This was finished yesterday. Let's dump some various

File: 1436645815624.jpg (488KB, 1600x2400px) Image search: [Google]

488KB, 1600x2400px

>>145261033

>>145261033
>GiTS not under Urban Scenery
>Dead Leaves not under Unique Style or Bizarre Visuals

It's not terrible but opinions. I don't think Lain is really that bizarre in terms of visuals honestly.

Also no Paprika...

File: a_chart_anime_2013version.jpg (2MB, 3247x1661px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3247x1661px

>>145261033
>>145261194

2013 version

>>145261313
Why should I give a shit about some
e-celeb?

>>145261213
>Wings of Honneamise
>Angel's Egg
>Metropolis
>Wolf Children
>Redline
>Dead Leaves
>Jin-Roh
>Cat Shit One

This list makes me happier but both lists together are an overall good selection.

>>145261313
why won't you die?

>>145261313

Please die in a digital music digital warehouse digital fire.

File: machi_6.png (829KB, 745x720px) Image search: [Google]

829KB, 745x720px

>>145261313
Oh my sweet Jesus, why?

>>145261313
what was special abotu kare kano, or shirobakos soundtracks?

File: anime mecha.jpg (506KB, 1279x1047px) Image search: [Google]

506KB, 1279x1047px

I can dump some, sure.

File: best anime.png (1MB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1200x900px

>>145261033

>>145262327
>Macross Plus
>cyberpunk

I can't begin to say "NO" enough times to make it worth while. Whoever made this chart doesn't even know what cyberpunk is.

File: anime tv 1970 - 2000.jpg (2MB, 1500x3300px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1500x3300px

>>145262646
AI conflict is typically a big cyberpunk thing right?

>>145262721

I suppose yes it could be considered as a trope but the overall movie/OVA isn't cyberpunk as typically considered. That and it's Macross which is very much not a cyberpunk series.

>>145262364

This chart I feel is more in tone w/ series that capture cyberpunk across the proper spectrum.

File: anime tv 2000 - 2015 2.jpg (3MB, 1500x2890px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1500x2890px

this one's slightly different, not sure why I saved two when neither are particularly good

>>145262947
>G-Reco

>>145261663
>rurouni kenshin
>classic
wew lad. This is triggering my autism. The TV series wasn't that good. The filler was unbearable and the canon content they did adapt was merely a serviceable adaptation of the manga like any other shounenshit adaptation.

File: greco mal.png (207KB, 453x367px) Image search: [Google]

207KB, 453x367px

>>145263170
Hello MAL-kun

File: Mac14.jpg (44KB, 583x464px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 583x464px

>>145262841
I think Plus is fine there given the context of the chart. Not a thing I'd usually consider cyberpunk but like if you think about it Sharon Apple is cyberpunk as fuck.

>>145263170
you just don't understand Tomino-sensei's genius

File: fBK8n.jpg (721KB, 2000x2000px) Image search: [Google]

721KB, 2000x2000px

Is there a update to this?

>>145263337
so much budget moe

File: 1446344538937.png (110KB, 540x524px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 540x524px

>>145263368
>rates shows before you finish them

>>145263376

No, I still think it really was just the chart maker filling a hole since he couldn't think of anything else to put in that spot.

I understand where you're coming from in terms of considering some aspects of the story as cyberpunk I just don't feel the movie/OVA as a whole fits into that particular genre.

I'd say Armitage III would have been better in the spot but it's also a list for mecha anime and despite having the proper feel for cyberpunk it doesn't have an giant mechas as a main aspect of the series.

>>145263486

No, and the only thing it's really missing is Jurmungand. or however the hell you spell it I can't be bothered to look it up.

>>145261033
I hate it

>>145263674
He hates it.

File: satan-e1348776842386.jpg (49KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 600x450px

>>145263368
>ranked 666

>>145261313
What fucked up reality do you live in where Gurren Lagann is better than FLCL?

>>145263755
I kinda prefer TTGL. Both due for a rewatch though.

>>145263755
Isn't that ranking soundtracks?

>>145261313
Impressive, even an e-celeb can make one better than a bunch of crossboarders ans newfags.

>>145261033
>even one piece in there
Holy shit, talk about cancer. Fucking newfriends ruining everything.

>>145263926
>not knowing who hosoda is
th newfag is you

/a/'s taste is SHIT! Absolute S H I T !

>>145263847
That makes it even worse.

>>145263975
he's bad though

>not posting manga lists

>>145263337
I only like this one.

File: Delinquent Chart (Small).jpg (4MB, 3167x4275px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 3167x4275px

>>145261033

>>145263337
I don't agree about everything but this is honestly the best one I've seen so far.

>>145264401

I don't even really care for delinquent manga but this list.. THIS LIST... Now THIS is how you make a list.

I'm saving this just because I don't want to ever forget that a quality list can be made.

>>145264401
Whoa this is real nice.

>>145263755
There are two kinds of people.
Those who like ttgl and those who don't.
And because in order to like ttgl you have to be stupid, all of your anime judgmenet is bound to be backwards.

