[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | | Home]

Daily reminder that Kekkai is so shit it doesn't make into

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 238
Thread images: 47

File: Untitled.jpg (156KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Untitled.jpg
156KB, 1280x720px
http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm27918547
http://bintan.ula.cc/test/read.cgi/wc2014.2ch.net/anime4vip/1449849425/l10
http://bintan.ula.cc/test/read.cgi/wc2014.2ch.net/anime4vip/1451474491/l10

01. 933 Shirobako
02. 643 Hibike! Euphonium
03. 542 Prison School
04. 347 One punch man
05. 285 Non Non Biyori Repeat
06. 280 Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
07. 250 Overlord
08. 229 Saenai Heroine no Sodatekata
09. 228 Soukyuu no Fafner: Dead Aggressor - Exodus
10. 191 Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry
11. 189 JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Stardust Crusaders 2nd Season
12. 185 Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans
13. 154 Knights of Sidonia: Battle for Planet Nine
14. 158 Himouto! Umaru-chan
15. 147 Shimoneta to Iu Gainen ga Sonzai Shinai
16. 143 Cross Ange: Tenshi to Ryuu no Rondo Taikutsu na Sekai
16. 143 Yuru Yuri SanHai!
18. 136 Houkago no Pleiades
19. 124 Owarimonogatari
19. 124 Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru.Zoku
21. 123 Parasyte -the maxim-
22. 121 Hello!! Kiniro Mosaic
23. 119 Seiken Tsukai no World Break
24. 110 Gochuumon wa Usagi Desu ka??
25. 108 Joukamachi no Dandelion
26. 106 RollingGirls
27. 100 PriPara
28. 99 Charlotte
28. 95 Osomatsu-san
30. 94 Shokugeki no Souma
31. 93 Fate/stay night [Unlimited Blade Works]
32. 90 Gakkougurashi!
33. 89 Go! Princess Precure
34. 87 Hacka Doll The Animation
35. 86 SHOW BY ROCK!!
36. 82 Lupin III (2015)
37. 81 Rokka no Yuusha
38. 78 Yuri Kuma Arashi
39. 75 Concrete Revolutio: Choujin Gensou
40. 74 Aldnoah Zero
41. 73 Subete ga F ni Naru: The Perfect Insider
42. 71 The [email protected] Cinderella Girls
42. 72 Etotama
44. 65 Senki Zesshou Symphogear GX
45. 63 GATE
46. 61 Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen
47. 60 Ore Monogatari!!
48. 57 Valkyrie Drive: Mermaid
49. 56 Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu
50. 55 WORKING!!!
>>
File: 1451630206559.png (970KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451630206559.png
970KB, 1920x1080px
>>135561783
>Japanese reddit
>>
>>135561783
Is Shirobako any good?
>>
>>135561860
No. It was decent. Only decent. Can't even manage to hold a single interesting plotkine for so long.
>>
File: KekkaiMILFsen.jpg (527KB, 849x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
KekkaiMILFsen.jpg
527KB, 849x1200px
>>135561783

>FSN
> #31

Justice
>>
>>135561783
2chan has shit taste tho
>>
>>135561860
Why don't you find it out by yourself.
>>
>>135561906
so does /a/
>>
>>135561829
/co/mblr don't have the right to say that.
>>
>>135561783
>Shitgatsu that high
So it's just a MALtier listing. Nothing to see here folks.
>>
>>135561906
>tho
>>
File: image.jpg (50KB, 563x317px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
50KB, 563x317px
>>135561783
>Calvary in top 10

That's how you know 2chan has shittaste. All they care about is tits and ass.

Kekkai Sensen and Osomatsu were robbed. Either one of them should of been AOTY.
>>
>>135561783
Shirobako #1 alteast Japan did one thing right.
>>
>>135562129
> All they care about is tits and ass.
Check their 2014
1.Barakamon
2.Ping Pong
3.Nozaki
4.Kill la Kill
5.FSN UBW
6.Yama no Susume 2
7.Locodol
8.Aldnoah Zero
9.Sidonia
10.Usagi
11.Love Live 2
12.Wake up, girls
13.Bahamut genesis
14.Mushishi
15.Yuuki Yuuna
16.Mikakunin de Shinkokei
17.Nagi no Asukara
18.Space Dandy
19.Psycho-Pass 2
20.Mahouka
21.JoJo
22.Sabagebu!
23.Hanayamata
24.Nisekoi
25.No game No life
26.Gundam BF
27.Gokukoku no Brynhildr
28.Space Dandy 2
29.Amagi
30.SAO2
31.Akuma no Riddle
32.Witch Craft Works
33.Haikyuu!!
34.Sakura trick
35.selector infected WIXOSS
36.Log Horizon
37.Hitsugi no Chaika
38.Saki: Zenkoku-hen
39.Buddy Complex
40.Uchuu Kyoudai
41.Silver Spoon
42.Nourin
43.Isshuukan Friends
44.Sora no Method
45.Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren
46.Kenzen Robo Daimidaler
46.Glasslip(wat)
48.Soredemo Sekai wa Utsukushii
49.Nobunaga Concerto
50.Shounen Hollywood
>>
>>135562175
Then how come this year the list is complete shit? Are you telling me Kekkai Sensen and Osomatsu aren't good enough to be in the top 10?
>>
>>135562324
Both are terrible shows that got decent sales thanks to the fujoshi.
>>
>>135561783
>Charlotte

