[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

Who's really the best band in music history and why is it

The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood.
Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.

Thread replies: 282
Thread images: 48

File: 348736-thom-yorke.jpg (38KB, 400x490px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
348736-thom-yorke.jpg
38KB, 400x490px
Who's really the best band in music history and why is it radiohead?
>>
>>713566038
>band
>radiohead

Kek.
>>
File: 200_s.gif (75KB, 442x200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
200_s.gif
75KB, 442x200px
>>713566038
D-12 is best band
>>
>music
>radio head

pick one faggot
>>
When it comes to music, /b/ has the shittiest fucking taste, it's so ridiculous.
>>
>Bob Marley and the wailers
>inb4 stonerfag
>>
>>713567212
I'll have you know I listen to drake, the most gangsta hippity hoppity youngster that all the young folks be getting lit FAM to
>>
Radiohead are amazing.
There's no such thing as better or worse music though.
The only thing that defines the standard music is the motivation behind its creation.
For example, music created to make money is soulless. Any music created from the heart is beautiful.
I'm sure Radiohead fit into the second category.
>>
>>713567428
Get fucked faggot
>>
>>713566038
CRAWLING IIIIIN MY SKIN

THESE WOULDS THEYLL NEVER HEAL
>>
>best band in music history
>radiohead

No. Radiohead is pleb-tier garbage.
>>
>>713567428
Lol you were so close to making a good point! So close!
>>
>>713567428
There are such things that define better or worse. To claim that radiohead better than beethoven is a fallacious argument.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrxePKps87k
>>
File: 23.jpg (192KB, 707x1000px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
23.jpg
192KB, 707x1000px
>>
>>
The Clash is the only band that matters
>>
>>713566038
Radiohead are a very good band

Best band tho? Nah sweetie.

Probably The Beatles tbh
>>
>>713568300

Stonerfag
>>
Ehh the best band of all time is obviously some gay shit like Metallica
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q888PBtrWc0
You honestly can't deny this tasty melodic goodness, it's a fucking masterpiece /b/
>>
>>713568261
lol I like tool but that's ridiculous

>>713568333
lol no I just am a bit of a music nerd, probably killed the thread by providing the correct answer.
>>
>>713568300

Beatles were mostly bland normie shit
>>
>>713568261

No, unless you are an edgy 12 year old
>>
>>713568517
Tool has songs that can and will make you think, unlike the garbage that is the Beatles.
>>
>>713568725
Ooh nice one. Are petty insults all yo have?
>>
>>713567694
Now let's hear your music taste, so we can make fun of it.
>>
>>713568730
Beatles were the first to experiment in the studio, mess with overdubbing, the fucking works. They don't make noise like Tool does bucko
>>
Best bands is obviously Type O Negative
>>
>>713568730
How old are you kid?

>>713568662
>bland
no
>normie
yes
>shit
no
>>
>>713568851
"first"
>>
>>713568730
>garbage
>The Beatles
Wut?
Listen to their shit...every album is like completely different band altogether. You're missing out /b/ro
>>
>>713568859
What's the point of music if not to incite emotion and thought, kid?
>>
>>713568859

The Beatles are far from great. It's still most commonly listened by hipster 15 year old girls along with Pink Floyd who think they're spiritual and special
>>
>>713568730

Make you think? Tool is to music like Joe Rogan is to politics. Empty-headed psuedo intellectual bullshit that pretends to be really profound when it is really just pretty dumb.
>>
>>713569165
Do you know what even one tool song is about?
>>
>>713566038
Funny joke OP. But everyone knows Clutch is the best band.
>>
>>713569165
If that's what you get from it then I guess that's your poroblem
>>
>>713568859
Beatles were the normie pop boy band of their day. They weren't great at all.
>>
>>713567226
who could hate uncle bob?
>>
NOFX

They've been in the scene for 30 years and with no major label backing they've still retained dozens of fans worldwide
>>
the beatles are shit, deal with it

overrated boyband from the day, the reason why they and many other bands have a following today is because people treated them like keeping up with the kardashians

Like the Rolling Stones, they did shit-house post 1970 yet people for some reason liked them because "hurr mick fagger did somefin with another selebrity lol" or "queef reichards did MOAR drugs whaaat!?! lol xD"
>>
>>713569212

I owned every tool album when I was an edgy 12 year old. There isn't much to it at all.
>>
File: hqdefault (2).jpg (10KB, 480x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hqdefault (2).jpg
10KB, 480x360px
So obviously Radiohead is really good. But not the best band in history.
>>
>>713569381
>dozens
>>
>>713569381
>dozens
yep all 36 of them
>>
File: 12732-time-out.jpg (93KB, 500x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12732-time-out.jpg
93KB, 500x500px
>>713569063
>What's the point of music if not to incite emotion and thought, kid?

