Hiro's Feedback Thread #3

Hiro's Twitter: @hiroyuki_ni

/ic/'s meta thread
>>>/ic/2684829

Final Results:
>>681974

Current /tg/-/qst/ idea & consensus attempt:

Allow quests back on /tg/. Use /qst/ as an additional board if quests want to use it, for example QMs who want to utilise the extra functions. /qst/ also serves as a /trash/-type board where quests can be moved if they're dead or overpopulating the board.

Quests on /tg/ only bump to page 2. This would be achieved via a 'Game/Quest' checkbox in the OP creation interface. Creating a game/quest without checking the box means quest can be reported and deleted.

Any comments?

/a/ consensus attempt:

1) More janitors
2) Visible autosage >>>/a/147330167
3) Light Novels should be allowed
4) Chinese and Korean comics should not be allowed
5) Word filters are necessary for cuck and kys
6) Move seiyuu threads to /jp/

File: cpsht - Superheroes.png (28KB, 370x430px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 370x430px

>consensus on /co/:
/co/ doesn't want live action cinematic universes (because 3DPD non-comics and non-cartoons do not belong on a 2D board).

>consensus on /tv/:
/tv/ doesn't want superhero cinematic universes (because the company wars raise infighting and lower the overall quality of discussion).

>not a consensus, just my observation (I'm not sure how I would measure this anyway):
No currently-existing board wants the BANE/INVINCIBLE SON/DANCE-OFF cinematic universes (because hot heads).

Superheroes (especially Marvel and DC) have content that thousands of posters want to discuss. However, no existing board wants to hold all the baggage associated with live action superhero movies and live action superhero television shows. Therefore, I ask Hiro to please make a new board for superheroes (especially live action superheroes).

>>682255
You forgot.
7) Generals are limited to existing only when new content exists to discuss.

>>682255
>6) Move seiyuu threads to /jp/

What are seiyuu threads? Yes, I know what a seiyuu is but I don't go to /a/. This sounds like something I'd be interested in, because I am obsessed with them and don't have anyone to talk to who knows enough about them. What do they talk about there?

>>682260
Why can't we call it /cape/ or /sh/ or even /hero/ instead of /cpsht/? Not only is /cpsht/ hard to pronounce but there's not a single other board on this site where the name of the board is specifically insulting to the subject matter.

>>682260
Wasn't this shot down in the previous tread?

File: Hiro on cpsht.png (15KB, 475x135px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 475x135px

>>682267
Because Hiro already agreed to that.

Also, you can't take things too seriously, you have to learn to treat life with a little levity, or else you're going to have a bad time.

>>682269
/qa/ posters are always resistant to change. The fact of the matter is that /co/ still wants that content removed from /co/, and /tv/ still wants that content removed from /tv/.

>>682261
My bad. These would be a good start if Hiro ever shows up.

>>682274
More like you have a personal vendetta and want to keep pushing it even when people said no. >>682267 makes a valid point about the board name being to long and demeaning.

File: 1473807561267.png (195KB, 499x499px) Image search: [Google]

195KB, 499x499px

WHO KEEPS FUCKING MAKING META THREADS ON /a/, IT'S INVITING CANCEROUS SHITPOSTERS.

>>682279
This isn't true, but since there's nothing I can post which can convince you of my honest sincerity, I won't spend the next 100 posts arguing it with you.

>>682264
Cute seiyuu doing cute things >>>/a/147144473
It's too 3D for /a/ though so they want it moved to /jp/.

File: board split.gif (11KB, 600x80px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 600x80px

The time has come Hiro.

>>682267
>>682274
/cape/ is a better name.

>>682260
Wholeheartedly support all superhero media getting a board. It would basically be a western parallel to /m/.

>>682267
/hero/ and /cape/ are pretty cool. The other one is bad and might make people think it's a board about CP shit.

>>682255
Don't filter anything.

>>682241
Keep Quests on /qst/ and just fix the problems with that board. Quests were barely tolerated on /tg/ before.

>>682269
No.

>>682297
Yes.

Every idea proposed by every board was shot down. There's always someone ready with a needlessly negative opinion here on /qa/.

File: C6r75.jpg (19KB, 450x271px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 450x271px

Hiro has created a monster with these threads...

>>682304

And a lot of them are the same guy. /d/ had an issue where a couple days into their feedback thread somebody from here somebody started shitposting up an absolute storm, impersonating a mod, demanding they delete the thread and go to /qa/, and botting all their polls. It was a mess.

I'll never understand why people are so desperate to avoid any kind of changes.

>>682296
>Keep Quests on /qst/ and just fix the problems with that board.
The problem with the board is that it's a board. It's not a topic that draws people in.
>Quests were barely tolerated on /tg/ before.
So barely that the complaining IPs could be counted on two hands.

>>682311
>muh twelve IPs

jesus christ, guy, give it a rest.

>>682313
I will when more than a handful of people actually complain about quests.
Hasn't happened yet.

>>682292
Is that the slashing animation from Undertale?

>>682314
seconding this. I'm one of the 12 IPs and I think OP is a faggot.

>>682285
Seems like a great thread. I can't believe I didn't know about this. Finally a place where I can make jokes about Sakurai and someone will understand them.

On one hand it's pretty /a/-relevant since it's directly related to anime, but it's definitely also a good fit for /jp/. Both sides seem to have a valid argument here. So I personally think it'll be fine no matter what happens but I hope it turns out in a way the majority is satisfied with.

>>682317
no?

>>682285
>>>/m/14740484
/jp/ should take on Sentai and Toku too. They can discus what onaholes to use while watching JAV that feature people from Toku shows.

File: 1474252387252.png (28KB, 370x430px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 370x430px

>>682260
Give all (You)s to this post if you prefer /cape/.

>>682255
>>682264
>>682285
>>682321
The funny thing is, Hiro already agreed last year that seiyuus don't belong on /a/ because "Seiyu is 3D".

http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/132387610/#132433097
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/132387610/#132433231

>>682331
/cape/ is to long. You can knock that down to /ca/ or /cp/ if you want to have fun.

>>682335
>cp

are you fucking stupid? /ca/ is fine

>>682335
>/cp/
/cpsht/ is preferable to this because at least the sht part really makes you think.

>>682338
>if you want to have some fun
I'd ask if you're retarded, but you already answered that.

>>682343
>inviting misinterpretation is fun

>>682348
>Can't have fun while trying to push his agenda on people

>>682208
Here's /asp/'s metathread.

