[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

Who is best girl of the season and why is it Stella?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 273
Thread images: 54

Who is best girl of the season and why is it Stella?
>>
>>133890488
You tell me
>>
>>133890488
> A slut who is a virgin!!
>>
>>133890488
She has very cute underwear.

>Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry

Literally what?
>>
>>133890607
98% of the sluts in anime?
>>
>>133890488
Stella a shit. Worst harem girl of the season.
>>
>>133890747
Those abs holy shit
>>
File: 1446173350987.jpg (916KB, 1441x1779px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446173350987.jpg
916KB, 1441x1779px
>>133890488
Mari >>>>>> Stella
>>
File: 1446570729896.gif (975KB, 400x225px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446570729896.gif
975KB, 400x225px
>>133890972
>>
>>133890488
Stella is bottom tier and already considered the worst tsundere of the season and a very shallow and underdeveloped main girl. And she isn't even the best girl in her own series.

Stop forcing it already, retarded Stellafag. You are half the reason why people shitpost Stella and Rakudai when you shitpost in other harem threads and try to make Stella popular via forced meme that hs failed.
>>
>>133891287
>hs
has*
>>
>>133890607
Every Sicilian man's dream
>>
>>133890972
There is no harem in first place.
>>
>>133890488
She isn't even close.

Shinobu, Ougi, Hitagi, Kuon, Nekone, Julis, Saya, Kirin, Mari, Ouka, Lapis, Shizuku, Nene, Tatsumaki, and many more are better than Stella.
>>
Just report this dedicated shitposter, he always use same files and same posts
https://desustorage.org/a/search/image/tJD_u7s5gjN6zLRDi_1k8Q/
https://desustorage.org/a/search/image/pG4I5MU7suXeaiJF8ijyww/
https://desustorage.org/a/search/image/F7-8DQRX6YoTUaZl0guTeQ/
https://desustorage.org/a/search/image/0BFw9WznlHFjJBQTgnraPQ/
>>
>>133890488
Good taste but she IS a slut
>>
>>133891746
>>133891773
More confirmation. This shitposter always shitpost with his le pink Houki meme too even he got btfo so many times over it. And of course he is samefagging hard as usual like he does in Antimagic, Asterisk, even Rakudai threads.
>>
Kuraudo is best Rakudai, Stella can go fuck someone else
>>
File: Lesbian constanza.jpg (70KB, 500x500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Lesbian constanza.jpg
70KB, 500x500px
>>133891836
>le
>>
>>133891868
Me?
>>
>>133891746
It is the 8th week, isn't it? This shitposter always repeats the same mindless stockphrsses and arguments, like his topic for this thread. And he does it daily despite knowing how more hated Stella will be.
>>
>>133891810
Fuck off you falseflagging cancerous shitter, you hate her and want everyone to hate her.
>>
>>133892036
what you gonna do about it?
>>
File: 1448230967442.jpg (513KB, 898x1264px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448230967442.jpg
513KB, 898x1264px
>>
>>133892051
I can only report
>>
>>133892036
>falseflagging cancerous shitter
That's what we thought for many weeks, mostly because he keeps forcing war with Asteriskfags and later with Marifags when she came around. But now it seems like he is simply a really obnoxious fan who doesn't care how shitty his posts are.
>>
File: 1444243271802.jpg (66KB, 717x960px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444243271802.jpg
66KB, 717x960px
Real question here Asteriskfags, how are you still watching it? Dropped it when the guy ran away when beta-kun had a chance to bone the student council president and ran away like an absolute anime MC.
>>
>>133892553
Fucking implying ikki wouldn't do the same shit
>>
>>133892158
Fuck off already, no one is falling for your bait. You killed the threads. Are you happy now?
>>
>>133892553
You filter him out. Ayato is the worst MC by far
>>
>>133890488
OP, I don't understand. Why would you ask to identify best girl, but then give the answer yourself? Does that not defeat the purpose of your query? Why even make a thread at all?
>>
I want to cum in stella
>>
>>133892553
I watch all three.
>>133892640
He would because he's commited to his girlfriend
>>
File: 1448177021152.jpg (53KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448177021152.jpg
53KB, 1280x720px
>>133891868
Post teeth
>>
File: 1438391233079.webm (189KB, 640x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1438391233079.webm
189KB, 640x360px
>>133892764
We need more shark teeth in anime.
>>
>>133892718
Ikki wouldn't even do stella
>>
>>133892640
>>133892841
>implying he wouldn't show Stella his Itto Shura of the night

>>133892718
Rakudai is fine, the last two episodes were really nice. Antimagic is retarded but I kinda like it. I couldn't stand Asterisk's MC and the girls were meh.
>>
File: 1447696698400.png (334KB, 515x446px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447696698400.png
334KB, 515x446px
>>133892676
>no one is falling for your bait
Then why's he always getting replies, even now?
>>
>>133892553
>Harem MC doesn't fuck girls in harem who throws themselves to the MC
Shit, really? Ikki, Takeru, and Ayato wouldn't and act like a typical harem MC in those situations, so I guess the only harem you're watching this season is Monogatari, right?
>>
>>133892718
>not watching Shomin Sample as well
>>
>>133893176
Nowhere near as much as a month ago.
>>
>>133893250
Not battle academy, I watch it anyway
>>
>>133893326
>implying it's not full of battle meidos
>>
>>133892959
>implying he wouldn't show Stella his Itto Shura of the night
Yeah he wouldn't, becuase he's such a beta fag he's embarrassed about being seen holding hands with the gf he dates for over month in front of his fukcing sister.
>>
File: 1448133089770.png (1MB, 1273x1438px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448133089770.png
1MB, 1273x1438px
>>133893241
Anyone Takeru impregnates has a chance to spawn an uncontrollable flesh monster that he probably won't have the gall to mercy kill
>>
Kirin = KING ARTHUR > Stella > everyone else > Julis.

