Things I like.

If it's got good things in it and was made goodly.

Depends on the genre.

>>149484485

feel free to pick your favorite.

>>149484388
realistic and believable characters - 35%
plot and writing - 35%
Visuals - 20%
Sound - 10%

Craftsmaship is the most important factor.

You can't nake a good show if your heart isn't poured into it.

>>149484388
When they have a cute glasses girl, who no one thinks is cute. Until they go to the beach or something and it turns out she is fucking sexy as hell.

>>149484388
If I have fun every episode.

Also sakugafag pandering and good banter.

>>149485161
What anime does this best?

>>149485161
Yeah, this.

If I feel compelled to watch the next episode directly, either to find out what happens next or to experience more of the characters. If the next episode feels like a chore, the show isn't remarkable.

>>149484388
If I enjoy watching it.

Cute girls

If I enjoy it it's good, even if it's bad

>Only the things "I" enjoy are good.
sasuga /a/

>>149486087
No, you silly.
Not what you like.
What *I* like.

>>149484388

An anime is good if it fulfills the vision its creators had for it, or otherwise finds an audience for itself.

File: 1447958579021.gif (1MB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 450x450px

>>149484388
If I like it, it's good.
I used to be one of the people who had a complete stick shoved up their ass and assumed what really mattered was shit like the "writing, character development, theme exploration" and God knows what but so long as it's fun, it's good. That's all that matters.

>>149484388
Has something else going for it other than "cute girls"

>>149484388
I enjoy it, everything else doesent matter.

>>149487352
As long as you have fun, everything else is irreverent.

if it gives me feels then its good

thats all pretty much

File: The Greatest Masterpiece In The History of Humanity.jpg (2MB, 1278x2160px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1278x2160px

Entertaining = Good

>>149487303
Perhaps you realized you had shit taste so you changed your definition of good to accommodate it?

>>149484388
Enjoyable for me.

Primary factors are character dynamics and writing
Secondary factors are characters and the story
Lastly, visuals and sound

It depends on the genre though, for example in a cute girls SoL kind of anime characters and visuals would be more important while writing and story not so much.

Good is subjective, so there isn't a correct answer.

>>149484388
Passion on the part of the creators, competent writing and good characters.

>>149492221
this

>>149485212
Banter is something I feel gets overlooked a lot. It's not appropriate for every show, but it really makes the characters feel real.

>>149484388
If it panders to me I like it.

>>149485663
What if it's one sluggish episode out of dozens that aren't like that?