[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

So out of all the shitty battle harem LN adaptions, which do

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 39

File: Rakudai_kishi_no_cavalry.png (489KB, 704x396px) Image search: [Google]
Rakudai_kishi_no_cavalry.png
489KB, 704x396px
So out of all the shitty battle harem LN adaptions, which do you consider the best?
Pic not related.
>>
>>153116072
With the exception of SAO (morbid curiosity) I don't think i've ever finished one
>>
You posted it, OP.
>>
That's like asking which turd smell less bad
>>
>>153116072
Stella a shit.
>>
File: 1459333832461.jpg (2MB, 2824x4000px) Image search: [Google]
1459333832461.jpg
2MB, 2824x4000px
BOOOOOOOOSSSTTTOOOOO!!!!
>>
>>153116072
Musaigen no Phantom World.
>>
>>153116072
Rakudai is near the bottom and has one of the worst main girl ever, so pic unrelated indeed.
>>
>>153116258
THIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIISTOOOOO
>>
>>153116504
Kyoani barely counts considering all the shit they add.
>>
File: 1485570325252.png (1MB, 1381x1055px) Image search: [Google]
1485570325252.png
1MB, 1381x1055px
>>153116072
Gonna play devil's advocate and say that I liked Rakudai for what it was. I've only watched like three battle harems total though, I don't regularly dabble in this genre like so many in /a/ do.
>>
File: 0578602aa18291d9bb244b7027dde70c.jpg (304KB, 1000x1429px) Image search: [Google]
0578602aa18291d9bb244b7027dde70c.jpg
304KB, 1000x1429px
>>153116247
>>153116574
Stella is best girl and did nothing wrong.
>>
>>153116810
Kill yourself, Houki lover.
>>
>>153116574
I liked Rakudai, Stella is best girl.

>>153116810
knows what's up
>>
Whichever your waifu is in.
>>
File: phantom world.jpg (292KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]
phantom world.jpg
292KB, 640x960px
>>153116072
Myriad Colors Phantom World

Battle harem done right
>>
Most if not all battle harems including the one in the OP are shit.

Some are less shit than others, but I hate how people defend Rakudai. The MC is overpowered as fuck, but in the same way that Batman is still relevant in a universe that contains Superman. Except that in Rakudai, everyone pretends that being Batman automatically makes you shit because you can't fly around like superman.

It's dumb wish fulfillment bullshit.

But it seems like the next big trend is monster girls, which I'm perfectly ok with, so fuck it.
>>
>>153117286
cant be all of em since dxd exists
>>
>>153117356
DxD is shit though.
>>
File: 1474332174795.png (4MB, 2864x1687px) Image search: [Google]
1474332174795.png
4MB, 2864x1687px
Out of the stuff in pic related, T7 was easily the best watch.

Honorable mention to antimagic, anime was meh but the source material is really good and the main story is translated all the way to the end now.
>>
>>153116072
Why is Stella so shit? She ruined the entire show.
>>
Reminder that the MCs of Rakudai fucked so much in a single night that they left the floor of the room with a sea of condoms.
>>
>>153117472
I feel inadequate now.
>>
>>153117416
>Hundred Emelia
>main girl
loving every laugh

>>153117472
reminder that Kirito and Asuna fucked but that doesn't make them based or even good characters in general
>>
>>153117416
Antimagic, Blade Dance and StB were the ones I enjoyed the most.
>>
>>153117472
pics or it didn't happen
>>
>>153116072
Rakudai was good but not because of the two you posted, it was because of this guy
>>
>>153117416
Of this list, how many Mc actually have a harem (Romantic feelings in both ways) or plan to have one?
>>153118264
https://jasonwanderblog.wordpress.com/2016/11/16/rakudai-part-5/ i don't know if is this or another untranslated vol.
>>
rakudai was utter shit on its own and even more compared to Asterisk.
>>
>>153118455
How was Asterisk even good? It's fights were horrendous.
>>
>>153116994
Yeah, but the anime didn't follow the novels at all
>>
>>153118410
I hope he cucks the MC
>>
>>153118607
If my imagination, or almost all Kyoany adaptation of a LN have original content?
>>
>>153118879
Nearly all of them. Touka from Chu2 was anime original while the loli and Ruru from PW are originals
>>
>>153116072
I watched a lot of these shows somehow. Let's see how many I can even remember.


