[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Extra juicy! | Home]

What does /a/ think of the anime adaptions of the Persona games?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 118
Thread images: 38

>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
>>
P4GTA is an anime masterpiece.
>>
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
They rushed or left out certain parts (Yukari x Makato hug and Junpei's resentment), but I do enjoy them.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
Loved it.
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
It's not awful, but it felt awkward how they shoehorned Marie into everything.
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
I discovered the series through P4's anime. I wanted to check out the series and decided that was the best way to gauge how much I'd enjoy it. I really appreciated the anime a lot more after finishing the game twice.
>>
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?

First one was okay, haven't watched the 2nd because I wanna finish the game first

.>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?

Yup, it was a pretty solid adaptation considering how much shit they had to fit in.

>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?

It did it's job, covering the golden content. The only way a person could've been disappointed is if they expected them to basically remake the P4 anime, which would be pointless because they weren't made that many years apart.

>Did you discover the series through the anime?

No.
>>
File: tfdun.gif (2MB, 250x181px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
tfdun.gif
2MB, 250x181px
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIuVO1SsFYs
>P4 cast visits Iwatodai
>All of those references to P3
>Using the P3 soundtrack
>King's Game scene in anime form
>>
>>123911507
NOODLE PEOPLE!
>>
>>123911640
>First one was okay, haven't watched the 2nd because I wanna finish the game first
What part are you up to in the game? You could be past the end of the 2nd movie.
>>
>>123911686
>>123911507
What the fuck did they spend their budget on the P4GTA? P4TA has some of the best animation I've seen and was a great adaption of the artstyle, while GA looked beyond awful.
>>
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
They're breddy gud. They gain a lot by diverging from the games; it doesn't feel like they're leaving shit out by accident.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
Better than the game, QUALITY aside
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
>A1
No. But it is honestly one of the worst anime I have ever seen.
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Pic related, actually.
>>
File: 1375693975255.gif (260KB, 266x207px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1375693975255.gif
260KB, 266x207px
>>123911747
>P4TA has some of the best animation I've seen
>>
>>123911818
>They're breddy gud. They gain a lot by diverging from the games; it doesn't feel like they're leaving shit out by accident.
What did you think about making Makato responsible for Shinji's death? I liked it and I hope it has repercussions.
>>
>>123911886
I really like the artstyle.
>>
>>123911893
>What did you think about making Makato responsible for Shinji's death? I liked it and I hope it has repercussions.
Not a huge fan of it. Ken's big moment was being a teamkilling fucktard, it was basically his whole development. Let's see where they go with this, though. It might turn out okay.
>>
File: naoto.jpg (22KB, 195x352px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
naoto.jpg
22KB, 195x352px
>>123911947
That's an interesting opinion
>>
>>123911338
>Who are you quoting?
>>
>>123911947
You said animation, not artstyle. Although neither look like the cutscenes in the game (both add fat to Yu's face and make him thicker), the original animation is admittedly much more pleasing to the eye than the Golden.
>>
File: The QUALITY bunch.jpg (23KB, 720x335px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
The QUALITY bunch.jpg
23KB, 720x335px
>>123911507
It truly was an amazing experience, I didn't think they could top the originals QUALITY but A-1 really outdid themselves
>>
>>123911338
DUB FUCKING WHEN
>>
>>123912285
Never, probably. Ratings were pretty low.
>>
>>123912285
I don't think the P3 movies are ever getting a dub, it dosen't have the same wide base appeal P4 has in the west for starters
>>
File: quality1.jpg (115KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
quality1.jpg
115KB, 1280x720px
>>123911507
>>
>>123911338
They are bad. Like really bad. P4A was full of QUALITY, I still enjoyed it somewhat. Golden was just awful because of Marie.