File: 1339818426801.gif (258KB, 400x225px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 400x225px

>>145264558
>being this pretentious about your far eastern oriental animated picture shows

I bet you're a thrill to be around in person. A regular dynamo of human charisma just dripping with so much intrigue that people commonly mistake you for an adult who's wet himself in public.

File: wow.jpg (70KB, 619x539px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 619x539px

>>145264882
Fucking brutal.

>>145261033
>This was finished yesterday. Let's dump some various charts to celebrate.

This is not fucking finished. What is wrong with you? Why do you keep consistently ignoring what I tell you?

I said, put Redline & Sword of the Stranger back onto the list. You took them off their respective categories for choices that are nowhere NEAR close in quality to them. They are literal champions of their categories, to the point that they shouldn't ever come off. Also do the fact that both of them are still incredibly fucking NICHE. Literally everyone I talk to don't even know what they are if I ask them if they've seen it.

So put Redline & Sword of the Stranger back into Animated Motion and Choreography, please, pretty please with a fucking cherry on top. I don't know what else to get this through to you, it's like talking to a fucking wall. Fix it. If you have to remove something, remove either Yozakura Quartet or Towa No Quon and The Little Norse Prince.

>>145265058
The guy didn't want repeats from the old chart so you gotta settle for second best.

File: 1462904421638.jpg (3MB, 1320x2960px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1320x2960px

>>145262823

>>145264558
>I use anime to establish an image of being intelligent because it's much, much easier than actually striving to be intelligent

>>145265155
I've never been to /m/ but they sound like fun guys.

I really need to make my Hentai chart that I've been wanting to make for years now..

>>145265236
That was in the past. Now /m/ is on the same level of /a/ and probably more 'no fun allowed' and concentrated autism in some cases.

>>145265058
Just forget it, OP didn't make the chart to be accurate and helpful, he did it to get attention.

>>145265121
Who fucking cares about repeats? This is supposed to be a chart to reccomend to people who haven't watched anime what the absolute best examples of each category is. Redline is the best example of animated motion and Stranger is the best example of choreography. I mean, let's take into account Quartet is only good by animated seasons standards, which is still fucking terrible. Stranger overlaps it by a huge margin. And I don't understand how you could put a film by Toei Animation in the animated motion category, regardless of what time period it was made in.

these charts always remind me how awful anime is compared to other media regarding time investment. TV anime at least

>>145265058
It's already on the 2013 version. You're complaining about something which was already done three fuckng years ago.

>>145265352
>And I don't understand how you could put a film by Toei Animation in the animated motion category, regardless of what time period it was made in.
Oh, you're one of those people. The retards who just echo others instead of actually watching them making their own judgements.

>>145265352
calm your autism

>>145265361
How so? Also in my experience there are way more good anime TV shows than good anime movies.

>>145265500
I have Mononoke on my backlog, anon. I'm really to watch stuff, but I have had too much bad experience to ever think Toei Animation can consistently put out anything watchable. If Mononoke & The Little Norse Prince are both good, then that's great, good on them. The only diamonds in the literal thousands of Toei's shit catalog. But I'll watch Mononoke when I get the time and based on the synopsis for TLNP I just looked up, it's not something I'm going to be racing to watch.

>>145265352
Toei had disney level animation at one point you retard.

>>145265500
Well, he's not wrong. Horus has good animation, but it's hardly a powerhouse of "animated motion".

File: Chrysanthemum 2.png (53KB, 906x906px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 906x906px

>>145264454
>>145264512
Thanks, It took a damn while to make so I appreciate it.

>>145265747
Yeah what, 40-60 years ago? Makes me wonder why they couldn't keep that quality going, when Disney has been managing to do it since 1937.

>>145261033
Horror visuals seems like a really unnecessary category because there's so little that can even fit there.

>>145265858
Disney keeps going because it has more money and influence than most countries.

>>145265722
Only because you're a retard that compares their weekly TV shit to movies.

>>145265792
>Horus has good animation, but it's hardly a powerhouse of "animated motion".
Yes, but he is still wrong because he dismiss all of it "regardless of what time period it was made in". The fact that he can say shit like that proves that he doesn't even know what's he talking about.

And he flat out admit that he hasn't even watched entry level movies like Mononoke. So he's still wrong and full of shit even if there are indeed better movies to be placed on the chart.

>>145265869
I think so too, horror isn't exactly something anime excels at in general so even the best of it isn't really that noteworthy.

File: 1470181008613.jpg (2MB, 2504x1681px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2504x1681px

>>145264401
>>145265835
This is lovely, thanks anon!

>>145265858
>Yeah what, 40-60 years ago?
And? That just means that it set a bar too high to top.

>Makes me wonder why they couldn't keep that quality going, when Disney has been managing to do it since 1937.
Because using CG models is easier than having to have a bunch of animators meticulously animate the type of stuff they used to do. Why bother putting in all that effort when the the typical audience aren't going to care about all the technical intricacies anyway. And for current Disney, it's even easier to simply acquire other established properties and live off those Marvel and Star Wars bucks. With all that options available, keeping that level quality isn't the pragmatic choice.

