Unpopular opinion thread >madoka magica wasn't all that great

Aikatsu > Love Live

File: 1408302851205.jpg (670KB, 1600x1103px) Image search: [Google]

670KB, 1600x1103px

Free was beter than K-On

File: Accel World.jpg (111KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 1280x720px

Accel World >>>> Sword Art Online In Every Single Possible Way

>>121177471
is this some sort of reverse bizarro thread?

>>121177635
That's not an unpopular opinion on /a/

>>121177471
That's an understatement.

It was complete fucking garbage.

>>121177471
fuck off to >>>/co/

>>121177669

But it is, for some incomprehensible reason, true everywhere else.

Kyubey was the only one who was right all along in Madoka Magica

Anime, as a whole, really isn't very good.

>>121177471
That's not really an unpopular opinion at all.

>>121177823
That's not unpopular. Every faggot on /a/ agrees that not all anime is great.

File: opm meteor.gif (2MB, 400x287px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 400x287px

I hated katanagatari. I never got why so many people like it. The only thing it has going for it is a somewhat nice artstyle.

>>121177635
implying that fat little cunt > kirito

3D>2DPD

File: 5f5671051bfb19702e8c9e028fe45a87.jpg (837KB, 810x812px) Image search: [Google]

837KB, 810x812px

>>121177471
>OP's Mom wasn't that great.
Sorry, man. It's true.

>>121177471
What a special opinion you got there

>>121177888
>Kevin is a Madotard
Not a surprise.

>>121177841
There's a difference between saying "not all anime is great" and "all anime is not great"

>>121177864
Why would you use OPM page sequence to illustrate this sentence

>>121177913
No reason, why would i need to illustrate my sentence?

>>121177868

The little pig at least has a personality and depth.

>>121177823
>Anime, as a whole, really isn't very good.
Neither are comics, film, books, etc. It's not really a profound statement.

>>121177913
It fits since OPM is trash that looks gorgeous.

>>121177471
>madoka magica wasn't all that great
But that's more than an opinion, it's a fact.

>>121178057
Weeaboo detected

>>121178070
>OPM is trash
I'll fucking cut you.

I think the use of "animes" is totally acceptable.

>>121177471
I believe that Origami is best DAL
I didn't like the Tokyo Ghoul OP

>>121178070
>trash
It's not trash. It's not some godly manga with tons of depth either, but it's entertaining and the characters are interesting.

>>121178103
>>121178159
It is though. "LELSORANDUMBXD!!11^^XD" gag shit to be precise. Murata art is wasted on this garbage.

Naruto as a whole was a fun, interesting and enjoyable ride and I regret nothing.

>>121178258
some solid argumentation you have on you

>>121177806
There was also Homu

File: 1423519943431.jpg (61KB, 720x480px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 720x480px

>>121178258

File: Hatoko_rant.webm (2MB, 720x405px)

2MB, 720x405px

Hatoko is undeniably didn't do anything wrong

>>121178605
>video quality
Jesus, what the hell did you do?

File: 1420620273203.png (732KB, 1300x417px) Image search: [Google]

732KB, 1300x417px

>>121178140
>Origami is best DAL

File: 1422778409088.jpg (44KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 200x200px

>>121178605
that´s just beautiful dude

Newer anime would be more enjoyable if it used older visual and musical styles

JoJo part 4 is boring

Hnk is the best battle shounen

Black Lagoon and VOTOMS are meh

Anime was a mistake

>>121178605
Hatoko done everything wrong

>>121177471
Madokafag especially homufag are the worst fanbase on /a/.

Rebellion a shit.

Nasu genuinely deserves every single bit of popularity he's got, and even though his writing is full of flaws, he's genuinely objectively good in a completely unironic way.

Kill La Kill is pretty decent.

>>121177705
This, I watched thinking its gotta be halfway decent but it was meh at best.

>>121178605
>breaking the 180 degree rule that many times.

Ow.

LoGH portrays politics and ideologies from an incredibly simple and incredibly populist (e.g. "We politicians don't contribute to society!"), it makes me wonder if anyone who masturbates to this show has even finished high school, because it's high school level of political discourse.