>>>/asp/1761072

/co/ doesn't want /cape/ hiro, a few people do but they are outnumbered

>>682405
/tv/ wants /co/ to want /cape/

>>682411
exactly, hiro don't be fooled

>>682405
According to the last poll, /co/ wants live action removed.
http://www.strawpoll.me/11229277/r


Hiro doesn't care about polls though, so why don't YOU give us YOUR opinion on why it's a bad idea, instead of lying to us about what "/co/" wants?

>>682413
oh boy not even 200 people of the couple thousand that use /co/

>>682416
It's more than the absolutely nothing that you have.

>>682255
All very fair rules

Why the fuck do you want new boards RIGHT NOW?!

Do you not get that nothing will get better so long as we're stuck with batch of mods

>>682429
>Concrete suggestion: New boards.
>Vague to the point of useless: Better mods.
Who gets to be a new mod? Where do they come from? How do we hold them accountable? What are the qualifications necessary to apply? You hate all the janitors too, so it can't be any of them.

>>682435
Hiro should bring his friends.

>>682439
You know Hiro's japanese mods on 2ch were much more strict than the mods here now, right?

>>682443
I'd rather have strict moderation than inconsistent moderation any day.

And chances are good that they'll be easier to talk to than the current batch.

>>682435
Making new boards doesn't mean things will get better. Just look at /asp/ and /his/.

We have absolute piss poor moderation, and it's been getting worse since moot left. The mods are destorying this site and everyone knows it. You make another board now it's just going to get infested with shitposters because the mods are too lazy to moderate the board.

>Who gets to be a new mod?
Anyone who cares about 4chan.

>Where do they come from?
The internet. As long as they have used this site for 6+ years or more they qualify

>What are the qualifications necessary to apply?
Someone who loves their home boards hobby and actually cares about the board, preferably someone 21 or older, and someone knows knows about IRC, computers, running things and is competent in their job. Must prove they are not newfags either.

>You hate all the janitors too, so it can't be any of them.
They don't even train the janitors we got. Seriously they actually stopped training them because were that lazy

>>682443
Better than what we got now. I'll take them in a heartbeat

>>682445
>And chances are good that they'll be easier to talk to than the current batch.
I don't agree and question whatever made you think that.

>>682447
How so?

>>682446
>Anyone who cares about 4chan.
Vague.

>The internet. As long as they have used this site for 6+ years or more they qualify
Vague.

>Someone who loves their home boards hobby and actually cares about the board,
Vague.

Please write up an actual proposal with solid, concrete guidelines. And then pass it around to see if you can get a consensus of opinions. Until then, this shit is honestly pretty useless.

>>682448
Because they actually listen to Hiro?

>>682449
Either you're a fucking idiot or a shitposter. Where have you been these last few days?

File: cockmongler.jpg (81KB, 600x791px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 600x791px

Huh, Hiro was absent today, I though he would at least reply today to keep in contact. Maybe because it was Sunday he was doing something with family.

Last post by him on /qa/ is here http://desuarchive.org/qa/thread/675371/#678852

>>682283
It's all me desu senpai.

>>682459
STOP FUCKING MAKING THEM

File: 20160919_005423.png (309KB, 1440x1464px) Image search: [Google]

309KB, 1440x1464px

Can someone send this to him on behalf of /pol/? Thanks >>682463

>>682478

also made a /pol/ metathread here

>>>/pol/89439744

>>682459

the /a/ meta thread turned to literal shit thanks to your constant stream of them.

stop making them

>>682459
>Huh, Hiro was absent today, I though he would at least reply today to keep in contact.
He's not coming back for another 3 months, he doesn't care.

fuck you g00k dont shit up the site you fucking sellout faggot

File: rezero.jpg (42KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 600x338px

>>682208
New Rules (See >>/a/147386171):
1. /a/ won't be split into /a/ and /ma/ nor will it merge with any other board.
2. LNs and gookshit are allowed on /a/.
3. Underage Bait like lol, kys, cuck and so on will result in a ban.
4. Board Based Mods have to be introduced.

File: 1474265732642.png (224KB, 933x1166px) Image search: [Google]

224KB, 933x1166px

>>682603
>1. /a/ won't be split into /a/ and /ma/ nor will it merge with any other board.
This is outdated.

>>682640
You can try forcing your reddit idea, but we already decided that it won't happen.

>>682640
This picture looks like nipples touching.

>>682644
>we

>>682646
200+ Votes against 30 is pretty clear.

>>682650
>straw poll
>while america is asleep

>>682652
Nice strawman

File: 0.jpg (18KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 600x450px

>>682644
>>682650
Ok this is my first post in this thread, but I just had to point out how funny this is

>Muh votes say your reddit idea is bad!

>>682655
>Let's ignore everyone else's opinion and just take mine, we need a r/manga here
Kill yourself

>>682660
Like I said that was my first post in this thread.

Can I assume every post you've made in this thread is based on equally poor reading comprehension or what?

and what the fuck are you even talking about with all this reddit shit out of nowhere? It doesn't make any sense. You honestly sound like a fucking idiot if you think reddit is somehow linked to the topic of manga in general just because they have a board for it. Wanting a board for manga has absolutely nothing to do with that site whatsoever.

How do you even know they have a manga board anyway unless you go there, and why are you so concerned with them?

>>682665
Because you're forcing your reddit agenda on /a/ and we told you that we don't want that, shitposter.

>>682667
You're some next level retard

>>682665
how many threads do you plan on making?

>>682670
Nah, you're just stupid.

>>682667
pretty paranoid m8

>>682603
>gookshit are allowed
Stop posting old shit and lies.

>>682682
>>682683
Kill yourself. Results are results.

>>682690
>strawpoll results are results
>strawpoll representing the entirety of /a/

nice fucking joke

>>682694
>thinking your opinion is worth more than that of at the least 200 people
Nah

File: blacked.jpg (60KB, 854x481px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 854x481px

>>682696
>200 people represent the majority of /a/

nice fucking joke

>>682449
The old goons and the new hotpockets have one thing in common: moderation is based primarily on personal interest and feelings. The global and board rules may as well be irrelevant for the most part.

>>682701
>The global and board rules may as well be irrelevant for the most part.
Where do you people get this shit? That's obviously not the case. All that one has to do to prove you wrong is break a rule.

>>682707
>Where do you people get this shit?
By being here for more than the past fucking decade.
>All that one has to do to prove you wrong is break a rule.
Only if the mod cares.

>>682701
>moderation is based primarily on personal interest and feelings.
I think it's a mix of that, and there not being enough mods to keep up with the shitposting.

>>682711
>By being here for more than the past fucking decade
So what. There are more people who have been here for more than a decade than you think.
>Only if the mod cares
It all gets deleted or removed eventually. You act like mods are derelict in their duties and that's not the case.

