With GitS and Death Note both now getting American adaptations, are there ANY shows you could imagine actually working as live action in the west?
Yes.
With love, a good budget, a good cast and a good director, I think most things could work.
Unfortunately Hollywood thinks a good budget can solve everything.
Netflix adaptation of Welcome to the NHK (the manga) has the potential to be wildly successful in the west.
Shows likeBojack Horsemanshow that westerners are really into depressing grim stories.
It would need a few tweaks for a western audience, but I think its got a pretty good base to be adapted
Can anyone give a rundown on the GITS saga? I'll watch the first movie, then what? There are like 4 movies and two tv shows. Are the shows great or should I just stick to the movies? I don't really feel like watching a series.
>>149551943
I feel like Black Lagoon could be good since the action, setting, and racial diversity should be easy to produce in Holloywood. And the amount of swearing is also is for Americans to pull off.
>>149553557
The problem with Black Lagoon is that you'd need to cast someone that could pull off Revy which would be impossible.
Cowboy Bebop is my go to in this situation but it would be difficult to pick what episodes to adapt. I'm surprised Jojo hasn't been picked to be adapted but I think you then run into the same problem of Revy's casting but this time with DIO.
Tiger Mask, using real wrestlers, not some boy band looking main actor using some kind of iron man armor.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cw3YzxwmlM8
If Marvel bought the rights to make a One Punch Man movie they'd make $1 billion+ easily.
>>149551943
i think pic related would make a good tv drama
>>149553974
I see it more as a single movie.
>>149551943
>>149551943
Cowboy Bebop could actually work as live action I think
>>149551943
Garupan live action when?
>>149554370
Forget live-action, we need to turn this into an actual sport for little girls.
>>149552678
Read the manga instead
>>149554122
Depending on how GitS and Death Note do, it might come out of Production Hell.
That being said, I still don't know how well Keanu would fit Spike. I like Keanu and all, but he doesn't have that "care-free" attitude that is Spike.
L is a nigger.
>>149554494
His first name is Samuel.
>>149552143
But it is already established that westerners like grim stories, just the American crowd specifically needed establishment.
>>149554494
*siren wails*
>>149552678
-Watch the 1995 Movie
-Watch the two seasons and the OVA of Stand Alone Complex
-Rewatch the 1995 movie
-Watch Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence
-Read the Manga
-If you are bored watch the Arise stuff.
Black Lagoon
Ajin
maybe Heavy Object
Knights of Sidonia
I am a Hero (though that's a manga)
>>149552678
It's the same basic theme but with focus on different aspects.
If you're only watching one of them, I'd recommend the SAC movie, it gives a summary of the most important story if you're not reading the manga.
But because all movies, series and the manga overlaps very nicely I would really just say watch all of them by release date.
>>149552678
>>149554115
Literally Evangelion but good
BASED ELBA
>>149551943
ping pong
>>149554533
Unlike Berserk Ash vs evil dead is good
>>149554494
dayum nigga it's dat muhfuggah Light guy, rite?
>>149553669
>He honestly thinks Hollywood would have a hard time properly casting an angry psycho bitch.
Nigga you need to get out of your anime bubble.
>>149555297
>Hot half Chinese woman that manages to be badass and ooze charisma.
A bad Revy would ruin the movie.
Hollywood should have no problem adapting Monster
Here's the problem though, as a motion picture Monster will have no novelty among movie goers. It will be too big a risk to gamble financially.
>>149554728
This. Going back and watching the original movie was great after getting used to SAC.
>>149555355
You sound like you're convinced Hollywood wouldn't cast a white girl instead even if a half-chinese actress you described actually exists
>>149555355
>half Chinese
Revy isnt "half" shit she's Chinese American. Not sure where you people got this "half Chinese" shit from.
>>149554624
What are you trying to say?
Takeshi Miiki's Blade of The Immortal is the only adaption that has any chance of being good.
>>149556063
>>149551943
I am really happy we are seeing more adaptions just for the fact that anime is getting more popular. But i would rather like to see some manga adaptions then anime ones. HBO Monster, Berserk or Akira would be awesome.
>>149556117
>>149556131
HBO or Showtime would be perfect for Black Lagoon live action
Monster or Pluto.
please
I'd like to see an akira miniserieswith a black cast
Symphogear.
By Michael Bay.
Oreimo.
Black Lagoon
Cowboy Bebop
Berserk
Macross
>>149556131
Ghost in the Shell IS a manga. But the adaptation will take more from the anime, just like literally every non-anime adaptation of a manga that HAS an anime adaptation.
>>149551943
Cowboy Bebop
Directed by John Woo , with a full chink cast and one singaporean.
>>149551943
The more I look at it the more fine she looks, non-Asian-ness aside (though you could argue that the "Shell" is the reason she looks like a westerner, so it's really not an issue).
