[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

EDH/Commander General /edhg/

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 327
Thread images: 86

File: 101.jpg (67KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
101.jpg
67KB, 312x445px
One drops edition (Hard-Mode: not Sol Ring)

Old Thread >>52112389 (Cross-thread)

RESOURCES

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
http://www.mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck’s strategy and card choices.
http://www.tappedout.net

>Another resource for commander discussion; they have an entire forum dedicated to discussing decks. People often make primers, which go into detail about how they built and play their deck.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the the internet.
http://www.edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen Commander’s color identity.
http://manabasecrafter.com/


CARD SEARCHING

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
http://gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
http://magiccards.info/

>Thread question
What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?
>>
New thread when
>>
File: IMG_0921.jpg (4MB, 3264x2448px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0921.jpg
4MB, 3264x2448px
>>52133868
I've always wanted to build Sharuum, but I never enjoyed playing with her.

Also Post decks!
>>
I want to make a beater deck. No nonsense. Just straight to the face. Help me out, /edhg/. Can I go toe to toe with people playing their CUHRAAAAZY decks in this format?
>>
File: 20170224_123012~2~2.jpg (919KB, 3955x949px) Image search: [Google]
20170224_123012~2~2.jpg
919KB, 3955x949px
>>52133903
This guy gets it.

W: Swords
U: Brainstorm
B: Dark Ritual
G: Birds of Paradise
C: Sensei's Divining Top
Best one drops for each color and also colorless.

Bant or Abzantress
There's no good general for either of them, but I'll get one one day.
>>
>>52133972
List for Rashmi?
>>
File: pixlr_20170104003822563.jpg (2MB, 1270x2048px) Image search: [Google]
pixlr_20170104003822563.jpg
2MB, 1270x2048px
>>52134006
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/04-01-17-rashmi-control/
This is it. There's been slight changes, but it should mostly be the same.
>>
File: Mental Misstep_NPH.jpg (56KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
Mental Misstep_NPH.jpg
56KB, 312x445px
>>52133972
>U
>Not the best 1 drop
>>
File: 87.jpg (66KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
87.jpg
66KB, 312x445px
>>52134160
Also a candidate. It's really personal preference to split hairs.

Misstep, recall, tutor, remora, and high tide are all incredibly good.
>>
>>52133868
>What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?
Knight Tribal called 99 Knights. Not sure where I want to go with it however. Knight creatures are scattered across all 5 colors and Legendary Knights are few and far between. Maybe Hakkon as a stealth Commander.
>>
File: fjsnfsfd.png (493KB, 1284x406px) Image search: [Google]
fjsnfsfd.png
493KB, 1284x406px
>>52134185
Oop. was gonna POST EM
>>
File: muh commanders.jpg (363KB, 1368x665px) Image search: [Google]
muh commanders.jpg
363KB, 1368x665px
>What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?
I've got a lot of em. Wanted to build something with 2 colors for a while. Just a few I've thought might be neat include:

>Kambal
>Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind
>Jori En
>Karametra

Also thought of building Queen Marchesa and Kazuul.
>>
>>52133941
Got a list for Nicky B?
>>
File: shadowborn_apostle.jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
shadowborn_apostle.jpg
32KB, 223x310px
>>52133868
>Not using the best one drop in the format as your OP image
>>
>>52134303
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/nicol-bolas-age-of-dragons/

Here you go, I've updated the list just for you.

I'm looking forward to Amhonket.
>>
>>52134185

I tried Knight tribal with Rafiq, but people always assumed I was running Rafiq.dec and would always attack me first.
>>
>>521339720
If by that you mean
Swords
Ponder
Demonic Consultation
Lightning Bolt
Quirion Ranger
Time Vault (honorary mention Skullclamp but there can be only one)
then sure.
>>
>>52134352
What set is that brolas from? Got any other foil dragons?
>>
File: joraga-treespeaker-16446-medium.jpg (32KB, 277x401px) Image search: [Google]
joraga-treespeaker-16446-medium.jpg
32KB, 277x401px
>>52133868
>one drop edition
>not sol ring
>yet still a sol ring
>>
>>52133941
Have you ever considered Sydri? She's a stealth combo machine if you fancy or you can play mana rock aggro if that's more your speed. She's not quite as powerful as Sharuum but only due to less 2 card combos. A plethora of fun and easy 3 card combos with her though, look up Karn, Silver Golem combos to get something of an idea.

I built her as an eggs list but it needs work. Just got a masterpiece Ancient Tomb for her though. She's also fun to build as a complex grinding deck of value that eventually hopes to get a critical mass of artifacts and combo off. Kinda like Slobad but with counterspells and tutors.
>>
File: white1drops.png (4MB, 1234x1333px) Image search: [Google]
white1drops.png
4MB, 1234x1333px
>>52133868
I love one-drops!
>>
>>52133955
Ruric-Thar/Xenagos, God of Revels are good starting points.
>>
File: blue1drop.png (4MB, 1233x1333px) Image search: [Google]
blue1drop.png
4MB, 1233x1333px
>>52134387
>>
>>52134387
White has some really nice one drops, it's great.
>>
>>52134387
Where's your Sunlance plebeian?
>>
>>52134363
Yeah, I've been tempted to make some sort of Bant list, but I didn't want to get gunned down for picking Rafiq or Derememe.
>>
File: Black1drop.png (4MB, 1231x1333px) Image search: [Google]
Black1drop.png
4MB, 1231x1333px
>>52134387

>>52134404
There's much better white removal. That said, I do love Sunlance.
>>
>>52134379
Sounds fun, do you have a list of what you're working on? She always felt a bit janky when I tried her.

Also Ancient Tomb masterpiece art is amazing.
>>
>>52134180
Mystic Remora is not something you want to play turn 1 despite the casting cost.
>>
Question: is there a website / app like tapped out which functions as a deck builder but also lists all the sets a card was printed in under/near each card? Looking through folders at the FLGS takes long enough without looking up which set every single card was printed in
>>
File: Red1drop.png (4MB, 1231x1328px) Image search: [Google]
Red1drop.png
4MB, 1231x1328px
>>52134420
>>
>>52134373
That's the From the Vault art work.

Also yes, I've foiled out my deck completely. (Also have loads of foil dragons laying around from when the deck was more janky than it is now. )
>>
File: green1drop.png (4MB, 1231x1328px) Image search: [Google]
green1drop.png
4MB, 1231x1328px
>>52134435
>>
>>52134369
None of those can even compare to the glorious unending horde of demon-worshiping 1/1's.
>>
File: Colorless1drop.png (4MB, 1231x1328px) Image search: [Google]
Colorless1drop.png
4MB, 1231x1328px
>>52134446
And I'm done. Probably some great cards I overlooked. Oh well.
>>
>>52134423
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/sydri-of-the-confusing-convoluted-combo-deck/

It's a little outdated. Maybe I'll update it before too long.
>>
>>52134369
Time vault costs 2 mana, friend.
>>
>>52134426
Why not? I say that you're wrong. Unless you're in dumb ramp meta where no one does anything but play lands for first two turns, then sure. In better metas everything important happens in turns 1 through 3, so it would be dumb not to play it on 1st turn.
>>
File: 1463939377696.jpg (39KB, 352x370px) Image search: [Google]
1463939377696.jpg
39KB, 352x370px
>>52134459
>Grafdigger's Cage
>mfw I've been playing zombie tribal lately
Fucking hell, this technology must never see the light of day in my playgroup.
>>
>>52134489
>Why not?
Because you will have only one mana avaiable every turn you want to keep it around.
>>
>>52134460
Have you considered Saheeli's Artistry?

