Dunkino general https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlX jP59jZCM

>>85531816

the soundtrack for this reminded me of Gallipoli and the first Halo

WHERE'S THE BLOODY AIRFORCE?

File: burning spitfire.jpg (285KB, 1125x1252px) Image search: [Google]

285KB, 1125x1252px

>>85532392

He's busy crashing the plane
with one survivor who's plan was to get caught

File: 1346421396476.png (42KB, 101x162px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 101x162px

>>85532906
>Your face when Bravo Nolan directs a sequel to Dunkirk where Tom Hardy stages a revolution and takes over Berlin by threatening to detonate Hitler's secret nuclear bomb unless they obey his every command.
>Your face when he detonates the bomb anyway and the film ends with an old man closing a book surrounded by awe-struck children whereupon he says "And that's how we won the war."
>Your face when it wins an Oscar.

>>85533577

>Predicting the future with dubs

We will stand and applaud when it happens.

>>85532906
I looked around the theatre at that moment to see if anyone was ecstatic as me because of the sheer amount of on-screen Nolan baneposting tipping.

I like to think that a fellow /tv/ autist was there also internally appreciating all the meme magic going on.

Just saw this like 10 minutes ago. Rate it 7/10
>50% of shots are of people just staring in to the sea with big sorry sad eyes
Yeah ok...

>>85531816
>Dunkirk

Are you fucking kidding me? It's Dunkerque.

>>85533666
categorically false

go back to /co/mblr

File: 1501136540422.png (271KB, 647x340px) Image search: [Google]

271KB, 647x340px

Is the boy alright?

>>85533666
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cN3yrJP24-I

t. pleb

>>85533817
poor George

RIP in peace

Did anyone else notice the reference to The Prestige with all the hats?

>>85533817
He's useful, sir

>>85533666
t. woman

>>85533817
rip

>>85531816
the moment when they were cheering the RAF sent chills down my spine t b q h

Best film of the year?

>>85536316
It's fucking shit

>>85536802
Ahh the pleb filter is working. Dance runt, dance.

>>85536802
You're fucking shit you cunt

>>85536316
yes

cried at the end. was shaken for 20 mins after. gave me a new outlook on life. brotherhood. i love this country. pakis and wogs out. the french barricade scene was dripping with tension it was so good and so eerie. the whole thing. masterpiece.

>>85536845
>>85536884
Nolan is a hack. His films wouldn't have any impact at all without the Hans Zimmer music blasting nonstop in the background.

File: image.jpg (54KB, 640x632px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 640x632px

>>85533817
>mfw one direction said, "he's dead, m8"

>>85533817
I thought it was interesting how the son figures out it's best to lie to him and the dad gives him a look like 'you did the right thing'.

Too bad not enough people bring up that scene and instead go on rants about muh backstory

Hanz Zimmer is honestly one of the most talented people in the world. You see how he ripped the coachella set?

>build huge amounts of extreme tension and suspense with spitfire dog fight
>instantly cut to harry styles eating jam on toast on a boat

B R A V O
R
A
V
O

File: Screen Shot 2017-07-27 at 23.52.32.png (311KB, 738x405px) Image search: [Google]

311KB, 738x405px

>>85533817
>he's dead mate

Where the fuck is the blood?

I mean, it's a fucking war film

Fucking trash movie. t/v/ is so low IQ these days.

File: Screen Shot 2017-07-27 at 23.55.17.png (853KB, 1121x721px) Image search: [Google]

853KB, 1121x721px

>>85537836
>play ticking clock non stop
>MOST KINO PERSON ON EARTH

>>85537999
Digits of truth!

BREXIT WAS THE RIGHT CHOICE

>>85537999
>low IQ
>Browses /tv/

>>85537369
What about this made you cry at all? Possibly one of the least emotional war movies out there.

>>85537369
almost cried too and not even british

it shows us what hardships life can really give and what peaceful times we live in, we're spoiled

>>85533817
>"The boy done kirked his head."

Nolan is a hack

Based froggo did nothing wrong.

File: dun-kirked_his_head.jpg (29KB, 568x310px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 568x310px

Help! Help! George has dun kirked his head!

>>85537962

>Then be careful with him

Damn....

>>85531816

is this "women will never understand" tier?

>>85537804
Yeah I liked that bit. A real father-son moment. You dont get many genuine ones in cinema like that

Last I can think of is "That'll do piggy, that'll do" from Babe (1995)

>>85538537
woman who sat next to me was actually yawning
stupid bitch

File: IMG_2235.jpg (1MB, 4032x3024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 4032x3024px

>>85532906

Why does he wear the mask?

>>85538537

>>85538537
My girlfriend enjoyed it
She went in for Harry Styles, came out liking Nolan

>>85538814
why didn't he throw himself out of the plane?

>>85538537
>Bravery
>Self-sacrifice
>Stoicism

It's the exact opposite of the average woman

I just got back from it.

I enjoyed it but what a strange movie.

I was pretty emotionless the entire film until the end when they hit it heavy with the feels

>>85538979

That'll do pig, that'll do

>>85539070

Oh I liked it. I actually just finished it too.

I had an entire IMAX theater to myself! (Minus 2 other random people)

>>85537393
>his films are bad because he effectively utilizes a component of filmmaking
Really makes you think

>>85538979
>She went in for Harry Styles, came out liking Nolan
Same here.

but no gf

>>85531816
Who here wishes /r/blacksonmyfamily was more active?

I really loved Dunkirk, and I think it's a perfect example to show the difference between what a proper film is, and other forms of video as entertainment. You really need to be in a cinema to appreciate it, if you watched Dunkirk on tv, or a plane, or a laptop it just wouldn't be the same experience.

The IMAX showing I went to had the sound system completly crash in the last 10 minutes, so I have no idea what was going on with the montage at the end. I got that kid got a mention in newspaper and Hardy got captured by ze Germans, but I couldn't really figure out what the other characters were doing.