Invaders of the Rokurobi has all the harem girls living in a one room apartment with the main character. Each is an alien or magical girl or something.

Date a Live was mostly bad, owing to the fagot Shido, but I really liked Tokisaki Kurumi's arc. Everything from the battles to the girl herself were incredible.

Sekirei was overall solid with really consistent animation.

Campione had a more interesting mythos than you'd normally expect, plus the main guy actually got lewd with his favorite girl

Rosario to Vampire anime was utter shit, but the manga became unique and completely fucking insane, with both the main guy AND main girl having alternate personalities who they couldn't control while the scope of the story just keeps ramping up every time you thought the entire world was involved. The main guy becomes a zombie and saves the world from a skyscraper-sized toad, and that's before it even gets crazy. There are plenty of bad chapters but it's like nothing else I ever read. I know it's not a LN adaption but it's still the genre you're looking for.
>>
Antimagic
>>
>>153119182
It's adaptation was garbage, what are you on about
>>
>>153119109
>Nepfag
>thinks his opinion matters
>>
>>153119109
You must be underaged if you actually liked Kurumi's arc or think she was good.
>>
>>153116072
The one you posted
>>
File: dc72d2141670b2d910cd29ad236c53bd.jpg (111KB, 720x1170px) Image search: [Google]
dc72d2141670b2d910cd29ad236c53bd.jpg
111KB, 720x1170px
>>153119462
damn i hate when I forget to clear that field

>>153119571
well, I'm weak to gothlolis and Tsunako. What would you recommend over it?
>>
>>153116072
Bakemonogatari series and Bamboo Blade
>>
File: tr42zg.jpg (130KB, 960x960px) Image search: [Google]
tr42zg.jpg
130KB, 960x960px
>>153118433
>He understood everything now, and looked over at the plastic debris. (I can’t believe we actually used them all..!)
So they used a full pack of condoms, my sides.
>>
>>153119711
Get some taste first.
>>
File: sweating guy.jpg (19KB, 262x326px) Image search: [Google]
sweating guy.jpg
19KB, 262x326px
>>153118433
Thanks for posting that.
>>
>>153118978
Deko and pillow senpai from Chuu2 were original too.

Only Yuuta, Rikka, Shinka and the pink girl from S2 were in the novels.
>>
>>153119109
Rosario Vampire has Moka's mom cuck her, in one of the most unintentionally glorious and hilarious moments in harem manga.
>>
>>153116072
Bahamut, because of the girls.
>>
Negima.
>>
>>153121050
Bahamut was awful
>>
>>153121050
But only one of them was any good.
>>
File: SaijakuBahamut_v3_000C_-_000D.jpg (857KB, 2803x2048px) Image search: [Google]
SaijakuBahamut_v3_000C_-_000D.jpg
857KB, 2803x2048px
>>153121050
Only Celestia is good though.
>>
>>153121187
Stellafag, go away.
>>
>>153121152
Not with that ending.
>>
>>153121206
>>153121187
I fucking abhor Stellafag for including Celestia in his shitlist of girls to shitpost with but i love Celestia too.

Fuck you stellafag
>>
>>153116072

Hagure has the best protagonist and the most rapeable girl
>>
>>153121206
I don't like Stella
>>
>>153121174
Which one?
>>
>>153121628
Celestia
>>
>>153121265
This.

It's best if the MC actually embraces how OP he is as well as enjoying all the girls instead of being a beta faggot.
>>
File: 1480479489367.jpg (967KB, 1060x1500px) Image search: [Google]
1480479489367.jpg
967KB, 1060x1500px
>>153116072
The one with this goddess in it
>>
>>153118433
I know for sure that the MC of Strike the Blood has a harem end. He has two daughters with two different girls and the daughters actually get along.
>>
>>153121917
>>153121778
>>153121263
>>153121187
Shit taste.
>>
Monogatari series. Is this even a question?
>>
>>153121941
>battle harem
>>
Date A Live (S1)
Strike the Blood
Asterisk War
Can't pick a favourite out of these ones.
>>
>>153121995
What's your definition?
>>
>>153122013
>Asterisk
Good choices otherwise
>>
>>153121938
And samefag.
>>
>>153119109
Shidou was fine. Ultra-bland, but he had a mission and carried out that mission without exhibiting typical insufferable harem MC pussy allergy.
>>
>>153117416
Man ichiban ushiro Maou (color wars) was so disappointing. I still watch the first few episodes from time to time because of how good they were
>>
>>153121778
I only vaguely remember Celestia as the single laziest manhating dyke converted to MCsexual character of all time, where that entire development lasted all of like an episode.