Also Eggs sounds like an interesting take.
>>
File: Screenshot_2017-03-12-03-27-54.png (2MB, 1440x2560px) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_2017-03-12-03-27-54.png
2MB, 1440x2560px
>>52134441
You don't say...
I've found you out, fucker.
>>
>>52134374
>3 mana Sol Ring that is affected by summoning sickness
>>
>>52134497
I play OG Sigarda and feel the same way about Glaring Spotlight.
>>
>>52134522
Yep that's the one, I've changed it up a bit since then because on of the comments was basically: get your shit together, run more ramp/draw.

And the more I thought about it the more I realized he was right. So I added the Signets, Fellwar Stone and a heap of draw spells to make it more efficient.

I got it from an average cmc of 4.7 to 3.9 whilst trying my best to keep to my theme.
>>
File: 1414957470328.png (104KB, 375x360px) Image search: [Google]
1414957470328.png
104KB, 375x360px
>>52134522
>>52134441
>two redshitters
>two
Holy fucking shit leave leave now leave fucking leave go away leave.
>>
>>52134508
It's a pretty fun card. Probably worth playing just for laffs. I'm going to add Helm of Awakening and Paradoxical outcome so I can draw heaps of cards and play lots of free artifacts. I've also got a Mishra's Bauble and a few new spicy eggs to throw in.
>>
>>52134225
post Mayael pls? I'm having a lot of trouble with mine.

how come there's no porn of this babe. I'm actually sorta surprised.
>>
>>52134507
You undervalue card advantage. You play it in 1st turn and stop paying when it becomes too expensive, which is usually 3 mana. It's most useful early game, but still useful somewhat late game.
The giggling ramp retard (not the one playing gruul because that faggot never pays and goes ballistic when blue player draws from his triggers) will have enough to pay for his Primal Surge and the Remora trigger.
>>
File: Screenshot_2017-03-12-03-43-32.png (2MB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_2017-03-12-03-43-32.png
2MB, 2560x1440px
>>52134571
You alright anon?
>>
File: 1472070674233.jpg (6KB, 226x226px) Image search: [Google]
1472070674233.jpg
6KB, 226x226px
>>52134522
>accusing someone else of browsing reddit
>while being a reddshittor yourself
Kys senpai
>>
>>52134821
You were a mistake
>>
File: 1478942034230.jpg (64KB, 633x758px) Image search: [Google]
1478942034230.jpg
64KB, 633x758px
/tg/ I need your help here, my playgroup consists of 4 people, two of them have degenerate combos that can kill out of nowhere in one turn, the other one is a land destruction deck with reaper king and I play control.

Now, I can make a person not win with removal and exiling stuff, but I can't control two people at the same time, I just run out of fuel, I don't even remember the last time I won a game. So what should I do, suggest them to do 1 vs 1 matches a lot more often? I can perform really good in those.
>>
Is /tg/'s autism overflowing lately or are kiddies migrating here from /co/ and /v/?
>>
>>52134864
The same 4 turboautists have shat up the last 3 threads.
>>
>best 1 drops
duh (duh)
norin the wary
volatic key (for sol ring)
burgeoning
savage summoning
thunderous wrath miracle cost
altar of the brood
lightning zerker
spy network
elvish vanguard
any geek.
there thats off the top of my head, im out.
>>
>>52134749
>2016+1
>Still not knowing that 4chan and Reddit communities are overlapping
>>
>>52134225
How big do you think Mayael prefers them? We all know she's a size queen, but do you think she's hoofdaddy sized?
>>
EDH is such a broken format lol
>>
File: winterorb.jpg (174KB, 450x383px) Image search: [Google]
winterorb.jpg
174KB, 450x383px
>>52134849
Stax is control for the group. Join the dark side.
>>
>>52134864
It's a cycle anon:
>some trendy crossboard posting faggot comes here thinking they're hot shit
>tries extremely rudimentary attempts at trolling
>one of our regulars calls them out on it, completely ignores them
>eventually they enlist another cross board poster to help them shit the place up
>after a month or so, they fuck off, regulars come back and the cycle begins anew
I just wish people would let us have nice things, just once.
>>
>>52134864
>>52135415
I can confirm it's crossboard presence
>>
File: 1454271857458.png (270KB, 326x612px) Image search: [Google]
1454271857458.png
270KB, 326x612px
What do you do with a person who scoops in a multiplayer game in response to you dealing damage so that some triggers or something don't happen and you don't get your trigger activations that could potentially help you?

Is this seen as a bad thing to do? One of the players in my playgroup doesn't like to die with honor, but my deck relies a lot on dealing damage for things to happen.
>>
>>52135109
No i know that and you should return to your cancerous site
>>
>>52135509
And if you insist on bitching, perhaps you should go to one of our containment boards. I bet /pol/, /b/ or /r9k/ would be happy to have you.
>>
What if one player is the monarch and he concedes when he's about to receive damage and lose it?
>>
>tfw Fumiko on turn 2 makes all three opponents concede

:^) christ aggro decks make people so fucking salty online
>>
>>52135561
The active player becomes the monarch.
>>
>>52135504
as a guy who plays with 3 black heavy decks on the table he either needs to suck it up or change his deck
>>
File: WitheringBoon.jpg (31KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
WitheringBoon.jpg
31KB, 223x310px
>friend brings out his new Azami, warns me that it's basically a "counterspell combo deck" and that his previous opponent hated playing against it because of all the counterspells
>I bring out Anafenza since she's good in 1v1
>he races to Azami, casts her
>counter with pic related
Needless to say he was on tilt. Then I switched to Aurelia and Pyroblasted her.

That said, Azami is a pretty sweet deck, especially now with the printing of Paradox Engine. You just have to know when to concede against her.
>>
>>52135509
>Return to your cancerous site
I'm already on the most cancerous one and I don't use Reddit, I hate the interface
>>
>>52135526
plebit pls go and stay go
>>
>>52135604
WRONG
If the monarch leaves the game for a reason other than than being dealt lethal combat damage the player whose turn it currently is becomes the monarch, if it is the current monarch's turn the next player in the turn order becomes the monarch.
>>
>>52134597
Fellow anon made a piece with her, I think it was buttfish
>>
>>52135526
>redshitter
>hates /pol/
Confirmed for libtard redshit pleb. Trump is your president, friendo.
>>
File: mayael2.jpg (80KB, 320x446px) Image search: [Google]
mayael2.jpg
80KB, 320x446px
>>52134597
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/mayaels-massive-monsters-1/
I think I need more ramp.
Haven't bothered updating it in a while either, there's quite a few great fatties that have come out recently.

