Is this accurate?

File: godzilwhat.png (398KB, 540x600px) Image search: [Google]

398KB, 540x600px

>>77841762
I suppose it's accurate to someone's tastes, though not necessarily my own.

Brave down, Monsters Inc up

>>77841810
Seconded.

>>77841762
People really like Toy Story 2 better than 1 or 3?

Huh. How about that.

File: 1430542325893.gif (2MB, 245x281px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 245x281px

>>77841762
>Toy Story 2 above Toy Story 3

And god dangit Bobby, when will you accept the fact that the original Cars movie wasn't that bad? It was the second one that should never be spoken of.

>>77841810
Third

>>77841810
Fourth

>>77841762
Wall-e down one tier
The Incredibles up one tier
Inside Out down it's a tier of its own, people either love it or hate it, but I wouldn't consider it great, it wasn't exactly original.
Brave down to shit tier
Finding Nemo down to one tier
Eh, what the hell, I feel generous, Ratatouille up to one tier.

>>77841930
>Cars
>Not bad
Am I special snowflake or something? I remember seeing girls gushing over it, some boys liked it but forgot it exists in a month and I thought it was too stupid for me to watch.

>>77841762
>Brave being Great Tier
That belongs in the meh pile and you know it.

Switch Up and Monsters Inc around as well and you're golden.

Was Wall-E really that good? I liked the underlying message and all, but the execution seemed a little clumsy. Ratatouille was good and all, but I couldn't shake the underlying feeling that most of the rats were going to die in like 3 years anyway, so I wouldn't call that a happy ending.

>>77841762
>MU
>meh
>under monsters inc
>inside out is better than ratatouille
no, stop it

>>77842014
>couldn't shake the underlying feeling that most of the rats were going to die in like 3 years anyway,

I'm pretty sure no one else thought about that

>>77841762
MI and Ratatouie belong in great
MU and Up belong in good
Brave belongs in meh.

>>77841762
Inside Out is meh, regardless of how many shitty autistic threads we had here for it. It was a good concept with poor execution

>>77841810
Fifth

>>77841762
Not quite.

>God Tier
Toy Story, The Incredibles

>Great Tier
Finding Nemo, Wall-E, Toy Story 2, Toy Story 3, Up, Inside Out, Monsters Inc., Ratatouille

>Good Tier
A Bug's Life, Brave

>Meh Tier
Monsters University, Cars

>Shit Tier
Cars 2


Haven't seen Good Dinosaur.

>>77842181
I'd move Brave down one, but apart from that, it looks good.

is the golden age of pixar finished?

>>77842220
Bug's Life was looking a bit lonely, but yeah, I was torn between putting Brave in meh or good.

>>77842232
>golden age
Cut that shit out.

>>77841762
UP had a great opening and an arguably average rest of the movie.

Its good tier. A 5 minute amazing scene doesnt make up for the rest of the movie being meh.

>>77842245
Fuck you the part where Carl gets to Paradise Falls and realizes he isn't happy always gets me

I can't take Monsters University seriously because of that race scene.
Seriously what the fuck was that

Personally, I'd move A Bug's Life down a peg.

File: 1446675373684.jpg (70KB, 725x820px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 725x820px

>>77841762
>The Incredibles
>Anything below God Tier

>>77842433
Move up down one.
Move monsters Inc to god.
Then is good

>>77842433
>>77842456
It's still invaldid
See >>77842454

why are people listing ratatouille so low?

>>77841762
Little Nemo, UP, Toy Story 2, and The Incredibles are their best work, though I haven't seen Inside Out. They're all fantastic for different reasons, but they're all great.

Personally, my favorite is The Incredibles if only for the soundtrack alone.

>>77842486
Because it didnt have an over done "muh feels" scene.

Car is ok

Everything after Cars is bad

>>77842454
You guys act like Incredibles is the best animated movie ever made. I liked it a lot. but it does not even fucking touch Toy Story.

>>77842014
Sentient animals live as long as people in Disney flicks.

File: 1448971034913.png (370KB, 876x1266px) Image search: [Google]

370KB, 876x1266px

Best version coming through.

>>77841762
Up is god-tier for me.

>>77842514
>Incredibles is the best animated movie ever made. Toy Story does not even fucking touch it.
FTFY

>>77842660
That is my line up

>>77841762
Wall-E is really heavy handed and lacks the subtly needed to impress me with its "unique" agenda

>>77842514
This. The Incredibles is fucking overrated.

I'm glad people are finally willing to admit Cars sucks.

