Madoka was a mistake.
>edgy smoker girl with hair drills
Dick status: muh
No, the mangaka is souryuu.
Subverting the magical girl genre is probably the least worthwhile thing you could do at this point considering how strong the cliches are and thus how obvious and predictable their subversion becomes
This was dumb as shit. The fact that she can just beat the shit out of that demon guy feels so forced. Its one thing if she had powers or was a Magical Girl with a terrible personality but instead she just smokes her cigarette and breaks literal walls. Also the art is atrocious.
Her being a superhuman would only work if the twist was she had already had her Magical Girlhood somewhere else and simply got hardened and cynical from the experience.
The delinquent angle is a decent touch, but it and this chapter is just executed very poorly. Fells like one of those movies that makes fun of the Disney formula without any basis.
It reads like a massive shitpost so I can't hate on it.
Well, neither of you are wrong.