>>682717
>and there not being enough mods to keep up with the shitposting
Hence prioritising feels over reals, because it's a lot easier to do. If there were an adequate amount of moderators, if would be harder for this culture of us vs. them mentality which has existed since day one.

>>682719
>So what.
So I know what I'm fucking on about.
>There are more people who have been here for more than a decade than you think.
Relevance? Do they disagree?
>It all gets deleted or removed eventually.
No it fucking doesn't, that's the point.

>You act like mods are derelict in their duties
They fucking do. Are you taking the piss?
You're either shitposting or are part of moderation.

>>682723
>So I know what I'm fucking on about.
It''s funny to me that I've been here just as long as you and not once have I seen mods treat the rules like they are irrelevant.
>Relevance?
My opinion is as relevant as your opinion, having been here for "so long", right?
>NO it fucking doesn't.
Yes it fucking does.
>They fucking do
Jesus Christ you're a sperglord.
>You're either shitposting or part of the moderation
I'm not doing either, but on the other side of the coin, you're definitely freaking out over nothing, or worse, total bullshit. Most people don't think mods are all that bad and you're acting like they committed war crimes or something.

remember to vote

http://www.strawpoll.me/11257671
http://www.strawpoll.me/11257671
http://www.strawpoll.me/11257671
http://www.strawpoll.me/11257671

>>682727
>It''s funny to me that I've been here just as long as you and not once have I seen mods treat the rules like they are irrelevant.
Have you been posting with your eyes fucking closed?
>My opinion is as relevant as your opinion
Clearly fucking not.
>Jesus Christ you're a sperglord.
Sure thing.
>I'm not doing either, but on the other side of the coin, you're definitely freaking out over nothing, or worse, total bullshit.
Yeah, no; no one fucking buys this.

>Most people don't think mods are all that bad and you're acting like they committed war crimes or something.
Fuck off back to IRC.

>>682731
>Have you been posting with your eyes fucking closed?
I was going to ask the same of you.
>Clearly fucking not.
And why is that exactly? Oh, that's right, I'm not a paranoid sperglord like you are.
>Sure thing.
Yep.
>Yeah, no; no one fucking buys this
You wouldn't know the opinion of "everyone" even if you did 40 different strawpolls.
>Fuck off back to IRC
I haven't been on IRC since 1999. Too full of cops and feds imo.

File: 1383432817587.jpg (912KB, 3756x2704px) Image search: [Google]

912KB, 3756x2704px

>>682719
>You act like mods are derelict in their duties and that's not the case.

>>682736
Cry more because your shitty thread got deleted, faggot.

File: 1386742734378.jpg (104KB, 682x1023px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 682x1023px

>>682737
>still keeping up the act

>>682730
You forgot to say this is for /a/. Not all boards have retarded children making threads.

File: 636093566589885222-AP-RUSSIA-SNOWDEN-71306234[1].jpg (36KB, 534x712px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 534x712px

>>682738
>he thinks it's a act and not reality

File: 1385250147288.jpg (63KB, 1338x716px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 1338x716px

>>682740
>admitting to modfaggotry

>>682446
I'd qualify but I know I'd just abuse the power for shit I find funny.

File: mqen0j9tuurfg4dbtkc8[1].jpg (47KB, 652x365px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 652x365px

>>682741
>he thinks I'm a mod
Truly your paranoia knows no bounds.

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:43:36 Post No.682745
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:43:36 Post No.682745 [Report]

First of all, I didn't ask to get feedback.
If there is consensus to change something,
I would like to know.

>>682723
I mean, I can understand why they might moderate where they know how to moderate, that would help explain why some threads are better than others. but then there are threads (even on popular boards like /v/) that have posts that are very obviously breaking multiple rules and those threads will have posts that stay up for many hours.

I'm convinced that the mods aren't the best, and I'm sure they would agree themselves. But the userbase is obviously at fault as well. I'm almost certain that most people don't report posts simply because they are so used to every other website where moderation does almost all the work for them.

The users on 4chan complain about moderation so much not just because there are somewhat unresponsive mods, but also because they are so damn used to being babysatby moderation on every other website.


If it's against the rules, and you want it gone, you MUST report it. Stop being lazy.

>>682745
Yes. For /a/

>>682255
>>682261

Everyone agrees with this. Thank you Hiro.

>>682745
As long as you realize that the opinions of 50-200 people in a strawpoll don't represent the thousands of people who post on most boards, then I personally don't care what you do.

Honestly, sometimes I wish you would just do something major that is wacky and random and funny, and then tell everyone here to enjoy it or get out.

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:46:20 Post No.682749
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:46:20 Post No.682749 [Report]

I'm wondering if quest threads are allowed on /tg/.
what happens on /qst/?

>>682745
There is none for /a/.

>>682745
/r9k/ all wanted
increase file size to 3MB
ban generals
more active moderation
>>>/r9k/31472016

>>682745
There is a consensus, ban generals on /a/, turn back on visible sage and add the text boards back.

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:47:20 Post No.682753
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:47:20 Post No.682753 [Report]

>>682747
Where do I find the consensus on the meta thread on /a/?

>>682745
Hello, Hiro-san.
Please ban the meta threads, they're shitposting grounds at this point.

>>682751
I'm pretty sure the entire website wants that.

>>682745
We don't want any changes on /a/

>>682749
Presumably it gets destroyed or stays around as an alternative to those who want the extra features. Whether or not it should have been allowed in the first place is a matter of contention (most /qst/ users seem to say no)

Here is /tg/'s consensus:
>>>/tg/49349218

>>682745
>>682753

>>682603
Here you go.

>>682753
>>>/a/147326985

>>682753
You won't find that, because we are far gone past that and are shitposting.

>>682754
Ban them everywhere else but here you mean, right?

>>682753
>>>/a/147425437
/a/ wanted a test board /ma/ for manga.

>>682745
Just a heads up, Hiro.

When people from any board say they reached a consensus. Almost always, they actually haven't.
Don't listen to these idiots.

>>682753
>>147425437

ignore "gookshit should be allowed" it's shouldn't be,

the rest of op is fne

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:48:53 Post No.682765
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:48:53 Post No.682765 [Report]

>>682748
Don't you think there would be a great idea which most of people agree?

>>682753
/a/ does not want any changes except that one person
Please ignore him

>>682762
No, we didn't, samefag.

>>682753
Hiro this >>682758 is not our consensus. There is a spammer lying, please don't listen to him and look at the thread.

>>682758
Fuck off.

>>682762
You too as well, especially you. No one agrees with this AND never have to the point moot rejected it years ago.

>>682761
Sorry I wasnt being clear.
Yeah, I meant every board but here, this place is a shithole, anyway.

