HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAH AHAHAHAHAH

This is it, lads.
The Japanese will soon completely go the Western route

hy the fuck doe sit have xboxhuge outlines? the 2D characters dont have that crap

When they are making it do they not see how shit it looks. I mean they must do if they know 2D that well.
As someone who did 3dvfx, the animation on the 3D is actually vomit, and turned the last scene from almost perfect to ruined.

File: [HorribleSubs] Shingeki no Kyojin - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_13.02_[2013.05.13_18.15.09].jpg (69KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 1280x720px

>>156866509
actually they do, the thick lines have been a prominent feature of the anime from the very beginning

>>156865691
Not from the anime tho

File: 1492143922393.png (174KB, 453x599px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 453x599px

>>156866695
>Not from the anime tho
is it now...?

>>156866566
The fact that they resort to cgi shows how tired/desperate they are, it's not like they're going to sit down and critique things with the kind of schedule they're on.

Quick question if you know cgi, why don't studios turn the frame rate down to match everything else? Whenever I see cgi in anime it's always at a jarring 60fps when everything else seems to be rolling at 24.

File: [HorribleSubs] Shingeki no Kyojin S2 - 31 [720p].mkv_snapshot_23.44_[2017.05.06_21.25.34].jpg (181KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

181KB, 1280x720px

>>156866742

>>156865691
>completely beautiful and badass scene
>great animation and great Voice acting
>they transform
>bert turns into a red disgusting mess and they don't even try to hide it.
>he stretches his disgusting 3d shit cgi arm across the wall over armin just to grab Ymir.
How do you fuck up a great scene so badly? they almost had it

>>156866783
They often do, actually. It's rarer that the CGI is super high framerate.

>>156865691
>if they eat up that kemonowhatever thing then we can get away with this
Great idea.

>>156866783
Most of the CGI in anime is actually 12fps.

>>156865691

this show just keeps dumber and dumber

>>156866945
It literally would look better at 30 or 60
Why do animators think the framerate gap is what makes CGI look bad and not the fact that it's CGI

>>156866982

everyone's a titan now lmao

File: 1451497104643.webm (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

Remember when snk was the only show that used CG well

>>156867542
>good use of CG
>that

Is this a PS2 game?

>>156867709
Give a better example then

File: 1433441189214.png (240KB, 432x429px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 432x429px

>>156865691
If a literal-who show like Etotama can have great CG, you'd think the most popular show of its time would get something decent.

Sasuga WIT.

Is nyaa down for anyone else? Just got home from work and can't seem to access it.

>>156867859
sit down, anon

File: 1283794325.png (205KB, 278x286px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 278x286px

>>156867859

File: [HorribleSubs] Shingeki no Kyojin S2 - 31 [720p].mkv_snapshot_18.18_[2017.05.07_11.01.30].jpg (97KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 1280x720px

>>156867859

>>156867859
Epic post my friend. Have dozens on (You)s.

>>156866466
the most popular show of the season was completely done in cgi
animes dead.

>>156867859
Anon I...

>>156866783
I'm not sure how much nips care about cg, or even notice it. As someone else said most stuff is 12fps, but that will probably be either to do with render times or scheduling.
But there is also the issue of frame blending or blurring. Where you can do it easily in 2d just by drawing the stretching of lines, in 3D its essentially done by blurring the frame.
So high frame rate 60fps rendered 3D plate will have little blurring. But if you look at anything filmwise higher than 24ish fps it starts looking too fluid and gives away the experience that you are watching film, that's why it stands out so much.
But the 12fps renders that you usually see looks terrible because it's not blurred between frames, (if it was at 12fps all you would see is blur) and it looks stuttery.
Then why not do it at 24fps? it will still have blurring if they want to blend it well into 2D plates, but as soon as you blur movement, you lose the sharpness from the 2D image, and sharpness is what they are trying to achieve in the case of anime.
In the case of the titan its essentially an amalgamation of terrible rigging, animation, skin deformation that fucks it.
They essentially chucked the simplest skeleton onto a 3d model, and just moved the arms with 0 skin deformation or really understanding how a skeleton works. It looks more like a robot than a fluid character. Time constraints isn't an excuse for such poor 3D work, they could do so much better so easily.

