[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

Well, this was fucking shit.

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 160
Thread images: 14

Well, this was fucking shit.
>>
>>139740291
What a boring blog.
>>
>>139740291
Yep, stick with the oneshot
>>
>>139740291
why because they didn't kiss?
>>
>>139740291
Was I supposed to like Ueno and class rep by the end?
They were shitty people at the beginning and remained shitty people till the end, with no development whatsoever.
>>
>>139740291
Don't worry about trying to bait like this because most people agree.
>>
>>139740291
Koe no Katachi was awesome. Would love to read more of this kind.
>>
>>139740957
That's just because they feel the manga cheated them by not pandering to their qt deaf gf self insert fantasies.
>>
>>139741072
I like it too, but then again I read it not for the romance and more to the guy searching for redemption aspect.
>>
>>139740421
Yes, don't build up of the manga on their romance if there's no actual conclusion.
>>
>>139741186
>it's not a real conclusion of there's no kiss
>>
>>139740291
It has its good moments but yeah, like from chapter 20 all the way to like 45 is pretty shit, and the remaining chapters aren't so good but are a bit less shit.
>>
File: 014.png (223KB, 900x1344px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
014.png
223KB, 900x1344px
>>139741174
yeah, that was my intention too
>>
>>139741228
Yes, a simple hand-holding doesn't tell you if they end up together or not, so it's not conclusive.
>>
>>139741262
>>139741072
Stop posting that piece of shit.
>>
>>139741228
Spergs will be spergs. We got the best possible conclusion.
>>
>>139740421
>Huge fucking confession scene
>Never answered or considered again
>Implying it was a good ending

Epic
>>
>>139740291
Had potential but it turned mediocre. The One Shot was better
>>
>>139741362
>half of the main cast doesn't change of grow as people but the thing is just swept under the rug
>asspull redemption to the two ex friends bullies
It's shit.
>>
>>139741282
I always though the whole point of the story is redemption...

at the end he's redeem from all he had done to her... mission successful, story ends.
>>
>>139741581
>the whole point of the story is redempetion

It would be... if it didn't have half of the manga about MC loving her and her loving him back and a confession scene that didn't go anywhere at all

It was literally School Rumble tier
>>
>>139740291
Dont worry
Kyoani will fix this shit.
>>
I dropped the shit around when they went to the theme park. Just another shit manga /a/ talked me into reading
>>
KYO ANUS SAVE THE DAY
>>
What was the point of the nigger brazilian kid?
>>
>>139740291
Only SJW love it crazily.
>>
Hopefully Kyoani fixes the shit ending
>>
>>139741741
In Yamada we trust.
>>
>>139740291
Did we not have this same thread already today?
>>
>>139741822

Diversity, not everyone in Japan is Japanese. I appreciate stuff like that.