>>682753
There is no /a/ consensus on anything. There are some popular opinions, but all of them are controversial. The most popular one is to ban generals, and even that is highly controversial and would make a lot of people mad.

>>682745
Ban generals and spoonfeeders boss, anyone who says otherwise are newfags who know nothing about /a/'s board culture.

>>682762
No we DO NOT

>>682765
do not trust a strawpoll,

it's fucking stupid and it can easily be manipulated

>>682765
Maybe one or two ideas that EVERYONE can agree on.

I think it's a little bit sad, but it doesn't seem like there are that many things everyone can agree on around here.

>>682768
You're the one lying.

>>682765
No. What's best is what's best for the community and overall fun and atmosphere. Numbers mean nothing because board raiding, poll rigging and samefagging is our oldest and favourite game.

>>682765
/a/ does not want any gook(korean) or chink(chinese) comics on /a/. Gook and chink shit should not be allowed on /a/

>>682762
No we don't faggot.

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:51:01 Post No.682780
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:51:01 Post No.682780 [Report]

>>682751
>ban generals
>more active moderation
how to ban generals?
Why don't you volunteer next time?

>increase file size to 3MB
What do you want to upload?

>>682762
HIRO DO NOT LISTEN TO THIS FAGGOT, MOST OF THE THREAD DISAGREE WITH /ma/ BEING MADE.

WE DO NOT WANT /ma/

>>682753
HIRO PLEASE LOOK AT THIS >>>/a/147330167
Please consider this.

File: kanbaru-consider.jpg (35KB, 452x526px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 452x526px

>>682753
There was no consensus. Don't believe their lies.
Enforce the existent rules and get rid of generals.
DON'T make more boards.

>>682745
You will never get "consensus" on these boards, friend. We're not very good at it.

Hiro, stop trying to get everyone to make the decisions.

It's your website.

You know what you're doing.

You decide.

>>682776
>keep spamming his shitty thread on /a/
Fuck off cockroach. As expected of gook

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:51:48 Post No.682786
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:51:48 Post No.682786 [Report]

>>682757
I left my question.

>>682749

>>682753
For years anons on /a/ have been wanting general threads to be removed.

>>682771
>and even that is highly controversial and would make a lot of people mad.
Yes, the minority of anons who linger in those threads. The rest of the board wants them gone.

>>682780
>What do you want to upload?
Virtual linux servers hidden in .jpgs :)

Make /ma/ and /gook/

>>682753
There is none. Please do not change anything in /a/

>>682753
There is none. Is some faggot who is trying to make the changes they want. Only thing even close to a consensus is the curb on generals and even then there are people against it.

>>682780
HIRO DON'T LISTEN TO HIM
It's >>682255

>>682784
Hiro owns the site, not us or the community.

>>682784
I second this. I wish you would just take decisive action like a benevolent father figure.

>>682780
You ban them by banning the people who make them and delete them.
>Why don't you volunteer next time?
I did but you never got back to me, all I said I wanted to do was enforce the rules more promptly.
>What do you want to upload?
Images. /r9k/ 2MB upload is lower than other boards like /a/ and it's frustrating.

>>682780
>How to ban generals?
Just nuke this board, snort cocaine from a prostitute's ass and give up forever.
Everyone go home.

>>682789
FUCK OFF

WE DO NOT WANT /ma/

>>682780
Hiroyuki, these korean and chinese are always spamming their threads on /a/ even though no one want their stuff on /a/

>>682785
I made like two threads of 20, but nice try.

>>682789
The answer for a manga board has always been no, and it will always be no.

>>682749
Quest threads were a pain on /tg/ and I am happy that they have their own board.

On /qst/ they just to text roleplaying. The people who use that board seem to like it.

The people who use /tg/ seem to like the /qst/ posters being away from their board.

It's good. Don't change it.

>>682780
hiroyuki can we stop making meta threads on /a/ there has been zero discussion and hardly a consensus has been made.

/a/ doesn't want changes

>>682800
No one give a shit about your samefagging. Kill yourself parasite. Gook and chink are the parasite of /a/ anime & manga

>Everybody arguing about what their board's consensus
Jesus this was a mistake.

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:54:34 Post No.682808
[Report]

hiroyuki ## Admin 2016-09-19 11:54:34 Post No.682808 [Report]

>>682784
While taking, you guys write reasons.
I want to know reasons.

I need reasons to decide.

>>682767
>>682769
>>682773
>>682779
>>682781
Hiro this are crossboarding trolls. Please just read the thread you will see the desire for a >>682640
>/ma
manga test board and well reasoned arguments backing it up.
See this diagram for an example
https://i.4cdn.org/qa/1474279912543.png

>>682797
Nuking this board would just cause the meta threads to be on every other board.

>>682789
No one wants /ma/ you filthy nigger.

>>682804
and we don't want /ma/ either,

fuck off

>>682749
Same as what happened before the mods moved quests to /qst/. Some people run on /qst/, some on /tg/.

File: mark my words.png (6KB, 590x109px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 590x109px

>>682787
>For years anons on /a/ have been wanting general threads to be removed.
For jap moot, mods intended to do it years ago but never got it for reference.

>>682809
So everyone except you is a troll? Fuck off.

>>682806
You should kill yourself instead.

>>682809
Stop lying, faggot.

>>682780
>how to ban generals?
Mod intervention and discouraging them when the discussion isn't on topic or meaningless. Ask the people who moderated /a/ between 2011 and 2013 on how they tried to remove generals since they have some experience in it.

>>682807
I don't know why you ever expected differently. This same thing happened the last time.

>>682753
A manga board would be nice.

Be careful. If you make it, there will be A LOT of shit-posters because other on /a/ don't like the idea.

Even though they will never use it.

Strange idiots....

>>682804
Yes we do.
We have wanted generals removed for years and it is the one thing consistently agreed upon in every single meta thread.

>>682809
FUCK OFF WE DO NOT WANT /ma/

ANIME AND MANGA HAS BEEN FINE FOR YEARS, STOP FORCING YOUR STUPID SHIT

>>682809
Kill yourself.

>>682809
The only crossboarding troll here IS YOU.

>>682809
Can you please just fuck off already? I know you think you can control the board, but you aren't. No one wants this, not even 7 years ago
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/31236541/

>>682820
FUCK OFF

>>682762
Yes, we did. And when we get one, please don't shit it up.

>>682816
Why should i kill myself, because there are lot of people doesn't want gook shit on /a/? gook and chink shit have no place in /a/

>>682820
HIRO DO NOT LISTEN, WE DON'T WANT A MANGA BOARD

>>682780
Don't listen to >>682799. Manhwa have always been posted on /a/. It's never been against the rules, and 99.9999% of /a/ has no problem with it.

