I'd still go with Haruhi and fumoffu but I really enjoyed Hyouka and Chitanda is my waifu.
>chitanda is literally not a character
Why would I? You're right OP
Hyouka is Kyoani's masterpiece
Disappearance is Kyoani's magnum opus.
After Story's second half comes right after it.
Disappearance> Fumoffu> Hyoka> Nichijou> TSR> Haruhi> Tamako Love Story> Clannad> Lucky Star> Tamako Market> K-On> Kanon > Chuu > KNK > Chuu2 > Air > Free
I haven't seen Munto, so I left it off the list.