Fuck, guess there's bad taste in every fucking country then
>>
>>135562324
Yep. They are good, but not that good. Also, the hype killer on KS pretty much ruined everything.
>>
>>135561860
I enjoyed it more than anything from this year
Cute office girls working hard and the despair of falling behind on your deadlines
>>
>>135562432
How the fuck is garbage like Overlord and Shigatsu in the top 10 but Kekkai and Osomatsu isn't.
>>
>>135561783
>03. 542 Prison School
Serriously? I love the manga, but the anime was pure trash.
Though the fact that it has Charlotte in there already makes me completely disregard it.
>>
>>135562324

Kekkai Sensen is a good concept on paper but it was terrible executed. I enjoyed the soundtrack, the visuals but the characters are paper thin and the plot was all over the place.

It doesn't help they delayed the last episode by several months and it made things even more confusing. Disappointing to say the least and I just wish it was an episodic anime of randomness of Jerusalem Lot. If that was the show, it would be much much better but instead they introduced vampires and shit just go boring as all hell.
>>
File: dayone.png (320KB, 540x643px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
dayone.png
320KB, 540x643px
>>135561783
The list is questionable as a whole, but that top five is pretty much perfect.
>>
File: 1442616794456.gif (67KB, 500x375px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1442616794456.gif
67KB, 500x375px
>>135561783
Who the fuck care with their taste
Some anon made poll on /a/ the other days, now what's that poll says?
>>
>>135561783
Doesn't matter when Kekkai Sensen sold more than most of those series.

Nips in 2chan don't fucking matter.
>>
>01. 933 Shirobako
This is the only thing they got right and even that's questionable since it started in 2014.
>>
File: 1448890115385.jpg (771KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448890115385.jpg
771KB, 1920x1080px
Rakudai win over Asterik anyday, anytime
>>
>>135562575
It's still better than garbage like Overlord and Shigatsu that made it in the top 10.
>>
>>135561783
Top 2 is okay. It's completely bullshit from 3 to 50 though.
>>
>shirobako

How did an anime that had no pandering or fantasy-fulfillment make it to the #1 spot?

Did japs finally get good taste?
>>
>>135562324
Last year's list was even shittier with ping ping garbage at 2 and glassleep in the top 50
>>
>>135562645
Except in getting another season.
>>
>>135562675
Moe girls, faggot.

So yes it did have pandering. They had to moeify shit.
>>
>>135562656

I agree it is better than Overlord but not Shigatsu. Shigatsu had well developed character, a beautiful ost, nice visuals and a great ending.

>>135562677

Ping Pong deserves the stop, it is a fantastic show anon.
>>
>>135562675
Seeing as how Owari was beaten out by Umaru-chan, Sidonia, and and Cross Ange, nope.
>>
>>135562734
No Shigatsu was garbage with its forced drama and sudden mood splash. The comedy bits were fucking terrible
>>
We had this thread last night.

Also at least I'm not a faggot who just copy and pastes from Reddit when making a thread designed just to cause shitposting. Fuck your presentation is even shit. Put some effort into it, having the #1 show be the first thing someone who reads your post see causes it to lose effectiveness at stirring people up.
>>
>>135562787

As a collective, it is still better than the jumbled up mess of Kekkai though I do have to admit Kekkai is one of the few anime that made like their entire cast, even the bad guys were cool.
>>
>Overlord
Why? It's garbage low budget adaptation
>>135561903
They rate UBW in past year if I'm not wrong.
>>
>>135561783
>Shirobako
>2015
>>
>>135561783
>26. 106 RollingGirls
We did it bros!
>>
>UBW that low

