Would /a/ rather have an imouto like
>Ui: Understanding, affectionate, and perfect in all domestic matters but is purely platonic and non-sexual
>Kirino: Demanding, judgmental, and abusive both physically and verbally, but bestows sex
Brother-sister incest is always set during the high school year era because, and this is important, it's at best escapism and at worst unrealistically fetishistic.
Once you enter your mid-20s you start to realize "man, my life would be so much more difficult if I'd fucked my sister". Unless you live in a doujin world, I guess, but depending on your writer you might've fucked up more than just your gene pool.
So if that doesn't answer your question, I'm taking the first option and never looking back.
Incest is immoral. Touma approves of Ui.
>imouto that calls you 'Oniichan
>imouto that calls you 'loser', 'trash', 'pervert', and 'piece of shit'
Only that Kirino isn't demanding and abusive.
What I'd like is a very imperfect imouto. That's needy and abusive. But still needs me at the end of the day.
So that I feel wanted and loved. Someone I could look after.
That scene was brutally butchered by the anime. In the novels it's one line that's more about Kyousuke being surprised than actually being choked.
Sounds like you want an
You're way too normal in your thinking. Incest stories are romantic stories. And where are anime romance stories placed 99% of the time anyways? School. Anime romance will either be escapist or tragic or both.
The basis of incest is the feeling of forbidden love, and the love that comes from someone extremely close (not unlike osananajimi). Romantic protags will never weight out pros & cons like that anyways. So even if they were twenty they'd just leap at wherever their heart directs them. Makes for better drama that way anyways.
>you will never have a kind-hearted-but-scatterbrained Oniichan to playfully bat awake in the morning and receive headpats from
Why are we here? Just to suffer?
Mature, understanding and affectionate imoutos who treasure their brothers are better than bratty tsundere little shits
Kirino is a miracle of the universe.
I like the way you think anon. Definitely the best route in Tsukihime
There is, however, the likelihood that when you try to move out and get gf/bf Ui will kill you and eat your liver so you can be 'TogeTHer FoREveR...