[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

ITT: Solid 5/10 shows

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 113
Thread images: 21

File: safdgewrqty65.jpg (125KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
safdgewrqty65.jpg
125KB, 1920x1080px
It tried to be a lot of things, it didn't excel in anything.
>>
File: 1461000312803.jpg (236KB, 648x750px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1461000312803.jpg
236KB, 648x750px
>>
>>143540398
I would bump it to 6.5/10.
If they only explained the origin of the revival ability and why he was the only special one, with some timeline implications, it could have been a 7.5-8/10
>>
>>143540398
It excelled in the NTR genre.
>>
>>143540800
kek
>>
Trinity Blood
Chobits
Chrno Crusade
Da Capo
Mai-Otome
Dog Days
Sacred Seven
Free
Love Hina
Kanon
Madoka
Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne
Inuyasha
Kiniro Mosaic
Shingeki no Kyojin
I My Me! Strawberry Eggs
Haruhi
Kanokon
Amagi SS
IS: Infinite Stratos
Sky Girls
Death Note
Asura Cryin
Sola
Juuden-chan
Garo
Hyakka Ryouran: Samurai Girls
Fate/Zero
Junketsu no Maria
Carnival Phantasm
Nourin
Nisekoi
>>
File: 39045w3095.gif (494KB, 500x282px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
39045w3095.gif
494KB, 500x282px
pic related
>>
>>143540398
Hina was pretty cute.
>>
>>143541678
Kayo*
>>
>>143540774
they made it pretty clear it was an act of god

and explaining the supernatural when it's not directly related to plot almost always takes away from a story
>>
>>143540398
It excelled in triggering touchy faggots. Also as an appealling story about family and friendship. I love stories of a group of kids becoming true bros.
>>
>>143540857
most of them are 5/10 yeah.
>>
File: Untitled.jpg (22KB, 410x263px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Untitled.jpg
22KB, 410x263px
>tfw not a single anime can surprise me anymore
>>
File: 12806674877585.jpg (39KB, 403x396px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12806674877585.jpg
39KB, 403x396px
>>143542995
>only 200
>>
>>143542995
>208
Pathetic.
>>
>>143543785
>>143544621
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Sanosai?status=7&order=4&order2=0

thanks.
>>
>>143540857
Sola is a -100/10.
>>
>>143543785
>>143544621
nerds.
>>
>>143542995
>>143544803
You'fucking trash, get the fuck out of here
>>
File: 1435584021005.png (670KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1435584021005.png
670KB, 1200x1200px
>>143540857
>Madoka
>>
File: Capture.png (42KB, 439x741px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Capture.png
42KB, 439x741px
All my 5s
>>
>>143540857
>Madoka.
Gr8 b8 m8.
>SNK.
The plots weak but I'd argue that the OST and actual aesthetics of the anime make it more than a 5/10. The mangas pretty bad though.

I think the problem with finding a 5/10 is that a lot of anime have some redeeming features like the art style, OST or great voice-acting.
>>
>>143544903
The ED song in texhnolyze alone makes it above 5/10.
>>
>>143544803
>EVA 10/10
>EOE Possibly the best Animated movie of all time.

