[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

It's been almost 3 years since TWGOK ended. Were you happy

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 137
Thread images: 29

File: 019.png (373KB, 843x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
019.png
373KB, 843x1200px
It's been almost 3 years since TWGOK ended.

Were you happy with the ending?
>>
>>154153741
Yes
>>
>>154153741
No, Tenri shouldve won and im a Kanonfag
Sadly author rushed the ending and the last arc it was the worst one
>>
File: chihirowins.jpg (3MB, 3848x3984px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
chihirowins.jpg
3MB, 3848x3984px
>>154153741
>>
File: tenri.png (24KB, 694x557px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
tenri.png
24KB, 694x557px
>>154153959
>Tenri shouldve won
>>
>>154154085
Missing the reactions to the final chapter where their hopes are crushed for good.
>>
>>154154085
that one anon talking about Nisekoi and hoping for Onedera ending; if only we knew back then
>>
>>154153741
Nah, I don't mind that chiroro won but we should at least see why she fell in love with him. She just did off screen with no known interaction.
>>
>>154154345
If you didn't know Chitoge was going to win from reading the oneshot, you were a retard.
>>
File: no hope.png (119KB, 838x170px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
no hope.png
119KB, 838x170px
>>154154345
I wonder if he sudoku'd.
>>
>>154153741
I thought it was OK, for the most part.
I never liked Tenri, always thought she was a sucky, mopey character, but I thought the ending gave her an unnecessary kick in the teeth.

I also didn't like the way Elsie's resolution dissolved her friendship with Hacqua, that bothered me more than most of the shipping crap, as I enjoyed the relationship between the two
>>
>>154154528
>I also didn't like the way Elsie's resolution dissolved her friendship with Hacqua, that bothered me more than most of the shipping crap, as I enjoyed the relationship between the two
This. This was the only thing that bothered me.

Haqua's century long friendship with Elsie was simply erased from history.
>>
>>154153741
still glad
>>
File: 1487610014588.png (345KB, 633x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1487610014588.png
345KB, 633x720px
Yes.

Chihiro was the only one that was distinct enough and deserving of the win.

Fuck True Tears still though
>>
File: 1363656630656.jpg (74KB, 478x598px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1363656630656.jpg
74KB, 478x598px
Is Wakaki's new manga any good?
>>
>>154154277
What were they even holding onto? I was too busy laughing at them to remember.
>>
>>154154085
>>154154277
>>154156053
i was lmaoing the whole time

good times
>>
File: 1376770348009.png (16KB, 161x195px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1376770348009.png
16KB, 161x195px
>>154156118
>i was lmaoing the whole time

>tumblr gif

No you weren't.
>>
>>154153741
>Were you happy with the ending?
At first, I was too busy laughing at all the faggots who were btfo. Then when the storm calmed, I was happy to see a shipping that makes sense, come true and the author didn't pander to his fans.
>>
>>154156751
This.
>>
>>154153741
Yes
I wasn't happy with the year+ of shit chapter that leaded up to it though.
>>
>>154153741
I thought the ending itself was fine and fit what Wakaki was going for. That being said, it did feel rushed. I thought that we were going to have at least one more arc after Keima returned to the present with that Demeter tease, but it never went anywhere.
>>
The ending was just the cherry on top of the shit sundae Wakaki had been making for the last few arcs.
>>
No, Chihiro winning was the only good thing.
But the whole thing was rushed and dissapointing, and the pointless final arc was so insufferable i dropped it just to catch on two chapters before that ending.
Also >>154154528
>I also didn't like the way Elsie's resolution dissolved her friendship with Hacqua, that bothered me more than most of the shipping crap, as I enjoyed the relationship between the two
>>
>>154153741
It was bullshit and I regret ever reading it.
>>
File: 1397241723611.webm (656KB, 311x213px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1397241723611.webm
656KB, 311x213px
>>154160995
>still this salty
>>
It was obvious from the end of the Goddess Arc that Chihiro would win. Shipping delusions were the only hope anyone had after that.

Wakaki obviously had a plan, and it was fantastic he had a plan, but sadly he burned out before he could flesh the plan out. That's the only disappointment here. It would be great for him to go back and flesh out the last arc properly with what he actually wanted to do without the pressure of weekly panels.

