd find a lot of this actually.

That's what I find nowadays. So that MC attitude seems to be appropriate. Because you see similar versions of that behaviour all over current society. And 2017 in the USA will make that even more fashionable I bet.
>>
>>150352994
Vegetables are healthy, clearly Gary Stu.
>>
>>150352985
>Just look at Richard from the Sword of Truth series. Basically a textbook evil character, but the author warps reality so hard to keep him as the "good guy".

God, that pissed me off so much. I can't believe how far that series fell. It started off with Richard having to grapple with the fact that his enemies are all people, who have good points and bad points, flaws and weaknesses, and even the guy who's constantly committing child sacrifice for evil magical powers is doing it because he really thinks he's going to make the world a better place. Then six books later he murders a village full of pacifists because they refuse to help him fight his enemies and the series portrays this as an unambiguously good decision from a moral standpoint and everyone who disagrees is evil. And that's not getting into all of the ridiculous mary sue bullshit he does like making a statue so good that everyone who sees it renounces communism on the spot.
>>
I can't believe people are recommending Nidoume. It's fucking garbage, I wish I didn't waste money on the LN. It's one of those series that gets progressively worse and lazy story wise.
>>
>>150352956
His Brown waifu was the only shitty part. Matt bones hot bitches for a while then settles down with a fucking nig.
>>
>>150352994
Everything is a gary stu. Everything.

Your character isn't a 'real character' unless he is a limbless, mute, blind, mentally retarded hobo on the brink of starvation who has been enduring sexual and emotional abuse his entire life. Also, he can't be good at anything, because only gary stus are good at things.
>>
>>150352872
Not the other guy, but which anime is that? Im still a babby so trying to soak as much as I can
>>
>>150352985
You'll find a lot of disposing people the MC doesn't need in web novels. Look for those that have an element of revenge and where MC has slaves/lovers instead of friends/companions.
>>
File: ReallyNigga.jpg (235KB, 869x1248px)
ReallyNigga.jpg
235KB, 869x1248px
>Look up OP's image
>Find this page
Why is her name "Femme Fatale"

This is quickly approaching the realm of lunacy. How do people like this get published.
>>
>>150353101
>not loving Tuon

Tuon is one of maybe five female characters (along with Min, post-development Moraine, post-development Nynaeve, and Verin) that aren't complete and utter cunts.
>>
>>150348913
I actually like Re: Monster
>>
>>150352748
Only if you give me cheat-skills.
>>
>>150347651
>this MC is actually unique.

Everytime.
>>
Belgariad anime when?
>>
>>150353096
>Then six books later he murders a village full of pacifists because they refuse to help him fight his enemies and the series portrays this as an unambiguously good decision from a moral standpoint and everyone who disagrees is evil.

I could understand to a point if they were getting in the way and there was no other option but killing them because they're not helping is just too much.
>>
>>150352233
>reading the manga
>fuck tired of it going nowhere
There's only 13 chapters out, this series is obviously not for you
And I meant Arachne as in half-spider half-human
>>
>>150353144
Lunacy? Have you ever seen names Kamachi comes up with?
>>
>>150353144
le video game world
>>
>>150353153
You may pick a cheat skill or a goddess. Choose wisely
>>
>>150352588
it only gets worse
>(Um, Sorry) I’ve Been Reincarnated!
>Because There Were 100 Goddesses in Charge of Reincarnation, I Received 100 Cheat Skills
>Skill Taker’s World Domination ~ Building a Slave Harem from Scratch
to name a few, all shit by the way.

>>150353004
WN where the protagonist does everyday stuff instead of going on adventures is practically a sub genre of isekai. cooks, manages a store, raises lolies, etc.
>>
>>150352994
most ln mc's aren't gary stus because they're competent, it's because they never lose or face any real challenges.
>>
>>150353192
They're afraid that if they team up with MC and he loses the bad guy will kill them all, so MC kills them all for being too cowardly to fight for what's right. They don't even fucking defend themselves.

Then again, this is a series where two major villains were a husband-and-wife couple composed of a serial rapist who fucks everything that moves and is also ingenious at manipulating and lying to people through cunning speeches, while the wife is an amoral sociopath obsessed with power and murdering everyone in her way. In case you don't get it, their names are literally fucking anagrams of Bill and Hillary Clinton. Like, holy shit.
>>
>>150353144
Alicia Sloppyjoes,
Stephanie Gorgeouspalace.
>>
>>150353296
Cityslicker still is the best name
>>
>>150353296
Flag Eggnogg
Elizabeth Schozzle
I love Kamachi
>>
>>150353236
>>Because There Were 100 Goddesses in Charge of Reincarnation, I Received 100 Cheat Skills
Would be a good one-shot manga.
>>Skill Taker’s World Domination ~ Building a Slave Harem from Scratch
Could be a good porn game or a book/manga about logistics.
>>
>>150353296
BURNING ALPHA
>>
>>150353296
My name is Seawax.
My parents are proud of me.
>>
File: img000012.png (757KB, 1120x1600px) Image search: [Google]
img000012.png
757KB, 1120x1600px
>>
>isekai with cheat skill: can access 2/4chan at any time and use what he is currently seeing as picture for his post
>constantly asks for advice on what to do in the new world
Would the internet help him or hinder him?
>>
>>150353222
Immortality (both types) przu.

If I lived forever then I wouldn't feel like shit for wasting so much of my life by sleeping 10-16 hours often. Not to mention the ability to slowly and steadily learn and experiment with all types of magic and/or science. I can't imagine a goddess that be worth trading that for.
>>
I started reading OP's manga. It's shit, but it's clean and easy to read, and I like the blonde slut.
>>
>>150353296
From what I recall the nips consider Qwenser's and Heivia's names to be weird but don't mind how silly the others sound.

The language barrier sure is a difficult thing.
>>
>>150353195

Most manga have at least some plot development by the 13th chapter. We still have no idea what is going on besides a girl woke up as a spider inside a cave filled with monsters. It's been 13 chapters of reading about grinding. And while I'm unsure if it's monthly, that might as well be an entire year of nothing happening.
>>
File: img000017.jpg (333KB, 844x1200px)
img000017.jpg
333KB, 844x1200px
This isn't very good but I guess it had an interesting idea
>old general dies on battlefield
>college student killed by Japanese truck crossing the road
>both reincarnate inside a child alongside the original soul
>act as backseat drivers
>>
>>150353455
Hero board exists, and according to that, yes.
>>
>>150353138
Ah, I see what you mean.

The problem with those is that they are cutouts in a completely different way. Almost nobody is that much of a reasonless cockbag, either.

Everyone in this thread, if given a world-class superpower and plopped down in medieval fantasy europe, would become a gigantic insufferable cunt. Killing someone for wasting time is obviously extreme, but it's not an unreasonable extreme if you are stressed out trying to make the world a better place (to your mind) and someone comes to you bitching about how your 4-field crop rotation has destroyed their monopoly on linseed oil, and demands repayment NOW.

