[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

Was the Nazi war machine the most dominant and powerful military

The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood.
Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.

Thread replies: 174
Thread images: 29

File: 1tt2.jpg (202KB, 1063x863px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1tt2.jpg
202KB, 1063x863px
Was the Nazi war machine the most dominant and powerful military until its defeat in 1945?
>>
What's a nazi?
>>
>>685107773
no cause they were defeated
>>
>>685107773
Hardly. Got rekt marching into Russia.
>>
>>685107932
Single military, not 2/3rds of the world.

Alone they were more powerful than the US alone. More powerful than Soviet Russia alone etc.
>>
>>685107997
Only because Russia had massive material aid from the US. Without that aid, Russia would have been destroyed if Nazi Germany weren't fighting a war on 3 fronts.
>>
>>685107773
it was definitely the shortest
>>
File: 1tt4.jpg (543KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1tt4.jpg
543KB, 2048x1536px
The Nazi war machine could have single-handedly fucked up any country one vs one.
>>
>>685107997
every German Soldier killed like 15 Russians

that is hardly what I call rekt Boleg
>>
>>685108183
>muh statism
>>
>>685107932
>what are allied forces
"Nazi" Germany alone was the strongest nation, period.
>>
>>685107773
Yes and no. I believe Americans were still more advanced, but we also have a lot of Germans too, but I think our strongest genetic wealth were definitely from the Brits.

Nazis invented the assault rifles, rockets, the autobahn, but I think Americans were way more advanced in other things. NAZIs had to use our computers and motorized vehicles.

Europe probably would have been better under German rule, though they probably would have been taken over by brits eventually.
>>
>>685107832
A national socialist, which should not be looked down upon
>>
>>685109037
They fucked up invading Russia. They would have fucked the US if they had enough time.
>>
>>685109277
A "nazi" is a slur for a national socialist. It's like using the term "libtard" for liberals, believing it's a neutral term.
>>
>>685109037

>NAZIs had to use our computers
>1940
>computers

please stop
>>
>>685109037
>Europe probably would have been better under German rule

for some, not for others
>>
File: 5.jpg (455KB, 1752x1275px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
5.jpg
455KB, 1752x1275px
>>685107773
I have a nazi fetish.
I have a really big fucking nazi fetish.
I want a nazi war machine to dominate me powerfully.
Fuck.
>>
I'm lurking to see where this goes.
>>
I wish they would've won, if i'd still be born (arian) I think this world would be far more developed. I see no reason why i shouldn't be able to enjoy life under nazi rule.

Probably i wouldn't even know about jews or stuff like that, i hope they would've turned on the muslims and eradicated them.
>>
File: 1463388694428.jpg (167KB, 700x525px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463388694428.jpg
167KB, 700x525px
>>685109434
wait... okay i change my mind

Americans were definitely better.

They would have nuked Germany.
>>
File: help.png (861KB, 848x918px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
help.png
861KB, 848x918px
It's gotten so bad throughout the years.
I'm fapping over a ww2 (Replica?) nazi officer knife guys.
I need help.
>>
>>685109488
this
>>
>>685109515
not for you jews..
>>
File: nationalsocialism.jpg (30KB, 200x292px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
nationalsocialism.jpg
30KB, 200x292px
>>685107773
the germans came out of one of the worst economic depressions the western world has ever seen to raise an army and new technology to threaten the entirety of europe.

Russia was a bad move, and I think they would have fared better by getting their jewish neighbors onboard instead of you know.

strongest tanks, jets, rockets, assault rifles. yea they bit off more than they could chew.
>>
>>685107773

not really easy to answer to that.

mostly NO - they wasnt, because they were defeated and could only rush half-europe because their oppponents were just badly prepared for such a case.
Also the nazi-machinery could stand the test of time only 6 years, thats far away from other empires.
Romans and Ottomans lasted for hundreds of years til they fall
The former British Empire also lasted a few decades.
Even the US is an Empire since the first world war

But of course, it was definitly impressive how the nazis run over europe.
It is clear they set the right goals and developed a few new techniques.
>>
>>685108108

wtf are you talking? more than the half german army was wasted in russia, its a real shame the us and brits had such problems attacking the remainig armies
>>
>>685109037

dude just shut the fuck up and browse some mlp-bullshit...
>>
>>685108040
> more powerful than the US

I'll take "What is nuclear fission?" for $500. Germany was at least 5 years behind on building a nuke.
>>
>>685107773
they invaded russia at winter
>>
>>685107773
It was really gay https://youtu.be/QTcf0ujFG7A
>>
>>685110585
Soviets vs US in damage to the 3rd Reich:

Soviets:
Fought the Germans for 4 years.
Highest motivation as they were fighting for their own homeland.
Right next to their supply source.
No other enemies to deal with at the time.