File: Mononoke_500[1].jpg (186KB, 500x333px) Image search: [Google]

186KB, 500x333px

>>145265917
>And he flat out admit that he hasn't even watched entry level movies like Mononoke.
Oh my god, are you FUCKING retarded? I was talking about the series that TOEI made, Mononoke, not Princess Mononoke, you fucking retard.

And I literally said if TLNP is good, then that's fucking cool. But we are talking about having a spot on the animated motion category. A movie made in '68 is not, no matter how good it is or how much money was put into it, going to have better motion than a movie made in '09 that was meticuously worked on for a period of 7 years to make it completely hand-drawn, when about half of the movie is in constant motion. I mean, are you serious right now?

>>145261313
I haven't seen Log Horizon yet, I am missing anything important?

>>145265835

I do have to ask even though it's not really a delinquent manga, why is GTO not on the list or that prequel manga for GTO?

I assume it's because there's not that much delinquent content and Onizuka isn't an adult not a teen.

>>145265352
Good choreography, far from fluid animation.

>>145266179
>I mean, are you serious right now?
I could ask the same for you.

>Mononoke
Ok, I messed up on that one, but you know what? It doesn't change the argument all that much, surprisingly enough. Mononoke is also entry level so I'm going to mock you just the same for daring to talk shit even though you haven't watched it. Keep back peddling your position.

> A movie made in '68 is not, no matter how good it is or how much money was put into it, going to have better motion than a movie made in '09 that was meticuously worked on for a period of 7 years to make it completely hand-drawn, when about half of the movie is in constant motion
Yeap, you have no fucking clue what you're talking about. You've done it again, you're making baseless assumption again. So, are YOU fucking retarded?

>>145266179
>Oh my god, are you FUCKING retarded? I was talking about the series that TOEI made, Mononoke, not Princess Mononoke, you fucking retard.

Not the guy you're yelling at but if you say "Mononoke" and "movie" in the same sentence many people will think of the more well known "Princess Mononoke". Maybe try not to come off like such an asshole next time ok? OK!

>>145266230
Both prequel manga for GTO are on the list, check again, maybe you expected them to be towards the top? They're a bit lower really. As for GTO it's simply not a delinquent manga in my eyes.

>>145266403
He was explicitly talking about Toei when he referred to Mononoke. Don't get angry because you can't even read.

>>145265722
Faggot, fucking Deen and JC Staff have made great stuff in the past. And Kyousougiga is good.

>but I have had too much bad experience to ever think Toei Animation
Sounds more like the problem is on your end. People who aren't new or have low powerlevel already knew that Toei can churn out good stuff when they're not going the easy route of just going for the younger audience/selling toys and merch route. Learn how to filter the shit. Yes, Toei is notorious for QUALITY, but dismissing all of their works is a major rookie mistake.

>>145266424

Ah ya the prequel is on there and no I wasn't really expecting it to be higher just missed it. Also I didn't think GTO would really be on there as I said it's really not a full on delinquent manga.

So are you going to do any other genres? I'd love to see another list that's not a genre commonly found outside of Japan.

>>145266571
No, I wasn't. Like >>145266403 said, the context was movies. And again, it doesn't the argument. You're still talking shit about it even when you've got a flawed understanding of it.

>>145266571

You're the only one getting angry here friend maybe you should go do something else for an hour and cool down ok? You're taking these stylish nippon animated shows a bit to seriously.

>>145266353
I don't have a clue what I'm talking about? Please, show me why TLNP deserves a spot over Redline. Show me some webms in action of how good its animated motion is, because that's what it's contending for. Because if I say, look it up on the Sakuga booru, I can find 72 different examples of Redline's superiority. But if I type in TLNP, or even its original name or japanese name, I can't find jack shit. So please, explain to me why I'm so wrong.

>>145266713
No it fucking wasn't, you mong. Like >>145266571 I was explicitly talking about Toei. Why would I bring up fucking PM? I would call it Princess Mononoke in that regard, not just Mononoke.

>>145265361
Then find another medium, I guess?

>>145266767
>You're taking these stylish nippon animated shows a bit to seriously.
Anon, take your own advice. The current bullshit happened because you blew your top first. And there are different people calling you out on it no matter how much you don't want to believe it. The other guy is right, the discussion wouldn't have gotten this heated if you weren't being such an ass in the first place.

>>145266713
Nigga, learn to read. The first time Mononoke was mentioned in this thread was in this post: >>145265722 which was specifically talking about Toei and replying to a post specifically about Toei. I'm not even that guy, I just find it ridiculous that, among the various stupid things he has said, you'd shit on him for a mistake someone else made

>>145265361

May I suggest you go Netflix and chill with some quality American sitcoms or dramas? Perhaps some Friends or CSI Miami?

>>145266796
Oh look, you're shifting the argument again. You know what, yes, you're right. You've won this argument. Good job.

>>145261033
>putting grimgar on a visual excel list of any kind after all that QUALITY
nah, i dont give a fuck how much you liked the scenery, that's bullshit
I'm not even gonna look over the rest of the list but I'm sure there's a lot more garbage on there

>>145261663
is Infinite Ryvius worth watching?