I want more shoujo series. Boys Before Friends was weaker than the other Hana Yori Dango dramas.
>>149556352
>Faye Valentine
>Spike Spiegel
>Jet Black
>Edward
>Ein
>Asian
>>149551943
Live action MD Geist when?
keijo
Phantom Blood
>simple story
>already has exposition
>self-contained
>takes place in England
>short enough to make it without major cuts
>>149556383
You need to look again. Unless by "fine" you actually mean shit
>>149556407
Faye :Singalapoorian
Spike:They're eurasian chinks
Jet Black: Brown chinks too.
Edward: He looks chink enough.
Ein: Stephen Chow is puuufect. He make good barking noises.
>>149556407
Faye is Asian though
>>149556551
This looks good, I don't see the problem at all. Plus we all now this actress is a top-notch one. Nothing to do with Dragon Ball's 'nobodies'.
>>149556383
Yeah, the movie made a point that she's an off the shelf cyborg body with the times she runs into others looking exactly like her. Being white is not a problem.
However I can't say the adaptation will be any good. Will wait.
>>149556117
>No Nazi sign
Pussies.
>>149556598
>Edward
>He
>>149556696
>Dragon Ball's
Chow Yuen Fatt was so great.
>>149554819
already done, and it was pretty good!
>>149554799
>TONIGHT!... We cancel the apocalypse!
>Hol up
>Pops pill
What did he mean by this?
>>149551943
Make a HBO monster, and trust me you will see a new age for anime adaptions.
With the right director which understood what makes the story good to the core, then you could create something truly successfull while still being great
>>149556696
Don't know about"top notch" she's OK at best. The director's claim to fame was a shitty Snow White movie and Avi Arad is involved yet another red flag. There is also the fact that she looks nothing like The Major , cg looks awful, the city in the bottom pic looks more realistic and "lived in" than the clearly green screened BG in the top pic.
The cast and crew behind the Alita movie inspires more confidence than this shit. Shame they couldn't get the calibur of Talent that the new Blade Runner movie has behind it. At this point I would even take the Wachowski's over this director. They would at least get the look right, though they'd probably cast Bae Doona as The Major
Anything made by a westaboo like Gunsmith Cats. Historical stuff like Vagabond and Vinland Saga would also be easy. I actually think shorter drama series like Punpun would be easy as well. The less anime clichés and stupid power level stuff the easier it is.
>>149555826
people misstake chinese american with "half-chinese"
>>149552143
This
Hellsing
Fullmetal Alchemist, based on either the manga, or brotherhood.
>Cast consisting of white people, asians, black people, middle eastern people, so diversity is a tick
>Kickass orchestral soundtrack
>Kickass battle soundtrack
>War may be necessary, but is never pleasant theme
>Compromising humanity is never a good idea theme
>General conspiracy plot to delight all
>Homunculi and chimeras and soldiers oh my
>Strong feminine role models
>Extremely likeable characters
>Very little region specific humor
>Diverse settings
>Protagonists are essentially orphans trying to make their way in the world
>Unique way of observing alchemy, possibly one of the best
I can't understand why western studios haven't jumped on it.
Not manga, but do you guys think a writer/director could work something out of the Dark Souls world? Not try to get the whole games, just a story inside the world. And would the general public be interested in it?
Berserk is an obvious candidate as dark medieval fantasy is pretty safe ground as far as genre's go, it wouldn't need to be altered radically in order to be marketable
I don't even think it would necessarily be that difficult apart from minor things like making the Dragonslayer not look goofy as fuck when held by a real human being, the main problem would come in attaching people who care enough about the source material to preserve it while simultaneously knowing what/how to cut it for the translation onto the big screen and how to assuage general Japanese storytelling conventions into something a bit smoother, and to keep it a hard R, or at least something on the level of a Paul Verhoeven movie like Robocop. A PG-13 Berserk would be dead in the water from minute one, although I'm not familiar enough with film rating to know if the Casca rape scene could potentially be enough to push it into an NC-17
Everything up to the end of Tower of Conviction/the introduction of Sheirke is already basically set up for a 1:1 translation, it's only a matter of time an interest
>>149559563
Not really, and I think that shitty DS3 comic they put out a while ago is evidence enough of that
The thing about the story and characters of Dark Souls is that they're only noteworthy in the context of a game in which you're slowly and deliberately going through dilapidated ruins and locations where you only occasionally run into something that doesn't immediately take a swing at you. By trying to make a traditional story centered in that world, and then just delivering that story to you directly instead of allowing you to infer it by item descriptions or locational design, you lose all the charm and value and just end up with a bland dark fantasy story
I actually loved the death note films - both the dub and sub. Definitely had a better ending than the anime/manga, fuck Near. And yes I know I'm gonna get flamed for this
>>149554370
I approve of this.