>>713569092
Your fav band then? The Beatles are great. All kinds of people listen to them. I can get if you don't like them cause they're pop, I personally like a lot pop albums.

>>713569299
Most people would differ in opinion there. What's your fav album? I assume you don't like pop in general then?

...

Another great album btw
>>
>>713568359
Pre-Black Album of course.
>>
>>713569381

>NOFX

Get out of here with that shit.
>>
>>713569165
goddamn man, this is pretty much spot on.
I still love Joe Rogan and Tool but
>>
>>713569439
Then it shouldn't be hard for you to tell me what a single one is about.
>>
>>713569381
PURGE THE XENOS
>>
>>713569439
now you are just an edgy 14 year old
>>
>>713566038

Its queen, every song they wrote was and still is a 1hit wonder
>>
>>713569461
>>713569463
Indeed. Yet those 36 fans keep them going, the band are pretty well off

>>713569518
My chemical green day 182 at the disco fan detected
>>
Umm, nobady has mention Default yet
so yeah, Default are the best band ever
>>
>>713566038
>>
>>713569474

Hard to choose, really. I've got a lot of favorite albums and it changes all the time depending upon my mood at the moment. Right now it would probably be a tossup between The Birthday Party's Junkyard and Leonard Cohen's New Skin for the Old Ceremony.
>>
shaggs - philosophy of the world

unironically the best album ive listened too, even frank zappa recommends them
>>
If you're taking Radiohead inspiration:
Miles Davis Electric era
Mahavishnu Orchestra
Pink Floyd Ummagumma
Coltrane/Cecil Taylor
Stockhausen

Add in Blur/Gorillaz:
Fela Kuti
Mikey Dread
Gregory Isaacs
The Clash
80's electro-pop

Modern style: Zombi, S U R V I V E,
>>
>>713567428
>meriting artistic value in something obscure
Music that is soulless, and made for money often causes a sub par product, but it's not *bad* because it's point is to make money. Loads of music made with heart is absolute shit too. Bad reasons will cause a bad product, but even with pure motives your music can turn to shit if you don't know what you're doing.
>>
>>713569849
Frank zappa was a talentless hack, says a lot desu
>>
>>713569679
>My chemical green day 182 at the disco fan detected

No. Pop punk has always been and will always be garbage. I've never liked a single pop punk artist or song even in the slightest bit in my entire life. It is a garbage genre for people with awful tastes in music.
>>
>>713569956
dumb list, your dumb
>kys dumby
>>
>>713569664
Queen is a pretty good choice.

>>713568359
Metallica actually comes up if you google it (you have to phrase it a certain way).

...

>>713569801
lol ok. I know LC but I've never heard of The Birthday Party.
>>
>>713570040
you know nothing about music, kys
>>
>>713570040
MF Doom ain't nothin to fuck with senpai
>>
>>713569590

drugs religion and society, for the most part. Nothing they ever wrote was really multi-faceted or layered. It was all very simple.
>>
>>713569969
>Frank zappa was a talentless hack
>>
>>713569381
Fat mike pisses me off. He talks about "real" punk because his shit band never took off, and he's a trendy faggot. He just so happens to dress like a women when it becomes popular. Calls himself transvest-Lite. There was already a word for him, trend-sexual. I can't believe I liked that peace of shit. I knew he was an asshole, but he really is shameless.
>>
>>713570040
>never heard of The Birthday Party

What the fuck? How can one claim to know something about music and never have heard of the Birthday Party? Nick Cave is, quite literally, one of the most influential and prolific musicians in modern history.
>>
>>713570100
Why do you say that?
>kys
If you're not over 20 I don't want you to respond