The fact is, characters in these are badly written because they are either too holy or too evil. There are no shades of grey. Even if a good character (and this is almost always an anti-hero in the first place) kills someone in a fit of rage or mistakenly, it's a huge traumatic event. What really happens in those situations is the person feels bad but then rationalizes the act, then moves on. Because rationalizing is what humans do.

I want an Isekai character who meets his own needs first, then when he rules the world with his invincible harem and assorted children... actually has to start running the world. And not everything he does is the correct move, and he begins finding out that maaaaybe things are like they are for a fair number of very good reasons.

But that would probably just be a giant fantasy version of Mao's great leap forward, and that would be depressing as shit.
>>
>>150353509
Hero board is used by fellow summoned heroes though.
>>
>>150353495
No, they consider his Japanese names weird but think his western names are normal.
>>
>>150353451
Kinky.
>>
>>150353236

I'm laughing so hard right now.

But I'm also dying inside a little.
>>
>>150353455
there are at 3 WN I know of with this premise, all shit.

if you actually want to find out, just role play some isekai fag on /b/ and see how that turns out.
>>
>>150347132
>le cheat meme
Why do they keep using this term? He's not going into a fucking videogame.
>>
>>150352496
>My house is magic power spot, just by living there i become the strongest in the world

This is genius, i want to read it
>>
>>150352994
Having any of these without blowing it out of proportion would be a good start. The problem is the authors never seem content to have a guy who is

a) only the third best swordsman in his town (slightly competent)
b) only a talented weaponsmith who might get well known in his country within next 20 years (overspecialized in some field) but has communication problems and needs an assistant to perform basic client handling (useless elsewhere)
c) only a rather average guy who nevertheless learns new things pretty fast (jack of all trades)

Nope, no way sir, you absolutely need

a) a magical warrior capable of taking on lesser gods after a few volumes of eating proper flesh and spending skill points correctly
b) a unprecedented genius improving technologies thousands of years old and developing new ones so mind breaking that nobody even thought about them before while being a bit shy and having attractive women throwing themselves at him nonetheless
c) an unprecedented genius who needs a week to master things his teachers took years if not decades to learn

I just want a human being that is within the 99% of the norm. Fuck, it doesn't even have to be a human being, just let it be within the norm.
>>
>>150353236
>>Because There Were 100 Goddesses in Charge of Reincarnation, I Received 100 Cheat Skills
for what purpose
>>
>>150353630
Maybe they were wasted.
>>
>>150347651
Why is he using a bamboo sword instead of glorious katana?
>>
>>150353106
Stop rehashing your defense of Kirito as not being a gary stu. That very same argument you use was repeatedly used over and over in those past SAO threads. The fanboys and fangirls would not accept that their favorite chars were mary sue type chars.
>>
>>150353630
For shits and giggles. If I were a god I would do it too just to see what happens
>>
>>150353630
Kind of sounds like that one short in Simple Survey only with isekai and reincarnation added onto it.
>>
>>150353702
Kirito is without doubt a gary stu. Sword art is shit and should never have been published.

But that doesn't change the fact that people here over-use the term 'gary stu' and misapply it constantly.
>>
What are some isekais in which the protagonist spends the whole time sperging over the magic system and how to minmax it?
>>
>>150353567
It's a metaphor that's so established it's no longer a metaphor. I can't think of an English example but there's bound to be one.
>>
>>150352496
22 and 23 don't sound like isekai on the face of it
>>
How about a Isekai about a guy living a real shitty unfortunate life moving to another world where he lives an even shittier life but over an entire life of blood, sweat, tears and tax evasion manages to build a house and get a pleasant, kind but slightly poor family ?
>>
>>150353619
>>150353004
This is Polish so not the same, but Stick in the Mud is similar. A guy starts a bar on top of a portal to hell, which allows him access to magic.
>>
>>150353782
kumo?
>>
>>150353690
the angels forbade a sword or something
just read it yourself, 2 translated chapters
for searching use the 3rd page of this manga posted here
>>
>>150353782
Boo Boo, but it takes place after Beatrice has already done that with purely fire magic.
>Using laser cooling on a mass scale
>>
>>150353814
Not enough explosions to be interesting, what fun is Isekai without "Grand Cataclysm Call: Sky Rending Inferno Supernova" ?
>>
>>150353809
23 is isekai. Some dude gets truck'd and his consciousness awakens in the body of a baby after an unfortunate accident, where an old magician find him and adopts him. He learns a lot of stuff from his adoptive grandfather's friends who are actually very important people. But his grandpa never teached him common sense.
>>
>>150353825
How is this comedy webcomic placed in the real world with some demons thrown in an isekai light novel again?
>>
So new Tanaka chapters when?
>>
>>150353919
>we can only talk about the thread's original topic
How is any of this related to OP's shit taste?
>>
>>150353630
>>150353619
>>150353558
>>150353360
you guys are getting too exited, I'm just skimming some of the blatant ones from the ranking list.
the isekai rabbit hole goes pretty deep

>Isekai Yururi Kikou ~Raising Children While Being an Adventurer~
>In a Different World with a Smartphone
>Parallel World Pharmacy
>The Reincarnated Vampire Wants an Afternoon Nap
>I Reincarnated Into a Vending Machine
>Cook of the Mercenary Corp
>I’m OP, but I Began an Inn
>The Ability to Make Town!? ~Let’s Make a Japanese Town in Different World~
>It Seems Like I Got Reincarnated Into The World of a Yandere Otome Game

I'm skipping over all the repetitive titles as well.
>>
>>150353752
>But that doesn't change the fact that people here over-use the term 'gary stu' and misapply it constantly.

Some of those people are deliberately misusing the term here in order to wreck the use of "mary sue" altogether. That's their reverse psychology method of defending gary stu characters. If they can wreck the term by overdosing its misuse, then no one will use it. They tried that tactic in the SAO days too.
>>
>>150353972
>>I Reincarnated Into a Vending Machine
That probably isn't very different from being a mimic
>>
>29 chapters of Ze Tian Ji to be translated

Nice.
>>
Let us pray to God for giving us the best comedy fantasy along with Konosuba in the last 5 years.
>>
>>150353945
Translator is slow as shit
Full chapter maybe in a half year or so

Can an /a/non take it over? Tanaka is god tier
>>
>>150354010
Blake-sama is a fighting GOD
>>
>>150354010
I like to call blake the eternal pokerface. His expression almost never changes
>>
>Other World Dining Hall is getting an anime
>LN translations are dead

Why?
>>
>>150353803
The closest you'll get in English is some nebulous concept of The Chosen One, because English YA fiction hasn't quite yet degraded into "the world works just like a videogame" stories being an established set of tropes.
>>
>>150353144
I though that was title or job description rather than name.
>>
>>150354103
>English YA fiction hasn't quite yet degraded into "the world works just like a videogame" stories being an established set of tropes.
ETA until that happens?
>>
>>150349011
I want an Isekai that's all of that except for the first and last parameter.
>>
>lolposter attacks again
At least /a/nons mostly ignored his baits and managed to change OP topic.

