[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

ITT: controversial gaming opinions Luigi's Mansion was shit

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 181
Thread images: 19

File: le_neogaf.jpg (206KB, 800x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
le_neogaf.jpg
206KB, 800x600px
ITT: controversial gaming opinions

Luigi's Mansion was shit
>>
Super Mario 3D World is not only the best Mario game, but one of the best games ever made.
>>
Wonderful 101 is garbage
>>
Dark Souls 2 was a direct upgrade over Dark Souls 1 in every aspect.
>>
>>262965530
it's not controversial if it's true
>>
>>262965447
>>262965530
>>262965592

I agree with 2 out of the 3
>>
>>262965447
Resident Evil 4 ruined the series.
>>
>>262965738
Luigi's Mansion and Wonderful 101 being shit, obviously
>>
Wind weaker is the worst Zelda game and the worst gamecube game hands down
>>
Final Fantasy VIII is the best Final Fantasy game. Precisely because it focused on characters and gameplay over story. Unlike nearly every other Final Fantasy game.
>>
File: 1410483168151.jpg (134KB, 640x853px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410483168151.jpg
134KB, 640x853px
FPS are shit
MMOs are shit
RPGs are shit
FPSRPGSs are the worst fucking thing in existence
>>
>>262965447

I imagine whoever took this picture was quite comfy at the moment.

I fucking loved Luigi's Mansion as a kid. I went back and played it again recently and it was not as good. I was blinded by nostalgia.
>>
>>262965447

anon are you me?
>>
>>262965901
1 out of the 2
>>
The Vita is a better system than the 3DS with better games overall.

Gothic 2 is better than Gothic 1.

World of Warcraft Wrath of the Lich King was the best expansion and everything after it was just a massive let down.

Hitman 2 is the best in the series.
>>
Let's plays and streaming are a cancer that are actually hurting gaming.
>>
>>262965738
Super Mario 3D world and Luigi's Mansion being shit.
>>
>>262965447
>opinions everyone has
>>
Final Fantasy XIII has an excellent story and some of the best lore in the series. It was just poorly projected in-game through the terrible writing.
>>
Dota 2 has a shitty art style
>>
>>262966276
1/2
>>
Sunshine was the best Mario.
Star Wars Battlefront was better than its sequel.
>>
>>262965447
you own a wiiu so you are too young to drink beer. oh wait is that apple juice?
>>
The best Mother game is the first.
>>
>>262965447
>>262966076
The game will always have a place in my heart for introducing me to survival horror in a sense. I was too much of a bitch to even look at a House of the Dead arcade cabinet back in the day. But that mansion concept would eventually have me revisiting old RE games and I love that shit to death. Also why is it considered to be a bad game by you guys?
>>
>>262965447

>beer

what are you, straight?
>>
>>262966485
Not him, but I'm 30 and I own a Wii U.
One of the best, most fun consoles I've ever had.
>>
>>262966471
Sunshine is fun but goddamn are the controls slidey as fuck
>>
>>262966682
You're probably a homosexual like me then. I love the Wii u
>>
>>262965447
I hate everything Nintendo
>>
File: 1404396079053.jpg (79KB, 711x906px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1404396079053.jpg
79KB, 711x906px
every elder scrolls game is garbage

including morrowind
>>
File: 1228805225739.png (131KB, 745x548px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1228805225739.png
131KB, 745x548px
I found Bully to be boring
>>
I think Halo 1 is actually a really great game in terms of single player and lan multiplayer

inb4 baby's first fps, underage, quake 3 is better etc
>>
File: 1406253442129.gif (3MB, 250x257px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1406253442129.gif
3MB, 250x257px
I don't believe feminists have any real pull on the industry and think gamergate kids are fedora lords more annoying than any SJW I've ever had to deal with.
>>
>>262966682
I'm married with 2 kids.
So no.
>>
Shadow the Hedgehog is the best game in the Sonic series.
>>
Duke Nukem forever wasn't as bad as everyone made it out to be. It was like a 5 or a 6 game, but casual fags who bought into the hype were disappointed and trashed it.
>>
>>262965447

fuck you OP, I loved the original GameCube one.