Prove me wrong.
>>
>>133893669
Is there no preterm abortion in the Antimagic universe?
>ultrasound
>if female, then abort
Easy peasy.
>>
>>133893729
With a good chunk of the world uninhabitable, I actually wouldn't be surprised
>>
>>133893704
Mari > Miyuki > Julis > Lapis > Ouka > Aika > Saya > Shizuku > Kirin > Others > Stella

Get your shit, right.
>>
File: nano.gif (121KB, 500x301px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
nano.gif
121KB, 500x301px
>>133893455
>holding hands
I thought /a/ was a work-safe board anon.
>>
>>133893704
>Stella
>Better than anyone
>Trolling objectively 2nd best tsundere lead of the season
Post discarded.
>>
>>133894159
>2nd best tsundere
I don't know how the hell you guys manage to like a character that goes from dere to vilent to embarassed in less than 1 minute.
For me Julis is exact example of a tryhard tsundere character.

It's not like Stella is the best tsundere ever by she's miles better than Julis in my book, even with all the shitposting she gets.
>>
>>133894370
>I don't know how the hell you guys manage to like a character that goes from dere to vilent to embarassed in less than 1 minute.

We don't. Anyone who has read the Asterisk LNs will tell you that she's one of the worst characters in them.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jycj-3QX8yk&feature=youtu.be
Fat autism rap
>>
>>133894626
>foreverfat
>>
>>133894528
I really hope so.
It makes me kinda mad when the worst girls are the main heroines, which is the case with IS and Asterisk.
>>
>>133894370
>>133894528
>dere to vilent to embarassed in less than 1 minute.
Confirmed for talking out of your ass. Stella is the one that goes tsun to dere to slut in one episode after just meeting the MC for the first time. Julis remains strong and tsun throughout the first arc in the anime that adapts volume 1, and she only started to go dere after the MC saved near the end. And she doesn't go full dere until volume 4.

Nice samefag, by the way.
>>
>>133894528
I was about to reply seriously but then I said "why Give the shitposter the attention he wants?" Still, I touched the reply button so have at least this.
>>
>>133894851
It's not shitposting. She's barely mid tier at best for some novelfags from what I've seen.
>>
>>133894805
>Tryhard trying to compare Houki and Julis
>Acting like you don't know Julis is nothing like Houki and is objectively better as a character and heroine compared to a shallow heroine like Stella

Reminder this is the Stella shitposter just pretending.
>>
>>133894917
>mid tier
>some
>Implying worst
You can't even get your bait story straight.
>>
>>133894952
I guess I went kinda hard on Houki there.
But as far as IS goes, Houki is just kinda boring, Rin has almost zero exposure.
Charlotte, Cecilia and Laura are way better than Houki.
The same goes with Kirin and Saya compared to Julis, but for different reasons.
>>
>>133894917
Now this is better. Everybody has different trastes so for some she will be better and mis tierra for others. So far kirin wins the polls but that's just memetic because oppai loli
>>
File: 1447608665854.jpg (435KB, 1920x2480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447608665854.jpg
435KB, 1920x2480px
>>133890488

Stella and/or Claudia in my humble opinion
>>
I think I like Anti Magic's opening more than Rakudai's
>>
>>133894370
>>133894528
>>133894805
>>133894917
Way to obvious, especially with the "we" there. You already got BTFO in other threads when you tried to argue seriously for Stella > Julis. This just embarrassing having to talk to yourself like this.

Kirin is the only girl more popular and that doesn't make Julis bad. Even if Julis was 2nd or 3rd, her quality as a character is higher than Stella who is most popular in her series.
>>
>>133895266
Rakudai's opening would work better as an ED than as an OP in my opinion.
>>
>>133895331
Is not really bad, but as a OP is shit. Had it been the ED it would have been better
>>
>>133895312
No. Saya, Claudia, Sylvia and even the genki girl are more liked.
>>
>>133890747
God bless the anime character designers for making her legs proportionally thick.
>>
>>133895578
Bullshit. Until Kirin came, Julis was most talked and liked. Saya is third behind Julis now. Vast majority of weekly Asterisk threads will show that.
>>
>>133895312
>He doesn't agree with me then he must be a samefag.
>Julis has a better quality as a character than Stella

At least Stella manages to say her feelings instead of being a generic tsun. And she doesn't even get violent anymore after her confession iirc.
>>
>>133895987

Airing day Asterisk threads are so shit now. It's not just that Stellafag anymore, that Aniplex guy is shitposting there too.
>>
>>133895987
You're just a delusional tsunderefag. Thank god pink bitch is starting to be forgotten now.
>>
>>133890488
>Bait topic using one of the worst girl of the season
Stellafags are the worst
>>
File: 1444830374463.jpg (251KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444830374463.jpg
251KB, 1280x720px
>>133892764
Quick reminder he didn't even use itto shura against shark man here
>>
>>133896005
>Denying the obvious
Just confessing her feelings doesn't automatically make her a good tsundere when she has poor reasons to like the MC so abruptly. She's terrible tsundere because of she didn't go through proper development a tsundere should have.