I meant Lisha. She actually had some cute moments.
>>
One of things I seek in battle harems are the quality of fight scenes, which is funny cause battle harems usually has the shittieet of budgets. I also look for characters + their interactions.

I guess in terms of quality of fights and direction I'll give Rakudai the best(due to the director). The characters are so shit, so it still doesn't save it. Also the tournament style fights are really grating. I love the DxD and T7 cast, and I think that's the more important part in battle harems.
>>
>>153117416
Date a live, form an adaptation standpoint was fairly solid. The first season had spectacular animation and the battles were very well done, music wasn't half bad. Story pretty fucking meh, but it had some good things about it. Strike the blood is fucking horrible but for some reason it's my favorite of all that shit there by far
>>
>>153117416
the girl in yuusha is a tranny, the way shee loked always threw me off, then i realized she had huge shoulders and a squarish face, and other features consistent with males
>>
File: 1479362704605.png (266KB, 699x346px) Image search: [Google]
1479362704605.png
266KB, 699x346px
>>153118433
>>
>>153118433
>stella isn't a virgin
What the fuck is this fucking horseshit? Teenagers aren't supposed to have sex? What the hell happened to that noble speech about wanting to meet her family first and trying to take the relationship seriously? Fuck
>>
>>153117416
Color Wars > Strike the Blood > Infinite Stratos (first season only) > Hundred > HxH > Trinity Seven > DXD > Bahamut > Asterisk War > Anti-Magic -> Shinmai Maou > Rakudai > Kuusen Madoushi > Date a Live

What am I doing with my life?
>>
>>153123126
They fucked as soon as they met their folks. This happens after Ikki wins the tournament and meets the royal family.
>>
>>153123157
>Hundred
>HxH
>Bahamut
You're wasting your life harder than the others.
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (67KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault.jpg
67KB, 1280x720px
>>
>>153116072
It's hard to judge, Where are the translated Asterisk and Antimagic doujins?
>>
>>153117416
ISUCA, Dragonar and Mahou Sensou were too terrible to remember?
>>
File: kuchie-004.jpg (1MB, 2214x1600px) Image search: [Google]
kuchie-004.jpg
1MB, 2214x1600px
In HxH the odious main girl get impaled in a wall with an enormous spear in the chest.

It's the perfection.
>>
>>153126153
I hope some similar will happen in Strike the blood to Yukina
>>
File: 1399546298533.gif (892KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]
1399546298533.gif
892KB, 640x360px
>>153117416
Gotta admit. Mahouka was unique.
>>
>>153126153
But she survived so this was awful.
And I don't understand why in the illustration they didn't put the blood.
>>
Colour wars. 2nd to that would be Hagure Yuusha, since the MC at least was open about liking lewd, though the girls felt like cardboard cutouts.
>>
>>153126153
Press F to her boobs.
>>
>>153116128
This.
>>
>>153126709
Kill yourself.
>>
File: vsd as.jpg (801KB, 2048x1534px) Image search: [Google]
vsd as.jpg
801KB, 2048x1534px
There is always this one
>>
>>153129056
Yukina deserve to wounded in the most brutal ways.
I don't think a more annoying character may exist.
>>
>>153129248
>I don't think a more annoying character may exist
Yes, it's (You).
>>
>>153117416
>Hagure Yuusha was fun
>Trinity Seven is legit good (for it's genre) because the MC isn't as dense as osmium
That's about it.
>>
>>153116072
Trinity Semen and Date A Live.
I haven't watched Rakudai because that's the time I got sick of watching battle harems.
>>
Does the Devil is a Part Timer count as a battle harem? If so, I'd say it's the best.
>>
>>153129280
I can already see the scene.