>>52135143
However big it is, its too small for her.
>>
>>52136135
yeah i saw that one. I guess at least it exists I can put away my crayons.

>>52136182
thank you Anon. smart use with the fox.
>>
>>52135792
Is your mother and sister the same person or are you just pretending? I recommend you look up what "active player" means and read the question before embarrassing yourself again.
>>
>>52134849
>>52135285
there's basically no real way to consistently beat 2 combo decks with spot removally control. there's 3 ways for you to deal with them though

1.
>play a better faster combo deck than them and win before they do

2.
>play hard stax like other anon suggested

but those 2 are just fighting cancer with more cancer, and will most likely start an arms race that will send your group in a downward spiral and eventually no one involved will be having fun

in a perfect world the answer would be:

3.
>convince them that they're misunderstanding the point of the format by playing solitaire combo decks and that your group should be playing 75% EDH that relies on board state rather than combo to win, like god intended

true EDH only reveals itself to the worthy, those who would blind themselves with their desires to win will only find pain
>>
>>52134849
Brent?
>>
>>52136367
darryl?
>>
>>52134441
Stop making edh suck again.
>>
>>52136394
Rocky?
>>
>>52134849
You have to be more specific.
What deck are you currently playing
What combos are being used
I imagine they aren't break neck speed because of mld reaper King's inclusion.
Also
Stax will help you.
>>
>>52136322
serves me right for trusting the Wizard's website instead of referencing the comp rules
>>
>>52134864
Reddit
Have you ever been to the edh sub? It's fucking cancer, worse cancer then teegee.
>>
>>52135600
>online
You care talking about a community who's content creators will bitch about counter spells and concede to a t4 Mana leak
I'm talking about you, gare_bear you fucking fat autist.
>>
>>52136344
>>52136432

Thanks for the suggestions, I guess the only correct answer is to make them build new decks or play 1 vs 1 more often

I run Wrexial and Obzedat, and they run Breya with a shitton of combos involving clan ironworks and the other decks is prossh with food chain and purphoros and things that kill very fast
>>
File: DampingMatrix.jpg (31KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
DampingMatrix.jpg
31KB, 223x310px
>>52136478
Dampening matrix reprint incoming
Get you one!
>>
>>52134821
Commend sudoku. Like now.
>>
>>52136582
Playing colorless voltron, I've got to repeat what >>52134497 said. It's already bad enough we've got a Karn player and a Sydri player who animate my equips to rip 'em off until EOT.
>>
>>52135504
In my playgroup, you are only allowed to concede during your main phases when the stack is empty.

Of course, this usually doesn't need to apply (and when one guy is obviously going to win, people can pack up their cards), but if said winning player requires the other players to stay in order to win, then they are still in the game.

So no conceding in response to Feast and Famine triggers, or conceding in response to getting attacked with a Rith with a purphoros in play etc.
>>
>>52135504
It's a legitimate strategy, don't be a little bitch. Account for everything. The extra layer of strategy it adds can be very fun.
>>
>>52135504
conceding at sorcery speed is best, otherwise you get little bitches like >>52136829 who like to play kingmaker by either conceding or not conceding
>>
File: Bestedhfeels.jpg (177KB, 910x406px) Image search: [Google]
Bestedhfeels.jpg
177KB, 910x406px
>>52136344
>>convince them that they're misunderstanding the point of the format by playing solitaire combo decks and that your group should be playing 75% EDH that relies on board state rather than combo to win, like god intended

Little timmy cry whe he cannot turn his creatures sideways? sing me in
>>
File: 8NQMN7y.jpg (2MB, 3264x2448px) Image search: [Google]
8NQMN7y.jpg
2MB, 3264x2448px
>What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?

I would wanna build a mono blue stax deck. But I don't wanna spend too much money on another deck.
>>
>>52136946

How can Timmy destroy your shit?
>>
>>52136971

Is that pic your deck? I have an annoying Prossh player in my group, what are the cards or strategies that hurt you THE MOST?

>>52136582

is this any good against you?
>>
>>52136971

This is a combo deck aiming for a turn 4-5 win on average. I am sure you are all aware of how Food Chain Prossh works.
>>
>>52136983
Yeah that's my deck. There are two ways to build the deck. The ramp value version (much slower, good for late game) or the food chain combo version (much faster and more competitive). Which version does your friend have?
>>
File: 1489332444949.png (321KB, 1839x693px) Image search: [Google]
1489332444949.png
321KB, 1839x693px
>>
>>52136946
timmies btfo!!
>>
>>52136946
>Little timmy cry whe he cannot turn his creatures sideways? sing me in
Are you strokin' out?
>>
>>52137007

she has food chain and purphoros and basically can kill you in one turn out of nowhere
>>
>>52136974
They can't
>>
>>52137046
Kill you how though? Does she always go infinite with Food Chain?
>>
File: IMG_3746.jpg (67KB, 680x848px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_3746.jpg
67KB, 680x848px
>>52137018
>>
I've started to notice edh only really boils down to two players:
>those who want to have fun and know how to play for fun.
>those who want to win and usually play under the guise of having fun, but don't realize it's only fun for the one person.

The latter also usually scoops or goes full revenge mode when denied their combos.

Folks gotta realize it's not a strictly competitive format, you can check if your LGS does tournies but it's unlikely.
>>
File: 5SEe6fDE.png (513KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
5SEe6fDE.png
513KB, 1280x720px
>>52136859
>Whines about the rules
>Calls others little bitches
>>
File: 1425882992154.png (39KB, 342x355px) Image search: [Google]
1425882992154.png
39KB, 342x355px
>>52137018
>>
File: 1422833440168.jpg (81KB, 680x680px) Image search: [Google]
1422833440168.jpg
81KB, 680x680px
>>52137138
>posts smug weebshit pictures
>>
>>52137132
First Goal on EDH
>Have Fun
Second Goal on EDH
>Make your opponent to have 0 fun
How is that hard for you to understand?
>>
>>52137093

yeah purphoros can or just something that gives prossh haste or any other dirty trick
>>
File: UNbncUUa.jpg (23KB, 416x415px) Image search: [Google]
UNbncUUa.jpg
23KB, 416x415px
>>52137157
>Posts on a Sri Lankan glassblowing forum
>Complains about Sri Lankan glassblowing cartoons
>>
File: 1423542131196.jpg (45KB, 446x400px) Image search: [Google]
1423542131196.jpg
45KB, 446x400px
>>52137173
>implying i'm complaining
>using the same tired "4chan is for weebs!" argument
Not only are you weebs guaranteed to reply, your replies are more and more pathetic each time.
>>
>>52137198
>Lol why are you replying to me
>When you got salty enough to whine about rules and call people out
Your tears taste heavenly on my tongue.
>>
File: 1477149279590.png (30KB, 246x200px) Image search: [Google]
1477149279590.png
30KB, 246x200px
>>52137132