WTF????
>>
Kekkai Sensen was labelled fujoshi early on and discarded on this basis because 2ch can't think for shit. Also, the last episode being delayed killed it.
>>
>>135562575
read the manga I liked the new content, but It cant hold a candle for the manga
>>
This proves that battle harems was not a mistake. Rakudai pulling it for the team.
>>
>>135562680
asterisk is split season
>>
>>135563354
type shit is dead and buried
>>
File: 1421862357011.png (90KB, 480x477px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1421862357011.png
90KB, 480x477px
Why nobody like kekkai Sensen? It's not that bad.
>>
>>135563514
>Saenai ranked higher
>racuckdai pulling it for the team
kek
>>
>>135563561
Forced sakuga bait.
>>
>10. 191 Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry
Top 10 was looking good until this ruined it.
>>
>>135561783
>Rokka no Yuusha at 37
Why tho? It did really bad in sales.
>>
>>135563599
Both shows are pretty shit so that list is just bad.
>>
>>135562935
>As a collective, it is still better than the jumbled up mess of Kekkai
Not even close also you're a goddamn idiot if you thought KS was a mess when it was incredibly straightforward
>>
>>135561783
>10. Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry
>11. JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken
Sasuga Japan.
>>
>34. 87 Hacka Doll The Animation
>3
>4
Best hackadolls confirmed.
>>
>>135563402
Not sales though.
>>
File: 1447538660427.jpg (392KB, 950x652px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447538660427.jpg
392KB, 950x652px
>07. 250 Overlord

Sasuga, Ainz-sama
>>
>>135561783
The delayed finale was a massive mistake. That said
>japanese
>taste
>japanese reddit
>any taste at all
Good one.

>Umaru
>14
>even getting on the list
154 voters need to kill themselves.
>>
File: 1435850120457.png (16KB, 250x391px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1435850120457.png
16KB, 250x391px
>>135562175
>27.Gokukoku no Brynhildr
>8.Aldnoah Zero

So these lists are a complete fucking joke.
>>
Top 5 are understandable. The rest are questionable.
>>
>>135563918
>The delayed finale was a massive mistake
Why do people keep saying this shit as if thus is the first time anime's last episode got delayed? GuP made the 2012 list snd its last episode didn't even air yet.
>>
>>135563972
>Top 5 are understandable.
>Prison School
>>
>>135563972
>Top 5 are understandable
>hibikek
>>
>>135562593
>trusting polls
There is so much that can go wrong. First annoying vocal fan bases will be more eager to click on vote threads and spam shit opinions e.g NNBR
Second actual voter spammers like proxy-tan
Thirdly you get an uneven demographic and it won't reflect whatever group you think it does.

A poll on /a/ might well be labeled 'this thread on that day' for all the consistency voting has. Although you will see trend appearing for shows with annoying audiences as seen in my first point for shows like Umaru.
>>
>>135563972
>Top 5 are understandable.
>OPM
>>
>>135563972
>Top 5 are understandable
Maybe you should just go live in japan if you like terrible opinions that much.
>hibikek
>prison school
>NNBR
Yuri-bait, trash and a sequel that is just the same shit
>>
16. 143 Cross Ange

Sasuga Japan
>>
>>135562562
>I love the manga, but the anime was pure trash.
The fuck are you talking about? It's a near-identical adaptation of the manga.
>>
>>135564066
I just want to know how's our shit taste is
I remember that poll using googledocs for anticipation of proxyfag, and we have to type the fuck out our favorite animu

Last time I saw Keit-Ai is in the lead though
>>
>>135564240
>Google docs
Yeah I saw that around. It needed an acc so I wasn't interested.
>>
>>135561783
>2ch
That's cute.

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2015-12-04/japanese-industry-insiders-pick-2015-best-anime-games/.96102
>>
> Non Non Boring
> #5
>>
>>135563750
fuck you fag, shigatsu is good and kekai sensen was shit, deal with it.
>>
>>135564306
>shigatsu is good
Hello MAL
>>
>>135561860
It's pretty good although the humor can be pretty shit sometimes and some of the side characters can be pretty meh...
>>
>>135564146
That canon c//uck ending where Ange clothed Tusk in a dress and lived in a lesbian paradise with him as her bitch is funny but fuck it put me off saying the series was good overall.
>>
Any list with Rolling Girls on it should be discarded.
>>
Kekkai Sensen was shit so it's not surprising.
>>
>>135564461
>Kekkai Sensen was shit
So why wasn't it on the list?
>>
>>135564502
Because the rest isn't as shit as Kekkai Sensen.
>>
>>135564306
Shigatsu is fucking awful.
>>
>>135561783
No, it's been so shit that this its been its only thread after the last episode aired. The most forgettable show ever.
>>
>>135561783
>06. 280 Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
This just piss me off every fucking time I read it.
>>
>>135564555
>>135564611
[Reply]
>>
File: 1451630151506.png (166KB, 500x281px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451630151506.png
166KB, 500x281px
>>135564706
Cry more Kekshit fag
>>
keken shitsen is literally how to not adapt a manga: the anime
>>
>>135562129
>All they care about is tits and ass.