Log Horizon portrays raiding and raiding guilds from how I imagine a casual who has never raided imagines raiding.

>>121177471
Ghost Hound is plainly a horrible anime and it has one of the most stupid ending ever.

Gunbuster is way overrated.

File: image.jpg (116KB, 600x876px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 600x876px

>>121179145
I'm glad we are so well received.

>>121179241
Didn't watch the whole show, did you?

Blue exorcist is not a good anime

>>121179241
This. It doesn't matter if the theme is well executed, it's simply stupid.

Then again, anime is notorious for having highschool level understanding of the world and topics.

>>121179360
>hurr durr you haven't watched the show
That's such a generic retort.

TTGL is awful

Monogatari series would not be worth watching if senjougahara or Kaiki weren't there

Tokyo Ghoul is terrible.

And apparently I'm in the minority for thinking so.

>>121179510
I'm with you, too much edge not enough philosophical discussion.

>>121179360
Seen the 110 episodes OVA a while ago, still haven't gotten around to watching the gaidens or that movie, but I will eventually.

Don't get me wrong, I certainly didn't hate LoGH, but people on 4chan (not just /a/) act like if it's the greatest work on political science in human history, which can be pretty annoying.

>>121179550
What philosophical topic did tokyo ghoul (manga) touch?

>>121179510
I'm with you as well

File: [HorribleSubs] Kantai Collection - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_07.02_[2015.02.11_12.47.27].jpg (63KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 1280x720px

Kancolle is shit.
I'm talking about the game, the anime is average.

>>121179241

politics is pretty much always simple in entertainment

>>121177471
This is the worst character in Death Parade.

>>121179714
It's not like Death Parade has any interesting characters.

Ninja Scroll: The Series doesn't suck.
Mind Game is surprisingly dull and worse than it has any right to be.

Mikasa Mikoto was a generic tsundere and in no way best girl. She was just a shitty bland trope that got copy and pasted all over to aru.

>>121179688
Yes but LOGH's politics is even simpler.

Index's plot has more holes than a Swiss cheese

>>121179510
I wouldn't say its terrible but its edge knows no bounds.
Its not great either but I enjoy watching it.

>>121179491
Well you're objectively wrong.

>>121179452
>execution doesn't matter
>thinks the entire show is about politics
>hurr durr
Quality posting right here.

File: order_56779_mockup.png (194KB, 876x446px) Image search: [Google]

194KB, 876x446px

>>121177471
>unpopular opinion thread

Homura did nothing wrong.

>>121180849
Execution does matter but it doesn't make the theme more complex or better.

The entire show may not be about politics but that's what LOGH fans praise it for, because the cardboard characters and the animation certainly isn't a strong point of the show.

>>121179745
It's not like you have demigods playing billiard with planets every day
probably every decade while we're at it

>>121180992
If only that was what the show was about instead of simple psychology and a a system of judgement that's flawed for the sake of the show sounding smart when it criticizes it.

File: Into The Trash It Goes (2).jpg (317KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]

317KB, 2048x1536px

>>121177471

Death Parade is other anime about ""deep, plot-driven and suffering" genre, same with Madoka magica

>>121181082
Death parade doesn't even have a plot.

>>121181104

It's a slice-of-afterlife

>>121181104
It does though. The latest episode was entirely centered on the unnamed woman and the dwellers of the afterlife.

Tatami Galaxy
Bakemonogatari
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei

All shit.

>>121179241
>Log Horizon portrays raiding and raiding guilds from how I imagine a casual who has never raided imagines raiding.
Have you actually gone raiding before? I know it's not exactly like your hardcore raiding that you did but it actually accurately depicts what a usual raiding is like.

>>121181445
>giving corny speeches after wipes makes people perform better

Also the whole point of silver sword is that they are supposed to be hardcore. Acting defeated after their first wipe to a new boss kind of destroyed that though.