US :
Fought Germany for less then one year
Moderate motivation as they were fighting for someone elses homeland.
5000+ miles away from their supply source.
Fought the Empire of Japan at the same time and even before fighting the
Germans. Defeating Empire of Japan pretty much by itself.

Also don't forget the 10's of million of tons of supplies the US sent to Britain
and the Soviets before it even entered the war.
>>
File: 40scomputer.jpg (27KB, 369x296px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
40scomputer.jpg
27KB, 369x296px
>>685109488
>they didn't have computers in the 40s

your nigger is showing
>>
As much as I love the NAZI war machine I would have to say that ultimately it would have been defeated. Even if it had won in Russia and even if it had turned back the Allies in Normandy on D-day or at the battle of the bulge, the US would have still developed the Atom bomb first. The initial plan was for it to be used on Berlin however the war finished sooner so the Japs ended up being the guinea pigs.

So due to this vast technological advancement the US even had it lost all battels up to that point would eventually develop the bomb and nuke NAZI Germany into submission. So even though they were advanced in more in many areas and had some of the best elite undeniably some of the best Divisions in the history of warfare, by declaring war on the US sealed their fate. Had the US not entered then they may have done it
>>
>>685112759
You gotta realise how close the nazies were to the a-bomb. The norwegian rebellion luckily halted their development alot, yeah the americans might have been first yet but the germans were also very close
>>
>>685112164
ura faggit,
>>
>>685108183
Germany never will be fighting one on one bro we're all itching to do it again....soon
>>
File: hiroshima1.gif (56KB, 357x260px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hiroshima1.gif
56KB, 357x260px
>>685112759
This time will be different.
>>
>>685110406
no the US is not an empire, it is a federation. unless you mean like a figure of speech.
>>
>>685107997
Germany's army was stronger, but the Russians used cold to kill a lot of them, along with Hitler going bat shit crazy thinking every one of his plans would succeed without a hitch so he would just send his men to march into Russia without enough food to make the journey.
>>
>>685109488
>>685109488

Ever heared of the enigma machine?
>>
>>685113360
This guy has a point, we only got the a bomb because of scientists we got from other countries. We weren't anything special we just got there a little bit sooner
>>
>>685110759
We are judging armies, not nukes.
>>
>>685115881
THAT WASN'T A COMPUTER RETARD, ALL IT DID WAS SPIT OUT LOTS OF NUMBERS NOTHING ELSE.
>>
>>685116339

How's that different from a computer which works with 0 and 1's ?
>>
>>685107773
Does it matter? All that needs to be remembered is the British beat them with cardboard tanks, ice cream vans and spam.
>>
>>685109037
>americans
They didn't do anything significant they literately came when millions of men on both sides died, and when germany was fighting a war on 3 fronts. Also being across the Atlantic helps with the fact that you didn't feel any direct effect of the war.

There was this 4chan post about some key victories in world war 2 and none of them were american.
>>
>>685115881
Indeed, cracked by a British homo in a shed.
>>
File: 1463517978118.gif (3MB, 300x200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463517978118.gif
3MB, 300x200px
>>685116442
because a modern computer does it in a much more intelligent level, its like saying that if i manually try to unlock a 4 digit lock and go singularly 1111 -> 1112 -> 1113 etc that i am a computer.... some people are such retards on this board i swear to fucking god... you cunts trigger me so much sometimes
>>
File: image.jpg (59KB, 800x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
59KB, 800x500px
>>685107773
Not as strong as America's gonna be after I build that fucking wall
>>
File: tefuck.jpg (15KB, 180x157px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
tefuck.jpg
15KB, 180x157px
>>685116696
>trigger me
>>
>>685111342
Ok they fought 2 wars, but what finally won the war, was the nuclear bomb. Which was made by.
German scientists.
And if it wasn't for the fact that they simply surrendered for america because. The living conditions were better than russia.