The movies are lackluster. The combat of Persona really doesn't fit well into anime.
>>
File: That collar though.jpg (198KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
That collar though.jpg
198KB, 1280x720px
>>123912379
>>
>>123912409
How does Yu even control his collar?
>>
File: quality.jpg (113KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
quality.jpg
113KB, 1280x720px
>>123912409
>>
>>123912409
I was about to joke about how the artstyle always uses gradients in place of any actual shading, but then I saw the background. That's embarrassing.
>>
>>123912478
Answer.
>>
>>123912384
>The combat of Persona really doesn't fit well into anime.
I highly disagree. It's basically JoJo with five to ten second summons.
>>
>>123912200
hownew.ru
>>
>>123912592
Jojo's fights are actually interesting though.
>>
I can't choose between Yukari and Fuuka. Please help.
>>
>>123912508
>>
>>123911507
I love how they obviously burned through all of their budget prior to the last episode. Truly a deconstruction of the anime genre.
>>
File: 1427134975799.png (704KB, 1024x957px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1427134975799.png
704KB, 1024x957px
>>123912801
Get better taste.
>>
>>123912826
Kanji is probably the hardest character in anime to draw.
>>
File: Sasuga A-1.jpg (103KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Sasuga A-1.jpg
103KB, 1280x720px
>>123912882
The best thing about it was the dickheads from /v/ who thought it was going to be good because MUH A-1
>>
>>123912885
I would give anything for an hour of sex with Mitsuru.
>>
>>123912953
Too bad there are too few doujins that get her large breasts right. Everything is gross cowtits.
>>
>>123911706
Right after the part where you go to the beach and meet Aegis.
>>
>>123912384
>The combat of Persona really doesn't fit well into anime.
Luckily P4 is just a visual novel with some dungeon slogging thrown in.
>>
>>123913036
Ah, you have a while then. Alright, when a certain character's Persona truly awakens, then you can watch the movie.
>>
>>123913007
Such is the case wih neary all girls in doujins.
>>
File: 1411096681098.jpg (176KB, 1365x768px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1411096681098.jpg
176KB, 1365x768px
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
First one was fine, second one got fucked with changes to the story to make Ken less of a bitch.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
Hells yeah! It's a much better adaptations than the movies which leaves too much out and are quite dull in comparison bad animation aside it was fun.
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
It was as expected really with the exception of the Adachi episodes which were great and far too well done for something like this hat they sort of stick out, the rest was mostly just fluff
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Played the games first.
>>
>>123912241
Did hiimdaisy draw this?
>>
>>123913544
>Ken less of a bitch.
But he's voiced by Megumi Ogata. There is no way that's possible.
>>
>>123913716
They removed his "I'm a mature" faggotry he had when you first meet him in the game and actually develop his relationship with Shinji to play off the tragedy aspect
>>
>>123911338

P4A was awful.
P3 movie 1 was average.
P3 movie 2 was terrible.
Didn't even bother with P4GA

So much wasted potential.
>>
>>123913794

Yeah, instead of appearing mature at first, they made him a little gay bitch from the start. Genius!
>>
File: 1427494552889.png (816KB, 688x688px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1427494552889.png
816KB, 688x688px
>>123913900
>P4A was awful.
>>
>>123913955
>instead of appearing mature at first, they made him a little gay bitch from the start
There's a difference?
>>
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Have only seen the first one, found it boring and didn't like the MC.

>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
It was great, the comedy worked really well and they did a decent job with some of the serious parts.

>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
It was alright but ultimately unnecessary.

>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Nope.
>>
>>123911747
Hanakana.
>>
>>123913956
>Being a p4 fag
Join all the cool kids over here at P3 or better yet save yourself for P5. Don't lower your standards to p4, you have options.
>>
File: really faggot.jpg (46KB, 575x517px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
really faggot.jpg
46KB, 575x517px
>>123914203
>cool kids
>P3
>>
>>123914203
>>>/v/
>>>/vg/
>>
File: Evoke.jpg (64KB, 500x366px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Evoke.jpg
64KB, 500x366px
>>123912826
>>
>>123914203
P4A was quite entertaining despite obvious quality.
>>
File: 1428445463125.jpg (722KB, 1062x1058px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1428445463125.jpg
722KB, 1062x1058px
>>123914254
>implying not
>>
Watched the 3rd movie the other day, had way too much fujoshit pandering.
>>
>>123914203

All these adaptations have at least taught me to never watch another Persona anime again, so that at least I won't have the P5 experience completely ruined for me when they ultimately adapt it too.
>>
I would've preferred if they never said protag's name. I really don't like when they give SMT protagonists official names.
>>
>>123914525

Because you prefer the shitty names the fans call them?
>>
I think y'all niggas are forgetting about the best Persona anime.
>>
>>123911338
P4 felt like my fucking little pony.
P3 was meh at best.
P2 Did have the best story, but gameplaywise, it doesn't measure to the las ones.
>>
>>123914525
MC is still MC (or door). P3 adaptations and spin offs have given him too many wildly different names and personalities. Yu on the other hand is pretty much established.
>>
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Yes, in fact I bought the BDs for them. I feel that doing a game like the format they did was a lot of a better choice than P4 and P4GA
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
The quality of the anime itself was terrible and I didn't like it. I did though enjoy the way that they embellished on the story though.
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
I seriously hated P4G because of the Marie shoehorned in everywhere and everything. Also not enough Adachi.
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Nope.
>>
>>123914650
That doesn't exist.