I always thought isekai genre is but a form to encourage useless NEET otakus to end themselves hoping to reincarnate into a fantasy world.
>>
>>150354103
>>150354139
It already happened in Russian fiction so it shouldn't take too long until it happens in english too.
>>
File: Helck.png (377KB, 1920x1361px) Image search: [Google]
Helck.png
377KB, 1920x1361px
Helck is an excellent fantasy manga currently running. Yuusha ga Shinda! is also pretty fun.

Stop reading Isekai, shit rots your brains out faster than acid.
>>
>>150354168
Some other anon posted that they liked it because it grounds people back to reality for those who hate them, or something like that.
>>
>>150354003
>That probably isn't very different from being a mimic
Except that the author resisted gary stu'ing the vending machine for the longest time. It's still pretty much a vending machine with a few tricks up its sleeve, errr, coin chute.

At least the story is an interesting "new idea" approach although it does still suffer from some "MMO" ailments like having some sort of stat management overlord computer exist and break the 4th wall constantly.

I consider those MMO type stories to be silly since the use of the computer to manage inventory, leveling, and stats is very much breaking the 4th wall. But the author builds that 4th wall necessity into the story.
>>
Is there a Isekai game?
>>
>>150354235
I think it's the opposite. Escapism in it's purest form, no wonder why isekai is so popular among the nip otakus.
>>
>>150348821
What about Drifters?

>still waiting for updates
>>
File: marche.jpg (63KB, 542x248px)
marche.jpg
63KB, 542x248px
>>150354295
>>150354339
>>
>>150354168
>>150354339
Pretty sure the moeshit you watch is escapism too
>>
>>150354424
I would love to see Marche go into every Isekai story, punch their lights out, and bring them back into reality.
>>
>>150354424
Fuck you with a rake Marche, you didn't even question if the world might actually be real.
>>
>>150352994
They want someone who's completely useless like Natsuki Subaru so they can bitch and moan about him for not being a Gary Stu.
>>
>>150354473
Touma please, you don't even punch people anymore even if every other form of violence has become acceptable to you.
>>
>>150354478
I think the world traitors are even worse. His entire guild knowingly helps destroy the anchors keeping their world together.
>>
>>150354478
Why would it be real?
>>
File: i246661.jpg (18KB, 245x350px) Image search: [Google]
i246661.jpg
18KB, 245x350px
as far as isekai go 'release that witch' is surprisingly good

>mechanical engineer reincarnated into ruler of a frontier town
>no OP ability, never enters combat
>plot revolves around building a foothold with technilogical and social reform
>>
>>150348821
>Amazing Fantasy

Guin Saga
>>
>>150354529
True but Marche has the more punchable face/hateable name.
>>150354549
It's not if it is real or not, it's that he doesn't even question for a moment that this clearly magical event might have actually done something that wasn't just an illusion. Then he takes other things at face value, like how to destroy the world. Complete and utter lack of critical thinking going on.
>>
>>150354529
>G-guys we need to help kupo MC return to his world.
>Ok!
>B-ut by doing so, our kupo world will be destroyed.
>Roger! Let's do this shit!
>>
Transported to another world is one of the oldest fantasy genres though, it goes back to at least The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe and arguably Dante's Inferno and Gulliver's Travels as well. It allows a more explicit juxtaposition between reality and the fantasy world you're trying to create, and an easy justification for exposition. Even the self-insert people complain about comes from it being easier to relate to someone from our world than a fantasy one, especially if it's more than just a world of humans with magic powers and might be a world of creatures with an almost entirely different set of values and thought processes. But at it's heart it's just a slight variation of main character is pushed into a setting that is unfamiliar to him, which is one of the most common premises over all genres. Isekai is currently a fad, so the most unimaginative authors flock to it, but there's nothing inherently about being taken to another world that makes it worse than any other genre.
>>
>>150353144
>dont act tsun tsun
kek
>>
>>150354183
This, Helck is fantastic. I picked it up on a whim and have yet to regret it.
>>
>>150354660
I gotta play this shit
>>
>>150354560
Are Chinese novels the new thing
>>
>>150354660
The world you originate from is the real one. No matter what happens, if you get isekai the world you go to is not your own and therefore fake.

Meaning you can do whatever you want because you do not originate from that world, and nobody in that world can be real because they didn't come from your world/universe.

tl:dr if it didn't exist in your world, its fake and you can do whatever you want. Murder, rape, steal, etc. Who care its a fake world you will never hear about in your world because it doesn't exist.
>>
>>150354880
Isekai immigrants are the fucking worst.

Report illegal isekaiees.
>>
>>150354560
Eeeh
>>
>>150354874
I've tried a few others after catching up on that one. haven't found anything else worthwhile so far.

they don't feel that different from jap or korean novels though, hard to tell them apart other than the names.but most are equally shit.
>>
>>150355010
Wasn't this a movie?
>>
>>150354874
Chinese webnovel is a diffeent set of copy paste shit. You might find it fresh if you read just 1 or 2.
>>
>>150354987
Isekai about building walls to keep out illegal immigrants when?
>>
>>150355010
>Isekai was created by an american
Japan needs to stop sucking white piggu dikku
>>
Spook apprentice anime when?
>>
>>150347132
how the fuck he is better than kazuma?
>>
>>150355052
They keep cultivating, popping pills, and slaughtering the arrogant stuck-ups who both wronged and underestimated them!

But I can't stop reading. Every one of them has a different system for their cultivation and daos that I enjoy analyzing.
>>
>Chinese webnovels

Does Sun Knight count? I'm not sure if the main story was ever a WN though.

>>150355167
Didn't the MC get NTR'd at the very end?


I'd rather have a Tapestry anime.
>>
>>150353296
BULK HARDCHEESE
>>
>>150354560
What the fuck she looks like the witch from Dragon's Crown.
>>
File: 1455262520274.png (167KB, 348x342px)
1455262520274.png
167KB, 348x342px
>>150355268
Why are you posting random words?
>>
>>150355311
it's the cover image from NU, don't think the actual novel has any of it's own art.
>>
File: spacemutiny3[1].jpg (60KB, 652x500px) Image search: [Google]
spacemutiny3[1].jpg
60KB, 652x500px
>>150355324
reasons

I sorta got swept up in the moment.
>>
>>150354010
Could this guy win agains king?
>>
>>150349011
Well kazuma is an otaku but rarely behaves like this, is more a asshole but is that what makes him a good MC
>>
So which isekai stuff is actually good?
>>
>unironically ripping off konosuba
There are levels of irony we have yet to comprehend
>>
>>150355533
Are there any normal-tier people in isekai novels? or more normalfag than other otaku perhaps? i can only think of Naofumi and Subaru
>>
>>150355187
>different system
It's all the same shit with different name, they just learn how to manipulate basic element then the law of universe and then the universe itself.
>>
>>150347651
You seem so intent on making everyone hate this, but reverse psychology won't work on me, I'm the most contrarion person on this board and I'll make it my personal goal to pick up this series even against your deepest wishes, hah
>>
>>150355373
That's the cover art for the WN, China doesn't give any fucks, there's a Shokugeki no Souma isekai self insert fanfiction on qidian getting translated now.
>>
>>150347763
When he gave that fucking 4 page speech about authority I was literally crying. Never in all my days have I seen something try so damn hard.
>>
>>150355640
There's that one I can't really remember the name, but he's the eldest of a group of isekaiees.

