Would an average guy consider it "creepy" if the girl

Abort!!!!

>>16543944
I would laugh my ass off if I thought it was a joke.

Pregnant chicks turn me on, so my dick would be diamond hard

It depends on if the two of you have talked about children previously. If it's clear this is a fetish thing and there is a very minimal chance of actually getting pregnant than I doubt many guys would care.

Personally in that situation I would nail her to bed with the force of my orgasm, god damn

If it wasnt something we talked about first? Run for the hills.

If it was just a fantasy of hers and she communicated like an adult, probably pretty sexy.

I'd pass it off as an "in the moment" outburst. Would probably crack up, though.

>>16543944
I'd give her every drop that's my fetish

If she doesn't have kids and it would be in the realm of her behavior, I'd still laugh and pump even harder.

If she was a shy, quiet , introvert in bed and suddenly yelled that - Id put another condom on, pump harder and run away after.

I'm going to try this one later just to see what happens.

>>16543944
No. That's hot talk. As ling as I knew that its just talk. And I trusted the girl enough not to poke holes in the condom or something like that.

I'd fly into a frenzy of lust and then when my rational brain comes back consider everything

Why not just tell him to shoot his manjuice deep inside you? Similar effect without the "has she gone off the pill" anxiety.