More like

>New playgroup
>Everybody builds their casual deck, everyone has a lot of fun
>Then everyone discovers good cards for their deck in EDHREC or something
>Everyone proceeds to make their decks as strong as possible
>Basically the playgroup becomes combo vs stax and sideboards and massive rage each game

I'm starting to realize the only winning move is not to play.
>>
>>52133941
Scott is that you?
>>
File: 1448080010529.gif (21KB, 196x267px) Image search: [Google]
1448080010529.gif
21KB, 196x267px
>>52137217
>Lol why are you replying to me
I never asked why, weeblord. But it never fails. Keep it up!
>now implying I'm salty
So this is the weeb retort? Pretend people say things they didn't? Doing a top notch job, friendo.
>>
File: Gm4w0gi1.jpg (111KB, 494x499px) Image search: [Google]
Gm4w0gi1.jpg
111KB, 494x499px
>>52137257
>"little bitches like this who like to play kingmaker"
>"LOL!!!!111, nice try putting words in my mouth and saying that I'm whining kiddo :^)!!1"
>>
File: 1424207881983.jpg (60KB, 509x720px) Image search: [Google]
1424207881983.jpg
60KB, 509x720px
>>52137276
>>"little bitches like this who like to play kingmaker"
>>>>>he thinks that was me
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>he thinks I'm the guy that posted that
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha you don't have a fucking clue, do you, basement dweller?
>>
File: Ozoap11I.jpg (39KB, 492x492px) Image search: [Google]
Ozoap11I.jpg
39KB, 492x492px
>>52137313
>So assblasted that he spergs out when anyone posts a smug anime face
>Implying that's somehow better than being a little bitch about the rules
I don't know how you managed it but you are even more autistic than I first thought.
>>
File: 1414731670119.gif (2MB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]
1414731670119.gif
2MB, 250x250px
>>52137342
>now trying to imply that i'm assblasted or sperging out
Keep replying, weeblord :^)
>>
And this, gentlemen, is why nobody takes the format seriously.
>>
>>52137170
Okay, I get it. The worst thing you can do to a Prossh player in general is to kill his mana rocks and his elfs. Slow him down. It's a 6cmc commander so.
>>
File: ULaPRhSp.jpg (25KB, 680x383px) Image search: [Google]
ULaPRhSp.jpg
25KB, 680x383px
>>52137353
>Feels the need to reply to someone posting a smug anime face regardless of what they said
>Somehow not assblasted eternally
>"lol keep replying weebo this is going on my ebin blog :^)"
>>
File: 1417038373824.gif (670KB, 320x234px) Image search: [Google]
1417038373824.gif
670KB, 320x234px
>>52137415
Keep replying, weeblord. ;^)
>>
WAIT I just realized why edhg took such a dramatic decline over the past 3 days, it's spring break month!
>>
>>52137436
>>
>>52133941

I like most of the cards in this deck, but aren't you missing win conditions? Drawing cards is fun and all, but you gotta win somewhow, and attacking with Rashmi doesn't sound like a great plan.
>>
>>52137166
Anon confirmed citizen scoops.
>>
File: 1419366969854.gif (767KB, 200x150px) Image search: [Google]
1419366969854.gif
767KB, 200x150px
>>52137448
>>
File: CcAa4WPQ.jpg (28KB, 337x404px) Image search: [Google]
CcAa4WPQ.jpg
28KB, 337x404px
>>52137482
>>
File: 11.jpg (65KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
11.jpg
65KB, 312x445px
New thread when.
>>
>>52137313
>basement dweller
>posts on tg
>>
File: 1419800117326.gif (967KB, 245x180px) Image search: [Google]
1419800117326.gif
967KB, 245x180px
>>52137546
>>
>>52137446
Well that explains everything. Time to hide my head in xmage until the shitstorm passes through.
>>
>>52137132
I think you should add a third kind of player, the salty ones.
>those who will always find something to complain about, in or out of game.
My group hated on anything that won right out down to considering banning sol ring or MY SUNFORGER. If it wins it's broken to them. Just salty as hell. We were just brewing and the fact I had a sword of feast and famine and aggravated assault was like I resurrected Hitler. But when I pointed out the Newzuri player had a sage of hours they jumped on that. Fuck me does it get annoying
>>
>>52137603
>down to considering banning sol
You say that like it isn't a brilliant and honestly perfectly logical and reasonable idea.
>>
>>52137603
they lump under the second player set as -they'll- have fun if you let them play their wincons unmolested
>>
>>52137551
Sorry anon, but we have to put up with smuganime.jpg poster and his boyfriend arguing, or we can find something to talk about. You like karmic guide? Im considering it for Aurelia.
>>
File: tUxEghka.jpg (62KB, 640x736px) Image search: [Google]
tUxEghka.jpg
62KB, 640x736px
>>52137585
>>
>>52137658
I was pointing out that they considered my sunforger was as bad as sol ring. I didnt even have a puresteel paladin. I was paying 5 mana for an instant in my deck and instead of krosan gripping it they wanted to ban it
>>
>>52137669
Yeah I see it. Carry on
>>
File: spirit-of-edh.jpg (79KB, 600x420px) Image search: [Google]
spirit-of-edh.jpg
79KB, 600x420px
>>52137721
Shut up it's too late for excuses. We're solringposting now.
>>
>>52137827
Well shit. I'm down for removing it as long as the crypts and vaults get removed too.
>>
New thread when?
The shitposting count has reached the limit about 20 posts ago
>>
>>52137866
What do you want to talk about?
>>
>>52137877
Children card games, the one where you get 100 cards and one of them is a general or something
>>
>>52137893
What about it?
>>
>>52137846
What kind of fucking scrub would want to ban these? They just give mana, they're not wincons like Craterhoof.
>>
>>52137827
soon
>>
What spiciness from Amonkek do you want?
>>
>>52137932
same folks who want to literally ban Ux
>>
>>52137910
What are some spicy wincons for Prossh? I feel like including the usual Purphoros and Craterhoof would just be boring
>>
File: 1488371443130.jpg (62KB, 392x464px) Image search: [Google]
1488371443130.jpg
62KB, 392x464px
>when you want to make a battle of wits deck using wish cards like spawnsire of ulamog and "shuffle back into library" effects but the rules say that wish carda do nothing so it wouldn't do anything at a non-playgroup table
Living is suffering.
>>
>>52137866
>Bitches about shitposting
>Does not contribute to the thread while doing so.

Anon, you are the shitposting.

More relevant to EDH though, how do people feel about Thoughtseize style effects in EDH? I have been using Vendillion clique and Thought-knot Seer in my grixis marchesa list and they have been doing pretty well, I never see anyone else run those kinds of effects though.

