Why doesn't Madoka love Homura romantically
Because Madoka is normal i.e. heterosexual.
She does.
>>149318424
Madoka is pure.
>>149318459
Heteronormativity needs to STOP!!!
>>149318464
No, Homura and Madoka are both straight. Please stop trying to make them gay to fit your stupid head canon. They both like boys, and they're platonic friends. Both even admit that there are boys they like.
The real reason you people want them to be homosexuals is because you're so insecure about your own masculinity that you can't bear to see them with another man. You also have deeply held homophobic beliefs, and think that homosexual relationships are somehow less valid than heterosexual relationships. You would rather see them together romantically than with other men romantically, because you don't think a romantic relationship between Homura and Madoka is "valid" so to speak.
Really sad and pathetic, if you ask me. Stop being so insecure and get the hell over it. Homura and Madoka are both straight and always have been.
>>149318506
This desu
>>149318424
>>149318668
No.
gateway anime of the worst kind
>>149318749
Honestly I can't imagine Madoka would have the strength to choke anyone with her tiny hands.
>>149318668
>>149318424
She's only known her for a month.
Reminder that girls can't love girls
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bI9hgp32-f0
Because the only character driven by romantic love is Sayaka. Madoka is the purest, driven by love for all of humanity equally, and that's why her wish is the good end.
>>149319261
Madoka, no!
Your hands are too weak!
>>149319943
>Because Madoka is a Mary Sue
Fixed ;)
>>149320011
I can't even imagine what definition you used to come up with this.
>>149318424
Am I the only one who loved Homu romantically?
Homura doesn't even love Madoka romantically. The butcher left clear that Homura doesn't have sexual attraction toward Madoka, so the otakus can feel safe that their waifu isn't a filthy dyke
>>149320337
You say that like it's a bad thing.
>>149318424
Who could? She is objectively a terrible shitty person in almost every regard. And she has no ass.
>still doing these threads
That's sadder than my life.
>>149318668
I agree that they are straight, but your average immature teen/manchild will think they are gay, or at least that homura is gay.
The show is yuribait, that's unquestionable. I just hope shaft doesn't actually make them gay to please the yurifag audience.
>>149321349
The original show did very little to feed into that. The movies gave it plenty of material, but there's pretty much nothing in the show to suggest romantic love. It only looks that way if that's the only way you can imagine feeling strongly about someone unrelated to you.
>>149318668
You care entirely too much about the sexuality of these fictional characters. Really sad and pathetic if you ask me.
>>149321611
It actually impacts the theme of the show to believe that they are romantically entwined. It's a valid thing to care about.
>>149318668
>Please stop trying to make them gay
Only if the staff stops.
>>149321404
I agree. The movie went full yuribait.
Especially with the forced kyousaya hand hold.
>>149318424
Because she dont havepenis, you need this for love someone.
>>149321767
And I get it. If your movies are literally rehashes of an already beloved series, you're just pandering to your existing audience.
>>149321767
POST GIF OF MADOKA HUGGING HOMURA
>>149318424
She might.
>>149321767
>kyousaya hand hold
Yep, it may not have been canon before, but those two are legit rug munchers now. All just to milk money from yurifags.I guess I'm okay with it.
>>149318424
It's literally only /a/ who thinks this.
>>149323933
Well everyone else is stupid
>>149320337
Go read Wraith Arc. Yuri's canon on all fronts. It doesn't matter what Butcher said 8 months before Rebellion. It matters what was said in Rebellion and what was reinforced through the interquel series. Shaft wants money and will go full yuri for that reason.
>>149318424
madoke prefers dicks, big ones
>>149324396
>go read this rando manga that's totally canon
Didn't we settle this like wow, fucking five years ago
>>149324573
>implying 90% of this thread has been here more than 1
>>149324573
You can't settle autism.
>>149324396
>wraith arc
>canon
on top of that
>mangas
>canon
>>149318668
Magical girls must love magical girls, not normal humans.
>>149327320
Hush, QB. You know nothing of love.
>>149327922
>love
Love is a social construct.