And yuri.
>>
File: 1377655691827.png (120KB, 434x400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1377655691827.png
120KB, 434x400px
>even Valkyrie Drive made it over Kekshit Shitsen
>>
>>135564928
Over what?
>>
>>135564118
It's the sort of show that's right up the alley of casuals and mainstream anime fans. What's hard to understand about it?
>>
>>135564665
I don't know what it is about that show, but the idea of it just makes me angry. It was really bad, but I've seen worse that didn't get me nearly this badly. I think it's just how manipulative it was, like they threw together a bunch of "poignant" elements and decided they could pass that off as a tragedy without putting in any effort.
>>
>>135565136
It was shit because their whole idea of dealing with a kid who had serious PTSD issues was just laughably bad.
>>
>>135565136
It's because the whole thing is an amalgam of shitty overused tropes. It feels completely ungenuine and it's horribly executed to boot.
The thing that really gets me though is how many people just eat it right the fuck up. It's incredibly frustrating.
>>
>one meme man

fuck off with this jap reddit site
>>
>>135562324
>My favorite anime didn't make the list! Wahhh!!!!
>>
I really enjoyed KS when it was first airing but I think it was around episode 9 that the show just completely lost me. I tried picking it back up a month or so ago from the start but ended up dropping it for a second time. I think its premise, setting and characters are a combination of unique and interesting, but it had a difficult time at both being engaging and making the viewer care about what was going on. I have a few volumes of the manga that I haven't gotten around to so I'll see if those are any better.
>>
File: 453045345.gif (1002KB, 272x198px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
453045345.gif
1002KB, 272x198px
>>135561783
>2ch
>having good taste

Here's your (You)
>>
>>135565279
The problem with Kekkai Sensen was that it didn't have a sense of unity. By themselves, some of the episodes were well done and good but as a whole, the show felt very disjointed. It was only Matsumoto Rie's 2nd show so hopefully she gets better.
>>
>>135562175
>2.Ping Pong
Well color me surprised, they do have some taste every once in a decade
>>
>>135561783
>49. 56 Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu
Better than I thought it would be.
>>
File: 1421983037447.jpg (12KB, 500x258px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1421983037447.jpg
12KB, 500x258px
KimiUso was good, eat shit all of you.
>>
>>135565339
This and the pacing for some of the episodes was a little too fast. I feel if the episodes were 40 minutes or so it might've been better. We would've gotten more time for other characters as well. The only other show I know that's done this is katanagatari though, so I'm not sure how feasible that would have been with airing schedules and whatnot.
>>
>>135565350
>4. Kill la Kill
>>
>>135565612
Yeah well, their taste ran out fast but still, I'd never have expected to see Ping Pong at rank 2.
>>
>>135565465
Fuck yourself to death. None of it was well-done. Plot, characters, scene direction, visuals, and somehow even the music direction, because just slapping famous composers on concert scenes is not effective.
>>
>>135565667
>it's all bad and I hate it
So, do you know other tricks, outside of parroting the rest of /a/?
>>
>>135565716
Tell me what you think was particularly well done and I'll go into it. I don't think anyone wants a giant rant about every little thing.
>>
>>135565769
True enough. Well, and sorry for not being precise (my memory is fairly shit), I mostly liked it for the characters and direction. While some of it didn't work (like the relation between Arima and his mother which isn't properly developped iirc, and some annoying minor characters), and while Kaori's motivations could be seen as really shonenish in how exaggerated it was, I loved most of the cast. As for the direction, I'm no music expert but I found the concert beautiful and the way the drama was handled sent me on the good ol' rollercoaster. I also really liked the artstyle and choice of colors.
The only real gripe I have about it is the whole part with that one dude's sister and how Arima becomes his tutor. Nobody cares and they just take way too much time with that.
>>
>>135565541
>>135565339
>>135565279
The people who hate this show seem to have a very hard time describing what's wrong with it. Maybe you're just really dumb.
>>
>>135565978
>The only real gripe I have about it is the whole part with that one dude's sister and how Arima becomes his tutor. Nobody cares and they just take way too much time with that.
I thought the loli and her brother and the other rival were the best characters. Arima's mother thing was bad, like you said,, and Kaori was basically a plot device and whose reactions/thoughts about her own fatal disease took a back seat to Arima's reactions to it. The two friends were irrelevant except for one scene every few episodes where we were supposed to pretend to care about the childhood friend's senpai troubles.