Jesus you even gave Kiss x Sis a 9/10.
>>
File: 1467167848290.jpg (55KB, 1024x466px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1467167848290.jpg
55KB, 1024x466px
>>143544865
This is you.
>>
>>143544870
What made you so upset? Me posting my list? I dont want recommendations if that's what you implied. Or is there a particular score that triggered you? If so, please tell me which one and i will explain my reasoning of said score.
>>
>>143544865
>>>/v/
>>
>>143545020
>Jesus you even gave Kiss x Sis a 9/10.
Personal reasons. We marathoned it with 2 friends, drunk of course. We had really the time of our life, i twas a very fun night. I then told them that i always had a thing for my cousin and we talked about it in detail of what i should do etc.
It's been 4 years since though. I can't give it anything less than a 9/10, because it means a lot to me and my friends.
>>
Why are people with less than 300 anime viewed allowed on /a/?
This was the base standard.
When did it go from 400 to 300?
>>
>>143545054
Not that guy but Stardust Crusaders a 10? I've not started Diamond is Unbreakable but I thought it was the weakest part, it was too formulaic with villain of the week battles and they didn't explain why Jotaro could suddenly fly during the last battle. I only kept watching out of hope of Dio being a massive bastard which he was but there wasn't enough of him.
>>
File: 1414965140089.png (147KB, 618x390px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1414965140089.png
147KB, 618x390px
>>143544803
>boku no pico only a 7
>>
>>143544903
>KnK 5
>5/10
How did you rate the others, 3/10?
>>
-10 for 3D pig in 2D form as main heroine.
>>
>>143545153
Diamond is unbreakable, so far, is the weakest one. But its only 30% through.
The second season of stardust crussaders is a 10 for many reasons, the first season was pretty bland i do agree. And yes, the flying thing was weird and unnecessary.
>>
>>143545184
Had quite i few laughs watching it with the same 2 friends again. I do admit i masturbated to it half a dozen times, but it's not something special yet above average, for me. also a 7 seems fitting.
>>
>>143545137
>Personal reasons.
That's the problem, you cannot judge based on personal reasons. There are objective criteria for what makes anime (or anything that can be considered art or creative work) something good. Otherwise your ratings mean shit.
>>
>>143545206
That's my lowest rated one, the rest are 7-9.
>>
>>143545137
>>143545263
>>
>>143545139
>>143543785
>>143544621
Are you trying to kill this guy by making him watch over 300 anime?
>>143544803
Kill yourself for watching over 100
>>
File: image.jpg (44KB, 312x285px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
44KB, 312x285px
>>143540857
>Chobits
>Chrno Crusade
>Madoka
>Fate/Zero
>Carnival Phantasm
>>
>>143542995
Pathetic. Watch less shounen shit with 300 episodes.
>>
>>143545228
Diamond is unbreakable is going to be awesome once it gets to the final kira arc.

DESU I'm so hype for Gio and steel ball run.
Joylene was alright, but felt really dragged out.

Battle Tendency was may all time favorite tho.
>>
>>143545393
I've completed 400 series. Totaling 126 Days. Quit your bitching, newfag.
>>
>>143545286
The majority of my list is based on objectivity, but sometimes i am biased. That's all there's to it. Bleach is pretty bad objectively, it's still a solid 7 for me.
>>
>>143544803
Literally kill yourself and bring your shit taste with you.
>>
>>143545422
I think the problem I had with Stardust Crusaders was that Jotaro was pretty bland. Jonathan was pretty bland too but he at least got more character development than Jotaro. It's weird cause Joseph was a great protagonist.
>>
clannad

come at me faggots
>>
File: D4C.png (707KB, 764x800px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
D4C.png
707KB, 764x800px
>>143545422
>DESU I'm so hype for Gio and steel ball run.
Yes, part 7 is also my favorite by far.
I hope they skip part 5 and 6 and jump straight to 7
>>
>>143545411
>91.7 days
>549 completed
That's a lot of short stuff.

I have 486 completed but 116.1 days watched
Mostly Precure and other 50 episode girl shows
>>
>>143540398
Boku dake is a solid 8/10, fuck off.
>>
Another dumb thread where MAL posters brag about their numbers of anime watched on /a/, as if it means anything at all.
>>
>>143545588
Well, at least I watched more anime than you, faggot.
>>
>>143545619
Not him, but kill yourself slowly.
>>
>>143545669
Stay mad, under 100 watchedfag.
>>
File: 4534535.png (6KB, 403x265px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4534535.png
6KB, 403x265px
Since we're measuring our e-peens itt now, might as well throw in mine.
>>
>>143545564
Nice bait.
>>
>>143545054
First and foremost, of all websites in existence you linked us to your fucking My Anime List account. Why do you think anyone cares about how bad your taste is you shitstain? Also, how fucking condescending and insecure does one have to be to comment most of their entries? Do you need so desperately a place to fit in?

