>good isekai doesn't exi-

Gate is shit though.

>>161147860
Well, finish the sentence.

>>161147860
Keep talking, i see nothing disagreeing with your statement.

>>161147860
>Decide to watch a shitty action anime
>Heard Gate was shitty action anime
>Watch it
>Actually more a hearts and minds show
Was pleasantly surprised, season 2 was fucking trash though

>>161147881

It was a good way to keep /k/ and /pol/ busy.

>>161147860
all it would take to make gate decent is have the jsdf actually take some casualties

also why did the anime cut all the loli gore vore out?

>>161147860
Nippon invented human rights.

>>161147860
Why do you have to falseflag the show, I actually liked it.
Fuck you.

File: 30645f28520756122631a8347cd0d608.jpg (161KB, 576x814px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 576x814px

this one was good isekai and even reverse isekai

>>161147860
Not every premise that involves an alternate world is an isekai.

>>161148383
That's literally what it means though?

>>161148442
Is Dragonball an isekai?

>>161147860
I need more anime where modern tech is fucking shit up in a fantasy world.

File: 1502674906602.png (128KB, 239x327px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 239x327px

>>161147932
>season 2 was fucking trash though
After they killed the dragon it all went downhill

File: GATE in a nutshell.webm (3MB, 840x473px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 840x473px

>>161148844
The raid on the Capital was pretty awesome

>>161148878
I liked the one where the japs lived out some Apocalypse Now power fantasy and fucking slaughtered the raiders with their attack choppers

>>161147860
It's a meh isekai.
Shit would have been better if Itami and a few of his men can't get resupplied and have to combine modern strategies with medieval+magic strategy.

>>161149091
That's what happens later on in the books, from what I heard.

Cute out the waifu shit and the JDF wankfest and it might have been a decent show

File: ara ara [sips from mug].png (374KB, 870x720px) Image search: [Google]

374KB, 870x720px

>>161149119
>cut out the waifu shit
>implying that wasn't the best part

File: (LOL).jpg (757KB, 1450x2150px) Image search: [Google]

757KB, 1450x2150px

>>161147962

>>161147860
-st

>>161149217
The Japanese have one significant advantage in that regard. They don't seem to be interested in colonizing the place.

File: 1365738587693.jpg (76KB, 1024x600px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 1024x600px

>>161147860

>>161147860
>Anything from the current isekai wave
>Good
Try going back a decade or 2 when they weren't all self-aware otaku bait.

The only redeeming quality is they got military equipment semi accurately, at least when compared to say OH EVERY SINGLE OTHER ANIME
The rest is irredeemable trash

>>161149217
>tfw no American version of Gate
>giving FREEDOM to a fantasy world
>FUCK YEAH AMERICA
>FUCK YEAH BURGERS
>USA USA USA
>tfw jews will run the isekai world too

It was okay, but the whole thing felt like an attempt to give the JSDF positive press. I get that the author of the novels is ex-JSDF, but it didn't have to be so ham-fisted.

>>161149254
>They don't seem to be interested in colonizing the place.
You mean 'not any more'

>>161149404
>Lt. Pain is a fantasy nerd instead of otaku
Might work

gate is Japanese propaganda; it's not a good show.

>>161149404
We're living in the american version of Gate

>>161148148
What exactly is reverse isekai? A fairey tale character is brought into the real world?

>>161149446
>orc girl
>goblin girl
>centaur girl
>free girl
>dwarf girl
>ogre girl
>monkey girl that nobody realizes is not actually sentient

>>161148878
Game?

File: f4ac56aa3146301a93f544c8e431b786--devil-part-timer-anime-animals.jpg (32KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 640x360px

>>161149482
Exactly

>>161147860
HAHAHAHA

...HA

>>161149526
Darkest of days

>>161149482
yes

in the case of Gundam Build Fighters, a prince from a fantasy kingdom gets transported to Earth to become the master of playing with plastic toys.

At the end, he and the main badguy go back to their world with their respective waifus. In which case the waifus get regular isekai'd

>>161149579
>tfw Reiji actually impregnates his waifu

>>161149567
S2 never.

So when is season 3 coming out?

>>161149574
The game ends with a cliffhanger and I don't think we are getting a second one. A lot of nostalgia from this one. It was bad but I liked it a lot

File: Nabiki-Tendo-akane-tendo-_the-red-heaven-way-29255972-500-372 (1).jpg (38KB, 500x372px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 500x372px

>implying gate is better than el hazard

>>161149482
already been several. Demon king working in restaurants and demon princess working in 7-11 and shit

>>161149710
>implying El Hazard is better than Sen to Chihiro

>>161149738
Not sure how that is implied

File: b3d52dbe9220bcb8a2c112ed78d4e3f9.jpg (34KB, 564x752px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 564x752px

>>161149710
implying gate was any good at all lol

>>161149421
Haha no shit? Did nobody tell him the JSDF has zero experience in real world ops? Even in coop training with the USA they're bumbling retards. Nationalism is a helluva drug.

>>161147860
To fully appreciate GATE, you need to see "Starship Tropers", and "Jew Suess" first and understand, why the first is a parody of propaganda, and why the second one is the nastiest piece of propaganda ever made.

If you understand this, then you can appreciate, how GATE takes the things that "Starship Tropers" made fun of, and plays them completely straight like "Jew Suess".

It's 100% military propaganda. And it's absolutely hilarious. When I watch it, I just stop laughing at how blatant it is.
>it was used as recruitment material irl desu

>>161149058
Apocalypse Now wasn't supposed to be a power fantasy.

