Most of those arguments are fairly shallow and just complaining about a lack of fights, that Okada (and some other dude I don't know) operate a certain way and that the show doesn't look good. If you want to make an argument about why it's awful you should probably start by addressing what's bad about the plot and characters. As is, it just feels like you grabbed a handful of troll posts and called it a day.
There's a couple of pictures of complaints about SEED that get bandied about fairly often during discussion of it and they're memorable because they do that instead.
I don't think IBO would qualify as the worst entry in the franchise. While it's very lackluster, it flows nicely and is competent. True, I get more enjoyment out of AGE but that's because AGE is poorly executed and stupid. It's great riffing material.
IBO isn't offensive, it's just underwhelming and bland, always taking the easy approach to telling it's story. It's like a modern-day SEED, only weaker. It's a decent 6.5/10 in my book to SEED's 7.
>>13815229 My gripe with the show how it hammers down suffering of the downtrodden and implication of upper echelon of society than actually revolving the plot around it. Which creates poor characteriztion and writing decisions for Kudelia.
Mika has come off as know all smug ass who had no conflict or problem of his own what-so-ever as he can use a 300 year old neutral interface without much health hazards as of ep 16. Whatever buildup for drama regarding his relation with Orga or problems faced while piloting Barbatos has taken backseat for a long time,which for a 25 ep anime is really bad.
To sum up, after lampshading about so many things at the beginning, little has came to fruition. Instead plot points like " I suddenly remember I had a brother to whom I have no contact for many years and then he suddenly appears" , it's pretty much evident that show is attempting to mix family matters along with a unjust world poverty and exploitation, and fails because the whole execution dosen't comes smoothly but rather very jarring or feels very separate thing happening just for sake of drama or shock factor. Which also explains problems with Kudelia's portrayal. And they are going to do the same with Fareed and his Father's relation in Gayhorn .
>>13815229 >Remaining in such a state of denial >Despite the show actually coming overseas and getting dubbed >Despite rumors of a second season >Despite widespread popularity in Japan Nah, you're right, it's everybody else that's wrong. You're the smart one.
>>13816196 >Despite the show actually coming overseas and getting dubbed They announced that after the first month. They weren't counting on it's present state >Despite rumors of a second season No confirmation/ >Despite widespread popularity in Japan Lower ratings than AGE, fans saying Nagai and Okada should apologize, 2ch saying model sales have dropped.
>>13815261 >Most of those arguments are fairly shallow and just complaining about a lack of fights,
They're largely taken out of context. Most the people bringing up the lack of fighting are responding to people saying they're only watching it for the giant robots because the drama and character development are shit. It's mainly just pointing out there's hardly any of that to be looking forward to on top of all the other issues going on with the show.
>>13816879 >IBO is widely liked, both in Japan No it isn't. Viewing numbers are some of the lowest ever, the BDs are selling like shit especially the second vol., and the gunpla sales are plummeting because there's absolutely no variety. It's not well liked at all. I know you were falseflagging, but still
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org with the post's information.