I'm not a music expert, either, so I'm not saying they needed to pick some obscure patrician stuff, but they'd just start playing and then talk over it and do some sweeping shots, it didn't usually feel like it was contributing to anything. And the designs/color palette felt like generic A-1 stuff, with some extra colorful splashes during sequences like the final performance.
>>
File: 1373227729016.png (159KB, 328x314px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1373227729016.png
159KB, 328x314px
>>135566236
>posts explicitly list what's wrong
>BAWWW YOU JUST CAN'T DESCRIBE IT UR DUMB

Grow thicker skin.
>>
>>135566236
Kekkai Sensen is a perfect example of all style and no substance. The characters are all colorful and unique in their design and mannerisms, but none of them are explored in any degree of depth, with the worst characters in the show being essentially nothing and the best still being pretty cliche. The world is the exact same way. Although there's the suggestion that this is a deeply interesting and unique place to live, only on one do we actually explore the city in any detail and tackle any problems that might be faced past "there's something vaguely dangerous that needs to be dealt with."

It also a fucking horribly opening episode. I would have dropped it right there if fans of the show hadn't kept saying to pick it back up. Admittedly, it got better, but not better enough to warrant a watch in my opinion.
>>
>>135561783
Sasuga Jaddit
>>
>>135566236
I don't even hate it, I just thought most of the episodes were boring. The White date and that Seventh Seal scene were great, but after that it went downhill.
>>
>>135566268
>Kaori was basically a plot device
That's a criticism I can't understand. Of course a main character is a plot device, else there's not much point to them being a main character. A good chunk of the story revolves around her, so I'd even say she's a plot engine or something.

>whose reactions/thoughts about her own fatal disease took a back seat to Arima's reactions to
Well, she's known about it for a while, so it's only normal imo.

>The two friends were irrelevant
The dude was irrelevant, yeah, but the childhood friend herself was interesting and helped getting some insight about Arima's childhood. On top of being good drama material because unilateral love. She had some good scenes too, the confession and some of the scenes with them going back home together were really well-made.

>they'd just start playing and then talk over it and do some sweeping shots
They didn't talk over it that much in my memory, just a few short commentaries to help the assumedly plebian spectator get what's up. Felt appropriate to me.

>And the designs/color palette felt like generic A-1 stuff, with some extra colorful splashes during sequences like the final performance.
I disagree, it had warmer colors than those of their usual productions iirc.

Anyway, I need to catch some z's so good night anon. If you reply I won't be able to reply but I'll read it.
>>
>>135561783
>12. 185 Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans

WHORUUUFAN NAMIDAAAAA
>>
>>135566557
I expect the dying girl who moves your plot to be explored or characterized somehow, but I didn't get that. It felt like she was only relevant as an accessory to Arima, and that's not really okay with how much time they spent on her and her long death.

I found it really hard to care about such the childhood friend's small side romance stretched out so much, with people having mental breakdowns and dying and stuff. I sort of need more than that to get invested, I guess.

> just a few short commentaries to help the assumedly plebian spectator get what's up
It's been too long for me to be sure how much they did it, but I think this is sort of what I'm getting at. I don't really want to hear a virtuoso performance in my anime for the sake of it and then be told how good it was. I want to hear whatever I'm hearing because it will enhance it somehow, and most of them didn't feel like that. For example, Nodame's music felt much more effective to me.
>>
>>135566236
You are misunderstanding me. I enjoyed the fuck out of ks. The only episode I didn't like was the chess episode. But I still think it would been much better if we had more time to develop other characters. I wouldn't say there was zero substance, but it had way too much going on to try and condense into 13 episodes. A lot of aspects were nicely explored like leero and whites relationship, but at the same time a lot of things weren't simply because they didn't have enough time.
>>
File: the truth.jpg (74KB, 1024x1150px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
the truth.jpg
74KB, 1024x1150px
>>135561783
>2ch
>Nico
>relevant

Kekkai Sensen boosted the manga sales to the top 30
>>
>>135567205
The anime also sold around 18k average.
>>
>>135562175
kinda suprised that tokyo ghoul didnt make it to both 2014-15 list regardless of how overrated it is
>>
Can we at least all agree Shirobako was the best anime of the past decade?
>>
File: 1411254297246.png (790KB, 792x792px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1411254297246.png
790KB, 792x792px
>>135561783
>28. 99 Charlotte
>placing at all
>ranking above anything else
But why?
>>
>>135567375
it isn't overrated you fucking hipster