Also does anybody have recommendations for good bounce spells? I already run Venser and rift and want to up my bounce count because I really like the interaction with this shit, but everything else seems to be overcosted or hits only creatures. Bonus points if the bounce effect is attached to a creature.
>>
>>52137932
Poor people who get buttmad because they see they're rich friends play them and they want one of their own but they can't buy one
>>
>>52137932
Apparently these guys
>>52137658
>>52137827
I'm not against it but I will remove them from my deck it happens willingly
>>
File: sol ring full art.jpg (94KB, 620x350px) Image search: [Google]
sol ring full art.jpg
94KB, 620x350px
It begins
>>
>>52137967
Well there is the added bonus of voltron prossh with a blood artist and a cutthroat out. But unless you have a haste enabler it won't stick.
>>
>>52137157
>using weebshit inappropriately

quit doing this to yourself. please understand words are important to know before using them
>>
>>52137893
>children's card game
You're thinking of Yugioh or Pokemon, anon. MTG is aimed at teenagers and adults.
>>
Does anyone else like to imagine each match as a full scale battle?
>>
File: fuuuck.png (768KB, 738x908px) Image search: [Google]
fuuuck.png
768KB, 738x908px
>>52134188
posting

Still looking for help with surrak and yidris, sadly. but i think i have a handle on the addiction now
>>
File: images (1).jpg (4KB, 276x183px) Image search: [Google]
images (1).jpg
4KB, 276x183px
>itt: people don't understand why Sol ring and fast mana is ban worthy.
How fundamentally stupid are /tg/posters?
This is why I like /r/EDH, they at least understand why fast mana is broken.

>>52138120
>people who unironically name their decks
>>
Alright /edhg/ I decided I wanted to build a Rakdos deck that would be... cruel, perhaps, but by virtue of its color choice if nothing else not tryhard. I've settled on Mogis but will not be going full Stax. I've got Havoc Festival, what goes best with that?
>>
>>52137975
>thoughtseize effects
They don't scale well to multiplayer so you're best off avoiding them unless they're reusable like the examples you mentioned
>bounce spells
Chain of Vapor just got reprinted and it's really good. Especially if you run Isochron Scepter or Snappy. Also Cryptic Command
>>
>>52138149
easier to name them than to have oijqtijadgji or my favorite, asfasfasfafa as a deck name.
>>
File: 1472649447888.jpg (63KB, 728x546px) Image search: [Google]
1472649447888.jpg
63KB, 728x546px
>>52138149
>/r/EDH
>>
File: 2465.jpg (34KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]
2465.jpg
34KB, 300x300px
>>52137932
>they're not wincons so they cant be format warping
>>
>>52138232
Play sydri and kill them with a sol ring. Then they will come around
>>
File: massbait.jpg (36KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]
massbait.jpg
36KB, 625x626px
>>52138149
>>
File: 1473558956011.jpg (474KB, 1619x1725px) Image search: [Google]
1473558956011.jpg
474KB, 1619x1725px
>>52137342
my smug anime faces are better
>>
>>52137991
>implying I wouldn't just buy one from a chinaman if I really wanted to become cancer
>>
File: 1483276451170.jpg (74KB, 960x538px) Image search: [Google]
1483276451170.jpg
74KB, 960x538px
>>52138338
You call that smug?
Watch this
>>
>>52138353
But anon, you already are the cancer
>>
File: 1483840862690.jpg (228KB, 981x1233px) Image search: [Google]
1483840862690.jpg
228KB, 981x1233px
>>52138338
>>52138393
>>
File: 1474615102450.png (277KB, 396x396px) Image search: [Google]
1474615102450.png
277KB, 396x396px
>>52138419
>>
>>52137585
>>52137313
>>52137257
>>52137198
>>52137157
>>52136859
>t.faggot who cannot into the rules of the game
>>
>>52138162
The only cruelty to be done by using a Rakdos deck is to its own user.
>>
>>52138529
You, sir, have clearly never faced Rakdos Stax. The denial of anything resembling a board state is positively delicious. And at least a couple Rakdos commanders support the notion, having destructive, resource eating effects. I mean, it's not Boros for crying out loud.
>>
File: odric.png (108KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
odric.png
108KB, 223x311px
so what kind of fuckery can i do with this guy?
>>
File: s4276.jpg (158KB, 600x821px) Image search: [Google]
s4276.jpg
158KB, 600x821px
>>52138588
>unironically using the combat step
>in a format where 3+ people each have 40 life
No anon, I don't know what "denial of anything resembling a boardstate," is because I play decks with actual win conditions that aren't completely btfo by a supreme Verdict/Merciless eviction. If you beat plebes by playing rakdos stax, more power to you. It just seems like you playgroup needs to git gud.

>>52138641
Put him in the 99.
>>
File: d7b.jpg (13KB, 300x169px) Image search: [Google]
d7b.jpg
13KB, 300x169px
>>52138338
I'd challenge you to a smug-off, but I'm on my phone without access to my main smug folder.
>>
>>52138669
>implying LD and discard don't exist or that BR doesn't do them

OK.
>>
>>52138760
Maybe if you want to play alone. These things are against the spirit of EDH and any good group should kick you out for running them.
>>
>>52138929
>stop stopping my combos! It's not fair!
>>
>>52138980
If my combos bother you then you should just combo faster. Hand disruption and MLD is for assholes. I'm not sitting down at the EDH table to have all my early ramp blown up by some fun-hating stax fag.
>>
>>52139017
>combos bother you
>fun-hating
>staxfag
STOP INTERACTING WITH MY BOARDSTATE
>>
>>52139051
That's literally not what I'm saying you fucking retard. You can interact with anything on my board that's not lands or mana rocks, as long as it's past turn 4.
>>
>>52139017
>comboing out turn 4 is fine but playing stax and discard is somehow against the spirit of edh
"Weeeeeeeeh, stop interacting with me, weeeeeeeh
>>
>>52139077
>ou can interact with anything on my board that's not lands or mana rocks
STOP INTERACTING WITH MY BOARD
>>
>>52139085
see >>52139077

Faggots like you are why this format needs anti-bullying rules.
>>
>>52138588
>The denial of anything resembling a board state is positively delicious
Oh I know. I play an actually good Stax engine with Brago that doesn't burn itself out by virtue of having blue and repeatable ETB effects. Shit that Rakdos as a color significantly struggles with.
>muh discard
Worthless in anything beyond 1v1. And if you're doing that, just go Vial Smasher and dunk niggers. An early discard is just painting a target on your head. And there's a good chance that it will help your opponent more often than not, what with GY being an extremely popular strat.
>LD
I'm going to be frank with you, MLD isn't shit now. People are rocking Mana Crypts and Vaults and mana rocks + dorks up the ass. It's a cute strategy, but one that gets worthless the more the game goes on. And again, if you start eating one dude's mana base, that's a target on your head.