How did the 3ds version end up? I have yet to play it.
>>
>>262966836
see >>262966953
>>
>>262967084
It's better in almost every way
>>
>>262966485
>not living in an apartment and playing the wii u in the bathroom

best console
>>
>>262965965
FFV does that better.
>>
>>262967127
So you're closeted then?
>>
File: cream4.jpg (63KB, 463x338px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
cream4.jpg
63KB, 463x338px
>>262966990

Sonic Advance 2 is the best game in the series. Precisely because it focused on speed and not shitty platforming that punishes you for going fast.
>>
Sony is the only one doing anything good in the videogame industry. No/Low story games like mario should cease to exist to make room for more games like TLOU and Destiny.
>>
>>262967206
Only for you baby.
>>
The only decent game Sony ever made is Uncharted 2.
>>
File: 1366252204135.jpg (147KB, 500x540px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1366252204135.jpg
147KB, 500x540px
>>262965447
Morrowind is shit
>>
>>262966926
this is actually the correct opinion. 95% of people who make games don't even know what an SJW or a GramerGate is.
>>
>>262965447
Nintendo has always been trash. The only thing good to come out of it is allowing Pokemon Gold to be on Gameboy
>>
>>262967330
Confession
I constantly complain about how all this "cinematic experience" shit is ruining gaming but that is one of my favourite games
>>
>>262967162

Nice, I will probably pick it up when the price drops
>>
I still see Sony as a second Sega
>>
>>262967497
try harder m8
>>
>>262967084
I loved the Original and I really enjoyed the 3DS one but it was a bit different in some good and a bad ways.
>>
>>262966926
Yes! This I can agree with. None of the people involved seem to have any perspective of how insignificant the whole drama is.
>>
>>262965705

Unfortunately it's not true, so it is.
>>
>>262967330
Ahaha, that's like the shittiest one man. The fuck are you doing with your life?
>>
Nintendo>Sony>>>>>>>>>Microsoft
>>
>>262965447
The Souls series is shit ironically praised by /v/irgins. Just like other ironic things on 4chan *coughcoughMLPcoughcough*, normalfags/autists took it seriously and now 10 year olds love their epic LE PRAISE THE SUN!1111!!! maymay
>>
Prepare your anus

Super Mario Galaxy was average and not special in any way.
Demon's Souls is better than Dark Souls1 and 2.
Dark Souls 2 > Dark Souls 1
Monster Hunter is a shitty boring series
Platinum games are all flash, and no substance.
Persona 4 > Persona 2 duology
Persona > Mainline
MGS4 is the best in the series.
Generation 4 is the best generation for Pokemon.
Wind Waker is the WORST 3D Legend of Zelda game.
LoZ;ALttP 2 sucked ass.
>>
>>262967307
Oh anon... <3
>>
>>262967402

every single bethesda game is shit
>>
>>262965447
I thought this was a thread about opinions OP. Why didn't you start with one?
>>
I enjoyed Luigi's Mansion 2 more than the first one
>>
>>262966926
I think both groups are shit. I just want to talk about fucking video games.
>>
Jet Set Radio is better than JSRF
at least the music is
>>
>>262965447
[spoilers]Gone Home [spoilers] was the best game ever
>>
LoZ games are boring
P4G was mediocre
Bioshock Infinite was boring to me

Oh and
I-I liked Borderlands 2. I mean I-It's n-not the best game a-and its not b-bad either. It w-was OK
dontkillmepls/v/
>>
Crazy Taxi is the best game there ever will be.
>>
>>262967857
Define substance

Because if you're referring to lacking a good story or any likeable characters you should try W101
>>
Smash 4 is underwhelming and not worth the hype. It's just a roster update with a different art-style.
>>
>>262967857
I could respect all of that until
>persona>mainline
nigga go ahead, bite the hand that feeds you, and the games that are actual unique and not a visual novel with a dungeon crawl minigame in which you kill god with the power of friendship.
>>
File: image.jpg (31KB, 240x320px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
31KB, 240x320px
Ape Escape 2 is objectively better than the first game.

Sonic the Hedgehog games have never been good. Even the Genesis platformers and first Sonic Adventure games were garbage.

If you play as Ryu, Ken or Akuma, you are a very boring person.
>>
i like video games
>>
>>262967857
I agree only with gen 4
>>
>>262965806
my nigga
>>
Skyrim and witcher 2 are both very similar games but of course popular = shit to /v/ so they will praise witcher 2 and shit on skyrim
>>
>>262965447
>macbook
hmm.
worth getting as a college student?
>>
Pokemon Platinum was the best pokemon.
>>
The only good thing to ever come out of capcom was fighting games
megaman is shit and deserved the treatment it gets
>>
>>262966926
>only ever head about sjws through /v/
>don't hear about them anywhere other than /v/
>even though I have a tumblr used exclusively for hentai because 4chan is riddled with saucefags
>never cared about any of it
>always thought it belonged on /pol/ and insta-hid every thread
>never cared about console wars
and my biggest contoversial opinion
>I only play vidya for fun and think tourneyfags are faggots
>>
Kid Icarus Uprising is the best Nintendo game since OOT.
>>
>>262965806
Agreed
But it went out with a bang with a 10/10
>>
>>262968185
>in which you kill god with the power of friendship.