When it came out people were like "no no it's great it's Pixar it's great"

Then when Cars 2 came out they were like "oh Cars 2 sucks but Cars 1 was pretty good"

And now finally people are willing to admit that it's shit filler movie made only to sell toys.

>>77842733
It's nowhere near as bad as 2, but yeah, it's pretty shit.

Ratatouille was their best movie.

>>77842660
I agree with everything but I'd switch MU and Brave. I just couldn't care about that "princess proves everyone wrong" movie but really enjoyed MU.

>>77842733
Nah I think people are mad a 3rd cash grab Cars is coming out.

The first one was pretty good in my opinion, but yeah Cars 2 sucks.

Why are people rating Nemo so highly? It's boring as shit.

>>77842733
>I'm glad people are finally willing to admit Cars sucks.
>people are finally willing
>finally

Cars has been universally derided here for years.

>>77842717
>>77842757
Some good opinions in this thread.

>>77842897
Buddy I've been going to /co/ for years and there were countless "when will Pixar finally make a bad movie" threads and I ALWAYS mentioned Cars and people ALWAYS went "Nah man you have shit taste Cars is great and A Bug's Life is amazing"

Frankly I don't like A Bug's Life, Ratatouille, Monsters INC, Finding Nemo, and Brave either, but I can see their merits. However Cars was a pure and simple cash grab and people still vehemently defend it.

>>77842928
I mean the "when will Pixar finally make a bad movie" meme was so strong that normalfags picked it up

http://www.cinemablend.com/new/It-s-Official-Cars-2-Is-Pixar-s-First-Bad-Movie-25380.html

>>77842014
Why does it matter if they die? They lived fulfilling lives and died a natural death of old age.

How about we all rank Pixar movies by story concept?

Brave belongs in meh tier, if not shit tier.

>>77842942
Would the humans have anything to rally under at that point?

>>77842660
Switch MU and Brave.

MU has a shit concept but is really well executed.

Brave is just dull.

File: 14417098325.jpg (55KB, 757x820px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 757x820px

>>77841762
>Bave
>Great Tier

>>77841762
Brave don, Incredibles up then itll be perfect

>>77841762
Toy Story 3 is only good tier. I'd put Inside Out down there, too. Brave is only meh tier. I'd be willing to move Cars up to meh tier, and I'd probably move Monster's Inc. to good.

>>77841930
Toy Story 3 was just a rehash of Toy Story 2.

>>77841762
Swap toy story 2 and 3, raise Monsters Inc, and put Brave in Meh tier where it belongs

>>77841762

I'll fight you about god tier, the rest is gravy.

>>77842660

I would personally argue a case for Inside out to go up one, but other than that, you're on the money. hell, if nothing else, you've got the best lineup so far.

>>77842514
>>77842717
The Incredibles is what you tell normies your favorite animated film is if you don't want to get judged.

I think Brave and Finding Nemo are incredibly overrated. Monsters University is very underrated.

>>77841762
First half of Wall-e was god tier, the rest way okay.

https://youtu.be/N4GIAdlbtLY?t=71 [Open]


When I'm drunk and high in the dark AM and I am masturbating furiously, my thoughts tend to drift towards the ending of Bugs Life. At a young age, seeing a beloved hero get a brutal beating was very...stimulating. Now, my fucked up brain has crafted a grandiose fantasy, of Hopper tearing off Flik's limbs one by one, Flik begging the colony for help, but they refuse out of fear. Eventually, Flik is an eyeless, limbless torso and head, begging to be put out of his misery.

Anyone want to RP some bugs life vote/Dom?

File: Incorrect.jpg (26KB, 500x312px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 500x312px

>>77841762
>Brave in Great Tier
>MU in Meh Tier

>>77841762
>Brave better than Ratatouille
Too obvious man.

God:
Wall-e - Up - Inside Out - Ratatouille
Great:
Toy Story 3 - Toy Story 2 - The Incredibles
Good:
Toy Story 1 - Monsters Inc - Finding Nemo
Shit:
Cars

Haven't seen the others, but Ratatouille might be my personal favorite followed by Inside out and Up. They might not be the very best objectively, but I found them to hit pretty close. Also, TS3 might be the same as TS2, story-wise, but the nostalgia was pretty strong for me.

Eh, just swap Brave and Monsters U's positions. Also, I never saw Wall-E.

why is a bug's life considered mediocre?

>>77841810
seventh

>>77845412
Not nearly as good as Toy Story. Characters were a little flat, story was little generic, and it didn't have memorable music like Toy Story.