>>149328640
Emotions are a mental illness.
>>149328823
A mental illness capable of producing enough energy from nothing to prevent the heat death of the universe
You know what this thread needs?
Crack pairings
>>149328977
I disagree
>>149318424
Doesn't matter what sexuality any of them are; Madoka has only known Homura for a month.
>>149329083
Madoka has known Homura for several million years
What is wrong with girls loving girls?
>>149328977
That actually seems pretty crack. I give it an 8/10 on the crack scale, but only a 2/10 on the quality pairing scale.
>>149329610
I don't know sis. This is probably the work of the witch's labyrinth we're trapped in.
>>149318424
She does, but Madoka also love everyone else as well.
>>149318424
Because she's not interested
Homura is delusional, DELUSIONAL
>>149330033
>madoka romantically loves everyone
>anon in charge of reading comprehension
>>149318668
Like a fiddle.
>>149318424
>Implying
The tragic yin-yang romance was set up in Rebellion. All they need to do at this point is 「Connect」and bring balance to the universe.
salutations lads
some of you seem to need a reminder
>>149331155
delet this
>>149330195
No she is not.
>>149331155
>were
>>149332123
>implying she's not totally off the rails
>>149332430
Who?
>>149331155
Poor Sayaka got replaced
>>149331155
Being Homu is suffering.
>>149332292
She did say "were". Madoka was ascending to godhood so she used past tense because her days of being friends with homura are over.
>>149333354
Until they would be reunited again under the law of cycles, of course.But we all know how that turned out.
>>149333464
I'm really interested to see how Madoka will react to Homura betraying her wish. I hope she isn't too forgiving.
>>149333354
>replying to it
>>149333517
Apple is my friend though
>>149318459
>Madoka
>Heterosexual
She's gay as fuck, but she knows better than date a devil.
>>149333508
Madoka will definitely be upset, but she'll forgive her. It's still going to end up in a fight because Homura still won't let Madoka be the law of cycles.
The only way for Homura to make Madoka hate her is if she kills of one of her friends.
Thread's over
>>149319261
Homura is receiving sexual stimulation from failed choke
Why are these shitposting threads allowed?
>>149333354
Unless she meant she became something more to her.
>>149334368
>engaging in the mental gymnastics
>>149334085
I think it would be a safe bet that the mods secretly lurk and enjoy this shitfest.
>>149334312
>>149318424
Who's to say she doesn't?
>>149318668
That's a lot of assumptions
>>149335124
>t. memer
most of this thread
>>149328823
>chemical reactions in the brain somehow equals an illness of the mind
Fake bunnyrabbit pls leave
>>149328977
Well that's a new one.
>>149335503
How else would you define the vast majority of mental illnesses? They're pretty much all chemical imbalances
>>149335521
The reason mental illnesses are illnesses are because they're uncommon within a population, and usually have negative symptoms associated with them. Normal, common processes that are gained evolutionary aren't illnesses.
Black and Blue is the most aesthetically pleasing, I think.
>>149335633
I'm pretty sure negative symptoms alone are enough to classify it as an illness. Kyubey would likely describe the irrational and often self-destructive actions caused by emotion to be a good example of that.
>>149335675
Who cares?
>>149335675
This is too illogical fort me to enjoy
>>149335678
I suppose, but to call something as basic to humanity as emotion a "mental illness" just rubs me the wrong way, since that phrase has a more medical connotation tied to it.
>>149335692
I do
>>149335773
Feel free to go find others who care. Just posting images that effectively have nothing to do with the show, let alone the thread is stupid.
>>149318424
Because Madoka loves Homura sexually.
>>149335863
Everyone loves Homura sexually
Would you Our Lord God Almighty?
>>149335967
But this is a proper Madoka thread.
this thread is full of keks
>>149335937
Ecchi master !GM pls.
>>149335996
This post has legitimately made me angry. Why are you even posting in this thread? There are literally entire boards devoted to posting images with no real contribution.
>>149336057
Cute!