The most disappointing part was LC's reveal though. Most speculation had already figured it out, but it would have been nice to see the plot actually build up to it, rather than just park it on our heads the way it did.

I really enjoyed TWGOK, it's a real shame what happened to it and Wakaki. Maybe if we'd succeeded in getting that cake to him he might have had the courage to do his job properly. Who knows.
>>
I still can't believe he didn't just go find ramen girl again and marry her.
>>
>>154153741
I think it's telling that it was once everybody's favorite manga but then the ending happened and nobody talks about it anymore.
>>
>>154162834
The last arc was so fucking bad that i'm surprised more people didn't dropped it.
The interest probably peaked at the goddesses arc anyway.
>>
>>154162481
Should have sent him a gift card.

Also I don't like that cake manga of his.
>>
>>154162970
Keima going back to a shota was a mistake.
>>
>>154162834
The author just gave up, the whole past arc had to be used for the present hell arc but everything was just flushed down the toilet.
>>
>>154163767
The mistake was time travel.
Too much drama and no comedy didn't helped.
>>
>>154163932
>The author just gave up
And i will never forgive him.
>>
File: 1342784326149.jpg (218KB, 400x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1342784326149.jpg
218KB, 400x500px
>>154163767
Shouta Keima did nothing wrong. That wasn't the problem.
>>154163997
Also, the comedy was still there.

The problem was the comedy just wasn't as good. Also that the ratio of comedy to forced drama was to high.
>>
No. Not because of Chihiro, but because it sucked and the final arc sucked.

Obligatory "anyone who thinks Tenri should've won is fucking moronic and didn't understand the manga at all"
>>
I wish Keima would have remained pure and loyal to the 2D instead of going for a real relationship.
>>
>>154162970
It's because of the goddess arc and all before it that people didn't drop the series. I did, and I still took a while to do so. It's a lot of faith to squander, you know? It used to be my favorite manga series.
>>
>>154164729
Why did he abandoned his waifu again?
Did Nora's heart reading thing made him stop loving her or the autor decided not to continue with that so he could get with Chihiro with no more bullshit?
>>
>>154164804
>>154164729
Go read the Akari arc again.
>>
>>154164850
Who was she again?
The girl that wanted to make a perfect human?
>>
>>154164922
Yes, AKA Elsie's sister.

By the way, the LC bullshit that people "figured out" was all wrong and was not hinted at at all. That reveal sucked and it sucked more that Elsie was forgotten from hell.

The whole last arc was such shit, god damn
>>
>>154164670
But she waited for 10 years even though she knew.

That is best girl material.
>>
>>154153741
Best girl won but it needed more build-up, like Keima actually apologizing for what he did since they never actually resolved that conflict. Instead we got 70 chapters of nothing people cared about
>>
>>154164955
>figured out
Keima did. So did everyone here. But I agree that a reader who would marathon it now would just be confused.
>>
>>154165602
Didn't Chihiro hear the reason for Keima's actions when she helped him with Ayumi?
>>
>>154153741
She is like waiting in line at the post office. Like working the rest of your life at the DMV. Like winning with Haruka in the [email protected] Or playing games of chess with yourself.

She is plain yogurt. Vanilla ice cream with nothing on it. Or a box of rice crackers.

It makes no sense to me why anyone would choose her. Ever.
>>
File: victory.jpg (321KB, 640x666px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
victory.jpg
321KB, 640x666px
>>154166000
keep crying
>>
>>154166037
Eh, whatever. You still can't sell plain and boring no matter how hard you try.
>>
>>154162481
This.

It was really obvious both Chihiro and Elsie endings were part of this grand epic vision. What we actually got was like watching Wakaki have a nervous break down.
>>
>>154165895
That's not an apology, that's understanding the situation.
>>
>tfw we'll never get a final anime season to cover the last arc
>>
>>154166000
she is the only one who fell for the real keima
>>
>>154166288
>I know how I can salvage this!
>Time travel!
>...
>Why the fuck did I introduce time travel!
>>
>>154166442
The las arch was shit. Why would anyone want that?
What i wanted was the mon and elsie's date episode, those were so good.
Also Yui's arc.
>>
>>154166496
she and tenri

tenri a shit though
>>
>>154166548
Salvage what? He was doing good and then fucked it up beyond recognition.
>>
>>154165602
>Keima needed to apologize before getting with Chihiro
No.
>>
>>154166861
yes
>>
>>154153741
Yes, but the last arcs were way too dragged out and I was bored to death by the time it got to the finale.
>>
I remember when TWOGOK was actually fun.