Also pic related you were lucky you weren't surrounded by 10 different countries which were culturally different from you and had their own ideals.
>>
File: 1463530623600.png (620KB, 574x540px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463530623600.png
620KB, 574x540px
>>685117011
i get triggered by retarded cunts, like when you see a nigger doing nigger shit and get that feeling.
>>
File: 1442164468061.gif (3MB, 300x252px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1442164468061.gif
3MB, 300x252px
>>685116339
>>685116696
>>
>>685116696

>Modern computer

I'm not talking about a modern age computer, I'm merely pointing out the fact that you can discuss what you define as a computer. The first computers had almost zero calculating powers. Also getting triggered by a discussion on a internet board.
>>
File: 1463650650505.png (102KB, 625x626px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463650650505.png
102KB, 625x626px
>>685116696
>>
File: NaziParty.png (253KB, 1270x687px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
NaziParty.png
253KB, 1270x687px
>>685109467
>slur
Why do dumbasses think this? Nazi is synonymous with National Socialist, you morons.

>American NAZI Party
>>
>>685117503

it wasn't a computer, it was specifically designed to break codes. there is no computing power behind it... all it did was systematically (via electrons) spit out numbers in an orderly fashion and they just happened to get lucky one day because the germans fucked up. it didnt even do shit until HUMANS intervened
>>
>>685107997
Winter rekt them, not the subhuman asiatic hordes.
>>
>>685111342
>Fought Germany for less then one year
You must be forgetting about North Africa and Italy
in 1942 and 1943
>>
File: 1463329668417.jpg (113KB, 800x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463329668417.jpg
113KB, 800x600px
>>685118099
I'm curious what your education discipline is
Please tell me
>>
I fucking hate Germany and the smugness of their people
>>
>>685118544

irrelevant, i watched the enigma code which is factually based off what happened
>>
File: 1420739286780.jpg (577KB, 980x3952px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1420739286780.jpg
577KB, 980x3952px
Germany conquer nearly the whole world im pretty sure that Germany would beat any other country in a 1 n1
>>
>>685111096
Actually they invaded in summer, but were held up in the winter.
>>
>>685116339
>>685115881

The enigma machine was a mechanical encryption device.

Theoretically I suppose you could call it a computer, although it only had one function that it could perform. This is still a German "computer" however.

>>685112164

Is that the ENIAC?

It was located in the US (and the Germans didn't have access to it) and I believe its design function was to calculate artillery trajectory tables for different firing conditions.

Indeed, a computer but nothing useful on the battlefield.

>>685116442

Modern computer is defined as something which works with electrical pulses (0s and 1s) rather than with someone cranking gears.

I would argue that the enigma machine is a mechanical computer designed to perform 1 function (such is the limitation where your programming "language" is arranging the mechanisms inside).
>>
They were and they weren't, they were the best army until around 1943, they had been prepared for war earlier than anybody, since 1933. Stalin believed that Hitler wouldn't risk a two front war in Europe and believed he was safe, obviously Hitler smashed France and there was no second front, by 1943 Russia 4/5 of output was dedicated to the war effort, and they began to outproduce Germany in both quantity and quality. I forget the quote exactly, but when Stalin told one of his advisors that he had learned of Germany's preparation for Operation Barbarossa, somebody replied by basically saying no matter what happens, who fights and where, germany will never conquer Russia. it's simply too big, Stalin, unlike Kutuzov in 1815 saved Moscow, but he could have retreated and retreated, Germany would never have had the power to beat it, yes their army was huge, but they were stretched 1000km from Berlin to Mozdok, and then 1000km from Finland to Turkey, if Stalin fought alone he would have had the option to retreat and retreat just as Kutuzov. He didn't because he had the power to defend Moscow
>>
File: 1463200751334.jpg (14KB, 267x267px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463200751334.jpg
14KB, 267x267px
>>685118695
>>
>>685118703
this picture is interesting
>>
>>685110759
actually they have heavy water factories and understood how to split the atom, they just didn't see the advantage of irradiating the entire planet.
>>
>>685116339
>>685116696
Even if these are bait, with a BA in computer science, I officially can say you are retarded.
>>
>>685118099
its called an analog computer fuckwits.
>>
>>685119090
You're an imbecil
>>
>>685109488
>>
>>685119170
>this
thank you, dear comrade
>>
>>685116696
You're the retard, m8. Computers actually work EXACTLY the same way, just much faster. All computer logic is still fundamentally binary and will be until quantum computing becomes a thing.
>>
File: 1461597765190.gif (4MB, 640x480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1461597765190.gif
4MB, 640x480px
I think the Russia was more powerful at the start of WWII, but if Germany would have waited a few years they would have been much more powerful and WWII might have taken another turn.
>>
>>685109488
the oldest computer is actually an ancient Greek device used to predict astronomical events, it's called the antikythera machine/ mechanism

