[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Flat Earth discussion continued.

The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood.
Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.

Thread replies: 189
Thread images: 36

File: flatearth.jpg (82KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]
flatearth.jpg
82KB, 1280x960px
Flat Earth discussion continued.
>>
>>699546876
NYPA, dumbass.
>>
>>699546876
Stop please!!!! That's stupid!
>>
Future ITT: retards
>>
>>699546876
There is nothing to discuss though
>>
>>699546876
Flat earth confirmed in last thread. An anon has actually climbed Everest with his father and confirmed the horizon was flat.
Any gullible round earth christfags care to refute a flat picture of the horizon, thousands of feet up?
>>
>>699547151
that's not high enough to see the curve
>>
The flat earth society has people all around the globe.
>>
So i have a question to all you flat earth believers:

Lets say your right and the earth is actually flat and it is all a big secret that NASA or the goverment or whatever wants to keep from us...well why? Why would they feel the need to keep it from us? Its hardly like it would change anything if we knew the truth...so answer me that please.
>>
File: Black Science Man.jpg (828KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
Black Science Man.jpg
828KB, 1920x1080px
>>699546876
Stop.
>>
>>699547151
>confirmed
No
>>
File: image.jpg (49KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
49KB, 640x480px
>>699547293
Are you fucking retarded? Seriously? That's all you Christfags can say. Not high enough to see the curvature. Kek. You sound stupid.
>>
>>699547151
but disproven by pearl harbor, how could japan attack from the west, if not by magically teleporting from the east side of the earth to the west side?
>>
>>699547447
>has no idea how big the earth is
>>
>>699547319
The funny thing is that faking all that would cost a fuck-ton more than actually doing it.
>>
>>699547447
Only christ fags believe the earth is flat really.
>>
>>699547466
What's more, why would God or Jesus help them attack the US?
>>
>>699547466
Please show me video of them attacking from the west? Or are you just going to produce more government sources to back up your claim. Govt cuck.
>>
File: Earth.gif (900KB, 240x240px) Image search: [Google]
Earth.gif
900KB, 240x240px
Everyone in this thread is an autist. The earth is a hypecrube
>>
>>699547491
>has no idea what shape the earth really is
>>
File: go-pro.jpg (73KB, 669x749px) Image search: [Google]
go-pro.jpg
73KB, 669x749px
>>
>>699547828
I do.

A sphere. As we've known for thousands of years
>>
The Earth is a dildo.
>>
I went for a shit today. It felt good. I have been constipated for the past 2 weeks. My asshole was bleeding afterwards and it hurt coming out but the pain was worth it in the end because no i feel so relaxed.
>>
>>699547828
All logic and evidence points to round
>>
>>699548081
Kek
>>
>>699547151
I also climbed Everest and can confirm the horizon has a distinct curve. Because anonymous faggots on the Internet always tell the truth. Also my cock is ten feet long and I fucked 10000000 women yesterday.
>>
>>699547315
Underrated post
>>
>>699546876
Don't give a fuck what the earth looks like
>>
File: image.jpg (201KB, 800x550px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
201KB, 800x550px
>>699547466
It's not completely flat, retard. They flew around the outer bowl to attack from the "west".
>>
>>699548202
I believe you. I also fucked 1000000000 women yesterday,
>>
>>699547705
if they had attacked from the east, they would have to go over US mainland. so, pearl habour was an inside job confirmed?
>>
>>699547896
>>699548087

>I know this is true because Jesus told me so
>>
>>699548507
got evidence to the contrary?
>>
>>699548202
First spherical fags say it's not high enough to see the curvature. Now suddenly it is?
Christfags literally can't even tell their globular lie with a straight face.
>>
File: 1425404719912.gif (1MB, 257x256px) Image search: [Google]
1425404719912.gif
1MB, 257x256px
>>699546876
>Other planets, stars, moons, etc in the universe are spherical
>except Earth, which is flat for some reason
Nothing more to discuss. That's the overall 'logic' of this argument.
>>
>>699546876
literally physically impossible and doesn't correlate with anything we see in nature
>>
>>699548684
shut the fuck up
>>
File: 1471108086422.jpg (362KB, 902x789px) Image search: [Google]
1471108086422.jpg
362KB, 902x789px
>>699547896
Technically its an oval.
>>
disclaimer - im not a flat earther or round earther, i dont care what shape the earth is.