I wish neither you nor the tumblrinas knew about it
>>
>>135567673
The anime is overrated by plebs in the west despite it being utter shit and an awful adaptation.
>>
>03. 542 Prison School
>04. 347 One punch man
POWER GAP
>05. 285 Non Non Biyori Repeat
NNB
B T F O
T
F
O
>>
>>135566432
Here's your reply
>>
>>135568045
There's a bigger gap between 3rd and 4th though
>>
>>135561783
>01. 933 Shirobako
that god-tier taste tho
>>
File: 1449899025324.jpg (25KB, 640x480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1449899025324.jpg
25KB, 640x480px
>>135566288
>posts explicitly list what's wrong
He posted a bunch of nonsense that ended up being less of a critque and more of a rant over not liking a thing. If you're going to criticize something try not to type like an idiot.
>>
>>135566497
>but after that it went downhill.
You've done a great job convincing me where it did.
>>
>>135568161
Read the fucking list idiot.
>>
>>135566236
KS is like Ping Pong, the people who hate it are too stupid to put into words why its bad.
>>
>>
File: 1444327299094.jpg (35KB, 500x502px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444327299094.jpg
35KB, 500x502px
>>135561783
>10. 191 Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry
FUCK YOU
>>
>>135568184
>>135566236
I like KS and I'm not one of the people involved in this discussion so far but it seems like it's just you who's too fucking stupid to understand their critique.
>>
>02. 643 Hibike! Euphonium

Why? It was mediocre at best. Was it because of the yuri shit?
>>
>>135567205
Hamatora was disappointingly fun.
>>
>>135567205
>EVA
>Bakemonogatari
>Madoka
>SEED Destiny
These are the best sellers and they're all four shit
>>
File: CNx4kwhUkAAeqS6.jpg (24KB, 465x486px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
CNx4kwhUkAAeqS6.jpg
24KB, 465x486px
>>135562175
>13.Bahamut genesis

Not saying it restored any faith in them though, it still sold like shit.
>>
>02. 643 Hibike! Euphonium

Barely reached 10k right?
>>
>>135562675
they moefying the animation industry so no they still pandering to moefag.
>>
>>135562324
Maybe they got pissed at the delayed KS ending.
>>
File: 1450922869412.jpg (273KB, 402x648px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1450922869412.jpg
273KB, 402x648px
>>135561783
>33. 89 Go! Princess Precure

Cool
>>
>16. 143 Cross Ange: Tenshi to Ryuu no Rondo Taikutsu na Sekai
At least 143 japs have taste.
>>
>>135561783
>02. 643 Hibike! Euphonium
Based Kyoani
>>
>>135564280
>obscure shit at no.1
>shigatshit at top 5
what you trying to convey exactly?
>>
At least they ranked Shirobako at #1.

The rest of the list is pretty bad though.

>10. 191 Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry
Top fucking kek. That show was terrible.
>>
>kekkai sensen doesn't deserve top 50
>07.Overlord
>14 Himouto! Chan
>19. Yahari
>21. Parasyte
Parasyte's adaption specifically was grade A garbage, this list is retarded.
>>
>>135563994
But GuP was undeniably good. It also sold a lot more.
>>
>>135562575
The first 3 episodes were God Tier, when does it start unravelling/
>>
File: 146324356565.gif (489KB, 458x260px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
146324356565.gif
489KB, 458x260px
>Rakudai top 10

Asteriskfags on suicide watch
>>
Oh wow the thread is still up.

>>135566849
>It felt like she was only relevant as an accessory to Arima
It didn't feel that way to me but if it did to you, I sort of understand why you didn't like it now.

Haven't seen Nodame's adaptation either, guess I should get to it.
>>
>>135562575
>but the characters are paper thin
>all have distinct personalities that bounce off one another with small bits of backstory
The show falls flat on its face with the vampire plot at episode 9+. The sense of mystery they gave when they're first introduced in the episode with Abrahms definitely kept me interested. Having the anime original stuff tie the episodes together worked well until Bones had to attempt to make an ending. If you watched episodes 1-10 and skipped the recap and the final two episodes this show was a 8/10.
The date scene and the hamburger episodes were best[/spoilers]
>>
isn't kekkai sensen one of the best selling TV show of 2015?
>>
>>135572799
Guess most nips with money aren't worried about popularity polls.
>>
Kekkai Sensen and Concrete Revolutio were the best shows of 2015.
>>
File: 1440115916897.jpg (70KB, 413x319px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1440115916897.jpg
70KB, 413x319px
>>135563972
>hibike
>prison school
>OPM
>understandable
>>
>>135572098
I came here to check if it's on the list and seeing there's at least two others did the same makes me feel good.
>>
>>135573241
you right, OPM should've been 1.
>>
Last years list got me to watch Barakamon and that was amazing so I guess the next thing to put on my list is Shirobako. I really liked Death Parade so its a little weird for me to not see it show up but I guess I can see how it wouldn't appeal to everyone. Also it aired in January which was a long time ago.
>>
>date episode
2ch virgins don't like date episodes
>>
>>135573241
How about you post your top 5?
>>
File: Greatest Tiger.png (444KB, 853x741px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Greatest Tiger.png
444KB, 853x741px
>>135561783
>Etotama listed at all.