also Poland actually cracked the enigma code before the English, can't remember exactly how but basically German soldiers, in their day to day handling of the machine were lazy, they wouldn't scramble the machines prior to use like they were supposed to, they would sign off, and people would sign off with the same initials, etc etc, basically repetition is the key to cracking codes
>>
>>685119566
you're welcome pal. willing to share some more of my knowledge if anybody has any questions
>>
>>685116696
>intelligent
>starts at 1111
You have to start at 0000 dude.
>>
>>685119595
This.
I don't care if it's gears or water.
A computer is a machine that computes
>>
>>685119753
>also Poland actually cracked the enigma code before the English, can't remember exactly how
Some polish people found an enigma machine and were able to decode the messages.
>>
>>685119753
I back this anon's claim.
>>
>>685120020
having an enigma machine doesn't allow you to crack it, the enigma machine was in production since 1920s, it was used by a lot of armies

>>685120056
it's not a claim it's a fact, it exists
>>
>>685116109
>other countries
These "other countries" were german regime- and later war-refugees. Not to mention the "voluntary" requisition of all remaining loyal german scientists during and after the war.

Look up operation "paperclip".
>>
>>685120283
I meant on Poland's cracking of the enigma first, sorry.
>>
It was dominant as long as it had momentum. Once it lost that momentum, they began losing because they couldnt muster enough resources to sustain the war machine.
>>
They defeated themselves. Hitler was no general, but was seems to have been acting as one. No one had the balls to stand up to him. They managed to snatches defeat from the jaws of victory, though they military minds like Rommel.
>>
>>685120283
Are you sure they cracked it?
I thought they just had the machine.
>>
>>685107997
>raspuza
>siberian hordes after Japan guaranteed peace
>>
>>685120402
yeah I think they cracked it, but the Germans discovered that it was compromised and switched it all up, and then clamped down hard on how it was actually being used by people, ie: no more heil hitler on the end of every message, which makes it pretty difficult to crack

>>685120420
this guy is right, basically the Germans had the Blitzkrieg, which could only really last for a few days, if you know about the battle of Dunkirk, the German panzers rolled all the way to near the coast, but Hitler stopped them from going in to basically take Dunkirk itself, because Blitzkrieg was only really meant for short bursts of extreme military might, ie: fucking up the Benelux countries and Czechoslovakia, not Russia. Russia had the Deep Battle tactics which were invented by Tukhachevsky I think, basically you go well behind the enemy, cut off their supplies and then surrounded, which is what happened in Stalingrad, the Caucasus, etc etc, the Germans lost a HUGE amount of men which were simply captured, I think 600,000 in the Caucasus alone.

>>685120724
They definitely cracked it, not like they could really do anything with the information they had though, they had no army, and were beaten quickly.

>>685120717
Rommel wasn't actually as successful a commander as history would have you believe, in Africa, the Germans relied almost entirely on information being passed by an American military attache, who was using out of date codes which were being decoded an hour after, Rommel referred to him as his 'good source'

in France, Rommel didn't really succeed much
>>
Wrong. Germany in WWI was much better. Their platform was essentially to return to how they were in WWI.
>>
Also, Heisenberg nearly nuked them. His reactor melted down and destroyed his lab, thus putting an end to the Nazi A-bomb effort. He could not get any funding after that.
>>
>>685119199
They didn't know how to make it into a bomb, not because they didn't want too.
>>
>>685118703
comparing the v2 to a cruise missile LAOHAHAHFAHFHAFHADSHFDSHFGSDLKGHSDKL:GHSDF:GKHJSDFKg
>>
>>685110759
The USA stole the knowledge needed to build a nuke from the germans.
>>
>>685121074
Yea, all he did was wrote the book on tank warefare.
>>
>>685121074
I think most of the information decoded by the Polish was given to their petty civilian militias who proceeded to harass German supply lines going to the Russian front.
>>
>>685121354
Not true. It was the jew! Einstein, Edward Teller. . . etc
>>
>>685107773
That would be US Army.
>>685116145
By that logic Russian army was the best, because they had the most people in it. Sure, half of them didn't have guns - but we're judging armies, not weapons, amirite?