>earth spins faster than the speed of sound

Why don’t we feel Earth rotating, or spinning, on its axis?
>>
>>699548684
>what is sarcasm
>>
Satellite orbit determination and satellite network design are evidence that the government has been hiding the fact that the earth is indeed flat.
>>
>>699548764
He's actually got a point....
The more you globe guys argue the more I think I believe in a flat earth
>>
>>699548354
so you are one of these the-earth-is-flat-but-not-so-flat-like-a-plate-more-like-a-flat-bowl-for-decoration-or-fruits people
>>
>>699548937
see >>699548733
>>
>>699548823
We are rotating at the same speed and so from our reference it is nothing
It's like if you were in a car with perfect shock absorbers, you wouldn't feel it moving after it speeds up because you are the same speed as it
>>
>>699548823
Inertia
>>
>>699549147
So by that logic a pilot moving at mach speed should eventually not be able to feel the g-forces.

Lrn2science, numb nuts
>>
>>699549426
But air resistance still happens.
>>
>>699546876
I think 4chan as a whole has become a honey pot for social experiments without consequence or accountability after the mainstream and fbi learned of its existence. I think it started with anonymous telling people to put a giant sign on their stupid fucking faces to announce that they were anonymous. I think the black leader of anonymous is perfect evidence to this fact. I think it all came from the Scientology protests one anon championed because he was removed from the life of a loved one. which the church will force you to do if they think they are detrimental to the cause. Moot bailed because he didnt want to be part of what 4chan has become.
>>
>>699549147
Lolwut? That's it. I'm officially a flat earther now after listening to this retard try to logic.
>>
>>699547151
If the Earth was flat and you stood on top of Mount Everest you would be able to see all of the way to the edge of the world. You could look around and see every major city in the world from up there. Unfortunately you cannot. Just because the horizon is flat does not mean the earth is flat.
>>
>>699548853
not really
>>
>>699546876
give it a rest you nonce
>>
>>699549699
LOL ok dude. Sheep
>>
>>699546876
Ive been thinking lately have humans reached ther peak and now we are degenerating as a species? Like we started out dumb, bout 6000 yrs or whatever of advancement, now a digression. Flat earth? Really?
>>
I can end this discussion quickly...

Climb up a mountain, but since some of you are fat asses, wheb you stand on top of a mountain, what do you see off the horizon....