>>145266192
no, if anything you've spared yourself the inhumanity
don't bother, especially with the second season

>>145263337
Was Shirobako that good? I avoid idolshit like the plague so I didn't watch it.

File: fuck ya.jpg (53KB, 522x436px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 522x436px

>>145266849

I'm the one who's been attempting to be rational while the two of you go about your little petty anime argument.

We should all just sit back, relax, and maybe look at >>145264401 and this awesome chart in hopes that >>145265835 might some day bless us with another insightful work.

Or maybe you or the other guy could do the same as >>145265835 did an actually contribute something besides hot air for once in your lives?

Now wouldn't that be great, all that anger turned into creative energy to help other people within our collective hobby.

mind blowing shit for 4chan I must say.

>>145266704
Doubt it, there's no other genre or sub-genre I like as much as delinquents to waste my time again with something like that.

>>145267043
mediocre

>>145267059
>make aggressive post
>gets called out on it
>no, it was you who is mad, please chill, you autist!
Typical.

>>145267043
Shirobako has nothing to do with idols, it's a work drama set in the animation industry. It's a decent watch if you want to give it a try.

>>145264401
Impressive.

>>145267131
>le famous cameos show

>>145266617
Yeah, I know Deen & JC Staff have made some good stuff, I have some of their shit on my HDD. But I'm not talking about them, I'm talking Toei, the single worst contender. I said that it's great that they've made that, but they, along with the show you mentioned, are probably the literal only good shows they've made, from a quality or animation standpoint, while the rest of their stuff is literal garbage.

>>145266910
No no no, I'm not winning anything yet. Tell me why TLNP deserves a spot over Redline. I'm agreeing with you at this point, since I looked up more about it and its seemed to have an effect on animation history, but how does any of that give a spot on animated motion? Why is it SO good that it deserves a spot over Redline? Share some fucking examples already if you want me to concede on this.

>>145267059
Ironic since you're the one who most need to take the advice of your own post. Especially the 'actually contribute' part.

>>145267043
It was exceedingly competent in all aspects as an anime, tbqfh. One of the best originals in recent memory and a big surprise at the time.

>>145267198

I'm neither contributing or detracting I'm just here for the ride currently.

>>145267127

Care to share your point without relying on green text crutches?

>>145261663
>denpa teki no kanojo
>good

no

It's like the anime versions of a shitty Lifetime network movie without being "so bad it's funny", no coherent plot and gore for the sake of being edgy.

>>145261313
has anyone actually managed to watch this retard's k-on videos? i couldn't watch more than 20 seconds of it.

>>145267446
k-on is good, pleb

>>145267482
i like k-on too. doesn't mean i think it deserves a 1 hour analysis on how "deep" it is.

>>145267555
Digicuck is a moefag forgive him

>>145261033
>>Afro Samurai

Uh

>>145267175
>>145267059
Different anon here, I think I see where the problem is. Nobody was actually saying it deserves to be on the chart more than the likes of Redline. Rather, it seem that it's more like people were taking issue with you saying Toei shouldn't be on the chart at all. And what follows was people pointing out that they do have good animated motion examples because they did use to put out good stuff. As said, things like Redline was on the previous chart hence this one is supposed to be to give attention to other stuff, which you disagreed with. Seems like somewhere along the line, the points got lost and both sides are arguing about different things that happen to overlap.

>>145267446
No. Youtubers and their attention whoring bullshit should be ignored and reported at all instances.

>>145267555
This.

File: 1376464657289.jpg (63KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 900x900px

>>145267555

K-ON is objectively better than Legend of the Galactic Heroes. It is the most sophisticated anime ever created; a tour de force, the pièce de résistance of animation! LoGH is little more than plebeian dreck in comparison, its creators wishing they could have produced an anime with even an inkling of the genius contained within Our Holy K-ON. From the profound debates about eating cake, to the highly philosophical discussions about procrastination, to the marvelous musicianship exhibited by the Light Music Club, K-ON has established itself as the greatest intellectual anime. You cannot disagree unless you are a terrible person. Seriously. It's an infallible law of the universe. K-ON is a masterpiece, and we all know that K-ON has the superior tea scenes.

"A phenomenal chef-d'oeuvre. My fifteen years of work on Evangelion now feel trivial by comparison." — Anno Hideaki, esteemed anime director

"During a time of struggle, K-ON's beautiful story provided the influence needed for me to become an ideal president. I am now a better man." — Barack Obama, 44th president of the United States

"I am an uncultured lowborn with pedestrian tastes in anime." — Anonymous plebeian, speaking in reflection of his love for LoGH

>>145262644
I just realized this list doesn't have some of the most basic shit.

>>145267702
Neither. Anime reviewers are shit.

>>145267702
Grumpy Jii-san is the only worth while anime reviewer.

>>145267633
>As said, things like Redline was on the previous chart hence this one is supposed to be to give attention to other stuff, which you disagreed with.
See, that's what annoys me. As I stated in >>145265058, Redline/Stranger are still really fucking niche, to the point where hardly anyone still don't know about them. And these two anons >>145265121 >>145265429 said that it was already on the previous list and this one wasn't for repeats, but you know what I noticed? There are still some repeats between the two. Belladonna of Sadness & Mononoke are two I noticed that are still on both lists. If this is supposed to be a list to show the best examples of each category, than why you leave off obvious champions of their respective category? People are finicky, there's no gurantee they'll look at any other anime chart besides this one.

