Now that the dust has settled, we can now agree that asterisk war was good
no, fuck you that show was a shit-circus and you know it.
It was shit.
>>148158020
Its shit/worse than Rakudai.
Now that the lust has settled we can agree it was shit
It wasn't.
However, WAITING FOR THE RAIN was god-tier.
Only worth watching for those two.
>>148158020
it was shit, but it had some good girls. shit tho
>>148158020
Why even bring this up at this point but for stupid shitposting
>>148158020
Boring doesn't mean good
>>148158020
Asterisk > Rakudai
Julis > Stella
Ayato = Ikki
>>148158020
It's mid tier battle harem that's neither good or bad.
>>148158020
Depending the context. It was certainly better than expected, and although at the beginning it look lot worse than Rakudai in the long run it ended being better.
Also, inside its genre I'd say its good, or decent at least, the battle school harem standarts are not very high though.
So in the big picture I wouldn't say its good anime. Was mediocre at least.
In other worlds, good battle highschool harem: yes, good anime: NO
>>148158020
The plot wasn't the best in the world, and the MC was quite generic, but I liked the rest of the characters, the designs, animations and action were all appealing.
It was really fun. Not some story-telling masterpiece, but a fun show.
It was shit and making a meme you OP only supports the fact that you have shit taste.
It's a solid contender for the worst anime of the last 20 years.
>>148158020
It was okay. It was better than Bahamut and Hundred at least.
>>148158020
It is "good" under battle harem standards. To say the least, Asterisk has solid writing and that's something most battle harems don't have. It also has a good female lead character to cheer for and become attached to.
>>148158020
No it wasn't. It was astoundingly mediocre.
Literally the most forgettable middle-of-the-pack harem there is.
>>148158020
This show was like fast food; easily consumable and totally forgettable
Claudia a best. A BEST.
Julis a shit. A SHIT.
>>148158020
The entire plot was literally about integrated battle entertainment. Was I entertained? I would think yes, so it was fun and enjoyable for the most part.
>394x550
What is this, ants?
>>148160752
>the Stella/Claudiashitter
Was wondering when you'd show up.
>>148160018
>better than Bahamut and Hundred at least
Amazing standards you have there.
>>148158020
It was pretty bad. It probably highlighted everything that was wrong with magical/sci-fi academy battle harems especially so because it actually had budget.
>>148160752
>Claudia
She was the worst girl. An irrelevant girl that barely did anything to be ahead in the harem.
>>148160752
>Claudia supports Julis x Ayato OTP
How does that make you feel?
>>148161199
>implying she wasn't just teasing knowing that Julis is too beta to do anything with Fagyato
How this shitty series got a season 2 and rakudai doesn't is a joke.
>>148161465
That's not what happened.
>>148161505
Rakudai is shittier than Asterisk.
>the anime ended right before best girl's arc
Still upset.
>>148161505
>Rakudaifags are still salty about the fact the better battle harem got a S2
>>148159759
This.
>>148158020
It was so bad that it killed any chances that a magical academy battle harem LNs would get another adaptation ever again.
>>148161808
>it killed any chances that a magical academy battle harem LNs would get another adaptation ever again
Based Asterisk.
>>148161647
Rakudai is better than Asterisk; A-1 Pictures just had more money to get a second season for some reason
Hope this gets a season 3, need the Sylvia arc.
>>148161505
>How this shitty series got a season 2
Because it didn't.
The show was split cour from the get-go.
Are there any big school battle harems left to adapt?
Surely they're running low by now.
>>148161808
If only that was true.
Stella > any girl in Asterisk.
Stella best harem main heroine of 2015.
>>148162187
Stella a shit. A SHIT.
>>148161505
Rakudai is honestly better off ending where it did.
>>148162187
>Worst girl in Rakudai and of the year with shallow writing being better than Julis, Saya, Kirin, or any main heroine
Heh.
>>148161808
There's still the TI7 movie. After that? Nothing.