The story takes place after the demonlord is defeated, MC is generally weak, but gets more powerful depending on certain circumstances of the fight(fighting against demonlords, fighting to protect someone, etc.)
>>
Who gets raped in this one?
>>
>>150355608
Re:Monster
>>
>>150355640
Saito Hiraga from Zero no Tsukaima
>>
>>150351319
Don't fall for this bait.
1-3 are shit
4-6 are okay
7-12 are utterly fucking shit
13&14 are okay

As far as Sanderson goes, mistborn and way of Kings are both great.
>>
I wish there were more timeloop stories like All You Need Is Kill or Mother of Learning getting translated.
>>
>>150352775
If you want to read malazan just start on book two and completely forget about the first one.
>>
>>150355608
>>150354560 is the only one I'm enjoying at the moment, but i doubt it's going to last
all isekai eventually turn into shit. serialization doesn't really work for novels, it barley works for manga.
>>
>>150356077
Oh yeah ZnT is isekai
>>
>>150353067
>Re: Zero
>an actual person
Just because he makes a very sad face and makes stupid decisions doesn't give him depth.
>>
>MC has law degree and dabbled in business.
>Get isekai'd for some reason into 18th mid-century fantasy world.
>Ends up on the manor of some cute noble beast girl.
>MC becomes her personal lawyer managing her affairs while a mix of American-French revolution happens in the country's capital and coastal cities wanting to establish a meritocracy by rich merchants.
>Comfy discussion of law, politics, economics of the 18th century, how to run fiefdoms for a monarch, and employing people to clear several miles of land for pay.
>Comfy slice of life stuff happens as MC does his job handling the affairs of cute beast noble, and ponders if he should get her involved in the revolution to protect her assists and status.

Nips have all this room for stuff, but always write the same powerlevel shit.
>>
>>150356277
Holy shit that sounds so boring kill yourself.
>>
>>150356277
You can't just add the word comfy to things to make it sound appealing.
>>
>>150355700
? I don't mind. That's what I want to be honest.
It's just that my thread literally turned into isekai LN thread, what the fuck people?
>>
>>150356312
Fuck this guy I'd read it
>>
>>150356312
dumb otaku
>>
File: od6N578kday4pYeg[1].jpg (193KB, 792x1140px) Image search: [Google]
od6N578kday4pYeg[1].jpg
193KB, 792x1140px
Ayyy why are gobbos always the bad guys?

#GOBBOLIVESMATTER
>>
>>150356277
>Comfy discussion of law, politics, economics of the 18th century, how to run fiefdoms for a monarch, and employing people to clear several miles of land for pay.
>Comfy slice of life stuff happens as MC does his job handling the affairs of cute beast noble, and ponders if he should get her involved in the revolution to protect her assists and status.
>comfy
Either everyone goes retarded against MC, or the author can't portrayed real law, politics, and economics of the 18th century right, and just goes all over the place with his retarded logic.

Loophole will be everywhere.
So yeah, comfy as shit.
>>
>>150356872
>Either everyone goes retarded against MC
>Can't portray real law, politics, and economics of the 18th century right, and just goes all over the place.
What makes you think everyone will go retarded against the MC or an author can't write about law, politics, and economics of the 18th century?
>>
File: ElBJkx7zDV9vAD6z[1].jpg (363KB, 1588x1140px) Image search: [Google]
ElBJkx7zDV9vAD6z[1].jpg
363KB, 1588x1140px
As someone who just read ahead to chapter 6, I can confirm there is absolutely nothing worth reading for nor is there a single redeeming point to this 'manga'.
>>
>>150357029
>LN
>good writing
Pick
>>
>>150356277
"Comfy discussion" sounds more like a self-wank over your analysis of your own world, you'd have to be careful with it. Otherwise, nice idea.

>>150356312
end your existence
>>
>>150357029
Because law, politics, and economics isn't something you can just make it up easily, especially in a fucking 18th century.

You need a fucking experts and not just an experts, several experts to actually makes it consistent.
And the author needs to have a complete (not fresh graduate) a fucking COMPLETE knowledge of LAW, POLITICS, AND ECONOMICS OF 18th FUCKING CENTURY.

You think people like that would just abandon his career and goes to write LN?
Fucking think man, holy shit.
>>
>>150357080
I pick good L, surely it stands for good lay right? right?
>>
>>150357138
Actually you don't need to be that meticulous, you only need to be good enough for your target audience. This is why science fiction novels often have very detailed worldbuilding and theories because that's one of the main appeals of science fiction. On the other hand isekai doesn't fucking care because it's all jRPG leveling up with generic racial kingdoms anyway. I imagine a mixture of fantasy and historical novel would be somewhere in between - make it sound plausible, but don't go into every miniscule detail, just enough to make it all work together.
>>
>>150348478
Oh man this guy sure manage to get on /a/'s collective nerve. Impressive, good going guy.
>>
>>150356856
>Ayyy why are gobbos always the bad guys?
>#GOBBOLIVESMATTER

The MC is definitely racist. So that anime panders to racists. It only substitutes a different noun "goblins".
>>
>>150353144

Yet you guys are fine with Indexs stupid ass names? Come on now
>>
>>150356277
>Comfy discussion

For isekai anime and isekai manga, the word "Comfy" means careless ignorance of details and a superficial treatment of technicalities.
>>
> People actually think Konosuba is good.
It's a stupid parody series that does not go beyond a parody. All you need to know that it is a bunch of idiots fucking around and still continue to fuck around while the fanbase think that sort of context is good. Around the first few times, you get a few laughs but if you look at context carefully, it is bad. The moment you speak shit about this series, the fans will shit all over you saying that comedy is subjective or "it's like your opinion man!" Or the worst excuse given "no fun". I'll tell you this, people don't get critical when they don't have fun, people get critical when they no longer have fun. The characters are literal jokes and should not be considered good characters when they are jokes themselves and not making jokes. Later on, not much happens other than having romantic interests and cockblocking. Still fucking around and people call this good. If you call the new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around and because series are comedies so it's good, then you people are fucking retarded.
>>
>>150356277

There is already one thats JAP LAW BOOKS ARE BEST AND FAIR isekai manga. Its total trash.
>>
Op is probably scared goblin

ANNIHILATE ALL GOBLINS
>>
>>150357261
>I imagine a mixture of fantasy and historical novel would be somewhere in between - make it sound plausible, but don't go into every miniscule detail, just enough to make it all work together.
Eh that wouldn't be comfy at all. It sound just more of an excuse so that the situation bends easily the way the author wants. And not in natural make-sense kind of way, but more of an asspull.

Not comfy at all.
>>
>>150357460
What have they done to you? Leave them alone you fucking racist.
>>
>>150357261
>Actually you don't need to be that meticulous, you only need to be good enough for your target audience.

