>literally a shitty version of Beck with an all girl cast

At least K-On didn't have shitty engrish like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOTFEL4fjX4

here's your reply

File: mugi (22).jpg (35KB, 625x351px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 625x351px

>>143825065
You take that back.

K-On has better Music and better Animation though.

>>143825161
Beck is a manga faggot. If you're gonna judge something judge it's source material.

File: yande.re 183629 sample horiguchi_yukiko k-on! tainaka_ritsu.jpg (237KB, 1174x1500px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 1174x1500px

I am literally going to marry Ritsu.

>>143825269
Good idea

>>143825204
>If you're gonna judge something judge it's source material.
>posts a picture from the anime
I truly see

>>143825204
If you are posting a picture of K-On anime promo material, I will naturally think that you are comparing Anime.
> If you're gonna judge something judge it's source material.
Why should I? Especially with a story about music, the premise of it gets better represented by a medium that actually has music in it.

File: 1437353105109.jpg (109KB, 922x940px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 922x940px

Why do people think You is lazy and dumb when she became really good at guitar to the point of having perfect rhytm and muting technique in the shortest amount of time possible through nothing but pure determination, without being a stuckup tryhard about it like Azusa?

Yui is truly the most admirable girl.

>>143825065
Idk man I don't see the similarities. Plus beck is generally hit or miss, moon phase wasn't bad but did you hear his new single? Jesus it's bad

File: 1439994711768.jpg (47KB, 255x247px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 255x247px

>>143825161
>better Music
>better Animation
Pick one.

>>143825381
Better music and animation.

>>143825139
I read that as "You take that black."

File: yande.re 147967 disc_cover horiguchi_yukiko k-on! screening seifuku tainaka_ritsu.jpg (596KB, 1876x1832px) Image search: [Google]

596KB, 1876x1832px

Friendly reminder:
Ritsu is best girl.

File: 1416167232576.png (78KB, 268x237px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 268x237px

>>143825399

>>143825381
Music quality is open to opinions, animation isn't.

Thanks for proving you don't know what animation means

>>143825381
I pick both,
because beck had shitty animation, while K-On had amazing animation.
And K-On had really impressive Music,
not only from a technical standpoint.
If you would actually play an Instrument, you would know this though.

Full moon sway>>>everything in trash ass k on

RANK THE KEION FINAL MIXTAPE TRACKS

God tier:
ふわふわ時間
ふでペン ～ボールペン～
ぴゅあぴゅあはーと
U&I
ごはんはおかず

Great tier:
わたしの恋はホッチキス
いちごパフェが止まらない
ときめきシュガー
五月雨20ラブ

Mid tier:
カレーのちライス
Honey sweet time
冬の日

K-On! is the MLP of anime except it is specifically made for autists.

>>143825457
What's the point of having amazing animation? When it's applied to such mundane scenes it becomes absurd.

File: 1442709880875.png (898KB, 1500x1430px) Image search: [Google]

898KB, 1500x1430px

If I wanted to go watch a shitty band play I'd go see Tool live

>>143825737
>Whats the point of being better?
Fun things are fun.
I like looking at good animation,
and I'm happy that kyo-ani like producing good animation.

>>143825680
this

File: 1450118350627.jpg (193KB, 881x675px) Image search: [Google]

193KB, 881x675px

>>143825737
Its called a narrative, plotfag

>>143825847
>expecting manimefags to understand anything other than "dude woah badass he called that guy a motherfucker"

>>143825680
but mlp is bad

>>143825944
I wouldn't know. I haven't watched it so I don't voice my opinion on it. What I find funny is people who never give something a proper chance nor actually bother to analyse it voicing such strong opinions in regards to said something. Seems like the epitome of dumbassery to me.

File: 86.gif (2MB, 250x188px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 250x188px

>>143825737
You're a fucking idiot.

File: 56546546.png (893KB, 1280x738px) Image search: [Google]

893KB, 1280x738px

>>143825397
ok u

>>143825453
>I don't agree with this guy so I'll just accuse him of not knowing what animation means when I'm the one that actually doesn't!

>>143825457
>Fuwa Fuwa Time!
You're baiting right? K-On! barely focused on trying to learn how to play an instrument. Sure they spent time choosing an guitar, changing strings and such but the majority of the anime was just them drinking tea while nearly everything went their way. Then again K-On! is literally just a show about girls starting up a band purely for fun in school, nothing else and that's fine. But to go and say that K-On! is better from a "technical standpoint"? As far as I'm concerned Beck is far more realistic. You should actually try learning an instrument and try forming a band outside a school club and get experience before you start talking out of your ass.