But it's soundtrack does.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh5ci3SOmTc
>>
File: 1426040083461.jpg (109KB, 440x582px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1426040083461.jpg
109KB, 440x582px
>>
>>123914725

He's still not Yu in the main game.
>>
>>123914735
>I feel that doing a game like the format they did was a lot of a better choice than P4 and P4GA
By eliminating every aspect of the game leaving nothing?
>>
>>123914735

>That image

I've had PQ sitting for a month because FUCK the final boss. Doesn't help that grinding takes forever in this game and there's really no good way to do it.
>>
>>123914827
He is in all the cannon games after that buddy. As is his personality
>>
File: 1380947703589.png (2MB, 1280x1138px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1380947703589.png
2MB, 1280x1138px
>>123914735
I'm convinced that most of that image is just people kidding around. It's too much.
>>
NO TIME TO WASTE
BUT MAKE YOU PACE
IT'S OKAY TO REMOVE, COPY, AND PASTE
I'M DOING MY WAY
YOU DO IT YOUR WAY
DON'T JUST FOLLOW YOUR LEFT, FIND THE RIGHT WAY
STEREOTYPES
TOO MANY HYPES
I'M THE EPITOME OF NEW TYPES
HAVING THE FEAR IS POWER TO MY SOUL
I OVERCOME THEM 'CAUSE THAT'S HOW I ROLL
>>
>>123914577

I prefer when I can call them however I want without some filthy secondary correcting me.
>>
>>123914944
>not repping "persona 4: Burger Idol"'s main theme
Still, good taste
>>
File: fel.jpg (169KB, 494x710px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
fel.jpg
169KB, 494x710px
>>
File: 1425684676817.jpg (222KB, 694x724px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1425684676817.jpg
222KB, 694x724px
>>123915061
Silly anon, secondaries are a ghost story made to spook you.
>>
>>123914882

Spinoff games and in the main game you choose his personality as with almost all SMT protagonists.
>>
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
I like it. Especially the changes they made, like giving MC some kind of inner conflict and growth in both movies, and they made Ken's arc more sympathetic because he only found out Shinjiro was the murderer after becoming good friends with him.

>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
It was bad to average, aside from the hilarious quality issues. Pic related.

>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
I can't be let down when I expected it to be bad.

>Did you discover the series through the anime?
No, played 3 and 4 first. Never did play Golden, but knew enough about it from hearing people talk about it.
>>
File: 1422632644884.png (365KB, 560x732px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1422632644884.png
365KB, 560x732px
>>123915130
Is that 'spin off games, and in the main'?
Because you don't choose his personality in arena m80 and however much you struggle it's confirmed cannon. Coincidentally establishing a personality in any game consistently, retroactively changes his personality in other games making your play through the variant.
Correct me if I'm wrong but it also feels like P4A is inline with the personality of P4:A and P4:AU which would make that characterisation also cannon or highly likely.

>P3 relatively unfucked with due to multiple interpretations and alt feMC shit
Feels good
>>
File: Beauty of Destiny.jpg (66KB, 640x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Beauty of Destiny.jpg
66KB, 640x360px
>>123914944
>>
>>123914832
Ah, I guess it sort of didn't make sense what I mean is how the P3 series is formatted into a periodic release with it being sectioned off with like 90-ish minutes of a better cinematic experience than 30 minute intervals on a weekly basis.
>>
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Really bad. Obviously geared toward established fans. Everything was crammed and rushed. But still entertaining. Having a friend watch the 3rd movie for me tomorrow.

>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
The animation sucked but it was hilarious. I loved it. This is how I got into Persona.

>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
Of course, moreso by the fact that A-1 pictures put their worst team (outsourced) on the project.