>>149554494
This political correctness has to stop.
L is supposed to be pale and looks tired at all times.
Black people just can't look pale very well.
Fucking Hollywood.
>>149559789
It would probably work but people would freak about the Kushan, and their whole thing being related to Muslims, and the whole project would go downhill
>>149552143
I don't think so, the masses only accept autistic loner MCs if they make up for it by being geniuses and/or getting better in time. The vast majority of normalfags would not appreciate NHK due to not identifying with Satou very much.
>>149551943
No. Take Gurren Lagann and imagine someone doing the poses and talking like that. I feel dirty just thinking about it.
>>149560211
Maybe, although when you consider that a movie like 300 got away with portraying ancient Persians just fine, and the fact that the story includes characters like that Kushan prince with the two musclebound body guards, it might not be that big a deal, since those are usually topics that are only broached by articles on Buzzfeed and Vox that your average person doesn't care about
Even then, there's a ton of early Berserk where the Kushan aren't even a significant presence, I mean you could do all of Golden Age and they'd never come up except for the prince and the five Kushan hired by the King of Midland
>>149551943
Rose of Versailles would probably work.
Normie women love historical dramas, and you'd also be able to attract the "strong, independent womyn" crowd too.
I think Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: Phantom Blood could be a good hollywood adaption in the right hands.
>>149560440
Really it comes down to if they want to go into the whole ark with the demon king, and in further inspection I meant to say Buhddsim not Muslim
Desert Punk. It's great but there isn't any subtelty that could be lost in the adaptation. It's just pure action and there isn't much gore so itd just be PG-13.
>>149560510
I see this a lot but I just don't see how
The early bits with Dio and Jonathan are enjoyable, but the bombastic nature of the presentation is what makes it work, like when Dio knees Danny. By making that into live action, you lose that, and all you're left with is a fairly thin story where a guy tries to poison his father, gets found out, then turns into a vampire
This is ignoring the fact that roughly 40-50% of Phantom Blood is Jonathan and Zeppeli fighting zombies with Hamon, which just isn't interesting and would suffer even more. The fight with Dio is fun enough but it and the encounter on the ship that run out Phantom Blood wouldn't be sufficient to round it out, it just doesn't make for a cohesive package. I think you could do Steel Ball Run and that would go better, because it's a fundamentally stronger story with more detailed characters and interesting situations that lend themselves to character performances that you would actually want to see as opposed to say the constant stream of Stand Battles in Part 3
>>149556551
The lighting, effects, and costume are what look bad here. She is fine.
>>149560411
You mean Sentai?
>>149560141
Its very likely that the amount of people trying out for a FUCKING ANIME ADAPTATION MOVIE are very small so maybe all the white volunteers were just awful compared to this guy
>>149556832
That IS the manji. Learn calligraphy first, you uncultured swine.
>KyoAni cinematic universe
>live action Haruhi, Chitanda, Kumiko, Kaname and the Frees joining forces to deal with a world-threatening crisis, ft. K-ON playing the theme songs
>A no fun allowed world government is going to enforce stricter education!
>That means fun stuff like club activities will be shut down! Bands will be shut down! No more eating cakes and drinking tea in classrooms!
>who are going to save the student and allow them to regain their TANOSHIII BUKATSU?!
SOS-Dan Revival: You can(not) Tanoshii
Summer 2020
>>149551943
Gundam, as long as its directed by Micheal Bay and James Cameron
>>149562398
It will be shit because both directors are notorious for being control freaks.
>>149560979
>She is fine.
She is ugly. Her face gives me nightmares. Also, terrible tits.
When do we get YUKIKAZE? Or is Tom Cruise just gonna sit on it?
Tiger and Bunny: The Hollywood is still a thing too.
>>149551943
>>149551995
DRAGONBALL EVOLUTION
Big O.
You forgot one. Reminder that this is the darkest timeline. I might work though
>>149551943
One Punch Man:
Many studios are trying to get the license for this and make a Live Action movie happen. This is one of the hottest brands right now more than we realize. People like Fox and WB are acting like One Punch Man can compete with the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
>>149563400
I mean it's valuable for a reason
In the right hands a OPM movie could very easily turn into another Deadpool, which I'm sure is probably the main factor behind any major interest in the movie rights
I don't even think it would be terribly difficult to adapt for a western market
>>149556430
I don't think Hollywood could fuck it up if they tried.
Anything bad would just make it even more entertaining.
Unless they change the music. That's a no-go.
>>149551943
I can only hope they do it justice
>>149556243
Too big of a cast how would they even handle Yang'sdeath
>>149559351
I would hope it would be developed as a series rather than movies
>>149560141
What about albinos?
>>149560979
She is "fine" as in I would fuck her, but no she' no Major
>>149554370
fury?