Also the ending is good, they don't need to kiss, it's obvious they end up together.
>>
Why are they keeping info top secret?
>>
File: 1459509468663.jpg (178KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1459509468663.jpg
178KB, 1280x720px
>>139741922
>unironically saying esssjaydoubleuu
>>
When is the next anime event
>>
>>139741282
Just because the author doesn't spell it out doesn't mean it's not conclusive, it seemed pretty clear to me.
>half of the main cast doesn't change of grow as people but the thing is just swept under the rug
Just because the athmosphere became full of happiness and forgiveness from the MC's side after the coma doesn't mean it was swept under the rug or all the characters' issue are solved. Kawai and Ueno are still bitches, and that is not changing anytime soon, no matter what the MC does or thinks. The story was about his redemption, not that of others'. Matter of fact the resolution is not fully positive, and intentionally so.
>>
>>139742703
go back tu tumblr faglord.
>>
>>139746525
*to
>>
>>139746525
>>139746573
>he's not a brave warrior of social justice
lel, pleb.
>>
>>139746525
Stop unnecessarily bumping threads to advertise your site, dumbass.
>>
>>139746759
*a *her
>>
>>139740291
Don't worry KyoAnus will fix it.
>>
>>139741327
You mean the best girl Ueno?
>>
>>139749272
How is Yamada even going to handle that witch? She might have to call in Okada.
>>
>>139746759
The girl never complains because she thinks she deserves everything for being a burden to everyone, the boy is kind of a dick as a child but not a bad person, and he had no idea the earing things were so expensive.
The teacher however, was a real piece of shit. And so are his "friends".
>>
File: Pedro.jpg (83KB, 585x585px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Pedro.jpg
83KB, 585x585px
>>139740291
Dont be like that.
>>
>>139749272
>"if he's gonna choose the other girl and not me I would prefer if he never woke up from the coma"
Pure fucking trash.
>>
So /a/ how do we fix manga plot?
I would chance the "love confession" to the end of manga.
>>
File: unseefs katawa.png (344KB, 1139x346px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
unseefs katawa.png
344KB, 1139x346px
CHEX
>>
SHECKS
>>
>>139749800
>>139749807
Jesus fuck
>>
>>139740421
He forced soap opera tier drama is pretty bad too
>>
>>139741174
>the guy searching for redemption
but the deaf doormat forgives and buddies up with the MC in like the first two chapters
>>
>>139740458
Only MC shows any character development. Everyone else is walking cliche.
>>
>>139749800
I WUB YUU
>>
>>139749800
one of the best doujins I've ever read
>>
>>139749956
This also Shouko is also a walking punching bag during the entire story. At first I felt sorry for her but in the end I was sick of her attitude.
>>
>>139744866
It was stupid. Most of his problems came from the fact that the people who he thought were his friends turned on him, because they were never really close, and then he is willing to have the same kind of worthless superficial relationships again, with some of the same people even, that as shown could break down the moment someone spoke his mind?
Forgiveness my ass, that's just stupidity.
>>
>>139750155
Autism
>>
>>139749956
This pretty much. Deaf-chan is already all over his dick the moment he apologizes, and then the other 5 volumes are wasted on a bunch of shitty side characters that never develops and the movie plot nobody cares about, all while the romance between the 2 MC is neglected.
>>
>>139750197
What's autistic about it?
>>
>>139750553
you not understanding human relations, my guess is you're leaning towards Asperger's on the spectrum, like many (but not all) anons in these specific threads
>>
>>139750761
Why, because I wouldn't call friends or hang out with horrible people that would backstab me any moment?
>>
This movie is going to bring kyoani fanboy autism to a whole new level. Is it going to be good? I sincerely hope so. Is it going to be the best animated film ever made? I doubt it. Yet the spam and dicksucking are going to be unbearable now that kyoani are once again adapting good source material
>>
>>139750099
I'm reading it right now, why did she slap his dick?
>>
>>139751022
Not your diary.
>>
>>139751022
I don't know what's worse, this or Shaft adapting Sangatsu no Lion.
>>
File: not_healing.jpg (415KB, 900x1308px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
not_healing.jpg
415KB, 900x1308px
>>139749586
Ueno did nothing wrong
>>
>>139751246
post scene and spoiler
>>
File: snk.jpg (138KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
snk.jpg
138KB, 1920x1080px
>>139751022
>he doesn't like a good old fashioned GodAni circlejerk
>>
>>139751337
KnK is fitting for KyoAni though.
>>
>>139751406
Why can't japs into character drama without turning in over the top autism?
>>
>>139751558
I'm sure they'll do a better work than Shaft, but I was talking about the fanbase and threads.
>>
>>139751752
Well Koe no Katachi won't be airing every week, so the threads probably won't be shitfests.

Sangatsu's threads are doomed though.
>>
>>139750761
>I don't have any valid argument so I am going to call everyone autistic and pretend I am right

Well if that makes you feel better go ahead
>>
>>139751937
It will be shit anyways looking at shaft's recent track record so nothing of value is lost
>>
>>139752037
Shinbo though
>>
>>139751022
Hey /v/ how is the war on feminism?
>>
>>139740291
it wasn't perfect. ending left lots to be desired but it's pretty far from shit. don't make manga threads with your autismal /v/ mindset please.
>>
Jesus fucking Christ why is /a/ so fucking autistic.

