Was it a war crime?

100%, Aragorn violated the NAP

>>87713100
that only applies to the living

dunedain of murder

>>87712196
No, it was just a dick move. They were all about to die anyway

He dunedain nuffin!

>>87712196
he escahrlated fahrce too quickly

LET THE LARD OF THE BLACK LANMD COME FARTH

>>87712196
What happens in the book again? I can't remember. Didn't the guy just take off after Aragorn threatened him? If that's right, why did PJ do this?

>>87712196
>was it a war crime
There was no Geneva Conventions and even if there were, Mordor goes fucking hard.

Only faggots let their enemies dictate the terms of a fight.

>>87713986
It was a deleted scene anyway, so he regretted it

>>87713986
>>87714473
It doesn't really effect the story and visually it's better to chop his head off then let him run away. I liked it.

>>87713986
Yeah, he just ran away. In the context of the book, Aragon decapitating him with no provocation would definitely be a war crime; the Mouth is just an emissary, and we was there to give terms to Aragorn and his army. He tries to do some negotiating, but says he can't do much behind Sauron's back.

In general, Tolkien humanized Sauron's forces way more than Jackson did.

>>87713100

Aragon has rightful ownership of the land, Sauron was the one who violated the NAP.

>>87712196
>Was it a war crime?
Mordor was breaking war crimes left right and centre. literally whipping their kin, forcing them to fight until death

File: say goodbye.gif (811KB, 500x256px) Image search: [Google]

811KB, 500x256px

Was it a war crime?

>>87714844
is this a deleted scene from Wanted?

File: 1411651921442.png (214KB, 400x399px) Image search: [Google]

214KB, 400x399px

>>87712196
Why dont they use toothbrushes in mordor?

>>87712196
Who gives a shit about "crimes"? They're the enemy, they're not even human.

>>87714569
>I liked it

t. barbarian sand coon

>>87714844
Why the fuck she starts flying after being shot?

>>87712196
He dindu NUFFIN

>>87714958
The Mouth was a human, although corrupt.

they should have completely overhauled the scene and made the mouth of sauron sword duel aragorn like he does in the video game

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jc6Js9tgTPE

fucking PJ with his troll fetish

File: 25-per-cent-living-with-parents.jpg (6KB, 283x160px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 283x160px

>>87714569
>then

talk shit
get hit

'nuff said

>>87712196
He implied dear Frodo was killed, Aragorn couldn't take it.

>>87715232
it's funny how this scene completely changes the context of the "for frodo" line

better or worse?

>>87715261
Worse. If Aragorn still thinks Frodo is alive, he attacking as a last=ditch effort to buy Frodo time to destroy the ring. If Aragorn thinks Frodo is dead (and Sauron probably has the ring), he's just throwing away the lives and him and his friends for revenge.

No,

His mission is to deliver messages, he started improvisation after delivering the message, stepping outside his mission. Therefore he is no longer a messenger.

>>87712196
Remind me again why the orcs were the bad guys... men = literal shit tier

>>87715378
sam could have it though

Isn't he a black numenorean?

Isn't it fully within Aragorn's rights to execute him as a traitor?

>>87713661
I really miss this minimeme and LotRposting in general.
Tax policies were good but not enough.

>>87715378
>he's just throwing away the lives and him and his friends for revenge.
Why would it matter? Sauron with the ring would obliterate them.

>>87715703
>>87715660
both of these are valid reasons

>>87714602

Either you haven't read the book in a very long time or at all, mouth of sauron was watered down in Jackson's bullshit

>>87715700
>minimeme

is this actually a thing? It's just reposting quotes from the movie in funny contexts

>>87714602
The Mouth was still evil. They just weren't going to kill him then and there because he was an emissary and you don't kill emissaries when they ride out to meet you. He was almost certainly killed after Sauron's defeat.

>>87715620
>15620▶
>>>87712196 (OP)
>Remind me again why the orcs were the bad guys... men = literal shit tier
They were made by Melkor/Morgoth, the Satan of Middle Earth. They're basically demons.

>>87715002
the laws of physics don't apply in quentin tarantino movies

>>87715002
Whoever decides to watch a Tarantino film and expects "realism" must be a real dumbass.

kings don't kill messengers, so both leonidas and (extended cut) aragorn acted foolishly, and dishonorably

it matters because the king's entire job is to show his subjects how to behave, and doing something violent to make yourself feel better is not a good lesson to teach them

File: 1422215619_841535344.jpg (11KB, 200x228px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 200x228px

The animated Mouth of Sauron is better. The movie version is too over-the-top edgy.

>>87715873
>it matters because the king's entire job is to show his subjects how to behave, and doing something violent to make yourself feel better is not a good lesson to teach them
>"don't take bullshit from demonic forces that want to eradicate you from this earth" is a bad lesson
American liberals.

>>87715910
Unintelligent social engineers

>>87715660
Aragon had probably forgotten Sam even existed by that point desu

>>87714473
It's a scene from the extended, not deleted

>>87715873
>kings don't kill messengers
Under what law?
> doing something violent to make yourself feel better
You're a lame ass pussy liberal. Aragorn was picking a fight PURPOSELY, with the support of everyone there, to give Frodo a chance to make it. It was a diversion, in an open war, that started when Mordor invaded Gondor. Your pussy ass misses the fact that this is EPIC fantasy, where men are warriors and heroes, and don't always follow pissy rules made by pissy little people like you.

>>87716018
epic fantasy always abided to these rules retard

>>87716018
its so weird that you actually believe these things

like you're so knee fucking deep in this generation z ultra conservatism that you see your ideological opposite, in anything that you happen to disagree with

take the advice of a more experienced conservative, pay attention to the things that trigger you emotionally, so you can have more control over yourself

>>87716142
It's so wierd your pussy ass fell for the bait, lol.

Go "Well actshually" at someone else, kid, lol. You already lost by reacting to an obvious bait. Fuck, i didn't even try! You're fuckin pathetic, getting all amped up over a fucking movie.

Now go polish your Walmart katana, neckbeard.

Those that betray the west deserve no mercy.

>>87716097
LOL

>>87716208
hurr why didn't Achilles killed Priam when he came to beg for his sons body

>>87716206
But Middle Earth is the east.

>>87716241
Hurrr I don't fucking care, i was trolling for neckbeards, and I won. I caught the fattest one.

>>87716253
Numenor is to the west

>>87716253
No, it's in the middle. Thus: middle earth.

>>87715904

>edgy

kys. movie mouth was perfect and that looks like shit.

>>87716527
North, east, south, west theres no "middle"

>>87712196
Why was there no blood in rotk

>>87716569
You're actually going to argue this? Really?

>>87715904
Shit taste.

File: maxresdefault (1).jpg (73KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 1280x720px

>gets elected king
>starts singing gay shit

Was he autistic?

>>87715779
for you