They gave everyone free IMAX tickets as compensation, but im not going to use them on Dunkirk again. I might see it at a regular cinema if it's cheap enough.

>>85539679
Mate if there's one film worth seeing twice it's Dunkirk.

>>85538537
My gf said she enjoyed it and wants to see it again

File: JUVE.png (1MB, 1132x608px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1132x608px

>>85539679
>but im not going to use them on Dunkirk again.

What happened to the french guy?

>>85540124

>my girlfriend enjoyed it
>she wants to see it again

RARE

>>85540505
Drowned in the boat that was shot at.

I thought this movie was just alright and there's nothing you fags can do to change my mind! HAHAHAHA!

The shrieks of those 109s will stay with me for a while.

Also, the opening shot of the lined men on the beach is the single most surreal scene in a war movie I have ever seen.

>>85539679
Last ten minutes are generic hamfest dialogue about how they'll get them next time and that war is honor and such. Definitely the weakest part of the movie, so you didn't miss much.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUpvEgJEn94
Kino soundtrack

>>85540935
>One of the most famous war speeches in the world is the "weakest part" of the movie.
Literally go kill yourself

>>85540935
it's churchhill you f-grade troll

File: 1497937800776.jpg (68KB, 805x935px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 805x935px

>>85537965

>>85541039
>>85541034
It wasn't presented well by any means. Fight me.

>>85533817
hes only gone and bumped his noggin down below guv

>>85540869

>the shrieks of those 109s
>109s

They were JU-87 Stukas that strafed the lads on the beaches

File: 72c.jpg (18KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 600x450px

>>85540935
>generic hamfest dialogue

>>85540935
I'm going to cave your fucking skull in you stupid nigger

>>85540935
>this is the average intelligence of a Redditor

>>85541088
It's rude to fight mentally retarded people.

>>85541443
>this is the average intelligence of a /tv/ poster

ftfy

>>85540935
I hope you know that your ancestors probably hate your guts.

hes on me

>>85533817
>>85537699
>>85537962
Play this song to remember him by.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kqQDCxRCzM

>>85531816
HE'S ON ME

I'M ON HIM

>>85538537
my mom liked it a lot but idk if that's a good example

young women will probably hate it for the most part

Official Thread Theme

https://youtu.be/9Yw5jkAHgME

File: image.jpg (40KB, 288x400px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 288x400px

>>85542266
>One Direction

>>85542367

Kek

File: rev.jpg (73KB, 960x960px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 960x960px

>tfw like Harry Styles now

>>85540935
sorry about the autism lad

tough condition for you to have at such a young age

>>85542563
Just a sign of the times m8.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qN4ooNx77u0

>>85542563
He played a true brit cunt, decent performance, blended in quite nicely.

>>85542563
wtf I like harry styles now

>>85542436
That used to be my alarm theme a few years back.

File: tom-hardy-working-dogfight-in-dunkirk-movie.jpg (268KB, 1280x853px) Image search: [Google]

268KB, 1280x853px

>>85542613
>Why are we always stuck and running from. The bullets? The bullets
>Just stop your crying. It's a sign of the times. We gotta get away from here

hmmmmmm

>>85542728
I'M ON HIM

Just watched it today, it was bretty gud, I actually like how the story was told with minimal dialogue and didn't turn into typical war movie that ends on a love story nobody cares about.

>>85542728

>BaneBurningHisPlaneAtTheEnd.jpg

THE FIRE RISES

Nolan has now made three bad movies in a row

>tfw this movie utterly destroyed any romantic idea you had about serving in war
>tfw once the entire world sees this movie they will stop fighting wars once and for all

B R A V O N O L A N.

I sure as fuck don't want to drown to death.

It's incredible that people actually think that this is a good movie. I mean it's just strange. It's not complete trash either but god damn. I somehow went in and thought, "yep, this is prolly gon' be one of his best yet".

But it don't

>>85542114
They're German.

>>85543074
>tfw this movie utterly destroyed any romantic idea you had about serving in war
>PG-13 "war film" with comically tame death scenes
Are you 12?

>>85531816
>watch dunkirk
>it's a great cinema experience
>come home to read how others reacted
>people bitch about not being able to emphatize with any characters
>"not enough character development"
>"lol it had no story"
>"the brits are propagandizing their retreat"
>people actually had to watch the movie for an hour before they realized the non-linear timeline and the inevitable convergence
>many expected more heroics

jesus christ how did this happen? why do movie-goers prioritize twists and heroics in the screenplay over visuals and sound design?

File: Dambusters.jpg (467KB, 2000x1326px) Image search: [Google]

467KB, 2000x1326px

New Dam Busters film when?

>>85543322

It's not that people prioritize twists and heroics over visuals and sound design. It's that thought visuals and sound design are superb, other aspects of the movie are abysmal.

>>85543322
Marvel movies are making billions and you have to ask yourself that?

>>85543408

PG-13 film probably didn't help Marvelbros

I would really love more WW2 air force-centric films (not the one about the exaggerated black pilots).

>>85538537
there were 3 groups of 13-15 girls in my theater, they all clapped when they saw Harry Styles

>>85543391
how? the movie attempts to convey the experience of being cornered on a beach with very little hopes of survival as a barely adult man illustrate typical courses of action that led to their rescue. it doesn't have to build characters or backstories because it doesn't need them, all you need to sympathize with the soldiers is knowing what they're going through at that instant, as that experience supersedes all other personality traits or individual quirks. it's actually amazing how well the feeling of urgency and desperation is constructed. why would you expect a story other than what the movie shows you, when the movie is made to convey the experience of being on that beach, rather than tell the tale of an individual or group that was on the beach.

>>85543168
at the movie didn't also think it was that good

but after thinking about it I began to understand what people are liking so much about it

it's different

it's original and new, it's a huge budget ORIGINAL film in fucking 2017, those are the times we live at

>>85543578
Same here, also they were talking pictures with Harry's name on the poster.