>>143826082
>I don't agree with this guy so I'll just accuse him of not knowing what animation means when I'm the one that actually doesn't!
Sure convinced me with those hot opinions. Where are the facts? K-On has better animation than Beck, it's a fact. If you disagree you're the one having no fucking idea of what he's talking about.

Again

K-ON! is a masterpiece.

One of the highest points of the medium.

>>143826082
>But to go and say that K-On! is better from a "technical standpoint"?
I'm talking about the actual music featured.
Beck features ok songs, but technically they aren't very advanced.
In this manner it's pretty realistic, since beck are just some kids, and the songs are something kids could come up with.
But if you listen to the songs in K-On, something like go go maniac, you can immediately recognize that they are not only really creative, but also much more advanced on a technical level.

>You should actually try learning an instrument
I play guitar for around 7 years.

File: opinion - fact.jpg (16KB, 324x271px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 324x271px

>>143826219
>If you disagree you're the one having no fucking idea of what he's talking about.
Is this denial I'm sensing?

>>143826357
I agree but Go Go Maniac is not a canon song of the band.

>>143825999
I've watched the first two seasons and it's bad.

File: large.gif (429KB, 500x224px) Image search: [Google]

429KB, 500x224px

>>143826385
I'm fairly sure you're just trolling at this point, because your posts are pointless.

Nearly every scene in K-On is well animated. KyoAni took special care to animate the music parts correctly so you'd be able see the girls playing their notes the way it should be.

Now I'm gonna dumb gifs because I have nothing better to do.

>>143825737
>When it's applied to such mundane scenes it becomes absurd.
What do you mean?

File: 1467627799484.jpg (2MB, 2011x3000px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2011x3000px

>>143825269
>>143825419
I love Ritsu!! I love all the Kaions!!

anyone who shits on K-On never watched it or is a retard

File: 876.gif (1MB, 320x180px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 320x180px

>>143826585
*dump

>tfw filesize too large

>>143826708
they are CG here, some damm good anime i'll tell ya.

Beck has better writing.

File: 3432.gif (1MB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 320x240px

>>143826745
Rotoscoped, actually.

You know 3D animation and rotoscoping can look awful as hell too, right? And yet KyoAni still nailed it and made it look great.

>>143825125
the movie had plenty of engrish

>>143826745
That was my one issue with LL, the CG was meh though, too robotic.

ITT:K on fags only praising the animation knowing full well the plotline and characters are fucking shit

>>143825737
>only anime with epic battles can have amazing animation
I hope I'm replying to a Berserkfag too

K-On is and will always be bad, no matter what you say. It's about retarded autist girls who drink tea and eat sweets everyday saying fun things are fun and then they ocassionally play some music.
It was made for autist manchildren and it will be liked by autist manchildren.
That's it.
Btw I watched the first season and it was awful, there is no way I can stomach another one.

>>143826932
>ITT my shitty uniformed opinionated argument failed so I'll just drop that and spew something else equally retarded instead to save face

Wow they weren't macho enough for you ergo they're shit man can't argue with that.

File: c5a.jpg (36KB, 512x572px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 512x572px

>>143826932
>>143826940
I could write an essay of how K-On is at the same level as Cowboy Bebop but I won't because you retards will say
>lol no
Have a smug K-On

>Beck
Best story
Best music
>K-ON
Best girls
Best instruments
Best character songs
Best animation

>>143827047
>at the same level as Cowboy Bebop
That's not saying much to be honest. Bebop's entire selling point was style.

>>143826932
>>143826940
>called out for being an idiot
>continue to talk shit

Just leave already
We all know K-On is generic. It doesn't make it any less great, because it's still a wonderful, very simple SoL and it doesn't try to be anything it's not. It's part of why it works so well.

Not your cup of tea? awesome, but don't come here stating your opinions as fact when it's clear you have no idea of what you're talking about.

>>143825065
>moetrash is for autistic manchildren
gee, who knew.

K on manga>>>>>> Anime

>>143827104
>Bebop's entire selling point was style.
Simpleton.

K-On is better than Eva too, it is just not better than EoE but it is close.

>>143827131
You'd have to be genuinely braindead to believe this.

File: 1444514777377.jpg (24KB, 325x327px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 325x327px

>>143827139
Great argument there you sure convinced me.

>>143827180
>EoE
>good

Really, nobdy is putting much effort into your shitty bait so you're actually being this desperate now?

>>143827248
what makes EoE not good?