File: 1396837569917.webm (1MB, 1920x1080px)

1MB, 1920x1080px

I've got one: if you have an unpopular opinion, post it in a thread about the anime or manga in question. It's a good thing for people to talk about their differing thoughts. Threads like these are just unnecessary ghettos that stifle actual conversation.

I don't think steins;gate is that good. It does not deserve the absolute praise everyone gives it 24/7.

>>121181823
I literally haven't even been able to make it through the first episode after 3 tries.

Mawaru Penguindrum is AOTY 2011

File: 1416080714373.jpg (14KB, 373x346px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 373x346px

>>121181823
I respect your opinion.
Though your opinion is shit.

>>121181736
When someone posts an unpopular opinion of an anime in the respective thread, people call it bait and the whole thread is derailed into namecalling, memes and imageposting "rebuttals".

>>121181823
Is Stein's Gate just like Interstellar? In other words, it's praised for having "accurate" physics but those accuracies don't necessarily make a story good.

People should spoiler spoilers indiscriminately.

>>121182091

What.

Go watch you fucking inbred retard.

I watched over 500 animu and I still don`t get what people see in FMA and Steins; Gate. I liked both but they are not top tier.

Anons shouldn't swear all the time.

>>121182133
Why would I watch SG if ends up shit when I can watch anime that people have described in better words like Kaiba?

Death Parade has a really shitty story, people only like it because it's "dark" and the woman is always the bad one

>>121182199
Fuck you!

LH is basically SAO ripoff, but since SAO is so popular /a/ is liking LH more.

>>121182187
I heard from some that FMA:B does a good job at handling the human condition.

That gave me a good laugh.

>>121182199
Fuck off you fucking faggot, eat shit and die.
I-it's not like I like you or anything, baka...

>>121182091
I fucking loved Interstellar

>>121182236
>Only once
>always

ITT bait exchange

>>121182269
>liking a movie that has "love is part of the physics equation!"

Please, tell me you're joking.

>>121182218

Because just like some people think SG is shit, some people think Kaiba is shit as well.

If you're watching anime based on /a/ recommendations, that's just utterly retarded.

Go watch it and make your own goddamn opinion.

>>121182091
Not really it just has a plot that is done well and isn't touched often; so it's uniqueness makes it stand out

>>121182314
So what? It was fun. Who the fuck cares if the physics were accurate.

I enjoyed every second of it.

>>121182314
Not him but I liked Fifth element.

Evangelion is paperthin pretentious faggotry.

Not sure how unpopular that is here. I don't frequent /a/. I just know it never put me on an otaku's good side.

>>121182328
The people who think SG's good have a harder time articulating why compared to the people who find Kaiba to be good.

>>121182336
That's good enough to make me watch the show. Thanks.

>>121182353
Forget about the physics not being accurate. "muh love transcends time and space" is just fucking silly shit. And it's funny that people who let that pass are atheists who supposedly wouldn't let a supernatural entity if it was replaced with "love" instead.

>>121182429
>"muh love transcends time and space" is just fucking silly shit.
Yeah, it was great fun.
>>121182429
>And it's funny that people who let that pass are atheists who supposedly wouldn't let a supernatural entity if it was replaced with "love" instead.
It's a fucking movie. It isn't real.

Next you'll tell me anime is real.

File: 1422157690531.jpg (13KB, 211x173px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 211x173px

>>121182429

It's good because I liked it.

Autism is actually a thing on this board

example:
>>121182429

File: 1418310729308.png (364KB, 486x330px) Image search: [Google]

364KB, 486x330px

>>121182452
Well if you find stupidity to be fun, good for you.

>>121182536
Pic related.

>>121182586
>Well if you find stupidity to be fun, good for you.
Why else would I be on /a/?

>>121182600
That's a very good point.

>>121182586
Fate is the epitome of "stupidity is fun"

>>121182633
Fate explores the depths of human morality and ethics.

File: 1403417132598.png (354KB, 725x684px) Image search: [Google]

354KB, 725x684px

>>121182429
>And it's funny that people who let that pass are atheists who supposedly wouldn't let a supernatural entity if it was replaced with "love" instead.
Jesus fucking Christ.