Look, difference between having nukes and not having them is like difference between having guns and throwing stones at the enemy. Or having tanks and charging at tanks on horseback. Pretty motherfucking significant. If Germany didn't surrender, and US would drop the nuke on Berlin, that would be pretty bad.
>>
>>685121241

Heisenberg when captured was still estimated to be a couple years away from a bomb, both in the engineering and the physics.

As far as funding goes, his political failing was partially that he was apolitical (and actually a bit sore on the expulsion of Jewish academics), partially that he was overoptimistic about everything he did.
>>
>>685121398
I think he did more than write a book, he was Marshall of the army during the civil war, Russia would have beaten Poland in the civil war of the 20s had it not been for Stalin disobeying him and marching south. Zhukov was the most prominent Marshall during the 2nd world war, and he was a pupil of Tukhachevsky, an interesting fact about him is that he was one of the only men truly feared by Stalin, scary mother fucker
>>
>>685121574
Funny because it's true. A majority of the scientists working on the nuclear bomb were jews. My high school chemistry teacher let us watch a documentary on it.
>>
>>685119753

The Polish "cracked" a civilian version of the mission which lacked the plug board in the bottom.

It was only the English who cracked the naval Enigma machine as it had a 4th rotor.

Also I was never arguing what the "oldest" computer was. If we are talking about predicting solar events then I would argue that I could class the pyramid of Giza and Mayan stone wheels under that too, as they predicted astronomical events as well.
>>
>>685121716
>expulsion of Jewish academics
it was deeper than that. Nazis declared bunch of scientific theories "Jewish science" which set Nazi sciences a lot back.
>>
>>685108575
>I'm better than all the others around me
>I'm just not better than all the others together
You must keep telling yourself that's why you have a shitty life
>>
>>685121736
to add to my point, if Tukhachevsky beat Poland in the 20s, Russia would have marched all the way to Berlin and Hitler would have probably died in the 20s.

>>685121854
I know the English cracked the naval enigma at Bletchley, but the definition of computer, like the definition of engine, predates 20th and 21st century definitions of being electrical and running off petrol
>>
>>685121854
I think he was suggesting the computers have been around since before the 1940's, although they may not be our modern interpretation of them.
>>
File: Герр майор.jpg (135KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Герр майор.jpg
135KB, 1280x720px
>>685107773
Yes they were Gentlemen!
>>
Deutschland über alles.
>>
>>685121458
>information decoded by the Polish was given to their petty civilian militias

Actually none of the information decoded by the Polish was given to either their military or civilian government -- even that regarding the imminent invasion -- because everyone knew that resistance was futile. Instead, information relevant outside of Poland was passed on to a British spy network, and arrangements were made to transport the bombes, codebreakers, and engineers to Britain before the invasion.

There was literally a desk drawer in the head of intelligence's office filled with the decoded German messages that were never passed on -- basically if any tactical information was responded to preemptively the Germans might suspect their code was broken.

The Germans only lost confidence in the original enigma iirc as late as 1941. That's when they started beefing up the complexity of the machine itself, but still the engineering and cipher concept were the same, so the British computers could still crack the code, albeit it took them a lot longer and they needed longer messages.
>>
>>685110585
Russia had huge aid given to it by the allies, they also have a huge amount of young men to send to their death. They would have been crushed.
>>
>>685122783
I stand corrected.
>>
>>685122907
they had millions more men, also the aid given to Russia wasn't that great or important, and before you start trying to claim that aid saved Russia, the only reason that aid was given was because the West wouldn't open a second front until 1944, pretty much because the Allies were worried that Stalin would conquer Europe
>>
>>685107773
They were until many less powerful nations banded together to rape the fatherland
>>
>>685123143
Essentially. The US and Britain wanted to invade the USSR after the war was over but couldn't because Russia still outnumber them in terms of military. I think the planed invasion was called operation "Unexpected" or something.
>>
File: 1452985785505.jpg (1MB, 2560x1600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452985785505.jpg
1MB, 2560x1600px
best tanks
>>
>>685123444
Nice trips, I'm not too sure about that sounds kind of bizarre, I've never heard anything about that, the general consensus was for universal peace after the war, the UN, EU, NATO, etc etc these are all evidence of inter-governmental co operation through association, Britain certainly never would have had the ability to invade a country following the war, it had bankrupted the country, and decolonisation was inevitable
>>
>>685123728
Wasn't decolonization due in-part to the US government as well?
>>
>>685123444
but you are right in that by the end of the war, Russia was a superpower, most of the satellite countries of the SU in Eastern Europe became so because the Russians had boots on the ground all over Europe
>>
>>685123728
also,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Unthinkable