>A new enemy is in front of Kojou.
>"This is my fight!"
>Yukina arrives.
>"No senpai, this is our fight".
>The enemy hit Kojou sending him on a wall.
>Yukina try to attack the enemy.
>He doge and pierce her with a beam in the stomach.
>She fall in the ground gasping and vomiting liters of blood while a pool of blood came out from her big hole in the abdomen.
>>
>>153116072
Just here to remind you that Rakudai is not a harem because only 2 girls like him and one of them is his sister

You need at least 3 girls for a harem
>>
>>153116072
that one
also imouto a best
>>
>>153116504
>>153116994
Not a harem
>>
>>153129512
Sayaka please calm down.
>>
>>153119109
>Date a Live was mostly bad, owing to the fagot Shido, but I really liked Tokisaki Kurumi's arc.
>Liking Kurumi
>Pity the normalfag
>Shidou a bad MC.

That's a new low.
>>
>>153117416
hagure yusha > strike the blood > date alive > dxd > hxh > infinite stratos
>>
>>153129625
How the fuck is it not a harem?

>All girls love MC.
>He is interested in all of them.
>>
>>153132208
They dont like him
>>
>>153119571
>>153129737
What's there to dislike about Kurumi? I'll admit Yoshino's far better, but what's so immature about liking Kurumi - do 16-yr-old YT/MAL fgts mostly like her, or are you just saying her traits appeal to that group?
>>
>>153132262
Shin Seitokai no Ichizo is a harem and most of the girls despise mc
>>
>>153132455
Besides the fact that they confess to him and some of them kiss him?
>>
>>153132451
She is a normalfag filter, it's easy to tell if you are a normie or cancerous fuck if you like Kurumi by just watching the anime.
>>
>>153121265
Basara a much better written character when compared to Akatsuki.
>>
>>153132451
>do 16-yr-old YT/MAL fgts mostly like her, or are you just saying her traits appeal to that group
All of that.
>>
>>153132642
You're wrong, then. My bro is 22, and has been in love w/ Kurumi for 3 years now.
>>
>>153132671
Not just because she is normalfag means older people can't like her but it really says a lot about your bro's taste.
>>
File: Claire is so cute.jpg (146KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
Claire is so cute.jpg
146KB, 1280x720px
Claire is a sweet girl
>>
>>153132747
Claire a shit.
>>
>>153132747
claire was the worst girl in that show
fuck off
>>
>>153116072
Date a Live
>>
>>153132747
>Yellow Houki
>sweet
Silver Charlotte was the only good girl in Hundred.
>>
>>153117416
Bahamut, Anti-magic, HxH, Mahouka, StB, DaL, and IS have the best designs. The rest are shit.
>>
>>153129499
It's not really about battle and it's not a harem but a love triangle (at least in the anime).
>>
>>153132524
>>153132451
Quite the opposite - if you like nondescript moeblobs like pretty much every other character in DaL, you haven't watched enough anime to get tired of them.
>>
File: houki chart.jpg (3MB, 5000x8640px) Image search: [Google]
houki chart.jpg
3MB, 5000x8640px
>>153132875
>Yellow Houki
>Silver Charlotte

you keep saying these things it's like you want me to post the chart
here's your free (You)
>>
>>153132929
Not really, Kurumi is only good for her design but she is pretty bad as an actual character or girl.
>>
>>153132929
And Kurumi is just normalfag bait, not even her own "fans" care about her beyond her design.
>>
The concept of tournament arcs in general bores me to tears. I have never finished a battle harem show.
>>
>>153132943
>Vast majority of Houki clones are worst girl.
Just like Claire.
>>
>>153132929
If you think Kurumi is actually anything special then you should watch more anime.
>>
>>153117416
Ange Vierge and Twintail don't apply the exact school battle harem formula but they are genuinely good shows.

Aside from those two the best series is probably Shinmai Maou.
>>
Tokyo Ravens
>>
>>153133135
You only like them because of their female only cast
>>
>>153133135
>Twintail
No, just no.
>>
>>153133041
>>153133043
>>153133081
Nice opinions you got there.
>>
>>153133195
Great argument, maybe you should go back to that cancerous clock thread and dump Kurumi pics because that's the only interesting thing about her.
>>
>>153133172
No, I like Ange Vierge because it has good writing and Twintail because it never jumps the shark and has hilarious dialogues.