>>713570112
My personal fav (at least in top 3). Not the best album ever.
>>
>>713570132
So you're basing your opinions on a popular conception of what their music is about and not their actual material. Thanks for proving my point.
>>
>>713567086
Can confirm
>>
>>713570242
Literally the greatest artist to come from Australia, he kind of makes me almost proud to be from this hole
>>
>>713570010
Enlighten me, awakened one! Where's your list? Put up or sit your ass in the back...and get ready to be reamed...
>>
It most CERTAINLY is not radiohead, their new stuff is absolute garbage homie. Try Opeth
>>
>>713570336
>greatest artist to come from Australia
Tame Impala took that title four years ago, sorry to break it to youl
>>
How come nobody mentioned these gods yet?
>>
>>713566038
holy fuck he got old.
>>
>>713570441
Gods that stole from every song you can possibly think of.
>>
>>713568261
COULDN'T HAVE AGREED MORE.
Sorry caps was needed
>>
>>713570242
I usually hate punk. You're a pretentious little bitch ain't ya? lol this sounds like crap. Not my thing. Try not to get offended.
>>
>>713570426

Tame Impala doesn't deserve to lick the boots of Nick Cave. There is no comparison.
>>
Rolling Stone says I'm right :D

http://www.rollingstone.com/music/lists/100-greatest-artists-of-all-time-19691231/bob-dylan-20110420

>>713568300
>>
>>713569969
Jesus. This is the biggest bait in the whole fucking thread. Awesome job.
>>
>>713570542
Kevin parker may be a cuck, but his albums have been excellent. He is arguably the only successful Australian artist within last 10 years

sorry im not sorry
>>
>>713570426
nice try troll

dude, I'm from perth, I used to hang around with Cam Avery, he introduced me to Kevin Parker. We started jamming, just the three of us, anyway, the guitar riff I was fucking around with ended up being the basis for the breakout song "Half glass full of wine"

>TL;dr
>kevin parker is a talentless hack who steals music
>>
>>713570542
You actually think Nick Cave can surpass the talented genius that is Kevin Parker? Everything the man works on is instant gold. Listen to Innerspeaker and you'll see what I'm talking about you fucking autistic pleb.
>>
>>713570654

Rolling Stone has about as much credibility as the Nickelodeon Music Awards when it comes to selecting decent artists.
>>
>>713570010
>your dumb
>your
>>
Google also agrees with me

https://www.google.ie/search?q=best+band&oq=best+band&aqs=chrome.0.69i59l4j69i61l2.2123j0j9&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#q=best+band+ever

>>713568300
>>
>>713566038
Best band radiohead ?
Kekekekekekek
Time to turn 360° AND WALK AWAY....
>>
>>713570749
Your opinion is in the minority.
>>
>>713570698
no you didnt you basic bitch. You wish you invented his riffs but instead choose to lie to strangers on the internet for no benefit
>>
File: u-wot-m8.jpg (495KB, 3004x1976px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
u-wot-m8.jpg
495KB, 3004x1976px
>>713566038
BOOOOOO
>>
>>713570698
Cam Avery might be the biggest cuck I've ever met, I run into him at every fucking celebrity party that I go to, wtf happened to him??? I'm guessing you're Luke.
>>
>>713566944
Are you implying they're not a band?
>>
>>713570688

>arguably the only successful Australian artist within last 10 years

Except for Nick Cave, who is still making (much better) music and is much more successful

>>713570733
>You actually think Nick Cave can surpass the talented genius that is Kevin Parker?

Yes. Yes, I do. By a pretty wide margin.
>>
>>713570698
omg this is gold.

I love how pretentious some of the kids are on here when it comes to music.
>>
File: 4L_mGS1jS81.jpg (95KB, 1401x788px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4L_mGS1jS81.jpg
95KB, 1401x788px
>band
How about a single man?
>>
>>713570802
No it really isn't, it's known as the fox news of the music world.
>>
>>713570815
nah dickhead, September 2006, my mate Cam invites me to come over to his mate Kev's place to jam, four months later, JJJ plays the song
"You fucking cunt" is what I screamed, from memory
We've crossed paths once since then, he shook my hand and mouthed "Thank you".
That was it. It cemented how much of a cunt he is.
>>
>>713570733
>>713570688

Also, Warren Ellis and Dirty Three are far better than Tame Impala and Australian as well.
>>
>>713570856
Regardless, Half full glass of wine goes way back to the dee dee dum days, I seriously doubt that you're fucking legit, coming from someone that loves Tame.
>>
>>713570796
>turn 360 and walk away
>turn around in a circle and keep walking in the same direction.
/b/ wasn't as dumb overall as it is now, I promise. This thread is chalk full of geniuses.
>>
>>713569792
Who let /mu/ out of the cage?
>>
>>713571012
>not knowing it's a meme
>>
>>713570796
360 isnt walking away retard.. XD
>>
>>713570749
Yeah I bet you know much better
>>
>>713571009
honest to god man, he took the riff.
In an alternate universe, where that didn't happen, I'd probably be a fan
>>
>>713570986
lol seriously though, are you luke? steve summerlin? give me a fucking hint anon
>>
>>713570964
lol k bud