Meticulous doesn't work for the wish fulfillment audience. That type of audience needs deliberately careless treatment of facts and technicalities. Otherwise the wish fulfillment cannot occur due to too much reality.
>>
>>150357138
When you're dealing with humanities even if you're an expert there will be people who disagree with you, so there's also the matter that it may end up looking pedantic and strawmanny to other viewpoints.
>>
>>150346874
>isekai garbage
Remove this shit from /a/. Thank you.
>>
>>150357537
KILL THIS POSTER

GOBLIN RACE EXTINCT STATUS WHEN
>>
File: 1401986072531.png (381KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1401986072531.png
381KB, 1280x720px
Mushoku Tensei was the only good isekai.

Has the continuation come out already by the way? I have a bad feeling about, it will probably suck.
>>
>>150357351
I don't read the Index LNs you dumb faggot
>>
>>150357392
>a bunch of idiots fucking around and still continue to fuck around
Looks fun.
>>
>>150357719
I personally liked Grimgar a lot but that was apparently an opinion that almost nobody else shared.
>>
>>150357719
MT is trash. The MT epilogue extras already show how much of a hack the author is and how shallow and fragile his ego is.

It was hilarious how the author was trying to justify incestual rape and then deleting the chapter by claiming he was censored even though other works on the same site were ten times worst and didn't have any sort of censorship at the time.
>>
>>150357392
>comedy is bad when it doesn't appeal to my sophisticated sense of humour
>>
>>150346874
Kuro no Maou is better than Goblin Slayer.

The antagonists are better though.

Literally the Japanese version of the Crusades: Humans (Christians) versus Demihumans (Muslims).

The magic chants are even in Arabic.

Kuro no Maou is also an older web novel than MT.
>>
>>150357920
MT wasn't great all the time, but it is overall good.
I didn't like the later arcs all that much which is why i haven't read most of the extras but incestual rape what?
>>
>>150357449
But anon, everything Japanese is sugooiiiii. The TV said so!

Fuck the Japanese.
>>
How do you guys do it?

I can barely finish any real novels in English because the writing is so subpar, how can you stand reading more than 2 words of these awful LN translations? Even the worst of the worst books I drop at least make sense in English and use grammar and have decent prose.

And this is all ignoring the fact that LNs are likely hot garbage in their native language as well.

So how do guys fucking stand reading this trash?
>>
>>150358042
MC's 10 year old son impregnated MC's 20 year old sister.
>>
>>150358103
These people watch unironically watch anime, anon. That should explain all that needs be.
>>
I thought they stopped Overlord or something?
Read through WN's to vol.9 where it cuts off for me,are there more out? How can I read it?
>>
>>150346874
>>150347132
I didn't know Konosuba had a reboot.
>>
>>150357924
> Straw-manning me
As expected from a Konosubafag. You disgust me. Sorry if the truth hurts (I'm not sorry).
>>
>>150358126
if you mean statutory rape rather than RAPE i don't even mind that much desu
>>
>>150349621
That ponytail got my attention. Post moar.
>>
>>150358214
>he thinks his retarded post deserves anything more than a greentext
>>
File: 1.jpg (628KB, 900x1350px) Image search: [Google]
1.jpg
628KB, 900x1350px
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FIcxqVRLEWI
>>
>>150358238
MC's son didn't really know what was happening. That was what was messed up. It wasn't really romantic at all.

MC's sister did it only because she wanted to fuck MC but MC didn't want too.

Author just wanted to shove his fetish at the cost of his story.
>>
>>150358103
The only vn i read all the way through was >>150357719, and i have to admit the writing wasn't ever particularly good, i just liked the characters and worldbuilding.
>>
File: 1469636403695.png (449KB, 401x277px)
1469636403695.png
449KB, 401x277px
>>150358103
>I can barely finish any real novels in English because the writing is so subpar

did you just drop an "I'm too smart for books" on 4chan?
>>
File: 2.jpg (652KB, 900x1350px) Image search: [Google]
2.jpg
652KB, 900x1350px
>>150358307
>>
>>150358311
Well that sounds pretty shitty, lowers my expectations for the sequel even more.
>>
>>150358103
>So how do guys fucking stand reading this trash?

You've heard of the term "suspend disbelief"?

It also applies to common sense. When reading these light novel and web novel stories, you turn off your common sense and just enjoy the good parts. As soon as you see a bad part, you immediately ignore it just as you walk by any homeless person on the street. Otherwise, you are obligated to help them right then and there instead of ignoring them.
>>
>>150355608
>>150356212
Parallel World Pharmacy was pretty good.

Translation died though.

I also like Tilea's Worries because it is so fucked up.
>>
>>150346874
I've read this, it's a generic harem isekai shit.
>>
>>150358158
/v/ crossie spotted.

>le ironically enjoying vidya eksdee
>>
>>150354874
Only chinks think so.

No one wants to read shit that is a 1000 chapters long only to get a sequel that also aims to be a 1000 chapters.

Chinkshit drags the story on forever because their chink authors depend on their chinkshit for income so they need to drag out their story forever unless they want to find another job.
>>
>>150358442
>what is every WSJ manga ever
>>
>>150358485
Actually, only a few manga authors get a chance to claim a thousand chapters.
>>
>>150357863
Ad hominems at this point if you can't seem to address it. You immediately lost the argument when you straw-manned me because you can't face the truth that Konosuba is not that great. Sorry if you like retards fucking around as a comedy.
>>
>>150358311
>MC's sister did it only because she wanted to fuck MC but MC didn't want too
Now that's just plain shit. I'm glad I stopped following when it ended.
>>
>>150356277
Does the MC get to dick the noble beast girl?
>>
>>150358103
I read the ones translated by somebody who actually can translate.
>>
>>150353972
>>The Ability to Make Town!? ~Let’s Make a Japanese Town in Different World~
That was is pretty nice. It's a guy who guys to another world and pretty much builds a nation. You don't go reading this is you expect a harem or one on one fights with powerlevels. It's pretty much, building a town, getting residents, dealing with town security and national defense.

Also Camels are sacred. Don't fuck with Camels
>>
>>150358499
You know they're trying to get thousands of chapters though, the only thing stopping them is the editors, which I doubt is happening with webnovels.
>>
>>150358510
>argument
Wow you've got issues man.
>>
>>150358528
Yeah, the extra chapters aren't worth reading.

They are a hundred times more corny and cheesy and even disgusting than the Harry Potter epilogue.