The curavture of the earth, hence the Earth is round.
>>
>>699549147
>perfect shock absorbers
Did you just use a hypothetical device in an analogy? My head hurts trying to fathom your tiny brain trying to make sense of our physical world. Do you wear a helmet?
>>
>>699549147
Newtonian physics would tell you that the closer to the outer ring of the flat planet the more lateral pull you would feel. if its a spinning disk the people on the outer edge would fly off the planet. you fucking dropouts.
>>
>>699549886
About 10,000 google search result images proved that wrong.
>>
>>699547315
kek
>>
>>699549637
What are clouds? What are the limits of the human eye?
>>
>>699550018
how?
>>
>>699550002
>Sheep physics and Jesus say I'm right
Stay blue pilled, pleb
>>
>>699547856
He's using fisheye, wtf is the point?
>>
>>699550282
No curvature.
>>
>>699547151
Start a go fund me account for a virgin airline trip to space ill donate 200, and start another one so we can fund a trip for all u dumb fucks to go to your "edge" in Antarctica
>>
>>699550181
What are telescopes?
>>
>>699550261
stop meming for crying out loud. these threads are worse than the 4 cock rate threads on the front page.
>>
>>699550355
>I'm bootyflustered because I've been proven wrong
>>
File: 1464553840823.jpg (901KB, 1680x1062px) Image search: [Google]
1464553840823.jpg
901KB, 1680x1062px
>People still haven't addressed the notion that the Earth is the *only* planet/celestial body in the universe that is naturally 'flat'
>ITT
>>
>>699550437
Telescopes see through clouds and other obstructions. Good try, retard.
>>
>>699550018
>>699550352
not high enough
>>
File: habitable planets.jpg (308KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
habitable planets.jpg
308KB, 1920x1080px
>>
can you explain lunar eclipses with a flat earth model? didn't think so.
>>
>>699550518
and we never landed on the moon. you have to wonder what kind of motivation makes people makes the same few threads every day for years on end. I mean actual people are here doing this every day. If you arent getting paid for it who in the world would do this.
>>
>>699550618
Sure thing, bub. The only height you can see the curve is coincidentally photos the uber honest government had taken. Please tell me you're just trolling now.
>>
File: A number of lightyears.....jpg (700KB, 2515x2515px) Image search: [Google]
A number of lightyears.....jpg
700KB, 2515x2515px
>>699550825
Scary part is, people in real life actually believe the 'flat earth' meme.
>>
>>699550902
I'm not, just saying facts
>>
>>699550723
Look flat to me.
>>
>>699547447
If its nasa thats covering it up, what explains the private space companys? Like Moon Express, they project going to the moon in 2020 for mining, and they got permission from the FAA to do tourism
>>
>>699550825
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGXTF6bs1IU
>>
>>699550952
scarier stillt is people are getting paid to do this shit.
>>
File: 1464553750830.jpg (776KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
1464553750830.jpg
776KB, 1920x1080px
>>699551036
Well, considering it's on a computer screen...
>>
>>699551062
Let me know when these "private" companies start providing proof that the earth is round.
>>
>>699551090
not to mention the fact theres a fucking mirror on the moon that you can point a laser at to determine the distance of the moon from the earth.
>>
>>699547719
Youve jus been waiting for a chance to post that cool gif
>>
>>699551226
the horizon alone proves it
>>
Explain a sun down flat earthers? The sun wouldnt dissapear if the world was flat.
>>
File: sataur.jpg (64KB, 511x380px) Image search: [Google]
sataur.jpg
64KB, 511x380px
If earth is flat, explain
>seasons
>why I can't see Japan from my eastern window from the Eastern Coast of the U.S.
>day and night
>auroras
>>
>>699547315
Topkek
>>
>>699551418
The sun is only 3,000 miles away and about 32 mile wide. It sweeps across the flat earth, unable to illuminate it all at once. Keep trying, sheep.
>>
Gravity makes round planets, not disks
>>
>>699551668
That's retarded and false
>>
>>699548202
I only fuckd 1 (sad face)
>>
>>699551668
there would be no life with that scenario
>>
>>699551668
but is it flat?
>>
>>699551729
>I got proven wrong. You're the retard.
lolwut?
>>
>>699551809
you didn't prove shit
>>
>>699551434
if the earth is a globe, explain
>y ur dum
>>
>>699551729
>>699551804
>>699551805
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GY0xhUOL3vM&ebc=ANyPxKqbwSmr_l544AXn7eeDFW6EFaFx95ZlsgWnSbsJ8vIHT-JN9ggiZbIOR07-A6ES9GAypYYD
>>
File: 018 - hnQAf.jpg (679KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
018 - hnQAf.jpg
679KB, 1920x1080px
I just want to know why people believe this.
>>
>>699551918
>>
>>699547856
What's going on here?
>>
>>699551931
wrong
>>
>>699551226
Publicly available equations based around the earth being round are used to track billions of dollars of equipment orbiting the planet. Some of those satellites are of importance to National Security. Some of those satellites are also to used track manned spacecrafts during launches. The earth is flat you fucking idiot.
>>
>>699548081
Under rated post.
>>
File: 1470185385563.png (926KB, 776x767px) Image search: [Google]
1470185385563.png
926KB, 776x767px
>>699551996
>no logic presented
>>
>>699552051
is that last sentence a joke?
>>
http://www.smarterthanthat.com/astronomy/top-10-ways-to-know-the-earth-is-not-flat/ flat earthers are ignorant. Read all of the article.
>>
>>699551809
who got proven wrong?
>>
>>699548354
If this thing was true id be able to see brazil from minnesota with a telescope u idiot, use logic
>>
>>699552051
>The earth is flat you fucking idiot.
Freudian slip, numb nuts?
>>
>>699551931
whats the ultimate motivation to make the whole world believe planets are round? Just for funsies. how good are you?
>>
>>699552259
Oh shit I've been found out
>>
>>699552201
have you ever tried?
>ffw to "no"
>>
>>699546876