>>153133188
Why? Because you don't like it or because you don't consider it a battle harem?
I know it references the sentai formula but it's still close to the battle harem genre. I think it makes sense to count it as one.
>>
>>153133225
I see you're angry, which is understandable since your only refuge is "n-no your wrong".
>>
>>153133135
Stop it with the AV is a battle harem meme already. It's a fun show but it ain't a battle harem.
>>
>>153133295
>No, I like Ange Vierge because it has good writing
I wonder if you would say the same thing if the female MC was replaced with a male

You wouldnt
>>
>>153133308
Still no argument, huh? Just look at all that amazing discussion they are having in that "Kurumi" thread right now.
>>
>>153133355
All the discussion has been done already. But what discussion can be had about 10ka for example? "My favorite retard, she's so baka it's kawaii"?
>>
>>153132943
Lyn is perfect. Fuck off.
>>
File: fall 2015 battleharems.jpg (367KB, 1500x1086px) Image search: [Google]
fall 2015 battleharems.jpg
367KB, 1500x1086px
>ctrl+f antimagic
>Only 4 results
Yeah, the adaptation was garbage

BUT I'M NOT EVEN MAD ANYMORE
>>
>>153133432
>All the discussion has been done already
People don't even discuss about Kurumi in the main threads and when they do is just to talk about how stupid her goal is. Tohka is not discussed that much in the threads but at least she has development in the novels. The fact you can only think about "My favorite retard, she's so baka it's kawaii" really says a lot of what you can say about Kurumi.
>>
>>153133331
Why? It has almost all the elements of the battle harem. It's just unclear how many girls are really interested in the MC romantically by the end of the show.

>>153133341
I really don't get why you have to force this "people like Ange Vierge only because the MC is female". It's completely retarded. If I had a problem with male MC I wouldn't be watching battle harems in the first place.
>>
>>153116128
this
>>
>>153133530
>All the discussion has been done
>People don't discuss her!
10ka fans, everyone.
>>
>>153116504
Is not a harem you fucking retard, everyone got friendzoned except Reina who's the MC's girlfriend and the winner.
>>
>>153133559
>I really don't get why you have to force this "people like Ange Vierge only because the MC is female
Probably because only dumb yuriscum like it
>>
>>153133606
Not even a Tohkafag, if you lurked the thread you should know they barely lurk anymore and Kurumifags didn't even talk about Kurumi, they just dumped pics. Don't pretend you have been in the threads because is clear you haven't.
>>
>>153133066
I give you that Claire is the bad type tsundere but if you insist on comparing her with IS characters she is more like S1 episode 1 Cecilia, Houki just doesn't fit
>>
>>153133689
Sorry, it's too late to make up for your blunder. At least you're kawaii.
>>
>>153132838
This.
>>
>>153133721
Another great argument, maybe you should try go to at least one thread if you have the time.
>>
>>153133432
You've never been to a DAL thread I see.
>>
>>153133799
They come in small doses and the author usually doesn't get the time to ruin them.
>>
>>153133793
>>153133802
Sorry. Too late.
>>
File: winner.jpg (114KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
winner.jpg
114KB, 1280x720px
>>153116072
Regios.
>>
>>153133892
I still can't believe best girl won
>>
>>153133658
>I'm butthurt because the best battle harem is also a yuri show and I hate yuri.
This is you.

I don't even like the MC of Ange Vierge, and I don't particularly like any of the other girls either. It just has well written conflicts, good pacing, good humor (in small doses), a few decent plot twist and a conclusive end. It's more than any other battle harem has to offer.
>>
>>153133135
Ange Vierge hearkens back to the more adventurous kind of battle musume Monster, or in this case senpai, of the Week format with the main appeal that it fully followed the rule of cool doctrine while also remaining consistent in its astounding stupidity. It's not really fair to liken it to a harem just because there was one gay vampire there whose affection was played for laughs. If the concept of 'FeMC helps each of her party members and develops their friendships with each other' automatically makes a show a harem, do you realize just how many shows suddenly becomes a harem by those standards?

And also, you know full fucking well why Twintails never gets mentioned in these threads. It's a battle harem but it falls on a completely different area on the spectrum.

