What ever happened to this series? It was really big and then

>>151705449
the LN became such a shitfest that no one cares if it doesn't get a S3 anymore

>>151705449
Yukimura won

>>151705449
the author happened

>>151705449
The author give the most autistic ending you could think of which made everyone glad S3 never happened

>>151705944
What was the ending?

File: 1468942144919.png (27KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 500x500px

>>151705449
>why doesn't shallow haremshit have any staying power?!

It's like that by design, man. I don't know what to tell you, you just move on to the next identical show.

>>151705449
The problem with harems is that for every X girls, only 1 can win, which will inevitably upset the fans of the X - 1 remaining girls, at which point the show has completely fractured its viewer base.

>>151706441
Wasn't Sena the most popular girl by far? If that's an issue, just choose the most popular girl. It's either that or harem end.

>>151706051
"Shippers can all go fuck themselves, MC sticks to his original plans, all characters get a conclusion".

File: harem_explained_minerva.jpg (131KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 1280x720px

>>151706441
Which is why we got so many inconclusive endings like Pie End for so long. Which only makes everyone upset.
>>151706640
Harem ends are becoming more popular but they usually seem like an even bigger cop-out.

>>151706641

It's been a while what was his original plan

>>151706784
>Harem ends are becoming more popular

Harem and Romance have less cross-over than Harem and Action or Harem and Comedy at this point.

>>151706815
Have fun with friends.

>>151706784
I'd take a 'copout' over nothing.

>>151705449
I remember when they were both ongoing, this was my chill pill for when I got to angry at Nisekoi for being fucking retarded.

But the author did everything in his power to switch this

>>151705449
My guess is that people slowly lost interest since shit was getting stale and the competition was shitting up more of the same trash, at the end the shippers (understand, meatfags who were 100% sure meat would win due to popularity and cuntfags who assumed that main girl status always conquers everything, people who follow stuff just for vapid pairings) got nothing. S3 never, the show was shit anyway, the manga is the only thing of value to come out of the franchise.

>>151706841
>>151706784

No kidding. Not only do harem ends rob the story of it's growth but it also sort of makes the girls feel like weaker characters, which is bad because in a lot of modern harems the girls are already token cute bland stereotypes.

I understand no one wants to see their girl loose even if they loose there's the sense they'll eventually move on and the growth they made as characters will ensure they're going to be better off. but nope they're just trophies for the boring MC to conquer. And yes I know the genre is wish fulfillment but that doesn't mean you can't have good writing

>>151706980
And then they can make Haganai: After Story, where one of the girls never really recovers and is seen with hundreds of random men around the old club house.

>>151706980
>even if they loose there's the sense they'll eventually move on and the growth they made as characters will ensure they're going to be better off
Or they'll continue to pine for the MC anyway because no one wants to entertain the thought they'd do better for themselves. Harem ending is fine if plausible from the very beginning.

>>151705712
How?
All of her plans backfired and worked out for Meat in the end

None of this matters.

Kobato best girl and the only one that didn't specifically lose, so by elimination she won.

>>151706051
Yozora's parents got tired of her being a peice of shit and got rid of her.
Meat took her into her home since she doesn't realize Yozora has actually been bullying her (And everyone else in the club to try and drive them off) the entire time. Yozora got ALL of Meat's family's money (due to secret shadow rulers of the family picking her as successor.) and began a reign of terror where she constantly bullies them all until her dying day.

Yukimara won the bowl but then fucked up via trying to give an ultimatum on if he wants to date her or hang out with his friends.
MC goes to college and Meat attends the same one so she's probably the only one still competing but we all know Kobato wins.

>>151706980
I remember I was completely shocked at Nisekoi's ending for how much the other girls clearly moved on from Raku. Two of them even finding other men.

>>151706784
>Which is why we got so many inconclusive endings
No, the ANIME gets inconclusive endings because they tend to only cover part of the source materials. The LNs do get conclusive ends. Whether the people like it is another issue entirely.

>Pie End
Unless you're referring to another series, I don't see why you even bring School Rumble up. It's a standard romcom, not a harem.

>>151705449
The trap won.

Sena a coalburner.

File: limpwristed.png (184KB, 498x167px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 498x167px

This triggers my autism. Stop it.

>>151706640
>If that's an issue, just choose the most popular girl
Bleach says hi

>>151708588
Bleach isn't harem and the writer didn't care what fans wanted.

>>151705449
>shit season 2
>panned by fans
>shit sales
>later novels sold like ass
>author was constantly at odds with editors
>by the time the last novel came out no one cared
No season 3. We're better off, the author wanted to be a vindictive cunt and ruined the series just to spite the waifu fags who harassed him.