File: 1489980633131.jpg (46KB, 671x665px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 671x665px

im looking at the OST
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PaSCOV7YPvA
what song was used near the begging when the french guy and the main character were running towards one of the boats while carrying a wounded soldier?

>>85543842
The Mole

>>85543654
Different does not equals good, it just makes people think that they're smart if they like it.

>>85536316
It should win best sound holy fuck

>>85543870
thanks

>>85543941
>I couldn't get into the characters

What a pleb. The film is about the experience of being on that beach at that time, you don't need backstory. It's like reading the description of a painting before taking your time to look at it.

>>85543175
Then we hate you instead.

>>85531816
so since /tv/ hates this movie should I go watch capeshit instead? It's all /tv/ ever talks about. That and feet.

>>85543250
You don't need blood to get grim deaths in a film. Like that guy who gets trapped between the dock and the sinking ship.

>>85543938
You're welcome.

>>85543941
this is actually what they'd say too

File: Untitled.jpg (46KB, 394x497px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 394x497px

Was he useful?

File: The-Slave-Ship-1840[1].jpg (79KB, 1140x326px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 1140x326px

>>85531858
>>85531951
thanks for posting these, william turner is one of my favorite painters.

>>85544248
he said he'd be useful sir, so yes I suspect he was

>>85544248
he probably would've been if it wasn't for the shellshocked asshat.

>>85544248
he was a hero.

>>85543623
There's a lot of problems with the film, but for example, if you look at the film as something trying to convey the experience of being on the beach, it kinda shoots itself in the foot.
This is because of the way the film is meant to be disorienting (unorthodox structure, breaking the 180-degree rule etc.), while still having the soldiers remain characterless. Both are things that you can have in a movie, but Nolan takes a real step in the shit trying to do both.
A way he could convey the feeling of being on the beach succesfully, is if he only did one of these, because these ambitions get in the way of each other.
At the same time, he purposefully strips the characters of dialogue to make them "not" characters, but actually just ends up making the movie completely unimmersive and unrelatable.
If you are to convey the experience of something, you have to understand that the people experiencing it are actually people.

>>85544248
if his corpse taking up space that could have been filled by soldiers is your idea of useful, then yeah I guess he was.

>>85544400
>>85543623
Also, having a movie be disorienting at the same time as having none of the characters being distinct, and at the same time as having so many characters simply makes for an even more unimmersive experience. You'll still want a frame of reference even when things are spinning out of control

>>85544523
Yeah, they made the point that a man lying down took up 7 standing. George killed those men

>>85544400
>making the movie completely unimmersive and unrelatable
i disagree a lot, i found it very easy to relate to, why would you need to know a character to relate to fear and desperation? i also didn't found it too disorienting, it literally gives you the titles and timeframes of all three of its plotlines with their first scenes. why is making a disorienting film with a shallow approach to characters something to avoid?

>>85544580
the frame of reference is the beach and the relatively small amount of water between the beach and england. again, why do you need an anchor character to immerse yourself in the movie? being alone in a crowd, fearing for your life, feeling cold, hungry, desperate, these are things you should be able to relate to regardless of how explicitly a character states having said feelings.

>>85544400
>while still having the soldiers remain characterless

this isn't true, in fact, this is flat out wrong. Just because the characters weren't named immediately and have fucking overly defining features does not mean they lacked character.

The only way I suspect you think this way is because you're desensitized by more action-oriented, wish-fulfillment movies.

>>85544400
i really like when cinema grad studends come to /tv/ to post their opinions, it is always funny to read

File: 160111_CBOX_David-Bowie-08.jpg.CROP.promo-xlarge2.jpg (53KB, 1180x842px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 1180x842px

>>85542613
Good tune, but its babies first Bowie desu

>>85542266
>>85542436
>>85542563
>>85542613
>>85542637
>>85542642
>BASED

File: big boss.jpg (348KB, 1080x1080px) Image search: [Google]

348KB, 1080x1080px

it was entertaining, very pretty, and extremely tense, when they were on the ship and it got dark outside i actually felt scared because of all the crazy shit that was happening and i thought "war is hell" i would watch it again and comparing it to marvel or dc movies i wouldn't re watch those movies again

>>85544671
The lack of frame of reference comes from the fact that he fx breaks the 180-degree rule.

And I didn't say that you needed to know the characters to relate to those feelings, more the fact that the characters remain so faceless, that they don't reach the point where you're able to symphasize.
The lack of dialogue isn't a problem in and of itself either, but coupled with the way the film is edited and structuralized it makes the characters seem completely lifeless.
The characters end up like robots, and though they're trying to survive, you don't really care. Was there any emotional impact when George or the guy in the boat with the bullet holes in it died?

>>85544689

here
>>85545087

>>85545087
i really don't want to ask this again, but why do you have to feel for individual characters when the movie isn't about the characters, and why is your inability to do so a bad thing? the soldiers are the props, the movie isn't about any one of them individually, it's about the atmosphere created collectively. it's actually more or less the point, there are hundreds of thousands of soldiers like them, with their own stories and personalities, which, at the thick of the battle, don't really matter. it follows several characters not to tell their story, but to use them as focus points while describing the various aspects of the dunkirk evacuation. you should be considering the conditions of the soldiers, not one or a few of them, but as a whole. this bizarre obsession with being able to sympathize with characters really bugs me, not specifically you, but in general. why would people want to be able to emotionally invest in a character to enjoy a movie that isn't necessarily about that character.

and if you don't mind me asking, are you american? i find that the desire to connect to characters is more common in americans, or people who mostly only see american movies.

>>85545087
what a nothing response. You have made 1 claim and have no support to it. come up with an ACTUAL cause for why you think the characters have no character. Because you haven't made one yet while feigning that you know something.

>>85538537
My grandmother loved it desu

>>85540935
a literal retard everyone

Why did he look up at the end?

