Wait just a minute, If Rosa killed Beato before then why didn't

>>149883591
Take any scene without Battler with a grain of salt.

>>149883591
It's called making it up as he goes along

>>149883647
I don't even know what the fuck is going on anymore.

That's because Rosa IS Beatrice. Who do you trust more, R07 or 9-hour youtube autist? Please remember episodes 7, 8, and the Lucia route in your response.

>>149883591
Because Yasu and his mother are different people? Were they really supposed to look identical? Also >>149883647
One of the things that kind of takes emotional weigh away from any scenes without the "detective", whole parts of the story are just made up bullshit.

>>149884030
>parts

Every single episode was fictional in-universe. The entire story was made up. None of it ever happened. It was just a cripple trying to cope with the fact his dickless boyfriend smashed him over the head with a gold brick, threw him off the boat, and ran off to go be rich on his own.

>>149884123
A lot of the episodes are possibilities of what really could've happened in the island though, it's just that many scenes would have to be fake for the murders to be possible.

Magic doesn't exist.

>>149884235
you don't exist

>>149884510
How can magic exist if it's all made up?

>>149883591
Episode 2 and 3 were written by different people. Episode 2 was written by Yasu before the Rokenjima incident and she figured Rosa would have forgotten everything. Episode 3 was written by Battler after the Rokkenjima incident and presumably at some point during it, Rosa discussed what had happened when she had met Beato.

File: Umineko Witch Theory.jpg (210KB, 1042x658px) Image search: [Google]

210KB, 1042x658px

>>149884235
>Magic doesn't exist

Bullshit. Magic exists in the When They Cry universe. Try explaining the ending of Higurashi without magic.

Uuu~!

>>149884235
>>149884510
>>149885083
>>149885391
>Magic doesn't exist
>In the year of our lord KEK 2016

Legit though "meme magic" is kinda how magic worked in Umineko kinda.
Can controlling the cultural context be equated to reality warping?

>>149885391
>Try explaining the ending of Higurashi without magic.

It was another fuckin board game dude. It was just one spun by Lambda and Featherine

Maybe it's just multiverse theory. I mean for all we (as in the real people in this thread) know a muliverse could exist so one could exist in story.

Is it necessary to play Higurashi before Umineko?

>>149886510
not really, umineko references higurashi a couple of times but the stories are completely unrelated

File: rxoW0y2.jpg (155KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

155KB, 1920x1080px

>>149886568
Oh. I might try Higurashi later but
>that artstyle

File: ipoxo2.jpg (57KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 640x360px

>mfw seeing the Maria smile CG for the first time

File: 1438657545495.png (136KB, 405x480px) Image search: [Google]

136KB, 405x480px

>>149886620
you learn to love it

>>149886784
I can't take Beato seriously with that artstyle. At least it's cute sometimes.

>>149885607
>asked to explain Higurashi without magic

> bring up Lambda and Featherine
>LITERALLY Witches

>>149886877
Higurashi didn't actually happen that way is the point, there was just a magic spin on it because the witches were used as the storytelling method. You know how the meta world works right? It's the same way.

File: 01Erika.png (331KB, 550x600px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 550x600px

>>149883591
Posting best Seacat.

How's the anime?

>>149886620
Go for the PS3 sprites if the original one bugs you that much, they're pretty good

>>149888943
Not great

>>149889835
Higurashi PS3?

>>149884510
Can you prove that? That's a devil's proof.