>>161147881
>/pol/
Wait what ? That would be Youjo Senki.

>>161149821
of course not, but the way the japs re-enacted that famous scene certainly was.

>tfw not enough Rory lewds

>>161149821
No but the scene in GATE where they recreate Apocalypse Now is a power fantasy

>>161149257
The world needs more Muvluv Isekai

>>161147860
To be honest I like the idea, but since this is japan they HAD TO throw in animu bullshit like elf waifus, 10000 years old lolis and jailbaits.
Remove all that pointless crap and this could've been a nice "humanity fuck yeah !" anime.

File: 1497382442809.png (86KB, 404x277px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 404x277px

Why did people sperg out over the artstyle of the anime while praising the manga when the manga art is pretty damn bad?

>>161149869
MuvLuv will always be the best Isekai, it's virtually impossible to surpass that, so why should anyone try?

File: 1452229755544.png (1MB, 828x1143px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 828x1143px

>>161149894
because anime was shit. get over it

>>161149894
50% trolling
30% innate hate for A1
20% legitimately preferring manga style because reasons.

>>161149901
I don't know which is worse SAO fans or MuvLuv fans, hard to tell which ones have their head further up their own ass.

>>161149404
Nah, a lot of books about some warship/town/whatever transported back in time to spread Freedom.
The mechanism is different but the meat of those stories is pretty similar.

File: 1473105434873.gif (855KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

855KB, 500x281px

To be honest, I liked log horizon a lot, there was a chance for a lot of books to be adapted since it was state sponsored I think. Shame the author was caught with tax evasion. Kind of ironic when you think about it.

>>161149617
Did you mean S3?

>>161150020
But, but, MuvLuv deserves the praise it gets

I was really excited at the premise and the guns shooting things part was not half bad (e.g. the artillery was pretty well portrayed and generally the jsdf wasn't half retarded what with all the helos firing hellfires at melee range nowadays), but it quickly turned downhill.

File: 1482224067622.png (135KB, 366x344px) Image search: [Google]

135KB, 366x344px

>>161150020
>SAO fans
No one unironically likes SAO anymore. They're too afraid of getting murdered by Digibro fanboys.

>>161150307
Don't bring that retarded faggot to /a/.

File: distressed fiddy.png (215KB, 419x419px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 419x419px

>>161150038
Maou-sama doesn't have an S2.

>>161150357
Stop being so fiddy.

>>161150357
This meme doesn't work for every show.
S2 wasn't nearly bad enough to use it.

File: gate.jpg (235KB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]

235KB, 1200x900px

What ould you have changed?
>International team in the special region ala Stargate Atlantis
>More focus on different story arcs from different people
That "I wanna burn everything" bunnygirl is not enough
>No harem tropes
You can keep everything else with cat girls etc. but dont enmass a harem raound one protag. Instead get creative. Have one interprator of the exploration team do some shit in some larger village that is rather important geographically wise and end up marring the leaders daughter or something without notecing first. Just not an group of tropes swarming over one person.
>NotRomans actually be able resist, do guerillia attack, maybe even capture some equipment
Briliant military leaders would not hurt either
>Have magic be the wildcard against modern military

>>161149793
A more obvious and direct comparison is Stargate. Gate might as well be Stargate with a coat of fantasy paint and a slightly smaller harem of love interests.

File: 0fd29ad42312151b1704b9a11612fb714a810018.png (75KB, 380x296px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 380x296px

>>161147860
It's not an isekai though.

The MC isn't killed and reincarnated into a different world.

>>161150392
If magic were actually useful, the military base wouldn't be maintainable.
There is no middle-ground for magic. Either it's useless or it's overpowered.

>>161150388
Now I looked it up and it seems I may have Altheimer's.
I was sure it had two seasons.
Was it split cour at least?
Maybe I dropped it and picked up later?
w/e I have no real excuse

File: gits-13.jpg (72KB, 600x324px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 600x324px

>>161147860
I think GATE would've been a lot more interesting if it was a 1940s era army invading the fantasy world rather than a modern military.

That or a more futuristic army, decades or hundreds of years more advanced than ours invading it.

>>161147860
>Posts one the crappyest Iskai series there is.

Obvious bait is obvious.

>>161150421
That trope is common for isekai, but it doesn't define the genre. There's plenty of "person summoned from another world to be a hero" stories that are also considered isekai despite the MC not technically dying to get there.

>>161150421
you don't necessarily need to die to get transported to the other world.

>>161147860
>GEIT
>good
quit smoking pot

>>161150421
Reincarnation is a subgenre of isekai.

>>161147860
It's not very good, but I certainly had fun reading it. I may just be a sucker for military stuff, but some of the uses of modern weaponry were pretty entertaining.

Pretty sure "When I was summoned to another world with RPG style, [Likes NTR] skill appeared" is the correct answer here.

>>161150392
>harem
barely relevant in GATE, meme'ing otherwise is bad and you should feel bad

>>Have magic be the wildcard against modern military
That was sorely missing. Or maybe I felt that way because I was expecting it.

>>161150446
>a lot more interesting
With Starcraft Terrans or something? Hell no.
And a 1940s army wouldn't have helped either. The show needed to be re-written outright.

>>161147860
>Isekai
Don't you mean 'military power fantasy'?

>>161150431
All a matter of scaling. Magic can still be rare or hard or make you fatigued fast, but still be useful to make somone invisible, fall to sleep, long range survey or whatever. It does not have to be a magical nuke

>>161150701
If you can make somebody invisible and the enemy relies on explosives you don't need a nuke. You just blow up their depot.