>thinks he knows a lot about music

kek
>>
>>713571012
Found the newfag
>>
>>713571165

I do, in fact. Rolling Stone is full of middle-aged pop-obsessed normie jews who couldn't tell a decent album if it hit them in the face.
>>
>>713571012
>>713571148
HAHA NEWFAGS....KEK
>>
>Is Radiohead the best band in history?
Probably not
>Are they shit?
No
>Are they pretty fucking good?
Yes

>Are the Beatles the best band in history?
Maybe
>Are they shit?
No
>Are they pretty fucking good?
Yes

Anyone in this thread that seriously claims Radiohead or The Beatles are shit should get their heads examined. Or get better taste in music, and and understanding of what makes music objectively good-- it might not be to your taste, for some reason, but that doesn't make it bad music.

>Is there objectively good music?
Yes, absolutely
>Is there subjectively good music?
Yes, absolutely
How good music is is a combination of the two. Like any art form. If you hit the high standards of objectively good music, and enough people find it subjectively good, maybe you're a contender for the best musician/band in history. Especially if those people know music.
>>
>>713568399
Agree , the whole Album "In Rainbows" is a masterpiece.
My favourite song on it is "Nude". It brings me tears of joy and sadness at the same time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbWBRnDK_AE
>>
>>713571178
aw man i guess i scared you off, bummer
>>
Fuck everybody else. ICP forever. Juggalo for life. WHOOP WHOOP!!!
>>
>>713570469
Who'd they steal Heartbreaker, The Ocean, Houses Of The Holy, The Song Remains The Same, Kashmir, No Quarter & The Rain Song from?
>>
>>713571372

>Anyone in this thread that seriously claims Radiohead or The Beatles are shit should get their heads examined

They're shit. Are they the most shit bands ever? No. Are they anything more than average? Definitely not.
>>
>>713571372
>is there objectively good music?
Fuck off. Music is an art form. It can be well crafted and well performed, but if you as an individual think it's turd then it is. Art you don't like has no value to you as an individual, and is therefore not GOOD. You can admire the craftsmanship or the feeling, but if it's not your schtick, then it's not.

You say "good" when it'd be more active to say "can music be objectively done well".
>>
File: 512UXaX2cWL.jpg (47KB, 500x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
512UXaX2cWL.jpg
47KB, 500x500px
>>713571372
Yep thank you. Man music nerds can be the moth pretentious people on the planet sometimes. I'm the dude who said The Beatles.

(Pic Unrelated)
>>
>>713571450

In Rainbows was awful. Their older material was OK, but their last decent album was Amnesiac. Everything after that went downhill rather quickly.
>>
>>713571729
>>713571719
Your wrong.
>>
>>713571215
lol, steve sucks, don't compare me to that bitch
I'm Tim
>>
File: nin.jpg (28KB, 500x270px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
nin.jpg
28KB, 500x270px
Best dunno, but great yeah
>>
File: faygo_icp.jpg (69KB, 500x333px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
faygo_icp.jpg
69KB, 500x333px
>>713571719
YOU'VE BEEN FAYGO SHOWERED!!!!!
>>
File: index.jpg (8KB, 225x224px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
index.jpg
8KB, 225x224px
>>713571942
SIP ON A COOL BOTTLE OF FAYGO NINJA! WHOOP WHOOP!!!
>>
>>713570986
so you were silently pissed like a woman? Why didnt you have the balls to tell him to own up to stealing your shit?

I am wrong, kevin parker wasn't the cuck since he is smug alpha, it is infact YOU, YOU are the CUCK ALL ALONG

