/mu/'s favorite artist's albums critque

File: templatemu.jpg (119KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 1493x936px

>>62049175

eat my fucking cock you worthless sack of nigger shit

>>62049175
This is a horrible idea for a chart and you should feel bad

File: 1453862640043.jpg (286KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

286KB, 1493x936px

>>62049175

>>62049246
how fucking new are you?

this has been posted at least twice a year for the last 5 years faggot

File: swanschart.jpg (230KB, 1493x898px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 1493x898px

>>62049175

File: corrected.jpg (223KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 1493x936px

fixed op's post

>>62049392
laughed out loud

File: 1453862640043.jpg (342KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

342KB, 1493x936px

interesting thread

>>62049709
>centipede hz not under best

>>62049709
This all the way but I actually like Danse Manatee

File: iceage.jpg (19KB, 445x313px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 445x313px

>>62049709
>mpp not in overrated
>instead Feels

>>62050171
I mean imo, it's not bad, im starting to warm up to it but where would you put it?

File: pf_chart.jpg (543KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

543KB, 1493x936px

>>62049175

>>62050456
>Best
Piper, Meddle, Uma, Animals
>Overrated
The Wall, WYWH
>Underrated
Saucer
>Define Their Sound
DSOTM
>Tried
everything else

File: elliott smith rank.png (417KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

417KB, 1493x936px

Most overrated is relative, because it's still a great album.

Also not counting the postmortem releases

>>62050456
good, just put animals into overrated

File: Blaze is king.png (1MB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1493x936px

Blaze Bailey saved Iron Maiden

>>62050628
you're right about roman candle

>>62049709
holy shit this. i've never found anyone else that thinks feels is overrated and MPP is one of the best.

File: zzzzzzz.jpg (300KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

300KB, 1493x936px

hmm that was easy

File: Untitled.png (12KB, 203x42px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 203x42px

>>62049261

File: 1393457977094.png (471KB, 1493x898px) Image search: [Google]

471KB, 1493x898px

>>62049175
You were close

>>62051611
fuck i forgot to crop

>>62049709
I agree with this.

>>62049338
all true

>>62049974
>best
>reedemer
>angel
is it bait?

>>62050938
baazbaaz?

>>62049175
i really dislike this chart desu

>>62051228
>not liking nashville skyline
that's not dylan and the dead.

Nashville Skyline is one of his best.

File: 1453862640043.jpg (120KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 1493x936px

genesis

>>62049175
>the bends defines their sound

Excuse me? what radiohead have you been listening to?

>>62049175
What if the artist didn't try at all?

>>62052217
>>62051389
>>62049338
praise

>>62049175

It doesn't, Amnesiac does. That's where they struck their specific blend of electronic and rock elements. The albums leading up to it worked toward that point and the albums after have stuck to and refined it ever since.

>>62050628
Right about XO and Roman Candle, I'd switch s/t and Either/Or though, and you forgot Figure 8, though it might fit in any of those categories, since it's not bad but it's not any of the other categories either

File: Untitled.png (1MB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1493x936px

This is up 'til 1980. Finally going through the post-'80 morass now.

>>62052217
Not exactly how I'd categorize 'em, but close enough that I can dig it.

Really, any chart that has TMS as "most overrated" I can dig.

thanks for that inb4 I thought I was going to have to write this out instead of just copy-pasting

"The Bends doesn't define RH's sound"

what the fucking fuck is wrong with you dude

>>62052991
this is wrong

>>62051389
this. this is the right chart.
except I'd say OK Computer is also one of their best albums.

>>62053079
Lowfag detected

>>62050938
how is piece of mind overrated

File: 1453600889102.gif (785KB, 269x199px) Image search: [Google]

785KB, 269x199px

>>62052165

>implying they tired

File: 1430567327443.jpg (34KB, 306x354px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 306x354px

>>62052217

Nailed it

>>62052336
i don't think that KC has a "most overrated" album. Red should be in best tbqh

>>62052991
How is Lodger overrated?

File: 1453862640043.jpg (154KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

154KB, 1493x936px

>>62052217
you now guys this is only my opinion, right?

File: 1429152918244.jpg (177KB, 852x581px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 852x581px

>>62054029

Completely agree, although I think sound defining album would go to TMS or TPTB

File: nin mu album categorization.jpg (184KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 1493x936px

>>62049175
tbqh familia

>>62054005

Seriously, Lodger is hardly mentioned compared to the other two thirds of the Berlin trilogy, let alone when you add in his other 70s work. Lodger should be filed under 'underrated' or be off the chart altogether.