Rakdos simply isn't a good color combo in the format, and rakdos stax is simply bad mtg.
>>
>>52139077
Jesus Christ you are a whiny pissbaby if I've ever seen one.
Stop posting any time.
>>
>>52139108
You're a fun-hating smegma-dicked pussy faggot if I've ever seen one, I bet you run counterspells too. Go back to vintage with your broken bullshit.
>>
File: 1488163657130.gif (1MB, 226x272px) Image search: [Google]
1488163657130.gif
1MB, 226x272px
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/jhiora-thinggy/

What 4 cards do I drop?
>>
>>52139104
>Worthless in anything beyond 1v1
Mostly, but there are some nice pieces like Necrogen Mists or especially Bottomless pit that, even if they aren't strictly good, will throw some folks into rage seizures.
>>
>>52139151
10/10 take it to worlds
>>
Can we please for the love of God new thread when?
>>
>>52139159
Ooops. Should be fine now
>>
>>52139179
Still have north of a hundred posts before this shitstorm hits bump limit.
>>
>>52139151
>thinggy
under aged posting is not allowed
>>
>>52138187
>Chain of Vapor
>Isochron Scepter
Yeah they'll just bounce the scepter
>>
>>52139156
I don't like Mists, because it's a free gy setup. Pit is alright, but I'd rather just pay the 1BB for an Arena and actually cover up Rakdos's piss poor card advantage, while not drawing too much hate.
>>
>>52133868
For fuck's sake, is summer here already? this thread makes /pfg/ Look like civilized discussion.
>>
>>52139217
Shut up you poo head
>>
File: Image.jpg (27KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
27KB, 223x310px
So I run related for any deck with big mana, I have nearly one of every eldrazi ever printed, and it's fun to spew them all out.
I do clear it with the people I'm playing with, and am willing to alter my "sideboard" to what they would rather play against. I have them all sorted by color identity, and cast only the ones that fit the the deck(I'd cast Decimator of Provinces in Omnath, but not Monored Artifacts). Some people insist on the 15 Card sideboard idea, which I'm also fine with, I just limit it down to the best 15 for the deck. No one has objected to my using it yet due to there being no official outside the game rules, but if they did I wouldn't use that ability at all. 4 mana for 2 tokens isn't optimal, but in a huge mana deck it works.

W-would you play with me /tg/?

Also post other pet cards of yours.
>>
>>52139317
I know right? God damn newfags not understanding 4chan's deep anime culture *pouts*
>>
>>52139466
I came here to fucking discuss magic, not for 24 hour circle jerk about bullshit.
>>
>>52139317
I think some legendary shitposter from /kspg/ was set lose by accident, the shitposting is running rampant in a bunch of threads today
>>
File: summerfags.jpg (62KB, 1024x409px) Image search: [Google]
summerfags.jpg
62KB, 1024x409px
>>52139506
But it's like this year round though.
>>
>>52135143
She won't even look your way if you're not at least a 5/5, but a 20/20 will really make her "sing."
>>
File: 1481173626742.png (31KB, 790x144px) Image search: [Google]
1481173626742.png
31KB, 790x144px
>>
>>52136829
Instantly losing isn't a strategy. If people can't take the heat and quit like a bitch fine, let them. But you can't say that is a strategy unless their goal in the game is to either: a) help someone else win, or b) impede someone else a bit. If your goal is to win, conceding is the exact opposite of a "legitimate strategy".

If your goal is to have fun, why bother conceding in the first place? Just accept that someone else beat you and get ready for the next game.
>>
>>52138110
That's not what Maro says
>>
>>52139931
If someone didn't honor a political deal we made, I'll try to fuck him over in any way I can to discourage that behaviour for the next game. I hardly even need pillowfort anymore due to not accepting any violation of the NAP.

It's a strategy.
>>
File: Blind Seer_IN.jpg (58KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
Blind Seer_IN.jpg
58KB, 312x445px
>>52139764
As a blind slut, she yearns for Urza's powerful oldwalker cock. She's ready to submit to blue mana's allure and get some of it cover her face.
>>
File: 1482787979630.jpg (26KB, 552x437px) Image search: [Google]
1482787979630.jpg
26KB, 552x437px
>>52139764
>Have been mostly playing Thromok lately
>Literal dickshape
>Mfw 400/400
>>
>>52139977
That's in the context of backstabbing though, and in that case your end-goal has shifted from winning to revenge. In which case, yea I get conceding to fuck the person who deliberately fucked you. Personally, I still wouldn't do it but I get it.

I was talking more along the lines of if Im playing my timmy saskia deck and l manage to get a big swing off at player A, which will then go to player B, itd be annoying if A went "lol no i concede xD" because he was upset he lost, not that I had wronged him somehow.
>>
>>52139998
Fuck, it's been so long since I've seen this card.

Has any popular cornerstone of /tg/ and nerd culture not ripped off Dune?
>>
>>52140027
Post Throbcock list pls
>>
>>52140148
>ripped off Dune
M:tG's done it plenty (Just ask the "Wurm" type) but the idea of a blind figure with great wisdom or oracular abilities is way, WAY older than Herbert.
>>
>>52140138
>Timmy crying
You deserve it
>>
>>52140148
>dune invented blind seers

read a fucking book jesus christ
>>
File: 48a7642fd4eb98cff00d14eab1110d44.jpg (139KB, 669x1100px) Image search: [Google]
48a7642fd4eb98cff00d14eab1110d44.jpg
139KB, 669x1100px
>>52140148
Even Tarot ripped It off from Dune, right anon?
>>
>>52140241
Don't have a list, I wrote it down on paper like a faggot.

However, Psychosis crawler + any of the draw spells that draw equal to greatest power among creatures or that draw equal to amount of creatures are delicious (or hell, even fecundity to discourage boardwipes).

It's a pretty casual deck, so I also run shit like mana reflection and zendikar resurgent and regal behemoth (because monarch is fun and goes in every deck), allowing for delicious plays like insurrection into thromok.
>>
>>52133868

>What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?

Jhoira. Her new art might make me finally do it.
>>
>>52139077
Holy shit you might be the biggest bitch I have ever seen. You seriously whine about people denying you resources at any point in the game and interacting with you before turn 4? You might as well quit and just play solitaire if you can deal with people trying to stop you from winning.
>>
What is the best commander for cheating out big fatties?
>>
>>52140528
Kaalia
>>
>>52133868
>What's that one deck you've always wanted to build but could never get around to it?
Grenzo 1.0 wide reanimator. It just never comes together into a reasonable form.
>>
>>52140528
Jhoira
>>
>>52139464
I wouldn't. 20 mana is stupid easy to get to in omnath and that allows you to cast 15 giant eldrazi for 20 mana? I'll pass being that the rules specifically state you can't do it, but maybe that's just me.
>>
>>52140294
I mean how the all-powerful main character pretended to be a blind seer to help out his generation spanning plan. (Gerrard and the Legacy, Leto II and the golden path.)
>>52140343
No one is that retarded, faggot.
>>
>>52140528
Timmy
>>
>>52140380
I meant to also reply to you here
>>52140722
In the nonrude catagory, of course.
>>
>>52139130
>Autistic screeching
>>
>>52133972
Hit me up with that there Saffi listo friendo
>>
Thoughts on this?
Not meant for "competitive"
http://tappedout.net/mtg-deckpaste/12-03-17-EYg-none/
>>
>>52140719
How it mentions to talk to your playgroup in the ruling itself is why I think that the ruling isn't the best argument against it. I don't think it's unfair, and if I don't have 30 mana right away, it has to stick around until I have 20.