And Julis hasn't been violent ever since she blasted the MC for peeping on her. Moot point.
>>
>>133896219
Nene and Touka are great but Shizuku and Stella are really shit. Rakudai has serious issues in that department and Sword Eater can't cover all.
>>
So basically this and Asterisk are basically the same thing but this girl got twintails and bigger boobs so it is selling better?
>>
>>133896072
>It's not just that Stellafag anymore, that Aniplex guy is shitposting there too.
Two shitposters can't make a whole thread bad, and they haven't.
>>
>>133896484
Rakudai had 3 shoddy fights and one really good one.
Asterisk had no interesting fights so far
>>
>>133890488

But Kiseki is best girl
>>
>>133896341
She doesn't need to go through a "tsundere development" to be a good character. I kinda agree that making her be with the MC so soon is abrupt, but since she lives so close to Ikki and kinda knows what he to go through you can see that she sees him in a very caring way.
She is less of a tsundere to be more of a common girl in love right now, with jealously antics and whatever else.

As far as Julis go, she's just a tsundere character that will probably have a spotlight at the end of anime without any progress or change to her, as far I can see. I might be wrong though, since I didn't read the LNs and I don't intend to.
>>
>>133896217
>Denying facts
>>133794297
>>133513770
>>133244248
>>132084708
>>132658448
>>132338067
The delusional faggot is you here, tsunhater.
>starting to be forgotten now.
You wish. Next arc only help make her more popular than she is now. Start your years already.
>>
>>133896484
They are battle fantasy with harem antics, but they are kinda different to one another.
If I had to compare, Rakudai is more similar to Index while Asterisk is more similar IS.
>>
>>133896753
Nah, Asterisk is more like Chrome Shelled Regios and Rakudai more like SAO
>>
>>133896672
>She doesn't need to go through a "tsundere development" to be a good character.
She does when her entire character is mainly being all over Ikki's D. She doesn't have anything else going for her. Skipping the process makes her a bad and poorly developed character. She's just terribly written.

She is a tsundere first and foremost. Having more dere doesn't not make her tsundere.

>probably have a spotlight at the end of anime without any progress or change to her, as far I can see.
You are wrong. To begin with, Julis already has more development from episode 3 and 4 than Julis has the entire season so far minus the sudden and shallow relationship she entered with Ikki from her confession. Julis has dreams, motivation, and the will to see her objective through that doesn't require the MC to give her reasons to move. We know why she fights in the Festa and whats to win, and we'll see her carry out her wish and also obtain new wishes as she befriends other people.
>>
>>133890488

I see these threads often, but I never see anyone give any examples of WHY she is the best. It can't be her looks, because twin-tailed, tsun girls aren't exactly rare in the animu.
>>
>>133897111
It's because she confessed to MC 4 episodes, apparently
>>
>>133897111
Same person always makes these threads hoping that he isn't the only one with shit taste.
>>
>>133897111
From my experience, most of her fans are normalfags who's all about muh cowtits. They don't see to care about her actual character being sub-par.
>>
>>133897148

That's it? Some people are really easy to please if that's the case. I'm somewhat envious. I tried to watch 2 episodes of this animu, but I almost fell asleep. I could appreciate the MC a lot more if I hadn't seen his character done more than 50 times before and better. He's pretty much just a nice guy and that's it.
>>
>>133890488

One of the Hime characters with big tits. Probably the Gundam one
>>
>>133897357
That's it.
He even has a love confession power up
>>
>>133896072

Or maybe Aniplex just makes a lot of shitty shows lately and people are commenting on it. The last non otaku bait thing they managed to produce that was any good at all was Ping Pong really so....
>>
>>133897016
As far as dreams and motivations go, we don't really have info about Stella's, so it might be something that it will be worked on in the future.
Stella's character being just being all over Ikki's D is kinda true, since she didn't have any spotlight to her own story till now It also kinda bothers me that she's pretty much a walking fanservice when she not doing anything.
I hope she gets more developed, because showing her own motivation to fight would make her ten times better than what she actually is now. If it ends up as "I fight to protect Ikki" it will be very shitty. I would really like to see her fighting for her own.

As far as Julis' motivations go it is kinda alright, but I don't see it as something that really makes her really better as a character. Might be strange to say that after what I said about Stella, but Julis' motivations isn't really something that struck on me, maybe because it isn't brought up as something important.
>>
>>133897542
The "first girls" in these series always have their introductory arc be a phase where they accept the MC and have their own arc again after the rest of the other "harem members" cover their arcs.
>>
>>133897628
I know, it's just that the best example that comes into everyone's mind about this kinda of storytelling is IS.
And in IS's case, after covering the charaters' arcs all that happens are harem hijinks with some terrorism plot.

I don't think that's exactly what will happen with Asterisk, but I can see that this will happen at some extent.

Meanwhile, Rakudai will probably follow the format that Index or Strike the Blood goes, where there are more plot arcs than character arcs, which has harem comedy in it.
>>
>>133898056
... I am afraid Rakudai only has character arcs
>>
File: IMG_20151117_172447.jpg (119KB, 1080x796px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
IMG_20151117_172447.jpg
119KB, 1080x796px
Everyone in this thread should kill themselves, you are the cancer that is killing anime.
>>
>>133897542
Aren't you just kind of making excuses Stella here? In any case, you more or less do agree that Stella right now is a lot less developed and fleshed out as character than Julis.


Rakudai is like most harem that follows a plot structure of main girl's arc that is followed by a string of different arcs for each other girl in the harem, and then it swings back to another arc for the main girl and then shared or various smaller arcs for the other girls, etc. Asterisk isn't different either. Antimatic is exactly like that too.

