What does /mu/ think of Alkaline Trio?

>>61673015
Actually really like a lot of their stuff

>>61673015
I love them, one of my favourites.

>>61673015
They've been my favorite band since I was for 8 years.

>>61673015

Absolute shite

>>61673015
Goddamnit is their only good one

>>61673776
this
i saw them at slims in SF one of the funnest shows ive been to

>>61673776
Really? Because Good Mourning and Crimson are my favorites by them.

>>61673943
Thank you! Crimson is so fucking sick, I don't know why everyone overlooks it.

>>61673977
Crimson > Good Mourning > Agony and Irony > Goddammit > From Here To Infirmary > Maybe I'll Catch Fire > This Addiction >>>> My Shame Is True

Admittedly My Shame Is True was pretty bad

>>61674120
Shame grew on me desu

Crimson > Agony and Irony = Infirmary > Good Mourning = Shame > Catch Fire > Goddamnit

>>61674247
Crimson > Agony and Irony = Infirmary > Good Mourning = Shame > Catch Fire > Goddamnit >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> This Addiction

Forgot their one utterly shite album

File: 058-alkaline-trio_original[1].jpg (48KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 500x500px

>>61673776
Their self-titled is really good as well. My two favorites by them.

why do alkaline trio fans always where black socks pulled up high?

>>61674273
This Addiction wasn't bad, just kinda generic.

The chorus's weren't catchy in the slightest, it lacked the emotional impact the other albums had. Just all around ok but boring.

>>61674273
>>61674247
>>61674120
No one likes crimson that much.

I FOUND AWAYYY

>>61674805
That's kinda how I would describe Shame's initial impact on me. Shame's saving grace was Dan, though. But on This Addiction, both Dan and Skiba were trash.

>>61674902
I do.

>>61674967
same desu senpai

Goddamnit= s/t >Good Mourning>Maybe I'll Catch Fire>From Here To Infirmary>>Crimson>This Addiction>Agony & Irony>My Shame Is True

>>61674953
I actually just started re-listening to My Shame Is True, it's a lot better than I remember

>>61675041
>Crimson and Agony & Irony that low

I will cut you

>>61675110
Only Love, Young Lovers, I Pessimist, I wanna be a Warhol are all some really dope songs

>>61675041
This

>>61675154
>The best thing Tim Mcilrath has ever been a part of wasn't even in his band

>>61675110
I could understand people liking Crimson, but why stick up for Agony & Irony?

>>61675442
Because it was pretty much a slightly worse Crimson

>>61675216
>implying sufferer isn't the best melohxc album ever

Reminds me of the type of people I hated in high school.

>>61675442
Idk about him, but I liked it for what it was: naked unashamed pop punk. No edge, just hooks. And it was damn good at that.

This Addiction, on the other hand, was bland uninspired, and worst of all uncatchy pop punk which is why I hated it so much.

>>61675501
I miss the 9th grade anon ;_;

>>61673015
I own their entire discography and even after probably 10+ years of listening to them they are still one of my favorites.

Matt Skiba is a literal god

>>61675621
hey look guys this dude is so cool wow check out how cool he is damn i wish i knew his secret

>>61675799
I was being genuine anon, Rise Against was my shit back in highschool.

>>61675769
I wish he still wrote like he did on that split with Kevin Seconds.

>>61675824
Same, but I mean unlike most 9th grade music Sufferer and Siren Song still hold up.

Sucks that they're now basically Foo Fighters level buttrock, but their old shit is still great

>>61675996
Appeal To Reason was always my favorite growing up desu.

>>61676084
ATR is where the decline started but it's still listenable.

REMEMBER WHEN I SAID