>>151707645

Every day I grow more and more glad I dropped that shit

>Title is "I want to have friend"
>People mad when it is a full of friendships ending
Why

>>151708683
>A work's only defined by it's title

>>151708683
>"It's about friendship!"
>blatant harembait setup and romantic lead ons
Surely the red chair is happy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFQCX6tIzC4

>>151708636
In his defense, Senafags and Yozorafags (domestic and overseas) were both autistic pieces of shit who didn't deserve their way. Worse than the girls they worshiped.

>>151708636
author is a girl (Rika)

>>151705449
The Sena x Yozora end is fine but everything else sucks.

>>151708683
>So thats it, huh?
>We are some kind of friends now?

So did the MC ever have any friends before?

>>151708934
Yozora.

>>151708636
>>151708815
This and Bleach really highlighted how utterly demented shipping fans are.

>>151708815
Only Senafags ruined this series, I'm glad they were ignored.

>>151706051
From the archives, it's everywhere man.

>Kodaka tries to back down and wants to talk with Rika first

>Yukimura pushes harder, let's him listen to their talk so that Rika knows that she confessed to him

>He says he promised he won't date anyone from the club

>Yukimura says then she will leave the club so there's no problem

>The fag gives up under pressure and they start dating

>They go back to the club room

>He hears Yozora saying she's going to confess and spill spaghetti

>Yukimura enters and says they are dating so the bitches should fuck off

>Yozora confesses eventually later but is rejected

>The fag is rejected by Rika

>One year later before Christmas Yukimura says that to commemorate their 1 year dating somehow

>The neighbour's club is throwing a party. She says If he's going to go to the club party they will break up

>He decides to go to the party in the end, so the break up

>Yukimura joins the club again

>The story ends with all of them eating stew like in vol.1

>"My youth sure was good!"

File: 1465023418590.jpg (360KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

360KB, 1920x1080px

>>151705449
One day I'll get around to watching it for Meat.

>>151711281
Motherfucker. It's worse than I thought

NEED MOAR MEAT

>>151711281
polygamy or harem is the solution

>>151711281
Shit endings like this should be illegal.

>>151712370
can you blame the author, his plan was for yukimura to win but death threats prevented him from doing so

>>151711281
Damn yukimura is a bitch

>>151711281

I guess this is a realistic ending since juggling all those girls is impossible?

He should've just joined the church next door and had Kate/Maria/Kobato family action.

>>151712435
Maybe people would have bitched less if Yukimura actually had more focus than Meat and Yozora.

>>151705449
>Remember the shitstorm over the MC pretending to be retarded?
That's why, if he were a natural retard like Rito it'd be fine, but by pretending he's a selfish asshole. That's why harems are so difficult, inject just a little bit of reality into them and the whole thing falls apart.

>>151705449
it ended and it was horseshit

>doesn't tap Meat
>nor Rika

NANDATTE?

EH? WHAT DID YOU SAY?

The author attempted to take the series away from light-hearted comedy and change it to drama. No one wanted that so it tanked and then he half assed an ending. It's an example of what happens when the author ignores the fans and just writes what he wants to write.

>>151708851
No, the author is a male.

>>151708851
here is that bitch's twitter
https://twitter.com/hirasakayomi

>>151708636
>the author wanted to be a vindictive cunt and ruined the series just to spite the waifu fags who harassed him.

Based as fuck.

>>151712435
It's no surprise then that his new (bad) series has the yukimura knockoff be the main girl right from the start.

I didn't have a problem with the actual ending because it was an actual ending that worked for the characters and themes laid out during the series.

No-one wins doesn't mean inconclusive or open.

>>151706051
MC friendzones all

>>151713621
But it is inconclusive. Sena is still pursuing him and it's doubtful Yukimura is going to give up just like that.

>>151705944
>>151706051
>>151706641
>>151711281
That doesnt sound so bad. Well it really is shit, but that would leave me a bittersweet taste. In the end it's all a waste of time like real life. Was the author going through depression?

>>151705449
>It was really big and then nothing
it was never big

>>151705449
Yozora drama queen fits ruined it

And Sena goes to college with him.

Yozora works for the Kashiwazakis but still lives with her mom because she is like her if she went further down.

And Kate is a fan of Kodaka's father just like Pegasus buy without the tsundere.

>>151712901

>gets all the Kobato he wants at home

Why would he?

>>151705529
Well shit

>>151713373
More like little bitch. Anyone so bothered by fans that it has to affect their work is a pussy.