They're the most competent fighting force of the past 100 years. Most military fags probably have some sort of hard on for the Wehrmacht. Marines are retards so they probably think of themselves as the Waffen-SS.
German war strategy and tactics was highly effective in World War 2. To knock a major European nation out of a fight in 3 weeks was unheard of, seeing as France endured all of World War 1 only to fold like paper under the Nazis, it was a rush to see who could emulate it first, or counter the blitzkrieg the quickest.
Germany developed the tactics for a "perfect war", but didn't have the manpower and resources to achieve that perfect victory against the titanic Soviet Union.
The United States however, does. and takes from the German warbook and gives it everything it lacked in terms of resources, speed of transporting resources, and effective frontline firepower and air superiority.
the most stark example of US blitzkrieg practice was the 2 Gulf Wars so far, capturing Iraq in under 3 weeks without losing so much as 800 men. So yes, infatuation with German military tactics is present because it fucking works, and works especially well when you have more military resources than the next 20 nations in the world combined.
>>623394 >What wasn't already in their manuals, they got it from the Germans >>623423 >They're the most competent fighting force of the past 100 years >>623593 >Nazis were cool as fuck >>623687 >Best discipline and morale
Speaking as someone in the American military, I have to express my doubts as to this supposed infatuation with WWII Germany present within our ranks. Most discussion among the enlisted vis-a-vis this topic boils down to "we kicked their asses, hurr hurr."
There is, however, a bit of doctrinal favoritism concerning the Germans. A lot of the American playbook borrows from their concepts of bewegungskrieg and auftragstaktik. In recent years especially, there has been an emphasis placed on the latter, with the goal of fostering creative and flexible thought at all levels of the chain of command from grunts on up. It's probably all moot, since American adherence to doctrine has always remained elusive, but nonetheless, the American military has had and continues to hold a particular reverence toward the German method.
Oh, and also, that whole thing with that SS flag came about simply because Marines are dumb.
I've always heard that there was a time, when limited in size by the Versailles Treaty, that the German military had extremely strict entrance criteria. This small selection was extraordinarily well trained and groomed for advancement, so that when the war began Germany had an elite core of young officers and noncoms who were responsible for its early success and reputation. They couldn't be replaced, however, and as attrition ate away at the German ranks in the East so went German's military exceptionalism.
>>624107 Nah that's just some folk lore shit. Weimar era German army was shit tier underfunded and neglected, Hitler built it up almost from the time he came into power until 39. Actually those troops didn't even perform exceptionally well, they just took the enemy by complete surprise,... German troops were better later on in the war since they had gained experience. The troops in 1939 were green recruits for the most part. The men in 1942-43 ost front were hardened veterans
>>624151 No it was just phased out after the war in Germany as part of denazification because it was too reminiscent of Nazism according to American authorities, though some east european armies still do it, such as Poland
>>623386 >>623746 >>623891 >>624012 >>624114 >>623867 Alright, Bitches. Vetfag here to lay some deep knowledge on you. The Marine Scout Snipers use the SS runes because Scout Snipers are one of the ideals that the grunts of that other branch aspire to and Marines are always all like "HIBBIDYHOOBLA! UMA DEDICATED COMBAT KILLER AND SHIT!" but they don't have the fucking brains to back it up. Seriously. They're retarded. Too retarded to know that they shouldn't put this up on youtube.
Marines now use this guy's name to mean Dumbass. But back to the point at hand, the Marines are attracted to anything that makes them look like a biker gang. The Army is as well but not to such a great extent.
Anyway, Historically speaking, go and try to find any engagements that the USMC fought with the Waffen-SS. Go ahead, I'll wait. In the European Theatre, they were confined to their traditional role, serving aboard vessels. Their land fighting capability was too focused on the island-hopping campaign in the Pacific. The Army maintains an institutional memory of the SS that the Marines don't and that institutional memory can be summed up as "They were such utter bastards that anything that we did to them was justified." Marines just see the SS runes and think "Scary, Elite Force!" So that's how that happened.
In terms of the institutional attraction to all things German, that's to be expected. We share a lot with them, due to the fact that the US military is a Prussian model military. Even the rank of "Lieutenant" is cribbed from the Germans rather than the British "Leftenant."
>>624997 >>625082 Armyfag here, can confirm. Scout Snipers are stupid. It's a job you get through infantry. They take people who they've trained to do urban ops, MOUT shit, stuff where the training is halfway tolerable, and ask them, "Do you want to sit all day and not do anything?" And these are the retards that say yes to that question.
So not only do they have to do all the stupid, useless shit the infantry has to do: ruck marching, retarded "elite" PT, retardedly spartan FTX's, and deal with full hooah highspeeds, but they're specialized training consists of sitting and trying not to fall asleep.
Institutional (not "institutionalized". Learn how to greentext properly, newfag) memory is actually a technical term. It refers to standards and practices as well as lore that persist in large, long-standing organizations.
As an example, consider the practice of stand-to. It's the practice of maintaining 100% security during periods of nautical twilight while in the field. Now, I've just thrown a lot of jargon at you so I'll summarize. "Nautical Twilight" refers to the periods of time in the morning and evening when there is still ambient light but the sun is beyond the horizon. We maintain this practice because that's when the Indians attack.
>>625828 Texas may not have the highest amount of Germans in their family trees, but Germans immigrants had a huge impact on Texas culture. The majority of the population ( if discounting Indians) of from the late 1820's to the 1870's was first generation European immigrants, not Americans or Hispanics. They were from all over Europe, but the Germans were the most organized of them. Thus a lot of people in the are learned German. It became the third (and later second) commonly used language in Texas, after English and Comanche. In did not get displaced by Spanish till the 1920's. Even by the 1940's Germanophones was so common that the POW camps that held German prisoners were built in Texas due to the ability to hire local workers for the prisons who could understand the POWs. The POWs who behaved themselves and were not part of the SS could even seek employment in the nearby towns, only having to check back in once a week. Every other week if it was a job that required the workers to live on site like oil or lumber.
Thread replies: 58 Thread images: 15
Thread DB ID: 478577
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.