How shallow must you be to think this is better than the

It's surprisingly fairly good besides some of the CGI. I also didn't like how they handled Desler or Analyzer. The original is better, but the remake is worth watching too imo.

How shallow must you be to think this isn't good based on some character design changes.

>>160887925
>there is fanservice, this means its bad
How often must you have gotten dropped as a child to reach that conclusion?

>>160887925
>>160888128
Oh and yes, its vastly superior to the original. The conclusion of 2199 still lacks something, but holy shit are the final episodes bad in the original. Whoever wrote the script for e26 back then must have been suffering from some severe mental disability.

>>160888233
Hmm? The ending of the original season one is fine besides the asspull of Yuki coming back to life.

>>160887925
you must hate everything ever made after 1999

>>160888266
This isnt about the story you fucking retard, its about the writing and the order of events. E26 in 2199 is so much better directed and has way better pacing than it did in the original. The final episode in the original is a fucking insult, thats how bad and unsatisfying it is.

>>160888277
Fanservice was just as common in the 80s/90s as it is now. You literally have panty shots of Kiki (inb4 "no dude those are bloomers XDDD")

>>160887925
>the adventures of space battle ship which gets almost destroyed every battle and gets magically repaired after and also have infinite disposable crew and materials for repair
>good

Nah. But girls are okay.

>>160887925
The original is a mess. 2199 does at better job at telling a story.

>>160887925
I only watched this because of the Rei doujins
worth

>>160888369
I'm obviously inviting you to elaborate what you mean here. It's been a long while since I've watched the show, but I don't remember anything terribly egregious as long as you accept the premise of the Battleship being super invincible and all that.

>The final episode in the original is a fucking insult, thats how bad and unsatisfying it is.
But it's not actually the final episode because there are two more seasons after it as well as a bunch of movies.

>>160888409

2199 tells a worse story.

2199 has some immense fat ass though, so good. XEBEC delivers at what they're good at.

>>160888440
>I'm obviously inviting you to elaborate what you mean here
I am not gonna humor your shit taste. When I say that pacing and order of events are bad then you should understand what I am referring to if youve actually watched both shows. However, if you already start this with "I dont really remember since Ive watched it ages ago" how could you possibly be in a position to EVER JUDGE 2199 in comparison to the original? If you cant even remember the shows fucking conclusion/final episode, why would I ever believe that you remember ANYTHING from the show at all? Oh right, probably because you dont. You either havent watched it and just pretend to have done so to appear "patrician" and "special" or youve watched it as a kid so arent in a position to properly judge it to begin with. The originals E26 is so overloaded with shit that the pacing is completely off.

>But it's not actually the final episode
>dude its just the final episode of the 26ep season for what was like 4 years until the sequel aired that uses the same content as 2199 but for some reason the fact that its infinitely worse than the ending of 2199 isnt legit as a point of criticism

>>160888689
>2199 tells a worse story.
You suffer from mental retardation, thats all there is to it.

>>160887925
Because it IS better. The pacing in the original was much slower. Also the babes don't hurt.

>>160888729
>You suffer from mental retardation, thats all there is to it.

You've never seen the original.

>>160888729
Why can't you just present an argument? Yamato is an ancient show and I've watched it years ago. I can't possibly remember every detail which is why I'm asking you to elaborate.

File: mpv-shot_[project-gxs] Uchuu Senkan Yamato - 26 [10bit BD 1080p] [73E285A0]_00_22_23.png (4MB, 1440x1080px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 1440x1080px

>>160888758
Is that it? The best you can do?

>>160888811

You think 2199 actually tells a better story, please perform at a mentally higher level.

>>160888426
Good taste

>>160887925
Its ok desu senpai

File: 1496983106060.jpg (85KB, 714x480px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 714x480px

>>160888088
>>160888128
>>160888233
>>160888369
>>160888378
>>160888409
>>160888729
>>160888732
>secondaries

>>160888809
Because I will not waste my time listing details. Why would I SPECIFALLY list every single fucking scene when you can take E26 of both shows, mirror watch them and instantly see why I say that its cramped? If I tell you that the pacing is shit, that the order of events is questionable, that the overall conclusion is lackluster, then what else do you need me to do? Do you not even remember that Yuki dies in the middle of the ep and is resurrected like 7 minutes later? Or that chase, final battle, yukis death and resurrection, final conversation between kodai and okita, desslers death as well as arrival are cramped into the same ep? Oh right, you cant recall that. Youre just blinded by rose tinted glasses and want others to point out the obvious issues while you cant even recall the fucking order of events.

>>160888849
>>160889037
This ultimate same fagging from some cocksucking nigger who probably thinks that everything from the 70s-90s is good. Are you the same disabled spastic who claims that RoV is the best historical show, Akage ga Anne the best SoL or Future Boy Conan the best adventure story in anime? Whats next? You gonna tell us that Gunbuster is good?

File: GREAT AND HONOURABLE CHAIRMAN DESSLER.gif (3MB, 461x334px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 461x334px

>>160889082

You seem angry.

CHAIRMAN DESSLER BANZAI

BANZAI

>>160889102
>You seem angry.
At this point its fair to say that I legitimately am.

