Which one is better?

Which one ripped of what again?

The Asterisk War SUCKS!!!

Left
>God tier OP
>MC and the main heroine kiss early on and get in a relationship
>MC gets emotionally and physically tortured just so he can get engaged to her and still wrecks shit of the strongest fighter in the school after going through it
Right
>S-Sorry, Claudia, I won't touch your tits

>>145295119
Right is a pile of shit. Left is a sligtly less smelly pile of shit.

>>145295119
The only thing that left does worse than right is the inclusion if incestshit, but on the whole left is much better. But both suck.

>>145295588
>>145295119
When you have a 12+ part Youtube series picking apart a single anime, you know right more than has its problems.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

I love how these two shitty anime will forever be linked.

>>145295119
both shitty battle harems, both are flatline 1/10s

>>145295119
Both a shit
Problem Solved.

>>145295119
I don't think I even finished Rakudai, but Asterisk is undoubtably shittier and I don't even remember why I forced myself to finish that shit.

>>145295119
The first season of both are garbage, asterisk got a second season which was surprisingly decent, so you might consider struggling through the first season.

>>145295119
Left had better fight scenes.
Really liked Shizuku vs Raikiri girl's fight.

>>145298927
I don't believe you.

>>145295832
This.

And they were both only made shittier by airing concurrently.

>>145298927
I'm sorry now i know you're shitposting.

Asterisk 1st cour was much better than that disastrous 2nd cour

File: 51c315b47ed579066d2b49556a7b11c4.jpg (3MB, 4953x3421px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 4953x3421px

>>145295119
Infinite Stratos

>>145295119
Left had better MC, right had better FeMC (in my opinion). I think left was better and should get a 2nd season, but I like battle harems so what do I know

>>145295119
Left was better because the MC's actually developed a relationship instead of skirting around it for two seasons fear of alienating purity-fags.
But they're both pretty generic overall.

>>145295119
Antimagic

File: MeATEf5.jpg (98KB, 681x960px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 681x960px

>>145300302
SOON

>>145295119
Left had the better closing fight, even if it was a single slash.

>The OP starts
>They start saying the same thing in unison
>The art style changes to the OP art style
>Dick status changed to MUH

>>145299658
It does have the best sluts

>>145302508
Is it actually good though?

>>145302538
Stop bumping shit threads, you fucking cancer.

>left
>shit everything but atleast i had a fight i liked halfway

>right
>literally everything was shit

>>145295119
Asterisk is better. In before fedoralord digibro.

>>145295119
Rakudai.

>>145302632
>muh taste

>>145295119
Asterisk is more shitty but both suck.

>>145302953
Name a single redeeming about Asterisk without resorting to muh girls or soundtracks.

File: ce5d99f9dff5394c586913eb88803b41e5a53b55b0cae5b25e0bd49f2deb3614_1-1.jpg (57KB, 800x430px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 800x430px

Of the two given, left is better

>>145303053
Better animation

>>145303431
From what I've seen, the animation in Asterisk is atrocious.

File: TMG_AM_003-004.jpg (2MB, 2627x2046px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2627x2046px

>>145295119
This one.

>>145303479
Still better than rakudai animation tho.

>>145303431
>being so wrong
Try again

File: 9zi07Sx.png (285KB, 681x960px) Image search: [Google]

285KB, 681x960px

>>145300403
Yes.

File: 1467526307673.jpg (583KB, 1071x1076px) Image search: [Google]

583KB, 1071x1076px

Stella is a goddess and Rakudai was ok. Asterisk was a little more boring

File: TMG_v07_0004.jpg (2MB, 2906x2046px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2906x2046px

>>145303431
>Better animation

The only one it had "better animation" on was AntiMagic. Even the anime designs for AntiMagic were shit.

File: wut.png (482KB, 848x802px) Image search: [Google]

482KB, 848x802px

Judging from the art alone it's fucking hilarious how similar both MCs look.

>>145303918
>generic edgy designs
The anime made them cuter

>>145303929
Most MCs have that same generic look, at least in the genres of harem and shitty action.

File: e4crUyr.jpg (101KB, 681x960px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 681x960px

>>145303929
Rakudai and Gakusen are clearly fraternal twins.

File: 1447955728982.jpg (133KB, 661x907px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 661x907px

>>145303996
Not even.

>>145295119
One of them got a second season and an english release of a video game. The other got shit

Take a guess which one is shit and which one isn't?

Neither. Both are complete trash of the highest order. Haremshit should be purged from this planet as soon as possible.

That being said, Stella & Kirin are cute as fuck. But that's it, that's literally all these shows have anything to offer. Cuteness / kawaii~~~~.

It works very well too, sadly.

>>145304187
>>>/u/

>>145304179
One sold better and is more popular regardless

>>145304179
They're both shit. Popularity has jack shit to do with quality, especially in anime.

>>145304231
I'm not a yurifag. I just like one girl from each show. Fuck off, faggot.