>>85545413

It's not that I think that you should know anything about the characters, but rather that they serve as a medium, that enables you to feel how it felt being on that beach. The way the movie is made removes any intimacy between the soldiers and the viewer, and the reason that i say this with the implication that intimacy is important is because the movie consistently follows the same characters. Think of how many extreme closeups there are in the film. It isn't congruent with the atmosphere. It suggests that you're intimate with the characters, but you're not.

Being able to symphasize with the characters isn't at all a necessity, it's only that the "Nolanesque" production isn't congruent with this.

And no I'm not American, I'm Danish, and no i don't primarily watch American movies.

>>85545413
>why do you have to feel for individual characters when the movie isn't about the characters, and why is your inability to do so a bad thing?
Because Dunkirk isn't interesting. It just isn't. "The Story of Dunkirk" isn't enough to carry a "great" movie. The draw is seeing how real humans reacted to and experienced a real event, and the characters didn't feel like humans.

>>85545508

The reason that I say that the characters have no character is because of the lack of dialogue I don't believe that dialogue is necessary to develop character at all, but the movie's turbulence hinders itself from being able to develop the characters from actions alone. Of course we're able to understand the basic motivations of each character, but the intimacy of each shot suggests that we're on a more intimate level with the character, but we are not.
I'd rather that there were no characters at all. I mean as in characters that we consistently follow. Why have a character at all if you're not going to do anything with it?

I think the movie's fatal flaw is that Nolan tries to do to many different things in the same movie. Things that either simply don't fit together or things that Nolan isn't capable of fitting together.

>>85545818
>but rather that they serve as a medium, that enables you to feel how it felt being on that beach.The way the movie is made removes any intimacy between the soldiers and the viewer, and the reason that I say this with the implication that intimacy is important is because the movie consistently follows the same characters.

How do you manage to write this in the same post and still think you know what you're talking about? Your post has so little content and reason that it's impossible to actually discuss your opinion and figure out why you think this way.

The characters are very human but surround by very in-humane spectacles taking place. Many people are line up on the beach, easy targets for the shrieking planes over the head and looks straight out of a dada art piece of soldiers skipping the middle man and just getting into a meat grinder. The characters we follow are the most human and natural, they do literally anything they can to get on a boat sometimes the help others, sometimes not if it seems like they'll be killed too. Pretty much every action in the movie by a person makes sense and is very plausible.
I literally cannot understand how you think the opposite because you have not given me anything.

>>85540935
>recitation of a real speech that followed the real evacuation of real troops from a real war

>ham

>>85546333
ok, how about this. You need to describe the word you're using because you're trying to Humpty dumpty this shit and applying more meaning to this word than it has.

> intimacy
what kind of intimacy are you trying to get out of this movie beyond what they movie presents? Because the movie's intimacy between the characters and viewer is the desire to survive and the fear of the MANY threats that the soldiers are facing and that over time the viewers begin to see as threats when they probably never used to (like the sirens, which means death from above. Or the fear of bellow deck, which has been a death trap in more ways than one).

>>85546781

All of you guys keep saying that the movie isn't about the characters and all that, yeah? So why does it treat the characters in the film as if though they were the focus? That's what I mean by intimate. The film treats its characters as any other Nolan movie would, though it tries to do the opposite at the same time.
That's my main gripe with the movie. It's trying to do several different things that aren't congruent.

I think that it should stick with one approach instead of trying to do different shit at once.

And no the intimacy between the viewer and the characters in the will to survive ffs jesus. The viewer can't relate to the feeling because the viewer most likely doesn't know what it's like to struggle in a warlike environment for survival.
That's why characters are supposed to be sympathized with, so that all of us stupid fucks can feel that, but no one gave half a fuck when the french mf died.

The movie should have just committed to the characters or not having them at all. It just half-asses two things.

>>85545783
He realized that there was still a lot of fighting ahead

And at that point the USA and USSR were not (directly) involved in the war yet and Britain seemed likely for attack

>>85538814
because he's a fucking pilot, you fat basement dweller. what were you hoping for? because he's a meme? grow up already

>>85540505
Perfidious Albion chained him to the boat. He could not allow one 'ally' to escape after all.

>>85547394
I've noticed people are extra autistic about defending this movie.

"If you think this movie was poorly executed you aren't as smart as me"

Same old /tv/

>>85540935
How are you that fucking stupid. Aside from that speeches literary greatness, it's all old english, if you don't appreciate its message you would at least appreciate its propaganda value

It's incredible how little people on this motherfucking board understand about movies considering its name.

>>85540935

how cockthirsty for (you)s are you jesus christ

>>85547542
he isn't defending it.

File: Cat.jpg (52KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 800x800px

Is it just me or does it seem like Christopher Nolan has a compulsive need to write stupid lines that sound "cool" before a cut?

"We have to save them"

"IF WE CAN SAVE OURSELVES!"

Ugh, jesus christ.

>>85547226
>tl:dr in the decision of focus; Characters vs events you think the movie does both, badly when it should choose one or the other, you think it should choose character

Ok, we've gotten somewhere.

>The viewer can't relate to the feeling because the viewer most likely doesn't know what it's like to struggle in a warlike environment for survival.
Ok, then you've missed the whole point of the film. The viewer is intimate with the characters in the film because they are by design vessels to be inhabited by the viewer to experience the spectacle not as an action movie but as a horror of war. As I said before the audience is made to experience the perils that the soldiers encountered, like the fighters and their loud siren, the water and drowning, and even fellow soldiers. the close ups of the characters (the intimate shots that apparently confuse you) put a direct emotion on the screen for the viewer to see and feel.

>That's why characters are supposed to be sympathized with, so that all of us stupid fucks can feel that, but no one gave half a fuck when the french mf died.
The audience or the characters? because a LOT of people died, eventually you have to just keep moving. Did you miss the part where they moved the boat away from oil before it caught? Leaving quite a few men to burn? They had to leave them or the whole boat would catch and no one would survive. That scene literally represents the whole movie and fact of survival. Not a shitty action movie heroism line about "We're bringing everyone back with us even if we all die!".