File: rararar.png (170KB, 1493x1812px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 1493x1812px

At least I tried

>>62051389
This is the right one

>>62050456
>dark side of the moon not overrated

>>62050456
>The Final Cut at least they tried

you just don't know

>>62052394
More like

>Yeezus; MBDTF; 808
>MBDTF
>808; LR
>CD
>Graduation

If Graduation is anywhere else, you have shit taste

>>62054209
>no TRON: Legacy Soundtrack
>no Alive 2007
Tron belongs in at least they tried
Alive belongs in underrated

File: Manchester Orchestra.png (579KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

579KB, 1493x936px

>>62049338
All good.

>>62050456
>Animals in Best
Er...
>Meddle in Underrated
>Dark Side not in Overrated
Okay yeah, I'll agree with that. But also, what >>62054221 said.

>>62052336
>In the Wake of Poseidon
>Underrated
Yup.

>>62054209
>Robot Rock
>Underrated
Mm-hm.

>>62049749
Are you fucking shitting me

>>62053075
Spot fucking on

>>62052219
Slip It In has both the best and worst tracks Black Flag has ever done. (unless you count what the. what the has all the worst tracks ever)

>>62049175
awful tier
>>62049261
dank
>>62049338
too accurate to be true
>>62049392
memay
>>62050456
>the wall
>"best"
>atom heart mother
>ummagumma
>"at least they tried"
Awful taste
>>62051389
not as bad as OPs but still very off
>>62051611
All of it should be under "At least they tried"
>>62052217
nldw isn't their best but other than that this is fairly accurate
>>62052336
>red
>overrated
>ITWOP
>underrated
Shit taste

>>62051389
yuupp

>>62051228
>Best
>not the Times they are a changing
At least you tried

>>62050456
>AHM
>"At least they tried"
kill yourself philistine cunt

>>62050456
I'm the asshole who made this chart

I was so wrong about the Final Cut.

>>62052991
>Lodger
>Space Oddity
>overrated
Well, I expect as much stupidity from someone who puts Heroes above Low

File: most-underrated nmh.png (390KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

390KB, 1493x936px

Ferris Wheel on Fire is their best and most concise album, Avery Island is pretty damn good too but isn't as cohesive as ITAOTS and has some weaker songs too.

>>62055358

>actually listening to NMH

holy shit fucking kill urself

>>62049175
the most I've agreed with someone on this sub. I'd put HTTT somewhere higher if I could.

>>62049392
ITT:
>wuts a redyehed?

File: KC.png (519KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

519KB, 1493x936px

>>62052336
You and I obviously disagree. This is okay.

I also found out today I don't like my favorite band nearly as much as I thought. They don't do enough Lizard.

>>62049261
I swear, everyone who heard Frontier Psychiatrist and wanted to check them out to hear more like that and were just like wtf is this shit

>>62054335
Came here to make a NIN chart. How is Year Zero overrated? Nobody likes it, and rightfully.

>>62055659
Frontier Psychiatrist isn't even their best song

>>62055582
That's a good thing, Lizard was awful

>>62055728
>I don't like it
>Therefore nobody likes it

>>62051389
you're right

>>62055812
It's their only 'song' as far as I'm aware

>>62054070
Same only switch The Slip with With Teeth

File: coldplayalbums.jpg (215KB, 1493x1024px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 1493x1024px

I wish there was a "just okay" category for Mylo Xyloto but whatever

>>62055695
This list sucks and you didn't include Saturday Night Wrist, Adrenaline or Koi No Yokan

>>62055947
made it in like two seconds and got super lazy because I was busy listening to Diamond Eyes and reading news.

>>62052165
>Hurley
>Not one of their better 21st century albums

>>62055985
Conspiracy of One is all we listened to at about age 12. I still have the tape somewhere.

>>62056024
I put CoO and RaF,RaG on the "At Lease You Tried" category but I think they both still have some good tracks, just the lowest ratio of good to bad.

>>62055985
Smash and America define their sound.

Smash is not overrated btw, it's seriously good.

on mobile but:

Animal Collective:

BEST - Strawberry Jam, Merriweather Post Pavilion, Here Comes The Indian, Feels

Overrated - Spirit

Underrated - Indian

Defining Album - Feels

They Tried - Danse, CHz

>>62056047
I think IotH and DGB define their sound because it represents them at their best ("All I Want", "Gone Away", "Amazed", "Change the World" for Ixnay and "The Future Is Now", "Secrets from the Underground", and "Slim Pickens" for DGB) and their worst ("Don't Pick It Up" for Ixnay, "Cruising California" for DGB).
And I dunno, Smash never really appealed to me as much as it does to other people.

>>62056100
Americana has the songs they are most known for. Smash also has some very famous songs like Self Esteem and Come Out and Play and generally considered their best. I think more people would think of the Offspring for those two albums more than any others.

>>62056149
All of them should be under "at least they tried"

>>62056152
catching a fish with a gumboot is better b8 than this

>>62052109
nashville skyline's garbage bro

>>62056149
ittod is better than presence imo

celebration day ain't that bad either, Kashmir is amazing.