not that Wikipedia is a credible source though
>>
>>685123936
Yes well de colonisation happened for loads of reasons, for one India was promised independence in exchange for continued support during the war, also yes the Americans funded practically most of Europe by the end of the war, the Marshall Plan gave Britain 3.75 billion dollars, so the foreign policy for near every European country not behind the iron curtain was to appease America, which wanted closer political and economic ties in Europe

>>685124047
Oh wow this looks interesting, thanks I'll read this tonight
>>
nope, America present day would rape them

If it's just about most power vs time of period, it would have to be either alexander the great, or napoleon before he invaded russia
>>
Hitler was irrational, and relied on the occult for guidance in making decisions. Some BS ancient pagan shit.
>>
At the time, yes they were.

Of all time, no way. The US could declare war on the entire world tomorrow and win. Warfare today is more technology based than troop strength/training. The US Navy is the most dominating unit the world has ever seen.

>inb4 nukes

Nukes would be suicide. The US has nuclear capabilities on nearly every part of the globe including all waterways. If one was shot at them, they'd retaliate and it would be game over
>>
>>685124152
Oh, I see
>>
Think about this. What sort of a "master race" genius marries his cousin? Was he trying to create superior retards?
>>
Yes.

3 vs what, like 15 countries, 2 of them are superpowers.

NAZI Germany alone is a superpower compared to its retarded axis bros.

When Japan spits on US (Hawai bombing), Hitler shouldn't have declared war on the US to show sympathy and camaraderie. That was fucking stupid. Going to war against two superpowers, WELL OF COURSE YOU WOULD FUCKING LOSE. CHRIST.
>>
>>685124269
untrue about the occult. Hitler relied on nobody but himself, Stalin understood that he wasn't a military commander, Hitler fervently believed he was a capable commander, would literally take absolutely no advice from anybody, he believed his ideas came to him from some kind of divine power, this was true in every aspect of Hitler's life, for example nobody wrote his speeches, he would lock himself in his room for hours, probably just sleeping, he was a very lazy man, but he would piss out a speech, for war, his generals for example Manstein didn't argue enough with Hitler over key decisions, ie Stalingrad. 90,000 soldiers trapped, and Hitler ordered them to stay within the city, rather than try and break out and reach the German relief forces. His generals understood the importance of the decisions at the time, but were too feeble to argue with hitler, leading to terrible decisions. Stalin was surrounded with yes men, but for Zhukov who would argue ferociously with Stalin, and Stalin was smart enough to know that he wasn't a military man, he was a politician.


>>685124625
Hitler wasn't aryan, he couldn't even prove he wasn't of Jewish heritage
>>
Hitler was a modern day scientologist....Fucked from the start. Anyways, I enjoy watching the German hangings on YouTube
>>
>>685124992
He didn't even have his German citizenship until 1932.
>>
>>685124433
I highly doubt the US could withstand a war against the rest of the world.
>>
>>685124047
>not that Wikipedia is a credible source though

Oh fuck off with this meme. It cites credible sources thoroughly in-line. Almost no other source other than a dry academic publication or textbook does that.
>>
>>685125482
historiography is the term for basically when historians near fabricate stories in a bid to sell. Wikipedia is largely made up of loose internet articles, quoting other internet articles, it isn't peer reviewed, and if you're quoting internet articles, you obviously don't know your shit, wikipedia is like spark notes, good to read for bitesize but doesn't really add up to anything.
>>
>>685125482
maybe just to highlight what i mean more, the wikipedia article in question cites 4 books, all dated between 2006-2013, one with the title 'the third world war' - does that sound like a genuine history book or a book you buy at the airport??
>>
>>685125179
Fuck Off!! .....Tom Cruise
>>
Germany wouldn't fuck with the US one on one. Sure they were more advanced technologically but they can't match US production.