Mainline.
Kill god with the power of anti-friendship!
>>
File: 1409818796829.gif (983KB, 260x195px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409818796829.gif
983KB, 260x195px
>>262967659
Not bait, friend. Never liked Nintendo. Got an N64 as a kid from a garage sale and sold it a month later. Never found any of their games fun, ever. And all of their consoles are goddamn terrible.
>>
>>262968405
didn't like oracle of ages/seasons?
agree with the second
>>
Skyrim>Morrowind>Oblivion>Daggerfall>Arena>Online
>>
Rockstar games tend to be really mediocre
>>
The PS2 had some great games. Including my favorite game of all time. But was also one of the worst designed consoles ever. And 90% of all console games being made for the PS2 really held its generation back.
>>
Super Mario 64 has no redeeming qualities when compared to any other 3D mario game.
>>
>>262968394
Yes.

>>262968475
>I only play vidya for fun and think tourneyfags are faggots
Christ yes.
>>
File: 1409273746033s.jpg (7KB, 216x250px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409273746033s.jpg
7KB, 216x250px
>>262968251
>>
>>262968495
I disagree but this is still a good opinion
>>
File: ugly.png (178KB, 403x387px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ugly.png
178KB, 403x387px
>>262965447
>ITT: Wrong gaming opinions
ftfy
>>
>>262968507
at least it's different
persona is dime-a-dozen
overblown
replaceable
not to mention it does every single concept worse than other games in the genres it mashes together
>>
>>262968863
>opinion
>wrong
>>
Rockstar hasn't made a good game since GTA2
>>
>>262968678
It carved out a lot of the qualities of 3D platforming that most games use today

Revolutionary at the time but boring now, pretty much the platforming equivalent of Half life
>>
>>262968554
oh shit you're right, they did make those and minish cap
okay, fighting games and zelda games i guess
>>
>>262967594

I too am guilty. The game is just too damn good. I replayed it recently and was surprised with how much I could'nt put it down like I could do with most games after playing for a while. The pacing is too good, and the gameplay is fun.

Half the reason why everyone loves TLOU is because it's just doing what U2 did first, but with Zombies. I can't bring myself to replay the game like I easily did with U2.
>>
>>262968908

Not quite.
It mixes Dungeon Crawler + VN quite well.
No other games/developers have gotten the balance of Social Sim and RPG right.
>>
>>262968937
What's your point?
>>
>>262968863
>ITT: /v/ mistakes contrary as controversial
more like it
>>
There has never been a good videogame
>>
>>262969078
I'm the guy who posted that. I completely agree. The first time I played it I had fun, but I couldn't pick it up when I beat it. It felt so bland after one playthrough.
>>
>>262969208
Good point, fixed that for me.
>>
OOT is garbage and MM is the best Zelda.
>>
>>262965530
>>262965806
>>262965447
>>262966152
>>262966471
>>262967883

Spot on.

>>262965965
Best 3D one next to 12 at least.

>>262968180
Different speeds too but yea not worth the hype.
>>
>>262969179
Another unpopular opinion

Whilst TLOU is probably the most overrated game ever I can't believe how underrated the online mode is, it's incredibly fun and pretty much the only reason I still turn on my PS3 from time to time
>>
>>262969193
>cardboard cut out characters worse than any visual novel ever made
>the travesty that is persona's dungeons could even be considered good
>>
>>262969612

>played through TLoU
>Never touched the multiplayer

I really like the game a lot, but I just can't seem to care about that aspect.
>>
Monster Hunter Tri is 4/10 - probably less:

C-stick simulator.
>>
>>262969721

There's no point in arguing with an butthurt mainline fanboy.
Anything Persona does is automatically shit to you people.