>>682829
You should kill yourself for crying to me about things you and your poll decided.

>>682808
If you want reasons, you'll need to shift through the threads that occured on the day you asked for the threads. And then make another OFFICAL thread yourself on the board of question and let people duke it out in a proper thread before you can get a proper conclusion that won't destroy everything permanently.

>>682814
He got fired because of that crusade of his.

>>682808
Please look at this:
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/31236541/
We did not want a manga board 6 years ago, and we do not want one now.

>>682808
There are three types of manga when it comes to /a/.
1. Small set of manga that consistently get lots of posters, SnK, BNHA, etc.
2. Manga that can sustain threads every so often for chapter releases and similar.
3. Everything else.
Threads in tier 3 are basically a crap shoot if they will get posters and even then they won't survive long. Tier 2 threads can do okay depending.
Effectively manga discussion on /a/ ends up obeying pareto principle where vast majority of it is discussing the same popular manga ad nauseum. There's plenty of good threads that simply can't survive on /a/ because of the board speed and proportion of /a/ that is primarily interested in manga.

/a/ is not conducive to manga discussion and a slower board would likely work very well.
Consider the solution shown here https://i.4cdn.org/qa/1474279912543.png
This would allow for more manga discussion and less popular (but still good) manga.
It would also still allow for discussion of manga to occur in anime threads which are adaptions of said manga.

All it would take is a short trial run of a manga board /ma/ to see how it would play out. /a/ would not be harmed.
You may see lots of anons saying and yelling against this but why don't they provide any reasons? They have none.

>>682816
>no argument
>kill yourself
>everyone on /a/ hate his gook trash
Fuck off, braindead gook

>>682831
THERES NO MANHWA ON /a/ RIGHT NOW,

FUCK OFF

>>682808
Okay, here are reasons.

I want a manga board because /a/ moves too fast.

When see a manga thread, it's already in the archives.

Also, a manga forum would encourage more interest in manga.

In Japan, manga is more popular than anime.

It should have a board.

>>682820
>lets ruin /a/ with a split
Anime and manga are too intertwined to separate that easily. It would create more shitposting and decrease discussion quality for both mediums.

>>682834
He got fired because this was around the time moot destroyed most of the mods for no reason and he was past his boiling point.

>>682831
Fuck off faggot nigger, speak for yourself!

>>682838
>>682832

File: 99d4f33f.jpg (48KB, 349x336px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 349x336px

>>682753
>>682782
Personally I'd like an expansion of the options field for thread OPs. Like on Futaba the OP can put an option in to have IDs display for all posters.
But while I do not want IDs on /a/, some stuff off the top of my head that sounded good:
Anon - forces Anonymous in the thread.
Sage - puts the thread on autosage but gets rid of post timers.
ID - makes everyone have IDs (like I said not on /a/ though, but for other boards)
Kana - enables kana captchas in the thread.

>>682832
>you and your poll
What the fuck? are you retard?
>>682831
All of these gook thread got shitposting to dead and mods always deleted them

/a/ decides to merge with /jp/, hiro. Do it, fast.

>>682808
We do not want a manga board. We usually discuss the manga and anime together, a separate board would just split communication. There are very few people who think that their unpopular manga will get popular on a new board, but they are wrong.

>>682837
I know Hiro can speak English really well, but dude, simplify.

>>682837
>All it would take is a short trial run of a manga board /ma/ to see how it would play out.
There is no such thing as a trial board and sure as hell no such thing as a trial split. A trial split is permanently damaging to a board and will forever leave a scar on /a/ to cater to a very small minority of people who don't actually use the board.

>>682808
/a/ has a problem with shitposting.
Everyone looks at shitposting and thinks 'it's fine'.
If you bring back 'sage' visible it makes people think 'did I make a bad post?'
If you make the threads 'sage' by default like in 2ch then it means 'my post is only my opinion so the thread will not be bumped'
If the person thinks it's an important post it writes 'age' and the thread is bumped.
But if you write 'age' in a shitpost, then it means you did it on purpose. Your post is deleted.
This will change how /a/ sees shitposts. Please test it in /a/ for a week.

>>682831
Chink and koreanshit are had always been deleted on /a/ dumb nigger.

>>682845
Let me say it again, are you retard? the only one who made this poll is you

>>682786
If the board is not deleted perhaps listen to /qst/ for what happens to it afterwards.

Their discussion thread >>>/qst/570135 here is quite big, but the general consensus with /qst/ from the /qst/ discussion thread was:

>the board is unnecessary
>ID's for anyone but OP are not useful
>reintegration with other board or boards preferable

This is summary though. There are other delicate opinions regarding what content the board must have, but it is significantly more divisive than these.

To be honest they may like you posting there again.

>>682749
It is too late.

People on /tg/ who don't like things will bother the mods until they get their way. This is how /qst/ was made and why mods put quests there. Because a small number of people whined and lied to the mods. The mods did what they said to do. Now no matter what, people who whine and cry to the mods will get things banned all the time.

This is how it will be from now on. the mods will do whatever makes the crying people happy.

>>682847
>>682854
>makes poll
>puts LN and gookshit together
>cries when it actually becomes a thing and people tell Hiro
Fucktard, try harder

>>682842
This doesn't happen between /m/ and /a/ so it wouldn't happen between /a/ and a manga board.

>>682808
the general consensus for the meta threads on /a/ that we don't want a manga board.

Okay here's how you do it Hiro.

Never ask any board for a consensus opinion.
Just keep things as is and let the idiotic userbase handle their own garbage. But if the mods or you yourself, as evidenced by the 404 page drama recently, cause outrage only then will you need to have a talk with the board spited.

Literally don't touch anything. Literally don't listen to anybody. If there's any subconscious consensus that always exists in the back of everybody's heads, is that change will always cause trouble.

This place ain't a democracy.

>>682831
>and 99.9999% of /a/ has no problem with it
>99.9999%
>when everyone in these shit poll thread saying they doesn't want any gook shit on /a/

He wants reasons, faggots, not constant bickering and arguments over who represents what board.

>>682765
You should set up polls on the site itself so you can grab the attention of the entire userbase.
Board specific of course.

>>682858
/m/ is something different, stop pretending to be retarded.

>>682811
>filthy nigger

Hiro, anyone who says things like this you can ignore.

File: 1469813356368.png (75KB, 325x244px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 325x244px

>>682808

Hiro did you know that strawpolls can be manipulated by proxies?

do not trust that shit at all

>>682857
The fuck are you even talking about? you know fake poll is a thing don't you?