Like if Germany makes 1 tank the US can make 10.
>>
>>685125934
reading all your posts gives me hope that maybe
everyone who browses /b/ isnt entirely autistic
>>
>>685126517
no problem, although i've learned some history here too today
>>
>>685125770
>made up of loose internet articles
Reliable sources are required. That means established publications for facts and experts or influential names for interpretations.
>if you're quoting internet articles, you obviously don't know your shit
Editors quote articles and books for interpretations and context -- you are not allowed to provide your own -- it's not a blog.

>>685125934
>4 books, all dated between 2006-2013, one with the title 'the third world war'
The article subject was declassified in 1998, so of course the books are all recent. That book, if you bothered to look it up, is by an academic on the Cold War.
>>
>>685127281
This is cute that you are defending Wikipedia, I would like to see you try and submit a real historical paper and defend Wikipedia there.

In the 90s loads of information was declassified regarding the Cold War, in particular about whether the Stalinist regime ruled with popular support or through fear. A whole batch of books was released, I have just finished reading number 16, claiming that actually people actively spoke out about Stalin and that resistance to Stalin in the Soviet Union was incredibly common, and in fact formed a key part of Soviet life. Of course this is not true, don't believe everything you read. Even historians get it wrong, I didn't bother to look it up because I know that there wasn't a third world war, you should be smart enough to know that too, but maybe seeing as you're here, start reading my other posts and learn something
>>
>>685125317
Shows a lack of understanding of the sheer magnitude of the US military.
>>
>>685129183
shows a lack of understanding of America's economic climate, and how most of it is owned by the people it would wage war on
>>
>>685127855
>Of course this is not true
Are you a historian with proper context of primary sources? If you're doubtful, check academic reviews online -- there will be plenty.

>Even historians get it wrong
That's why it's good to have a site that presents multiple academic interpretations. When another interpretation comes up from an academic source, an editor can add it to an article. If another editor calls bullshit, they can only do so if they can find an academic criticism of that source (again, there are plenty for every book).

>I didn't bother to look it up because I know that there wasn't a third world war
So you literally judged a book by its cover? More to the point, you didn't stop to think that maybe it was in reference to the hypothetical scenario contextualizing literally every Cold War strategy document?
>>
File: 1461524932310.jpg (761KB, 2048x1360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1461524932310.jpg
761KB, 2048x1360px
>>685107773

dom·i·nant
ˈdämənənt/Submit
adjective
1.
most important, powerful, or influential.

So NO they were not
Also
They lost like a bunch of hicks in a basketball game
Lmfao
>>
>>685125317
Who cares
>>
>>685129486
i'm not arguing the uses of Wikipedia, i even gave you a use of it. I use it myself, I'm just trying to tell you, you've never read anything from a book, that has been written by an author who used Wikipedia. Wikipedia is an organisation, not an institution. It therefore can never be legitimately used academically because it is published by an Organisation, not an institution, like a University, this is the principle on which medicine, science, history has progressed in Early Modern Europe.
>>
>>685129486
>hypothetical scenario

so it's a book about a hypothetical scenario? Isn't that called fiction? For someone who types dense paragraphs of text, you sure don't read much
>>
What of Hitler's drug abuse towards the end? Did this contribute to his irrationality?
>>
Both the T-34 and M10 were better than anything the Nazis had.
>>
>>685130152
Doubt it, I don't know too much about the ins and outs, but for all of Hitler's role during the war, him taking drugs would not have made any impression, he was inherently lazy and was a corporal, not a general. Drugs wouldn't have changed that

>>685129486
Why do you suppose that more people know about the cuban missile crisis than the supposed invasion of russia by britain and america? Because one actually happened, was experienced by people, recorded at the time, was commented on at the time, was evaluated afterwards by historians from institutions funded to advance human understanding. Not a company on a website that relies on user donations, and user input, using 4 books (you don't understand how insignificant 4 books are when you are trying to tell me that there was nearly a third world war in 1945.
>>
>>685130152
hitler was abusing drugs from the start at the behest of some quack doctor

hitler and all his stooges were looney tunes
>>
>>685130597
He was obsessed with building big things (?!?!). The Gustav, the Panzer VIII Mouse, the Bismark. . . It just isn't practical for mobile warfare at the time.
>>
>>685130597
to put 4 books in context, in the past 2 weeks i have read 4 times that many on a different issue, which would make me the absolute supreme master of all knowledge in that field, but i'm not, am i?