It's kind of funny in a sad way.
>>
ugh let me try this again
gone home was the best game ever
>>
>>262969612
It just felt tacked on.
I played a few rounds and safely felt like I could never touch it again without missing much.
>>
>>262969976
okay then, defend the dungeons
what makes them so great?
>>
>>262969721
>worse than any visual novel ever made
persona's vn aspects are mediocre even by incredible low vn standards, but that's kinda pushing it
there are so many beyond-terrible vns
>>
NSMB.U is the best 2D Mario.
>>
>>262969813
It's actually really fun, littered with codbabbies using the same "semi-auto + silencer" loadout but if you get creative

I put all my points into crafting and healing so I can play support and have become a crackshot with the revolver because it's all I have
>>
Mass Effect 1 and 2 are the best modern science fiction games
>>
>>262966298

Final Fantasy XIII-2 was a better time traveling game than Chrono Trigger.

As was Dark Cloud 2.
>>
Any game that tries to put any emotional depth below cardboard into the character is pretentious shit
cardboard cut-out characters are lazy
>>
Wii U is the only current-gen console worth owning for the next couple of months

Persona 3 is a tryhard piece of shit far outclassed by P4

Wind Waker is overrated, Skyward Sword is the best 3D Zelda since MM, and Twilight Princess is the series' weakest link

Elder Scrolls lore is far better than that of the Souls series, considering Souls fans have to pull said lore from their ass.

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is the best 3D Mario.

Sony's current first-party franchises are shit, and their devs should have kept to their prior franchises or something in the same vein (Crash, Spyro, Jak, Ratchet, Sly, etc. etc.)

Silent Hill 2 is the pinnacle of gaming as an art form

M&L: Partners in Time is actually a better game than Super Star Saga (which was still good)
>>
All the Golden Sun games are overrated as hell.
>>
File: 1410460869832.jpg (22KB, 360x351px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410460869832.jpg
22KB, 360x351px
Steam is literally cancer:
At an industry level by rewarding bad video games and developers with money via sales.
At a distribution level with heavy DRM/privacy invasion and all sales final.
At a community level by making steam facebook for gamers,

Valve is just as bad as EA, in terms of buying out developers and extorting their game for huge profit. The only difference is EA kills their developers with abuse, Steam kills their developers with laziness, gluttony, and Hats.
>>
Mass Effect 1 was a terrible video game with a great story and universe.

Mass Effect 2 is superior in every meaningful way.
>>
>>262965447
- FF12 is garbage
- PS2 sucked besides shadow of the colossus and MGS
- Ocarina is still the best game ever made
- Twin Snakes is better than the original
- Rome Total War 2 is not that bad anymore
- Dreamcast deserved to die
- WiiU is best console of this gen
>>
The Saturn version of Symphony of the Night was the superior version
>>
There's no such thing as a good horror game.
>>
>>262970695
Hmm, did you try cyanide to cure yourself of your shitty opinion?
>>
>>262970697
yee
>>
>>262965447
I value stories in video games a lot. Theres a lot of room for it to grow as an interactive medium because of it.

its also mainly the reason i play Old JRPGs.
>>
Anita Sarkeesian is right.
>>
>>262970923
This is true. Fuck the PS1 version.
>>
>>262965931
>Worst gamecube game
Oh yeah, way worse than this gem right?
>>
>>262970763

The only thing more wrong than your Wii U statement is your Twin Snakes one. How in the fuck is TTS better? Take away the graphical upgrade and it's objectively a worse game, and I'm not just talking about the cutscenes.
>>
>>262970695
I like them but yeah they get waaay too much hype. They are mediocre.
>>
PS1 is the worst console ever made and ruined videogames
>>
The most important part of a game is good pacing

If the pacing is good enough, even mediocre gameplay can be enjoyable
>>
>>262970763
I used to play Rachet and Clank and Burnout all the time on my ps2
>>
Fallout New Vegas was too open-ended after you confront the man in the checker suit. I forget his name, but it's not important.

After that, you're supposed to choose what side you want to align with, but do so without really any information of what for and why. So the goal of the game moves from getting revenge to... take over the town, without any good transition of goal. I have to choose what faction I want, among four, without any knowledge of them.

It turned me off completely from the game, other games like it understood the main plot having a flowing focus.

You want to find your father, then save your father, then avenge your father and/or stop an invasion of an old threat in FO3.
You want to deliver a message, then you want to learn, then you learn of a greater purpose to the situation in Skyrim.