Julis's motivation was a big thing in the first arc and it is a recurring reason for her and the MC who wants to help her. The main reason the MC got attracted to her was because of the awe-inspiring scene he witness at the end of episode 1, and that came about because Julis exploded and made a speech to rebuke someone who thought she wasn't taking the Festa seriously.
>>
>>133898223
Well, lastest arc was half-character half-plot arc.
It introduces Ayase as a heroine and as an arc-antagonist, while introducing a rival for the MC.

In my opinion, if you introduce at least one enemy that we can lookf foward to see a fight, the plot at least went one step foward.
>>
Any significant fights yet in Asterisk yet? Slacked on it for couple weeks.
>>
>>133898859
Even if that rival won't appear ever again?
>>
>>133898956
What? Are you really watching the show? Ayato vs Kirin was one of the most significant fights plot-wise and arguably the best fight yet. And that happened in the previous episode.
>>
>>133898563
>Aren't you just kind of making excuses Stella here?
Maybe, but I'm only going so far because I kinda want to see why you guys like Julis so much, or why do you guys hate Stella so much which possibly because of the spammer than her actual character.

Because so far for me, while Stella's character has been more of a tool to see MC as a better character which kinda worked in my opinion, she still is better than Julis, which is for me just a generic tsundere with a backstory slapped on her.
Or maybe I just see her in a worse manner because every other character in her anime is more compelling to me.
>>
>>133898969
I really doubt that.
I can see he not appearing in this season of the anime and then Rakudai not having a S2, but I don't think the author would scrap Kuraudo like that.
>>
>>133899122
No, he reaaly won't appear. So far he only was in vol 2. After that? Nothing at all, nada, kaput.
>>
nude filther of that shizuku pic on the booru when?
>>
>>133890607
I don't think you know what a slut is.
>>
>>133899224
>Vol.2
So the story haven't really gone for long then?
Has that tournament thing started?
>>
>This thread
Stellafags BTFO.
>>
Male antagonist in Asterisk when?
>>
>>133899425
>fags
>plural
It's just OP and he isn't even a real fan.
>>
>>133899479
Probably that guy in the beggining of the first episode.
But I don't think it will be interesting at all, since that fight between Ayato against those dolls was pretty boring.
>>
>>133899331
Next volume (10) should be the final. Unless the author makes another training volume.
>>
>>133899479
Male robots count?
>>
>>133898563
Anti Magic does character arcs until Volume 5 and it becomes all plot. That being said, it arguably has the MOST plot going on.

and the winning point, a male rival
>>
Everyone can fuck off, haunted is the best girl and the best villain out of the 3 shows.
>>
>>133899929
No, Kurogane is
>>
>>133899068
Julis is proper classic tsundere that's a decent character. Stella isn't a good tsunder and is poorly written. I don't think the reason can be more simple than this.

The Stellafag spammer aggravates the hate, he isn't the primary reason she gets hate.

>Stella's character has been more of a tool to see MC as a better character which kinda worked in my opinion
How is that even a good thing? That doesn't actually make her a better character. Be honest, Stella is far too much like a character who was made for pandering than to be an actual person. Her personality isn't consistent and is all over the place, which is why she seems dere one second, tsun the other, then all horny for the MC.

Julis may be generic (which isn't always a bad thing), but she certainly is written better and has some depth to her as a character. To say the least, she is understanding and noble, a contrast to initial impressions. But she has a hot-headed side to her that doesn't appear awkward because her overall behavior is consistently relative to all of her traits a hot-blooded. All this makes her endearing and admirable.
>>
File: 655538.jpg (2MB, 3388x2388px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
655538.jpg
2MB, 3388x2388px
>>133898563
>Antimatic is exactly like that too.
Except it's not, the introductory volumes certainly followed that formula, but they were all in order to build up to the main story arc. The character arcs were simply that, small stories to introduce the main characters and their subplots to the audience. But they served a larger purpose by also introducing a number of major shit for the actual plot (of debatable quality, but I like it personally).

The main point being that they served a purpose other than shoving more girls in the MC's harem. I'm not saying that AntiMagic is necessarily better than others in terms of the quality of the plot (I would argue it is slightly more in depth though). But there is a reason why the AntiMagic threads have minimal "Best Girl" arguments, and mostly discussion on other shit.

>>133899926
Shame the rival is getting shafted so much by the Anime. I'll still watch it with "It has to be this way" in the background, but I'm prepared for disappointment.
>>
>>133899068
When you see a character as a tool to see another in a better light then is a baddly written character. Start again from there
>>
Can you do it /a/?

>Describe Stella WITHOUT saying what she looks like, what kind of outfit she wore, or what her profession or role in the anime was. Describe her to your friends like they ain't never seen Rakudai.
>>
>>133900880
She's this huge slut...
>>
>>133900880
The princess of a foreign nation attending a magical academy in Japan.
She's shy and gets easily flustered because she has very little experience interacting with others, especially those she can call friends. Still, she cares deeply about others, and is willing to sacrifice herself to protect both those that she cares for and those who she feels she must look after as a member of the ruling class.
Is that okay?
>>
>>133890488
when are we getting porn of her being raped
>>
>>133901161
Really vague and it doesn't at all create a clear image of who she is. Aside from the princess stuff, this could easily be any girl from any anime ever.
>>
>>133899926
>>133900595
Volume 6 is was the magic side story and that was Lapis' volume. Mari and Kanaria had some focus too though being magic related heroines.