When did it stopped?
>>
File: y.jpg (51KB, 598x644px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
y.jpg
51KB, 598x644px
>>154168333
When the goddesses arc was ending and the waifu wars started.
>>
File: 1337970393573.jpg (157KB, 800x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1337970393573.jpg
157KB, 800x600px
>>154168211
>you know Keima, I really have fallen in love you, and I know now you weren't toying with my feelings out of any malice but were put into a position in which you had to play with women's hearts and woo them to save the world, and though I now kinda realize the situation you were in was hard on you, and though you've just expressed your true feelings for me, which is a big step forward for that guy I used to know but still fell for in a big way--that being a confident and assertive (yet coolly aloof) genius who inspired me to strive for something real and be a more serious person--before we go any further you're just gonna have to jump through my western-derived, post-modern feminist hoops now until I say the word "stop."
Yeah, really. No.
>>
>>154153741
I still get a semi chub thinking about the autism and despair from the ending. We happy few fucking told you Chihiro was the obvious endgame but most of you refused to listen.
>>
>>154168760
what the fuck am I reading
>>
>>154168760
Take your meds anon
>>
>>154153741

it felt pretty damn abrupt

weirdest shit was elsie's. I just... what.

I guess it was ok
>>
>>154168760
>m-muh femunisms
Fucking hell, take this shit bogeyman back to /r9k/.
>>
>>154169041
A lengthier and more comprehensive reply to
>Keima needed to apologize before getting with Chihiro
than a simple "no."
>>154169178
What other reason is there for there to have been a requirement put on Keima to apologize to Chihiro for what he'd done?
>>
>>154169104
Nah, I'm fine. I'd put it another way, but I've done that before without having it penetrate.
>>
>>154164031
And apparently nobody else either, his new work is so irrelevant.
>>
>>154168760
>apologizing for hurting someone's feelings
>"WESTERN RO-FEMISM HOOPS FUCKING SJWs GET AWAY GET AWAY"
wew
>>
>>154169104
>>154169787

see? >>154170148

No real counter-argument, just more screeching.
>>
>>154170323
a counter-argument would require an argument to counter
>>
>>154153741
I honestly was hoping for more of a "I've saved the world, back to being a farmhand" ending wherein he just plays his vidya and ignores bitches

I never liked Chihiro on top of that
>>
>>154170367
I put like six of them in my post above.
>>
File: 109239023.jpg (71KB, 495x698px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
109239023.jpg
71KB, 495x698px
Keima didn't deserve a single girl he used or took a dump on. He was a jerk until the end. Chihiro should have rejected him and let him fester in the sting of rejection for the first time in his life, then go off with Ayumi and Yui and do karaoke, enjo kosai or whatever Japanese girls normally do for fun. LC is real imouto, Tenri lets her hair down, Shiori and Tsukiyo are buds, Kanon fucks her bosses.

While Keima is out for a walk sulking, he spots Miyako playing a PFP. She tries to hide it, but Keima prompts her to show it. She's really gotten into games lately, but she's a total noob. Keima's not so sure he's in the mood until he notes she too loves Yokkyun, sparking his interest into turning her into a fine otaku. He'll show her the world only god knows.
>>
File: 1339462981937.jpg (90KB, 1809x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1339462981937.jpg
90KB, 1809x720px
>>154170438
Why would Keima do that when he could come home to Chihiro every night?
>>
File: 1336607312328.jpg (66KB, 735x1072px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1336607312328.jpg
66KB, 735x1072px
>>154171257
>Kanon fucks her bosses
You just had to take it too far.
>>
File: Yotsuba_Sugimoto.png (186KB, 462x272px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Yotsuba_Sugimoto.png
186KB, 462x272px
>>154153741
Fucking 3DPD won. The faggot had a loving 2D waifu & decided to go for 3D.
>>
>>154171358
>when he could come home
Keima is obviously gonna be a NEET husband, anon.