>soul gems are just rigged batteries that make girls into eldritch abominations when they lose the will to live so aliens that work for the space power company can harvest their sadness energy.
So how about that Madoka Magica? The hype for wraith arc was met with disappointment.
>>149336077
Seriously. Answer me. Why are you here?
>>149336117
Didn't you get the message?
Memes....
>>149336106
That's pretty much PMMM's lore
>>149336117
Because I want to be?
Why was Sayaka such a bitch?
>>149336125
Only one of those are me...
>>149336138
Because she is frustrated that her crush doesn't love her back and that her best friend is kind of a backstabbing bitch.
>>149336138
Because she didn't know how to deal with having someone she likes like someone else. The whole "fighting eldritch abominations on a daily basis" didn't help either. Or the "my soul's been ripped out" thing.
>>149336173
Wasn't Madoka her best friend?
>>149336114
If they really do make another anime adaptation, I want them to keep the bittersweet pace they've kept up. However it ends, it should wrap things up nicely, but at a hefty price.
>>149336138
Because her own insecurity caused her to lose her only chance at getting the love of her life to her close friend who gave her a fair chance to get said love of her life.
>>149336224
me mum said to me when i was a wee lad that people can have multiple best friends
>>149318424
You don't get a woman to devote herself to you just by being nice to her. You have to control her both emotionally and sexually. Homura shows all the signs of a woman who has been thoroughly manipulated, and she hamster it by telling herself how there is a pure love between Madoka and her.
You don't get to see the manipulative sides of Madoka often because most of the time the audience see things through Homura's eyes. Homura believes that Madoka can do no wrong. Even though Madoka possess a similar character to Sayaka, in that she loves playing hero and will use everyone else so she gets to be the hero.
>>149336224
Madoka is her friend but Hitomi is her best friend.
>>149336251
>play hero
Is there a more edgelord phrase?
>>149334085
I don't understand, isn't choking supposed to be hostile.
>>149336245
>multiple best friends
Did your mom also tell you that multiple waifus were okay?
>>149336253
Sayaka sure doesn't know how to pick her friends. Sasuga worst girl.
>>149336291
It's a fetish that masochists love, don't ask me why.
As a fan of Madoka, the characters in Madoka are unattractive in a specific way that makes them unsexual. Their features and especially facial features look way off kilter and shapeless/formless, like children's drawings, and their proportions seem to shift around from scene to scene (not that the animations bad, it isn't, it seems intentional). It gives them a childish quality, when a lot of other anime treats characters who are technically children according to the plot no differently from adults.
Their relationship is very abstract as well, their conversations are typically short and stilted and not very well articulated so it's hard to tell how they relate to each other and by the end of Rebellion they've been raised to the level of/reduced to the level of concepts rather than characters. Not only is their relationship not sexual, it barely even exists in reality. It's in every practical way like they're imagining one another.
In other words, I would agree that they don't love one another romantically.
>>149336296
My religion tells me that you can have up to four waifus.
>>149336251
>>149336251
>she hamster it
go away MRA scum
>>149336296
>having multiple friends you consider your closest is the same as cheating on your waifu
>>149336319
That's fucking heresy
>>149336319
Enjoy hell.
>>149333464
Rather than 50% off, she now gets to fuck two for the price of one.
>>149336319
Found the mormon
>>149336424
>All of them are yours
But they're not.
When was the last time we actually had a decent Madoka thread?
>>149336536
2011.
>>149336536
I lost track.
>>149336317
I agree with you on Rebellion. The girls seemed like cutouts that emodied ideals rather than fleshed out characters in there. Another reason why Rebellion was shit.
>>149336291
To some it is. To others it is a fetish. Maybe Homura likes being choked.
>>149318668
Hetfags really are disgusting. I wish they would all die.
>>149337476
What's wrong with girls loving guys?
>>149337568
Girls should love girls and boys should love boys.
>>149337623
Anyone should love anyone.
>>149337658
I love Apple-chan.
>>149337658
And yet nobody loves me.
>>149336385
It took her a long time to catch a concept. Releasing Madokami is very risky.