>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Yes.
>>
>>123915345
>P4A
>P4:A
This tickles my autism every time. Why can't they just have stuck with P4U instead of having two of P4A?
>>
>>123915445
It annoyed me too. I wasn't sure which to give the colon to, given that they should both have it. It's more practical take it from Animation so the arenas can look uniform with :AU
>>
>>123915345
>Correct me if I'm wrong but it also feels like P4A is inline with the personality of P4:A and P4:AU which would make that characterisation also cannon or highly likely.
Unless you wanted to say that PQ is inline with the personality of P4:A and P4:AU, that's not really true.
The Arena and Ultimax Yu is definitely different from the anime Yu, while you can be blame it on the fact that the stories in both games happen in few hours meaning there wasn't really enough time to for him to show anything else than "MUH BONDS", the difference is definitely there. PQ Yu however is a great mix of his both personalities, but that means he still isn't like in the first anime.
Either way Yu had a personality in 3 games now, soon it will be 4 since he is not a silent protag in P4D, out of which one happened in the middle of P4.
everyone is forgetting that P4G and PQ confirmed that there not only are multiple universes, but Yu can contact with his other selves in those universes. His anitsocial Hitler Stalin is just a protagonist in a different universe, not the one we're following
>>
>>123912384
>Golden was just awful because of Marie.
Shit taste
>>
>>123916391
Alright, everything except for Adachi's episodes (minus the Marie parts) was just awful. But Marie was still the worst in all that mess.
>>
>>123916435
>>123912384
>everything except for Adachi's episodes
>Marie was still the worst in all that mess.
Pls refer to >>123916391
>>
>>123916487
>Mariefag thinks he can judge other people's tastes
How cute.
>>
>>123916553
>Adachifag thinks his shit self insert character is good.
How sad.
>>
>>123912719
What the fuck
It's not there anymore
>>
>>123916648
Nice try, but I couldn't care less about Adachi. His episodes had flaws and they handled some scenes in a terrible way and the OVA was complete garbage but it all still was more interesting than Marie Sue: the Show.
It didn't say his episodes were good, just mediocre.
>>
>>123911338
The P3 movies are arguably better storywise than the games. They gave the MC more character and personality with his conflict over ending the Dark Hour and such.

This also may be because I haven't played it in a long time so I don't remember, but the fact that Ikutski is a traitor also seems better portrayed, since he actually does and says a few things that are pretty sketchy and suspicious that I don't remember from the game.
>>
File: laughing.jpg (344KB, 726x800px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
laughing.jpg
344KB, 726x800px
>>123916820
>The P3 movies are arguably better storywise than the games
>>
>>123916820
The only thing the P3 movies show is how dull and boring the storyline in the games actually are. On top of being terrible adaptations in itself.
>>
File: Sigh.jpg (6KB, 277x182px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Sigh.jpg
6KB, 277x182px
>>123916770
>but I couldn't care less about Adachi.
and yet
>everything except for Adachi's episodes (minus the Marie parts) was just awful.
Don't abandon your self insert anon.
>Marie Sue
>Does not even know what Mary Sue means.
>>
File: 1400773902796.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1400773902796.png
1MB, 1280x720px
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Yes. Quite happy about it. Only part I hate is the year long wait for the BDs.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
It was all right. But only because I've played the game. Otherwise it'd be pretty meh.
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
Quite so. I played Golden after watching the anime, and I was pretty disappointed. Marie a shit anyway.
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
Nope. Played Persona 3 and 4 long before as well as other SMT titles.
>>
>>123916919
Do you have brain problems or something? Serious question.
>>
>>123916842
Don't be upset because it is harder for you to self-insert when the main charactee actually has feelings and emotions.
>>
>>123917044
>the main charactee actually has feelings and emotions.
You're killing me.
>>
>>123916862
This. You really have to be a die hard P3fag to actually think they're good.
>>
P3 movies are fine so far but apparently 3rd movie has some...questionable changes.
>>123917011
>arguing with Marietards
Just drop it
>>
>>123912508
>>123912409
>>123912379
The backgrounds just look like real photos with a filter.

is that a common trick? it looks awful.
>>
>>123917325
That's what they are.

In a very low budget anime, yes.
>>
File: 1424394003470.jpg (247KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1424394003470.jpg
247KB, 1920x1080px
>>123917325
>is that a common trick?
Incredibly so
>>
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Feels like they should have just made a tv show instead.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
It was hilarious, all I needed from it.
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
I don't think there was anything good about it.
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
No.
>>
>>123917011
>Has no rebuttals and resorting to attacking me directly
kek
>>
>>123911338
>>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
It was decent.
>>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
It was decent even though animation isn't that great.
>>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
It sure is a let down.
>>
File: Hatoko.png (788KB, 1079x605px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Hatoko.png
788KB, 1079x605px
P1 movie when?

http://a.pomf.se/omoyqy.webm
>>
>>123911338
>Do you like the P3 movies so far?
Yes, they look good.
>Did you like Persona 4 The Animation?
The comedy parts were better than the game
>Was the Golden Animation really a let down for you?
Meh
>Did you discover the series through the anime?
I've played P1 and P2 before watching the anime adaptations, but as far as P4 goes, i watched the anime first
>>
>>123918185
>they look good.
Must be tough being blind
>>
Yukiko best girl.
>>
>>123911559
They left out the hug? Fucking hell.
>>
>>123919889
They also skipped all Persona evolutions except for Junpei's, just because.
Also Makoto is the team killing shit, not Ken.
>>
I SHOULD be at the last month of the p3 game. I want to get to at least make Messiah before facing last boss just to be safe.
I will watch the movies after I'm done with it.

Aigis best.
Thread posts: 118
Thread images: 38


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.