also your naive wikipedia defense mechanism has forgotten the fact that being a historian is a job, you have to produce, you cannot write a book on something already written, you must find something new, something worth purchasing to feed your family. This is why I said that historians cannot always be trusted, but like always i have to spell it out for your retarded brain, how about you go read that article on wikipedia and see how much you learn


>>685131092
the whole big building thing is a result of the German belief in being supreme. They believed they could shock and awe the world into submission, the Bismarck wasn't a bad idea, it took an enormous effort to sink it, and the war in the Atlantic was very nearly won because of the Turpitz and Bismarck, which sunk the British flagship in a single shot. There's no connection to drug use, just their fanaticism that they could achieve more
>>
>>685107773
clearly not
>>
American Generals were superior. MacArthur, Bradley, Ike and of course Patton. They feared Patton. The British had Mongomery, he was ok.
>>
>>685108183

>russia
kek
>>
>>685131521
also it's worth mentioning, a lot of these colossal projects were propaganda machines, they influenced the Germans to fight as fanatically as they did, which contributed a lot to their war effort, but yeah a lot of their war effort was wasted on things like attachments to allow you to shoot round corners, which are pretty useless, but under Albert Spier, armament production was actually increasing towards the end of the war
>>
>>685129908
>Wikipedia ... can never be legitimately used academically

No shit. It's an encyclopedia. You use encyclopedias for quick reference and referrals to other sources.

>>685130597
>you don't understand how insignificant 4 books are
Historians didn't know about the operation until 1998, dude. How can you compare the scholarly research on that, the source for which is a single set of papers and nobody alive to interview, to the Cuban Missile Crisis (the article for which has a shitload of sources)?

Your argument is simply moronic.
>>
>>685109846

without jews you wouldn't have the internet you fucking nigger
>>
>>685131521
The Bismark was obsolete. It was sunk by a torpedo. Air power made it vulnerable. I don't think that the Nazis even had a single aircraft carrier.
>>
>>685130012
>so it's a book about a hypothetical scenario?

Now I know you're trolling -- nobody's reading comprehension is that low.
>>
>>685107773

look...the fact of the matter is that you obviously can't conquer the world by yourself. the germans were retarded if they thought they could.

they failed in every way possible to use diplomacy to gain the help of other useful nations, and were defeated because of their failure.

military might is not the only thing that wins wars, they were stupid to not realize that.
>>
>>685131956
Germany was a continental power, not a sea power why would it have an aircraft carrier? where would it go with it? Why do you think they aligned with Japan?

It was sunk by a torpedo yes, but when? How many years did it take until that happened? Just because it was destroyed easily doesn't mean it didn't dominate, and wasn't a naval priority of the British. Ever heard of the achilles heel?
>>
>>685132058
okay then when did the third world war start?
>>
>>685132058
also i'm currently writing a book on how the third world war nearly started in 2003, when America invaded Iraq, which had nuclear weapons
>>
File: frrr.jpg (787KB, 1580x2080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
frrr.jpg
787KB, 1580x2080px
>>685132148

Bismark barely lasted six months. Complete was of time/resources. Epic fail.
>>
>>685132148
It was launched Feb 14, 1939 and was sunk May 27, 1941. Short lifespan for a weapon that dominated. My point was that it was made obsolete by air power. Aircraft carriers allow you to project that power.
>>
>>685107773
well obviously not, because they fucking lost.

smh
>>
>>685132603
aircraft carrier but where? In the British channel? Good idea.

>>685132523
sunk the british flagship though
>>
BTW, anyone seen that Netflix comedy called "Look Who's Back?". It's hilarious. It's about Hitler waking up in today'so Germany.
>>
>>685132603
you keep making points, you don't answer any of my questions though, that is how i know you don't know what you're talking about. Anybody can regurgitate information. copy and paste init. But you can't analyse or weigh up anything because you don't know what you're talking about. Why don't you answer some of my questions?
>>
File: 1412091296683.jpg (345KB, 920x1211px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1412091296683.jpg
345KB, 920x1211px
>>685133119

one obsolete weapon destroyed another before failing. Your point?
>>
>>685132603
aircraft carriers are more of a modern thing. Only america and japan had one, Britain, the naval empire didn't have one. Why would Germany build one? The germans never had any air power, they lost the battle of britain, Goering was a fucking idiot
Thread posts: 174
Thread images: 29



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.