>>121177471
I think Madoka is all that great

>>121182633
Maybe but at least you don't see pretentious plebs like redditors praise watching it to be "the closest thing humans get to be gods" like Interstellar.

>>121182669
You know it's true.

>>121182054
Then I guess /a/ is beyond saving.
Or maybe you need to say something more than, "This anime is shit, how do you guys like this?"

I really want to enjoy Yuru Yuri but it is just so god damn boring.

>>121182770
Fate is huge among normalfags.

>>121182853
So is Spiderman but I don't see either of them being overpraised like Interstellar.

I mean just look at this: https://www.reddit.com/r/interstellar/comments/2lp2b2/i_couldnt_keep_my_shit_together/

>>121179346
>im punk so i must rebel
yes, you fucking retard, that's kind of in the god damn description holy shit

I really don't understand how people can feel genuinely offended in this thread when you can re-title it as "opinions that would annoy others."

Log Horizon's battle plans are retarded.

Nasu is a good writer and a genius.

>>121181074
>a system of judgement that's flawed
>implying there is a better system

>>121182658
Ethics? No. Morality? Yes.

>>121183073
Yes there is. Here:

>Have arbiters that are omniscient

There.

K-ON! is objectively better than LoTGH

I don't really like anything gatari.

>>121182898
I liked Interstellar a lot but I have a daughter so I'm probably biased.

I like watching shows that /a/ claimed to be moeshit.

>>121179346
Of the 3 real ones here, one of these is racism, the others are pretty valid behavioral correlations. Dying your hair 'crazy colours' is a choice, it IS related to looking for attention. Wearing a skill and crossbones tie that hangs down to your crotch? Yeah, I'm sure that's part of your identity which is somehow unrelated to your worldview.
Prejudices against a race is in no way comparable. God that pisses me off.

File: 1416323614657.jpg (45KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 1280x720px

>>121183013
My guess is the fact that you genuinely like a show and some faggot says, "That show was bad and you are a shitty person for liking that show"
It angers some and others don't really care.

And then we get the bait posters like >>121183018 that people seem to fall for.

>>121183143
You should watch or read Usagi Drop, if you haven't already.

>>121177613
nigga u gay

>>121183162
How is his post bait? It's a valid opinion.

It seems you take more offense at someone stating a different opinion that's not aimed to insult anyone rather than the statements that boil down to personal attacks.

>>121183162
There have been posts I don't agree with but I'm not anal hurt that people have different opinions or are trolling. There is a difference between discussion and two babies crying at each other.

>>121183138
>yeah just randomly be able to have omniscient Arbiters!!!!
If they were perfect there would be no point to the fucking show

>>121183190
Just watch the anime if you don't want to get pissed off at the ending in the manga.

>>121183162
>He has a different opinion that me, it must be bait!

File: QUALITY as fuck.png (350KB, 632x351px) Image search: [Google]

350KB, 632x351px

TTGL is not very good. It's significantly worse than Kill la Kill.

Big titts>small titts

>>121183263
Maybe so but you argued there wasn't a better system of judgement. That's simply false.

>>121183190
I have.

I enjoyed it till the end.

I liked Hinamatsuri more.

Madoka deserves a lot of the praise it gets

>>121183280
I did and I liked the ending of the manga. It was well done except for drama.

File: what.png (379KB, 577x698px) Image search: [Google]

379KB, 577x698px

Subs are fine most of the time

>>121183283
I agree with you on the second half of TTGL being worse than KLK.

But I think the first half of TTGL is better than KLK.

File: 1404155475859.png (147KB, 576x461px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 576x461px

>>121183241
Claiming Nasu is a genius is delusional level, or /jp/ tier.
He's good at world building and his characters are better than average but his story writing sucks ass.

>>121183350
Mah nigga, S2 got a bit too slow until magical space navy ship

>>121180956
Lot of assumptions you're making, anon.

>>121183358
Are you talking about the prose?