File: Taimadou Gakuen 35 Shiken Shoutai.jpg (243KB, 757x426px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 757x426px

>>145295119
Taimadou was better than either of those.

File: [HorribleSubs] Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry - 06 [720p].mkv_snapshot_15.58_[2015.11.07_23.47.04].jpg (91KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 1280x720px

This fight and the Sister fight at the end were the only good things to come out of Rakudai.

Asterisk had like 0 fights worth seeing and more time spent on shitty robots.

>>145304231
>not shipping Kirin and Saya

>>145304187
>Haremshit
But Rakudai is about true love and marriage, oh I see, you're a retard whose opinion will be discarded by all who read it.

>>145304380
Their pussies belong to Ayato

>>145304337
>garbage animation
>rushed piece of shit
>CGI

was the worst anime that season

File: Taimadou.Gakuen.35.Shiken.Shoutai.full.1939412.jpg (1MB, 3145x4085px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 3145x4085px

>>145304337
Silver Link should have focused on this instead of Rakudai ffffff.

>>145304410
>"b-b-b-but the MC did choose a girl!!!! It's not a harem!!!"
>"just ignore how all the other girls get super jealous and still want to ride his dick hard every episode!!!"

You can't fool me.

>>145304410
Dont reply to retards and shitposters

File: Asterisk Saya and Kirin.gif (2MB, 540x304px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 540x304px

I only watched Asterisk for these two.

you're dumb as fuck and probably have shit taste if you think asterick shit can even touch Calvary in terms of quality

>>145304513
the only other girl who wants his dick besides his GF is his sister, and even she backs off once she knows she lost

go be a retard somewhere else

>>145295119
Left because the MC name is Ikki which what most of my ex called me by

>>145304609
That's even more of a waste of time than posting on 4chan.

>>145295119
Left: Shit MC but not as shit as right's.
amazing fights scenes
actual relationship development within the first 6 episodes
is Rakudai really a harem?
Right:
did not watch it past 2nd episode because the i watched the other 2 magic highschool shows

>>145304513
>just ignore how all the other girls get super jealous and still want to ride his dick hard every episode
I know you've never been a handsome, capable young man with a girlfriend, but that is exactly what happens.

>>145304964 here
it has just come to my attention antimagic and rakudai were both made by silver link.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

>>145303650
muh dick shouldnt be reacting to an illustration with two guys, so why?!

>>145295119
left was the biggest shit i ever watched.

right was kinda...meh.

>>145304513
>"just ignore how all the other girls get super jealous and still want to ride his dick hard every episode!!!"

Wow, not only "choose a girl and have sex" self-insert move, but also they didn't resign from harem. What utter garbage.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

>>145295119
Asterisk War is a 2/10, Chivalry is a 5/10.

>>145295119
They were both shit.

File: TMG_v11_229.jpg (396KB, 1451x2046px) Image search: [Google]

396KB, 1451x2046px

>>145305716
Because the artist makes 1v1 look based as fuck.

File: Co3AVLlUAAABVXU.png (1MB, 1451x2046px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1451x2046px

>>145306465
Not just artist's 1v1 is great.

>>145295119
Left had better MC, rigt had better girls.

>>145306820
>better girls
Maybe better, but still shit.

File: TMG_v09_002-003.jpg (2MB, 3620x2553px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3620x2553px

>>145306757
True that.

>>145298927
Even if the 2nd season is better there's no reason to watch a show with a first season so bad you had to force yourself to finish it.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

File: 1447594675179.png (220KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

220KB, 500x500px

>>145304609
THIS

>>145300455
That's the power of Oonuma. Silver Link's best productions are directed by him.

>>145307372
There are a million other anime with the same character archetype and similar designs, but done much better.

Stop watching bad anime.

>>145295119
Asterisk because it had better music and animation.
Bonus points because that cancerous youtuber e-celeb hates it.

>>145307673
What a surprise, anon is a petty bitch with shit taste.

>>145307552
Saya is one of the best of her archetype though

>>145307673
Pretty much this, digicuck and his followers are the epitome of bad taste.

>>145307811
If she's one of the best, I'd hate to see how bland the worst ones are.

Rakudai had fights worth watching.

I knew Asterisk was straight garbage when all the fights MC was gonna have was against girls

>>145307673
>>145307911
>waah YouTube exists

Cry some more.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA!

File: 1445695146733.jpg (2MB, 985x1455px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 985x1455px

>>145307911
>implying this is bad taste

>>145307779
>>145308074
>faggots who watch Digishit's videos on youtube
You literally can't say anyone else has bad taste. You're the 2015/16 equivalent of a Forneverworld viewer, why the fuck are you even on /a/.
Just kill yourselves.

>>145308736
>waah YouTube exists

>>145308736
Please explain how he is wrong about Asterisk.