Everywhere you go it's either NTRfags, yurifags or "they didn't kiss"fags shitting up every single series threads.

Get over yourselves you fat delusional fucks.
>>
>>139752473
If you bothered to read the thread you would have seen that there's actual discussion, you cancerous faggot.
>>
>>139752307
>feminism

What the fuck are you talking about
>>
>>139752653
Buttmad kyoanifags respond to criticism with the /v/ ad hominem, this is nothing new
>>
>>139740291
>fun series
>threads on /a/ every week filled with people who liked it and were looking forward to every chapter
>then they didn't kiss at the end
> "THE ENTIRE SERIES IS GARBAGE WHAT A WASTE OF TIME REEE"

You faggots don't deserve shit.
>>
>>139752653
>>139752741
samefag
>>
>>139752751
They just expected too much. A nice hand-holding is good enough.
>>
>>139752751
The manga is less than mediocre regardless of the kiss.
>>
>>139752583
The exact same conversation that has been repeated in every single KnK thread since it finished.

Nokissfags whine and cry saying they wanted conclusion, other anons comment the closure was in finding redemption, because it was.
Nokissfags don't care because theyre autistic and self insert as the protag and want to fulfill their autistic fantasies through the manga.
>>
>>139752826
Nope
>>
>>139751022
i certainly will vacuum suck kyoani's dick if they manage to improve upon the source material like they tend to do.
because lately it's nothing but dissapointment after dissapointment from them.
>>
They better give Shouya the same voice as the manga trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sbOEnxodQA
>>
Best chance is the movie but it'll probably still be shit. That deaf chick was such a pushover and she never got stronger.
>>
>>139740291
It was okay. Less forced drama would've been nice. It's a shame how little impact her disability actually has on the plot, the way it's used it's really just a quirk. I get the impression that the author read Helen ESP and wanted to turn it into a romance story.
>>
>>139752838
As I said, you didn't read it.
>>139750155
>>139749992
>>139751609
You can start adressing these complains if you want to do something else other than whining like a petulant child.
>>
>>139753146
Great thanks for showing me three "arguments" two of which have no replies and are more than likely bait, and the other which ends in petty conversation about autism.

The fact is, it's difficult to have a discussion when people are so butthurt that it didn't end the way they wanted it. No matter how you counter their arguments you won't get anywhere.
>>
>>139752882
Mobileposters are subhuman scum who deserve to be lined up and shot.
>>
>>139752741
>Everyone that disagrees with me is le buttmad kyoanifag

See you people just as bad if not worst that the people you criticize.

>>139752882
>Phone poster

Of course
>>
>>139753417
So you don't want to discuss and you're only here to shitpost. Got it.
>>
>>139753417

And yet another post with but excuses and no real argument. And you still cant refute any of the claims made by other people.
>>
>>139753494
But now you know he can't be samefagging with just phone.
>>
>>139753754

Is not like it matters but

>Dinamic IP and proxy apps
>>
kissfags are still mad topkek
>>
>>139756242
>topkek

Fuck off
>>
>>139740291
didnt /a/ rage because of this book, awhile back?
>>
The thing that makes my blood boil the most is how everybody here is saying that they want KyoAni to change the ending and that the story needs fixing, and yet if when/if KyoAni does change the story, even if for the better, everybody complains about how they disrespect the source and how they butchered it or turned it into shit. There is no fucking winning. If they don't change it, people call it shit for not straying from the manga's "bad" ending; if they change it, people call it shit for straying from the manga's original ending. Will shitposters ever give anyone a break?
>>
>>139756242
>Topkek
>>>/b/
>>
>>139756956
Nobody complains about Yamada changing K-On but it's hip to criticize KyoAni nowadays.
>>
>>139740291
I don't care about the kiss. I loved the manga when it started but I got tired of the forced drama and that Shouya was the only character that got any significant development.
>>
>>139740291
Was a great comic. Especially liked how the deaf girl was an actual flawed, selfish character and not waifu bait. The second half is underrated, especially the movie festival plotline and how it stays true to its realistic take on bullying and uses the cruel director as a way to destroy the myth that parents and teachers try to pass on to their children that bullying and the like isn't in the adult world.
>>
>>139757466
>deaf girl was an actual flawed, selfish character and not waifu bait