Your argument would work on most if not all the other Noland movies prior but it just does not hold up here.

>>85547893

>Ok, then you've missed the whole point of the film. The viewer is intimate with the characters in the film because they are by design vessels to be inhabited by the viewer to experience the spectacle not as an action movie but as a horror of war. As I said before the audience is made to experience the perils that the soldiers encountered, like the fighters and their loud siren, the water and drowning, and even fellow soldiers. the close ups of the characters (the intimate shots that apparently confuse you) put a direct emotion on the screen for the viewer to see and feel.

I can't make you understand my point here so agree to disagree.

>The audience or the characters? because a LOT of people died, eventually you have to just keep moving. Did you miss the part where they moved the boat away from oil before it caught? Leaving quite a few men to burn? They had to leave them or the whole boat would catch and no one would survive. That scene literally represents the whole movie and fact of survival. Not a shitty action movie heroism line about "We're bringing everyone back with us even if we all die!".

My point was that we knew who the french guy was for an extended period of time, but when he died it meant nothing to us. The soldiers in the oil were completely faceless and they meant nothing either, so here's my question: why the fuck spend any time on the french guy then?

>>85544772
get a load of this fag

File: 4235252165.jpg (61KB, 858x312px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 858x312px

>>85538537
Yes

It's like this:

People who are retarded don't like the movie

People with an IQ over 90 like the movie

People with an IQ over 100 don't like the movie

>>85548108
>why the fuck spend any time on the french guy then?

Desperate survival, A shift in trust, death.

Seriously, you felt nothing when the frog died? That's on you and only you. Because as the secondary character he was perfect, he earns the viewer's trust gradually but turns out to betray our trust near the end yet for understandable reasons. Only to drown, which is as close as the movie got to making the audience feel like drowning and actually dying unlike the spitfire pilot.

He was not a waste at all.

>>85548397

Come on man, people in this thread are asking BTW what happened to french guy? No one gave a fuck.

Christopher Nolan: Making mediocre movies for mediorcre people.

>>85548397
>which is as close as the movie got to making the audience feel like drowning
That was clearly Nolan's intention here, but the cross-cutting robbed scenes like that not only of their emotional portent, but their tension. I liked the film enough, but Nolan's formal inadequacies brought it down a lot.

File: JMW Turner - Fisherman at Sea (1796).jpg (1MB, 2258x1678px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2258x1678px

>>85544260
have this

>>85548435
>/tv/ is representation of an intelligent viewer

people here are like the speed readers of /co/ and /lit/. They'd miss the titles of the books if it wasn't on the cover.

>>85548530

opinions on here seem pretty disparate

>>85548596
I'll admit I was harsh in posting. But I literally could not pinpoint the criticism the previous posts are making about the film because they were pretty vague. I like the film, thought it was clear but others disagree and I'll leave it at that. Which is about time, as my captcha is getting weird.

File: file.png (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

why didn't he land next to the beach so he could come back home with the boys?

>>85549267

Yeah the only part that bothered me was based off the time lapse, he was gliding for like 5 hours...

>>85532906
why did he do this? i am serious

>>85549817
So the germans couldn't steal the plane and reverse engineer it and shit.

Shit's common knowledge anon

Same reason the US Navy Seals blew up that experimental Helicopter that crashed during Osama Bin Laden's raid

>be American
>no one clapped at the end
>overheard people criticizing while walking out

Even the plebs know this film did not live up to the hype.

>>85538537
Girlfriend and I enjoyed it a lot. 9/10 for me.

>>85537804
Everyone knew the kid was dead the second he didn't get off the boat at the beginning. Death flags were so obvious.

>>85550434
no i mesnt why didn't he just land in dunkirk? not why he burned his plane. he could have made it easily like his friend

>>85549267
getting caught was part of his plan

>>85550549
Both other planes crashed in the water. He stayed and fought to protect the men on the ground, even though it meant eventually running out of fuel and getting captured.

I was wondering why he didn't just parachute onto the beach and hitch a ride home, but that would have been less interesting. Dude was awesome, favorite character for me

>>85539043
The film displayed none of those though? It depicted the British troops as being cowards who were willing to sell out their fellow countrymen and backs stab their allies to get out. Only the officers were depicted in a positive light, and the old people at the end.

File: They're eating her.jpg (21KB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 320x240px

This movie was a visual and technical masterpiece and it had

As much narrative thrust as Skyline.

>>85550659
good point. did not see it in that way.

>>85540935
It was blatant virtue signaling to the british and french audiences, like how in Tora Tora Tora they make Yamoto give that "sleeping dragon" speech because people don't want to see a film where their sides loses, except for the germans. Yeah it's weak and hamfisted but it's necessary to prevent plebs from burning down the theater. My proof of this is how butthurt people are getting at your post for suggesting it wasn't well done. Now imagine how mad these autist would get in person after spending their welfare checks to see this film?

>film finishes
>normies at the end scream "what a shitty movie!"

>>85551014
Guy by my side couldn't get up after the end of the movie, he was suffering so much with the characters.

Was there some hidden scene after the credits or something? Walked out immediately when the credits started playing

>>85551014
this NEVER happened at my 70mm imax showing

>>85551137
no just check mediastinger it says no scenes during or after credits

>>85543250
>I need gore to understand the horrors of war

>>85551137
Almost everyone in my theater stayed. I can't tell if they were looking for after credits or just wanted to give the film some respect.

How likely will we get a pseudo-sequel to Dunkirk, only it's set on the beaches of Normandy in D-Day?

>>85551071
I definitely held back tears whenever the citizens showed up on their boats to ferry the boats over.

>>85550817
He is talking about the actual speech itself.

File: 1430375240476.png (108KB, 194x192px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 194x192px

>that screaming and crunching as the boat slowly bumps up on the pier

>>85551292
>D-Day with Dunkirk's gunshots and sound effects

That would legit destroy all of the theater's speakers and equipment

>>85551357
Fucking kek. The first scene scared the living shit out of me.