Yass
>>
>>135564403
off yourself you retard
/u/ got shit on
>>
>>135572799
yes
this is the japanese reddit, so nobody actually cares
>>
>>135575436
No need to be so upset if you didn't see anything from the artbooks or the drama CDs.
>>
>>135561860
It's a solid 7/10
>>
>>135575501
I'm sure the fukuda was in charge of the artbooks and drama cds
>>
>>135561783
Well deserved.
>>
>>135561783
I already know Kekkai is shit, I don't need japs to confirm this.
>>
>>135564403
Wait what?
>>
>>135561783
>Hibikek 02
polite lack of bump
>>
>>135575530
>anime is made by a single person
Fuck off tekyutard
tekyutard.
>>
Why did Leo let Huwaito die a virgin?
>>
>shirobako
>2015
>>
>>135561783
>>135562175
>no Tesagure
>no Choboraunyopomi series
Disgusting.
>>
>>135572799
Happy for it. I hope to see more of the creator.
>>
>Prison School, Overlord and Cavalry all in the top 10
Nice going Japan real good
>>
>>135567205
Well, duh. Everyone with half a brain can spot the interesting setting and atmosphere behind the mess that is the anime adaptation. Of course they've moved on to the manga.
>>
File: Miia.jpg (155KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Miia.jpg
155KB, 1280x720px
>No Monmusu

Ah well.
>>
>>135571580
Kyoani has always been well-known by those who have developed an interest in the medium, but a good part of buying power lies upon those who have developed a tunnel-vision approach to the industry (fujo/otaku) that shows that try to appeal in different, classier ways typical of more respectable media often gets ignored.

2ch is very vocal about the industry, and henceforth aware of the objective qualities of Hibike, but they have little sway in terms of sales.
>>
>>135561783
>Hibike only second to Shirobako
Absolutely correct. Hibike was the best thing that aired fully in 2015 and it's not even close.
>>
>>135561783
>Shimpachi
>topping anything
>>
File: 1440877144289.gif (2MB, 450x188px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1440877144289.gif
2MB, 450x188px
>>135572256
Would you prefer the live-action version?
>>
>>135561783
>prison school and opm higher than NNB
sasuga shit taste
>etotama higher than GATE
I like the way this is, but I don't understand why jap shit taste failed to work here
>>
>Shokugeki no Soma at 30
I'll take it.
>>
>>135561783
>Orphans before Sidonia.
Fuck this list
>>
>>135577628
S2 was utter shit.
>>
>>135561783
>Shirobako
>Hibikek
>NNB
>Ainz-sama
>Saekano
>Cavalry
>Jojo
>Sidonia
>Pleiades
>Oregairu
>All in the top 20

Bretty good
>>
File: doman cohee.jpg (31KB, 640x480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
doman cohee.jpg
31KB, 640x480px
>Daily reminder
>I'm trying to force a meme
This thread's a big circlejerk
>>
File: ann.png (361KB, 1263x4138px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ann.png
361KB, 1263x4138px
Superior list coming through
>>
>>135561783

The show was a dull mess.
>>
Why do people say Nico and 2ch are Japanese Reddit when they have nothing in common?
>>
>>135562175
>4.Kill la Kill
>5.FSN UBW
>8.Aldnoah Zero
>19.Psycho-Pass 2
>30.SAO2
Thanks for proving how shit their taste is.
>>
File: 1349047887623.gif (498KB, 420x236px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1349047887623.gif
498KB, 420x236px
>06. 280 Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso
Lets not pretend like this list matters at all if this is above Overlord and Parasyte.
>>
>>135578184
Besides Aldnoah I don't see anything wrong with that list.
>hurf durf SAO2
/a/ has no right to talk about taste when they keep pushing Non Non Boring as AOTY.
>>
>>135572485
>all have distinct personalities that bounce off one another with small bits of backstory