Would you allow it in a colorless deck?
>>
>>52140795
Then why do you care about feedback. Go and lose with your shitbrew
>>
Is it possible to build Brago without becoming cancer? I like flicker for value but it seems hard to put a stop to the value before it becomes unreasonably good
>>
>>52140960
just play only shitty cards and you're good
>>
How does everyone play their EDH here?
>>
>>52140960
Just don't include an easy infinite turn/combat engine and you should be OK. You can still go pretty degenerate without that, but this is EDH you need to be at least capable of doing something degenerate somewhere along the line to be in competition.
>>
File: 1476346901307.jpg (341KB, 800x1132px) Image search: [Google]
1476346901307.jpg
341KB, 800x1132px
>>52140999
Sorry I meant to type:

In what form does everyone play EDH here?
*Paper
*Modo
*Xmage
*Cockatrice
>>
>>52141039
Paper only. For me at least it's a core part of the M:tG experience
>>
>>52141039
paper
what>>52141076 said, it doesn't help that all digital forms are also inferior
>>
>>52140999
in person only nice trips
>>
>>52141039
On Xmage and in meat space.
>>
>>52141039
Paper only, trying to get xmage to work for shits and jiggles. Now give me sauce on that page
>>
File: Image (2).jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (2).jpg
32KB, 223x310px
Any spicy tech for Thrun voltron?
>>
>>52141364
Rancor
>>
>>52141039
Paper only right now. I used to do xmage but it broke and now my computer will only attempt to open it in Adobe Reader. Java just doesn't work no matter how many times I reinstall it
>>
>>52141364
Losing.
>>
>>52139464
The games go long enough for you to activate that?
>>
>>52141364
Riding the Dilu Horse.
>>
>>52141501
>playing games that don't last over 2 hours
>>
>>52141501
Usually not, but when it happens it's fun.
I run it in my heavy manaramp and rock decks, and as a bad wincon for infinite mana for comboing off.
>>
So I'm brewing a Kami of the Crescent Moon deck and I need suggestions for some tech to use. Will most likely be just group hug with my win con being everyone drawing a shitton of cards and then being forced to discard them.
>>
>>52141632
Forced Fruition
Arcane Laboratory
Ward of Bone
Sunder
Coastal Breach
Cyclonic Rift
Devastation Tide
Hurkyl's Recall
Jin-Gitaxias
Rebuild
Reduce to Dreams
>>
>>52141632
Forced Fruition makes an opponent draw 7 cards whenever they cast a spell. You can put it together with Dream Halls to have people draw obscene amounts of cards, discard a couple, and then draw even more. Then shit like Windfall gets rid of them, or Jin-Gitaxias does at the end of their turn.
>>
>>52141632
>>52141816
Also run an Elixir of Immortality for yourself and some decent no hand cap tech like Reliquary Tower
>>
>>52141632
>>52141816
>>52141840
The best part of the Dream Halls + Forced Fruition combo is it only gets better the stronger your meta is - I've seen folks nearly deck themselves getting into counter wars with the Halls on the field. It's ridiculous how short-sighted they are.
>>
>>52141856
If you don't play with shortsighted people, they'll draw until they figure out how to end fruition or else just combo out. That's why I prefer lab so you get a zillion cards but can't use them
>>
File: Saffi_Eriksdotter.jpg (73KB, 640x456px) Image search: [Google]
Saffi_Eriksdotter.jpg
73KB, 640x456px
>>52140781
Just updated it for you.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/saffi-combodotter-3/
>>
Does red have any good single-target creature removal that is efficient? Obviously bolt exists, chaos warp exists.
>>
>>52141947
Why though?

I mean, other than that there are always limits. Pretty much all burn will have some relevant targets it won't hit, and most larger burn spells are hillariously inefficent. If you're making a million mana X burn like Burn from Within can do it but then you wouldn't care about efficiency. Shivan Meteor is a thing but you're paying either 5 or 3 and 2 turns for that Murder so is it really worth it?
>>
>>52141039
Source on the picture?
>>
>>52141632
This is a stax list but there's probably some spicy stuff in there for you.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/kami-of-the-crescent-moon-staxstasis-edh/
>>
>>52139464
Rules question, wouldn't casting Decimator of the Provinces with this put all eldrazi spells on the stack with its ability, then all the cast triggers on top of that, meaning that all cast triggers would resolve before any of the creatures enter?
>>
>>52141881
Well yes, the arcane lab + forbid route is a nasty one no matter what else is on the field. I would assume anon has more than just Forced Fruition and Dream Halls on the field at a given time, due to the combination potentially leaving the Kami player VERY vulnerable to getting slam-dunked.
>>
Which colors are best for spicy elfball? GW? BG? MonoG?
>>
>>52142155
Monogreen Ezuri Elfball can be fantastic
>>
>>52142069
I believe so but pre-existing creatures will still benefit from the overrun.
>>
>>52141856
Isn't forced fruition a little expensive though? I also hate the idea of hrlping your opponents draw into answers.
>>
>>52141947
Chain Reaction, Blasphemous Act

lesser tier: Aftershock, Fissure
>>
>>52142287
You can use Forced Fruition if you've got a stax lock going on to pretty good effect. They can only cast one or two spells each turn, but they draw way too much and can't use everything.
>>
>>52141897
saffi has quite an ass
>>
File: 1476137362561.jpg (44KB, 251x231px) Image search: [Google]
1476137362561.jpg
44KB, 251x231px
>>52141524
When the people you play with have to keep taking 15 minute smoke breaks.
>>
>>52141364
grafted wargear
>>
>>52142531
Just take up smoking, dummy.

Ok /tg/ my friend just barely got back into magic, and wants help building a deck. He's got his heart set on Tokens and I told him Selesnya would be his best option, however he doesn't like GW so what would be other good token centric commanders?
>>
File: counterspells.png (12KB, 636x125px) Image search: [Google]
counterspells.png
12KB, 636x125px
>>52142531
>Not smoking with them
>acting like some body-conscience faggot who's excuse is "it's bad for you."
>eats like shit
>doesn't exercise
>has sedentary hobbies like mtg and watching anime
The reason you don't like this is because it interrupts your escapist fantasy game and you're too much of a sperg to step out with them and smoke and talk like a reasonable person, or even just step out and talk. You don't have to smoke. But that would just be too difficult.

>>52142653
>not encouraging your friend to make izzet/dimir/esper/grixis/Breya thopter tribal.
His can you even call yourself his friend?
>>
File: szadek.jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
szadek.jpg
32KB, 223x310px
Never played a mill deck before, but I have really been wanting to try it. Apparently my Nath of the Gilt-Leaf deck was too fucking annoying for people to stomach, so I have decided to go for a slow-burning deck. Anyone got any advice for how to build a mass-mill?
>>
File: 56.jpg (58KB, 336x469px) Image search: [Google]
56.jpg
58KB, 336x469px
>>52142775

Add a reanimation subtheme and/or ways to take advantage of your opponents' graveyards.