>>682808
Hi Hiro, I propose a test of a manga board.
There is much more manga than anime in the world and yet /a/ discuss only a small fraction of manga most of which is very popular series in WSJ and similar. Manga discussion accounts for only a fraction of the discussion on /a/.
Meanwhile /a/ is one of the faster boards on 4chan this makes it very difficult to discuss these less than popular manga that are still quite good, I'd call them hidden gems.

A slower board is far more suitable to the level of manga interest on 4chan and would allow for higher quality discussion and more manga to be discusses.
As it stands now manga is stuck int he shadow of anime on /a/ and it will never flourish as it could and should.
I hope you'll consider at least a test board for manga. I think it could work very well.

Cheers.

>>682860
While I personally preferred moots hand off approach, there is some shit that needs to actually be fixed.

>>682865
Fuck off nigger

>>682864
How is it so different?

>>682808
Please remove generals from /a/. Thinks like draw thread or learn japanese thread have nothing to do with anime or manga.

>>682749
It dies and gets deleted as it deserves and we go back to the perfectly functional system we had before. It was a terrible idea concocted by a moron and put together by an idiot.

>>682865
NIGGER

>>682808
hiro the general consensus is that we do not want a manga board,

it's fucking stupid

>>682857
>that gook who keep saying his gook shit is /a/ related despite /a/ always shit on it and mods always deleted gook thread
>>682808
Korean are disgusting, Hiroyuki

>>682842
/a/ will not be ruined if manga gets its own board.

Anime is too popular for that.

>>682843
>for no reason
I have no reaction images because this is a brand new computer, but let me assure you that I am laughing derisively at a relatively high volume.

>>682874
Call me nigga one more time, I dare you. I double dare you.

File: manhwa.jpg (45KB, 338x500px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 338x500px

>>682839
>>682844
>>682847
>>682853
>>682861
Fuck off, newfaggots. Manhwa has ALWAYS been discussed and NEVER has been deleted.

>>682871
/m/ was made because it was stupid popular and made posting about other things on /a/. It wasn't a board split, it was made to be a partner to /a/ to help the board. The shit can go on both boards. On-top of that, /m/ is fucking horrible, full of shitposting and actual elitsts arseholes. A board split a a /m/ style /ma/ WILL NOT WORK IN AND FORM.

>>682876
>projecting

>>682780
>how to ban generals?
Mod intervention.
>Why don't you volunteer next time?
Not the person you were replying to obviously, but I have been applying every Janny drive since 2011 and never got a reply.

In general it seems nearly impossible to get hired for thi compared to how many Janitors and mods quit per year.

Who looks at applications, Hiro? How long have they been doing this?

>>682875
No there is not a consensus. And frankly, any time someone who is for a manga board posts, it's met with swearing and childish name-calling and not actual counter-arguments.

Get a manga subforum, please Hiro.

>>682808
Hiro, a small and sensible request for the entire website:
Please get the mods and janitors to better enforce the rules. Especially Global Rules 3 and 6.

>>682808
Hiro please consider a manga board.
I am somewhat biased as I much prefer manga to anime, but as /a/ is currently manga discussion is all but impossible with he exception of the very popular series. Manga readers on 4chan would be very happy with a manga board.

The 'N word' should be banned only underage kids use that word.

>>682880
NO IT HASN'T YOU FUCKING LIAR

>>682880
See >>677174

Please introduce a board for each anime and manga series, Hiro!

>>682880
Literally the same gook
>>147425791

>>682886
fuck off,

most of the threads posted on /a/ says that we do not want a manga board.

>>682892
Oh you!

>>682888
>but as /a/ is currently manga discussion is all but impossible with he exception of the very popular series
This is not true at all. It's just that no-one wants to discuss your manga.

>>682880
I've had a Freezing thread deleted once.

>>682881
Are you kidding me?
/m/ is a lot better than /a/.

>>682881
It's because mecha is a genre of anime.

Manga and anime are just two mediums to tell stories. There's nothing superior or inferior about either.

This is why i think a manga subforum would work.

It would be just like /a/ but slower and only about stuff you read.

>>682858
It doesn't because they are quite different since one is a genre type and the other is a medium. Both mecha manga and anime can be taken to /m/. With a manga board made people would push out any discussion of manga on /a/ and any anime discussion on the manga board causing more shitposting over when people bring it up in a thread. Even Pokemon threads have people trying to remove the discussion from /a/ back to /vp/ as another example.

>>682877
Any reduction of quality is on the road to ruin even if the board would survive.

>>682808
I would like a board focused on manga because anime is much more popular in America so it drowns discussion of manga on 4chan.
Thanks!

>>682780
>how to ban generals?
Buy banning them? Simple as that. Mods ban people who make them or try to make threads similar to them and users tell people who make threads of their kind to fuck off. Increase education.

>Why don't you volunteer next time?
Yea, I bloody wish. That's never happening, I've tried tons of times and damn well know I'm knowledgeable and care. Also, doesn't that shit require you to provide personal real life information now? Fuck that.

get fucked, you fucking pathetic gook
>>>/a/thread/147425437#p147425791

>>682808
1. DO NOT SPLIT /a/ OR MAKE A MANGA BOARD
Reason: A manga board would be slow and would quickly die off. There would be no discussion on it. At the same time, it would take manga threads from /a/, making it harder to discuss manga there. In short, a manga board would kill manga discussion.

2. DO NOT LISTEN TO THESE IDIOTS THAT ARE CALLING FOR BANS ON MANHWA
Reason: Manhwa has always been discussed on /a/. There has never been a change of policy on this. The people who are against it are a vocal minority of shitposters who just like spamming the word

>gook

over and over. /a/ has always enjoyed Korean comics and has never had a problem with it.

>>682880
Ignore this liar, you can check the archives as proof Hiro.

Why does /b/ still exist?

>>682894
>fuck off
>no actual counter-argument

Way to prove my point, chief.

>>682880
This filthy gook is in /a/ thread too, probably OP
>>>/a/147425437

>>682899
>subforum
This poster is clearly very new here and does not understand this website.

>>682905
Fuck off lying spammer.

>>682907
Containment board.

Deleting them is a bad idea. Killing /new/ and /r9k/ off that one time fucked the site.

>>682899
>subforum
Can you just fuck off from 4chan? Why are you trying to dictate a website you obviously don't even use. Great job showing how the people who want /ma/ don't even fucking use /a/ or 4chan.

>>682898
Yea, no. Trying to talk about mecha on /a/ can be hard sometimes because /m/ tards bring their stupid drama to /a/ as well.

>>682897
Not because it was manhwa.

>>682907
honeypot for outsiders

>>682899
>subforum

>>682896
How would we know when it gets pushed off to the archives by your shitty waifu threads?

