>CGI in anime can never be goo-

>>155182005
That's not CGI though.

>>155182005
It looks like shit.

>>155182155
>not appreciating the webgen style

>>155182163
This shit is just a sequence from the opening the anime is still awfully animated, next time put more effort.

>>155182005
That doesn't look good though.

>>155182163
webgen is shit

>>155182005
The Mizukage was criminally underused.

>>155182289
I'd bang that bitch.

>>155182284
It's the leading style of contemporary Japanese animation and it's very creative.

>>155182005
>template threads will always be canc-

>>155182005
is it just me or does the Raikage punching Madara look so weird?

>>155182641
It's not the only time it's happened in Naruto, but the punches completely lack impact. There's some flashy hitsparks, but no significant reaction to each individual punch, making them look ridiculously weak.

>>155182641
Is it the effects?

>>155182722
They're a bunch of rapid fire punches on an impenetrable barrier. There's not going to be much of a reaction.

>>155182722
Thats kinda the point because none of those hits actually reached the target

>>155182005

These clips are from the opening animation, don't pretend it's representative of the typical animation in an episode.

File: [Ajin2.com] Ajin Season 2 Episode 9 [720p] [Subbed].webm (3MB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 800x450px

>>155182005

>>155183564
Garbage.

>>155182005
if only the actual fight looked even half as good...

File: fucking silvers.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>155183579
This one is 100x better.

>>155183683
>>155183564
The choreography is great, but limited animation in CGI doesn't look very good. It doesn't help that there's no squash and stretch either which makes the motion look stiff.

It takes some hardass mental gymnastics to say that this looks shit.

>>155182005
-d

>>155183716
>limited animation in CGI doesn't look very good
Of course. I would never argue for that. I'm not the OP or anyone sharing a perspective akin to the OP, I simply thought that the fight looked just as good as conventional animation would likely be able to make it look. Returning to the limited animation thing, though: part of what makes Satou vs the SAT team look so good is the fact that the animators appear to have left in a lot more frames - seconds 3-4 and 8-9 of my webm, at the very least, clearly have way more than 8 frames per second.

>>155183716
>The choreography is great
Nah.
Very nah.
It's several cardinal sins of choreography the most major of which is
>It's 5v1, let's all attack 1 at a time anyway
With guest appearance by
>we have ranged weapons but let's stand 3 feet away from the target anyway
Shit like this makes Jackie Chan cry.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DrRFzwPE0d4

>>155183942
They *have* to be physically near him; he's immortal, so they're trying to immobilize and capture him.

>>155182005
Link to the post you are quoting or duck the fuck off /v/tard.

>>155182005
>Greentext OP cut off with a hyph-
Why do you do this?

File: konop.jpg (91KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 640x960px

>>155182005
>supports CGI
>bought 4chan pass

>>155183942
>Ladder weapon
Impractical and unrealistic as fug. Which is what jackie always does.

>>155183683
>Shotgun Kata
Also unrealistic.

File: Etotama - 08 [720p].mkv_snapshot_18.49_[2015.05.28_21.51.10].jpg (86KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 1280x720px

Don't make me stay up to talk about Etotama again, /a/. I have work tomorrow. And I miss it. It hurts

>>155182005
Those white sparks look like shit.

Also
>pass user from 2016
For what purpose?

File: CC2 CG short 4chan.webm (3MB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 800x450px

The main problem CG has in anime is that for whatever reason they always animate it overly rigidly and it usually only animates at like 20fps for some dumb reason.

Studios who do CG need to look at what game devs do in cutscenes. Especially Cyberconnect 2, their cutscenes and animations in vidya look fucking stellar.

Here's a short they did for an anime expo, it looks great: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlRU_J5qYg0

>>155184299
Shit, linked the wrong short, that's the Studio Khara one, this is the Cyberconnect one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-PudD1UrvU

>>155184226
'Realism' is not and cannot be part of the discussion intended of this thread. This thread is about methods of animation, and their intrinsic and potential values.

>>155183716
>It doesn't help that there's no squash and stretch either which makes the motion look stiff.

There can be, those effects are easily possible in 3d software, it's just hard to do it with keyframes due to those modifiers not interpolating well.

But it can be done, as >>155184307 shows

>>155184299
Khara's approach is actually quite effective with their use of limited animation. Unlike typical anime CGI, there's a lot more thought put into varying the frame rate and it carries a lot of techniques used by 2D animation.

>>155184299
>>155184307
There's plenty of example of good CG if you look at things like video game cutscene or short movies but the problem is that it takes a ton of work to make them right now.
It can be done for small scale things but a whole show with that kind of quality would burn any budget tot he ground.

My fagorite CG stuff is animator expo stuff like casette girl
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhwXxjiqDEU
and vidya like guilty gear
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2PNm4CsH50

Best cgi I've seen was Space Battleship yamato

>>155184299
>The main problem CG has in anime is that for whatever reason they always animate it overly rigidly and it usually only animates at like 20fps for some dumb reason.
Old habits die hard, they're trying to do traditional anime in a non-anime format where it inherently won't mesh.

A good video on the subject:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q6kVU8uNdic

>>155182005
Of all the latest cgi/3d/2.5d anime scenes to come out not a single one has come even close to these two.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prGqE6T2JAs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZi0neoZJfM

Why is that?

>>155184712
Lol idol garbage, even the Idolmaster 2 games has better 3D than that shit.