How seriously do academic historians take Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morals?
How seriously does anyone take academic historians?
>>1435266
Everyone knows he was describing a plausible arc for history, not a perfect account of it. GoM is mostly social critique and most academics know that
>>1435266
They don't care, it has little to do with what historians do.
Is circumcision justifiable today?
>>1435192
No.
>>1435192
No.
After Crete Hitler said he'd never order another airborne operation but the same battle caused the British to model a paratrooper force after the Fallschirmjaegers.
What gives?
>>1435107
Dictators who only served as grunts in the last war were not military geniuses.
More news at 8.
>>1435116
Was Hitler that intent on micromanaging in 1941? I thought it came later, after the winter of '42 in Russia.
* micromanaging as in overruling the advice from other more experienced officers.
Was the battle of new orleans the most embarrassing defeat of all time? how did a bunch of untrained farmers manage to btfo the British so hard?
Humidity and heat.
>untrained farmers
We also had some pirates
the soldiers were irish
Alright /his/, we know each other well enough and I'm bored so let's have a quiz thread.
I'll ask a question and the first person to get it right earns a (You).
Question 1: Who was the leader of the Nazi Party in Germany for the large majority of its existence?
>a) King Edward VIII
>b) Mr. Nazi (Herr Nazi)
>c) Joseph Stalin
>d) Adolf Hitler
Mr. Nazi
>>1434913
Whoever gets it right should get to ask a question
anyway, "d) Adolf Hitler"
>>1434928
Alright, fair enough. You got it right first so you ask the next question.
Why did Kemalism fail in Turkey? Why did the Turks fall for the Gulenist meme?
>religion has a negative affect on civilization
>religion encourages violence and ignorance
>as soon as any religious organization becomes powerful enough, they immediately begin suppressing religious and intellectual freedom in society
>>1434581
All true desu.
>>1434599
Not all religion, all Abrahamic religion
>Why must we make effort?
It seems everyone is in a struggle to be the last man standing.
>Why are we so quick to assume someone else is wrong?
It seems people usually respond with "No, because I think this way", and very little do you see someone admit they could even have a chance of being wrong.
>Why do people attack religion with memes?
For people who say their mind is the highest state, why is it so hard to logically perceive any notions of soul being more than the mind?
>Why do the religious, claiming to be saints, actually persecute everyone who is not associated with their groups?
You guys sees that Christians who call each other heretics are their own worst enemy. Christ is branded as a heretic by the Jews, so why do Christians brand each other as heretical.
>Why do people separate the enlightenment of Gautama and Yeshua?
This is not to say "Buddhism has different beliefs than Christians" but rather, the person who is known as Buddha, and the person who is known as the Christ, both having the same dimension of higher being, are both of high wisdom and are distinct from the religions that came after them. They taught the metaphysical law, not any confining belief system.
who cares
>>1434549
no seriously, who even posed these "questions" and why is OP blabbing on about them to himself?
What do you think about the idea of writing a diary so your future heirs can read it? I realized that pretty much no one leaves something behind that will allow others to dwell into their minds. Be it at least some demented ramblings others can laugh about.
What would be the best format for this? I want to tap into immortality of digital data but not sure what would be best at having text, pictures, maybe some music and short vids in it.
>>1434407
>I realized that pretty much no one leaves something behind that will allow others to dwell into their minds.
The internet...
>>1434409
Aside from plebbook people write some inane shit scrambled across various forums under gibberish nicknames - it's unsearchable and unstructured. Also not something you want your children to read.
What would you honestly write? I have my grandpa's notes from college about nitrogen,plants, and sticking fingers up chickens asses to see if they lay. A great grandfather was obsessed about writing the weather down. None are really worth reading, beautiful handwriting though.
Is there any ancient book or text like the Bible which espouses again and again the virtues and concepts of love, faith, humility, charity, empathy, compassion and mercy? Not only in the New Testament but the OT as well?
Other ancient texts from what I've read just focus on gods winning wars, defeating dragons and demons and taking heroic men into the pantheon of the gods or taking beautiful women as their mates.
any ancient philosophy work
Why should books only promote love? Life isn't just about love. You can't survive by just loving everyone, there are people out there that hate you and want you dead.