In New Vegas, the leap is just 'the choice is yours... oh didn't you know that was coming up? That this is what was the next arc? Well tough, time to choose.' I get why they wanted to do it, but the sheer lack of understanding the implications, combined with a sense that all of this was built for pre-established Fallout fans, made me feel unwelcome and uninterested. I haven't played the game since, and I don't understand why it's rated so high. In fact, if I were to be honest, I hated it, and much preferred FO3.
>>
JRPGs are the only games worth playing.
>>
>>262971351

The Wii is a far worse console and ruined video games far more, despite Galaxy being an exclusive for it.
>>
>>262971307
Literally everything about TTS is better. It's not even close.
>>
>>262965447
Resident Evil 6 is not the worst game ever made
>>
Dungeon Crawlers are the only good genre of RPG
>>
The Gamecube was the last console that was worth owning.
>>
Demon's/Dark souls a shit.
Skyward Sword/Twilight princess was good.
Pc gaming isn't worth the effort.
>>
>>262971307
The GC Controller.
>>
File: O9dhVOs.jpg (215KB, 800x620px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
O9dhVOs.jpg
215KB, 800x620px
This entire thread makes me think of the last panel of this, you're all Dobson tier

Nice hat
>>
>>262971579

The MGS2 moveset irrepairably breaks the level design, the soundtrack is worse, framerate drops, the fucking retarded controls (A+Start for the codec, when Start alone does nothing?), voice acting was worse in some areas, etc.
>>
This board is a better /s4s/ than /s4s/ will ever be.
>>
>>262971470
- Rachet and Clank is overrated shit
- Burnout was better on other consoles of the time
>>
>>262971750
if not counting portables, maybe
>>
>>262971509
I partially agree with you but too many JRPGs, or rather playing too many back to back just sucks.
>>
>>262971307
There's not much to MGS series outside of cutscenes so improving those improves the game dramatically.
>>
>>262972035
Why was it shit to you?
>>
>>262971842
Almost perfect except for the PC part.
>>
>>262971490
I don't know how you can't make an informed decision about what course of action to take. They don't even make you choose right away, and the entire game throws information at you well before you even get to the strip, about what each faction is like.
>>
Metak Gear killed the stealth genre
>>
>>262972041
I am not counting handhelds. The 3DS and to a lesser extent vita (if you like lewd games) are worth owning.
>>
>>262967213
my nigga.
I remember cheating my way with Cream the first time i played it
>>
>>262972246
The previous gen (PS1, N64) had much better collectathon type games. The only thing R&C had going for it were the weapons and weapon upgrades.
>>
>>262965447
I enjoy my 3DS more than my Vita.
>>
>>262972474
I haven't played the games in a long time, so I probably just have nostalgia goggles.

I used to play with my stepbrothers all the time to, so that probably influences how I feel about it more than anything else
>>
The Nvidia Shield is my favorite handheld this generation.
>>
>>262965447
Minecraft sucks, how is this a game? Why people "play" this shit?
>>
>>262970718
Spot on
>>
Your opinions on video games are subjective.
>>
I think that all next-gen consoles are a scam.
>>
Socom combined assault was the best of the socom series.....
>>
>>262972267
All I know is NCR are the local government, Ceasar's Legion is a crazy bunch of murderers, Mr. House has been fucking with me, and Yes Man is a... thing that exists. Has the NCR been effective? Is the Legion actually as destructive a force as I thought. What on earth does Mr. House even want to do, and who am I to run things any damn better?

If I'm to make such a decision, I need MUCH more information. And I didn't have it. And frankly, it didn't feel like a decision that needed my input. All I came for was to find out who shot me, and why. And I got switched into something else entirely. There's not even an indication the plot was going to keep at it. He's dead, his goons are dead, and I'm walking around a building not sure who to listen to.
>>
>>262972646
Who doesn't? Vita has no games.
>>
OoT is so bad it makes the CD-i games look good
>>
>>262973767
That's not a controversial opinion, or even a bad one. That's a bad troll.
>>
M.A.G was an intuitive fun addictive game that just needed a better player base.
>>
File: 1410472510056.gif (3MB, 255x191px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410472510056.gif
3MB, 255x191px
JRPG's are a massive pile of steaming shit

Don't get me started on Final Fantasy... that shit is not an 'RPG'
>>
Banjo Kazooie is way better than Banjo Tooie.
>More compact level design
>less tedious character switching (which makes transformation feel more unique as well)
>Powers have a lot of purposes throughout the whole game (as opposed to all the eggtypes)
>Better music
>>
>>262965447
first one kinda was
3ds one was ballin tho
>>
File: relent.png (61KB, 162x164px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
relent.png
61KB, 162x164px
>>262965447
These threads are the most pathetic shit, do you really need a hugbox thread to be able to state your opinion?
also
do you feel unique just because your opinion is so "unpopular"?
Thread posts: 181
Thread images: 19


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.