/a/ wants to have a collaboration with r/manga, please!

FOR FUCK'S SAKE HIRO STOP ASKING PEOPLE FOR THEIR OPINION
THERE WILL NEVER BE A CONSENSUS EVER

JUST DO YOUR OWN SHIT


Actually. One suggestion is to have post IDs here in /qa/ so that samefagging is less prevalent.

>>682808
Please reinstate the 48hour autosage rule on /news/ (like it says in the sticky) so that the stories on page 1 will all be current again.

I'm sure you had good reasons for temporarily getting rid of it but it's hurting the board when /pol/ can bump 2 month old racebait news on there.

>>682808
Create a /as/ (Asian) and put all mangwa shit there

>>682905
>Reason: Manhwa has always been discussed on /a/. There has never been a change of policy on this
What policy? can you show me this policy you keep talking about?

/a/ - Anime & Manga
All images and resulting discussion should pertain to anime or manga.

>>682909
>probably
He's literally the only person who wants gook in /a/ so he's obviously the OP.

There are only very few changes of /a/ that I could really support:
Make sage visible again.
Reduce bump limit (drastically).
Make bumps require a minimum of symbols written in the post body.

Additionally one could experiment with a complicated system of reducing bump limit to 50, but changing the rules so that sage posts don't count towards that limit anymore. Threads go on autosage after 24 hours. I don't know what that would mean for posting habits though. It would make regular threads with several thousand replies possible so long as no one bumps by accident. It would also enable people to bump threads to a quick death.

>>682749
tg doesn't change much.

qst gets re-evaluated for what features it should actually have, with the mods actually discussing with the people who would go there, instead of the people who hate quests.

>>682918
Add flags as well so you can ignore canadians and australians while you are at it.

>>682808
Like others in the thread I would like a manga board Hiro.
If you look at /m/ - mecha as an example you will find it often has higher quality posts and discussion when compared to /a/ it is also a slower board.
Much like /m/ a manga board could do very well with a slower post rate more inline with the number of people interested in it.
I hope I get to see it!

>>682916
Wait. You know that /ma/ would not be just a few generals, right?

Can't dragonball get its own board already like Pokemon has /vp/?

>>682905
Even when you keep spamming these shitty poll thread, everyone /a/ will against your shitty gook trash,get fucked pathetic gook

>>682841
>>682886
>>682899
>forum
Can you just fuck off already? Go back to whatever shitty website it is you came from and stop trying to destroy /a/.

>>682923
>Reduce bump limit
why

>>682926
Stop spamming you faggot, no one wants a manga thread

>>682926
Why do you reply to Hiro several times with this /ma/ bullshit?

Ban all Spacebattles.com posters on the site permanently (or at least keep them banned for 2 hours since their last visit to Spacebattles.com)
t. /tg/

>>682905
>/a/ anime & manga
Where the fuck is gook shit in this?

>>682931
Because short threads are better than long ones.
Most long threads enter a period of NOTHING before (sometimes) a new discussion arises. Why?
You could just have a short thread, and then ANOTHER short thread.

File: dumb tripnigger.png (25KB, 1526x150px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 1526x150px

>>682927
The dumb tripnigger already proved you wrong.

>>682905
> A manga board would be slow
Yes, that's the point.
>and would quickly die off
Japan's not going to stop making manga anytime soon, so no.
>it would take manga threads from /a/, making it harder to discuss manga there
Yes, because we would be discussing it on a manga board. You are free to discuss anime as usual though.
>In short, a manga board would kill manga discussion.
... do you even think about things before you post them? A manga board would make manga discussion thrive because it has its own dedated board.

>>682916
How many times do people have to explain this? /a/ isn't a "fast" board. This isn't /v/ or /pol/ where threads who don't get replies fall off the board in 30 mins or less. Threads on /a/ survive for hours after reach bump limit, so clearly the problem is people just don't want to talk about manga on /a/.

>>682931
There's a lot of people who for some reason believe that their threads "fail" unless they reach the bump limit so they keep bumping them and even after all the discussion has long since been exhausted and everyone but them left the thread.

Hiro here's a suggestion,

make a board for gook shit and call it /gook/

Then the gook spammer can fuck off and we can all be happy,

thoughts?

>>682808
Here is an example of a few general threads on /a/ which anons have wanted removed for a while now, years infact.
I will quote the post: >>>/a/147328798
1. Japanese learning general to either /jp/ or /int/
2. Buyfag general to /toy/.
3. Drawfag general to /ic/.
4. Exhentai general to one of the handful of porn boards.
5. Image dump threads to either /c/ or outright delete them.
6. Seiyuu 3DPD worship threads to /jp/.

1/2

1. The Japanese learning general, found here:
>>>/a/147406689
does not belong on /a/ as it is not about the discussion of anime and/or manga. The primary form of entertainment they discuss is Visual Novels/ エロゲ and the focus on the thread is language learning. Their interests are suited to the /jp/ board, while the topic itself is related to the international board, /int/. They also have a website of their own which they post in every thread and essentially exist simple as a means to promote their website.

2. The toy buying general, found here:
>>>/a/147401547
is a general thread which is about the discussion of buying mechanise, posting photos of their toys and discussing shipping costs. They also have their own website and guides. The thread is tangential to /a/ at best, though it acts more like a chatroom.

3. The drawfag general, found here:
>>>/a/147296917
to put it simply, belongs on the board that is dedicated to artists to post and discuss their artwork, which is /ic/. On /a/ they have created a circlejerk community mentality and the resident artists often use the thread as a means to promote their work and encourage anons to buy their work. This is essentially a form of undermining the advertisement policy on 4chan.

>>682936
Confirmed for not watching popular seasonal anime.

>>682940
Generals need to die.

>>682926
>>682916
>>682899
>>682888
>>682886
>>682868
>>682841
These were all written by the same poster. He has some obsession with creating a manga board, even though no-one else wants that.

>>682941
dats raciss

File: 1448959930543.png (155KB, 240x1904px) Image search: [Google]

155KB, 240x1904px

>>682808
Manga board please.
/a/ - Anime & Manga does not live up to its name because anime is much much more popular on /a/.
Manga gets drowned out by all the anime! I personally like manga very much and it's frustrating not being able to discuss it very well on /a/. I think a manga board could work.

>>682939
>/a/ isn't a "fast" board
Yes it is. I'm sure Hiro has better stats so why try and lie to him?

>>682921
Yes, you fucking retard. Mods have said before that manhwa is allowed on /a/. I'm not going to dig through my image folder to find it, but it's been documented.