>>149324573
Newfags can't be settled. They're too new to know.
>>149321682
There is such thing as going to far.
>>149337658
As it should be. Girls can love girls so you can love Kyoko all you want.
>149337916
You sound like Lawnchair.
>>149339566
In this case girl love boy.
>>149336317
The faces are cute.
>>149318424
this >>149335863
>>149318668
U WOT M8.
>>149329471
Nothing.
>>149331155
>>149332292
>>149333354
In Japanese language, the following forms are ambiguous expressions: present tense, present continuous tense, present perfect tense, past tense, past progressive tense, past perfect tense, future tense, future continuous tense, future perfect tense, etc. You have to translate what creators want to express into English. In the present instance Madoka told Homura that あなたはわたしの、最高の友達だったんだね.
It is written as a past tense or a past perfect tense in Japanese but it isn't necessarily a past meaning. Madoka just meant Homura was Madoka's very best friend during a certain past period. You, westerners might doubt Homura is Madoka's very friend now. Madoka did not clearly refer to it. In Japanese language, "What you tell your favorite friend that you should had had affection for the friend for a certain past period" means "you like the person even now", when you did know the person had been suffering in order to save you for the first time. The meaning depends on your situation, because Japanese language has high-context cultures. Yeah, Japanese is very difficult.
>>149335937
>>149336021
Yes, yes!
>>149336388
Utah! (Chunibyou)
>>149337568
Nothing.
>>149337658
I love you!
>>149337916
Fuck off. The juicy Apple is mine!
>>149337996
I love you!
>>149339566
>implying nobody loves Apple except me.I'll support you.
>149341833
Fuck off.
>>149341833
What
*That
>>149342722
What?
>>149337916
O-okay.
>>149337996
Someone will find you. It may take a while, but it will happen.
>>149342910
You are an awful person. You responded to the post >>149337916, you were sure the anon >>149337916 is not me. Also, you definitely see my posts.
>>149343067
*because
>>149342910
Hey, Apple-chan! Are you taller than !GMeguca?
http://desuarchive.org/a/thread/147953948/#147973789
>>149342910
Do you think Florida is likea big penis?
>>149343269
>>149343303
Being Meguca is suffering.
I legit can't tell whats bait, what's trolling, and what is just straight up autism in this thread.
>>149333720
>The only way for Homura to make Madoka hate her is if she kills of one of her friends.
But Mami did this already. In fact, Madoka saw Homura at least attempt to kill Sayaka and she didn't care.
I've always had a crush on Lawnchair
>>149337476
>>149337623
Humanity would die off after one generation. No more cute anime girls. I think that is enough reason to want straight couples, right?
>>149337996
You will find you're waifu someday, anon.
>>149337916
We all love Apple-chan, don't we?
>>149344663
I love Apple the most.
>>149344663
>>149344776
>>149335518
That's a nice boy on the left
>>149319875
>dubbed
Horrifying.
>>149345101
>>149318424
Because Madoka is incapable of any form of love. She is a manipulative bitch who uses Homura's love for her own selfish gain. She seduces Homura under the pretense of nobility and innocence and convinces her that Homura is worthless unless she sells her soul and suffers for Madoka's sake. Madoka completely warps this poor, sickly girl's worldview to the point of enslaving her. She then dies repeatedly to traumatize Homura and force her to reset the timeline, which increases Madoka's own power. Madoka abused Homura's devotion in order to become a god, and then threw Homura away at the earliest convenience, laughing at her and cruelly giving false hope by saying that they will meet again. Madoka deserves no love after hurting Homura so much, but ironically Homura is so broken that she believes that her whole purpose is to worship Madoka, not realizing herself to be nothing more than a pawn.
>>149341833
>I love you!
Y-you too.
>>149344663
>You will find you're waifu someday, anon.I already found her, in my dreams. But whenever it happens I get the feeling her love for me is "just" sisterly.
Though I'm not hating it.
>>149336319
My religion allowed up to 1000 waifus
>>149346760
Well, it is not bad to have a sister. The bond between sisters is a very special kind of love. You should be happy to have a sisteru.