~JohnTheRegularRedditor signing out
>>
>>713571458
how did you scare me off?
I had to take a shit dude
>>
Not even joking
>>
File: 61z+BBE0lPL.jpg (230KB, 500x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
61z+BBE0lPL.jpg
230KB, 500x500px
Clearly the Red Hot Chili Peppers guys!
>>
File: 960.jpg (96KB, 960x540px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
960.jpg
96KB, 960x540px
>>713572029
YOU'VE BEEN FAYGO SHOWERED!! MUCH LOVE NINJA!! WHOOP WHOOP!!
>>
>>713572014
him mouthing thank you was the admission dickhead, and what was I supposed to do, kick the shit out of him?
There was like 20 people around, all there for him, if I started anything, I'd have gotten rolled
>>
Metallica, even though their new stuff is shit.
>>
>>713570883
nick cave looks like a faggot and literally sings about sucking dick

sorry im not sorry
>>
>>713572008
I'd rather listen to ICP than drink Faygo
>>
>>713572182
yeah, but he still rules
>>
>>713571894
well damn tim, were you in any local bands around the time? Cease? Four Walls?
And why the fuck is Cam trying to fit in with all these Hollywood celebrities???
>>
>>713572061
SURPRISE!! FAYGO SHOWER IN YOUR EYES!! MUCH CLOWN LOVE NINJA. WHOOP WHOOP!!
>>
Opinions? https://vimeo.com/178823364
>>
>>713572195
AHHHH! DUCK!! THE JUGGLA IS HERE!! WHOOP WHOOP!!
>>
File: facepalm.jpg (65KB, 640x426px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
facepalm.jpg
65KB, 640x426px
>>713566038
I tried listening to that shit. Shit fucking sucks asshole. Really, how do you like Radiohead? Boring ass shit. I really tried over and over to try to like it.
>>
>>713571729
>Music is an art form.
That doesn't excuse poor knowledge of music. In fine are, for instance, I can safely write off the opinions of those who think Picasso was shit. Because they obviously have a limited understanding of art. But I can respect someone who says he's not to their taste.

>Art you don't like
Is not the same as bad art. While you don't like it, you can still accept that it is good.

>Art you don't like has no value to you as an individual, and is therefore not GOOD
Not good for you personally, fine. ut that doesn't mean it is not generally good. Some people just don't like The Beatles, but without them, many musicians you like wouldn't be producing what they are. So they are objectively good, regardless of your taste.

>You can admire the craftsmanship or the feeling, but if it's not your schtick, then it's not.
Which is why I said
>it might not be to your taste, for some reason, but that doesn't make it bad music.

So while it may be objectively good (admirable craftsmanship & feeling) it may not be subjectively good to you (you just don't like x type of music).

>You say "good" when it'd be more active to say "can music be objectively done well"
Good is a general term. I'd say objectively good music is "good" and subjectively bad music is "not to your taste."
>>
>>713572238
I was in a band named End of Summer, and I dunno why Cams trying to be something he's not man
>>
File: fbvjaxe2-400x400.jpg (41KB, 400x400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
fbvjaxe2-400x400.jpg
41KB, 400x400px
>>713572334
AHHHH THE JUGGLA IS HERE!! DUCK!!! WHOOP WHOOP!!!
>>
File: 1466134563633.jpg (37KB, 431x450px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1466134563633.jpg
37KB, 431x450px
>>713567694
>>713572334
>>
>>713572144
confront him you little bitch. You said you have friends who know him so you should beable to find him. Fucking kick his teeth in if he actually stole your shit.

but you cant and you wont because you're a fat neet whose lying for attention. This is my last reply
>>
>>713566038
I think in terms of physical size, NIN must have it with the sheer number of members, FLA might have it in # of seperate tracks
>>
>>713572212
not really.
>>
>>713572182

Nick Cave probably got more pussy in one weekend of touring than you've gotten in your entire life.
>>
>>713568359
>Metallica
>gay
choose one faglord
>>
>>713572392
this is you.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaH-YtdKmJs
>>
>>713571719
>Are they anything more than average? Definitely not.
I question your standards in music. Both have been on the tops of most lists of good music, by people that matter (i.e. not you and not me). They have both influenced most or a lot of the music we both listen to. By any objective measure, both are good. Well above average. Or perhaps a couple of the greatest bands to come out in the 20th century. Unless you can explain how they are, objectively, not good, then no one really cares. Because all you're talking about, then, is that they don't fit your taste in music.
>>
>>713572452
bruh, he's hardly in perth anymore, and if I asked my mate to set up a meeting, he'd refuse, knowing my feelings for him
>>
>>713572503
still a faggot and so are his fans
>>
File: hqdefault.jpg (7KB, 480x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hqdefault.jpg
7KB, 480x360px
>>713566038
Soopavillianz
>>
>>713572583
Metallica is ok, but i've always preferred Megadeth
>>
>>713572597
and?
>>
>>713572655
I wish i can hear more stories, perth/fremantle music scene fascinates the fuck out of me and I'm from Los Angeles
>>
>>713572673
WHOOP WHOOP NINJA MMFCL DOWN WITH THE CLOWN TIL IM DEAD IN THE GRIZZOUND. THIS FAYGO IS FOR YOU FAM
>>
>>713572744
that isn't him you cuck
>>
>>713572417
Juggalos are the most cringeworthy of all styles ever
>>
>>713572212
his songs are him talking, there is no artistic talent to any of them. He is not experimental, since he's performing safely in known genres, he keeps a very specific style to all of his songs which indicate the lack of range. He isn't singing because he isn't exerting his voice and the instrumentation are traditionally structured like any other song of its genre.