>>85551292
I could dig it. The War cinematic universe.

worth paying a ticket or just wait and download it?

>>85551357

>bitter fighting in Stalingrad
>told from Russian/German perspectives: Infantry, Tanker and Airman

someone get Nolan

>>85551410
Better in theaters desu

>>85551372
>>85551357
Apparently a veteran of DUnkirk went to the movie, and said it was louder than the real thing

>>85551410

I'm usually not one to say this and I know it sounds like a meme, but you're going to want to experience it in IMAX. Or at least in a good-tier theater

>>85551490
>IMAX. Or at least in a good-tier theater
well, I live in the deep third world

>>85551410
Honestly I don't know if I'll even get the blu-ray. I watch everything on my laptop and the shitty 19 inch screen and stereo headset would be doing a huge disservice to the film

>tfw the only way to experience dunkirk is in IMAX, Blu-Ray and DVD will be nowhere near that quality

You dun fucked up Nolan

Just reserved 8 seats at IMAX on Sunday for me and my faggot bf. Feels good

Emoji movie was better

>>85551357

I went to college to a prestigious audio engineering college 5 years ago. Right before I graduated we had PRG Vegas come and setup in our auditorium millions of dollars in line array speakers, same setup they use for main stage EDC. Anyways they were setup the entire weekend doing demos, certing people in line arrays and front of house mixing and what not. On Sunday just before they packed up to leave Monday morning, we were able to watch a few movies on a massive projector. We watched Saving Private Ryan and I will never forget how amazing that shit was, probably a once in a lifetime thing. Louder than any movie theater known to man. My fucking shirt was bouncing around and pushing against my chest in the beginning with all the mortar rounds on the beach, I'll look and see if I can find the shitty cell phone pics of the setup. It was insane.

File: IMG_0275.jpg (619KB, 1600x1200px) Image search: [Google]

619KB, 1600x1200px

>>85551894
>>85551357

Here you go, didn't take long. All the speakers were used, and that was just the center. we had that shit in 7.1, literally surrounded by fucking speakers. Shits on ATMOS. no joke

>>85552015
>>85551894
do you wear hearing aids now?

>>85552077

It was a safe amount of DB to watch the entire film and not cause hearing damage or loss.

>>85543493

HBO is working on another WWII miniseries that is air force centric

The sound of that torpedo impacting that troop carrier will fucking haunt me forever.

Also it kills me inside knowing some idiots who watched the movie will think "Wow the sound of those dive bombers was just stock sounds used from 30 years ago"

File: 1490823496103.jpg (19KB, 480x640px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 480x640px

>mfw this film only appeals to non-autistic, intelligent people

>>85552415
how bout you go read some Tolstoy you degenerate, mouth breathing plebeian

>>85550659
He was wayyyyy too low to parachute. He would have been mashed potatoes.

>>85552525
>implying I haven't

>>85533636
As I was walking out of the theater I heard a couple guys behind me say "Why would you shoot a man before throwing him out of a plane?" in the Bane voice. Gave me a good chuckle.

>>85552957
>watched it with friends who also browse tv
>made a veeery quiet little laugh as the plane was gliding down to land on the beach
>friend laughs a tiny bit too
>have to use every ounce of strength and will in my body to not crack up laughing
>as we walk out of the theatre friend says "crashing this plane" in the voice

File: faggot gun.jpg (225KB, 764x1024px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 764x1024px

>>85543941

Shit like that is what happens when you do nothing but listen to AmazingAtheist videos while playing world of warcraft. They're literally assraped by MTV like mind control.

God save our imploding generation.

>>85544105

that and all the John Podesta wannabe asshats who spam us with cunny threads.

>>85545010

Literally looks just like the big guy pilot.

>>85551410
Definitely worth watching it in IMAX. If you just grab it from the bay or even buy a blu-ray in a few months, you'll be getting an inferior version sadly.

>>85548397

That's the one death that left me sour in the end. French man literally did nothing wrong and got trashed on. The French in the film were mostly seen in a good light as those allies that were holding the line while the Brits evacuated. Yet covert Frenchman's death made the audience feel like he wasn't supposed to be totally sympathized with I guess.

I have to see it again.

>>85550659
>>85550549

First of all parachuting in the water can be very dangerous. Your chute can weigh you down and/or you can become entangled in it. See that scene in Spiderman homecoming? Yeah.

Also there was no guarantee he would find a boat even if he splashed in the water. The Brits were literally nervous as shit to catch a ride on the beach and even then their transports were being shot to shit by the Germans.

I would have probably said "fuck it" and let the Krauts capture me too.

File: ferris-bueller-go-home-gif-fvin.gif (996KB, 400x179px) Image search: [Google]

996KB, 400x179px

>>85551137

Yeah, this guy came out in the end, called us all a bunch of faggots for staying, and then ordered us all to go home.

>>85549319
the other timelines were progressing much faster so they essentially passed him by

He probably landed just a ways down the beach from them a couple minutes later

>>85553790

Plus weren't the Germans pretty much beginning to already roll up their right flank? Those Scotsmen in the boat were being shot at by what appeared to be a probe force.

>>85553790
The "one week" for the ground timeline goes past the evacuation and into the future

The "one hour" for the air ends right around when Bane runs out of gas

>>85553527
>see that scene in spiderman homecoming

No, because I'm not a fucking fag who likes capeshit. Go back to /co/

>>85552415
This. It's why /tv/ isnt talking about it and I've seen more fucking threads about that nigger horror film in the last week than actual Dunkirk threads

This board sucks now, full of nothing but capeshitters

>>85539679
hey we were in same theater. did you hear me yell out "this movie is boring"

>>85553790
But sense the sun setting when he finally did crash and it was dark when the Germans captured him

>>85553941
name your top 5

File: 1497511454949.gif (3MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 480x270px

>>85554028
Mate, how long do you think it takes for the sun to go down?