>>145308736
ForneverWorld just talks about a handful of super mainstream anime. Digibro has much deeper content

>>145309003
Just looked up his channel now and saw that SAO is getting an American live action adaptation. What the fuck

File: digishit shill is at it again.png (16KB, 631x309px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 631x309px

>>145309003
>Digibro has much deeper content
Sure he does. I bet you think he's a fucking genius reviewer, just like I bet he think he's one too. Just look at those pretentious pseudo-intellectual video titles.
Doesn't change the fact that your taste is garbage and you should kill yourself.

>>145308963
He's a youtube e-celeb so his opinion is automatically shit.
No explanation required.

>>145295119
They're both shit, but right is slightly better and less retarded.

>>145296472
>some neckbeard autist's ramblings over 12 episodes somehow means it's shit
I'm sure any anon could make a rambling about anything for 100.
Thanks for confirming you base your opinion around an e-celeb's though, you'd fit in with the ledditors who refuse to watch anything that digishit hasn't give a thumbs up on.

File: 1440510200118.png (30KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 300x300px

>>145310126
>Just look at those pretentious pseudo-intellectual video titles.
>Sakamoto is Seriously Perfect!
>ERASED Was Never That Good
>Konosuba Is Genuinely Hilarious!

>>145310299
>being this mad that your shit show is shit

>>145295119
Asterisk because I'm not faggot Digibro samefagging.

>>145310126
Please give some suggestions as to how you would rephrase those titles to sound less pretentious.

>>145295119
>Tale of Worst One
>Is not actually worst but ultra OP

This is not wishfulfillment but something akin to forced underdog plot. It's the stuff that makes people cringe. Like a super OP twin-personality that has a cooldown for whatever reason.
I still have no idea why either of them would get a second season, maybe Asterisk got a headstart in terms of sales due to fucking Rasmus Faber?

>>145310126
Considering he makes a living on it, he is a fucking genius reviewer. And he regularly takes the piss out of himself because he knows he is a disgusting hikibeast making videos about chinese cartoons. He's just some anon that shitposts in video format because he realized people will watch that shit and if you have a regular content stream, you make money off it.

>>145310299
>Thanks for confirming you base your opinion around an e-celeb's though, you'd fit in with the ledditors who refuse to watch anything that digishit hasn't give a thumbs up on.
The irony in this is amazing, a fine meal for shitpost gluttons.

>>145310747
>advertising your shitty troll reviews
Kill yourself.

>>145295780
>Left
>Good OP
>MC and the main heroine kiss early on and get in a relationship, but nothing ever happens from then on
>MC gets emotionally and physically tortured just so he can get engaged to her and still wrecks shit of the strongest fighter in the school after going through it. Like a true gary stu, in one hit like a true badass like Kirito!
>everyone worships MC and wants him "the weakest" to train them
>harem is fucking boring, why do they even exist when Stella "won"
>literal Kumagawa rip off in the student council
>all fags do is circlejerk over Stella and how she "won", so progressive for harem anime
>post Stella "reply to" meme images because there's nothing to discuss
>villain character voiced Hosoya by is 1000x more interesting than the passive MC
>ear.RAPE ED
>digishit watchers think its the best harem ever made

Right
>S-Sorry, Claudia, I won't touch your tits, I'm dedicated to another girl and I can tell that you only want to use me
>God tier OP/ED for S1
>God tier OP/ED for S2
>EDs start playing leading into the ED video
>god tier harem
>Kirin
>Childhood friend is a bro and likes guns
>god tier OST by Rasmus Faber
>good animation with Sakuga, unlike Silver Link's shitty 3 anime by them in one season QUALITY
>great worldbuilding
>has a spinoff about girl's school plus characters from it in the anime as a bonus
>that based Idol best girl (arc animated when ;_;)
>animator care enough about one random girl to animate her fluidly because it's his waifu
>EDOTY 2015

There I decided to include everything unlike your cherry picking.

>>145295588
Kill yourself.

>>145295119
asterisk because it has mecha musume

>>145310947
>god tier harem
>any harem ever
>good

File: 1470210309796.png (168KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 400x400px

>>145310299
>Complaining about autism on /a/
>>>/v/

File: Yplh18u.png (26KB, 527x409px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 527x409px

>>145310947

>>145295119
Left:
>God tier OP playing in the last episode
>Early relationship, no bullshit
>MC Actually fucks the heroine
>They fucked so hard that the floor was covered in condoms.

Right:
>Kirin
>Oppai loli
>Good ED/OP overall

>>145295119
Rakudai MC > Asterisk MC
Asterisk Main girl >>>> Rakudai Main girl
Asterisk harem > Rakudai harem
Asterisk OP/ED > Rakudai OP/ED
Rakudai OST > Asterisk OST
Rakudai best fights > Asterisk best fights
Asterisk animation > Rakudai animation

>>145298926

I like Rakudai's designs and art better, for sure.

>>145310126
>He's a youtube e-celeb so his opinion is automatically shit.

I think you're being autistic anon-kun.

>>145296890
THANK YOU BASED STELLA

both absolute shit

Stella has no butt

>>145296890
STANK THOU YASED BELLA!