Im sorry, but nick cave is uninspired and lacking ballad writer which really points to a dick sucking, cum guzzling nobody with nothing going for him
>>
That's a funny way to say pink floyd
>>
>>713571331
And you are... ?
>>
>>713572655
all im hearing are excuses for you being a little bitch
>>
File: juggalos14n-4-web.jpg (186KB, 1200x1676px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
juggalos14n-4-web.jpg
186KB, 1200x1676px
>>713572942
FUCK OFF YOU FAKE ASS JUGGAHO. YOU WONT SAY THAT TO MY FACE CUZ MY JUGGALO BITCH WILL POP A CAP IN YOUR ASS. (pic related)
>>
>>713573038
what albums of theirs do you consider good
>>
>>713571331
Do you have a tiny penis or...? Really ugly?

Why are you so angry?
>>
>>713573155
Animals, all the way senpai
>>
>>713568049
damn i wish i was smart
>>
File: 29.gif (1003KB, 220x220px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
29.gif
1003KB, 220x220px
>>713573155
Here we go!
>>
File: wut.gif (655KB, 460x426px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
wut.gif
655KB, 460x426px
>>713572417
>>
On an objective basis: no one.

In my meaningless opinion: Judas Priest.
>>
>>713573016
>his songs are him talking

No. He uses a range of singing and speaking styles

>He is not experimental

What the fuck are you talking about?

>he keeps a very specific style to all of his songs

Not at all. He's done everything from orchestral to electropop to western to industrial etc

>the instrumentation are traditionally structured

What the fuck are you even listening to?
>>
>>713566038
>radiohead
*shudders*
>>
File: 66.jpg (142KB, 1600x1000px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
66.jpg
142KB, 1600x1000px
>>713573276
>>
>>713573203
heres a hint, anything after atom heart mother is reddit tier and may as well be under a thousand tons of shit

its like they got an autistic boy, sat him down at a mixer table and told him to go crazy Anything including and after 1973 may as well never existed as it was garbage
>>
>>713573155
Their entire discography
>>
You're all idiots. Loverboy is the greatest band of all time.

/Working For The Weekend, bitches!
>>
>>713568399
Faggot-ass pussy-ass bitch-ass shit. Nigga u ghey. Ole Ryan Seacrest looking ass nigga.
>>
>>713573276
i saw a video on pornhub one time and it had Nick cave sucking on this black mans penis for literally 45 minutes straight. When he asked to stop sucking his dick because his mouth was getting dry, the black man smacked him across the face and told him to start again because he fucked up his blowjob

Then nick cave had to go another 2 hours, it was embarrasing before the black man came in his mouth. He didn't even thank him
>>
>>713573038
Post a few Pink Floyd songs that are god-tier for us. I'm also interested.
>>
>>713573467
wrong
>>
>>713573442
Wrong faggot, anything including and after the wall may as well never existed, I thought you knew better dumbass
>>
This is the greatest band of all time
>>
Can.

>>713568300
The fact that so many books still name the Beatles as "the greatest or most significant or most influential" rock band ever only tells you how far rock music still is from becoming a serious art.

>>713573615
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7RL1F7hqRc
>>
>>713573733

No.
>>
>>713573733
THAT'S WHAT I FUCKING SAID!
>>
File: pepeface.png (98KB, 500x505px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
pepeface.png
98KB, 500x505px
Top motherfucking Pepe

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WidInHVCqqg
>>
>>713573779
They haven't been great for like the past ten years. Not the same without Frusciante, By The Way was their last decent album
>>
>>713573733
no fucking way
>>
>>713573779
30+ years and they're still being creative and killing it. Not to mention they are unbelievably talented
>>
>>713573442
youre a fucking retard clearly never tripped on acid and put Animals on.
>>
>>713573766

A lot of people also seem to think that the Harry Potter Series is a great work of literature and that Big Bang Theory is quality television. That doesn't necessarily make it so.
>>
>>713573766
>serious art
You are so deluded.