Then let's not forget Nagaru's volume.

Antimagic's main plot starts and gets real in volume 5, but Takeru's harem still grows and the author does dedicate volumes for newer girls.
>>
>>133901256
Well, what are you looking for?
I could describe a few well done characters and have it sound quite vague. You're limiting me to keep her profession and role out of it, which of course makes things less specific.
>>
>>133900880
>Can't be done
>>
>>133901544
Already done 5 posts earlier
>>
>>133901318
I wouldn't exactly consider his harem growing, it stays within the squad
>>
>>133901346

Princess could technically be considered a profession or role in the story.
>>
>>133901708
Okay, but how about this:
A brash young country boy who goes on a rollicking adventure against the forces of evil, maturing into a proud hero as his journey progresses.
That could be any number of characters. Does it make Luke Skywalker a shitty character or a poor example of the hero's journey just because a limited description doesn't give you a detailed image of him?
I think you're being a bit unfair.
>>
>>133901346
Let me put it this way. Five years from now, you post the exact same text on /a/ asking people to decipher which character you just described, would anyone come to the conclusion that it's Stella? You haven't really named one specific characteristic that defines her or seperates her from anyone else. Even the combination of the characteristics you did mention, isn't enough to distinguish her from other characters.
>>
A 15-year old shouldn't look like this.
>>
>>133901887
Isn't Luke humble though? That aside, I may dislike Stella but the conditions make impossible to describe any character. At most you can describe an archetype like that.
>>
>>133901896
Describe yourself without reference to your job, titles, or looks, in a reasonable amount of space. Can that description distinguish you from others?
>>
>>133901640

>>133901256
>>133901896
>>
>>133900880
>>Describe Stella WITHOUT describing Stella
I get what you're trying to do, but looks, profession and role in the anime are still important part of a character.
>>
>>133899425
That's so common now. It is just redundant to point it out.

I feel bad for Satsukifags and Nenefags who have to put up with shitstorms caused by Stellafags.
>>
>>133901896
That's fair, but again, there are several characters that I could describe similarly that would be near unidentifiable from such a vague description; characters that many consider to be fine examples of characterization.
Now, if you're saying that Stella has little more to offer, I can see where you're coming from.
But then, I could mention that she is romantically and sexually unabated when it comes to her love interest, which does set her apart from perhaps the majority of characters in her archetype.
As her deeper motivations have yet to be delved into in the anime, and I've not looked into the source material, I'd imagine I'm describing her at a disadvantage.
>>133902014
Luke became humble as he matured. My point is that Luke is the archetypal hero. he follows the traditional hero's journey. What makes him unique is the setting in which he exists and his individual personality traits, i.e. the way Hamill played him.
>>
>>133902082
I can describe myself rather okayishly well enough to distinguish myself from other people but this is 4chan and I'm probably going to sound like some edgefag, so pass. Plus blogging isn't allowed.
>>
>>133902869
And here's that one Stella spammer trying too hard.
>>
>>133898391
underrated post
>>
File: 0lYjSNL.jpg (751KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
0lYjSNL.jpg
751KB, 1920x1080px
>>
File: just a fagbook file.png (385KB, 1102x967px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
just a fagbook file.png
385KB, 1102x967px
just fuck off to fagbook stellafag. you'll find lots of friends over there that has similar shit taste with you.
>>
>>133903639
Stellafags confirmed for FB cancer.
>>
>>133903639
We know she appeals mostly to normalfags so that is not surprising at all. I bet reddit is crazy about her too.
>>
>>133903667
>caring about Fagbook's taste
just fuck off anon. as i told you earlier you'll be better out there so that your shit taste wont spread here on /a/.
>>
>>133903639
The funny thing is they insist Rakudai is not harem show
>>
>>133903639
>Hiyori isn't top
>Sodachi nowhere insight
>Second worst girl out of those 10 is 1st place
Into the trash bin.
>>
>>133891746
>he loves this character and keeps posting about it!
>I don't agree with him so he must be a shitposter!
Kill yourself.
>>
File: witches_and_whores.jpg (1MB, 2292x1081px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
witches_and_whores.jpg
1MB, 2292x1081px
I like all of them.
>>
>>133904845
>Apologist for a cancerous spammer who gets called out for shitposting all the time
End yourself first.
>>
>>133904845
>Someone actually defending shitposter
>>
>>133904880
Finally, someone who isn't a cock gobbling jizzbeard.
>>
File: 1446060057324.jpg (79KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446060057324.jpg
79KB, 1280x720px
>>133904880
Is even Ayase even important anymore?
>>
>>133905298
Do these two have the best interactions between all the characters from the 3 currently airing battle harems?
>>
>>133905638
Comparatively speaking, without a doubt.
>>
File: why.png (314KB, 730x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
why.png
314KB, 730x720px
Why is Stella so shit? She ruined the entire season.
>>
File: hdw182ss2poxw259.jpg (135KB, 640x644px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hdw182ss2poxw259.jpg
135KB, 640x644px
I want to cum inside Stella.
>>
>>133905818
>15 years old
>>
File: Mad Rabbit.jpg (74KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Mad Rabbit.jpg
74KB, 1280x720px
>>133905807
I firmly believe Usagi has one of the more collectible facial expressions this season
>>
>>133905807
>red hair
Must be burn.
>>
What I want to is, will anything happen with Stella and Ikki, or the "you are my girlfriend" was for nothing?
>>
>>133906439
Not even remotely close.
>>
File: TMG_v10_183.jpg (696KB, 1498x2100px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
TMG_v10_183.jpg
696KB, 1498x2100px
>>133905748
>>133905638
Their Tsundere attitude towards each other is just the best.
>>
>>133906540
Is it weird that I want them to end up together?
>>
>>133906603
I wouldn't think too wrongly about it, this entire series screams threesomes
>>
>>133906540
Literal best OTP. I would pay to see them have rough and wild hate/rapesex with each other.
>>
>>133903639
I didn't know Noragami and Haikyuu were so popular.
>>
>>133906603
>>133906819
Isn't there some Euphonium thread you should be shitposting in?
>>
>>133900880
I see what you are trying to do, but if you describe both Stella and Julis you will probably end up with similar results, since we are ealing with tropes here.
>>
File: 1445815052811.jpg (90KB, 456x540px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1445815052811.jpg
90KB, 456x540px
How can she be best if she isn't the best girl in her own show?
>>
>>133904689
Where is this so called harem?
>>
>>133905807
Another shitposter
https://desustorage.org/a/search/image/geOixhuJfv5O5eYSu0qK5w/
>>
>>133907211
No one gives shit about you shitaste, tripshit
>>
File: 1426970640721.png (192KB, 1252x1252px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1426970640721.png
192KB, 1252x1252px
>>133907327
>>
File: 1412140723904.jpg (1MB, 1975x5000px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1412140723904.jpg
1MB, 1975x5000px
>>133907327
I'm not going to say Julis is good but nothing comes close to being as bad as Houki.

