There are people RIGHT HERE that unironically prefer Brotherhood

While I thought the Nazi bullshit was pretty retarded, I did find it more acceptable than the manga's ending.

I didn't like how Brotherhood ended on a completely generic shounen fight with "God" as everyone cheered from the sidelines. I don't know, I expect that shit from Naruto but not from FMA.

>>146631697
the music was better in the 2003 show.
but the I liked the direction brotherhood took more than the original anime.

>>146632746
>cheered from the sidelines.
dude everyone was fighting father,
greed even sacrificed himself to turn him into charcoal, ed just got the final blow.

>>146631697
It tells a much better story than 2003. Simple as that. 2003 OST is GOAT though.

Both are shit.

Why is Bones so based?

>>146633004
>2003 OST is GOAT though.
Obligatory

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwzAEwzUI8k

Read the manga

>>146631697
I don't.

File: a8f75c97791e847f6e5f8db1f4585b4c1239578843_full.jpg (172KB, 640x342px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 640x342px

Is this time to post FMA maymays?

>>146633335
Sounds like Ico.

I like brotherhood more
but as a standalone series 2003 was good.

>>146633353
It's the same as Brotherhood. The tone got a lot more kid friendly as it went on. Became stale shonenshit in the second half. The first volumes are amazing, though.

>>146633614
this

>>146633335
https://youtu.be/r_ngJDBdMpE

>>146633614
>The tone got a lot more kid friendly as it went on.
Because edgy shit like Shou Tucker didn't happen in every chapter?

And to be honest I found Kimblee a way better edgy villain than Shou Tucker.

>>146631697
Pretty much everything about 2003 is better than Brotherhood except for the ending despite the fact that Brotherhood's wasn't really good.

File: Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood - Greed vs Wrath.webm (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

>>146631697
Meh

File: Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood - Scar vs Wrath.webm (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

>>146633928

>>146631697
2003 has better early episodes, better fight coreography and better OST
Brotherhood has better everything else

There, debate settled forever

only saw brotherhood...
can someone explain me why evil guy waited for the good guy squad to kill him instead of just killing them and forcing random people to open this weird door like he did with mustang to have sacrifices?
this villian got really stupid pretty fast.

>>146633817
No, because in the coup they didn't kill anyone, for example. It just gradually changed tone.

>>146634509
What they did with mustang is desperate measure. Pride paid the price and became unstable enough that even Ed could beat him.

>>146634519
>coup didn't kill anyone
>old Fu
>Bradley
>Bucaneer
>Pride
>Sloth
>Greed

Oh gee

>>146634707
Inb4
>Good guys don't count
>Homunculi don't count

>>146634651
Yeah i get that they wanted mustang to do it himself and had to force him when it didn't work, but that didn't explain really explain why...
Also the fight with those bradleys made angry. mustang could've burned them instantly, he even did his gesture but didn't kill them for the script...

>>146633817
>edgy shit

Can you express an opinion without using buzzwords?
Just asking.

>>146633928
>>146634004

That's actually cheap and cartoony as fuck. They skip a lot frames to avoid doing difficult key animations and introduce unreal cargo cult anime animations to make it flashy.

>>146635088
>Can you express an opinion without using buzzwords?
this is 4chan what do you think?

>>146634065
2003 has better late episodes actually. Even if that's not the popular opinion on /a/ they handled the second part in an original way whereas Manga went full shonen cliche.

Also quality took a huge dip in the second part of Brotherhood as most modern animes.

Its better.

>>146634950
They are just too fast. They are Bradley clones after all.

>>146634509
They needed alchemists that have seen the door and survived, Alphonse was skilled and yet he would be dead if Ed wouldn't save him. Using any person wouldn't work.

>>146634950
>Also the fight with those bradleys made angry. mustang could've burned them instantly, he even did his gesture but didn't kill them for the script...

Mustang's power were retarded in Brotherhood. In 2003 they actually gave him a good fight that made sense. It should be extremely fast and destructive no matter the outcome.

File: fma1.png (14KB, 100x100px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 100x100px

>>146636674
Please don't.

>>146637502
But you just...

>>146637502
Worst character in the history of shonen. Prove me wrong.

>>146637823
How

File: (kuiper) roy.jpg (5KB, 100x100px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 100x100px

>>146637574
I know, right?