For a start they're more pop then anything else.
>>
>>713573865
>Red Hot Chili Peppers
>creative

KYS
>>
>>713573841
Dude come on. Stadium Arcadian was a fucking treasure, and their latest album is solid as fuck. You can't disparage them when they're still making good music after all these years
>>
>>713566038

Radiohead are the best because everything is in it's right place.
>>
>>713573929
:( poor you
>>
>>713568730
Top kek
>>
>>713573631
the wall was a terrible album that was made for a movie, it was not a standalone album. and guess what? the movie sucked

sorry to burst your reddit enhanced tard bubble, but The Wall was an overrated and a terrible entry for Pink Floyd and was arguably their downfall for good music

Remember, atom heart mother was their last good album, anything afterward The Wall was ambient trash which is extremely dated by now, something good music shouldn't do
>>
>>713573929
Kill myself? Stack them up against any other band since 1990
>>
>>713573889
Opinions and taste.
>>
>>713572061
this
>>
>>713574032

Most of them are likely better.
>>
>>713573887
>animals
yet another album praised by stoner circlejerks. They couldn't stop singing about their dumbass asspie friend syd barret who decided to ragequit life

it was a directionless, meaningless filler album made purely as a cash grab
>>
>>713574133
K.
>>
>>713574022
Are you really forgetting what came in between atom heart mother and the wall? how fucking stupid can you be? I never said The Wall was a masterpiece btw, it's a shit album, and indeed their downfall. No Rick Wright = No Pink Floyd. I'd beat the shit out of you if i could.
>>
>>713574133
faggot
>>
File: 61.jpg (18KB, 294x292px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
61.jpg
18KB, 294x292px
Mfw when the correct answer was given almost 200 posts ago....

....and people are still arguing
>>
>>713574251
but you can't cause you're a skinny faggot who's never been in a fight in his life
>>
>>713574358
It ain't frank zappa you fuck, go listen to The Bends, masterpiece of an album, compared to the fucking noise zappa created
>>
>>713574358
Please tell me which band that would be
>>
>>713573889
Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz musicians of all times are Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, who were not the most famous or richest or best sellers of their times, let alone of all times. Classical critics rank the highly controversial Beethoven over classical musicians who were highly popular in courts around Europe. Rock critics are still blinded by commercial success. The Beatles sold more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore they must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music of the past, classical critics grow up listening to a lot of classical music of the past. Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved.
>>
>>713566038
This is the greatest troll I've ever seen
>>
>>713574251
I didn't read a single word of your post but i can tell you you're wrong. Pink Floyd is entry level trash that serves as cuck feed for the masses

>blah blah blah, Id beat the shit out you if i could
bring it on faggot, i bet you could beat me off all night too
>>
>>713574441
You'd be surprised, I'm not much of a skinny faggot, and I can definitely cuck you the fuck up, you beta piece of shit
>>
>>713574573
fckin b8d ya looser
>>
>>713574491
zappa's skull can suck my BBC

shaggs - philosophy of the world is true GOAT and i will defend its honor
>>
Cuz every album is completely different yet all are amazing
>>
>>713566038
Probably the Beatles
>>
File: Front.jpg (412KB, 1413x1407px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Front.jpg
412KB, 1413x1407px
>>713574653
>>
File: 12.1.jpg (32KB, 453x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12.1.jpg
32KB, 453x500px
>>713574688
Yeah that was established over 200 posts ago, these guys are in denial.

>>713574492
>>713574491
>>
>>713566038
Megadeth
>>
>>713574573
Oh yeah? Any fighting experience? Where do you live?
>>
File: the band best band.jpg (11KB, 259x194px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
the band best band.jpg
11KB, 259x194px
>>
Thread's dead baby, Beatles are confirmed the greatest band of all time. It's a fact.
>>
nirvana! fight me...
Beatles might be better