>>121183414
Read the praised reviews, read the /a/ archive threads (I made some to get arguments out of people, that's what LOGH fans argued), etc...

Those assumptions are based on that.

>>121182097
I agree. Spoilerfags are cancer. I want to read the story, not a list of half incorrectly translated spoilers from Chinese raws.

One Piece was the worst of the so-called big three.

>>121183358
Even if they are delusional as you claimed them to be, that doesn't make people who hold this opinion to be bait.

Bait is intentional and it's trolling.

Your posts are actually bait. Heck, I'm not even sure why am I replying to someone who's intentionally changing the meaning of "bait" just to save face.

>>121183541
All of the big three are shit, one piece being the worst shit

>>121183428
Not exactly. The way he writes is fine, and I'm sure a lot of it is lost in translation, but the story itself is pretty dull. I had to look up prose
The story in FSN/Tsukihime/Zero/KnK are all pretty mediocre. The only reason KnK being so amazing is the way Ufotable adapted it (but they dropped the ball on UBW).

File: spic and cunt.png (738KB, 718x439px) Image search: [Google]

738KB, 718x439px

I really didn't think this show was all that good, it had it's moments but dragged on for far to long

>>121183638
>I had to look up prose

Fucking ey. You don't even know what prose means and yet you're tackling the issue of the quality of storytelling. It shows you don't even have the serious amount of knowledge when it comes to critically reviewing writing and anything literature related.

If this isn't bait, I don't know what is.

>>121183695
Its just a word, chill.
Even then, I know what it means.

>>121183733
It's a very basic word when it comes to writing and literature (VN is written in prose after all).

It'd be like arguing with someone about logic but they don't even know what an axiom is.

File: 1419401264830.gif (543KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

543KB, 500x281px

>>121183810
Just because I didn't know what the word meant at the time, doesn't mean I didn't experience it.
You are just trying to invalidate my experience because my opinion doesn't agree with yours.

File: 1415374553287.jpg (65KB, 400x600px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 400x600px

>>121183203
yes

>>121183810
I know what an axiom is but I didn't know the word.

Does it matter?

>>121183914
No. I'm invalidating your appeal to your own knowledge since you're not giving any reasoning to your arguments.

If you were someone who'd actually knew about writing, I would let your "X is shit" statements pass, because I'd be assuming you're someone who's speaks from knowledge. But you're not.

>>121184079
Yes.

>>121183695
Not him, and I actually agree with you that Nasu is good. But him not knowing what a prose means(neither did I) is a trifle when discussing on /a/. I mean, he's gotta have a right to have an opinion.

>>121184114
>Yes.
No, it doesn't. If you understand the concept but don't know the concept it doesn't invalidate your opinion on something completely unrelated.

>>121184136
I don't care if Nasu is a good writer or not.

He can have an opinion but I don't have to take an opinion on someone who claims to know what makes good writing when they don't even know a very very very very basic word like prose.

I mean come on. This word is taught in highschool level English classes.

>>121184138
Anyone can claim to understand a term but you can have a pretty good idea that they don't if they don't know what it is.

>>121184240
You can completely understand the Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon without knowing what the word is.

Get over it nerd.

>>121184292
False equivalency.

Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon has an other term that's much more prevalent with the same meaning, i.e Frequency illusion.

Prose has just you know... prose.

>>121184379
>Frequency illusion.
Never heard of that in my entire life.

In fact I just used the archive and it's said exactly 4 times in 7 years.

>>121184426
I just checked with every board.

Baader-Meinhof is used literally 5x more than Frequency Illusion.

Amazing.

I think Katekyo Hitman Reborn is an excellent Battle Shounen

>>121184426
>>121184479

My point still stands, if you don't know the term at least you can know the other term.

With prose, there's just prose. So if you're arguing that people will know the meaning without knowing any word related to it, you'd be wrong.

File: Mikono.Suzushiro.full.954490.jpg (397KB, 848x1200px) Image search: [Google]

397KB, 848x1200px

Pic related was a good girl. While i don't hate Zessica, i think most of her suffering was mostly her fault.