I also would put szadek in the 99, I feel like he's a little bit too slow and would have to pump himself again every time it gets destroyed. I like Lazav a lot for a mill commander but there are some options, just look into UB legends
>>
>>52142775
Don't

If you have to, you can play Lazav or Wrexial and use mill as a way to fuel your commander.

Oona, if you want to do infinite combos.

Best however for pure mill is Phenax, using mortivore-type cards. Szadek also works great in Phenax.
>>
>>52136478
Hurkyls recall, stony silence, null rod and pithing needle would help with breya; prossh, just kill the food chain and stop attempts to get it back; purphuros hurts but you're playing black in both decks and one is orzhov! Drop soul sisters, zola port cutthroat, suture priest, blood artist etc and purph's token etb's or ltb's will do hurt, do nothing, or help depending on if you have 1,2, or 3.
Those aren't even too vicious as decks go. Focus all counters and spot cc on prossh, his combo is much more two cards than breya, with breya watch his sequencing of actions and attack at the right time or when he messes up. Always insist anyone plays out the combo they can mess it up and that's when you punish them. You can even take advantage of the combos to let them kill each other first and then stop the combo (easier with prossh, breya is critical mass, if he isn't dropping redundant pieces with extra mana then that's a weak point to attack). If someone insists on playing combo than insist they play the combo.

I agree with >>52136344, the best route is meta level communication, but understand that by changing your expectations you can still enjoy the game just as much. Edh is 3 different games imo (maybe 4) fun beer league for laughs, cutthroat politics at 75% (where it seems like you are), and singleton vintage. I personally play and enjoy all three of these styles but if you are expecting the first one and getting the second one then I definitely understand how that would be frustrating. So talk to your group about each other's expectations for the game and play/build accordingly.
>>
>>52142709
Calm down there Freud
>>
>>52135504
It is a function of the game rules that you can concede at any time. There was a half joking friendly reminder that this is true a few threads ago. Magic is a game of strategy. Your strategy needs to include the fact that a player can take that action to thwart you. If your plan hinges on a kill happening with the a certain creature on the victims board and they respond with a kill spell at instant speed to kill the creature that's just good strategy. If your game plan doesn't extend beyond "kill this person" then you're not playing like you understand the game you're trying to play. If a consequence of killing a player is that it leaves your defenses open for another player to alpha strike you then you need a new plan. If your path to victory can be stopped by some last second kingmaking then you need a more robust plan. Basically, play magic as it is, understanding what it is, and don't force your ideas of what it should be on it, that's the path to being a salty crybaby who's just a bad spike.
>>
>>52137975
Thoughtseize, mental misstep, and their 1 for 1 ilk are excellent at high power level play, otherwise don't offer enough utility for the slot.
>>
>>52141039
Paper is my preferred, but most of the deck lists I try are built and tested on xmage, Forge, and tappedout first.
>>
>>52142155
Nath elf ball with discard synergy is my go to.
>>
>>52141039
MODO

someone play with me ;_;
>>
>>52142034
Now I feel like rebuilding my Kami Stax with all the cool new cards I got for my blue pool.
>>
>>52143790
Oh, what's up anon, anything cool you have differently in your list?
>>
>>52143441
Did I disturb a delicate area of your spergitude?

New thread when.
>>
>>52142775
If you're gonna do Szadek, then every other card in your deck should be control and ramp to get him on the field and keep him there, whilst giving the middle finger to your opponents. Giving him Trample is fun too, Haunted Cloak and Sword of Vengeance are both good idea's.
>>
>>52143819
My original list was too grouphug focused. I'd watch others draw a bunch of cards and win. I built it because I wanted a deck that wasn't so focused on controlling the game, but now my only option is slowing the game to a crawl.
I might be inspired because 3 decks that I've been slowly building have stax elements.

I'm going to post my prototype list in a moment, I have to type it all down.
>>
>>52143871
>Analyzes the personality of a complete stranger with almost no information
No, you're just retarded. I'm not that guy but even I can see how cringy you are.

Also, we're on page 2, calm down.
>>
>>52134225
Do you have a TO link for Overlord?
>>
>>52144121
Here you go.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/super-sexy-slivers/
>>
>>52143819
I came up with this: http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/kami-kami/
There's less creature hate because there aren't many creature-based decks at my LGS.
>>
>>52137721
But anon, interaction is unfun
>>
>>52138149
>Not naming your elf deck Dirty Hippies on Parade
>Not naming your Fumiko deck Pure Japanese Waifu
>Not naming your Tasigur deck Thai Ladyboy

Look at this fucking scrub
>>
How do I build discard? I have things like necrogen mists, creeping dread, hymn to touarch, and sire of insanity, what's the best way to build a deck like this? My gut says Grixis for some dirty red recursion and blue card draw but I feel like I'm in over my head.
>>
>>52144847
Nath.
>>
>>52136421
Brad?!
>>
>>52144847
Nath or Leovold Maximum Bullying
>>
>>52145141
Janet!
>>
>>52136705
If my opponent massacre wurms my board after I've rebuilt for the 6th time that game but it doesn't kill me, can I concede after he gets his blood artist triggers? Because the game had gone on for three hours longer than it should have due to the pillowfort convincing the retard I was the archenemy instead of him and I legitimately didn't care anymore
>>
>>52144296
>dat name

Have a +1 on your deck.
>>
File: card he picked up.png (4MB, 2867x1620px) Image search: [Google]
card he picked up.png
4MB, 2867x1620px
What are some commanders to build fun/chaos decks around? My playgroup has been complaining about being a bit too competitive and I want a deck I can just have fun without necessarily being worried about winning.

I'd prefer something that includes red and/or blue, as I'm on a bit of a budget but have decks built on those colors already.
>>
>>52145169
Doctor Scott!
>>
New thread when.
>>
>>52145473
Whenever you feel like making it, friend :^)
>>
>>52145473
Pls stop doing this.
>>
>>52144847
>red
>capable of recursion
>>
>>52145375
Zedruu, norin, jhoira are all popular picks for chaos.
>>
>>52145607
Feldon, shreds of sanity, charmbreaker devil.
>>
New thread
>>52146012
>>52146012
>>52146012
>>
>>52146027
>>52146027
new thread
>>
>>52139151
Go through every card in your deck and imagine you're trying to walk someone else that's really good at magic through your reasoning for putting it in your deck. I like to go through these points:

1) Why it works with your deck
2) Why it's better than your other cards/why it's better in certain situations
3) Why you don't have enough of it's effect in your deck
>>
>>52142653
R/G or Jund might work well. Something like Prosh or that new partner commander that makes saproling tokens. You could partner her with vial smasher for just straight up Jund goodness.

You could also do Talrand, that way you just make tokens with evasion while just playing a goodstuff blue deck.
Thread posts: 327
Thread images: 86


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.