I'd rather not talk about your anime taste and overall knowledge, your shitty list speaks for itself.

And fiinally I saw your manga "list" and I cried, of laughter of course but also of sadness knowing that I share a board and interact on a daily basis with scum such as yourself.
Get lost, you social defect.
>>
>>143545049
>>143545099
ayy the nerds got butthurt
>>
>>143545694
Have a nice day, anon.
>>
>>143545536
I feel like the old graph site had a graph showing distribution between series lengths, but I can't find it on the new site.
>>
>>143544803
>Gunbuster
>running out of budget.
Holy shit you're fucking stupid, the artstyle they did in the last ep actually cost them more money.
It was an art direction.

I'm laughing my ass what a laughworthy list.
>>
>>143540857
>Carnival Phantasm
>Fate/Zero
>Madoka
>Maria
>Kiniro Mosaic

All on the same level as IS, Sky Girls, Free, Dog Days, Trinity Blood.

wew lad
>>
>>143545806
I just discovered something very disturbing: The whole idea of quantum mechanics is nothing more than an elaborate ruse to keep intelligent people busy with irrelevant made up bullshit.

Those in power fear intelligence. They fear people who can think for themselves, and who would consequently threaten their power. Hence they created a meme field with seemingly complicated mathematics and spread the rumour of QM being the hardest and most scientific field in existence. They literally made up some quasi-mystical aura that compels the brightest minds to waste their time with it, only so that said bright minds don't ever think about questioning that which is really important and never threaten the status quo. QM is complely made up and the books on QM, RQM, QFT, QED, QCD, ST and whatever other bullshit theories they invented are written intentionally convoluted in order to keep up the illusion of being intellectually challenging and to take away more time from the gifted people who read them. Now look at the names of textbook authors in QM. "Coincidentally" these "researchers" happen to be named *berg, *stein, *blatt, ...

Let's be serious: Have you ever seen a proof of quantum mechanics existing? Of course not, because the whole theory is supposedly about things which cannot be observed ("uncertainty principle").

So, if you're reading this and you consider yourself scientifically inclined and intelligent, don't fall for the QM meme. Remain a free thinker and don't get trapped by those who have bad intentions for our society.
>>
>>143545918
>Holy shit you're fucking stupid, the artstyle they did in the last ep actually cost them more money.
>It was an art direction.
Sure thing m8.
>>
>>143540398
are you the kind of retard that thinks a 5/10 is "average"?
>>
>>143545987
>5/10
>not average
You are a special kind of fullretard, aren't you?
>>
>>143545987
Assuming that theres an equal amount of good and bad anime, 5/10 is average.
>>
File: 1453869715906.jpg (34KB, 514x536px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1453869715906.jpg
34KB, 514x536px
>this thread
>>
>>143545987
Yes, 5/10 means the middle aka average.
>>
>>143546018
Not if you're in school where anything below a 70 is failure.
>>
>>143545987
I bet you think 7/10 is average. Fuck off back to MAL.
>>
>>143546018
>>143546054
>>143546067
That's not how anime/music ratings work you retards

10/10 = Masterpiece/great/"classic"
9/10 = Very good
8/10 = Enjoyable
Everything under = Wow what of autist watched/listened to this pile of crap and actually enjoyed it
>>
>>143546113
Again: You are a special kind of fullretard, aren't you?
>>
>>143546067
Middle is median