The extra chapters will end up souring your memories of the main story.
>>
>>150346874
The isekai storyline is trash. The backstory of the MC's youth would have made an infinitely better story.
>>
>>150358103
I bet you love western novels that are pretty much the same thing don't you faggot.
>>
Does this have more than two translated chapters?
>>
>>150359147
no
>>
>>150359224
Alright, time to shitpost then, I guess.
>>
What do you think will be the next anime isekai adaptation?
>>
Why are these threads always full of whiny crossboarding /v/ retards?
>>
>>150355027
It was a short story. Written by Mark Twain. It's also fucking awful, holy shit.
>>
>>150358749
Who are you to call issues if you can't even hold up a proper sentence with punctuation? It is anathema. You would be wise to fix yourself before you attempt to call out on problems.
> Inb4 you try and say something like, "Oh, you're trying to get me by attacking my sentences."
My response as of now is that a hypocrite should learn to hold he/she's tongue since backtracking won't work.
>>
>>150348821
thats your shit taste dont make it fact
>>
>>150352588
It's funny because skeleton knight is definitely the worst among those.
>>
>>150359596
Why don't you like the Elven land of Canada?
>>
File: 1355701624951.png (10KB, 429x410px) Image search: [Google]
1355701624951.png
10KB, 429x410px
>>150359522
Are you okay anon?
>>
>>150357719
Mushoku Tensei, like most isekai, is wish fulfillment, and a shameless one at that. Putting aside the power fantasy of everyone in the academy being afraid of Rudeus and the wish fulfillment in which all the main girls fall for Rudeus and marry him, what really got me was that Rudeus somehow had enough money for him and his family to live like 40 years without work. The world building was decent but the writing is plagued with cliché archtypes and mediocrity. Also, Rudeus is a piece of shit.
>>
>>150359891
Did he whore himself out or did oersted give him a ton of money?
>>
>>150359891
Well i'm not about to come and say a story where the protagonist marries 3 girls isn't wish fulfillment, but Rudeus had some personality while still being relatable, i thought he was ok.
>>
I rather liked Evil God Average.
MC a girl with scary eyes, Evil God guy summons her, grants her wish to look average, chucks her into fantasy world.
She finds out she is average, for an evil god. Tries and fails to be an adventurer because she is too scary to guard, and monsters run away. Anything she touches for an hour turns into cursed thing of top quality.
For example, her knife is now very evil super knife, and teleports to her hand if she tries to pick up a different weapon.
Can't stay at the inn, because the innkeeper is too scared of her. Things develop from there, but it's only 2 novels. No otome stuff, mostly humor and dungeon owning. Good times.
>>
File: 1479294662730.jpg (255KB, 868x1158px) Image search: [Google]
1479294662730.jpg
255KB, 868x1158px
This being the closest thing to an LN thread that isn't about to drown, I may as well post this here.

Whoever it is who keeps uploading Kindle rips of Yen Press novels to the sekrit klub, could you please pick a source to rip from other than Kindle?

Kindle is pretty much the only source that deliberately murders image quality. Pick Google Play Books or Kobo or something that actually allows a publisher to save the images in the original non downscaled resolution, and with JPG quality 98 instead of 40.

Or you get horrific artifacted shit like this.
>>
>>150360233
I should specify that it successfully concludes at 2 novels.
>>
Rudeus's internal narration is annoying as fuck to read, because all his sentences seem to consist of only one or two clauses or phrases. If Mushoku Teensy were to be written in Microsoft Word, there would be a shitload of "Fragment (consider revising)" grammar corrections everywhere.
>>
>>150359928
no, he does it for free. he was a fat fuck who died with regrets in his previous life for being a useless NEET who wasted his life away in his room and vows to "live seriously" but all he does in his new life is fuck around, literally.
he was seduced by a 15 year old. keep in mind he's like over 50 years old mentally. he actually tried to refuse but his hebophilia made him cave.
he committed adultery against his first wife. he was feeling down because his dad died when a pseudo loli tempted him and again his hebophilia made him cave. the next morning, he made a joke saying his dick was feeling "Paulish", meaning erect, because his Father (Paul) was a manslut, which shows how much respect he has for the dead, seeing as he jokes about them, his own father!
After he married the person he committed adultery with, with his first wife's permission, he becomes obsessed with the idea of a threesome. You can see how much remorse he has over his actions. He leaves his newborn baby with some babysitter and his mother who is in a vegetated state (mentally) to makes plans to get his wives to agree to a threesome. This is where I dropped the series because of how much I hated him.
There's more gripes but long story short: Rudeus is a manchild, in more ways than one. he may be over 50 years old mentally, but his lack of self-restraint and self-control is on par with a 5-year old.

>>150360072
putting aside his immaturity, Rudeus was relatively normal, when he wasn't acting like a creepy old man trying to lure middle school children into coming into his basement.
>>
>>150358199
I think the latest was vol 11, google it
>>
Are Mushoku Tensei LN version translations still dead?
>>
>>150358602
So it's just playing Civ in a fantasy world?
>>
>>150360233
Dat No Life King tho

Seriously, I enjoyed it. The joke at the very end of the dungeon challenge made me laugh my ass off.
>>
>>150360696
>Free
What, when Rudeus starts working for Orsted he specifically says that he need some sort of payment because he has a growing child and a family to feed. Orsted just gives him a bunch of rare shit that Rudeus can sell
>>
The only thing I liked from Mushoku Tensei was Roxie's monologue when she was trapped and alone, and Rudie's last chat with Hitogami.
>>
>>150360233
I enjoyed that one, wish it was longer

Reading I Said Make My Abilities Average! now, but it's not the same
>>
>>150358855
>An accomplished kendoist since childhood, at the age of 13 he takes up swordsmanship, hence allowing his talent to bloom.
>At 15 years old, moved to mainland China for warrior training by taking part in the underground society.
>He killed a large number of people using a single sword, hence was called by the nickname of “sword demon“ (T: ken no oni)
>The number of people he killed in the underground society activities caps at 912 people in five years.
>Then, he served in World War II.

>The number of people he killed during the war period of four years was 3712 people. The number of people he killed during the war period of four years with his blade alone was 3712 people.
>Hence the name, “Blade ogre“.

Literally the oniisama of Isekai.