In this threads I cant tell if comments like this are sarcastic or not
>>
>all this autism hating the ending
The ending's the best part. By going into the class reunion hand in hand they're bravely facing their past and the possible scrutiny of their former classmates and in doing so show that they have conquered it. Its honestly one of my all time favorite scenes in manga.
>>
>>139740291
Not shit, just mediocre. You kids need to stop using shit for anything that isn't a 10/10 masterpiece.
>>
>>139757917
100% serious. How she's so avoidant and cowardly and how the story doesn't hold back from showing us that she was a major cause for many of her problems too was really something it excelled at.
>>
>>139740291
Some fag in other thread said that the only people that think that Koe No Katachi is good are the ones that almost never read manga. I though it was bullshit but comments like this >>139757466 and > >139757968 make me thing that it might be trued.
>>
>>139758149
Here's your reply.
>>
>>139758130
And that is exactly what makes her a waifu bait. She is a pure girl incapable of being mean to anyone even if the entire words treats her like shit. Her entire character consist in look cute and get bullied.
>>
>>139750155
>Forgiveness my ass
What I meant is that he hasn't solved ALL his problems, the last chapters just give that impression, but it's far from a completely positive ending. He's redeemed himself, but (some of) the people he hangs out with haven't. I though the part where Ueno says she still doesn't like the Shoko and the fact she and Kawai stay unpunished made it clear enough
>>
File: 1460047415896.jpg (184KB, 750x735px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1460047415896.jpg
184KB, 750x735px
>>139758130
>>139758504
She is in this chart. She woukd be the Moe the inocent, pure girl that needs to be protected
>>
>>139758149
People who think Koe No Katachi is bad are incapable of understanding subtlety and/or missed out the point of the manga completely.
>>
>>139758760
>implying
the manga makes in explicitly clear that she's a really not sweet in any way. She blames others for her problems and is secretly really catty, and rather than submissive she is passive aggressive in how she avoids people. Also super bitchy btw.
>>
>>139758504
Anyone who has been bullied as a kid (and I bet most of us were) knows that forgiving the kids that bullied you is retarded bullshit.
>>
>>139759062
>She blames others for her problems
Now I know this is bait. She fucking tried to kill herself because she thought she was the cause of other people's problem.
>>
>>139758925
The point is that it was an story about growing up and moving from the bad experiences from the past to a better future but it was terrible executed.

If anything KnK proves that a good premise doest make up for bad storytelling and lack of imagination
>>
>>139759193
>storytelling
>imagination
Thank god Yamada is directing it.
>>
>>139759184
Exactly the suicide attempt was just showing that she is so pure and innocent that she would rather die that keep causing troubles.

I think it was easily the worst part of the manga. Not only because she was saved in the last minute by knight in shiny armor MC but the next say was also saved by mommy from the stereotypical evil cunt.
>>
>>139759154
Don't go stamping your shitty childhood on everyone else.
Not all of us were turbo autists as children.

I bullied a ton of faggots like you before. Half of them are still mad, and there are some that have moved on that I still talk to. Not everyone is as two dimensional as you think in your still-mad head. It's very possible for a character in a manga to be more mature than you are and not spite someone for the past.
>>
>>139759749
Stop projecting your turbo-autism on others
>>
>>139759255
Yeah, we'll get a lot of characters fidgeting, great imaginative storytelling.

Yamada might be the most overrated director in anime right now.
>>
>>139759491
It makes sense considering for all her life she thought she was just a source of problems for all the people around her. It was more due to desperation rather than innocence.

