Is KnJ the greatest loli manga of all time?

MnR, but it ends in a few chapters.

File: a1efbe68.jpg (20KB, 500x465px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 500x465px

>>159636289
Too much blatant fanservice for anyone to take it seriously and to hide the fact that it's incredibly mediocre as a loli story.

>>159636289
No.
Cop-out ending.

>>159637624
It was the best possible ending in the circumstances.

>>159637872
I don't care about what excuses you have without any proof, it was a cop out ending in the end.

>>159637979
I'm just telling you how it is, it's completely up to you what you want to believe.

>>159638023
No, you're just making an assumption, so you don't have to shitpost hard, and even if that assumption would be true, that doesn't change the fact that it's a cop out, no matter who is responsible for it.

>>159638132
It's not a cop out since there were no alternatives. It's obvious how the editor refused the mangaka the ending she had planned.

>>159638179
How is it not cop-out on the editor's part, if that's the case?
All the while, manga with adult woman getting on a shota, making him cum (the come splurt is visually shown) is allowed, not to mention the shotas impregnation adult women in various manga/LN.

>>159636289
Yes especially since it's based off of the female authors own childhood feelings and experience

>>159638273
That ties in on the circumstances. It's not the fault of the creator if she's being hampered by outside sources.

Different magazines have different guidelines and rules.

>>159638392
And like I said, I don't care about whose fault it was, it still was a cop-out ending, so in regards to how good the story was, the bull shit ending made sure to ruin a lot of its worth.

>>159638469
But the ending was perfect, considering the circumstances.

>>159638528
Fuck you and your circumstances.
The ending was a cop-out shit, and that's that. I don't care who was to blame.

>>159638644
It wasn't a cop-out, it was the best ending possible.

>>159638733
It was a shit ending. Moralfag/10.

>>159636997
I didn't know about that
Really sad to hear that

>>159639048
Best possible does not mean absolute best.

>>159639225
>"there was only rotten beef at home, so I made steak from it, that was the best possible steak I could have made, so it can't be shit!"
Boom.

>>159639289
You need to add
>and there is no possibility to obtain fresh beef
and then you have the situation down to a t.

>>159639353
Now that we found the perfect metaphor. I'm still gonna call it an "inedible piece of rotten shit" instead of "best possible steak", just like I'm going to call this an "irredeemable shit cop-out ending" instead of "best possible ending".

>>159639462
Well that would be pretty disingenuous, considering how it really was the best possible ending.

>>159639508
Not that anon, but I disagree. The best possible ending would actually be Rin being an old hag. Considering they couldn't get Rin together with Aoki as a loli the best solution would be to have Rin grow up and be with him, not the wierd cop-out ending where they try to do both.

>>159639689
She looking like a loli is a lot better than her looking like an old hag though, what the hell are you talking about?

She will grow up with him no problem.

>>159637366
Have to agree.
It really doesn't hold much value.
>>159639289
Shit am I on /v/?

>>159639800
>defends anti-lolicon, cop-out shit ending
>calls the person who doesn't "/v/"
The irony.

>>159639860
How was it anti-lolicon? She obviously stayed looking like a loli.

>>159639743
It isn't though, especially since Aoki isn't a lolicon. The best possible ending would have been Rin growing up and the two getting together as she grew up. Rin staying a loli is only good in that it's one last chance to show loli fanservice, but it cheapens the ending to do so. "we will wait until you grow up" is better than "we will wait until you grow up except we don't because you don't grow up and just stay a child forever." Even the sex scene is wierd in the ending because it shows Rin as the same impatient child she has always been. Despite "growing up" she hasn't either physically nor emotionally.

In fact the more I think about the ending the worse it becomes.

Aoki is shit.

>>159639860
Maybe you should try reading next time because nowhere did I defend the cop-out story.
Are you a bit mentally challenged maybe?

>>159639949

She stays looking the same, but has matured mentally. You'll forgive for being impatient after years of not seeing the person she loves.

I think the "we'll wait until you grow up" doesn't mean "grow up" in the literal sense, it means "get older". He's not a lolicon, as he loves Rin for who she is and not because she's a kid, but there are legalities to consider. She was his pupil, and she was still underage. If they immediately got together, he'd be risking jail.

>>159639930
On three accounts:
She was "legal age" anymore, because lolis can't ever win!
She grew noticably still, it's even mentioned, she's more like a petite teen at the end.
And still they played the "too little to fit in", which is also disturbing, since Rin will be forever too little for it, then.

>>159640114
>He's not a lolicon, as he loves Rin for who she is and not because she's a kid
Text-book anti lolicon right there, QED.

File: 1493805127613.png (166KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 500x500px

>>159636997
I have not much to live for then. I bet the ending is going to be terrible.

>>159640114
>I think the "we'll wait until you grow up" doesn't mean "grow up" in the literal sense, it means "get older".
It doesn't just mean "get older" it means "mature".

>but has matured mentally
Can you please show why you believe this?

>You'll forgive for being impatient after years of not seeing the person she loves.
Eager to spend time with him again? Absolutely. Eager to rush into sex? That seems like the same Rin we knew when she was a kid.

File: 1495249658794.jpg (2MB, 3094x4500px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3094x4500px

>>159636289
No, but I'd put it on the Mt. Rushmore of loli.

>>159640185
That's stupid. Aoki loving Rin as a person was always a central theme in the book, he doesn't feel a thing for the other kids. Remember the time when Rin started chatting in text with Aoki, using the picture of her mother?

>>159640322
>It doesn't just mean "get older" it means "mature".
No, it doesn't. He already loved her, which he openly admitted to himself, so there was no need for her to mature any more. They only needed to make sure that neither was going to be suffering for their relationship.

>Can you please show why you believe this?
Can you please show why you don't? People mature when they get older. Why wouldn't Rin?

>Eager to rush into sex? That seems like the same Rin we knew when she was a kid.
Sure. And what exactly is wrong with that?

When everything's said and done, though it might be a decent ending, it's not the ending I wanted from it, I wanted a loli to win, for a fictional love to defeat the age barrier that can't be defeated IRL, for Rin to stay the same as always as well as her friends; I wanted Children's Time, and in that it failed to deliver, so it will be forever a sour, bad ending for me.

We only fuck children. All those geriatric fetishists have to deal with pregnancy shit, stds, large size and corrupted, indoctrinated mind to believe that love with an adult is bad.

Fuggin stupid to fuck any girl over 8.

>>159636997
Uran better do more porn

File: 1416900956525.jpg (70KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 640x360px

>alright a KnJ threa-
>LRD
Die already you insane autist

>>159640517
Welp, I can't continue this since I seem to be missing chapters after 90, so I can't reference the ending. Sorry anon.

>>159641564
You don't have to. We have only seen Rin's character for a single chapter after the time skip, which is not enough time to fully evaluate how much she has matured.

Well, that and the "lunch time after" chapter, in which she just recounts what she did with Aoki and how she's always been kind of naughty.

File: aokirin4.png (156KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 500x500px

>>159639961
Aoki is lovable and pure.

>>159636289
Stopped following this a while ago. How did it end?

>>159642219
She got a bit older, they got together, turns out she looked the exact same, they fucked (or at least tried) and that's more or less it.

File: 02.jpg (305KB, 800x1116px) Image search: [Google]

305KB, 800x1116px

>>159642353
>she looked the exact same
More or less the same*
She grew.

>>159642625
Well, fine. Almost exactly the same, then.

>>159640757
Kate had the sexiest kid voice ever.