An anime about the Black Dragon Society clandestine wetworks and sabotage of China to pave the way for the Imperial Japanese invasion would be way better than whatever fantasy haremshit this will devolve into.
>>
Mother of Learning is pretty good. MC gets sucked into someone else time loop and it restarts if the main recipient dies. Also the MC actually has a shitty mana pool so he isnt super duper op. Most of it is just world building and MC trying to learn shit to not be such a shitter
>>
>>150360890
Pretty much, Has to deal with countries trying to start shit with him, hiding his ability as best as possible, building his city/nation up so that it can last even when he's gone and so forth.
His biggest problem thus far is the lack of trust-able people to place in his military. He can roll out tanks, cannons, and guns and such with his ability, but he has to worry about spies possibly getting their hands on it, or people using those weapons against him. It's the problem of having too advanced tech in a not so advanced world.
>>
>>150359705
He doesn't look okay to me.
>>
>>150361139
That really would have been a bit better than the isekai rpg harem story it currently is.
>>
>>150359705
Shut up you hypocrite.
>>150361304
> Saying the truth is called crazy.
Is what you are saying. Konosuba is not that good.
>>
>>150361256
>His biggest problem thus far is the lack of trust-able people to place in his military.
If he literally can't find anybody who he can trust to run the army and not coup the shit out of him, he has problems a lot bigger than just spies.
Another problem with relying on cheating to leapfrog for a technological advantage, without a real research infrastructure and education system in place this edge is impossible to be maintained. Unless he can personally teach organic chemistry, mathematics, mechanical engineering, electrical engineering, metallurgy, geology, city planning, medicine, etc etc etc to lots of people who can then go on to teach others and create a university system, it's basically impossible for a modern city state created through cheating to be able to sustain itself, because empirical knowledge can only take you so far.
>>
>>150361102
Is that when he flips hitogami off?
>>
>>150361496
Anon, I don't even read Konosuba and I can't take your "argument" seriously. You call ad hominem on others but you yourself would do it. You imply that only your opinions on comedy is correct and what's funny for others isn't funny as long as you say so. The way I see it, you're as much as a hypocrite as what you claim others are.
>>
File: 1280.jpg (353KB, 1280x808px) Image search: [Google]
1280.jpg
353KB, 1280x808px
Is Alice in Wonderland isekai?
>>
>>150361570
It's when Hitogami is trying to show off his grand plan to Rudeus to make him despair, but he couldn't care because he lived a good life and he's dead, and there's nothing more for him to do.
>>
>>150361668
Yes, so is The Wizard of Oz and some other shit.
>>
File: 019 (2).jpg (255KB, 862x1236px) Image search: [Google]
019 (2).jpg
255KB, 862x1236px
Posting the true best fantasy manga.
>>
File: 1364543140248.jpg (32KB, 603x452px) Image search: [Google]
1364543140248.jpg
32KB, 603x452px
>>150361496
>hypocrite
I don't know what imaginary anon you're arguing with, it's amazing that my random post made your butthurt shot up to 11 and back in your butthole. I don't even read Konosuba LN.
>>
>>150361688
That was really cool of him, accepting his after-life like a total champ.
>>
>>150361628
Oh please. Like you should preach to me about hypocrisy. And you tell me about my opinion about a comedy. It is not an opinion. I stated the truth. Tell me what is so opinionated about my claims towards Konosuba.
> Parody series that does not go beyond being a parody.
> Essentially the cast are a bunch of characters that fuck around.
> Jokes are literally them and people call them good characters.
> Context of people fucking around is not exactly good. If you look at it carefully, it is bad.
> The moment you criticize, the fanbase shits all over you (I'm not kidding).
>Later on, not much happens other than having romantic interests and cockblocking. Still fucking around and people call this good.
What's wrong here? Tell me. I'd like for you to point out anything wrong.
>>
>>150361516
He has people he can trust. It's just he needs more. The modern weaponry helps with the numbers gap, but only so much.
And the problem you point out is the exact problem he has and the one he's been trying to rectify the most. His power lets him buy a lot of things like manga, soap, tanks, and even manuals for them(naturally it's not for free). But before all that he needs to teach the ones he trust most how to read Japanese. So he does that and he gets them to read and learn a lot of things. It's at the point where many know how to drive cars and operate tanks now.
>>
>>150361781
Look back at the reply chain, or can you not read?
>>
>>150361748
I loved the part where she gets fucked from behind.
>>
>>150361998
You've got issues man >>150357863
>>
>>150361889
>>150361889
Oh for fuck's sake is it this shit again? Japanese humor is based on puns, absurdity and retorts, then funnymen and a straight man.

Fuck off and find something else to cry about.
>>
>>150361889
>What's wrong here
That there are people enjoying things you don't and you're mad about it.
>>
>>150361913
Just operating the cheating equipment is one thing, but I assume he does want to avoid a WH40K scenario where they only know how to manufacture according to a limited set of existing equipment patterns and can't really innovate because even the tech priests don't know how it really works.

Reminds me of the toaster project actually. Guy tried to see if he could build a toaster completely from scratch, and it was hard.

http://www.thetoasterproject.org/page2.htm

Restricting education to a handful of elite is probably a handicap. Keeping it only to those you trust is one thing, but in the long term knowledge is too easy to lose and your base of educated people only have so many hours in the day to work on so many projects.

One reason why China fell behind the West technologically is that they had no shortage of labor thanks to their massive population and so had no need to invent labour saving devices like the steam engine or the spinning jenny etc. And also that there was no arms race with a large number of competing nations in the area.

If he makes his nation too overwhelmingly powerful through no effort of its own, there is no incentive to keep progressing because you are content and arrogant in believing you're the best, and before you know it your country is flooded with opium and the barbarians are forcing you to sign humiliating treaties at gunpoint.

Remember, Japan didn't modernize by buying all their shit from the West, they sent people to bring back the knowledge and ideas they needed to actually build that shit themselves. Does he have all that knowledge in his head?
>>
>stop enjoying things
Fucking /a/
>>
>>150361748
the fuck is this
>>
>>150361889
I can't answer about Konosuba since I don't read it. You're wrong about comedy though since comedy is subjective. What's funny for you wouldn't always be funny for others and vice versa.
>>
>>150355502
I don't think the planet would survive the fight
>>
>>150362210
At least there aren't any high-class entities that can influence people via emotions at least. So there's that.
>>
>>150362127
> It's because I don't have fun.
People don't get critical when they don't have fun, people get critical when they no longer fun. I never mentioned what I enjoyed and you straw-manned me.
>>150362054
I never once replied to that anon's comment. And I said, "And people think that is fun." The fuck are you on about?
>>150362077
> Boo-Hoo! He's right! So I can only say that's it's japanese comedy to backtrack the facts he gave!
Is what you are doing right now.
>>150362260
> Pulling the subjective card.
I've heard this shit before. I said this right here in an incomplete phrase in the last sentence. Listen CAREFULLY:
> The new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around and because series are comedies so it's good!
Repeat that in the mirror. I tell you to do it. Now. It sounds terrible in context. Do it. Think about it until you get it through your skull and reflect.
>>
>>150362210
>he does want to avoid a WH40K scenario where they only know how to manufacture according to a limited set of existing equipment patterns and can't really innovate because even the tech priests don't know how it really works.
He really wants to avoid that.
He's not really restricting education to only a handful either. Currently he has a population of over 100,000 I believe. The majority are humans. He can't however use them for the military due to various reasons mainly because of demihuman discrimination and the fact that most spies from other nations will be other humans. So he has to rely on the demihumans. Who are less in number and don't reproduce as fast. Demihumans he trust(Wolf tribe his trust completely, down right loyal, he's building his nation just to repay them.). He doesn't trust the other demihumans nearly as much as the wolves, but due to how the world views demihumans in general, it's unlikely for them to betray him either so long as he's careful.
He gives both humans and demihumans education, though the demihumans get the better one. they are also the only ones allowed in the military, for now anyway.

And it doesn't help that the nations in continent he's on are mostly at war with each other now. And their are other Japanese with different powers as well, though he has the most broken for nation building. Others either got shit powers or powers meant more for individual achievements.
>>
>>150346874
Thank you for the lol cancer
>>
>>150362651
>I never once replied to that anon's comment.
Look back at the reply chain, or can you not read?
>>
>OP try to bait GSfag
>Dumb konosubafag got baited instead.