Mind you it was their second movie after Toy Story so most criticism comes from how it's a lesser movie than TS

>>77841762
Personally, I would move The Incredibles and Monsters Inc. up one tier each. But otherwise, this is pretty accurate to my tastes.

>>77841762
Nah. The only animated sequel that surpasses the first is shrek 2 and just barely.

>>77841762
Wall-E and Ratatouille are the best films Pixar has ever made, I will fight anyone irl who disagrees.

But i think we can all agree that the only good thing in Bug's Life was Hopper right?

>The Good Dinosaur
>The is underlined

Am I meant to read/pronounce the title with a "thee" instead of "thuh"?

I'd put the original Toy Story in God Tier because of how groundbreaking it was at the time. I believe it was the first movie to be animated completely in CGI. Wall E was also groundbreaking because of how it went a good 20 minutes without dialogue, which was unheard of for an animated movie.

Honest question, why do people hate Cars? It wasn't the best Pixar movie but I enjoyed it. I've seen virtually everybody saying it's shit, but noone has never explained why.

Cars 2 was an abomination, no contest on that.

>>77843983
>i take the opinions of internet movie critics and use them as my own

I think that all 3 Toy Stories should be God Tier.

Also, more Cars 2 down one level to dogshit tier.

>>77841810
Sixth

>>77846885
Opinions can match completely.
Doesn't mean they're not terrible.

>>77846937
Toy Story 3 was the weakest

Wall-E was shit
Brave was shit
Inside out was shit

>God Tier

Ratatouille, Inside out, Finding Nemo, TS3

>Great Tier

TS, TS2, Incredibles, UP, Wall-E, Monsters Inc

>Good Tier

Brave, Monsters University

>Meh Tier

A Bug's Life, Good Dinosaur

>Shite

Cars, Cars 2

>>77841966
I won't argue it deserves higher but the unoriginal argument is a pile of shit. Yes, you saw personifications of the mind before. I saw living toys before toy story, I saw deconstructions of super heroes before incredibles, I saw a whole tv show about the premise of monsters inc before monsters inc. This is one of the least important quality deciders.

File: Ratatouille.jpg (184KB, 300x400px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 300x400px

Ratatouille needs to be in Great Tier, at least.

>>77841762

I'm probably the only one that enjoyed Brave the most out of their films 2bh

>That atmosphere
>The attention to detail in the animation/backgrounds
>The comfy setting
>The feeling of adventure when Merida goes outwith the castle and disobeys her dad
>The soundtrack
>Most of the characters
>The weird unexplained witch providing an air of mystery

The entire thing just seemed like a step up from what they were doing in Cars, Monsters Inc and Up.

File: image.jpg (22KB, 263x309px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 263x309px

>>77841762
>Monsters Inc
>not great tier

File: more accurate.png (357KB, 876x1266px) Image search: [Google]

357KB, 876x1266px

>>77841810
Eighth.
Here is a far more accurate list.

>>77847533
The technical part of Brave was great, but it lacked soul.

>God Tier
Toy Story 2
The Incredibles

Great Tier
Toy Story
Finding Nemo
Wall-E
Ratatouille
Up
Toy Story 3
Inside Out

Good Tier
A Bugs Life
Monsters Inc.

Meh Tier
Brave
MU
The Good Dinosaur

Cash Cow Tier
Cars
Cars 2

File: genoBSOD.jpg (164KB, 426x306px) Image search: [Google]

164KB, 426x306px

>>77848034
god those human performances were CRINGE worthy

>brave above meh
I thought you guys didn't have shit taste

>>77844240
this.

Brave should be in shit tier

God Tier
>Toy Story 3
>WALL-E
>Finding Nemo
>The Incredibles
>Inside Out
>Ratatouille

Great Tier
>Toy Story
>Up
>Toy Story 2

Good Tier
>Monsters U
>Monsters Inc
>Bug's Life
>Good Dinosaur
>Cars

Meh Tier
>Brave

Shit Tier
>Cars 2

>>77842928
Cars 2 was a cash grab, Cars was a cynical contractual obligation. It was made when Eisner Jewed Pixar so hard that he got shitcanned and replaced with a different Jew willing to play ball. The inherent bitterness of the film and the short before it(Pixar mocking Disney and Dreamworks with their Mary Sue who needed neither of them) is still so ugly. The short with the Mary Sue rabbit beating the shit out of Walt Disney was at least funny.

>>77841762
no

>>77848034
Personally, I'd put Brave into the shit tier.

>>77846810
"Thuh," because the following word starts with a consonant.