>Earth is flat
>Mountains
>>
File: jupiter_polar_aurora_800.jpg (69KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]
jupiter_polar_aurora_800.jpg
69KB, 800x600px
>>699552280
>believe
It's not so much a belief, rather, an acknowledgement of how physics work and how planets are formed. One *should* be asking the motivation/reason behind a 'flat' earth.
>>
>>699551931
This is bullshit
>>
>>699552459
have you ever seen a planet form?
>believe
>>
>>699551931
Please explain eclipses. If the moon is seeing a reflection of the Earth, but the moon is above Earth, wtf?
>>
Why does everything go over the horizon if it's "flat"
>>
>>699551931
Holy Fuck, I was on the fence but I think I'm a flat earther now. That actually made a lot of sense. Not even joking.
>>
>>699552459
meh. I'll never understand how this became a meme on /b/.
>>
>>699552707
over is a stupid way to put it. it goes beyond your ability to see it.
even if the earth was a globe, you would lose sight of it before it went over the horizon anyways.
>>
>>699552896
no you wouldn't
>>
File: 1471187999209.gif (2MB, 480x292px) Image search: [Google]
1471187999209.gif
2MB, 480x292px
>>
File: 1455524372498.jpg (327KB, 1280x1280px) Image search: [Google]
1455524372498.jpg
327KB, 1280x1280px
>>699552688
Yet we have planets. I doubt you've taken the time to sit down and watch a star form, go through it's life, and then 'die,' yet we still have and can directly observe
>protosuns
>multiple 'classes' of stars at different stages of life
>nebulae
>white dwarfs

>>699552789
Rappers said it, people in real life believed it (and not just blacks, oddly enough), and so it became a meme. They're literally trying to undo centuries' worth of astronomical research.
>>
File: round earth.jpg (41KB, 640x335px) Image search: [Google]
round earth.jpg
41KB, 640x335px
>>699552786
>>
>>699552968
I dont think you are the one who I was talking to. If this is a reverse troll kys.
>>
>>699546876
You fucking Muslim
>>
File: dietjoke.jpg (276KB, 2200x1578px) Image search: [Google]
dietjoke.jpg
276KB, 2200x1578px
>>699553169
>Islamic Science
is one of those 'oxymorans'
>>
>>699551668
Why does the sun never set through the summer in the arctic circle and there is 6 months of darkness through the winter? If the sun circles a flat earth that wouldn't really add up
>>
>>699552935
kek. never been outside, have you?
>>
Why does the southern hemisphere see different star constellations than the northern hemisphere?
>>
>>699550467
Virgin airlines has a spaceship, what r u talking about proven wrong? The everest pic? That doesnt prove anything to me, go to Antarctica
>>
>>699553495
galileo was a faggot.
>>
File: 1468643139136.jpg (65KB, 443x726px) Image search: [Google]
1468643139136.jpg
65KB, 443x726px
>>699552968
yeah, you're right. I definitely don't have millions of years to watch something like that happen like you do.