Stop dragging unrelated shit into generic academy battle harem discussion.
>>
>>153133929
Almost fooled me there /u/

Take your shit back to your own board
>>
>>153133914
Miracles happen.
>>
File: 14658638.jpg (1MB, 1600x2295px) Image search: [Google]
14658638.jpg
1MB, 1600x2295px
>>153133911
nice
>>
>>153133880
I just felt like replying.
>>
>>153129512
I don't know why but this description gave me a boner
>>
>>153133799
This is perfect for finding the next haremshit that I'll watch
>>
>>153116258
Season 4 fucking when?
I want more animated Rossweisse
>>
>>153133799
How does this work?
>>
So, do any of the MC's actually end up with someone in these Harems?

It seems they always become mutual friends with the lead girl and then fade to credits, or the MC is a spineless idiot and is forever oblivious to any of their advances.
>>
>>153133958
>Stop dragging unrelated shit into generic academy battle harem discussion.
OP asks what is the best show, and somehow we're supposed not to mention the best because it deviates a bit from the original formula? Why? Because it dispruts the "Stella is best girl" posting?

>>153133966
You have no argument. You're pitiful.
>>
>>153116072
KoreZom, Rokujouma.

Fucking easy. What prize do I get?
>>
>>153134122
Nobody wants your gay shit anon

Just fuck off already
>>
>>153134175
>Korezom
>A good adaptation
>>
>>153133505
What the fuck is this even trying to say?
>>
File: 1480389522792.jpg (149KB, 552x1020px) Image search: [Google]
1480389522792.jpg
149KB, 552x1020px
>>153116072
the one you posted
>>
>>153134175
>shitty
>>
>>153134184
I did say that Twintail and AV don't apply the exact formula in my first post, and I mentionned Shinmai Maou as the best aside from those two.
You could have just ignored it but you decided to challenge me for some retarded reason.

Finally I read OP post a second time and realized he did mention "LN adaptation", so Ange Vierge doesn't count.
You could have just said that but I suppose you couldn't let a good occasion to shitpost slip by.
>>
>>153119830
>Battle harem
>LN
>Bamboo Blade
You fucking what?
>>
>>153134851
I want a harem of cute kendogirls.
>>
>>153134897
I'm glad it wasn't. It would have ruined the charm.
>>
>>153135154
I mean I want a harem for myself.
Bamboo Blade was good as it was. I wouldn't have mind more romance though. I was disappointed when the anime started a pseudo romance between Tamaki and the bland guy but in the end nothing happened.
>>
>>153134264
Total AMA domination as far as the LN goes, with likeable characters and a satisfying ending whereas both the other series are just spinning their wheels.
>>
File: 1405588599998.gif (2MB, 511x360px) Image search: [Google]
1405588599998.gif
2MB, 511x360px
>>153116072
pic related, its the best
>>
>>153134851
>>153134897
>>153135154
>>153135321

Did anyone read/finish the ln's?
>>
>>153136205
Is MC making fuck with Main girl spinning wheels?
>>
>>153137617
Ikki fucked Stella, and then nothing fucking happened plotwise. Antimagic didn't have anybody fucking anybody (though sword got the first kiss) but it did have a proper multi-volume plot arc up to and including the planet being consumed by an eldritch imouto.
>>
>>153132919
I see your point, the later novels(from vol 3/s2 if we get one) can be considered a bit of a harem, although he pretty much doesn't want anything to do with the girls since they are mortal and all.
>>
>>153137568
You mean the manga? Yeah it's done
>>
>>153117416
How can one formula be used in so many ways and still be so fucking shit? Woah.
>>
>>153139337
It's precisely because of that.
>>
>>153139337
Because when it deviates only a little from the most generic formula and becomes actually good, you get people screaming "But it's not a true battle harem!".
>>
>>153133799
There are obviously multiple reasons, but I think a major one is that the author is under pressure to make the girl fit the "main girl prototype", because of his own interpretation of the readers expectations and sometimes of the actual pressure from his editor. This results in boring generic girls. On the other hand the author has more freedom when he writes side characters so he can put more of his soul (and fetishes) into them, and they come as more genuine and likeable characters.