>>156867542
That looks cheesy.

>>156867859
Owner diff oil be back up next week. You'll just have to stream until then anon.

>>156868051
Most popular show of the spring season of 2014, probably.

>>156867227
Because they this low framerate makes it look more anime-like.

>>156868589
*they think

>The CT is the most shitted on titan.
>Not even Frieda's titan get this much shame

File: [HorribleSubs] Shingeki no Kyojin S2 - 31 [720p].webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>156866695
except it is

>>156865691
How bad are the sales projections for this crap?

File: 1394298784528.jpg (74KB, 485x496px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 485x496px

What did Bert do to deserve this?

>>156871771
Isayama has an Colossal suffering boner. The more he gets invested on a character the more he suffers.

>>156867859
Its dead jim. Gone forever.

>>156865691
that from berserk?

la

>>156867227

Because the real animation is like, 4-8 fps. Really. Its all about good animators. A CGI with 12-24fps is extremely jarring.

>>156866809
Honestly, i cant say its CGI from this still.

Here is pretty visible though:>>156868689

>>156865691
He doesn't look that bad.

>>156867709
I mean, if they made it any more realistic it'd make the 2D drawing stand out too much and thus shit.

File: 1434362458192.png (211KB, 470x423px) Image search: [Google]

211KB, 470x423px

>>156867859
You may grieve with us

>>156868007
Lol great reaction

>>156867542
clearly you haven't seen Etotama

https://youtu.be/hjr3a9_WlPU

>>156865691
4 YEARS

12 EPISODE

How can SnK and Berserk, two of the biggest names in anime and mango, have instances of such shitty and lazy CGI when a no name show like Shingeki no Bahamut uses it so subtly and well? I don't get it.

>>156876540
Cygames money

>>156876313

What the fuck are you even talking about?

This looks like trash

>>156876773
What the hell are your standards? Etotama's CG scenes are fluid, have good shading, and make good use of smearing and stretching the models.

>>156876540
Hooooold on, CT's cg even on its own is still nowhere near as bad as the cg in Berserk. At the very least they bothered to texture the CT model.

File: quality.webm (3MB, 853x480px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 853x480px

The most popular series from the last season is totally in CGI.

>>156876540
Because even with half assed animations and bad CGs, idiots will still buy the BDs because it is popular.

Having Reiner just calmly tell Eren he and his boyfriend are titans was really underwhelming. Felt like a comedy scene desu.

>>156865691
What a colossal fuckup.

>>156865691
All the talent to actually draw action is gone, isn't it?

>>156875595
Because it isn't. Some cuts are CG, some cuts are handdrawn. This is the latter.

>>156877152
yeah but its moeshit, the reveal that reiner and sweaty are responsible for eren's mum's death is probably the most serious scene in the season and they ruined it that giant fucking red blob

File: 6547567547.jpg (4KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 225x225px

>>156865691
>CGI
>xDDDD
This is why we can't have good things, if all we do is complain then they will just stop making it.
What does you multi million yen anime look like?

I like Bertolt.

He didn't choose this life , you gotta feel for him.

>>156876773
pleb detected

>>156877314
Watch the show before you bitch. The fact that this many episodes in and this is the only complaint about the visuals anyone has had should tell you volumes about how good it looks otherwise, considering the popularity of the show. The animation is pretty damn good for a TV version, and there's only been a handful of stills so far. Even the CG was at a reasonable framerate rather than the faux-2d too many directors try to do with it.

>>156875611
Keep eating this shit up.

>>156867813
Etotama kind of worked in part because it could set hard constraints on its use of CG:
* The 3DCG parts and the 2D handdrawn are kept completely separate, both conceptually (ETM12 battles taking place in an alternative world vs. the human world) and technically (no integration of 2D and 3D elements)
* All 3DCG characters are SD, greatly decreasing the detail problem, which 3D made to look 2D tends to suffer from.
That said, even Etotama faltered at things like mouth-flaps (though this was only really a problem when characters weren't in motion, which didn't happen very often).