Best film of the year for me

My only complaint was that they should have had more soldiers on the beach and more ships in the civilian flotilla

>>85554061
Given the sun was high in the sky when the timelines converged it would have taken more than an hour you retard

>>85538814
He's an elevated fellow.

>>85554093
So the sun was setting but also high in the sky. I wonder who the real retard is here.

>>85554029
Shoo shoo

Neckbeards belong in /co/ with the other capeshitters

>>85549267
He was out of fuel, the fact he managed to land at all is impressive.

>>85554112
You are clearly

>>85548303
Her opinions are bottom of the shit barrel tier on everything though.

>>85554072
I had the same problem, all I read before go watching it was how the scale was so big yet it felt like everything was so little visually. Then in the end they mentioned 300000 were saved and the visuals honestly didn't match that. Aside from that I liked the movie a lot, especially Rylance and his son, they gave me the most feels

>>85543920
And some of us just wanted to see a well made war movie that showed the terror of war, a rarely tackled subject and even more rarely done well one, that was handled very well in this movie that has a plot that really isn't why anyone's even watching it anyway.

File: bernie sanders pronz film.jpg (108KB, 600x791px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 600x791px

>>85553941

You're right, you're a transgender who likes cuck films because you want to be this guy in the center.

go back to /mlp/ your tourettes patient.

wtf is this general about? Sharia law?

>>85554072
>My only complaint was that they should have had more soldiers on the beach and more ships in the civilian flotilla

They had literally thousands of extras on the beaches, and 60 ships where used (with the civilian flotilla being actual ships used in the operation). The reason it doesn't look more grand was that Nolan wanted only practical effects, no CG at all.

did anyone find out what's the trailer song name?

1/3 of soldiers saved were french. Why did the film show only brits getting saved?

>>85554392
Because it was a British story.

I adored some aspects of this but it had quite a few flaws

-a few shots of everyone slowly turning their heads to look at something in the distance too many
-magnificent sound design, but atrocious sound mixing accompanied by music playing under pieces of important dialogue means not being able to understand 60% of the dialogue
-George's pre-death monologue was where Nolan's tradition of awful dialogue popped through
-Hans Zimmer is a fucking hack who takes one or two good ideas and stretches them into an hour long sound track with some fucking stupid "emotional" string section melody #786234 thrown in to ruin scenes that are already great enough to stir emotions without music. And he gets praised for it again and again by people who don't know what they're talking about

File: 1488177052149.jpg (39KB, 470x500px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 470x500px

If you didn't watch this in 70mm you didn't actually watch it btw

>>85537393
during my viewing of this film, i thought the opposite. i thought some scenes would've worked better without music.

What was going on at the end with the old man pointing on the boat while a plane flies by?

>>85554496
It's obvious Nolan has an extreme fascination with Time. Hans Zimmer being able to write a score with three movies that use Time as a theme is quite amazing.

>>85554656
That's strange, all he managed to do was waste that very thing

>>85554496
>>85554656
>>85554674

I hear some people complain about the lack of music but in my opinion it should've had less music and more silence.

>>85531816
boring as fuck

>>85554674
Your hate boner for Zimmer doesn't somehow manifest into some reality where Hans Zimmer doesn't write good music.

>>85554301
It's noticeable though and it really bugged me. The beaches should have been packed yet you barely saw anyone

>>85554720
SJWtard kike detected

>>85555145
If you can only pack 200-300 men on a ship at a time, why crowd the beach with thousands of men?

>>85555163
Because you have 400,000 men and not a lot of space for them.

>>85537393
>the score of a film achieving its purpose
but youre right what a fucking hack!

>>85539237
>Nolan
>effective filmmaking
Keep telling that to yourself you delusional bong.

>>85555489
If making your ears bleed was the purpose then you're probably right.

>>85548108
If you can't understand the horror of burning and drowning then maybe that's one you. I don't need to know a man's life story to find his death horrific.

Especially considering this is a historical piece, and while that individual may not have been a real person dying, real men died in similar ways and now I can see what it might have been like to live or die through those trials.

>>85543074
>movie that showed the eternal brotherhood thats forms through members of armed service
>shows men with a purpose and pride in what they did and the honor that it brought to him
>the heroic acts constantly portrayed throughout the film
>thinking this will cause people to be turned off by the idea

war is hell their is no questioning that. But this movie could inspire younger men to become more patriotic about their countries, especially in the U.K.

>>85544248
ok i literally walked out to se the bathroom when this guy got killed. Could some explain real quick how it happened?

>>85555958
The peaky blinders guy had a PTSD freak out and stomped on his already injured head

>>85556035
how'd he get the head injury

>>85556112
When the solider was trying to take control of the boat to turn it around, he knocked the kid's head into a valve or something and it's implied he punctured the skull

File: bravo noland.jpg (92KB, 950x708px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 950x708px

>Nolan makes the best movie of the year
Truly we are living in the end times

Hey, so we never see a german until the very end of the WW2 movie

is this groundbreaking in some way? I don't know why, but that feels important for some reason

>>85556376
I noticed that too, I thought it was neat. The Germans felt more like some huge lurking force instead of just people

>>85543074
Had the opposite effect on me, I felt emasculated desu

>DUDE WW2 LMAO
>DUDE WINSTON CHURCHILL LMAO
>DUDE THE BEACHES LMAO
>DUDE PATRIOTIC WAR REVIVALISM LMAO
>DUDE THE SPIRIT OF THE PEOPLE CONQUERING TRAGEDY LMAO
>DUDE BRITISH EMOTIONAL REPRESSION LMAO

Decent movie. In the end though, just one of countless other war movies which fail to actually depict war truly negatively, and instead chooses to pander to the commemoration of tragic events that never should have been necessary in the first place. The human race as a whole learnt almost nothing from WW2 and this movie is testament to that.

