Thread replies: 9
Thread images: 3
Thread images: 3
Anonymous
TIFF vs RAW in Lightroom 2017-09-04 08:26:16 Post No. 3144412
[Report] Image search: [Google]
TIFF vs RAW in Lightroom 2017-09-04 08:26:16 Post No. 3144412
[Report] Image search: [Google]
File: P1020163.jpg (353KB, 1000x669px) Image search:
[Google]
353KB, 1000x669px
Let's say I want to remove some lens dust in PS from my raw files before doing any other editing.
When I then go to edit these photos (now TIFF) in LR, my edits and presets look different.
What can I do to work around this?
[EXIF data available. Click here to show/hide.]
Camera-Specific Properties: Equipment Make Panasonic Camera Model DMC-LX100 Camera Software Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 6.10 (Windows) Maximum Lens Aperture f/2.3 Sensing Method One-Chip Color Area Focal Length (35mm Equiv) 35 mm Image-Specific Properties: Horizontal Resolution 240 dpi Vertical Resolution 240 dpi Image Created 2017:06:02 13:24:16 Exposure Time 1/60 sec F-Number f/9.0 Exposure Program Aperture Priority ISO Speed Rating 100 Lens Aperture f/9.0 Exposure Bias 0 EV Metering Mode Pattern Light Source Unknown Flash No Flash, Compulsory Focal Length 15.90 mm Color Space Information sRGB Rendering Normal Exposure Mode Auto White Balance Auto Scene Capture Type Standard Gain Control None Contrast Normal Saturation Normal Sharpness Normal
>>
Learn to use the spot removal tool and in lightroom
>>
>>3144414
It really sucks compared to what you can do in PS.. doesn't cut it sometimes
>>
>>3144412
Are you exporting in a different colorspace maybe?
>>
>>3144453
i'm just doing "Edit in Photoshop" and saving.
this is the raw, with a really shitty preset
>>
File: DSCF0263.jpg (866KB, 1080x607px) Image search:
[Google]
866KB, 1080x607px
>>3144466
>this is the raw
[EXIF data available. Click here to show/hide.]
Camera-Specific Properties: Equipment Make FUJIFILM Camera Model X-Pro2 Camera Software Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 6.12 (Windows) Maximum Lens Aperture f/2.0 Sensing Method One-Chip Color Area Focal Length (35mm Equiv) 35 mm Image-Specific Properties: Horizontal Resolution 240 dpi Vertical Resolution 240 dpi Image Created 2017:09:04 12:30:44 Exposure Time 1/420 sec F-Number f/9.0 Exposure Program Normal Program ISO Speed Rating 200 Lens Aperture f/9.0 Brightness 9.0 EV Exposure Bias 0 EV Metering Mode Pattern Light Source Unknown Flash No Flash Focal Length 23.00 mm Color Space Information sRGB Rendering Normal Exposure Mode Auto White Balance Auto Scene Capture Type Standard Sharpness Normal Subject Distance Range Unknown
>>
File: DSCF0263-Edit.jpg (885KB, 1080x608px) Image search:
[Google]
885KB, 1080x608px
>>3144467
and this is the TIF, with the same settings.
the TIF is darker and is more saturated.
[EXIF data available. Click here to show/hide.]
Camera-Specific Properties: Equipment Make FUJIFILM Camera Model X-Pro2 Camera Software Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 6.12 (Windows) Maximum Lens Aperture f/2.0 Sensing Method One-Chip Color Area Focal Length (35mm Equiv) 35 mm Image-Specific Properties: Horizontal Resolution 240 dpi Vertical Resolution 240 dpi Image Created 2017:09:04 12:30:43 Exposure Time 1/420 sec F-Number f/9.0 Exposure Program Normal Program ISO Speed Rating 200 Lens Aperture f/9.0 Brightness 9.0 EV Exposure Bias 0 EV Metering Mode Pattern Light Source Unknown Flash No Flash Focal Length 23.00 mm Color Space Information sRGB Rendering Normal Exposure Mode Auto White Balance Auto Scene Capture Type Standard Sharpness Normal Subject Distance Range Unknown
>>
>>3144470
Make sure the colorspace settings are the same in LR and PS.
Also clean your lens once in a while, don't be a slob with a disgusting camera.
>>
>>3144412
This is completely normal.
TIFF is a normal image format.
It contains all the information a program needs to display it.
So it should look similar in any software unless it has some bug.
Raw is unprocessed.
There is a lot of room for interpretation on how to show it. (for example: what white balance to use, which tone curves, how to convert the Bayer pixels to RGB)
So it will often look different in different software.
Unless Photoshop and Lightroom are set up to interpret raw files the exact same way you will have differences.
But what should work for you: import to Ligtroom -> export to TIFF -> open in Photoshop -> import edited file in Lightroom.
Thread posts: 9
Thread images: 3
Thread images: 3