Who would win in a battle? Of course we're considering

What kind of battle? Are we talking about sword against sword, or "sword" against "sword"?

>>146375789
same answer either way

I think Thors is physically stronger

can we add goblin slayer too

>>146376972
yeah and Kirito
how about Umaru for the fun of it

>>146376972
That thing is super fantasy right from the get-go so no.

>>146374206
muh dick

>>146377297
this is the right answer

>>146374206
Guts would win easily.

It's no question. Even pre-training in Golden Age he's superhuman.

He killed 100 men by himself with one usable hand and several pre-existing injuries.

>>146374206
My money's on thors hes got that zen level badass where guts is just rage level badass.

>>146377730
Guts cleaves through plate armour and helmets, even with his 'golden age' sword. So even then he's got a pretty magical sword and sooper strength. I don't remember anything *that* silly in Vinland

>>146374206
Fucking Casca could reasonably fight Thors, let alone Guts.

>>146378366
Thors would trick guts into becoming a slave to atone for all the people he's killed. After 2 years of being a slave guts will have died a true manga death.l He will be dead in the hearts of all the readers of Berserk.

>>146378729
Guts doesn't actually feel guilt for the vast majority of people he's killed tho. He doesn't feel the need to redeem himself.

>>146378796
True, but that is precisely where thors comes in to ruin a whole manga with his disgusting morals. After talking with this master level shame-er guts will cut trees and plant potatoes for the rest of his days. Until every last reader has left him. Thors is the winner of the battle. With a defeat so complete guts is deleted from the space time continuum.

>>146376972
I always though Goblin Slayer was a pretty good fighter, but not a god tier one.
Like he kills goblins, and most of the time he fights multiple ones by outsmarting them, instead of straight out going 10 vs 1

Guts literally killed 100 men by himself, while handicapped.

There's no argument here.

The Vinland Saga setting doesn't allow for people to do things like that.

>>146379334
Well Thorkell I think his name was uppercutted a horse and crushed a bear unarmed so silly things do happen. Also I got the impression Thors was a better fighter than Thorkell so you never know.

File: thorkell.jpg (81KB, 428x600px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 428x600px

>>146379334
Both Thorkell and Thors could do that