>>149551943
Usagi Drop
>>149557313
>There is also the fact that she looks nothing like The Major
a human being doesn't look like a cartoon character, go figure
The less the West gets involved in anime, the better.
>>149566335
Buh.... But animu characters l..look White!
Alice in borderlands
It's an HBO wet dream
>cheap post apoc light setting
>compelling mystery
>mind games
>twists
>character melodrama
>very fatal to the main cast
It's like if Lost, saw and twd had a bastard child.
>>149566227
Ask Woody Allen to make a biopic on himself then.
>>149567352
He's busy self inserting into his own wish fulfilment flicks.
>>149551995
>>149551995
>>149552143
>>149552678
>>149553557
>>149553669
>>149553747
>>149553898
>>149554115
>>149554122
>wanting americanized anime
Literally worst than new cancer. Fucking poison
>>149553557
>Hollywood
confirmed for not know shit
Black Lagoon could only work if it's made in China, since the primary inspiration is Chinese gangster film.
>>149560141
It doesn't matter, if you get a competent actor to do it who can do something interesting with the character and it might even be a good and interesting idea.
But obviously generic black kid #304 can't do that and putting blacks into a film for a no reason feels pretty racist to me, in this classic ancient roman "look at the nigger, everyone" way.
>>149556383
The problem with scarjo isn't that she's white, but that she can't act.
At all.
Tsukihime
>>149553669
brenda song could maaaaaybe do it
>>149567734
Written by Tarantino and directed by Mathew Vaughn, boom you got your fucking Live Action Black Lagoon
>>149551943
wut
>>149567846
It would be easier to just hand it to John Woo and tell him to go all out.
>>149567734
>China
You have to specify Hong Kong, because Mainland isn't worth shit for gangster films with cool fights. Sorry, looks like you don't know shit either.
The major problem is that most of these can't be made into movies because too much plot would need to get cut.
But anime movies can work if done correctly. Chronicle was basically an anime movie and so was edge of tomorrow.
>>149560878
It's a vampire hunter story, like Van Helsing, but with a martial arts master as the protag. Most action movies really do not need to have a better story than that.
>but the bombastic nature of the presentation is what makes it work, like when Dio knees Danny
I feel like people just say this because, for whatever reason, the anime carried the sound effects over from the manga as a visual gag. Reading the manga, what I got from that arc was Hokuto no Ken meets Castlevania.
>>149559789
>kushan
they are actually related to Hindu not muslims unless all brown people look same to you, that's even more racist
>>149556268
You leave symphogear out of this.
>>149568451
A little late to be giving that attention.
Still, the over the top nonsensical action, why not?Yes, I am the one you quoted.
>>149558788
Also Vampire Hunter D
>>149554494
>google it
>it's legit
This
>>149568074
The thing is they go after the wrong properties. Stuff like GITS even Battle Angel I am skeptical of despite the people behind it. Stuff like FMA , Black Lagoon, mother fucking Hellsing, lend themselves to Western adaptions the most
>>149569793
Who could possible portray her though?
>>149551943
The Death Note one is already out, and it's trash. Who would've thought?
Thoughts?
>>149556551
>when the hand painted anime background looks more real and high detailed than the cgi background of the live action
>when the hand drawn motoko's face is more expressive than the canned determined scarjo's face
how can they fuck up so badly?
>>149551943
Pretty Cure
Stein's Gate directed by Danny Boyle
>>149567414
>>149572072
*eye twitch*
>>149565541
Jackie chan
>>149556189
I came in this thread to say just that.
>>149570935
>a story about a bunch of otaku fucks in otaku land being otaku
>american live action movie
There is no way it would even resemble the source
>>149572621
Yeah have you watched this thing called the big bang theory?
Coming in late, but Psycho Pass could actually be adapted into a live action TV series easily enough. I've ignored enough crime drama TV shows to know that it could work well enough, given that it's not done like shit
Spice and Wolf could definitely work.
Too bad it won't appealing enough to last long.
>>149553669
She could.
>>149570272
I don't get what adaptations are supposed to be
It doesn't convey anything from the original mood in that shot nor is it as aesthetically pleasing as the original
If it's supposed to be a replica of it it's doing a shit job and if it's supposed to be a reimagination it's just as shitty
>>149554859
They're both good.
>>149551943
There are plenty of generic action stories with lots of violence, sex, ninja, and samurai that would be great to adapt.
BnP
>>149577473
It's probably meant to be fan service.
>Capeshit failing
>Anime and manga adaptations about to be big or have renewed interest in with the 2020 Tokyo Olympics approaching
>TBBT theory ending which helped prolifereate the psuedo nerd facade persona
we just need one good adaptation, a shitty sitcom about weebs and everyone will be on the "I'M SUCH A WEEB XD" bandwagon