It's all the same shit, really. Nothing new or interesting is learned about a person's underlying character.
>>
>>135575699
artist are not in charge of the writing my friend
>>
>>135561783
What an absolutely garbage list.
>>
File: Ichibei.jpg (130KB, 772x814px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Ichibei.jpg
130KB, 772x814px
>>135578097
>>
File: 1430373882434.jpg (65KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1430373882434.jpg
65KB, 1280x720px
>>135578097
Shit taste: the list.
>>
File: 1443873426940.png (989KB, 1465x2137px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1443873426940.png
989KB, 1465x2137px
>>135578237
>thinking that Kill la Kill is good
>thinking that UBW was good enough to be in the top 5
>thinking that the second season of Psycho-Pass wasn't shit
>thinking that SAO is good
>>
>>135561783
This poll is completely irrelevant. Osomatsu-san losing to >Charlotte? You must be jesting.
>>
>>135561783
>Cross Ange
>16
>not 260
Japan
>>
>>135561783
>Pleiades is higher than Monogatari, Yahari and Fate
Well, that was unexpected.
>>
File: 1451733229030.jpg (93KB, 500x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451733229030.jpg
93KB, 500x500px
>Working!!!

What the fuck happened /a/?
>>
>>135579589
Japan happend anon
>>
>>135562175
>Locodol
>Bahamut Genesis
>Sabagebu

You're alright, China.
>>
>>135578097
>Baby Steps S2 that high

How did MAL manage to have better taste than /a/?
>>
>>135561783
>Kekkai Sensen nowhere to be found.

Finally, good taste has been observed in Japan when it is normally the other way around. Unfortunately the only reason KK isn't on the list isn't because the plot and characterization and total execution were atrocious but because the show is "too western" for Japanese sensibilities.
>>
>>135561860
It was the best anime of both the years it aired in.
>>
File: 3461.jpg (65KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3461.jpg
65KB, 1280x720px
>>135579644
Sports genre isn't a big deal on /a/.

I'm sure about 6 people here watch DnA ;_;
>>
>>135565350
Ping Pong is one of these works in media that you can't simply exclude from your "top" rankings without looking like a complete retard, doesn't count.
>>
>>135579705
You probably like Overlord, Shigatsu, and Calvary judging by your shittaste.
>>
File: 4367453264.jpg (30KB, 395x334px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4367453264.jpg
30KB, 395x334px
>>135561783
HAHAHHHAhahha fucking Charlotte is on the list
god please
>>
>>135579865
Hating Shigatsu because its cool? nice
>>
>>135562175
>Barakamon and Nozaki that high

This makes me happy.
>>
>>135578097
>Baby Steps 2
huh, neat.
>>
File: 1435952850221.jpg (64KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1435952850221.jpg
64KB, 1280x720px
>45. 63 GATE

Stopped reading there.

GATE easily wins worst adaptation of the year.
>>
File: 140000000000.jpg (22KB, 480x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
140000000000.jpg
22KB, 480x360px
>04. 347 One punch man
>05. 285 Non Non Biyori Repeat

NNBFAGS BUTTHURT

I repeat

NNBFAGS BUTTHURT
>>
File: 1431723927802.png (403KB, 456x443px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1431723927802.png
403KB, 456x443px
>>135561783
>30. 94 Shokugeki no Souma
I'm fine with this.
>>
I still haven't watched the last episode
>>
>>135561898
>plotfags

Not the point of the show
>>
File: watashit.jpg (41KB, 317x320px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
watashit.jpg
41KB, 317x320px
>>135561783
>shirobako

Should I drop it, I 'm at the half
>>
File: 1441482908408.png (307KB, 600x750px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1441482908408.png
307KB, 600x750px
>>135562175
1.Barakamon
3.Nozaki
Glorious Japan, spiting out the truth.
>>
I just watched the first episode of Shirobako and fell asleep. Thanks Japan.
>>
File: Prison School X-Mas.jpg (565KB, 1280x1813px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Prison School X-Mas.jpg
565KB, 1280x1813px
>Prison School even with a mediocre adaptation bringing the smackdown on NNB

Hurrah.
>>
>>135583124
Are BDs out yet? I didn't want to watch it censored
>>
>>135562175
Is there a 2011 version?
>>
File: t.jpg (99KB, 721x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
t.jpg
99KB, 721x720px
>>135582905
Let me guess: your AOTY is One Punch Man?
>>
>>135561783
>hibike in the top 50
dropped. That show was pretty and literally nothing else. And it wasn't even that pretty for a Kyoani show.
>>
File: mfwASS!.png (89KB, 351x412px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
mfwASS!.png
89KB, 351x412px
>>135561783
>Prison school 3rd

Oh yeah. Still waiting for the BD though, not watching this censored
>>
>>135568228
A list with Shirobako on the top is a good list.
>>
>>135562324
Liborek pls.
>>
>>135562680
Did it bomb?
>>
>>135561783
Didn't it sell like 20k
Thread posts: 238
Thread images: 47


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.