File: F749A1FB-3CD7-483A-A05F-9B1ECAB9A093-556-0000005BB8598259.jpg (102KB, 1069x674px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 1069x674px

>the screams of the dudes being drowned in the torpedoed boat

>>85556673
>The human race as a whole learnt almost nothing from WW2 and this movie is testament to that.
Surely you don't actually believe that, right? Surely no one is actually this stupid? The dropping of the atomic bomb changed the entire psyche of the world and our awareness of the consequences of scientific progress more than any event ever did and ever has since.

You are a moron if you truly believe what you just said.

File: mnbch.jpg (73KB, 600x624px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 600x624px

>>85555145
The beach was pretty historically accurate.

>>85556778
>The dropping of the atomic bomb changed the entire psyche of the world and our awareness of the consequences of scientific progress more than any event ever did and ever has since.

When did that happen? The first bomb didn't stop them dropping another three days later, it didn't stop there being a huge conflict based entirely around threats of use of atomic weaponry half a century later, and it hasn't stopped major powers from stockpiling nuclear weaponry since. What exactly changed so drastically, friend?

>>85544248
A human bean and a real hero

>>85556673
Shut the fuck up and fuck off you paint huffing nigger.

>>85556376
It was more of a disaster movie than a war movie. It doesn't matter who the Germans were what mattered was their plan

>>85556376
Yes, it was a great move. Zero talk about the "nazis", focus entirely on the situation itself.
No cliche "le ebil crazy screaming nazi general", no nothing. It's told completely from the perspective of the brits on the beach, they also pretty much didn’t see a single german soldier up close on that beach.

>>85538814
HE DIDN'T FLY SO GOOD

>>85554656
Nolan is a sculptor, and time is his medium.

For me it's a 6/10. I can't give anything lower for a competently made movie, especially one as technically proficient as this one. But I never gave a shit about any of the characters, and I wasn't nearly as tense as the movie wanted me to be, despite the constant buzzing of the soundtrack. It's just a series of barebone events that aren't actually fed by anything.

When is Nolan going to do a WW1 film based on the Somme?

>>85540935
fucking /thread right here.

This man speaks the truth. Amerilard plebs will disagree tho.

>>85531816
This movie was 4chan, I admit, but I found myself daydreaming during parts of it, which hasn't happened to me since I saw Fast and Furious 6. Not Nolan's best.

>>85537895
This happened throughout the whole film.

>tense scene trying to get a wounded soldier across the mole before the boat leaves
>cut to Tom Hardy checking his fuel levels

The cross-cutting was used effectively in a few places (the juxtaposition of Cillian Murphy before and after getting bombed comes to mind) but mostly it was disastrous.

>>85541130

> the (((JU)))s did it

well colour me SHOCKED

It's downright offensive that Nolan has completely invalidated the contribution of other races in a historical moment like Dunkirk. The movie is TOO white, and TOO male, and while I wish I would not have to say this about director Nolan for he was behind my favorite movie - the Dark Knight Rises - I believe he has a conservative agenda on his menu.

The day of Dunkirk was a great triumph amidst the countless losses that the British forces suffered during WW2. Not because countless lives were saved that day, no not at all, but because it was the day that the world saw the empowering might that a sexually and racial diverse army can exert. The troops on Dunkirk that day was led by the first female general in the history of mankind, general Alyssa Breechelle, who also happened to be of African heritage. It was her who hand-selected out more than 50 thousands soldiers from more than 10 races and all spectrum of genders. "I want my army to be a walking memento of freedom. The nazis will fear us" - she said. And it was because of exactly this that many British civilians were mustered to the rescue of the Dunkirk soldiers - none would have shown up had the army been white.

Nolan, if you read this, please consider a remake. Britain deserves better than this - ever since the medieval age (during which Dunkirk takes place) Britain has been populated with men, women and other kins of equally numbered colors. Please do not give into the nazi agenda!

>>85556376
part of the point about the surreality of the entire situation

war sucks and in the end it's about you and your mates survival

All of Hans Zimmers soundtrack sounds the same and is so generic. Fucking hate Hans Zimmer.
DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK TICK

The dive bombers alone should win best sound

Super glad that I saw this in the theater instead of waiting for blu ray

Sequel when?

>>85559432
this, feeling the airbrake sounds in your stomach was insane

File: IMG_0547.jpg (60KB, 720x960px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 720x960px

Lord Gort, I'm NSDAP

that part where they were plugging the bullet holes in their scrappy ship with their hands to keep it from sinking as they were taking fire was probably the most desperate-feeling scene I've ever seen in a war movie

>>85559754
>when that guy trudges into the ocean and just starts swimming toward England

>Have one of the best sound for an opening scene in a war movie
>don't feature any street fighting for the rest of the film

REEEE IT WAS SO GOOD

>>85559432
No, bombers didn't sound like that. Only the Stuka had that sound and it was to frighten the civilians it was bombing but its sound became synonymous with diving aeroplanes.
It can't win best sound for its glaring historical inaccuracies.

>>85531816
Good:
Sound
Little dialogue
No romance
Cinematography

Bad:
Too few aircraft involved
Too few French and Germans depicted
Not enough realistic violence to raise the stakes

7/10

>>85560155
The category is Best Sound Mixing and Best Sound Editing, in what way does any of that have to do with history? Literally every sound in the film could be artificially made up and in no corellation with realiry and the film could still win both of those categories if the sound is mixed or edited impressively.

>>85560215
>Too few aircraft involved
That's how it happened

>Too few French and Germans depicted
The film is not about the french (though based froggo is the representation of their sacrifice) and we don't see germans because the brit soldiers on that beach also didn't see a single german up close.

Be honest
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTkhZNLWt6s

How is this going to win any Oscars? It looks fucking terrible.

File: 34475782.jpg (270KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 1920x1200px

>>85538537
yep

>>85538537
My sister liked it and she's a raging college progressive "I'm With Her" feminist.

>>85538379
kek

File: laughing.gif (2MB, 400x206px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 400x206px

>>85560215
>Not enough realistic violence to raise the stakes
lol, you got me