Retards.
>>
>>150362260
> I'm wrong about comedy!
That sounds great if I actually said my preferences and opinions on what a comedy should be! You straw-manned me again (if you are the same anon in the past), when I only reiterated other's opinion and the series for what it is in general. The thing I said here is that it is not that good.
>>
>>150362840
To be fair, GSfags is actually pretty chill.
>>
>>150362859
>The thing I said here is that it is not that good
Your opinion is wrong.
>>
>>150362790
Shit. Sorry, my bad. I thought I was talking to that greentext anon. I accidentally replied to you and that caused this chain. My mistake. I think I have a fever.
>>
>>150353690
that bamboo sword is a JAPANESE kendo sword and its OP as heck and obviously cursed.
>>
>>150363000
Listen here, I know you may have trips and all, but Konosuba is not that good as people say it is. And that's a fact, not opinion.
>>
>>150362697
>Majority human population
>Demihuman minority that everyone hates monopolizes the guns, monopolizes the best education, and has the special favor of the god emperor
Sounds like a recipe for disaster to me.
>>
>>150363118
>And that's a fact, not opinion
Because you said so
>>
>>150363198
I gave my reasons as to why it is not that good while reiterating fan's opinions about it.
> It's like your opinion, man!
Is what you are saying and that automatically makes you lose the argument.
>>
>>150363164
It would be, But he pretty much tells them if they don't like it, leave. They won't though, because they don't know how much the demi-humans are getting better treatment, and because the humans get far far better treatment in his city than other nations anyway. Clean streets, jobs, delicious food, baths, free firewood, an actual education period.)

He currently trying to make sure all the humans can read and eventual get a newspaper industry going. Would help amazingly with propaganda. They would learn how other nations are and then compare it to them.
>>
>>150363285
>I gave my reasons as to why it is not that good
Characters fucking around? Yeah, it's like, your opinion man.
>>
Hey guys I have a new Isekai novel to run past you. It's called "I Can't Believe I Was Born into a Fantasy World! What? I'm Limbless, Mute, Blind, A Mentally Retarded Hobo on the Brink of Starvation Who Has Been Enduring Sexual and Emotional Abuse His Entire Life?! And Goddess-sama Gave Me a Cheat?「Pity」? Whaaaat?!"

His cheat skill is a low tier brainwashing that makes people look favorably upon him, But I can't tell if this is a gary stu or not.
>>
>>150363358
How are they not fucking around? Story not progressing at all (Until the plot demands it) because the characters keep playing around a lot with them teasing each other and acting like idiots for the past 10 volumes?
>>
>>150363000
>Your opinion is wrong
But, that's like your opinion, man!
Seriously, you never use this card against people. You set yourself up for failure the moment you said wrong and opinion.
>>
>>150363315
>But he pretty much tells them if they don't like it, leave.
I'm really more worried about the demihumans becoming a violent and repressive ruling armed and educated minority class/race, like the European imperial powers in their colonies except with an added long history of being the ones everyone spits on and treats like shit.

>He currently trying to make sure all the humans can read and eventual get a newspaper industry going. Would help amazingly with propaganda.
Can't he just hire town criers to shout out the propaganda?
>>
>>150363374
>Not using 「Japanese Quotes」
>>
>>150363443
It's a comedy. It's not like the story is dragging out 40 volumes.
>The new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around and because series are comedies so it's good!
So you're complaining comedy being a comedy-you-don't like is bad.

>>150363495
He's posting his opinion as fact, it doesn't matter if we're both opinions.
>>
>>150363568
But I did.
>>
>>150363598
No anon you're doing it wrong. It's <<Pity>>.
>>
>>150363657
Take (((Pity))) on me
>>
>>150363358
>>150363583
Dude, I've read Konosuba and the series goes like this:
> Darkness still being stupid by the same masochist. Counts as fooling around.
> Love shenanigans where even Megumin and Kazuma get cockblocked. Counts as fooling around.
> Megumin still using the same damn spells like an idiot. Counts as fooling around.
> Aqua still being the blockhead.
> Pulling phoenix wright references.
> The villains go through shenanigans made by themselves and the protagonists.
> Kazuma dying and not staying dead and being resurrected multiple times (that's not good, deus ex machina).
> Shenanigans with some princess.
And the thing you said here about story dragging out, at this point, this ain't much of a story. Even the anime is going to have the same pattern like always with nothing really of value beyond a parody.
>>
>>150363563
>I'm really more worried about the demihumans becoming a violent and repressive ruling armed and educated minority class/race, like the European imperial powers in their colonies except with an added long history of being the ones everyone spits on and treats like shit.
Not really happening in this case, More discipline and the city is separated into two sections. MC figured there was no way for them to currently get along well together, so he did it this way. And he's slowly going to get them to work together by building up a common culture for the city and it's people. Also, part of the reason why there's discrimination is a certain religion, and many teachers are from said religion and it's theocracy. So he making sure teachers aren't from there. Though this is most likely to cause that nation to declare war at some point.
>>
>>150363583
You just straw-manned me again.
> So you're complaining comedy being a comedy-you-don't like is bad.
Also, re-repeat this
>The new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around and because series are comedies so it's good!
in the mirror and try and look at the context of it. Does that good to you? Repeat it until you get it through. Make yourself hear that again and see!
>>
>>150363563
>>150363770
>Can't he just hire town criers to shout out the propaganda?
He could, but the newspapers are less obvious and it will still serve as a reliable source of news. And like I said, he's trying to build more culture with increases the people patriotism.
>>
>Konosubafags in charge of not being buttblasted.
>>
>>150363850
That happen when your fanbase is general-based. Their circlejerky fanbase is filled with information filter and confirmation bias, thus they can't stand any criticism.

General killing /a/, as always.
>>
>>150363833
>The new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around
>new age
>>
>>150363899
Forgot the rest of my post.

Idiots fucking around is the second oldest form of comedy next to the pain of others.
>>
>>150363924
And?
>>
>>150363899
I repeated what an anon said about the new age of comedy all about idiots fucking around months ago. If you repeat it in the mirror enough times, you start to see how kinda sad it sounds.
>>
>>150354010
Even on the serious note this manga is far better than half the fantasy gigs japan spits out.
>>
>>150357047
There's really no need to read that far to ascertain that.
>>
>>150363924
You want to know what actually sounds better in context? An idiot that fucks around but gives a good lesson to others. That's Onizuka.
>>
>>150363833
I did and yeah it's good.
>>
>>150364024
Not enough times. Do it again and again until you start being cynical.
>>
>>150364024
Well then, I hope you enjoy how bad the context is. Just saying in retrospect here.
>>
>>150363770
>Not really happening in this case, More discipline and the city is separated into two sections.
After everyone has already put down roots and lived separately for a long time it's going to be quite hard to reintegrate them later. Physical separation is already a barrier to forming a common identity and common culture.

This is why Singapore for example has government regulations on ethnic quotas for public housing, to force different ethnicities to live next to each other roughly in line with national composition and prevent enclaves from forming.
>>
NEW THREAD
NEW THREAD
>>150364093
>>150364093
>>
>>150364102
>After everyone has already put down roots and lived separately for a long time it's going to be quite hard to reintegrate them later. Physical separation is already a barrier to forming a common identity and common culture.
The roots haven't taken yet. And before demihumans liviing in the same city would have never been possible. They were down right becoming an endangered species.
>>
>>150364218
Can humans and demi-humans crossbreed?
Thread posts: 557
Thread images: 72


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.