Please enlighten me in what makes Stella that innovative though
>>
>>133907327
>Stella is a wonderful, innovative and unique tsundere
>Julis is a carbon copy of Houki
Even a shitposter such as yourself don't believe what you just said.
>>
File: 1444659828925.jpg (988KB, 1500x3057px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444659828925.jpg
988KB, 1500x3057px
>>133907614
I could say the same for Stella if you're cherrypicking from episode one. The first episode for both series are ass, get over yourself.
>>
ok guys powerlevel time.
What if the 3 LN MC's swapped worlds and now ikki is fighting against haunted, ayato against arrowguy in rakudai and takeru against that doll guy in asterisk(Assuming takeru has lapis and ayato has his own ogre lux). Who will survive and who will die?
>>
>>133896323
Fucking bullshit, and I thought the MC found a decent match.
>>
>>133907690
If Takeru has Lapis, there's no question he'll make it out with little problems. Especially if he's up against that fucking pushover in Asterisk.

Ikki vs Haunted is just unfair, you need some Kamen Rider armor to fight that motherfucker.
>>
>>133907737
Best Boy didn't reveal his limiter if that's anything, they were both fighting below their 100%.

and maybe it's just me but Kuraudo didn't use both his hands.
>>
>>133907690
Ikki isn't strong enough for Anti-magic setting unless maybe if he got one of those Relic weapons, Takeru could easily beat the doll faggot from Asterisk, and Ayato would be pretty strong in Rakudai since he's like Ikki but with longer time limit and deadlier sword.
>>
File: 1438867518242.jpg (4MB, 1280x3577px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1438867518242.jpg
4MB, 1280x3577px
>>133907753
Are you completely glossing over the fact that Ayato and Julis had a duel just like Stella and Ikki did? Or the fact that Stella threatened Ikki in the office before their match?

Jesus fuck why am I even responding at this point.
>>
>>133907081
Not the same anon but Ouka and Mari already kissed twice.
>>
File: Evolution.jpg (2MB, 3600x2400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Evolution.jpg
2MB, 3600x2400px
>>133907447
Not him, but Stella really can be considered the pinnacle of tsundere evolution. She's better than anything that came before and I'd wager she won't be surpassed in our lifetime.
>>
File: 1392431006053.jpg (2MB, 800x800px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1392431006053.jpg
2MB, 800x800px
>>
File: 1418419143836.jpg (26KB, 600x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1418419143836.jpg
26KB, 600x600px
>>133907885
>pinnacle of tsundere evolution
>>
>>133907885
>Not him
Sure
>>
>>133907512
Not him, but that alone doesn't make her anything of that. At best, she's just an atypical tsundere but is still very formulaic. Not even going to mention how badly botched and rushed job she is as a tsundere. Freaking Mine from AgK did a better and more believable confession than Stella.

Also.
>Still gets jealous
>Still acts touchy
>MC still raise flags with other girls
A lot of good that did.

>>133907885
Nigga, now you are baiting and being delusional.
>>
File: they're all shit.png (185KB, 932x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
they're all shit.png
185KB, 932x600px
>>133907885
>pinnacle of tsundere evolution
>>
>>133908066
This is incredibly accurate.
>>
>>133908066
>neo tsundere

Stella was a mistake. REMOVE Stella from history.
>>
>>133908066
Your so called "neo tsundere" really is a massive improvement over those bitchy bitches
>>
>>133908066
DOU GA PREASE CAN U KEEP MAI SEKURETO!
>>
>>133908261
>Delusional derederefag
>>
File: 1430627398973.png (3MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1430627398973.png
3MB, 1920x1080px
>>133907653
>she also has fire powers (get it because shes hotheaded?)
No its because they are Shana clones with pink hair and tits
>>
>>133908066
There is no such thing as classic and modern. Ignorant fags like you need to stop spread misinformation. One of the oldest tsundere is the type people like you would consider "modern" so the term that denotes contemporary is completely wrong.