>>143545977
Grayscale is more expensive/time consuming than colour actually.
>>
>>143546065
shhh don't draw attention to it. Just let it continue, grab a drink or some shit, and relax.
>>
>>143545936
That wasn't a pasta you turd.
>>
Why not use letters for taste rating?
S=Superawesome
A=Great
B=Okay
C=So-so
D=I didn't like it
F=Utterly terrible
>>
>Death Note
>That One anime where you wish to forget in order to watch again, this is it.
Stopped there.I think i will die from laughter if i go through the whole list
>>
>>143545936
Nice copy pasta, I've never seen it on /sci/ though. What's the point in posting it here?
Also
>"Coincidentally" these "researchers" happen to be named *berg, *stein, *blatt, ...
What about Sakurai?
>>
File: 1382959866629.jpg (11KB, 228x244px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1382959866629.jpg
11KB, 228x244px
>>143546121
>>143546067
>>143546054
>>143546018
>Assuming that theres an equal amount of good and bad anime, 5/10 is average.
>assuming
complete retards, all of you.
just think for a second, what is the average and how can it always be a static 5?
this is nothing more than a /v/ meme.
>>
>>143546471
If a 10 is top 10% anime
a 9 the next 10%
8 the next 10%
etc.
1 is the bottom 10%.

Then 5 will be the average and median
>>
>>143544903

>GitS
>5

i don't get some people
>>
>>143546471
Keep entertain us, buddy. All I need is a pop corn.
>>
>>143546537
I also gave GitS a 5. Problem?
>>
>>143544903
>Cream Lemon

Shit taste
>>
>>143546113
Thats only in america in my 3rd world country if you get 10/20 in math of philosophy it means youre average
>>
>>143546595

i don't get you. if you consider that a problem, then yes, problem.
>>
>>143546471
Goddamn you are stupid.
>>
>>143546697
>>143546554
>>143546522
>>143546184
>>143546121
>>143546067
>replying to obvious autismbait
>>
File: 1451295592913.jpg (39KB, 374x347px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451295592913.jpg
39KB, 374x347px
>>143546522
so if the next 10 years nothing but shit comes out and the "average" get's skewed we'll keep it at 5 anyway and readjust every prior rating ever given?
a rating system that changes values constantly is not a real rating system. you can't base it on the average.
again, what logical reason is there to force 5 as the average? the average should be somewhere on the scale, not in the middle just because you retards fell for some memes.
>>
>>143546018

being average does not mean you're not a failure.

in fact one could argue that for a show, or a person, to be average is the greatest failure possible.
>>
>>143546813
The top x list won't change in that case.
>>
>>143546522
If you're doing this, it should be a normal distribution, with most shows landing in the middle range, not uniform one with equal amounts of shows in each quality range.
>>
>>143544903
Usually people either love or hate Texhnolyze
>>
>>143546327
This. 6 and 7 point scales are the only good ones
>>
>>143546434
>What about Sakurai?
He made the best game of all time and then went to make brawl and tr4sh.
>>
Not an attempt at bait.

>Shingeki no Kyojin
>One Punch Man
>Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
>Hellsing
>Clannad (not including AS)
>Ergo Proxy
>Eden of the East
>Mikakunin de Shinkoukei
>Psycho-Pass
>Shigofumi
>Toradora
>Zankyou no Terror
>Darker than Black
>Watamote

I don't even remotely understand the hype for WPM. The only decent parts of that show was when Genos or that guy on the bike was the focus.
>>
>>143547236
OPM*
Dumb mistake
>>
>>143546900
of course it will, since it's the average.
realistically speaking, you'd need a lot of outliers to change the average, but the principle is still true, the average changes.

any ratings system is based on VALUE. which means that 5 is the middle between good and bad.
depending on wether the glass is half full or half empty, a 5/10 is "barely poor" or "barely decent".
this means in no way can a 5/10 be "solid", as OP said.

i've always wondered about this, but i'm pretty sure i'm making sense here.
>>
>>143540398
Oh fuck off. It kinda dropped the ball by the end and triggered a lot of autists, but it's still overall a solid 7.5 or 8/10 show.
>>
>>143547236
>Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
>Hellsing
>Clannad (not including AS)
>Eden of the East
>Psycho-Pass
>Toradora
>Darker than Black
>Watamote
I agree with these, including AS as well though.