how easily fooled some people are.
>>
Please flat earther explain the different moon phases and why some of them looks like a banana if it is not the shadow of a round earth between the sun and the moon. I'm waiting maestro :)
>>
File: This unscientific shit.png (163KB, 270x320px) Image search: [Google]
This unscientific shit.png
163KB, 270x320px
>>699553624
That didn't answer his question.
>>
>>699553495
because the southern hemisphere is composed of mainly non-whites.
>>
File: betelgeuse-vs-sun.jpg (41KB, 488x371px) Image search: [Google]
betelgeuse-vs-sun.jpg
41KB, 488x371px
>>699553652
As I said, we can observe stars being 'made' now by observing different points in the lifetimes of several.
>>
>>699553663
because it's not the sun that creates the "shadow"
believe everything your Sunday school teachers told you.
>>
>>699553663
Literally no one's impressed with your insistent "look at me"s. Please go back to your trap threads.
Sincerely,
A spherical-earther.
>>
>>699553766
oooh, exactly the same way as we can tell why people are the same by examining different ones.

waiting for a very well thought out response as usual.
>>
File: 3934316614_c45f625870_o.jpg (226KB, 1024x599px) Image search: [Google]
3934316614_c45f625870_o.jpg
226KB, 1024x599px
>>
>>699553703
why not? faggots make shit up all the time.
>>
>>699553958
#rekt
>>
>>699553990
that's a nice photo. did you take it?
thank you for sharing.
>>
File: ultra-deep-space1.jpg (4MB, 3000x2168px) Image search: [Google]
ultra-deep-space1.jpg
4MB, 3000x2168px
>>699553958
We can extrapolate similarities based on how people from several samples develop.
>>
>>699554132
Please never reproduce
>>
File: earth-dick.jpg (1MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
earth-dick.jpg
1MB, 1920x1080px
>>699546876
YOU IGNORUNT FUCKS EARTH IS SHAPED LIKE A DIKC
>>
>>699554132
strange.
I didn't know science was based on similarities and assumptions.
I've always been told it was somewhat factual in nature.
>>
File: Horsehead nebula.webm (3MB, 1280x688px) Image search: [Google]
Horsehead nebula.webm
3MB, 1280x688px
>>699554037
>make shit up
>get jailed for saying a fact that contradicts religious doctrine
>why?
Now I remember why I don't deal with the more 'religious' side of the family.
>>
>>699554229
wow.
>real proof
>>
>>699553805
Wow very poor answer i was expecting more but ok lets say it is not the sun what creates the shadow but the shadow is still round and obviously it's earth what 's between that thing that creates the shadow and moon. Uf it id not because earth is round then why maestro?
>>
>>699546939
It's a discussion not a personal army request, retard.
>>
>>699554249
faggot.
>>
>>699554119
I did not :(
>>
>>699554229
Florida stretches to South America now?
>>
Guys I'm a pilot and I'm finally done with the lies. I took a super secret oath along with all of the other tens of thousands of pilots, helicopter pilots, nasa employees, satellite and cell phone company employees, all world governments and all religious leaders to hide the flat earth from all of you. It's a multi-billion dollar industry and I'm coming out for all of the oath takers right now to tell the truth. The earth is flat
>>
File: science intensifies.gif (2MB, 425x247px) Image search: [Google]
science intensifies.gif
2MB, 425x247px
>>699554216
>non-sequitur
>ad hominem
k