radio head is bland background noise
>>
>>713574862
Fuck off troll Kurt Cobain wasn't leader of Megadeth
>>
>>713574632
I don't get it, it sounds shit
>>
>>713574862
but that's not megadeth
>>
>>713574928
go to sleep, it's past your bed time young faggot
>>
>>713574862
kek
>>
>>713574886
Can confirm.
>>
>>713574886
Beatles for blandest band? Totes agree.
>>
Amon Amarth
>>
>>713575021
>totes
>>
>>713575069
Or Sabaton
>>
File: 31.2.jpg (28KB, 400x400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
31.2.jpg
28KB, 400x400px
>>713575021
They're the best, interesting that you don't agree...
>>
>>713575077
>>
>>
>>713575069
Hahaha
>>
I really really like Nickelback
>>
D12
>>
Any Cannibal Corpse fans here?
>>
File: 1427260704408.gif (987KB, 229x176px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1427260704408.gif
987KB, 229x176px
>>713574862
>>713575069
>>713575093
top kek
>>
>>713574978
if you dont just 'get it' you feel it. its an enhanced experience that acts as an extension of your body. Im sorry if you dont 'get it' because you never will

only the cool kids understand such complex rhythm that the shaggs possess
>>
>>713566038
'tis Pink Floyd. always and possibly forever.
>>
>>713575165
>that pic
thats not nickleback you goddamn mouth breathing retard, thats powderfinger
>>
>>713575477
Nah brah they're shit get over it

you just like em because nobody knows them

nobody knows them because they are shit
>>
>>713575230
cannibal cucks more like it

just generic edgy teenagers who grew up and are still rebelling against their moms for serving brussel sprouts
>>
>>713575525
it tis isn't it? they thee thy merry band of men LOLeth
(im self taught in shakespearean dialogue so im pretty smart like that ahahah)
>>
>>713575550
shit are they because them knows nobody

them knows nobody because em like just you

nah brah they're shit get over it

OWNED BITCH

Im sorry you cant understand modern classical composing like the shaggs. People like you cant seem to grasp their talent like true patricians
>>
File: 4f2023b4986b3.jpg (561KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4f2023b4986b3.jpg
561KB, 1920x1080px
>>713575230
They're pretty good, but not even in the god-tier
Let alone the best
>>
File: Ghost2015.jpg (60KB, 630x420px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Ghost2015.jpg
60KB, 630x420px
>>
>>713566038
The answer you seek is obviously New Order
>>
>>713575776
SOME
>>
Am I the only person in here that listens to tool for the amazing drum and rhythm work?
>>
>>713575761
Yeah I get why you like them
>>
>>713567352
Point on case
>>
> The Beatles
> Pink Floyd
>>
mfw no-one's mentioned The Jesus Lizard yet..
>>
>>713566038
One direction <3
>>
File: can.jpg (68KB, 497x358px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
can.jpg
68KB, 497x358px
Can
>>
>>713577631
>The Jesus Lizard
>Can
Nope. Thanks boys you're a little late to the thread tho. It's over we had a clear winner.
>>
File: IMG_0011.jpg (56KB, 609x441px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
IMG_0011.jpg
56KB, 609x441px
No it's Joy Division. New Order are O-K but nowhere near as good.
>>
>>713577433
See, the thing about Pink Floyd is that they're WAY too inconsistent to be called 'greatest' anything. The run in the 70s from Atom Heart Mother to Animals is pretty unassailable. Beforehand it has its charm I guess, but 60s psychedelia is a bit hippyish for my taste - and as many have said, The Wall was the beginning of the end into meaningless easy-listening slop.

The Beatles are OK I guess. I find their history and personalities slightly more interesting than the music, slightly. It's decent stuff for sure, but not the second coming like some folks make out..
>>
>>713577472
FUCKING YASSS!
>>
>>713566038
Radiohead sounds like a constant yawn. They have some decent depressing stuff but everything else makes me want to sleep or just turn it off.
>>
File: 1480457147220.jpg (222KB, 657x1024px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1480457147220.jpg
222KB, 657x1024px
>>713566038
nirvana,motorhead, evanescence, disturbed, nickelback,deftones,system of a down
>>
OP is correct. Greatest band of all time.
>>
File: 1479516794876.jpg (1MB, 2944x1472px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1479516794876.jpg
1MB, 2944x1472px
Waiting for this thread to 404

>>713577472
Holy fuck - honestly listening to Goat for the first time, holy shit this is incredible
>>
>>713578016
This concludes the thread, boys. It was nice talking to you, Radiohead is the GOAT
>>
>>713578051
My nigga
Goat is a stone cold mean mutherfucker, enjoy!
>>
>>713569063
Entertainment? Does everything you do incite a rollercoaster og emotion?
>>
no one brought up Rush to talk shit about?
>>
>>713582055
WTF is wrong with you let it die
>>
How about System of a Down? are they too good for everyone to bash on here?
>>
sorry, I wasn't around(sage)
Thread posts: 282
Thread images: 48





[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.