>>145267619
Afro Samurai is good, anon. And it's in the category where it shows that it's good.

>>145267633

I'm honestly just >>145266403 and I just wanted >>145266179 to more or less not be such a dick while discussing Japanimation.

File: 1401035968309.jpg (64KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 450x450px

>>145268059
>Japanimation

>>145267955
>Redline/Stranger are still really fucking niche
Really? Those two are mentioned pretty damn often. Redline for instance was one of those show that gets mentioned even among mainstream circles. Hell, even /tv/ talk about it since as far as anime is concerned, those guys only know the common stuff like Ghibli, Oshii, Kon and the likes of it.

>There are still some repeats between the two.
Blame the people in the previous threads for not being able to come up with stuff to replace it. Oh, and blame chart maker for being indecisive and vague.

>>>145268059
Also this.

>>145268101
Yeah, it should be Laotian shadow puppets.

File: toshinowhatever.jpg (96KB, 1120x702px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 1120x702px

>>145268185
It's just been a long time since I've seen that word used anywhere, let alone here.

>>145268101

I'm sorry I just felt like a throw back and didn't want to say something along the lines of "animated oriental line art fantasy picture shows".

>>145268185
But that might confuse others with Taiwanese Kung-Fu Puppets.

>>145268185
You would think its more popular, but it really fucking isn't. The typical anime watcher does not know about something like Redline or Sword of the Stranger, they only know what they see at conventions, what they watch that's airing on TV, or what they see typically talked about online or what they watch online through their various outlets streams. Redline & Stranger are not in any of those categories. They have little to no fan-art made of them (I can count the amount made for them with about 5 hands, I can count the good fanart made out of that with one). I have seen damn near no merchandise for either of them, besides the DVD or Blurays. Neither have aired on TV and you have to actively look for discussion on either one of them.

Trust me on this, because I'm the kind of guy who goes around and actively tells people about both of these movies so they can get more recognition.

>>145265155
I hope Regalia makes it into that list

File: recommended_anime_m.jpg (580KB, 1218x1642px) Image search: [Google]

580KB, 1218x1642px

>>145268761

>>145263486
No, but add Sabagebu.

>>145268761
good stuff

File: k Approved.jpg (2MB, 2011x3353px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2011x3353px

>>145263486

File: m fags b.jpg (2MB, 1648x5950px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1648x5950px

>>145265236
They sure do.

>>145269043
No Phantom:Requiem for the Phantom?

>>145268882
what the fuck

>>145263926
At least try to hide your new.

The new cinematography section is garbage. A lot of unnecessary sections too.

File: image.jpg (43KB, 310x310px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 310x310px

>>145264558
RETARD
E
T
A
R
D

>>145264066
Not really

File: 1468829751000.gif (855KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

855KB, 500x281px

>>145261033
>charts

>>145268185
The repeats are in different categories than they were were before. Guy wanting Redline and SotS wanted them back in the same category they were originally in.

>>145261663
08th MS team is not good or a classic

>>145273734
Suck a dick, 08th MS Team is great.

>>145267446
K-ON is the pinnacle of moe but he's being overly autistic and retarded about when talking about it.

>>145267043
The thing with Shirobako is you can tell the staff put a lot of heart into it, as it tells a big amount of the problems they have to face themselves to make an anime series.

>>145269206
Everytime I see Reideen the Superior I just think its like a businessman saw how popular Saint Seiya or even Yoroiden Samurai Troopers was and decide to make a show like that with constant intentional manservice not realizing that the people watching the shows for that reason prefer subtlety.

>>145267043
Shirobako was excellent, and has nothing to do with idols, I don't even know how you would get that idea.

File: Heisei Busou Seigidan (Complete).zip-[Neptise] Heisei Busou Seigidan (Yamaguchi Takayuki)-heisei busou seigidan c1 - 028-029.png (579KB, 1408x1024px) Image search: [Google]

579KB, 1408x1024px

>>145264401
Decided to check out Heisei Busou Seigidan because of the craziness level and holy shit, it's by the same guy who did Apocalypse Zero. It gets better with every page.

>>145261033
>This was finished yesterday.
Great. Hope this will be the last thread of this cancer.

>>145262376
God bless who made this, I love how OPM is deservedly in there.

>>145261033
>that giant fucking spoiler for Texhnolyze

>>145263755
FLCL is fucking trash with shit characters.

File: 1408398301214.jpg (1016KB, 3484x2148px) Image search: [Google]

1016KB, 3484x2148px

>>145267799
speaking of grumpy jii-san

>>145267004
Yes
Ikumi did nothing wrong

File: grumpy jii san.jpg (2MB, 2004x2805px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2004x2805px

>>145277355

>>145261119
>gg

>>145263755
WOAH DUDE ITS LIKE DIFFERENT PEOPLE LIKE DIFFERENT THINGS DID I ENTER THE TWILIGHT ZONE? XDDD FUCK YOU FAGGOT

>>145277355
>Planetes
>3.5 stars
did moot killed ji san?