File: beatlesrating.png (655KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

655KB, 1493x936px

shaking my head to be honest family

>>62058153
Best:
MMT, Sgt Peppers & White Album

>>62049338
Swap Love of Life with Greed and you're 100% correct.

>>62056290
completely disagree

>>62051389
fuck you in rainbows is awesome

but i wholeheartedly agree with the rest of your chart anon

File: 1453678698563.jpg (28KB, 500x380px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 500x380px

>>62052394
>yeezus is simultaneously the best, worst, most underrated and overrated ye album

sounds about right desu

>>62053075
>Best
Hypnotize
>Most Overrated
Toxicity
>Most Underrated
Mezmerize
>Album That Defines Their Sound
Toxicity, Steal This Album!

>>62058153
>their sound
>help!
what? don't u mean n/a? also rubber soul is not overrated but you're right about mmt by far the most underrated

>>62052394
What the fuck

>>62052217
I don't think any album really defines their sound.

>>62059538
close. madvillain should be in defining sound though

also born like this is overrated not underrated

>>62056435
completley agree

>>62059600
you're right. most people just hear "that's that" and "gazillion ear" and thing "FUCKING MASTERPIECE" (no diss on those songs at all)

i still stand that madvillainy is his best album, not his defining sound. DOOMSDAY defined it, madvillainy perfected it and added more flavor.

>>62049709
this is pleb as fuck. but at least you've acknowledged hollinndagain and campfire songs

>>62051389
why does everyone keep putting OKC as sound-defining, literally no album after it sounds anything like it

>>62058153
>BEST
Sgt. Pepper
>OVERRATED
Abbey Road
>UNDERRATED
Magical Mystery Tour
>DEFINING ALBUM
Revolver
>AT LEAST THEY TRIED
Let it Be

>>62055985
>Americana
>even remotely good
The album is garbage
Ixnay is actually their best album desu

>>62058536
>BEST
THE SUBURBS
>OVERRATED
REFLEKTOR
>UNDERRATED
NEON BIBLE
>ALBUM THAT DEFINES THEIR SOUND
FUNERAL
>ATLEAST THEY TRIED
n/a

File: bjkjhghjk.png (526KB, 1540x960px) Image search: [Google]

526KB, 1540x960px

soof

>>62049261
Can't argue.

>>62049392
If you don't like Radiohead why even try. They put out consistently great material.

>>62050456
Animals is the best PF album by far

>>62050628
Agree

>>62051389
️OKC defines their sound in the 90s and maybe a little bit of Kid A.
I think In Rainbows probably defines their sound the best.

>>62052217
Agree

>>62050456
>the wall on best
>momentary lapse of reason and endless river on overrated
>underrated:division bell
>At least they tried; Atom Heart Mother, Ummagumma, Final cut

Just please, please, leave and never come back

>>62053130

"How could I possibly disagree with this obvious bait"

>>62052394
BEST: yeezus, 808s, mbdtf, lr
OVERRATED: college drop out
UNDERRATED: 808s lr
DEFINES SOUND: MBDTF
ATLEAST THEY TRIED: LOL? WTT

>>62049709
Surprisingly accurate

CHz and Danse still good though

>>62055381
wut do u listen to anon?

>>62056258
where do u get these album covers anon?

>>62060405
finally another age of adz lover, Illinoise and Carrie & Lowell are good but truly are overrated

File: 1453862640043.jpg (173KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 1493x936px

>>62050938
literally hang yourself

File: chart01.jpg (408KB, 1492x928px) Image search: [Google]

408KB, 1492x928px

>>62050456
More like

File: burzum.png (637KB, 1493x901px) Image search: [Google]

637KB, 1493x901px

am I me?

>>62061377
THIS

File: 145391618919393.jpg (115KB, 1006x631px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 1006x631px

>>62055540
Unforgettable Fire is God-Tier

>>62060299
Switch TMS and NLDW and you got it

>>62055934

To me it's like

>best: parachutes, viva la vida
>album that defines their sound: a rush of blood
>atleast they tried: ALL OF THE REST

>>62061312
Close, I'd only switch Meddle with Animals

>>62060527
>1017 Thug not underrated

>>62061377
agreed desu

>>62055934
>Liking Coldplay
Kill youareself senpai

>>62049338
>>62049709
>>62051389
>>62052217
all objectively 100% correct

>>62056290
>all lights fucked
>they tried tier
kek

>>62051389
pretty spot on. Although I like the Bends

>>62061377
is fallen overrated tho?
also belus is pretty underrated i'd say

>>62052165
wrong! Pinkerton is best. Raditude would go in the "at least they tried" section

>>62058153
let it be is pretty good desu senmpei

>>62051611
Von is fucking amazing you pleb. AB is their best album.