Stella is still a shit though.
>>
>>133908066
>A girl is deredere
>Hurr durr I am new so I am calling it neo tsundere

Fuck off retard.
>>
>>133907653
>Damn maybe i should write a light novel
you should have done that earlier like 2 to 3 years ago. Who knows, the LN you've written might be animated by Deomedea
>>
>>133908066
Saved
>>
>>133908510
>A girl is deredere
Did you even read the post he was replying to?
>>
>>133892029
that's why he keeps posting this stuff. he doesn't really appreciate the show and the fact that Stella really is the best girl this season.
>>
>>133908311
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kk8TgkkwAoA
>>
>>133906889
Please, Haikyuu is fujo bait and Noragami is one of the most popular shows according to mal
>>
>>133904880
4 > 2 > 3 > 1 > 5 > 6
>>
>>133908501
This. There have always been tsundere that takes time to soften up and tsundere that shows a bit of dere as a reaction during the tsun phase, and both design are timeless. But Stella is truly a different brand of tsundere born out of recent time. Neo tsundere completely fits her.
>>
>>133908885
>Neo tsundere completely fits her.
>Samefagging to push some faggot's cancer
Fuck off m8.
>>
File: 1448230879395.jpg (110KB, 516x729px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448230879395.jpg
110KB, 516x729px
She's the best one
>>
Why nobody shills for Ouka?
>>
>Rakudai gets an anime
>The manga will never be scanlated again
Every time
>>
File: 163124.png (517KB, 970x612px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
163124.png
517KB, 970x612px
>>133909232
Because hardly anybody cares for her despite her main heroine status.
>>
>>133909315
Is there a nico rank for Asterisk or Rakudai?
>>
>>133909381
None I'm aware of.
>>
>>133909315
And? Kirin is best girl and people shills for Julis.
>>
>>133909434
I would assume the gap between Kirin and Julis just isn't quite as big. Only reading taimadou threads you might come to think Mari is the main heroine and Lapis her main competition, but you wouldn't get that kind of impression from Asterisk threads.
>>
>>133909315
>Mari is top
Good.
>Lapis is lowest
This is not okay.
>Ouka is 3rd
That's fine.

Usagi is too high for her own good. She's really my least liked.

>>133909434
No, Kirin is just most popular while Julis is second most popular. Nothing strange for the 2nd most popular girls to have supportive presence a thread.
>>
>>133906634
These two are going to have such a abrupt introduction into the anime. It feels like the director just read a summary about each volume online and went "good enough".
>>
>>133909655
The anime adaption fucked Lapis over, she just has no chance with secondaries. Personally I'm not a fan of hers anyway.
>>
>>133909550
>Stellafag
Implying, fuck off with your cancer m8. No one likes you.
>>
>>133909770
Lapis' cuteness is in a league of her own, damn it. Can't wait until the anime starts on volume 6 so Lapis can get the attention she deserves.
>>
>>133909770
Usagi is best 35 shotai, too bad nobody likes oppai loli.
>>
>>133909828
We both know it'll never get that far. The show will bomb and never get a 2nd season and that'll be that. Curse you Silver Link and your prioritization of Rakudai.
>>
>>133909891
Which is a shame, because I like Anti-Magic far more than Rakudai.
>>
>>133909820
>Denial in the fact of defensive butthurt defending Stella

>No one likes you
Apply yourself.
>>
>>133909965
I don't give a fuck about Stella but Neo Tsundere is pure cancer made by a cancerous shitter like yourself. Kill yourself already it will sure help.
>>
>>133909891
What? Pretty sure Antimagic has two cours. The author said the anime would adapt 9 volumes somewhere in one of his Afterword.
>>
Why are people suddenly waifuing seasonal shit for a girl that has existed long previously?
If stella was such a good girl, waifufags would have made her known long before the anime was announced.

What's worse is after the anime is over, this shitty poser is just going to move on to a different girl. His love isn't even pure.
>>
>>133910055
First time I ever heard of this. As far as I know only Asterisk is confirmed for another cour.
>>
I don't understand the appeal of Rakudai

Like it's just inferior to the other two. In terms of animation, fight choreography, soundtrack etc. it gets beaten hard.