I say this as someone who almost always prefer the side characters to the main girl.
>>
>>153133799
Because people love an underdog.
>>
>>153137568
There's no LN.
The manga has been finished for years. The author is now working on the Saki spin-off manga.
>>
>>153141595
And by author I mean the person who did the drawings.
>>
>>153139337
Clearly you are not their market.
>>
>>153116994
It was pretty shit senpai
>>
File: 1370062988856.jpg (59KB, 794x960px) Image search: [Google]
1370062988856.jpg
59KB, 794x960px
>>153116121
>SAO
>harem

Aww fuck, you're right.
>>
>>153143199
Does it actually turn into a harem at some point? I only watched the first season.
>>
>>153143938
Even in the first season it was a harem.
>>
>>153144570
The girls in the game are mostly successive one-time encounter, and he doesn't reciprocate their feelings. By the end of the season he is with the main girl and only his brocon sister is still around.
So no, it's not a harem in the first season.
>>
>>153143938
Second season introduces Sinon who probably has the most development with Kirito out of any secondary heroine besides Alice. So there is that.
>>
>>153116128
>this
>>
>anime
arr r shit

>LN
Campione, Magika, Antimagic, HxH, Mahouka, Fafnir in no particular order.
>>
>>153116072
>Still no subbed BD's
Guess this show wasn't popular
>>
File: 1486354592482.png (4MB, 2864x1687px) Image search: [Google]
1486354592482.png
4MB, 2864x1687px
>>
>>153149171
>he thinks he can give ratings when he hasn't read half of the fucking novels in that list
>>
>>153149225
>/a/ - Light Novels
Shit, I always forget where we are. Thank you for reminding me.
>>
>>153149367
I welcome the change since I read more manga and LNs than I watch anime, which I assume is pretty normal here as there's some 30+ anime every season and not even a third of them is good, while there's enough manga out there to bury the Library of Congress.
>>
File: image.jpg (1MB, 1200x1478px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
1MB, 1200x1478px
>>153133152
I remember when the author tried to add Kyouko as a potential lover. It crashed and burned really quickly. I do believe that Tokyo Ravens is a great battle LN series which does power levels correctly and not haremshit.
>>
>>153149572
There's no way that floozy tramp can compete with the Goddess Suzuka, Kon and Natsume
>>
>>153129512
But that's the best part
>>
File: image.png (2MB, 1456x2046px) Image search: [Google]
image.png
2MB, 1456x2046px
>>153149682
Suzuka is gonna win the ogre dick
>>
>>153149881
Hope it can fit.
>>
File: harem-route-unlocked.png (2MB, 1295x1465px) Image search: [Google]
harem-route-unlocked.png
2MB, 1295x1465px
>>153133631
>Is not a harem you fucking retard

>everyone got friendzoned except Reina

So Rakudai is not a harem since MC got together with Stella like two episodes in?
>>
>>153149931
Its not a harem because the girls dont like the dude actually
>>
>>153149962
There's at least FIVE fucking girls who like Ikki.
>>
>>153129311
its a shame Hagure Yuusha only got one season, and the LN isn't being translated.
>>
>>153149962
Did you not see the pic I posted?
>>
>>153149989
1+1=/5
>>
>>153150010
When you only get a little blush like that from an entire cour and nothing else, then you can confidently say its not a harem

Im sure the girls blushed more for the other girls, because its a kyoani show and all
>>
>>153149491
I love manga but I don't understand people who read more than a handful of light novels, they're mostly pseudo-manga scenario that can only shine if well-adapted into manga or anime. Maybe I can understand if you read them in Japanese but not in English as most of them have terrible fan translations.
I like anime and manga because they are visual media. And I like "bad" anime like battle harems mostly despite the shitty designs, characters and writing, not because of them.
If I want to bother reading a book I prefer to read an actually good classic novel as there's a fuckload of them instead of some fiction for teenagers.
>>
>>153150155
When you exhaust all manga you start hunting light novels and visual novels.
>>
>>153150208
>exhaust all manga
Hard to do. Unless you're an actual NEET, spend a lot of time reading manga and barely reread anything.
That is, if you have access to untranslated manga. If not it's much more plausible.
>>
I've read DxD, Shinmai Maou, Hagure Yuusha, Rakudai, Blade Dance, Magika, Mahouka, HxH , IS as far as they've been translated, several unfortunately were dropped by translators.

What else out there is like Shinmai or Hagure with the detailed /e/ scenes, sometimes /h/ scenes. Basically R-18 scenes

OP MC also a plus.
>>
>>153150403
Shishunki na Adam
>>
>>153150446
That's straight up porn.
>>
>>153150476
>Basically R-18 scenes
>>
Strike the Blood is the epitome of a generic battle harem but why do I love it so much
>>
>>153127073
How is mahouka even harem? Protag is literally mind fucked to only care for his sister, making all other girl advances weird for him. Other harem anime at least show protag in a state of mind when he can go either way, but mahouka has him one track minded with only little hints he could change, but not enough to actually do so.
>>
>>153155727
"harem" in that several females want him, and that he's capable of showing various levels of compassion towards them, just not to the same degree as his sister.