>Shingeki no Kyojin
>One Punch Man
>Ergo Proxy
I disagree with these.
>>
ASA
MO YORU
MO KOIKOGARETE
>>
File: Kobeni00.jpg (94KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Kobeni00.jpg
94KB, 1280x720px
>>143547236
>I don't even remotely understand the hype for WPM
Sakugafags

Psycho pass is a love it or hate it anime, It's weird you found it average
Mikakunin was fun!
>>
>>143540857
>Chobits
You're damn right i'm pissed.
Also add Rokka to that list
>>
>>143547352
HOSHI NI NARU YO...

Is outlaw star good? At episode 3 right now. Thinking of holding it and watch RahXephon.
>>
File: 79073l.jpg (78KB, 318x450px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
79073l.jpg
78KB, 318x450px
>>
>>143547236
>wpm
I give it around a 6-7/10 solely because of the animation during the fight scenes. It's the same reason why I gave hellsing ultimate an 8, I just fucking love the art style.
>>
1) TIME RESETS MAKE NO SENSE.
Just look how there is absolutely no consistency amongst them.

First & Second resets:
- Trigger before someone nearby gets killed
- The protagonist doesn’t need to know about the eminent death for the reset to happen
- The protagonist has no control over when it happens
- The reset sends you 5 minutes into the past
- If the protagonist fails, time moves on as normal

Third reset:
- Triggers after someone nearby gets killed
- The protagonist needs to know about the death for the reset to happen
- The protagonist has no control over when it happens
- The reset sends you 20 years into the past
- If the protagonist fails, time reverts to present, and he can try again until he succeeds
- Let’s not overlook the time paradox of managing to chance the day of death but everything else remained exactly the same, something which is impossible because of the butterfly effect. Also, we are supposed to believe when he returned to the present, his old self magically forgot everything, life went back to normal and played out in exactly the same way. Bullshit. And the fan boys still don’t accept it is nonsense, they now think the protagonist could always control time travel but was too afraid to use it consciously. Excusing bullshit with more bullshit.

Fourth reset:
- Triggers when everybody is fine.
- The protagonist wills it to happen. The fan boys were defending the show before this, saying it was great how he had no control over this power, since he can’t use it to his benefit and the tension is tenfold because of it. Well, so much for that.
- The reset sends you 20 years into the past but not at the same moment as in the second reset.
>>
>>143548439
Fifth reset:
The problem with this one is that it doesn’t exist. We get to a point where the protagonist is in grave danger and yet no time reset triggers. Why is that when it fits several criteria from previous cases? I mean, sure, the protagonist says that the fourth reset would be the last, but how did he know that? Did he read the script for what happens next? Does he know he lost the power? How does he know that??? The story never explains anything regarding that; it just throws it out there and then expects you not to give a damn when it’s vital to the story.

2) THE PROTAGONIST HAS NO STEADY MOTIVATIONS.
They change in every episode with no rhyme or reason. But the fan boys don’t notice it because he is a bland self-insert who can be anything and anyone at any given moment because the plot said so.

First & Second reset: He saves kids because he is altruistic
Never explained why he is, he was magically born that way.

Third reset: He wants to save his mother by manipulating the emotions of a little girl
A selfish reason, now he is magically no longer altruistic. Also he deducts that he must save the girl because he is at the time the murders began. Well, thank goodness nothing else happened in the world that year, or he might arbitrarily assume he had to do something completely different.

Fourth reset: He wants to save the little girl
He no longer cares about saving his mother, which by the way was never hard to save since he had 20 years of time to simply be around her when the fateful night arrives.
>>
>>143545310
You have some very strange taste pal
>>
Sorry, I don't pick up anything below a 7.5/10
>>
>>143550403
can i see your list?
>>
is there even more than 100 watchable anime
Thread posts: 113
Thread images: 21


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.