She should have definetely bitchslapped Ueno once and for all when the MC was in the hospital though, I agree the author pushed the "nice girl" sterotype too far with that.
>>
>>139759154
Not really. At some point you recognize that little kids are retarded and move on.
>>
File: 1463746738472.png (341KB, 564x400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1463746738472.png
341KB, 564x400px
>there are people still falling for the "KnK's ending was bad" meme

I thought we had all agreed that the ending left over perfectly thematically while clearly indicating a romantic feature between Shoyo and Shouko, /a/. I kiss would've felt forced at that point in their relationship and also with considering their characters
>>
>>139759749
You sound like you're still a turbo autist desu.
>>
>>139759810
Great post.
>>
>>139760069
>we
No, you were just retarded.
>>
>>139759785
>>139760110
I'm not the faggot who got bullied as a child
>>
>>139760121
Come on, anon. That didn't even deserve a pity reply.
>>
>>139760177
Name one reason why it's bad besides "muh kiss", and we'll see who's really reatarded
>>
The first 30ish chapters were great and her confessing and him thinking she said moon melted my heart

Then i turned to shit
>>
>>139760069
There will always be those retarded kissfag autists.
>>
File: IMG_20160116_211054.jpg (182KB, 728x1036px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
IMG_20160116_211054.jpg
182KB, 728x1036px
>>139760069
We did. It's literally just butthurt fags that are still mad at this point.

This was honestly the most perfect final page. They found respect for each other and are ready to face the rest of the world and the future.
>>
>>139759749
Self-defense mechanism at its best.
>>
>>139760203
>>139760121
It's about the same quality a post as "Thank god for Yamada," honestly.
>>
>>139760069
I know that "the ending isn't bad" is great shitposting material but seriousIt went to total dogshit when shouko tried to kill herself.
>>
>>139760243
The problem isn't the ending itself, it's the entire second half of the manga it's just terrible.
>>
>>139760243
>muh kiss
More like muh complete derailment of romantic progress in favor of retarded drama and then a timeskip.
>>
>>139760470
>More like muh complete derailment of romantic progress in favor of retarded drama and then a timeskip.
The timeskip was right after the bullying arc dumbass. What "romantic progress" was there to derail?

>>139760336
>It went to total dogshit when shouko tried to kill herself.
Why?

People keep falling for the "second half is bad" meme but don't give any reasons why except for something stupid like "forced drama"
>>
>>139760568
I think he meant the final timeskip.
>>
>>139760610
I honest to god don't remember a second timeskip. When was that? I'm thinking it was small
>>
>>139760568
>any reasons why except for something stupid like "forced drama"
Because no one wanted to see shitty angst and half the cast being insane and then all that getting no conclusion.
>>
>>139740458
>Was I supposed to like Ueno and class rep by the end?
no?
was that too hard to get?
>>
I don't know what had a worse ending this or MGX
>>
>>139760968
Why did MC keep hanging out with them and called them his friends then? Was he retarded?
>>
>>139761574

Because he was a loser with no friends
>>
>>139760568
How do you call shit like this >>139751406
beside forced drama?
The drop of quality in the writing department was baffling.
>>
File: Friends-tv-show-1-.jpg (17KB, 290x200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Friends-tv-show-1-.jpg
17KB, 290x200px
>>139761574
because the MC is a guy who got bullied as a kid and had trouble making friends because of that later in life. by later i mean high school.
what did you think this story was about that you had to like every one of his "friends"? pic related?
>>
I think the series peaked really early on and was pretty much on a downhill slope since then, but I don't think it ever got shit until the coma.
>>
>>139761574
You take what you can get, fuccboi.
>>
>>139761994
That explains him reaching out to them the first time. Then they disappoint him again and he finally tells them what they think about them on the bridge and they fuck off.
But after that the manga became masturbatory and devoid of any development whatsoever and so nere they are hanging out with the MC for no reason despite learning nothing and being utterly useless to the plot.
The author bite more than he could chew and had no fucking idea what he was doing with half of the cast.
>>
>>139740291
Kyoani movie when?
>>
>>139762702
Fall 2016

Any predictions for the full staff?
>>
>>139762821
Director: Yamada
Script: Yamada
Animation Director: Yamada
Voice of Shouko: Yamada
>>
>>139762821
Director: Yamada
Script: Yoshida
Character design: Debut of a newbie
Thread posts: 160
Thread images: 14


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.