File: grin.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

Sports is the best genre I'm not sure if that's unpopular or not though.

>>121184520
Axiom has no equivalent in my language.
I still understand the general meaning of it, though.

to be fair my language is also shit but that isn't the point

>>121184520
>will likely know

Fixed.

>>121184555
Well if prose doesn't even have an equivalent in your language, you should probably just leave whatever shithole you're from.

Saint Seiya Omega was decent.

>>121184645
You are the definition of pretentious

Tatami Galaxy has godtier visuals but it's overrated as fuck as a whole

>>121184736
Oh please, I don't fit in /a/ that much.

>>121184775
Yeah, you really don't if you think that was a compliment.

>>121184809
>what is sarcasm

>>121178094
But he's right. Most movies and T.V. shows aren't that great.

>>121184520
Language is just expressing.
You can know the meaning behind the term but still not know the term itself.

>>121184871
>what is honesty

>>121184913
>honesty is the opposite of sarcasm

You couldn't be any more retarded.

>>121178094
Sturgeon's law. You probably think TWD is good.

>>121184905
Right. But it's usually not the case when it comes to a very basic word.

I mean, if you don't know a very basic term that usually goes hand in hand with writing, why should I assume you're speaking from knowledge when you're making statements like "X has dull storytelling".

>>121184949
Looks like I need to explain that I wasn't trying to be funny, just honest.

>>121185129
No, you were being retarded.

>>121185032
It is a very basic word, hence it doesn't hold any weight in your argument.
Its just a shorter way of saying, "speaking in a matter-of-fact tone" which face it, knowing the word isn't going to change your reading experience.

File: 1400295157868.jpg (112KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 1280x720px

>>121185165
We can't all be geniuses can we.

>>121185177
You need more than reading experience to be able to know what makes good story telling and what doesn't.

Besides, if he did have enough reading experience, chances are he'd know what prose is.

>>121185207
>if you're not a retard, you're a genius

There you go again, with your silly false dichotomies.

>>121184895
>>121184962
Anime is inferior because of the small range of people which it caters to. Books and movies have a lot more of diversity. Unless you have grown to like anime cliches and tropes, not 90 but 99% of anime will be shit.

>>121185233
I've read as many books as any other average person.
I've literally never, ever heard the word "prose" before.

>>121185306
>I've read as many books as any other average person.
>as any other average person

You're not really helping your point. The average person doesn't even read that much.

I'm just going to assume you're trolling and not stupid.

clannad is shit

(clannad was what got me into anime so my opinion is valid)

Cowboy bebop was a crap

>>121184962
>stugeon's law

Stop stating those laws like a pseudointellectual like "Godwin's law". They have no weight to them and are not "truths".

>>121183695
Anyone can decide for themselves if a work is good or bad. You don't need a special set of vocabulary to appreciate art. It would help you expresss what you like or dislike about the work, but it won't make you enjoy it more or less.

Redline was shit. Even animation was just meh.

>>121185341
You are arguing that my review and opinion doesn't matter all because I didn't know what a certain word meant, even though I already understand the expression behind it.

File: Mugi Nurse.gif (993KB, 500x536px) Image search: [Google]

993KB, 500x536px

Mugi is overrated.

>>121185421
>Anyone can decide for themselves if a work is good or bad

No one in this fucking thread is taking the opposite position of that statement...

>>121185450
>because I didn't know what a certain word meant

Almost there but not quite.

Anyway, you've already said that you read as much as the average person. I don't think you're a good authority on what is a good story telling and what isn't.

it wasnt Kamijou Touma that made the series so bad, but Index.

I seriously cant believe there are people who like index, and I fucking hate touma too

>>121185256
Good to know you are humble. Though me judging this "prose-debate" I can see you are wrong by the sheer numbers against you.

>>121185525
>No one in this fucking thread is taking the opposite position of that statement..
>I don't think you're a good authority on what is a good story telling and what isn't.
You literally just contradicted yourself.

>>121185548
>I can see you are wrong by the sheer numbers against you.
Appeal to people fallacy.