Rakudai > bahamut >>>>>>>>>>> asterisk
Cry harder asteriskfags
>>148162898
Antimagic > Asterisk > Bahamut > Hundred > Rakudai
Rokujouma > KonoSuba > Trinity Seven > Machine Doll > DAL > Taimadou > Ore no Nounai > Mahouka > Kanojo ga Flag > HS DxD > Black Bullet > Shinmai > Absolute Duo > Saenai > Shimoneta > World Break > Bladedance > Shomin Sample > Rakudai > Asterisk > Brynhildr > Bahamut > L&L > Hundred > Kuusen Madoushi > Fafnir > LN'M > ISUCA > MG HxH
Pacing seemed really odd.
The tournament fights were good enough but they didn't really feel hype enough.
Season 1 finale was straight up bad.
Rakudai final fight was solid and ended the anime on a positive note without hinting at a more which won't really come anyway.
>>148158020
Asterisk is underrated tbqh
Its getting a lot of hate because some dude made a video
>>148163348
That's not bad. Fairly accurate, actually.
>>148163684
>Its getting a lot of hate because some dude made a video
Oh boy here we go.
>>148163348
>mixing harems
Stick to battle ones please
>>148160996
she did plenty. it's not her fault ayato was gay and it didn't work.
>>148158020
It was VERY good. Also, Ayato is a god tier mc.
>>148160704
No. I will watch it again. Cuz it's damn good.
>>148162187
> Stella > any girl in Asterisk.
yes, but
Asterisk is still >>>>>>>>>>>>> Rakudai
Best girls:
Magika: Mio
T7: Liese
DAL: Tohka
Campione: Erica
Antimagic: Ouka
DXD: Xenovia
Testament: Mio
Vanadis: Ellen
StB: Asagi
Rakudai: Stella
Fafnir: Kili
Machine Doll: Irori
Bahamut: Celestia
Hundred: Claire
Asterisk: Claudia
IS: Cecilia
Raildex: Misaki
HxH: Yurishia
Blade Dance: Fianna
Color Wars: Purple
Absolute Duo: Lilith
World Break: Shizuno
>>148158020
It wasn't insultingly bad, like most other battle harems out there, but that doesn't mean it was particularly good. 6/10
>>148162898
In terms of girls alone:
Antimagic > Bahamut > Asterisk > Rakudai > Hundred > HxH
>>148163914
Is that why they all end up settling for the flat tsunderes.
>>148162187
Not when Ouka exists
>>148162187
Stella a hot. A HOT.
>>148164267
Magika: Koyuki = Kanae
T7: Sora = Levi = Arin = Mira
DAL: Kotori = Kurumi
Campione: Athena = Luo Hao
Antimagic: Mari = Lapis
DXD: Ophis
Testament: Maria
Vanadis: Mira
StB: Avrora > Yukina = Natsuki
Rakudai: Shizuku = Nene
Fafnir: Charlotte > Vrita = Mitsuki > Kili
Machine Doll: Yaya = Charlotte
Bahamut: Krul = Yoruka
Hundred: Emilia > Karen
Asterisk: Fan > Julis
IS: Laura > Charlotte
Raildex: Leivinia > Mikoto > Othinus
HxH: Gertrude
Blade Dance: Restia = Est > Claire
Color Wars: Red > Green = Brown
Absolute Duo: Julie = Sakuya > Rito
World Break: Maya > Satsuki > Shizuno
>>148163824
Asterisk is bad and easily ignored; its just attracting attention due to e-celeb shit
>>148164267
>>148164827
Do you need to do this every thread
>>148162187
>Stella best harem main heroine of 2015.
this is true. only ouka can compete
>>148165433
>Compete
You mean blow out of the water?
>>148164921
No, just in the threads derailed by battle harem talk.
Literally stop liking what I don't the thread
>>148165517
Stella is good but not that good in comparison.
>>148164267
>Mio (testament)
>Ellen
>Stella
>Misaki
shit list.
>>148169665
>not liking Misaki
Mikotopleb
>>148159542
>Ayato = Ikki
delusional asterisktard