>>156877916
> if all we do is complain then they will just stop making it.
Good. They will not disgrace Return to Shiganshina that way with disguisting CGI.

>>156878173
>Watch the show before you bitch.
Not going to watch attack on shit. I just found OP's picture a glaring magnet for criticism.

File: 94f0612ae61fa1163a2ac6f2f1c88320.jpg?6010285.jpg (153KB, 650x1000px) Image search: [Google]

153KB, 650x1000px

>>156868051
what are the chances of the remake being 2D though?

I'd say decently high

>>156875595
I feel bads for plebs who can't tell at a glance

>>156866813
please buy the BDs はい

>>156868129
pretty good for a tv show at least, I remember when I first saw the PV I thought it was for a movie and wasn't to impressed but for a tv show it's a decent trade to see the characters themselves animated so well.

>>156868689
Jesus that looks awful

>>156868051
eromanga is completely done in cgi?

>>156867859
you must have had a hell of a work week

>>156877820
>yeah but its dogshit
fixed

>>156878881
He was talking about Kemono Friends and you know it.

>>156877152
this cgi actually looks good but the animation is shit

>>156866982
Read the manga. Threads are fun.

>>156866982
it'll get even worse

>>156877916
>"ALL" "WE" do is complain
>they will stop making it regardless of sales
>logical "do it better then" fallacy

This post could qualify you for a home for the mentally handicapped

>>156878934
I fucking hate Kemono friends was CG but I couldn't deny the quality of the show even though I fucking hated the CG.

I stopped reading when the conspiracy bullshit happened. I heard there's time travel or some shit like that now and Titans dindu nothing.

should I pick it up again?

>>156879037
There is no time travel and the story became basically WW1-era politics + Titans.

>>156868689
Looks better than Berserk, and by fuck that's my benchmark now.

God I want to kill myself.

>>156879029
True.
It's painfull when something you love could become a harbinger of doom.
CG is evil, and that it has consumed traditional western animation is a travesty.

>>156879037
Less time travel physically and more 'memories travelling through time'

>>156879385
Indeed, I do not want nips to fall to this shit like the west did.

>>156865691
Tecmo-Koei's game had better CG than this.

>>156866783
Sometimes they do, but if you don't do it right it can look REALLY out of place.

An example would be the very first scene of Girls und Panzer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VAAnUqhKWZI
(though they improved it right after)

I think Kizumonogatari is one of the best examples of CG done right.

>>156867709
not even the PS4 AoT games look that good.

>>156876540
Bahamut's CG is as shit as any other show. Why did this show get so many praise by /a/?

Just because it's not popular doesn't mean it's good.

>>156866783
>Quick question if you know cgi, why don't studios turn the frame rate down to match everything else?
they do
you aren't watching anime at 60 fps dumbass
the motion just looks worse because it's bad computer animation

File: colossal titan.jpg (394KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

394KB, 1920x1080px

>>156879480
>>156865691
I think the PS3/PS4 game actually looks better...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1fa4ca4kTI

>terrible cgi
>one cour
what went wrong

>>156876313
Holeee shieet, This is the first time I see this

>>156879729
>Bahamut's CG is as shit as any other show
Because they use it very little and for golems only. Dragon Nina was normally animated unlike Colossal CGI

>>156865691
CT? More CGT

>>156868087
>>156866783
>>156867227
>>156866945
>>156868087

I don't know about other shows but as far as the Colossal titan is concerned he actually should appear to be moving very slow. Very large objects always appear to be moving slow due to their scale.

Also in general my real grip is with how goofy some of the scenes with horses have look. Colossal titan looks fine.

File: 123412343112.jpg (78KB, 483x585px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 483x585px

>>156867859

>>156865691
>4 years

>>156878482
I hope instead of doing a series like this and fuck it up with CGI, they do an OVA series like they did with Gundam Unicorn and make everything handdrawn. Release one OVA a year or two if you have to but make it look amazing so Return to Shiganshina gets the treatment it deserves.

>>156865691
i don't get it. what's wrong?

>>156865691
Doesn't really bothered me.

>>156865691
I don't see any problem.

People complaining about the CG are fucking autistic.