>>160889082
>If I tell you that the pacing is shit, that the order of events is questionable, that the overall conclusion is lackluster, then what else do you need me to do?
Explain what you mean because I can just say that the pacing was great, the order of events is excellent and the conclusion was fabulous and it's just as valid of an argument.

>Do you not even remember that Yuki dies in the middle of the ep and is resurrected like 7 minutes later?
I mentioned that in my first post.

>Or that chase, final battle, yukis death and resurrection, final conversation between kodai and okita, desslers death as well as arrival are cramped into the same ep?
How were they crammed? Like I said, I agree that Yuki's death/ressurrection was silly but everything else was good. They were building to that the entire series.

File: CHAR.gif (489KB, 320x242px) Image search: [Google]

489KB, 320x242px

>>160889144

>>160889153
>I mentioned that in my first post.
No you didnt. You said that the resurrection itself was questionable which I never claimed you illiterate monkey. This isnt about the event itself, its about the order of events and the pacing related to them. I pray to god that English isnt your first language because your reading comprehension skills are on the level of a fucking 4th grader.

>>160889253
That's a lot of assumptions you are marking there. How do you not know that one of my issues with the resurrection wasn't the fact that it happened so soon after her "death?"

>>160889253

Funny how you're dogging the originals pacing issues in the LAST episodes where they are wrapping everything up compared with 2199 which was dogged with pacing issues throughout as they tried to cram in too many plot threads since they were taking material from too many sources and introduced too many new characters while trying to keep the oldies (the new fapbait girls should have taken the stage from the OG crew, would have centralized focus).

>>160889318
>besides the asspull of Yuki coming back to life
Yea, this TOTALLY related to the pacing. Absolutely.

>>160888233
The original was cancelled so they tried to savage and cram a bunch of plot points into the remaining episodes.

File: 1431406094080.gif (2MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 640x360px

it had some good asspects

>>160889359
Are you bad at English? How does that statement exclude the possibility of pacing being part of the event?

>>160889405
>part of the event
part of my complaint*

>>160889388
I dont really see how that speaks in its favor?! If you do a shit job then you do a shit job.

>>160889405
>asspull
>ever relating to pacing and not the event itself
Ok, that confirms it. Youre fucking illiterate.

>madass secondaries: the thread

>>160889388
>The original was cancelled

I don't recall hearing this, got a source?

>>160889441
>I dont really see how that speaks in its favor?!
You were insulting the staff itself.

>>160889441
Amusing. You can't let go of your mistaken assumptions, so you go on to rewrite how English is generally interpreted. I made a broad statement about an event that can encompass a wide range of possibilities.

>>160889512
It's true. It was cut from 39 to 26 episodes.

>>160889549
>It's true. It was cut from 39 to 26 episodes.

I looked it up and seems legit, but holy fuck:

>The 13 episodes would have introduced Captain Harlock as a new series character.

It's a very good thing it was cut, Harlock would have stolen too much thunder and also deserved his own show by itself that touches on completely different themes. Complete mismatch.

>>160889512
http://ourstarblazers.com/vault/576/

This isn't specifically about the cancellation, but about a big element from the original plans that was cut (Mamoru Kodai becoming Harlock). That's the only reason he survived and why he just appears out of nowhere alive in the original tv series and doesn't do anything.

>>160889518
Ok, let me elaborate: If youre forced to conclude something and do a bad job at doing so then it doenst suddenly improve the experience. Every studio is "forced" to do stuff constantly. If you have rush job animation then you were forced to speed up the production process, to give another example. Does that suddenly mean that you as a viewer will simply ignore those flaws when assessing the quality of the show? No you wont. They are still as blatant.

>>160889549
>>160889153
>I mentioned that in my first post.
>>160888266
>the asspull of Yuki coming back to life
This doesnt refer to the pacing, it refers to the event itself. There isnt the tiniest implication of anything else. But then you go from "I mentioned that in my first post." to this
>>160889405
>How does that statement exclude
You claimed to have MENTIONED something. Mentioning is not the same as IMPLYING or LEAVING TO IMAGINATION or not mentioning at all just to later on claim that you didnt exclude it you fucking retard.

>>160887925
I loved it and I'm not into women. The original is off-putting with designs like >>160888811

>>160889697

>not loving good ol' matsumoto potato folk

how dare you

>>160889665
This is some severe autism and I don't say that lightly.

>besides the asspull of Yuki coming back to life
Very simply means that I found that part of the episode to be silly and done poorly. I called it an asspull to point out the biggest obvious problem with it, but that doesn't mean it's the only problem I had with it.

File: 5688-2097336907.jpg (241KB, 968x492px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 968x492px

>>160889697
I am shit talking the original here and I dont get this. He basically looks the same 2199

File: 135151.jpg (55KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 640x480px

>>160889793

>his pet fucking PIG was made into that busty medic girl character

literal breeding sow, bravo xebec. b r a v o.

>>160889665
You're saying all these things, but still not actually elaborating on why the pacing in particular is abd rather than saying that it is.

Please do. We'll gladly listen.

>>160889082
You're just mad Sanada stole the show with his mirror shield that was never mentioned again.
Xebec hated Sanada and never let him take the spotlight.