>>79699903 The worst part is that she was getting better throughout All-Stars and it seemed like she and Scott were going to be the saving grace of an otherwise awful season. Then this episode happened.
>>79700045 Courtney was actually becoming nicer throughout All-Stars. She rekindled her friendship with Gwen and started dating Scott. In this episode, she revealed that she doesn't give a shit about them and even has a plan for the exact order of elimation to assure her victory.
>>79699629 Island was the best this series ever saw both in content and hype and everything else is pointless milking and ruins the satisfying ending to Owen winning season 1 and all the characters ending on a moderately good terms with the game over.
Prove me wrong. Pro Tip:You might be able to. I haven't actually watched any of this show past TDI
And the shit thing about it, is that Mike's evil alter ego Mal could have EASILY planted the elimination plans, thereby making him more of a villain and saving face for Courtney (who, by the way, rightfully hated Gwen for being a damn boyfriend kisser.)
>>79701100 You just fixed the biggest problem of the whole fucking season right there. If they had done that, TDA would still be the indisputable worst season. It would still be second worst because of how hard it fucked Lindsay, Sam, and Sierra and the Mike vs Zoey finale that no one deserved to win.
>>79700540 well Action was garbage outside of Harold and Lindsay(who were great), World Tour was over all pretty decent(even if it did have a massive plot tumor involving Duncan, Gwen, and Courtney, and it was frankly ridiculous that Heather managed to make it past two or three episodes), Revenge of The Island was pretty good(had the best finale in Total Drama history in my opinion), All-Stars had some good moments but ended atrociously and made some really huge mistakes in terms of cast choice and elimination order, Pahkitew Island was decent but too short to develop it's cast properly, and Ridonculous Race is probably the best season since Island(which one is better is a matter of opinion)
RR is way better if we ignore the lackluster ending. I rewatched all the seasons and is by far the funniest and they toned down the fart jokes and unnecessary slapstick. The only problem is the lack of interaction between characters what TD is all about) and the ending.
I still think a Courtney vs Zeke series finale would be a good idea to wrap the show up. Courtney would be redeemed at that point and Ezekiel wouldn't be in goblin mode but still has the animal habilities that make him a strong competitor. Both characters who got so much shit throughout the whole show now have their moment of glory. Also it would mirror the first elimanition ceremony for full pottery.
>>79702200 What is wrong with the ending? The ending was great, with 2 of the objectively best characters in TD history winning and the Ice Fuckers getting 3rd. The only bad part of that season was the overdone cringe couple trope (Noah/Emma, Devon/Carrie, Ryan/Stephanie).
>>79700540 I think it's because TDI was a reality show made into a cartoon while the rest were cartoons made into reality shows. I haven't watched past World Tour because at that point I stopped enjoying the series and their constant attempts at flubbing up their character developments. Once the initial enjoyment came and went there was barely anything they could do and once they began to use the same characters over and over I figured they couldn't go much further.
>>79704552 The problem with All-Stars wasn't the amount of drama, it focused too much on a single story and the writers didn't give a shit about anything else. If anything, I think it lacked genuine drama from other characters, since they were all just walking plot devices for Mike and Zoey's boring storyline.
Boring challenges, boring location, (New York could have been great but it was just a fucking grey city) everything came down to who was faster in a foot race , not all the losers were able to say something.
Also I'll fite you, Ice Dancers best team. they should have lost in 4th, their 3rd place had less drama compared to what happened in Bahamas
What suprised me about All-Stars as the lack of 'stars' in the contestants. Could Jo, Sam, Mike and Zoey be considered All-Stars? Past winners like Beth and Owen were missing, and fan favourites seemed absent.
>>79704860 well there's different kinds of drama, and All-Stars used a really bad kind
>>79705135 they really should have waited another season or two before doing it, actually that's a good hypothetical, in a world where the All-Stars we got never happened, and instead we got a full season length version of Pahkitew Island, and then after that they decided to do an All-Stars season(one that would be a full length season), who would you pick as contestants(it'll be 22 contestants like Island)?
Hard Mode: only one or two of the following characters can be chosen(the ones not brought back you have to explain why Chris didn't or couldn't bring them back despite being obvious choices); Duncan, Gwen, Courtney, Heather, Alejandro, Owen, Izzy, Bridgette, Mike, Zoey, Lightning
Probably both winners are from the loser side. Being a waifufag I want to say Courtney or Ella, but I think a good one would be Brick and Lindsay, both great characters (at least in Action for Lindsay) who were unjustly kicked out.
>>79705760 originally I was going to suggest 22 campers, but dividing that evenly between all three generations doesn't work, so I'm bumping it up to 24(which can be divided into 3 teams of 8), here's my thoughts(following my hard mode rule from >>79705380 so certain characters are restricted);
Team Wawnakwa Island >Alejandro(unanimously voted off at the first opportunity by the rest of his teammates) >Eva >Cody >Harold >Katie & Sadie(count as one contestant) >Lindsay >Beth >Sierra
Team Boney Island >Anne Maria >Cameron >Sam >Dakota(zoid) >Dawn >Scott >Lightning >Brick
Team Pahkitew >Samey >Ella >Shawn >Jasmine >Sugar >Scarlett >Max(both him and Scarlett are brought back by demand from the network, Chris isn't happy about either of them being allowed back) >Rodney
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at email@example.com with the post's information.