>>699554238
The difference between science and religious myth is: science doesn't pretend to know everything, and improves upon itself (through research) when new, empirical, peer-reviewed fact is presented. So far, no one has presented an ounce of proof of a flat earth in a universe of round planets, stars, moons, and so on.
>>
File: 1378785025798.jpg (22KB, 400x300px) Image search: [Google]
1378785025798.jpg
22KB, 400x300px
>>699547315
>>
>>699554390
Confirmed. Get wrecked, sphericals. You Christ Loving blue-pilled faggots.
>>
>>699547549
Yeah and all telescope manufactures are in on it too. Unless earth is some super special place that its the only planet thats not round. Yes NASA is full of shit but come on. Gravity would be so much more different in the "middle" than on the edges if it was flat.
>>
>>699554390
>billion dollar industry
That would imply that there's a market for 'flat earth' belief. What, do you sell refrigerator magnets or something?
>>
>>699551216
where can i find cool pix like this online? plz
>>
>>699551226
No need to prove it, its already been proving the earth is a sphere, these companys wanna make money, if they wer only doing this to provide proof for flat-earth believers, thats lik saying dairy farms provide tours for non-milk believers
>>
>>699554608
>>>/sci/
>>
>>699554300
your guess is less in value than mine, good anon.
I was unaware we are in the presence of an answer judge, please forgive me.
be aware that even if I am wrong, circles are round, while not being globes.
>>
File: allah-troll.png (47KB, 810x512px) Image search: [Google]
allah-troll.png
47KB, 810x512px
>>699553990
Its just a wave
>>
>>699554621
>its
>proving
>wer
>companys
>thats
>lik
Everyone please meet your average spherical earth believer.
>>
>>699554509
just because you shun the evidence does not mean it is false. much evidence has been provided, you just fail to see the significance.
much in the same as when people see the signs of their significant other cheating but do not believe it. it is still happening.
>>
>>699549637
Nu uh cause you can't see that far.
>>
>>699554589
We sell the lie my friend, that and globes
>>
>>699554678
>answer judge
Kek. Stop arguing with that attention tard. He doesn't see the error of his ways.
>>
>>699554888
Checked & kek'd
>>
File: science.jpg (753KB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]
science.jpg
753KB, 2560x1440px
>>699554888
>evidence
You've yet to provide any.
>i-it's there
Then explain seasons, differences in constellations, night and day, differences in seasons themselves, and why everything else (planet-wise) would be round except Earth.
>>
>>699554919
Yep, because the earth is round and you get cucked by it's curvature
>>
File: Chakotay_2376.jpg (122KB, 396x528px) Image search: [Google]
Chakotay_2376.jpg
122KB, 396x528px
>>699554967
>selling flat-earth globes
>globes
>>
File: 3c5b7-flat_earthqq-900x450.jpg (56KB, 900x450px) Image search: [Google]
3c5b7-flat_earthqq-900x450.jpg
56KB, 900x450px
>>699546876
Accurate model of earth
>>
>>699555072
did you not watch the video provided by the other anon?
shunning at 100% power, captain.

inb4
>that video doesn't prove anything
neither do any other videos you've seen for that matter.
>>
>>699555182
the 'sun' would be too small. Also doesn't account for seasons.
>>
>>699555182
So when 24/7 sunlight here up north happens does the little sun just kinda stop and chill there?
>>
>>699555286
too small is an opinion.
size doesn't matter, anon.
ask your lady friend.
>>
>>699555127
A-Are you retarded? He didn't say flat earth globes. He said globes. The whole reason for maintaining the conspiracy is to continue profiting of globes, stupid.
>>
File: Earth vs Mars.jpg (233KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]
Earth vs Mars.jpg
233KB, 500x500px
>>699555251
Here's a live-feed from the ISS.

Look flat to you?
https://youtu.be/njCDZWTI-xg
>>
Question:
If the earth was flat why are the worlds religions not shilling the shit out of that fact? It would give them some serious ammunition for proof to support the dark age beliefs in the flat earth and legitimize their religions.
>>
>>699555383
watch the video provided by the early anon.
it is explained in motion.
Thread posts: 189
Thread images: 36


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.