>>145261033
At last. Looks good.

>>145268559
Bullshit. I've got friend's who are way outside the anime community who've seen both of those and basically nothing else. Any circle even vaguely interested in quality international films includes them on the list of "must watch". Heck, I know Sword of the Stranger had a limited theater run around here. Redline is literally the first movie normal-fags watch.

Also the chart is meant to be supplementary to the 2013 list, not a replacement. It's not a top 10 list.

>>145261033
>>145261213
The progression from 2013 to 2016 in what picks were made for each version pretty much proves that /a/ has become r/anime 2.0.

File: hqdefault.jpg (16KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 480x360px

>>145280202
The only difference is he's not banned

>>145280202
There is an older version of the chart here
>>145277583

>>145280354
I've watched/read over 95% of the stuff in that chart. I don't need these things. I was just commenting on board culture and what dreck is being pushed at the top now. The uniformization of the internet continues apace I guess. I guess 3 years from now, /a/ will be indistinguishable from facebook.

>>145280504
Its the natural result of multiple charts being created that people want to have different info than the other one.

>>145269043
That's the old one, faggot.

WHERE'RE THE MANGA CHARTS?

>>145280793
>reading manga
In all serious I have no idea if OP was also creating a manga chart as well.

>>145280504
Thinking about it, I agree. A lot of these don't really belong on a general commendation list, even if they excel in the specified category.

Seriously who would actually recommend Fafner, Etotama, Roling Girls, or Mine Fujiko? They were all mediocre at best. Also, I never watched the Tamako movie because the anime was fairly unremarkable. Same goes for the Exorcist movie or the One Piece movie, a recommendation list shouldn't really contain things that require a lot of investment in mediocre material before they're worth watching.

And there are a few other bad picks beyond that, it seems like a bad idea to put shows from the past year on the list. Gotta wait for the hype to die down so they can be judged more reasonably.

What I'm saying is that if I were to show this list to a friend, I would have to cross half of it off first. And asterisk half the remainder. Seems like a pretty crap list to me.

>>145261313
Can someone post this again?

>>145281140
this again?

>>145281140
No. Fuck off.

>>145281140
Yes

>>145281240
No, fuck you. I can't find it I'm the archives

>>145281444
If you're the archives look into your mind and find it there.

>>145281478
>>>/reddit/

>>145261119
Didn't Kujibiki Unbalance become an actual OVA that was sold with the DVDs for it's mother series?

>>145281478
I cannot do that because I have never laid eyes on it before, as it was deleted before I could and therefore is not stored with my mind's library of information. However this problem could be rectified if someone posted what was deleted into this thread thread again.

>>145263368
Inconceivable that that dude might have an opinion of himself.
He must have gotten it from a website you hate!

>>145281444
Good. And fuck off.

>>145281534
Fuck off back to /v/ if you care so much about some anime reviewer.

>>145281496
Don't blame me, blame the guy who typed it.

>>145274994
Yeah it's pretty nuts to say The least.

File: Readyourpostagainbaka.png (797KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

797KB, 1280x720px

>>145281534
You aren't a very good archive then.

>>145281444
>>>/youtube/
>>>/reddit/

>>145281502
Yes, it was

File: tatami galaxy.png (2MB, 1181x664px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1181x664px

>>145261033
>suggested twice Tatami Galaxy when the list was in progress
>didn't put it
some problem with it fagget?

>>145262376

ahahhahahahahhahhahahhhahahhha

jesus anon, you want to kill me by making me laught to death?

>>145261033
Is there a high quality version of texhnolyze anywhere?

The version i have looks like shit but fuck it was good.

>>145282269
Probably

>>145282343
Thanks anon, nice to know it's out there.

>>145281137
>a general commendation list
it isn't.

>>145282443
Fair, I misspoke. I should have said any recommendation list. If something excels at one aspect but is otherwise terrible I don't think it should be recommended at all. With exceptions for the very pinnacle of a specialization. The question still stands, if someone right now walked up to you and asked for a 3DCG show, could you recommend Etotama with a strait face?

>>145268882
>pilot candidate
It was one of the first anime I ever dropped.

I don't know how it made it onto TV.

>>145282793
>weekly animation/sakuga/isCGshitorthefuture thread
>uneducated newfag tries to join discussion
>tell him to diversify his experience before opening his whore mouth again

In that context the chart is perfectly fine for example.

File: 1453458552402.jpg (1MB, 1965x1905px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1965x1905px

I heard you galz were little girls

File: cat dora.webm (3MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 480x270px

>>145282793
yes, also the cg in etotama is animated nicely

File: 20120213-thebiglist-IC.png (280KB, 1690x2086px) Image search: [Google]

280KB, 1690x2086px

"chart"? List, I guess.

File: 1272731441327.jpg (1MB, 846x4825px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 846x4825px

>>145283186
That one I had saved because I thought it was funny
The fags that posted it got b& for making the thread.
/mu/ a shit

File: 1414611058841.jpg (3MB, 5000x5000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 5000x5000px

What's the newest version of this one? I have about 5 different iterations of it.