Chihiro will be the one earning the family's living.
>>
>>154171257
Miyako best girl though. Pretty sure she was the only one who ever talked positively of Keima and never fell for him.
>>
File: 1337992670354.png (296KB, 829x553px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1337992670354.png
296KB, 829x553px
>>154171870
>wanting a bug ridden corpse for Keima's waifu

And they said shippers were awful.
>>
>>154153741
terrible ending

my waifu was the dojo chick and she lost early on but still a terrible rushed ending

so many unanswered questions and loose ends
>>
>>154172269
I always figured Keima would grow into his dream job creating the world's most complex galgames to be run on futuristic super-computers.
>>
>>154153741

No it could have taken several different routes, instead we got the shitty time travel arc, and then it got axed and worst girl won out of left field.
>>
File: 1347075796033.png (69KB, 320x425px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1347075796033.png
69KB, 320x425px
>>154173920
>could have taken several different routes
>worst girl
>won out of left field
>>
No but not because MUH AYUMI/MUH TENRI the right girl won. It sucked though because of how goddamn rushed everything was. That shit needed at least another volume to properly conclude. It wouldn't hurt so much if they didn't spend so goddamn long on namek.
>>
>>154153741
Very yes. It was pretty obvious from far back, but it was still satisfying.
>>
>>154153741
Yes and no. I was happy with his choice, but I felt it could've ended better
>>
File: 1435210217655.png (57KB, 708x480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1435210217655.png
57KB, 708x480px
>>154153741
>almost 3 years
No no no no no don't do this to me now.
>>
>>154153741
While the ending WAS admittedly rushed, it was consistent with the way Wakaki handled things before. When all the goddesses woke up, Keima wasn't part of the big battle. He always stood to the side and only did what he wanted to do. That's his character. Everything else was background noise to him.
I actually liked that the more fantasy or battle-manga elements were pushed aside. It was funny and made the story keep going.
But yeah, the time-travel arc was pretty meandering without a good objective to strive for.
I get it, it was a way to do a "save point - load" galge mechanic. But it was pretty wasted since Wakaki obviously didn't really know where he was going with it, keeping the whole thing unmotivated and aimless.
>>
Anyone have long hairdo Chihiro? her bowl cut has been bothering me since forever
>>
>>154154409
Elsie didn't win here.
>>
File: Kaori_Collour.png (1MB, 687x1134px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Kaori_Collour.png
1MB, 687x1134px
Pretty much the same opinions as others here. Chihiro was best girl to end with, but the second it was announced that the series was ending, the now-final arc turned from a fun Kid Keima arc into a rushed nonsensical conclusion except for who he ended up with.

I wanted to see what Kaori grew up to be.
>>
File: 1334781320546.png (72KB, 196x269px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1334781320546.png
72KB, 196x269px
>>154174997
>I get it, it was a way to do a "save point - load" galge mechanic. But it was pretty wasted since Wakaki obviously didn't really know where he was going with it, keeping the whole thing unmotivated and aimless.
I mean, you're going to do that as basis for a whole arc, but not make a running commentary slew of 4th wall breaking in-jokes about it?

>>154175364
Step away from your monitor and look at it from a distance.
>>
>>154175666
>I mean, you're going to do that as basis for a whole arc, but not make a running commentary slew of 4th wall breaking in-jokes about it?

They wouldn't work with Keima's state of mind and he's pretty much the only one who should be making them. I guess.
>>
>>154165129
That's called obsession. It's unhealthy. She also barely knew him (original timeline, they shared ONE afternoon together in which Keima gave even the slightest shit)

>>154165809
You don't get what I'm saying. The annoying bastards on /a/ basically said Elsie was a mastermind orchestrating everything.

She wasn't. Frankly don't really understand what she was. A weapon, maybe. It was stupid and absolutely unneeded. Not interesting in the slightest, and not at all what people were theorizing. Didn't stop them from pretending they guessed the asspull. Saw "final boss" and said "good enough"
>>
>>154166496
Her, Tenri, Haqua, Dokuro, Elsie, nearly all of the goddesses, etc.
>>
File: 1333652685940.gif (3MB, 480x270px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1333652685940.gif
3MB, 480x270px
>all this revisionist history from Chihirofags now that no one really cares to fight back
>>
>>154178316
It was preached for years.