>>149318424
If she doesn't love Homura in a rug munching way, she will next movie.
>>149318668
I like this post.
>>149346760
Maybe the sisterly is outside, but deep inside it is something more.
>>149346797
Your religion is a lie.
>>149347928
Dang it coobie.
>>149347785
Why?
>>149318424
Why would she? She hasn't known her that long, like a month at most or something right?
>>149344536
Madoka never saw Homura threaten Sayaka. IIRC that scene was just after Sayaka got angry at Madoka and ran away.
>>149350339
>Madoka never saw Homura threaten Sayaka.
She saw everything Homura did once she became god.
>>149350883
I think it wasn't that simple. I think she just gained the memories she had from the different timelines.
>>149351196
>>149350883
Isn't it the same thing?
>>149351304
No. If Madoka only regained memories, she would only remember the things she actually experienced in those other timelines. If Madoka became omniscient, she would see everything.
>>149336176
Fighting eldritch abominations was part of what she wanted. What broke her was learning she had to let them kill people to get grief seeds, and other magical girls were ok with that.
Homura being gay for Madoka I can understand but what evidence at all was there for Madoka being gay for Homura?
and for my frame of reference, these are a pair of straight best friends.
>>149352746
There's nothing.
>>149352746
Most will use the boat scene of rebellion.
>>149352746
>>149352974
>>149353911
Wraith Arc. The principle of love was born from Madoka and Homura's desire to be reunited.
>>149354210
>wraith arc
but muh canon
>>149354210
The mangas aren't canon.
>>149354598
But the wraith arc was between the series and Rebellion.
>>149354830
That is irrelevant. The mangas aren't canon.
>>149336317
That sound more like shit writing
>>149354937
it is
>>149331155
shes a girl
shes a friend
shes a girlfriend (sexual)
>>149318668
>>149318668
>they're platonic friends
I want todestroy those whosexualizethe megucas.
Because no one loves Homura and she will die alone and unloved!
>>149347785
Thanks, I put a lot of effort into it. A lot of effort that appears to have been wasted on the illiterate and uncultured masses of /a/.
>>149356564
>official art
Hate Homura!
Make fun of Homura!
Beat Homura!
>>149318668
I think Homura's gayness is up in the air. She could be genuinely gay for Dokes or just delusional in her compromised mental state.
Madoka's straight. She fantasized about getting love letters from boys in the first episode. How people forget this is beyond me.
>>149357358
>fantasized about getting love letters from boys
Slut.
>>149357393
Madoka is pure and she wants a good husband!
>>149357474
Official sources indicate her ideal husband would be "Someone cool, like mom".
>>149358201
So a cool person.
>>149358201
That's adorable.
>>149358201
Furthermore, Junko likens Homura to herself.
>>149358675
And where is this stated?
Would you guys like to read doujinshi with me? Do you like derivative works? I'll invite you guys to my world! Here we go!
>>149344603
I'm glad I got a boy/girlfriend.
>>149346760
I finally got a (You)!
>>149358338
You should go to bed.
What makes Homura so disgusting?
>>149358777
PSP game, I believe.
>>149359075
A lethal combination of autism, desperation, and crazy.
>>149359119
>PSP game
so not canon
>>149318424
Because she wasn't born with a deformation and isn't a faggot
>>149359213
are you ok, anon?
>http://g.e-hentai.org/g/728798/1d27c484e4/
How was it?
>>149357206
That is a very cute image. It needs Nagisa though.
>>149359119
Well, part of the PSP game's premise is Homura acting differently than normal trying to spark a change in hopes of success.
So it can be safely discounted in debates of her character.
>>149360636
Are you kevin-kun? LOL. I'm off. Bye!
>>149360854
No. I gotta go.
>>149318668
Sounds like a solid argument but also looks like a pasta. Is this pasta?
>>149361013
I write all my own posts. Stop asking me if they're pasta, it's insulting.
>>149361383
Maybe don't write them to look like pasta.