>>143827182
Manga is always better than anime newfag.

Anime character designs were plagued by kyoani shit.

>it's a contrarian faggot tries to pretend that k-on isn't the best anime ever made episode

>>143826357
>Crap, I can't stop, won't stop. Morning, noon and night I'm singing so loud
>more advanced
Look, I'm not trying to say their music is "bad" but their songs sound like they were written by little girls (which is what it's supposed to be). How is that more advanced? Beck's music developed and you know, sounded like real music. I wonder why Beck's music is praised much more.

>>143826585
You know they did that for Beck too, right? You sure showed me.

File: 1467398480070.gif (480KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 600x450px

>tfw i'll happily be going about my day and then i'll remember that k-on is over and most of the girls went to high school and i'll never watch a show like that ever again
why did i have to marathon it all so fast bros.

>>143827305
>Crap, I can't stop, won't stop. Morning, noon and night I'm singing so loud
That's some Twisted Sister shit right there and I'm definitely not praising it.

File: anime and manga.png (51KB, 500x385px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 500x385px

>>143827248
>lol le bait xd
why is real discussion /a/ so fucking terrible?

File: 1306409384195.jpg (43KB, 512x572px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 512x572px

>>143827287
Like I said, braindead.

>>143827396
Yeah because you posting 5-12 word generic statements providing nothing insightful to start a discussion and only serving to provoke reactions is quality discussion right there and obviously not bait.

Kill yourself, retard.

>>143827457
Tough Luck, pal.

File: 1462043261381.jpg (335KB, 1031x1500px) Image search: [Google]

335KB, 1031x1500px

>>143826629
>>143826629
Anyone got more pics like this

I've got some for Hibike but none for K-on

>>143825065
>literally

>>143825125
That's why you watch the dub which is actually good.

>>143825065
Reminder that Kids on The Slope is better than this even though they're different genre and the comparison itself is stupid.

>>143825605
This.

File: [cj nf] K-On!! 27 [0E0A99F0].mkv_snapshot_10.14_[2011.03.21_09.47.40].jpg (219KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

219KB, 1280x720px

>>143825065
It's literally a totally different show with the only common factor being music. Comparing them is stupid.

File: 1453395092716.jpg (65KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 1280x720px

K on is Kyoani's worst anime.

Worst fanbase too.

File: 1446476663829.gif (568KB, 240x291px) Image search: [Google]

568KB, 240x291px

>tfw K-On is too deep for these plebs to understand

>>143827537
Agreed.

>>143827305
>dumbing down music to it's lyrics
anon..
My point still stands,
the musical content of the K-On songs is more advanced.
For a series about music, this is probably a big plus.

>>143827566
Eh, I can live with arrangements, and slopekids did it well, but ultimately I enjoy original pieces more.

>>143827651
No, their worst anime is AIR.

>>143827702
Worse yet
>dumbing down music to TRANSLATED lyrics
>translated lyrics from two completely different linguistic families

>>143825125
I dont know what your talking about I talk like that all the time

>>143827651
Worst anime is Phantom World.

Worst fan base is Hyouka.

>>143827878
Hyouka has a fanbase?

>>143827925
Troll smarter not harder. No one is going to take you seriously when you unironically use moetrash. All that shows is that you don't know anything about anime.

>>143827651
will hyouka ever get a season 2? or is that considered an 'ending'?

I would watch k on if it had a male mc.

Female protags are an ultimate No.

>>143827986
It's an adaptation newfag, they only adapted what they could.

Go read the novels or something.

File: 1459828887121.jpg (225KB, 770x750px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 770x750px

>>143828075
Don't call me newfag anon, rude

>>143828028
Female protags are always best for slice of life. FACT

>>143828028
Why?

>>143828028
> Hi, I am stuck in a closet

File: enough.png (235KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

235KB, 500x500px

>>143827702
Except the series had barely anything to do with music.

File: beck-mongolian-chop-squad-volume-4-20071210003057906-000.jpg (122KB, 460x345px) Image search: [Google]

122KB, 460x345px

>>143825065

Beck is terrible, the story is retarded and characters have that ugly faces all the fucking time.

File: minami-43_animestockscom.jpg (25KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 640x480px

>>143825065

Beck
>average japanese teen turn in the most celebrated musician of the 20th century but his girlfriend Maho ruined everything.

K-on is not for manchildren....

>>143830661
It's commonly loved by 30 yo's

>>143830748
So is cake

Is that for manchildren?

I liked K-ON!. OP can suky suky my diky diky

beck is superior honestly