File: 1317026630962.jpg (2MB, 2200x3400px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2200x3400px

>>145283231
If you have the one with "No Gendo No Life" in rainbow font, that's the newest one as far as I know.

File: 1406937100214.jpg (4MB, 6000x6000px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 6000x6000px

>>145283231
This one i think, but you are supposed to add to it.

>>145283004
Sure, but that isn't the only context it's going to be viewed in. If that were the case the chart should only include best of or most influential rather than being an addendum to previous charts. Previous picks have been explicitly excluded because of that. As is it'd be better to slap them with one of those rather than this chart. Seems to me each chart should stand on its own. If there isn't enough content to fill it, don't fill it.

File: 1412362237082.jpg (983KB, 1650x1510px) Image search: [Google]

983KB, 1650x1510px

There've been so many shorts lately this one needs an update. Maybe that can be /a/'s next project, of course Luluco is getting put on there. but so should the good shit like Wakako-Zake and "I can't understand what my Husband is Saying"

>>145283346
We do not exist in a vacuum, neither do charts.

And nobody denies that it's an incremental version.

>>145283312
>but you are supposed to add to it.
>to a jpeg
My CDO would not allow it.

File: 1316805841435.png (2MB, 1084x1655px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1084x1655px

This chart is as perfect now as it's ever been

>>145283448
Part of my point is that we aren't working in a vacuum. Just being above average in the category should not be enough to earn a spot if it's garbage in ever other aspect. If it's the absolute best in that catagory, sure. I'm not saying make the same chart over and over. I'm saying that if there isn't enough good content to build a new chart yet, don't put mediocre stuff on it just to fill the space.

>>145264401
Excellent list, lots of stuff here I haven't checked out.
Wouldn't classify Buraiden Gai as deliquent manga though. Sure the main character is a deliquent, but not in the same way as the classic ones which are meant when you say "deliquent" (high school setting, pompadours etc).

File: jinrui_wa_suitai_shimashita-11-watashi-student-distressed-panic-cute.jpg (64KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 1280x720px

>parody chart has anime on it that you like

File: Short Anime 2.jpg (2MB, 1655x3600px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1655x3600px

>>145283355
Well there was an update some time ago.

>>145283753
but most things on the chart aren't garbage in all other aspects. some are average, sure, but it's not like the chart is full of dogshit like troll charts.

File: entry level anime.jpg (570KB, 1800x1556px) Image search: [Google]

570KB, 1800x1556px

This is one of my favorites.

>>145283960
Well damn, must have missed it
Good to have this though (despite it having a lot of medicore series in it), thanks.


>>145284094
How many layers of irony?

>>145261033
Celebrate what ? your autism ?

>>145265352
>This is supposed to be a chart to reccomend to people who haven't watched anime what the absolute best examples of each category is.
That's where you're wrong.

File: Old Anime.jpg (634KB, 884x800px) Image search: [Google]

634KB, 884x800px

I never found part#2

Anyone have the shounen protag quotes chart?

>>145284430
nope, only the villains

>>145261033
>>145261213
2016 CG column is trash compared to the 2013 one

File: Quotes.jpg (2MB, 3663x2304px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3663x2304px

>>145284430

>>145284602
Post it anyway.

File: 1433441189214.png (240KB, 432x429px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 432x429px

>>145284608
Good thing one chart isn't meant to replace the other
Use both and split the difference

>>145283765
Yeah guess you're right but I took The delinquent term in a more literal way and not just The iconic 80's style. There aré several manga in the chart that stretch The concept of delinquency as well as others that evolved into more modern delinquents, which means no pompadour or bosozoku, like Saru Lock, Gang King, shonan seven, a-bout!

File: image.png (2MB, 973x972px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 973x972px

>>145261313
>>145281140
Didnt see it but I'm guessing it is this.

File: villains.jpg (1MB, 2455x1939px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2455x1939px

>>145284657

>>145284608
both contain trash in my opinion
>semi-realistic shading
>anime
might as well post pixar shit

>>145281565
Digibro isn't really a reviewer. And I don't know why you guys hate him, there really isn't anyone else on the internet that makes content who has close to the wealth of knowledge and perspectives Digibro has with anime

File: 1469414376432.gif (564KB, 800x430px) Image search: [Google]

564KB, 800x430px

>>145263337
>2015
>trying to deny the existence of the polls

>>145284040
Well, I guess it might be better to move into specifics then.

From Nature scenery I'd absolutely pull RDG and Grimgar, haven't actually seen Grimgar yet so I'm not going to comment on how well it uses scenic shots. This is just due to the one year thing I mentioned a few posts up. I'd rather wait until everyone's gotten over it so it can be compared fairly and objectively without the hype and drama of it being relatively new. Also what ends up being memorable isn't always immediately apparent. Case point being Kyoani's urban fantasy show with the blood swords. I recall that having some fairly fantastic shots, but it hasn't made any lists I'm aware of, and rightly so.