>>62060405
how the fuck is SS overrated, I'd call it his most underrated, alongside EYR

>>62052217
How would their newest album define their sound you ding dong?

>>62049338
agreed, except switch the seer with tbk

>>62052217
government plates was their magnum opus desu

File: viper kill urself my man.jpg (14KB, 315x316px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 315x316px

>>62058832
>Adore under at least they tried

File: images.jpg (14KB, 358x310px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 358x310px

>>62049392

>>62066383
Actually pretty accurate. Discovery is amazing, Homework aged badly save a few tracks, RAM was hyped a lot but not a bad album.
Alive 2007 is a banger.

>>62049175
The funny thing is without Pablo Honey, I doubt Radiohead would of had the funds/critical claim or equipment to make any of the later albums.

>>62054029
NotM is great, what are you on about. Better than GP.

>>62050628
Swap s/t and Either Or.

At least they tried = Figure 8

>>62056290
nooooooo

>>62049338
fuckin perfect
>>62049709
pretty fuckin great
(i would switch strawberry jam and sung tongs
then switch MPP and feels)
>>62049749
i've grown tired of this meme
>>62050456
this is embarrassing
>>62052165
>>implying they tried
fuckin LOL
>>62052217
i'd split up TPTB, notm in best and JD in atleast they tried. and exm defines their sound best imho
fashion week is underrated tho
>>62052219
this is good
>>62052336
discipline is overrated as fuck and itcock best defines their sound

>>62061659
kek. Should've put st anger in the underrated

>>62050456
mostly wrong

The Piper At the Gates of Dawn: 9/10
A Saucerful of Secrets - 8/10
More: 5/10
Ummagumma - 9.5/10
Atom Heart Mother - 7/10
Meddle: 6.5/10
Obscured By Clouds: 5/10
The Dark Side of the Moon: 6/10
Wish You Were Here: 7/10
Animals: 6/10
The Wall: 4.5/10
The Final Cut: 4/10
A Momentary Lapse of Reason: 3/10
The Division Bell: 4/10
The Endless River: 2/10

File: 1437127846408.jpg (194KB, 1493x936px) Image search: [Google]

194KB, 1493x936px

ok

File: 1452754675295.jpg (118KB, 371x371px) Image search: [Google]

118KB, 371x371px

>>62052991
>Heroes above Low
you really wanna fucken go there

>>62070035
'you tried'

Filth: 8/10
Cop: 7/10
Greed: 7/10
Holy Money: 7/10
Children of God: 8/10
The Burning World: 6/10
White Light From the Mouth of Infinity: 8/10
Love of Life: 6/10
The Great Annihilator: 6/10
Soundtracks For the Blind: 9/10
My Father Will Guide Me Up a Rope to the Sky: 5/10
The Seer: 6.5/10
To Be Kind: 6/10

>>62070187
Go away scaruffi

>>62054335
I liked Hesitation Marks desu

>>62070202
nonsense. Swans are a great band and I enjoy all of their albums except for their first reunion album.

>>62067067
Jenny Death literally incorporates elements from all of their previous releases and even has the fucking "It's death" motif that had been missing from their previous two albums

>>62070581
perfect. I would not change a thing, anon. and kek at the least one.

>>62049392
thank you.

>>62049709

someone understands me

>>62052217
this is backwards af

>>62056435
lel

>>62058536
latest album is an at least they tried

>>62061258
heh

>>62062419
you are under the age of 20

>>62066350
;D

>>62068753
yummi

>>62063227
this is accurate

File: 1449428379306.jpg (9KB, 256x197px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 256x197px

>>62062419

>>62052336
Full pleb.

>>62052165
BEST: Pinkerton
MOST OVERRATED: Green
MOST UNDERRATED: Red
ALBUM THAT DEFINES THEIR SOUND: Blue
AT LEAST THEY TRIED: Maladroit, Everything Will Be Alright, White(?)
GARBAGE: Everything else

>>62051228
>Best not blonde on blonde

stop

>>62070760
I'm over the age of twenty. I am 57 years old.
>>62071185
No, you are the pleb. My ratings are objective.

>>62070035
i really don;t think sftb defines swans' sound in any way, it's their most varied album, yes, but it also is their most unique album, some of the sounds there appear nowhere in swans' career.

File: woo hoo.gif (862KB, 495x371px) Image search: [Google]

862KB, 495x371px

some1 do joanna newsom i don't have photoshop

>>62072196
u don't need photoshop you just need paint

File: 1450490850421.jpg (40KB, 332x396px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 332x396px

>>62071482
>I am 57 years old.
>No, you are the pleb. My ratings are objective.

>>62073605
literally
what
h
a
t

>>62052217
Switch TPTB and NLDW and I agree completely