I can understand where its kinda grey zone though
>>
>>153123190
wait is this the 1st tournament the anime covers or the one after the double/triple agent guy part and the 2nd? tournament
>>
>>153157678
The super duper big tournament that defines Ikki's entire life and where the series should have ended when he won it.
>>
>>153116072
.
>>
Shinmai Maou

Every girl is best girl.
Has everything from cake to loli even brown.
Protag isn't little bitch.
>>
>>153116072
Probably IS. It got treated right by the adaptation.
>>
>>153150155
>Reading all the recently popular isekai fanfiction like MT, kumo etc and senki LNs like Madan, Altina, Youjo senki, Rakuin no Monshou
>Enjoying it much more than watching anime and reading manga these days.
>Even started learning zipangeeze
How far have I fallen /a/?
Can I ever recover?
>>
File: zero-no-tsukaima-488-1362143827.jpg (117KB, 300x430px) Image search: [Google]
zero-no-tsukaima-488-1362143827.jpg
117KB, 300x430px
When battle harems were actually good.
>>
>>153150155
You have to be deluded into thinking something like Zaregoto for example can ever shine as an anime and capture what made the LN so good.
>>
>>153116072
I've only watched like 5 or so of them.

I liked Rakudai and Mahouka. A shame that we will never get another season of either.

Hated IS and Bahamut. Bahamut pretty much killed all interest in anything remotely close to the genre.
>>
>>153165060
Forgot this piece of shit >>153149931 . That's the last one I can remember more or less.

And yeah, all from the last like 5 years or so. I have shit memory for anything beyond that.
>>
>>153150400
Not at all hard to do, I've been reading manga for over 15 years already.
I can only wait for new stuff to come out, and most of it isn't all that worth a read.
>>
Blade Dance.
>>
File: HERESY.png (98KB, 239x299px) Image search: [Google]
HERESY.png
98KB, 239x299px
Has it been pointed out that Asterisk's mutant superhuman kids are literally called Genestealers?
>>
File: nenene.jpg (726KB, 1280x1483px) Image search: [Google]
nenene.jpg
726KB, 1280x1483px
>>153116072
Rakudai would have been god tier if Nene-ne was the MC!
>>
>>153166595
IIRC it was also hinted in volume 7 that aliens may have been involved in their creation somehow.
>>
>>153117286
I think people give Rakudai a pass because he MC is "alpha" and he dates a girl from early on in the story. Even though pretty much everything else about it is pretty terrible and even the MC & heroine aren't particularly likeable outside of those things I mentioned.

Hell it's exactly a case of "MC actually has the most overpowered ability/is a special snowflake" dressed up as him being weak and having to work hard that people on here make fun of yet tolerate in this series.
>>
File: kiri.jpg (366KB, 768x768px) Image search: [Google]
kiri.jpg
366KB, 768x768px
Asterisk whenever Kirin got the spotlight!
>>
>>153161877
Infinite Stratos is the best battle harem hands down. The MC isnt a dense retard like most harem protags
>>
>>153166735
Asterisk has a long list of great girls and boys, but everything else about it is AVERAGE, white canvas MC, nonsense story, dry prose, average fight scenes.

The characters and only the characters shine in Asterisk.
>>
>>153164534
That's why I said "mostly". Many LN are just wannabe manga but not all of them, I don't deny that.
>>
>>153165733
Really?
Maybe I've been overestimating the amount of already published manga. Or maybe you're a bit too much picky with your read.
Have you read all the long-running shonen? Everything by Yokoyama, Ishinomori, Kamimura, Hirata, Umezu? Do you read Shoujo manga? Jousei manga? Yonkoma?
>>
>>153160047
All the girls are surprisingly entertaining characters and competent fighters. The slice of life scenes are fun. Basara is one of the few "overpowered as fuck" MC's done right. The borderline H scenes and the actual sex is just icing on the cake.
>>
>>153116072
all of them are bad
Thread posts: 255
Thread images: 39


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.