>>682905
You're the one who keep spamming, disgusting zipperhead sub human

>>682913
I use the word subforum because of force of habit. I've been on the internet for 2 decades now. A difference in vernacular doesn't actually counter any of my points though, kiddo.

>>682923
>Threads go on autosage after 24 hours.
This is a good idea but I'd make it so that if there was a sudden spike of posts from different countries, the autosage would be revoked. In case a thread flies under the radar until it's too late.

File: 1451074013469.png (37KB, 596x892px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 596x892px

Can we stop replying to the stupid ESL who doesn't even use the website and just wants to destroy /a/ and talk about actual issues, like generals.

>>682808
>>682942
2/2

4. This is a general dedicated to the pornographic comic website, exhentai, which is found here:
>>>/a/147420213
It exists solely as a platform to post links to pornographic content and, as a group, masturbate together. There already exists multiple boards for drawn pornography, hence they should be moved to one of those as opposed to being a literal circlejerk, by proxy, as a consistent thread on /a/.

5. Image dump threads as usually threads which start off by the OP posting a lewd image along with some sort of set phrase, to encourage image dumps. Here are some examples:
>>>/a/147412940
>>>/a/147421780
>>>/a/147422800
These are commonly referred to as "template threads", due to their lazy and often copy/pasted format. They are often nothing but an excuse to dump images. There are already boards for image dumps, such as /c/.

6. 声優 threads, to put it simply, belong on /jp/. Here is an example:
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/147144473/#147144473
They are distinctively 3DPD discussions with are almost always nothing but a group of obsessed anons talking about their favourite voice actors. That's fine, but that's what /jp/ is for. They even have these threads on /jp/, meaning there is no reason to have them on /a/. /a/ is for 2D, not 3DPD.

>>682930
Holy shit, stop being triggered by shit that doesn't matter.

>>682943
I do watch seasonal anime, but I will freely admit that I avoid fast threads. So there is definitely a side of /a/ that I am missing.

>>682808
Do not split manga from /a/. Given the inherent relation between the two media, it's pointless to split them. Instead, I suggest allowing LN content on /a/, as well as maybe allowing chinese/korean stuff given that there is nowhere on the site to discuss it.

Hiro, please. It keeps happening. Please make it stop.

>>682942
>>682952
Content can go on more than one board, you know.

>>682947
>some random mods from 2012 answer the question when some gook ask him
>gook shit still got deleted by mods
Yeah, fuck you pathetic policy you fucking filthy gook

>>682934
Do the same with 1d4chan.

>>682938
>Yes, that's the point.
No, it isn't. Slow boards die.

>Japan's not going to stop making manga anytime soon, so no.
They still make books, but /lit/ is dead.

>Yes, because we would be discussing it on a manga board. You are free to discuss anime as usual though.
No, it would kill manga discussion on /a/. People would try to go to /ma/, but not be able to make successful threads there.

>... do you even think about things before you post them? A manga board would make manga discussion thrive because it has its own dedated board.
Just like /lit/ has thriving literature discussion?

Fuck off. A manga board is cancer and would kill manga discussion.

>>682934
This would be awesome.
It would also remove 80% of /tg/'s posters at this point.

>>682957
That which doesn't belong on /a/ doesn't belong on /a/.

>>682942
>quoting your own posts in the meta thread
Fuck off. There is no consensus about the generals so stop lying to hiro about it.

>>682947
Look at the time and date, newfag.

>>682946
Again. Threads dont simply "fall off and disappear". It takes hours, hours during which people can bump the thread, start discussions, shitpost, do whatever they want in the thread. Threads fall off the board due to a lack of interest or discussion material, not speed

>>682749
It would be deleted. The move there was forced and most /qst/ users find it lacking. If not deleted then fixed according to what has been suggested in their meta thread.

>>682939
How many times must you be told that /a/ is only out-paced by /v/, /pol/ and /b/ and it basically the reason why 4chan exists in the first place on account of 14 year old moot wanted to talk anime with a bunch of Something Awful goons.

>>682958
>>gook shit still got deleted by mods
Never happened. Never will.

Manhwa is /a/. Deal with it.

>>682949
A "force of habit" isn't going to fucking make you use incorrect terminology or are you going to call them subs now as well?

You also being on the internet for 2 decades doesn't mean you've been on 4chan for longer than a year, little kiddie.

>>682808
I'll echoe the call for a manga board. I don't want to repeat what others have said so I'll keep it short.
Here is an example of a frustrated manga fan because modern /a/ is not good for manga.
>>>/a/147427649

>>682960
>No, it isn't. Slow boards die.
Get out and see other boards besides /a/ and /v/ anon.
There are plenty of great slower boards like /out/.
Almost all boards on 4chan are slower than /a/.

We need IDs on /qa/ to stop the samefag spam.

>>682947
This gook is literally braindead

>>682963
See >>682808
>While taking, you guys write reasons.
>I want to know reasons.
>I need reasons to decide.

That was exactly what Hiro asked for. Do you have any actual response or is this just another kneejerk from a generalfag afraid of losing his safe space? /a/ has wanted generals removed, for years.

>>682971
This isn't /q/.

>>682808
1. Don't split /a/ into any more boards, it would destroy our board culture. Only a few persons want a separate manga board.
2. Many want general threads banned on /a/ because they are more like chatrooms than normal threads.

>>682971
For once, anon, you're brilliant.

If everyone responds to this with yes, we can end samefagging on /qa/!

The best consensus I can give you Hiro is that nobody actually wants you to listen to them.

That being said, I suggest that you delete /qa/. Or at least add IDs to this place.

>>682962
More like needlessly rulefagging is retarded. There is nothing wrong with loosely related content as long as it doesn't consume the board like say /v/. It is pointless rulefagging and missing the point of this place being free and unrestricted.

>>682968
Keep trying, you're the only gook here

Hiro please add ID's to /qa/ to prevent samefagging

Hiroyuki please respond to >>682852

>>682808
/ma/ - Manga please.

>>682978
Do you have any actual response or is this just another kneejerk from a generalfag afraid of losing his safe space? /a/ has wanted generals removed, for years.

>>682980
This isn't /q/.

We need /ag/ - anime general, /ma/ - manga and /korea/ - gookshit

Add country flag to /a/

Please add ID's to /qa/.

Reasons: It would make chains of productive discussion easier. People would have more difficulty samefagging.

>>682968
>>>/trash/
You're fucking nothing, filthy gook

>>682973
He wants to know the reasons for the whole board. Your opinion does not represent the whole board. Stop lying.

>>682808

hiroyuki the general consensus is that we do not want a manga thread

>>682983
Fuck off idiot. I want generals to fuck off and be banned, but you want them gone for all the wrong reasons.

>>682987
This isn't /q/.