You should love people who deserve your love, not just give it away unconditionally.
>>1433940
But what about religions? Are there ancient religious texts which hold those values in high regard, or even command it's followers to practice them?
Future historians will browse through THIS VERY THREAD in order to get an accurate portrait of per-immortality historical shitposting, whilst we are all dead. What would you like them to know?
DON'T TRUST THE SERBIANS
that OP is a faggot
Pinochet did literally nothing wrong.
Post your feels
>>1433836
>extremely unhealthy africa
>major african trade routes & ports
>cecils.roads
major african SLAVE trade routes & ports.goddamnit
>7ft niggers in america
>everyone else left behind is 4ft tall
>shit tier genetics mind goes with body
>rene descartes cartesian dualism is ALWAYS a lie.self evident existential god [email protected]
>last 300-indefinite underdeveloped culture, land civilisation. GGGADAFI
>>1433843
Extremely unhealthy africa is for the dengue and malaria infested rainforests and rivers.
What was his deal? Did his mommy never bake him enough chicken tendies? Were his GBPs wasted?
>>1433773
>GBPs
the German Reich used Marks as their currency anon
>>1433773
why do you make always make thread about him after the last one is archived .Do you hate him or something ,are you a butthurt Belgian mad about WW1
its true he had mommy issues tho
Hey /his/
Why are there no good historical Sengoku-era video games that let you live the samurai life?
>Hes never heard of Nobunaga's Ambition
Sengoku Rance
Go Go Nippon!: My First Trip to Japan
>tfw you don't even read books anymore because you can't bear to give up on Nicholas Nickleby and if you give it up then you'll be considered a definitive pleb
>tfw so much literature is self indulgent UNENJOYABLE no fun allowed bullshit
>tfw pomo trash takes this to another level and the forced lol so randumb sense of humour is excruciating
>tfw mccarthy is genuine trash with only the road being worthwhile
>tfw the academia-media-publishing industrial complex and its lackeys (many of whom browse /lit/) treat literature as not enjoyment but as a medium to tee off their ramblings and to try to gain cultural capital by talking about their tastes
>tfw reading is as much a pointless worthless status symbol as travelling (lit is the pseuds equivalent of instagram whores)
>tfw laughing when watching the dying embers of reverse-fedoras praising religion as profound when Stirner lays it all out for all to see
>tfw stirner doesn't even say anything that a common unpretentious person doesn't know, it's just that lit doesn't listen to any idea unless it has been presented by a published author
>>1433489
Morality is subjective
kill yourself then
>le epin disillusioned internet man
>I'm just too smart for literature and religion LOL
probably the type of brainlet faggot who replies to people making fun of his meme Borg opinions with "n-not an argument!!"
Fuck off back to WoW
Is this true?
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/28/health/nutrition/yoga-fans-sexual-flames-and-predictably-plenty-of-scandal.html
>Yoga teachers and how-to books seldom mention that the discipline began as a sex cult — an omission that leaves many practitioners open to libidinal surprise.
>Hatha yoga — the parent of the styles now practiced around the globe — began as a branch of Tantra. In medieval India, Tantra devotees sought to fuse the male and female aspects of the cosmos into a blissful state of consciousness.
>The rites of Tantric cults, while often steeped in symbolism, could also include group and individual sex. One text advised devotees to revere the female sex organ and enjoy vigorous intercourse. Candidates for worship included actresses and prostitutes, as well as the sisters of practitioners.
>Hatha originated as a way to speed the Tantric agenda. It used poses, deep breathing and stimulating acts — including intercourse — to hasten rapturous bliss. In time, Tantra and Hatha developed bad reputations. The main charge was that practitioners indulged in sexual debauchery under the pretext of spirituality.
>Early in the 20th century, the founders of modern yoga worked hard to remove the Tantric stain. They devised a sanitized discipline that played down the old eroticism for a new emphasis on health and fitness.
>>1433472
Yes
>yoga
>Taylor swift
>ny times
rock-bottom plebs get the fuck out
>>1433472
its definitely cultural appropriation and I hate that