Ironically, what's revisionist is how the common theory was "the non goddess host will be the true end" but when it turned out that was Chihiro, people started turning back on that theory.
>>
File: 1381071322744.jpg (76KB, 900x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1381071322744.jpg
76KB, 900x1200px
>>154178316
>all the Chihirofag arguments were laid out with precision months or years in advance of the manga catching up to the theories

>waifufags of all stripes exclusive of Chihiro still operating under the delusion in the year of our lord 2008+9 that they were ever doing more than shitposting into a bleak future when they simply could have been admiring the art of their favorite girls while awaiting the inevitability of Chihiro's complete and utter victory

Show us on the Chihiro where Wakaki hurt you, anon.
>>
File: forever.png (94KB, 535x532px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
forever.png
94KB, 535x532px
Chihiro a cutest and deserved her win.
>>
>>154178700
It's sad how little porn there is of her.
>>
File: 47375522_p0.jpg (281KB, 675x900px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
47375522_p0.jpg
281KB, 675x900px
>>154179520
There never was a whole lot of artists lewding up the twgoks in the first place, and the last anime didn't really lend to a porn-y moment for Chihiro at all.
>>
Chihiro winning ended up becoming obvious.

I'm just fucking sad how Wakaki handled Elsie.
>>
The ending? Hell, I hated the entire second half.
>>
>>154153741
No. Everything after the goddess arc was awful.
>>
>>154153741
Is this fucker even still doing manga? Does anyone even give a fuck anymore?
>>
Don't forget Chihiro was whoring herself out to Chads.
>>
File: 15.png (461KB, 868x1250px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
15.png
461KB, 868x1250px
>>154180895
nice meme
>>
File: TWGOK28_15_RH.png (174KB, 830x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
TWGOK28_15_RH.png
174KB, 830x1200px
>>154181347
Nice denial.
>>
>>154181429
>giving chocolate
>whoring
she's pure and liked keima the whole time anyway. only reason she did it was to feel special.
>>
>>154181429
Knowing how Keima already felt about Chihiro puts his facial expression here in a whole new light.
>>
>>154181347
>that fucking part

The entire goddess arc was fucking god tier. Too bad that the plot went full retard and rushed beyond belief in the future arc.
>>
>>154178898
I think her early capture arc is the best capture in the series too.
>>
>>154153741
I liked how Chihiro won but I didn't like how it felt rushed.

>>154180613
IIRC, the author was doing a manga set in a cafe.
>>
>>154153741
Absolutely no. People seem to forget that the only reason she won is because the assistant want it. It was shit with no build up at all. I would at least say it's okay if there's actually development for it. But trying to develop a couple of chapter before the ending really makes it hard to swallow.
>>
>>154182170
>He didnt pay attention to the chihiro parts
>>
File: 1328564031270.jpg (600KB, 897x1300px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1328564031270.jpg
600KB, 897x1300px
>>154153741
I miss the threads in the goddess arc.
"Haqua, the deathflag eater" was really fun at the time. Haqua was best girl.
>>
>>154182170
Fucking hell you can't even get your unsubstantiated rumors right.
>>
>>154153959
>Tenri
>Kanon
Nce shit taste holy shit
>>
>>154182349
That has to be one of the best pages. The second to last panel is just perfect.
>>
Time travel was a bit needed cause otherwise it wouldn't have made any sense for all the Goddesses to be so involved with Keima.

But fuck that final arc was bad.
>>
Trap Keima Doujins
>>
Ok with the ending, Still fucking disappointed with the last arc. The only redeeming thing there was Dokuro, period.
>>
>>154182349
>>154153741
Nobody cares about that fucking cake-shop.

Can't he do some supernatural romance again?
>>
>>154153741
No.

Chihiro winning was fine, everything else was a mess
>>
#HAQUA4EVER
FUCK SHITHIRO
>>
>>154153741
Still winning.
>>
>>154181550
He didn't like her back then.
>>
>>154153741
The ending itself? Yes, it was damn good.
The part leading up to it? Not really.

After some thought I dropped the series from my 3x3.
>>
>>154182170
>It was shit with no build up at all.
Do people actually read the manga they talk about?
>>
As others have said. Chihiro winning was great, but the parts leading up to it were not. Needed more time.
>>
KEEP YOUR DELICIOUS TEARS RUNNING FAGGOTS

Chihiro was and always will be,

BESTO GIRL

suck my hairy nuts
>>
We're never going to get translations for Nanoha Yougashiten no Ii Shigoto because of all the butthurt tied up in God's ending.
Thread posts: 137
Thread images: 29


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.