Madoka Magica

>>156762128
Incoming heavy spoilers.

Regarding rebellion, I'm a bit confused.

First, when Homura was talking with Madoka telling her how she was starting to think that her memories of Madoka were fake because she was far away, Madoka tells her that she's not capable of leaving someone she considers precious.

Now, after Homura hears this, even though she knows the Madoka she's talking to isn't the real Madoka, she straight up says that the real Madoka would say that as well. It strikes to me as odd because it gives me the impression that Homura just convinces herself that what the fake (or brainwashed because she didn't have her goddess memories) Madoka said is what the real Madoka thinks.

Other question I have is the origin of Homura new power. She broke the law of cicles by not allowing goddess Madoka to take her and by preventing the goddess Madoka from returning to where she came from, thus forcing a new principle in the universe of continuing to have the law of cicles and Madoka at the same time. What could have given Homura so much power? Is it her wish of straight up saying she wants to be the one who protects Madoka?

The new project wants to make Mami a sort of god of war but how could she even face all of Homura power with her own? It doesn't make sense.

>>156762908
>Now, after Homura hears this, even though she knows the Madoka she's talking to isn't the real Madoka, she straight up says that the real Madoka would say that as well.
This is not completely true. Homura has her doubt because she figures Madoka shouldn't exist (naturally) in their world, (and in Wraith Arc she has to deal with a fake Madoka), but upon interaction she realizes the Madoka in the barrier is indeed her friend (with amnesia). Ofc later she realized that the non-amnesiac Madoka would probably make a different choice so that's why she asked her again the same question, but too bad the deed's already been done.

>>156762908
Rebellion was shit, just pretend it never happened.

File: bait.jpg (336KB, 800x644px) Image search: [Google]

336KB, 800x644px

>>156763584
>He's content with an ending, where Madoka and Sayaka are dead, Mami and Kyoko don't remember shit and Homura constantly suffering

>>156763627
Rebellion ending is pretty good for an optimistic like me. Homura might burn down the universe one day, but so far they've been okay.

>>156763627
being meguca is suffering. Never forget

File: 1471592910269.jpg (333KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

333KB, 700x700px

I like Tomoe Mami.

>>156763627
Madoka isn't dead in the anime's ending, though

>>156763723
Madokami isn't really alive either. It's kinda fucked up.

>>156763723
for all we knew, she might have been. Magical Girl Heaven was nothing but a theory, which got proved in Rebellion

>>156763802
But that's what Rebellion came up with later, the original ending didn't have that and was perfectly fine on its own.

>>156762908
> What could have given Homura so much power?
To be honest there are multiple theories for this and none has really been confirmed or seems convincing enough so I guess you just have to pick your own interpretation for this.

First, there was one scene in Rebellion which suggested Homura's time loop not only increase Madoka cosmic karma but also her own as well, and that karma was what allows her devil form to be so powerful. I don't think Homura has necessarily rewritten the universe law the same way Madoka did, it's just her barrier was large enough to encompass the entire universe . So LOC still exists outside that barrier but Madoka's human part is allowed to exist inside the thing.

Second, it might have something to do with her wish since Homura technically never got it fulfilled and her existence is an oddity since the reason for her wish never exists. This may fucks up the system somehow and Homura could have found a way to exploit it.

>>156762128
why doesn't Mami turn into a witch or explode violently when she dies? How does that work with the whole energy balance thing?

>>156763627
that's good in my book

File: 1493659265152.jpg (70KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 1024x768px

Kyoko a best

>>156764665
>can i join?

>>156764722
>Sure, Mami-san!