In RDG's case, it was a very bland story. I finished it back when it aired but I can barely remember it now. It was almost the definition of unexceptional. I can't recommend it based on narrative merits or "fun" merits. And I don't recall any one scene that was so pretty that I absolutely needed to show someone. Further, scenic shots don't really compliment the narrative. Again, I'm a bit fuzzy, but as I recall the story is a bullied shy school girl turns out to be a goddess and saves all her friends. Scenery pron doesn't really add much to that.

Contrast with Non non Biyori. There are tons of great shots, but more importantly, those shots enhanced the simple country life atmosphere that has made the show so popular. For another example of this, see the 2013 chart. Mushishi is among the greatest examples of using scenic shots to set the tone of a narrative, even outside of anime.

As to the other two, I don't recall that many excellent shots in Akagami, but they do serve the narrative and the main character very well. I would review it again and get a larger consensus before giving it the spot. I dropped Fishlips around 2 episodes before the big apocalyptic shindig went down. Been meaning to pick it back up. Seems like it earned the spot but obviously I'm not a fair judge in it's case.

>>145275831
comedy has 3 Kumeta shows

>>145263752
Actually Ranked #6666 For reals.

>>145285804
>Case point being Kyoani's urban fantasy show with the blood swords. I recall that having some fairly fantastic shots, but it hasn't made any lists I'm aware of, and rightly so.
KnK comes up in visuals discussions at least. So it fits the bill. But i agree that it wasn't very memorable beyond that.

>RDG
Heh. I'm actually responsible for suggesting that. I only did it to fill a spot. I expect other people to feel compelled to post something better.


Anyway, if your argument is that not all shows excel on multiple facets at the same time, then I don't disagree.

But the 2013 version has a few meh shows too. Nerewareta Gakuen and Fantastia Dolls for example.
And iblard jikan has no story at all. It's just a sequence of paintings with a bit of animation sprinkled in.
GitS innocence is also a mixed bag, sure, the CG sequences are convey some sense of awe, but they also stick out like a sore thumb stylistically. And let's not forget the terrible sequence in the shop.

>>145284608
But Precure CG is actually really good. Its got a lot more expression and energy than most other anime CG out there, especially cel shaded.

>>145287385
While I don't agree on the technical achievement basis, the movie did that retarded shiny shading and the EDs are too little content to qualify for anything, it would be cheating.

>>145287518
Hopefully they expand the CG in later movies to be the full length thing and not just a third. Still, it's worth a look at in terms of what can currently be achieved.

>>145286897
I don't mean to imply the 2013 chart is perfect either. But that one's already set in stone so I can't properly bitch about it. Also I don't mean to just pick on RDG, a few of the other categories are way more egregious but this one was in the first column and had the obvious counterpoint sitting right next to it on the chart.

Apart from the 3D Captain Harlock, I gave a fair shot to and dropped every single thing in the 2016 3D catagory. I honestly don't think anything 3D deserves to be on the chart right now. I know they're trying to make 3D and anime work, and if Berserk is any indicator, they're starting to get a little better, but for now it's all just crap.

Outside the CG and Nature columns, I'd take issue with Blue Exorcist, Yami Shibai, Berserk, OP6, Tamako, Lupin, and Kagewani. Though I don't mean to say that I'm absolutely right I am, your taste is shit, etc. about all of them or that I've necessarily picked everything that needs to be pulled.

Positive note for the chart, I haven't actually seen anything in this particular experimental column. Which is a weird given how much crap I've watched over the years. So I'm gonna have give a few of those a go.

>>145287518
that's supposed to be
>While I do agree

Negations are the worst typos

>>145287952
So you agree that the 2013 chart doesn't just contain flawless gems. But expect the 2016 one to do?

>I honestly don't think anything 3D deserves to be on the chart right now.
Think of it as grading a class in the school for special children. They're all retards, but a few show enough promise that they might lead an unassisted live one day.

>and if Berserk is any indicator, they're starting to get a little better
That's sarcasm, yes?

>>145288207
>2013
Yup, something being crap in the past doesn't mean it's alright to make it crap now.

>Retard Art
You wouldn't take retarded children's art and put it on public display would you? This chart is supposed to be examples of excellence, not examples of things that are embarrassment to their creators.

As to Berserk, compared to Sidonia it's an improvement. And compared to CG a decade ago it's on a whole different level. Hence "little better". Don't get me wrong. The manga is beautiful and the fact that it's getting such an ugly adaption is a travesty. But the industry high water mark is getting better.

>>145280793

>>145264401

>>145288671
>As to Berserk, compared to Sidonia it's an improvement.
you should see a doctor, your eyes must be failing you

>>145238066

>>145289017
That is pretty fucking awful. Again, I am not defending Nip 3D. I said it is all terrible and has no place on a best of chart. However, compare to Sidonia s1. As I recall without fps modification it was near unwatchable whenever things started moving.

>>145289248
Sidonia was somewhere between steaming shit and barely tolerable.
Berserk is just steaming shit, sprayed up your nostrils.

File: 1454094265197.png (83KB, 261x234px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 261x234px

>>145283312
>those ara aras
Every time.