Is it literally just Stella?
>>
>>133910122
I remember Rakudaifags who were looking forward to the anime and praised Stella right after the anime was announced, which was long before it aired. But I'm pretty sure THE stellafag wasn't part of them.
>>
>>133910162
>just Stella?
The girls are always the main reason to watch a harem. But Stella isn't even best girl when there's Shizuku and Nene, anyhow. Rakudai barely has a plot and its setting is pretty boring, so there's nothing else but the girls.
>>
>>133910159
>To everyone who keeps saying the anime will cover 9 volumes, this was probably a mistranslation on Krytyk's part. The afterword of volume 10 on his site now reads
>On the topic of anime, there's an official announcement on the band of the ninth volume.
I just went to check and found the afterword is different now. It appears Krytykal fixed a mistranslation.
>>
>>133909279
But it is still scanlated
>>
>>133910272
>Shizuku and Nene
No one gives shit about them
>>
>>133910858
>What Stellafag with tunnel vision actually believes
>>
>>133896851
You compare that rakudai to SAO? At least Ikki has a better personality and character development than kirito and the show actually does swordfighting. Unlike a certain wish fulfillment protagonist having an actual harem ready soon.
>>
>>133909232
Different caliber
She isn't really that much of a tsundere
>>
>>133910792
Sue me mason I'm retarded
>>
File: 1448190097691.webm (1MB, 720x405px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448190097691.webm
1MB, 720x405px
>>133910162
>In terms of animation, fight choreography
Let's not get ahead of ourselves, as much as Stellafag is doing, I can at least admit is more animation going for where it sort of mattered.
>>
>>133898563
Stella has a vibrant personality and has an extent of wanting to prove that she works hard and at the same time falling in love with a man and having her affections returned. Julis like you said has more fleshed out more character development but under reasonable circumstances that there are too many to point out I prefer Stella. BUT THE MC ASTERISK IS NOT MORE DEVELOPED THAN IKKI. So far there is no motivation and how he decided to come to the school or for his sister. Ikki has the stronger personality as he attempts to prove to people that he will win and be known as strong even without a natural skill. Having a goal and personality is pivotal in character development and Ikki wins in both categories.
>>
>>133910162
Animation and fight choreography and soundtrack? Is this bait anon kun? I'm sorry but have you watched to the current episodes?
>>
>>133907823
>Still hasn't be responded to
Stellafag btfo
>>
>>133911525
Stella shitposter got banned. His posts got purged.
>>
File: TMG_v07_0004.jpg (2MB, 2906x2046px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
TMG_v07_0004.jpg
2MB, 2906x2046px
>>133910428
I wouldn't want the rest of the series to be butchered
>>
File: 1447849643805.jpg (185KB, 500x705px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447849643805.jpg
185KB, 500x705px
>>133912429
So if a second season does get greenlit (I hope the LN gets a decent boost in sales, 3K sold is depressing) what studio would you trust with it?

Obviously not Silver Link considering the mess they've made already.

>>133909655
>>133909315
>Mari is top

You know it's weird how Mari is a character who literally solves the issues in the plot with asspulls, and yet everybody loves her and couldn't care less about them. That summoning thing was off the charts on my Deus ex Machina scale.

I still love her too oddly enough. Ouka may have more flags but I still have hope she'll win the bowl.
>>
Any alternate Subbed for Rakudai beside HS?
Holy fuck that yellow text
>>
>>133913025
>not liking yellowsubs
they're nostalgic
>>
>>133912665
I'd want SL again, and even do it all over, only if they had Rakudai's staff instead. God I love watching all the harems this season but I become incessantly bitter when Rakudai comes in because I keep thinking how Taimadou could have gotten that staff instead.
>>
>>133913566
The only offensive things they've done is just cutting cool character moments that'll pay off in the future. Lapis, Kiseki, Kyouya, and Kurogane just need to be distributed nicely before the big drop of happening in Volume 5
>>
>>133913025
Doki and Heroine but I think they're both a week behind.
>>
>>133913668
>The only offensive things they've done is just cutting cool character moments that'll pay off in the future.
So the show looking like ass doesn't count as offensive? First two episodes were decent enough, I'll concede that much. But as was to be expected it's been going downhill ever since. Rakudai is directed by Shinbo's old understudy and still gets some respectable animation like >>133911428 from time to time, AntiMagic is directed by a nobody and gets nothing. Fuck SL.
>>
>>133913668
Anon, the fight scenes alone are offensive.
>>
>>133909842
But /a/ loves her after her arc, so it's not that bad.
>>
>>133907690
To be honest, Takeru woukd creme both Tournaments in Asterisk and Takudai by vol 11, really nuke sword is kind of unfair.
>>
>>133899926
Kyouta really is best rival, I can't wait for Nero.
>>
>>133914058
The character designs, cast, and the soundtrack are the only things going for it. And the first two are the bare minimum that any studio should get right.

Everything else is pretty much shit.
>>
>>133914460
Yeah but I don't think too many studios could nail of those fight scenes, especially Arthur or the Mech dragon
>>
>>133903639
>Mikazuki that low
>people sincerely believe OPM is better than IBO
REEEEE
>>
>>133906634
When do they come back in? Didn't the necromancer kill both of them in like episode 2? I've been waiting for them to return because the silly face on the chick makes my dick diamonds every time I watch that OP
>>
File: TMG_v07_0080.png (833KB, 1456x2046px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
TMG_v07_0080.png
833KB, 1456x2046px
>>133915019
He was supposed to kill Blonde rapist in Volume 4 but he chronologically comes back at the end of Volume 3 so really soon
>>
>>133915019
They were supposed to cone back in ep 6 bt the anime skipped it.
>>
>>133915166
That's a shame. I'm really indifferent to Rakudai, but I've been enjoying the shit out of Antimagic. Then again, I'm caught up on Antimagic and only have seen 5 eps of Rakudai.
>>133915120
Where are we in the anime now? Like what volume?
>>
>>133904746
hiyori is trash tier m8
>>
File: TMG_v03_225.png (2MB, 1640x2313px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
TMG_v03_225.png
2MB, 1640x2313px
>>133915296
Volume 1 (1-2)
Volume 2 (3-4)
Volume 4 (5-6)
Volume 3 (7-8)
So far, I hope they have the rest of the episodes dedicated to Volume 5.

I'm primarily an AntiMagicfag too but I can vouch for Episode 8 of Rakudai, Hosoya gives an amazing performance.
>>
File: Slut poll 2015.jpg (743KB, 1000x1412px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Slut poll 2015.jpg
743KB, 1000x1412px
>>133890488
What if she joins this list?
>>
>>133915436
Julis would since she actually needs money.
>>
File: 1428166033445.png (186KB, 576x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1428166033445.png
186KB, 576x720px
>>133908501
>classic means old
Thread posts: 273
Thread images: 54


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.